We got into a HEATED Debate over Geno Smith

#PickaSide #NFLWeek2 #408
Watch the Full Ep Now: • #408 Week 2 Overreacti...

[@RCunderscore]

2022 vs 2023 Geno is the biggest test to see who knows ball. He was much much better in 2023 but box score merchants don't know that.

[@nas8350]

Literally a direct seperation between the people who watch tape and evaluate a player, and the “bUt HiS sTaTs WeRe LoWeR” group

[@thesecond1a]

If anyone outside of Seattle fans paid attention they would know his o-line was injured heavily in 2023.

[@CHRISTBRO]

@@nas8350Geno was good, he also had a lot of boneheaded plays . Overall, he’s a good quarterback and one of the best value contracts at the position and i hope we extend him

[@nas8350]

@@CHRISTBRO I think he’s more than that. I don’t think he’s just a good value for his contract, I think he’s one of the best qbs in the nfl.

[@evanvargas3170]

It doesn’t matter what Geno does some fans will always point to his days with the jets. Since becoming Seattles starter he’s been playing great football. I say he’s top 10-12 easily.

[@Sleeprr11]

Glad Genos finally getting his respect

[@NBAHive]

2nd from the left really knows his stuff. Geno is soooo underrated, lucky to watch him

[@thewarhammerguy5995]

I’ve never see any QB be as divisive as Geno Smith lol

[@twistedfantasyy]

Geno is divisive because people are stubborn. They still cannot fathom that a guy can just turn around his career like that. Another one is Geno is still yet to win a playoff game, but our playoff matchup was literally the 49ers at its peak. I hope he can have a win against the 9ers as a Seattle QB but whenever we play them it's not even just him our entire team just gets ran over by the 9ers lol we have like a bottom 5 offensive line and run defense lol it's our skill positions that are elite (secondary and wr room) other than QB

[@danpshop]

Geno is modern day Rich Gannon. He’s getting better every year and is currently playing the best ball of his career. He’s 90% mastered this offense and their protections. The OC is still figuring out how to scheme around the leaky guards and awful situation at RT. It’s hard to imagine the OL playing any worse than they have in the first two weeks. It’s also hard to imagine them getting much better. A lot of these guys, Purdy, Goff, Stafford for example, would meltdown behind this Seattle OL. No doubt Geno is top 10. I’m really loving watching him play.

[@jakegebo6447]

Awful situation at LT??? Charles cross is not awful. Maybe you meant RT

[@danpshop]

@@jakegebo6447 yeah my bad. Thanks for the correction! I edited the post. Cross has been playing quite well

[@divinecomedy7311]

Finally ppl outside seattle waking up on Geno. Guy is a top 10 QB no doubt

[@jordshuttlewood]

Now you went to far why not just say he's a good qb mahomes,burrow,Allen,lamar,herbut,Rodgers,dak,purdy,hurts,cousins,Stroud,love,goff,Stafford,kyler who's he better than I think he's close to couple in same tier but not better than but you tell me who you take off this list to get geno in top 10

[@unknownuser69420.]

@@jordshuttlewoodmahomes burrow Allen Lamar Herbert stroud love Stafford kyler. That’s it

[@jordshuttlewood]

@@unknownuser69420. That's nonsense my man sorry but how can geno be better than purdy it's just not reasonable take Seahawks have better receivers than niners better oline niners better RB and tightened for sure but geno has all weapons he needs but Brock has just been better it's not even debateable

[@jordshuttlewood]

@@unknownuser69420. I think he's maybe on level with hurts and that's only because hurts as only been better for one year if he was playing every year at the level he did in SB run he would be way ahead too ill let cousins go cuz he's coming off surgery I'll give that one goff is a sb qb I'm not willing to say he's better than him or dak.

[@utryping]

@@jordshuttlewood geno's oline is 31 of 32 in pass block win rate and 31 in run block win rate. idk what it is on the niners but it's almost impossible for it to be worse than that. purdy is running a shanahan offense that got jimmy g to the super bowl and geno has a first year oc from college

[@reap3r_5oh]

Shane Waldron screwed over Geno and the rest of the offense last year that’s why his stats regressed.

[@DaNxYsmells007]

Yeah casuals only care about the QB but couldn't even name the coaches he played for lol

[@reap3r_5oh]

@@DaNxYsmells007 preach brother🙏🏼🗣️💯

[@SndjjwwejWdbbwene]

@@reap3r_5ohwhy is Seattle so hated ? It’s starting to piss me off cause we are a good team we just need a new o line like 2 players

[@ZachLester]

AND GENO BETTER THAN HERBERT - HERBERT HAS REGRESSED EVERY YEAR SINCE HIS ROOKIE SEASON

[@kingkoloa4733]

Ain’t a single soul in the league taking Geno over Herbert. Even if you took Genos skill now and put it in his 25 year old body 😭

[@alginvestmentllc7638]

@@kingkoloa4733 Geno has been to more pro bowls than Herbert has. Been better than him last two years. Beat him at LA. Geno has an mvp vote on top of that. Herbert is overrated. Geno is ascending this year

[@bobjeff1243]

thats pushing it a bit...

[@bobjeff1243]

@@alginvestmentllc7638 he also has a better offense

[@alginvestmentllc7638]

@@bobjeff1243 it is not. If you wanna say like mahomes or Allen yes that’s pushing it for sure. Herbert has not done anything to be considered at their level but yet they try to squeeze him in there

[@Still_Lawless1]

Geno smith is honestly hated on because of his name

[@jazzorion1]

I’ve noticed people still have this preconceived notion about Geno’s ability from his days with the Jets (who have proven to be a franchise that is a death sentence for young QBs by this point), rather than actually watching the tape and looking at the stats since he became the Seahawk’s starter. He is literally one of the most pressured QBs in the league and despite that has one of the top pressures-to-sack ratios and is completing 70% of his passes. Dude has been a dawg since he took over the starter job. Stop basing your analysis on your feelings.

[@jazzorion1]

He literally broke the record for number of game-winning drives in a single season last year. What are we even arguing about?

[@Fhreze]

We would have blown out the broncos lmao we got 2 safeties and a muffed punt that lead to a FG most of denvers points came from our incompetent oline even when geno threw the pick he was hit while throwing to a relatively open lockett geno has played at an elite level these 1st 2 games

[@SndjjwwejWdbbwene]

Not to mention o line being trash first half

[@trevormcguire6984]

Geno is top 10 no doubt. Dude is a freaking wizard in the pocket and he has elite arm talent and accuracy. Pull your heads out of the past and go watch some tape

[@ZachLester]

GENO BEEN GREAT FOR GOIN ON 3 YEARS NOW, JORDAN LOVE HAD 1/2 OF A GOOD SEASON - EVER!... ARE WE REALLY GONNA SUCK OFF LOVE FOR PLAYIN GOOD FOR HALF A SEASON. PPL JUST DONT LIKE GENO CAUSE OF HIS PAST

[@woahhtim]

Fr ppl not ready to accept Geno

[@matthewphillips5911]

Oh man. I feel bad I don't know names, but second from left... came in with the guns. Makin' people look like fools. I LOVE that he just demolished the "Geno regressed!" narrative.

[@alginvestmentllc7638]

Justin Herbert lost bad to Geno at LA. Stop overrating Herbert

[@matthewphillips5911]

Hey, Chargers only have 2-6 weeks of enjoyment of the season. Next offseason their fanbase is going to tear itself apart arguing over who to fire, Harbaugh or Herbert. Let them have this time.

[@alginvestmentllc7638]

@@matthewphillips5911 chargers will charger themselves.

[@colingundel8779]

Seattle fan here. Have any of you seen how our offensive line has played? The only high point has been Charles cross. And geno has still been putting in work.

[@andrewmermel6217]

GENO GENO!

[@SndjjwwejWdbbwene]

“Heated” debate ☠️

[@Doom253]

And geno doing it with out an oline he’s like that

[@willmerrick9563]

Love the pod. -Spotify fan

[@_Obsessedsports]

Bro came with every stat he was READY for this fight. Geno will end up top 5 book it

[@DaNxYsmells007]

Only 1 person on this podcast took the time to do research the other guys don't know shit about seattle

[@kailshont]

I’m glad some people in the room have solid ball knowledge, it’s a complicated discussion, Geno SHOULD be in top 10 CONSIDERATION

[@hawkfan12s]

Bro in the left middle gained a lot of respect from me. Nobody standing up for geno like him and the 12s understand how great he is. Nobody else in the country gives a fuck about geno and overlooks him all the time don’t give him credit for shit. Geno is a top 10 qb if he’s 10 then he’s 10 but he’s definitely in the top 10 with his effectiveness to the team and the consistency is the thing that concerns people but he’s a clutch qb and makes up for his mistakes nearly every time.

[@RyanTay3]

All anyone has to see about Geno is hes doing everything with a bottom 3 OL. Imagine if he had a middle of the road OL.

[@SergioDuran-h7e]

bro said trevor lawrence lmao

[@SndjjwwejWdbbwene]

Mfs stay hating on the Seahawks more than the cowboys the NFL, their analysists , and other fans look at all social media posts of Seahawks being 3-0 and look at all the comments

[@nfn58]

this is okay as long as you say the same thing about murray, purdy, carr, mayfield, darnold, and rodgers

[@ericsong5155]

You can say the same thing about Purdy but Geno Smith cookin more than the others you listed for these past 2 years

[@matthewphillips5911]

Murray has had 2 games. His play has NEVER been consistent. Purdy is behind maybe the best o-line and is asked to do very little. Mayfield starts to fit the bill... but has done it for less time and with less impressive stats. Darnold also has done less in 2 (maybe 1) game in an offense that is beginning to look like it drastically elevated Cousins. And Rodgers... is one of the most overrated QBs of all time. Your take is ok, as long as you don't care about reality and facts

[@MaxxxBetz]

"Bitch you lost me (yeah), fair weather, wishy washy". - Eminem. Man yall have the craziest takes, im assuming that east coast/midwest bias dominates this pod. Put some respect on Geno, he is elite. And maybe go watch some highlight of charboniet destroying defenders via stiff arm and bulldozing mfs.

[@latinoheat2806]

When are the week 3 predictions being uploaded gang?

[@pickaside]

Tonight. We couldn’t record yesterday

[@matthewpollard6754]

Can I make a over reaction the saints will go 17-0 and win the superbowl doing what have never been done before

[@tdbowenmusic]

They played the Broncos and Patriots, and those games were far too close for how bottom teir those teams are. Geno is good, but not great. He was a top half QB in 2023 (barely). He definitely gets way too much hate, but he's also not as good as some Seahawks fans imagine he is.

[@DaNxYsmells007]

Geno is a great QB and you act like he doesn't have a rookie HC and OC yet agin having a trash o line. How many "great QBs" have a top tear coach and O line? Not Geno that's why he's Great.

[@_Obsessedsports]

Box score watcher 😂ydkb

[@jessicaphoenix1312]

We'll find out.

[@BenjaJohnsonIII]

Geno smith is top 5 and that’s not a hot take You can’t name 5 qbs better then Geno

[@ryaver1925]

Gino’s a dog put some respect on my boy and the hawks there going places

[@creamdreamer]

Put some respect on your boy by spelling his name correctly.

[@DavidTheGoliathProductions]

@@creamdreamerfacts

[@ExposingFootballFallacies]

Geno over Kyler Geno over Jordan Love to me is crazy

[@ogbops]

It’s simple, watch the tape and buckle up this season.

[@Dose561]

I agree Geno Smith is a top 10 backup. I really hope somebody didn’t imply that he’s a top 10 starter cuz that’s wild AF

[@DROPOUTCRIS]

Hes definitely close to top ten. Name 10 that are definitively better than geno

[@adrianhernandez-j8l]

Either you didn’t watch the video or you didn’t watch the video because the whole point of the video was he’s performing like a top 10 starting quarterback in some people eyes 💀

[@dr3693]

name 10 better

[@DigontoZahid-lc7kt]

Stop embarrassing yourself son

[@demetriusdemarcusbartholom1929]

Your unintelligent

[@JdWalker-o6w]

Geno smith top 10????? Must be a Seahawks fan

[@michaelhacault1665]

No, just not an idiot

[@evanvargas3170]

From 2022-20224 Geno is top 10 in every passing statistic. So by the numbers he is top 10 and he’s put those number up behind one of the worst offensive lines.

[@evanvargas3170]

Yards 6th - 8404 TDs 8th - 52 Passer rating 8th - 96.8 Completion % 3rd - 67.8 Yards per game 12th - 247.2 He’s borderline top 10 in my opinion if you disagree then you just are going off of feelings instead of facts .

[@DaNxYsmells007]

You don't know ball