Pikesville vs Rare Breed Rye Whiskey

[@100puremustard5]

Great video. Throw in KC 2009 Cask Strength Rye 119 proof (it's really good!) to that flight fight. Pikesville is $39.99 locally, can't beat that. Cheers!

[@cyrano33]

I love the Pikesville. She’s never disappointed, always delivers, and will forever be destined to be a part of my bar!

[@mitchilito99]

I revisited my bottle of Pikesville last night and boy oh boy is it good. Thanks for you two takes on the subject. Keep up the great work!!

[@tommyg5095]

Started liking bourbons o ly a few years ago,,, then tried and like scotches,,, but gotta say, when I found some good ryes, I am a rye kinda person... Funnily enough, I picked up a Compass Box Spice Tree, and this scotch, for me, is like the best rye ever... Soooo, my favorite rye is really a scotch... True...

[@millerscott4003]

My wife and I just did the bourbon trail about a month ago. While on the tour at Buffalo trace a person in the group asked the guide what the best tasting bourbon was. He had a great answer that would probably piss off his marketing person. In a nutshell he said whatever bourbon you like best is the best bourbon. Having said that wild turkey rare breed rye is my favorite rye whiskey.

[@jkojiro4945]

Flight Fight last night! OF 100 added to the mix: 1. Rare Breed Rye- Evolving palate, long finish, mouthcoat is great, complex flavors. 2. Pikesville- Best Nose, Nice coating of palate. 3. OF Rye- Decent Nose, and almost beat out Pikesville because palate is my favorite of the three, but has almost no finish and disappears on the palate.

[@Twotonsandwich]

Really appreciate the editing of the live session to pull out the featured tasting! Lives are fun, but I never have enough time to watch through the whole thing. Thanks! And skål from Minnesota!

[@ThriftyWhiskey]

You guys should definitely do this blind, and throw a few other ryes in the mix. Rye Flight Fight! Flight Fights are probably my favorite episodes from you guys and we will absolutely be stealing that idea from you on our channel. Haha. We will mix it up a little bit though. Thanks for the videos!

[@rjt135]

Watching this after picking up a bottle of Pikesville after searching (unsuccessfully) for Rare Breed Rye. Really enjoying it so far

[@goodperson6622]

Wow! Same here 😅

[@stevenrankin6672]

The first rye I tried was Sazarach and it just tasted bland to me so I didn't try another one until last night. I did a little fight and was really glad I did. Jim beam rye, Russell reserve rye and Jack Daniel single batteries select rye changed my mind. Now I'm gonna go puck up these 2 bottles and a know creek rye

[@jreezy70]

I’ve had a couple bad bottles of Pikesville recently (cut too close to the tails, or something like that, is what the tasting manager at my local store said it tasted like). I miss my Pikesville, and can’t find the Rare Breed Rye, so for now I’ll sip my Rare Breed bourbon. Cheers 🥃

[@matthewtsai4847]

Ha I just picked both of them up yesterday! Paid 50 for WTRBR and 40 for Pikesville. Still have yet to pop them open

[@jaradwhite9352]

Found your channel a couple of days ago and have been loving it.... Thank you

[@ItsBourbonNight]

Jarad White Thank you! Glad you’re enjoying it!

[@jordanstamps5475]

So glad y’all started pulling from your live videos keep it up 🥃 cheers

[@DC632A]

Pikesville is the liquid gold standard of what a Rye should be. Hands down.

[@samuelmorse784]

Ralfy agrees and so do I.

[@tde2019]

I popped my Pikesville last night. DELICIOUS pour. Definitely going to be my go to rye for sippinh. I have a RR SiB rye I haven’t popped yet and a Sazerac so I’m excited to see how those compare. Also have a Whistlepig Boss Hog VII comin in a few weeks :D

[@carlupthegrove262]

I need to try the Rare Breed but I love Pikesville....as you both do

[@lonewanderer3603]

Add in the Knob Creek 115 Rye to your flight fight.

[@Ilikewhiskey2112]

This is my favorite whiskey for the price.

[@puddingwar5110]

Need a wild turkey 101 rye VS the rare breed opinion compare, if your doing a flight fight I would like to see old foresters rye in there.

[@christopherciulla8190]

I would love to see this done blind. Just because the two of you are so entertaining and I would love to see the struggle when you don’t know which is which.

[@thefreshprince8005]

Pinkesville nice finish.👌🏾

[@mattknisley4105]

Flight fight. Pikesville, rare breed, wilderness trail, KCBP

[@jamestaylor9258]

Great review. I'd love to see you blind these. Great references and double entendres. 😳😁😉 The understanding and smiles? Win-win!

[@taunaengus4978]

I'll take both, total toss up.

[@DMBVR4]

OF100 Rye could be added to the flight fight, its triple digit proof and barely legal.

[@Thumper99TA]

OF100 Rye is NOT a barely legal rye.

[@jkojiro4945]

Exactly what I was thinking, and what my plan was. KC for the fourth maybe?

[@RobertSmith-tt5qv]

OF 100 RYE IS 65% RYE. THAT'S A HIGH RYE AND A DAM GOOD ONE AT $22.00 IN OHIO.

[@DMBVR4]

It tastes closer to a bourbon than most any other rye. Its as barely legal as it needs to be for this purpose.

[@josephwatts2904]

Can’t wait to try the RB Rye!

[@jmhamilton87]

I guess I’ll have to go find a pikesville... already have the rare breed rye.

[@robbanta2979]

Speaking of jelly... all I can smell in Old Forrester Rye is grape jelly

[@ShadowHawk05]

Need that RareBreed Forgiven maybe do that against a Russell’s Forgiven or a regular Forgiven.

[@Erik_T_Thompson]

When you did your "live studio audience" shtick I realized you have a really good voice over guy.

[@loganclemons4961]

May as well add knob creek single barrel 115pf rye and willet family estate 4 year and call it a blind flight fight!

[@lukewo5067]

And that's the plot to back to the future 😆

[@TheDWeeks]

Will you be restocking glassware on your WA website? I wanted to order the "Drink More Bourbon" glasses, been sold out for quite a while now. Thanks!

[@ItsBourbonNight]

Dan Weeks Yes, it’s on order now, just slower bc of the pandemic but it will be here soon!

[@VaryingViewpoint]

Great review!

[@jamesbullard4897]

Jelly on my belly And here comes nelli

[@squad5111]

I cannot find pikesville rye anywhere where I’m at

[@prespa9]

Its all about the finish right.

[@Jaynick1977]

Do a barely legal rye flight fight which will have given your bottles enough time to open. Throw in an Old Forester 100 because it's similar.

[@prespa9]

Can I find Pikesville in Phoenix AZ.

[@jamesbullard4897]

Man I love to watch Sara drink high proof😍

[@whiskeytraveler1698]

I have a bottle of Pikesville it's on my Favorite list.

[@tde2019]

Pikesville is an absolutely DELICIOUS pour!

[@JoseMtz02]

#NuttySquad Rye Oh Rye! They fight it out!

[@877-MASH-NOW]

Whiskey cheers

[@richardh.1600]

When you guys air out a bottle, do you just leave it uncorked and for how long? Thanks!

[@roscoejenkins4221]

Great question.. I'm still waiting for an answer

[@jskypercussion]

I usually leave mine open for about 15-20 minutes

[@richardh.1600]

@@jskypercussion same!

[@albertgrant1017]

Scott81 Try Rittenhouse Bullitt or Old Fitxgeralld Rye or Wild Turkey Rye .

[@ItsBourbonNight]

Albert Grant We love Turkey 101 rye in cocktails.

[@mrrednick81]

Can anybody recommend a good entry level rye whiskey.i love wheated whiskey and bourbon but I would like to expand my world of whiskey and try something new

[@jamesbullard4897]

Genes 2/ times removed is attractive

[@jrc480]

Rye whiskey is the pumpkin spice of real people.

[@jporter6253]

Where did this blind flight fight go?!

[@ItsBourbonNight]

What flight were we talking about? We can’t remember half of the time haha.

[@jporter6253]

@@ItsBourbonNight The blind fight between Rare Breed Rye and Pikesville, I just picked up the Rare Breed and watched your head to head review.

[@jporter6253]

I picked up 2 bottles of Pikesville strictly on your guys love for it! Can’t say it disappoints! You guys content is bar none some of the best in the WhiskeyTube! Thanks for what you do!

[@ItsBourbonNight]

@@jporter6253 thank you!

[@proofisinthebourbon]

Did that blind flight fight ever go down?

[@ItsBourbonNight]

Humm, I can’t really remember what flight we talked about in this episode. Which one did we mention?

[@proofisinthebourbon]

@@ItsBourbonNight Pikesville vs rare breed rye vs two other barely legal ryes

[@ItsBourbonNight]

@@proofisinthebourbon Ah, that makes sense. No, I don’t think we ever did that one. We’ll have to when we start Flight Fights back up.

[@jamesbullard4897]

Wow this is soo interesting

[@jamesbullard4897]

I love 101 rye as much as rare breed sad to say

[@cowpattycreek]

drinking pikesville rye right now ... rye is just too minty for me ... just too partial to sourdough and honey

[@prespa9]

Pikesville it is.

[@jakewkayakfishing8457]

I do like Pikesville, but for some reason to my palate Pikesville tastes the least like bourbon of any of the lower rye ryes. I get a strong black licorice flavor from it.

Wooo hooo funny show guys

[@bschnell9]

Non blind is so biased. Add a 3rd to the flight fight

[@ajwhitfield5793]

Do the same thing blind, Rare Breed will win. Guarantee.

[@adamrethlake973]

100 percent and she shakes her head NO....

[@samuelmorse784]

This yuppie couple could never convince me to buy PIKESVILLE. But Ralfy the Scottish whiskey expert did. Pikesville wins hands down

[@ItsBourbonNight]

Yuppie? Hahaha, well that's a new one :)

All tastings must be done blind

[@hokeypokeyalso1783]

You both need to drink a lot more before you make a decision!