High Taxes, Low Services: Pakistan's Tax Trap & the Blame Game

[@mehrmazulfaqar2816]

Such a mind opening discussion..Thank you PIDE ❤

[@FitLifeJourneyUSA]

Ather Maqsood Ahmed explained very well Specially last words..that we are almost 70 years old now the time for our youngsters..deep and meaningful words

[@ranahammad4561]

Gem 💎 shabbar zaidi

[@ranahammad4561]

Shabbar zaidi is great person

[@AbdulGhaffar99]

Shabbar Zaidi Sahab is most intelligent, sane and rational voice i am glad to hear his thoughts on such matters.

[@AsadAbbasSZ786]

Syed Muhammad Shabbar Zaidi is a brilliantly ruthless person when it comes to telling the truth. The last few minutes of this debate tells everything. He is a true patriot and true well wisher of Country and its people.

[@anlearnersgroup]

Dr Ather is our gem such a great personality. May ALLAH PAK protect him and gives him long healthy wealthy life. Ameen Sumameen

[@mohammadjaffarabbas9880]

Shabar Sahab is correct that governments and economies are managed rationally, not emotionally. Athar Sahab's last statement was merely an emotional outburst. He should have behaved like an economist not like a layman.

[@khalidiqbal1987]

Before an economist, he is a human being.

[@mohammadjaffarabbas9880]

@@khalidiqbal1987 So?

[@husainzaidi1527]

Thumbs up for Shabbar Zaidi Sb.

[@munawarahmadmajoka3736]

Thanks for attending to this important issue. However no body touched the untouchables. Emotional Nationalistic outburst was uncalled for. In one such seminar kakar got emotional and got the top slot. 😊

[@ranahammad4561]

Heartily discussion

[@iqbalkeerio3079]

Shabbar Zaidi is 100% right.

[@ranahammad4561]

Heartly well discussion

[@zaf7794]

✨ Excellent outro by Shabbar Zaidi. Pakistanis need to get out of this patriotic jingoism syndrome as it is not going to lead them anywhere as we have already witnessed this in past 70 years history of this country. Anyone who criticise becomes indian agent, ghaddar, mulk dushman, anti state, all this rubbish need to stop. People need to address the issues, injustice, inequality and identify people in authority and call them out who protects and benefits from these problems of a common citizen.

[@vikasb1400]

Liquor 🥃🍸 should be made out of Government control and tax should be levied on it.

[@ranahammad4561]

Very good discussion love this

[@ghulamuddin-gd9642]

Very good show, the link should be sent to ministry finance, provincial governments and all relevant departments.

[@MariaAli-g4s]

mr Athar the gem .

[@javaidak4204]

😂 well said by Shabbar,such debate and discussion is all bakwaas,they fully know it and deliberately do it to make us chareya 😅

[@advocatehafiznasirmahmood5980]

I always waite for you all my dear ones❤

[@Iramkabir7298]

Very informative discussion & latest issues of our economy are discussed here ....but my question is ...Why taxes system not efficient in Pakistan only documentary policies made by government...... why not practically imposses these policies??

[@RahulMishra-ld2bo]

Because there is a force which controls everything in Pakistan. They will be against it every time, it's called the Pakistani army.

[@prafulagrawal7426]

Nehruji used to tell bajpayeeji. You are a right man in wrong party sameway Shabbar Saab aright man in wrong country

[@DevendraSingh-dp9qu]

@@prafulagrawal7426 Mr Praful Agarwal jee , vajpayee is right man in right party . Jai shri Ram .

[@ranahammad4561]

So nice

[@tariq4846]

ہم نے اکانومی کا مطلب اکاؤنٹنسی بنا لیا ہے اور ملکی معیشیت منشیوں کے حوالے کر دی ہے۔ یہی سب سے بڑا مسئلہ ہے۔

[@zaf7794]

Acha economist 2018 government ney lanay ke koshish ke the lekin us py mulk mey shor macha dya tha molvi party ny

[@vikasb1400]

Shahbaz Sharif, Nawaz Sharif, Hamza Sharif, Maryam Sharif, Son in law of Nawaz Sharif, Isac Dar all wants post

[@vikasb1400]

Zakat is there no need of Taxes

[@fafareedahmed]

Pakistan has to a take a very ruthless decisions to get out of this quagmire. First and fore most is to cut the size of government including security forces, and utilize the surplus manpower in constructive work. Must control over population, ensure 100% primary education.

[@HashimTareen-i1f]

Excellent reviews however let's not include burucracy because they are helpless if he refuses always showed door by politicians

[@KaramjitSingh-yv6tj]

Kuj Nahi palle pouna Inna ne. Shabber Saab sach bol rahe hain unko Kodi ne kaam Nahi Karne dena

[@masroorkhalil9655]

20:15 whooo is this satyaaa huwaa chapar ganjuuu 😂😂😂😂

[@anlearnersgroup]

Mind your language bro. Aap k ilfaaz se sap ki trbiyt show ho rahi r ye ilfaaz aap ne apne baap ko bolein hain.

[@masroorkhalil9655]

​@@anlearnersgroup Ageer wooo ittnaa badaaaa chutyeaa or chapri hotaaa toooo mee uskoo bhee boltaa yeee baat yad rakhoo kamine admi keee pass dum nae hotee hotee uskii zaban heeee usskee sab seee bade nishani hotee hain

[@Kanishka-d6w]

*Pakistan NA khappey*

[@zaf7794]

Mr. Athar ny wohi ghisa pita nara lgaya to provoke patriotic sentiment of audience and viewers but sorry to say this is not going to work anymore. Yeh emotional bkwas is not going to produce any results yeh typical political nara hai awam ko beywaqoof bnanay k liyey.

[@anlearnersgroup]

Tou aap koi nayi policy bata dein hm wohi maan lein gein😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@KaramjitSingh-yv6tj]

BAAT dusri dunyian ki mat kro Isi dunyian ki kro pehle isko toh Sahi karlo Bhai dusri dunyian KO baad mein Dekh Lena. Khud roti Khao fer dusre KO Anand SE khila sakte ho

[@AbdulWawab]

Tar tar karty ho bas