Bass Singer FIRST-TIME REACTION & ANALYSIS - Geoff Castellucci | Way Down (Low Bass Singer Cover)

[@mityakiselev]

IDK why, but Jeff, Goeph, Goff, and Darryl just send me every time. That's exactly my sense of humour

[@mdoe8]

I have realized that I gravitate towards Geoff as my favorite bass singer. However, as awesome as his voice and range are, I’ve come to realize that his arrangements are what sets him over the top.

[@jorge37325]

Him and Layne both are what make Voiceplay far and away my favorite acapella group. Not only their vocal talents, but their arrangement abilities are second to none.

[@shelleeroe7305]

@@jorge37325 right. And with people like Peter it definitely helps me understand just how complex things can be.

[@Samurai-is6ue]

Eric hollaway

[@MuriKakari]

Geoff definitely had fun with the cinematography on this.

[@Badger77722]

Gotta love the humor Geoff puts into all of his solo videos! And hips! Geoff's got hips!

[@3912James]

You KNOW when someone (like Geoff) is about to hit a scary bass note when you put on the SHADES!!!! 😎

[@swiggzforlife]

12:34 I am a gentleman, but Geoff, my good sir, you are CAKED UP. All do respect

[@Kiradeit]

It's official, Peter Barber reacting to bass notes is my favorite thing to watch!

[@susiebell6716]

You should watch him reacting to Halo ... he totally fangirls on it 🥰

[@susiebell6716]

Oh and the final line of Pentatonix The Prayer .... he's very cute 🥰

[@yasmingoosey3028]

I would love to see you do an interview with Geoff if you ever got the chance! It would be so interesting to hear both of your insights into techniques and arrangements and I love hearing your analysis of videos! Great work with the bass gang and your own songs too btw!

[@Tootsiepop201]

I don't think my speakers can handle that much bass in one place. (Kidding, that'd be awesome.)

[@Lilith-Rose]

I agree, but in the meantime charismatic voice did an interview with him that covered a good bit of the technical details

[@yasmingoosey3028]

@@Lilith-Rose yes I caught that one! What a great interview 😊

[@nightspicer]

@@Lilith-Rose there's also one done by matt fouch on bass singing central channel

[@Taytodude]

1 year later, you got your wish.

[@daventunes3822]

Thank you for giving props to J.D. Sumner. He's kind of passing into history and it's nice that you're helping to keep the legacy alive. Also appreciate the note that the ending is a classic barbershop tag ploy.

[@LednacekZ]

to be consistent on D1 or #C1 is incredible. That is something to be proud of.

[@christinestromberg4057]

When you check his patrom again he provided us with the full "other Geoffs/Jeff's" video. So much fun. :) Their name badges reflect some of the many ways that some reactors mangle his name. :) He said it took him 80 tries to make it sound decent. And yes I did join your Patreon too , at a low leverl, as I also support Geoff and VoicePlay.

[@NathanJ-E]

He actually did that last part live on tiktok! I reckon it only took him lots of takes to get it to sound the way he wanted, not necessarily not hitting it at all. Awesome reaction!

[@rtsbass7829]

Oh gosh I finally got a New Phone and now I can get notifications, So cool. Also, I love how happy you look here!

[@billparrish4385]

Geoff's comedy is full-on in this one, with the one guy licking the toilet brush, and the other eating popcorn out of the dustpan. And as always, Peter, I love your detailed analysis, but most of all the generosity you extend to a fellow bass singer in your choice of wording and props freely given. That's the good stuff that, once given, eventually comes back around to you, and well-deserved in your case!

[@patriciaschuman4205]

Thank you once again for a reaction that is both so detailed and informative, while remaining so enjoyable to watch as well! I do find it really interesting that although it took him those 80 tries to get that C1 recorded for the video, he has since that time released a tiktok of him singing it live that takes him through three lines of the song, dropping 3 and a half octaves from his starting point down to that C. I can't help but be reminded that it's been nearly three years since Layne asked him to hit an E1 for the ending of Oogie Boogie's Song. That note and phrase also took him quite a while to do initially, and then lots more practice before he attempted to sing it in a live setting. I know that basses are generally considered to be lucky in that they can usually expect their range to continue to deepen with age, but Geoff's continuing to push himself to expand his range and abilities is certainly admirable. It wouldn't really surprise me to learn that, in another three years time, he may well have a lower 'consistently reachable lower range' than he does today. (Of course, I also admire the fact that he has also stressed that it's more important to be a 'better' singer than to be a 'lower' singer.) I love opera, but am ashamed to say that I didn't realize until very recently (since I grew up listening to it on audio recordings, television programs and the movie theater presentations of the Met performances instead of sitting in a theater to view a live performance) that it was of course developed during a time when there was no mechanical amplification of the human voice available. Given that, what is typically the lowest note that an opearatic bass is expected to sing?

[@BangYongguk-sf8ly]

Noice. Geoff is honsetly crazy idk how he practices tho. Ive been practicint subs for 1 or 2 years. I do it everyday throughout the day suddenly. My lowest subharmomic is A1 and its still A1. I really want to get that G1. But thats not working for me, instead 2nd subharmonics are happeing to me. Btw lowest note is E2 and im prolly a baritone by judging my own timbre.

[@danasutherlin1764]

I love just listening to you explain everything. You pick out things I don’t hear until you say it.

[@ajyadamiec]

I love the voiceplay / Geoff reviews. Keep them rolling

[@debgalloway1398]

I've watched this song more times than I can count yet you ALWAYS make me hear & realize there are things in his singing I have never heard, bringing even more appreciation in his talent. Your faces on your first time reactions are always priceless! I am so addicted to listening to you! One thing I have always loved about Geoff is how seamlessly he goes from the lowest notes into a typical melody (like the end of Sixteen Tons).

[@KaivalaJenva]

So Peter Barber does Elvis when??? Lovley breakdown and reminding us the range of Geoff and pointing out how he plays with us musically.

[@phobia4656]

Amazing analysis! 21:54 I think you meant "C2"

[@ondrejlukas326]

It's C1 tho

[@OnyxRose6]

His range is amazing & consistent which is what makes it so impressive! And his choreography is always so fun!

[@ChrisHaar]

I like your take on studio reliability. In the horn world live reliability is everything. When we have a young gun new to the industry that isn't quite there yet we call them rehearsal Rambo(s).

[@bruno5336]

Just the reaction I’ve been waiting for! I really enjoyed this one

[@shelleeroe7305]

Peter, I’n definitely new to your channel, but I’m definitely going to subscribe to you. You have enhanced my experience with music from a singer’s point of view. I’ve even learned some music theory. I love that you respect the artists and their arrangements. I have learned the complexities of how and what makes certain things work in arrangements. I have come to love music more through your analysis and I’ll admit it makes me happy to see your reactions to the low notes Geoff hits. Thank you for what you do. You are the person I keep coming back to when I want to learn about Geoff and Voiceplay arrangements. Also you have such an amazing voice. Keep up the great work and once again thank you.

[@rmdewberry2482]

Can't get enough Geoff. Can't get enough of you talking in detail about Geoff & VoicePlay!

[@kanelbulle59]

I love your reactions to the Geoff clones hahaha

[@huldradraco]

well, Geoff said hitting the C wasn't the hard part, it was hitting it with a good tone that was hard, as it easily just sounds like a burp, lol. he has to induce light trauma to his vocal cords to get good tone on anything below C#1

[@Chiefbird007]

the screen grab at 16:05 is amusing. It would be cool for the Bass Gang and Geoff to collaborate on a song.

[@carinarodebak9419]

Congratulations on the success of Bass Gang vol.2 but glad to see you back on reacting and analysing. I'm nagging at a reactor to view your solo Thomas Shelby tribute and he says it's on his list. Loving this playful Geoff.

[@ilonadever8249]

Peter, I always enjoy your reaction and analysis of Geoff's work, even if you are more highbrow than me. Great job!!

[@janetdw]

Whew! I was afraid you were going to stop before you got to the end. Thank you for the great analysis. And I love seeing you smile through the whole thing. I know that when I’m watching I’m grinning like a fool. I don’t know what you’re talking about a lot of the time because I have absolutely no musical training. But I have learned a lot from you and other informed reactors and I am always so grateful that you are so even handed in your comments. If there’s something you’re not crazy about, you make that criticism is a lot of grace. And when there’s something that truly deserves a shout out you give it wholeheartedly. I’m glad that you pointed out the difference between hitting a low note and hitting a low note consistently and musically. I have seen comments from people saying “oh I can do that”. But the difference is that they can’t do it consistently, and it may be low but it may not sound very good. I am anxious to see your reaction and analysis to their cover of Running up that Hill. There are some really interesting things that Geoff does that I haven’t heard before. And I would love to know how he’s doing that.🤨(And be sure to wait until the Patreon reel starts!)

[@techstormsproductions-gary9921]

Wonderful Geoff voice, and a lot of humor--a Geoff licking that cleaning brush at the end, while another Geoff eats popcorn from a dust bin.

[@tompeavy8254]

Highly-anticipated analysis and it didn’t disappoint. Great job. The video analysis of this would be as complex as Jeff really went all out to make the other Jeffs interact with one another. Such a cool piece.

[@DavideBaroni]

As always, LOVED your analysis. It's incredibly interesting to watch and listen the reactions and comments and explanations of someone who really KNOWS what he's talking about, and not just because he knows the theory, but because he actually PRACTICES it daily and professionally. Also, I love the respect you show not only to Geoff, but to EVERY artist you react to / analyse, and this is something that strucks some deep strings in my soul. I really appreciate it, it's something that is becoming less and less common, and to perceive it in your words and attitude is a breathe of fresh air for me. ❤ Oh, and BTW... Kudos for the Bass Gang stuff. You guys are not getting the success, the following and the positive critique you deserve, not by far. I try to make as many friends and people watch your videos as I can, but I'm a drop in the ocean, you guys have a distinct personality, and to me you are the 4th element of the "a cappella" QUADRIfecta, and think of it as an appreciation. I LOVE your work and I hope there will be more soon. Thank you for all you do.

[@Tiger5672]

Peter, great analysis of this amazing cover! I learn so much watching your videos!

[@johndeeregreen4592]

I am good to E1 in chest and J.D. Sumner has always had me in awe... I can do a C1 in chest-fry, but J.D. is the only bass I have ever heard hit C1 in full chest voice.

[@BluevesPL]

Imagine russian oktavists singing chest C1 without a mic

[@johndeeregreen4592]

@@BluevesPL, yeah, I know, lol. I am good to about F#1 in a choir setting... then there is the Oktavists.

[@Tiewaz]

I was waiting to see your reaction to this one. Your analysis is great, but I love your appreciation of the other parts of the whole video.

[@galaxyjay6918]

Ive been waiting for this!

[@michaelkler8191]

Always watch Geoff Castellucci/VoicePlay videos until the patron roll or you may miss a special outtro. I like to watch the video with subtitles on because Geoff sometimes puts humor in the subtitles. Could you please react to VoicePlay's latest Running Up That Hill? There are sounds that you need to comment on. I think Geoff is doing overtone singing and there is another short background part I can't identify.

[@alexwalker8440]

Thanks for another great reaction, Peter! I was really looking forward to it! 😍 Looks like Geoff had a lot of fun with it, and of course did an amazing job! 💯

[@Starrynightdiner]

For your algorithm. Smile.

[@alecsandyr]

My goodness, that finish made my ankles hurt. Lol

[@IAmTheDjinn]

would love to see a pentatonix amazing grace reaction!

[@diamondrosealkire7997]

I have fallen in love with Jeff as a bass singer I have heard many through the my lifetime from Tennessee Ernie Ford the P picker to Jimmy Dean To Harold from The Statler Brothers Barry White to name a few but I have never ever heard any of those go as low in base as Jeff does he takes base to a whole new level I think he has made a wonderful name for himself with his music I think he is fantastic and I hope the best for Jeff and he can continue to inspire us with his wonderful music and bass notes for the rest of his life what a talent

[@jillknowles5965]

Woo hoo!! Came home from a frustrating day at work and saw this reaction. It is wonderful, and saved my whole mood. Thank you so much for sharing your insights with us!!!!

[@WraithW69]

YAY! thanks Peter, sorry about my whine on your previous video. I always enjoy your reactions & great to see you cover this one. If I whine again, just roll your eyes & continue doing you :)

[@sarawlindgreen3115]

I really appreciate that you explained about the SOVT, because as someone without much knowledge into music theory I haven't actually thought about a thing like that, but just enjoyed the sound of it.

[@virginiathomas362]

I would just like to take a moment to appreciate "enhancening" as a word that really should already exist in the English language 😆 "Enhancing" + "enlightening" is a totally accurate description of your analyses, so I'm just gonna roll with it. And also possibly (probably) swipe it for future use. In all seriousness, I really do love this channel. I'm a writing nerd rather than a music nerd (I try but it never ends well 😂) so it's an absolute delight to be able to learn new things in such a fun format. It always surprises me how much I can apply to my own vocal efforts as well, despite being a high soprano. I even enjoy the digressions into music theory, and I hate music theory! (Too much like math. *SHUDDER*)

[@maudglazbrooke1287]

It basically is math in a party frock

[@virginiathomas362]

@@maudglazbrooke1287I just made an incredibly undignified honking noise 🤣

[@shirleykarr560]

Great analysis! As always, you pointed out and explained things I hadn't noticed or couldn't figure out on my own, no matter how many times I've watched and listened. I wasn't familiar with the original. Have a new appreciation for JD Sumner. Geoff clearly had so much fun with this, and Eli with the lighting and Layne on the camera, and Kathy throwing stuff to him/at him. We hadn't seen Geoff dance since Monster Mash. (It's so fun when Wolfman figures out he has hips.) It may have taken him 80 tries to get a good C1 for this, but just like expanding his range down for Oogie Boogie, it seems he's added a new note to his tool chest. He posted a Tik-Tok of him singing the very end, with nothing more than his phone's camera and mic, and cleanly hit the C1. Of course we don't know how many takes he did before the one he posted but I'm guessing a lot less than 80. You had me worried you were going to miss the funny bit at the end. Seems to be a new habit of both Geoff and VoicePlay -- keep playing until the Patreon credits roll or you'll miss good stuff. Can't wait to see your reaction to their latest, Running Up That Hill. The song is everywhere these days so it might pull in some viewers new to you.

[@chandlercarter349]

Ive been waiting for this video for so long. Can't wait to see this! Love the vids

[@Lilith-Rose]

Thought you were going to miss off the little comedy bit from the geoffs at the end before the credits, glad you snuck it in there

[@acsj78]

Love the ending of the song

[@markieman64]

Your JD Sumner name drop sent me down such a nostalgia rabbit hole. My family were really into the Gaithers when I was growing up, and I always remember his close friendship/rivalry with George Younce. I thought for my whole childhood that they really hated each other, but it wasn't until much later that I realised they were actually really close. If anyone is interested, there's a compilation of them where they are interviewed about each other, totally taking the Mick. Honestly, that rabbit hole made me so happy after I had finished watching this video, so thank you for your unintentional part in sending me down that!

[@brendaswolfe1435]

I love it when he does something fun like this or Monster Mash. I am awed by the rest of his work but with my life I need something lighthearted in addition to well executed. The outtro with one eating popcorn out of the dustpan and the other licking the toilet brush is hysterical 😄 🤣 Bass singers have always been my favorite and I really enjoy your channel and analysis. I'm learning so much.

[@MelodieRose727]

fantastic analysis! this was a wonderful way to learn more about a song that I truly love. thank you!

[@thomasfarr7934]

I enjoy your analysis! More than just a reaction!

[@ruthardis1452]

If you haven't already check out Tim Foust Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow /Won't You Stay A Little Bit Longer

[@royj.mattice]

Nice reaction/analysis Peter. What do you think is better? This or Misty Mountains?

[@PeterBarber]

Misty Mountains is probably my favorite Geoff song ever so I’ll have to go with that

[@christinestromberg4057]

The thngis his "solo" videos are all so different it's hard to choose between them. I love them all for different reasons.

[@lkayh]

I always look forward to your reactions! Love to see those pit vipers come out!!

[@Larisa0155]

Peter, я не понимаю, что Вы говорите, но мне так нравится Ваш голос!

[@bjspeck4337]

I loved the lightness and fun with this video. I know that Layne handled the steadi-cam for it wasn't a still piece and Eli handled the lights. Would have loved to have heard some of the shenanigans going on between the 3 of them. It would be fun to hear the 2 of you do a duet. Don't know what it should be but I'm sure anything that you guys put your minds (and voices) to would be terrific.

[@maia.t]

So happy to see you finally react to this one! 😍 So fun and very bass-y as always. 😄 I always love learning about the voice from you and your videos, especially as a flutist who certainly can’t sing haha 😂😊❤️

[@christophercisneros5548]

That G1 C2 is how the theme song starts of the Mandolarian

[@stevanholland7672]

It’s always a pleasure to watch your videos. Thanks for all the hard work

[@berserkervtuber6285]

I can't wait to see you break down the latest Voiceplay content; no, Geoff has no Halo notes, but the breakdown of the other notes are blissful to hear.

[@jimpayton8285]

Thank you including JD Sumner. Such an awesome bass singer

[@gailseatonhumbert]

Excellent analysis as usual Peter. 👏👏👏 Geoff is hysterical in this. I love the different spellings on his name tags. Have you looked at his video on hearing loss yet? A very good discussion. I also noticed Avi's 2 year old niece wearing headphones as hearing protection when they took her to his L.A. show at the Troubadour and other children at other artists' performances as well. Oh and on vocal technique can you at some point look at Avi's layered choruses on his new album? How do you produce that? And as a fellow bass how the heck does he get that high in spots like both the lead and chorus of "He Don't Love You Right"! Glad to see you back Peter on analysis even though the Bass Gang songs were fun.

[@jimpayton8285]

Thank you for your teaching in bass vocals. You are an awesome singer yourself. Love JD Sumner and Richard Sterbsn of the Oak Ridge Boys who sang with JD and the Stamps Quartet with Elvis

[@melindahancock8518]

I'm glad you brought up JD Sumner. So many folks have no idea who he is. Ever thought of putting together some vids of some vocalist history?

[@toddreed882]

Ok Peter…when do we get the reaction to Rains of Castamere? Waiting anxiously!!

[@pitchperfectcontralto]

6:31 killed me 😂😂

[@amioffenbacher4835]

I’d love to see you, Peter, sing with the group! Also a newbie question, what do your shades do when you put them on, if anything? I love your channel, thank you so much for the entertaining education!!! ❤

[@artchic1984]

Been waiting on u to do this one. So excited!! I love when u totally get into it, love seeing those genuine 1st time reactions in addition to ur amazing analysis. I had such fun watching this video of Geoff's, its so different and light and fun even tho the Bass is in the basement lol

[@tackdaniel9978]

Awesome Peter. Thank you for the notes on consistency and reliability and Jeff's vowel choices. Plus his range in chest! Love this guy.

[@tackdaniel9978]

Reminds me a little, of Rebroff, when he sings thru his range and the fun he has around his top notes.

[@caitlinkavanagh3298]

Thank you so much for the analysis, appreciate it greatly! I can always count on learning something new.

[@vallynmar]

Glad you are back to reacting. Hope your program is going well and looking forward to more from you. Love all the information you give and this reaction/analysis does not disappoint.

[@judybrowning1463]

Loved this!!

[@kaylagarvin2181]

I enjoyed this one Peter if you ever get a chance you should look into Tim Foust come go with me its really good thanks again Peter!😊

[@toddreed882]

I’ve been waiting to hear your take on this one! Great analysis!

[@Guest.7289]

1:52 and onward... Eric holloway has done a duet on his youtube channel (video not short) on this and hits the double low C pure chest and its thiccc too

[@wisdomplaysbtd6144]

it would be crazy to see peter react to a bass battle of the "big 3" bass singers (being Avi Kaplan, Tim Foust, and Geoff castellucci) it would be interesting to have insight from a bass that is just as low if not lower than them

[@PeterBarber]

They're lower than I am hehe but this is a great idea!

[@wisdomplaysbtd6144]

@@PeterBarber you don’t give yourself enough credit, you’re definitely top 5 bass in the world

[@troymclain9441]

You really need to listen to his new song Carol of the bells karma and be ready to wear the vipers through most of it

[@gentlemanlygerry]

Excellent review, analysis, explanation, and demonstrations. Would think that you might want to react to Eric Hollaway @thatbassvoice and his duet of this doing C1 in chest/throat mix, and his other videos too. He is a Basso Profundo and a full on Oktavist. Enjoy. Stay safe and stay awesome.

[@Guest.7289]

24:04 or watch eric holloways duet on this cover if you want to hear another person besides JD do it because its rare asf

[@clffliese26]

Have you reacted to Geoff's cover of Big Bad John? The original was by Jimmy Dean, yes, the sausage guy and Geoff's cover is awesome. I think Jimmy Dean would have approved.

[@kargyraa1]

Bobby Mc Ferrin , probably the best singer , would be interesting . Starting with Blackbird from Spontaneous inventions ( A solo voice masterèiece concert ) . And you will know about his range and all .

[@marshayoung9387]

Please do a reaction video of Voice Plays version of Running Up That Hill ? I heard it said that Geoff actually does throat singing in the start of the video & at the end. Wait until the credits roll before you stop the video. You don't want to miss anything.

[@barbarakennedy2667]

To me that beginning sounds like a combined hum and whistle.

[@danielbenjaminmesser6234]

Crystal River Boys Rainbow of Love the bass Ken Turner sing full subharmonics and I think hits a C1 it’s soooo smooth please check it out.

[@razorx2024]

i'd love to see you react to Geoff singing Take Me Home Country Roads, it looks like you haven't reacted to that one yet and it's great 🙂

[@tmfyi8048]

Geoffs C1 sub took him 80 tries

[@sammyb528]

Bro, gotta do Goeff's version of Take Me Home (Country Roads) it's Pit Viper central

[@johanneslang2527]

where did u find the behind the scenes content from Geoff?

[@alaaddintimez1887]

Badass bassy bashful befuddled big boi!

[@matthewiam4581]

Supposedly that final note took him 80 takes!

[@maeco7]

He clarified that it took 80 takes not just to hit the note, because hitting it alone isn't such a problem - it's that it takes a lot of tries before he can get a musical tone out of it once he's down that low rather than it just sounding like a croak. That's some dedication!

[@matthewiam4581]

@@maeco7 exactly! The take be got had to be right so it sounded really rich and fat

[@kelseyhampton727]

I’m naturally a soprano, but I have in fact learned to sing all the way to baritone range. I want to get lower to learn to sing where Geoff is. I am a gremlin for music and this is my dream.

[@jakesbel8237]

Wait for menopause! I’m dramatic coloratura, the huge voice of a dramatic with coloratura range. I remember in high school middle C was rough. I’ve now can get to A below middle C but that’s it. Lost a few of my high notes but who needs F above high C. lol But I’m 70.

[@erinromary2796]

Loved this. Please, PLEASE watch VoicePlay new one Running up that hill.

[@cloudyskies8644]

Fun

[@nationstationmusic227]

21:50 LMAO HAHAHA. To be able to sing a C1 with subharmonics you have to have a comfy C1 chest so in order to hit C1 subs you have to hit C1 chest im pretty sure only JD has a comfy C1 chest lol

[@simonfitzgerald7104]

Personally I’d say the G4 is in his head voice. It would be much more belty if it was.

[@js_musicmedia8981]

Was Elliot's C1 in Mad World not chest?

[@Ascension721]

He went to a D1 in chest, i dont think he went down to a C1 there

[@crunchycrackers7364]

@@Ascension721 lowest he went was C#1. It didn't sound very good though.

[@hugobasilio1303]

​@@crunchycrackers7364He actually has gone down to a B0, a few times too.