Pink Floyd’s ‘Dogs’ 2018 Remix: A Legendary Track Reimagined: Rock Drummer Reacts and Rates

[@candrv]

Great reaction. It’s understandable to be awestruck by the song, especially given your history with it. Music is a time machine - your comments were well placed and welcome. I found the remix to be quite nice, the added cleanliness gives it more nuance in my opinion. Thanks again.

[@llarose]

Music really is a time machine. It has this incredible ability to transport us back to specific moments in our lives, and Dogs is one of those tracks that carries so much depth and emotion for me and many others. I'm glad you enjoyed my comments. I agree with you on the remix-the added clarity does bring out some nuances that were maybe a bit buried in the original

[@thomaswest7746]

I got to see this concert in Cleveland Stadium in Cleveland Ohio also my favorite PF LP

[@llarose]

That's incredible! Seeing the Animals tour live must have been an unforgettable experience, especially at such an iconic venue - definitely one of Pink Floyd's masterpieces.

[@riocorrespondant7797]

Both sound good in their own way. Regards the song itself, it's a giant. A masterpiece as you said. Keep up the great reactions.

[@llarose]

Thank you for the kind words. More to come from PF.

[@doscwolny2221]

Both the original(muddy sound) and the 2018 (bit colder,less emotional) have their strong points. Love both. I like the original dogs but i prefer the 2018 pigs 3 diff ones, and sheep im undecided both are good.

[@llarose]

It’s interesting how both versions bring something different to the table. The original Dogs definitely has that raw, gritty vibe, while the 2018 remix offers a cleaner, more polished sound-there’s something to appreciate in both. As for Pigs and Sheep, both are coming up soon. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

[@garymoore4909]

Hi Larry! I lost both of my parents in the last 4 years so I feel your pain bro! The Animals album is also one of my favourite Pink Floyd albums if you are able to get around the youtube copyright algo you should try to upload The Wall studio album reaction imo its far better than the movie and you will love the drumming in it!

[@llarose]

I'm really sorry for your loss; losing both parents must have been an incredibly tough experience. The Animals album is such a powerful piece, and it resonates even more during hard times. Thanks for the suggestion about The Wall-I’ve got to agree, the studio album is a masterpiece. I’ll definitely see what I can do about getting around the KZbin copyright algo. Ugh... Thanks for the support, bro!

[@XionLuis]

The remix sounds really nice but I prefer the original version. Something didn't sit well with me with the remixed version, though I can't put a finger on it a the moment.

[@llarose]

@@XionLuis My only critique of the sound fidelity is it is a bit bass-heavy. I also agree, the original is also beyond reproach for an era-correct recording. Thanks for chipping in.

[@capetowntrikeman]

I agree 100% I think it sounds too "clinical"...lacks the warmth of the original.