Pokémon Red/Blue AI Tournament - Scientifically Ranking the Pokémon Red Trainers

[@pimanrules]

After far too long, the follow-up to this video is finally out. In it, I fix many of the issues with the original tournament and run the whole thing again, except this time with all the Pokémon flattened to level 50. Check it out: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aGWaondnptqfibM

[@Fandresvc]

Off topic but the misty misty thing activated some dormant neurons about a certain 2006 shitty pokemon animation for me. Love it.

[@Sunaki1000]

Its been a while, and a lot of work for you, but are you interested in continuing your Research? I would die to know whos the strongest Hoenn Trainer is. Maybe even whit all the Frontier Brains at Lv 50 included.

[@cephon6198]

Is that a Pokemon spoof reference at 3:30?

[@KinnikuNINJA]

PLEASE do this for Gold/Silver/Crystal!

[@PHEEliNUX]

>Lorelei got a bug in the code that made her "better" >Stills spams rest Ah yes, the universal constant of Red and Blue

[@GdotWdot]

Gen1 gonna Gen1.

[@lisavauhti7675]

BuT PsYCHic>aLl

[@Sir_Isaac_Newton_]

@@lisavauhti7675 what is my irl name

[@Calmtimer]

Now, say my name

[@feha92]

I mean, if she is spamming rest then she is doing her job. Her entire position in that team is to lure out high-damage low-pp moves and make you exhaust them as early as possible. The only issue is that she uses pokemon with some really unfortunate matchups, both against starters (pikachu/venusaur defeats water, and charizard ice) and various other beasts/TMs likely found in your team. Should have had a team of snorlax.

[@mads_in_zero]

I actually laughed out loud when I noticed Lorelei's draw ratio. That infamous soft lock... Pokemon Yellow actually added a check that goes "are you Lorelei? if so, don't spam rest just because it's psychic type"

[@abarette_]

yea lmao, that code is hilarious

[@Metalhammer1993]

lol? really? that#s awesome

[@Silith13]

I believe one of Lance's Dragon pokemon does it too with Amnesia.

[@zacharyadler4071]

@@Silith13 You might be talking about Lance's Dragonite using Agility

[@FrostGlader]

@@zacharyadler4071 it’s the sole reason that the All Terrain Venomoth from Twitch Plays Pokémon was also known as the Dragon Slayer. Also, I am pretty sure it was Barrier, Lance’s Pokémon have illegal moves at their disposal, namely Dragonite with Barrier.

[@SethEverman]

this is so cool!!!!!!!!!!

[@a1b3a3c14nbcv]

im here before the "hi" comments

[@mrnoneofurbusiness7942]

oh wait thats the bold guy

[@Hypertoniclemon]

Wow a comment by Seth that went largely unnoticed!

[@crabs632]

the bald king

[@disguisedfrog8325]

@@a1b3a3c14nbcv Hi.

[@MMAddict39]

I love that the trainers with just magikarp actually won a few games, I can only assume they were against trainers who just self destructed immediately so they had magikarp to spare

[@MrEntinen]

Its fun of those funny quirks of red/blue. The ai is stupid enough to sometimes lose against lv5 magikarp. Its proven to be possible to train a lv5 magikarp all the way to evolution and beyond in victory road, to the dismay of many attemps to stuck a save into indigo plateu

[@plasmakitten4261]

I always just imagine... What is going on in the minds of those Electrode trainers? "Yes, all of my Pokemon battles are just my Pokemon exploding immediately and me desperately hoping the enemy's Pokemon is fainted so I can be declared the winner". That's such a sad, braindead life.

[@vanbaguette7368]

@@plasmakitten4261 Maybe they're just cruel. Their goal isn't to win, but to inflict as much pain on others as possible.

[@plasmakitten4261]

@@vanbaguette7368 I think that their Electrode's happiness stat would be so low we'd know about it if that were the case

[@Frog-ux5qu]

@@plasmakitten4261 According to the game, their happiness stat would be incredibly low. However, according to the Pokédex, Electrode actually *enjoy* exploding.

[@secondengineer9814]

"But kids don't like boring math! They like tier lists!" *Proceeds to turn tier lists into math*

[@UntarLaManteca]

Objective tier lists are based on math

[@kyurei4478]

*to turn maths into tier lists.

[@brinleyhamer729]

I LOVE MATH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@thatonekidwhoexists2219]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

[@petelee2477]

@@UntarLaManteca most tier lists aren't really objective as much as they try to be. SMOGON for example base tier lists off of usage. The theory is a really good pokemon is going to be used far more often then a bad one because people are more likely to win battles. Obviously this isn't always the case as some pokemon aren't able to be slapped on any team but have some kind of niche that no other pokemon can do issue is these team archetypes won't be as common so it's tier placement becomes lower despite being perfectly viable in the higher tier. We also have cases of pokemon being more viable in higher tiers while the meta of their own tier is completely inhospitable to them for example shedinja in gen 3 was actually a legitimate threat in Ubers but would be laughed at in OU.

[@TheDinoWarrior]

Would like to point out that channeler #6 beat giovanni with just a lvl 24 ghastly

[@leirbag1595]

That is probably on the level of the Haunter who beat Lance.

[@ryanskotzke3187]

It might be because the game prioritizes Giovanni's ground-type moves against Gastly, a Ghost/Poison type, but Gastly dodges all those attacks with its Levitate ability. Although I think the game does ignore secondary types (as demonstrated in the Ivysaur vs. Oddish battle, so maybe it's more complicated than that.

[@ShanaFlareon]

@@ryanskotzke3187 but gen 1 doesn't have abilities, so any ground moves would've been super effective.

[@somegal-89]

Was fissure a ground move in gen 1? I just realized I don’t think I’ve ever used it. Maybe Giovanni’s AI thought “fissure ground and OHKO” Another reason could be that Giovanni’s gen 1 move sets are awful and are filled with normal type attacks.

[@cliswp]

It might not have been the final Giovanni. You fight him three times and at least the first one basically only uses normal type moves

[@JZSNooB]

This video's production is insane and it shows. This is an S tier video. It's elo will surely beat out other videos on the yt algorithm

[@RohanDaDev]

it didnt sadly

[@VictorownzuA11]

@@RohanDaDev I just saw this in the yt algorithm after so many months, so there is how, and this video definitely deserves it

[@Entyipo]

@@VictorownzuA11 I literally got this recommend this too right now

[@benign_oracle8875]

This video is suddenly trending.

[@JZSNooB]

@@benign_oracle8875 That's awesome if this video is finally getting the algorithmic recognition it deserves.

[@lightsen]

This was extremely interesting, I appreciate the ton of research you put into this, thank you!

[@deimos_da_boss2732]

hey lightsen!

[@pokemonherogaming4669]

so when is part 4?

[@terrariafan288]

@@pokemonherogaming4669 2077

[@technicalchirag5757]

Waiting for Part 4 , lightsen

[@Frog-ux5qu]

@@technicalchirag5757 Animation takes time, they're probably doing their best

[@TunaBear64]

12:11 If you ever feel useless remember someone with four level 21 Pokémon lost to a level 5 Bulbasaur

[@scraps7624]

I am 1000% sure Blaine is only on A tier since he can't use his signature move: super potion on his full health pokemon

[@williamfalls]

I mean... Doesn't he still have roar as a gym leader? Roar didn't have a function in gen 1 trainer battles... So it always failed. But it's still an option to use, so another wasted turn between super potion on full health.

[@willofthewind]

Why _does_ he do that so much, anyway?

[@rjante2236]

​@@willofthewind If I recall, Blaine's AI is bugged and doesn't check the amount of health before healing. From a lore standpoint, I like to think that he's gone senile

[@willofthewind]

@@rjante2236 Fs in the chat for Blaine

[@zacharyhunt9594]

I was honestly surprised he even made it that high 😂

[@ulisesvilasanchez1996]

17:53 it's interesting to see that, even in the ai tournament, one of the only two loses prof oak received was against Lance, just like the lore suggests (Lance defeated oak to become champion)

[@dimitripetrograd9808]

The other loss from Oak is Green3 (Charizard). Presuming the player character would beat Oak in the end as well, he would have two A+ tier protégés. Not bad for a professor.

[@Gatorade69]

@@dimitripetrograd9808 Well he does hook you up with an awesome starter. Just imagine starting with like a caterpie or something.

[@TheMissingLink2]

I'm pretty sure Oak renounced his title of Champion and that's why the seat was vacant. I mean, they did send him an email asking him to return.

[@RadeticDaniel]

@@TheMissingLink2 Dang it, you're right!!! Just a few more minutes and could have fought him... if only games worked that way xD

[@Akakiryuushin]

@@dimitripetrograd9808 and theoretically if you pick Bulbasaur you fight green Charizard and oak blastoise meaning the worst starter to pick is Bulbasaur

[@pimanrules]

Hey, thanks for watching! I'm working on a follow-up to this video where I run the tournament again with all the Pokémon level balanced (and some other changes...). If you're interested, be sure to subscribe! (...it'll be a while, though)

[@collectorsalmanac]

@CJ Who are you on about?

[@milanutup9930]

That sounds really interesting!

[@insertnamehere1398]

i know this would probably take forever but try G&S when you get time because well the AI should be smarter and i think Lorelai might be a- tier

[@kingrojin7692]

Pog

[@charmizarrk]

@CJ lmao

[@ZenoDovahkiin]

Lorelei _specifically_ got patched, so she would not have produced this amount of draws with her Pokémon Yellow AI, which keep sher, and _only_ her, from spamming rest.

[@TheCOOKIECHEESEMAN]

It would be cool to see this done with Pokemon Yellow with the fixed mechanics

[@bartiz12]

@@TheCOOKIECHEESEMAN I am really curious to see where Sabrina would fit with lvl 50 (!) Kadabra and Alakazam.

[@TheCOOKIECHEESEMAN]

@@bartiz12 She'd be Top 10 I bet

[@gengarzilla1685]

She's just gonna be spamming Recover vs every other Psychic type.

[@YouW00t]

"You'd think the Beauty would be sure to win, but... a-Lass". That got me good for some reason.

[@Kosmicd12]

Really cool video :)

[@gratedshtick]

O hi Kosmic

[@PhineasOyna]

E

[@ΓιάννηςΤσίντζας]

Ε

[@JACKHARRINGTON]

E

[@chartreusemoon]

hi

[@BAIGAMING]

17:13 All these years, I never realized they changed the rival's portrait for the final battle

[@michaelcarlton1484]

His backpack apparently had a cool jacket inside.

[@ssjbread2803]

His appearance changes a couple of times throughout the game

[@ChangedMyNameFinally69]

@@ssjbread2803 He gets a backpack and does a different pose, but then he's wearing an outfit they brought back in HGSS

[@ChangedMyNameFinally69]

@@michaelcarlton1484 Can see why they gave him a Blastoise in the anime: he's got DA DRIP

[@AnonymousMaykr]

This video is really well made, lot of effort put in. I really hope it will be picked up by the algorithm soon!

[@pimanrules]

We must all make a sacrifice to the Almighty Gorithm and pray for a bountiful engagement harvest.

[@vagrant8271]

It already has!

[@Richard-jq4mq]

Welp

[@PlotlinePlus]

Just showed up for me. So maybe now?

[@SaintPainkillerLinda]

It did, this got recommended to me and I'm very happy it was!

[@baggelissonic]

Professor Oak taking revenge for the poor squirtle that stayed behind. Truly a touching moment

[@psyxypher3881]

Fun fact: In Pokemon Yellow, Lorelei's data was altered to prevent her from softlocking you.

[@masterofdoots5965]

Yeah, there's basically code that checks "Are you Lorelei? If so, don't spam Rest" And I think it's the funniest code in any video game

[@Skull_Knight_]

So if Blue was the worst trainer in the game at the first battle, that means everytime I lose against him was *I* the worst trainer on the game lol

[@EastSideRudeBoy]

Yes. Lol

[@wewhoareabouttodiesaluteyo9303]

Depends on what Pokemon he had.

[@user-mh9dx7nz2r]

@@wewhoareabouttodiesaluteyo9303 Only if you chose Bulbasaur.

[@haruhirogrimgar6047]

@@user-mh9dx7nz2r Only if you managed to lose with Bulbasaur*

[@Lualow]

@@user-mh9dx7nz2r only if you choose *Charmander*

[@kiramortwilson7411]

“I ran 87000 battles for over 4000 hours of battling-“ Dude that’s worth a subscribe right there. Holy crap.

[@atharwanavyam5315]

Yeah why is noone talking about the effort went into this video like seriously

[@martinsz441]

i dont think he let 4000 hours of battleing happen in real time. you can speed this up by magnitude of orders

[@HypnosisBear]

@@martinsz441 oh!! Since it's an AI he can speed up🤔🤔🤔 I think so...

[@thatoneguy9582]

i mean assuming non-stop, 4000 hours is a bit under half a year which fits right into his upload schedule

[@SirGary]

Wow, this is amazing

[@joaquinlaroca2886]

Pero que hace aqui señor gary, ah claro, video de pokemon.

[@lenira7750]

ojo que se nos hace gringo

[@Sh0velyJ0e]

The idea of two oddish just endless using absorb on each other forever just makes me laugh.

[@tarabelle7716]

"How do lesbians have- you know what nevermind"

[@felixvelariusbos]

As a data engineer in real life, I really appreciated the "look at all this fancy mathematics...realize we don't like it...and just fudge the numbers until it feels right." That's basically 70% of the data science projects I see nowadays 👍

[@michaelbread5906]

That's mad!

[@felixvelariusbos]

@@michaelbread5906 Don't worry, we just say the words "linear regression" and "deep learning" a bunch until management gets scared and approves it.

[@five12man]

Science is more of an art than a science...

[@Litevaar]

@@RadkeMaiden At least engineers do something useful. Dedicated mathematicians rarely make useful contributions to science or society, just argue over "different kinds of infinities" and other pointless constructs that have no bearing on our actual, physical reality.

[@sanstheblaster2626]

@@Litevaar... Until we discover something those "useless" rules actually apply to. That's a mathematician's job. Discover and create new, undiscovered (and thus unused) rules that COULD be useful for future generations. Without a mathematical rule that precisely accounts for what you are doing, every other branch of science is stuck and must either create a new rule from 0 or find an old rule that also applies for wathever they are doing. That's true for every branch science, form rocket launching to statistical analysis. If there's a situation never encountered before, you either search for an elusive theorem that somehow works with what are you doing and that no one has ever noticed before (and, when that happens, tha mathematician that discovered it suddenly becomes popular and important) or you ask to current mathematicians to create a new theorem from 0.

[@waleedkhalid7486]

This was amazing. It actually shows that despite the flak gen1 code gets, it was actually fairly well designed to give the player enough of a challenge at every stage of the game to keep things interesting.

[@tylerb6981]

I thought something similar, this demonstration really highlights how well balanced and thought out this game is.

[@acousticeel9695]

Gen 1 is incredibly well made considering it’s limitations. It’s just slightly unfortunate that all the optimizations and compression also made it very easily become a buggy mess.

[@Patterrz]

This video is fantastic! Super interesting stuff

[@Sir_Isaac_Newton_]

it's spelled "impostor," not "imposter"

[@Waffle-Ex-Eye-Vee]

Yooo

[@moonofterror]

@@Sir_Isaac_Newton_ both are correct

[@sebasfabila7639]

Gold and silver please. I want to see if Whitney’s miltank really is that difficult.

[@bluedrago5]

Yes this would be an interesting thing to see, how much the difficulty fits the curve once the quirks of gen 1 have been ironed out.

[@JohnSmith-ti9uq]

I went back and battled her as an adult and she was stupid easy She's hard when youre a kid because you dont properly level your pokemon or catch and level new pokemon for your team early in the game

[@whoisanarnb]

Female geodude is great for making her cry in like 5 minutes

[@seankraft410]

I was also thinking about miltank during this. Excited to see what comes of it.

[@PokeBronYT]

That would definitely take soooo much longer to make haha two regions and so many more trainers

[@loulou3676]

Boys: Wow, a girls only school! I wonder what goes on in there Girls: ODDISH VS IVYSAUR FOR ETERNITY

[@MrNettoon]

these memes are better than the boys locker room ones

[@mouth2548]

im so upset he didnt let the lass win

[@dominickperez2952]

Korega Requiem Da

[@notatroll7128]

Boys: Probably nothing interesting, wanna play smash?

[@gt2p818]

14:06 Everyone just going to ignore how this one random rocket grunt made it to A-?

[@oliverleonard7730]

It's because he has a Hypno I guess.

[@MikeJohnson-nr4yo]

Having a physic in gen 1 makes him good.

[@tmoran527]

I do wish he noted what’s the farthest a trainer class maid it and what team they had

[@AlphaSquadZero]

@@MikeJohnson-nr4yo there's another at 14:04 without any psychic types.

[@aml500]

@@AlphaSquadZero Yeah I counted about 4 rockets in A-

[@MrZirkusaffe]

The "Misty Misty" at the beginning was a blast from the past

[@Illia5]

FRUIT SALAD YUMMY YUMMY

[@johnnyriley]

That “Misty Misty” sound bite unlocked an old memory that I totally forgot existed.

[@Missingno4]

right?? I miss the days of pokemon spoof,,

[@jesusramirezromo2037]

whats it from?

[@Missingno4]

@@jesusramirezromo2037 it's from pokemon spoof!! kzbin.info/www/bejne/fZK5nJ-OnbN1hpY

[@MikeOfMichigan]

Yeah, I had to pause the video and sit for a minute trying to figure out why it sounded so familiar

[@brunop.8745]

literally one of the first videos i ever saw on youtube

[@EluTran]

Wow, this video was absolutely phenomenal. Interesting methodology and explanations, and the visuals were incredible. High quality work man. Amazing job! Was super intriguing all the way through!

[@stylishjolteon4514]

I predict comments about Undertale songs

[@aetherarcanist4819]

wow it's Elu :3

[@stardustreverie6880]

oh wow it's the morenatsu ost guy!!

[@flimksi]

oh wow it's the undertale ost guy!!

[@gabira10]

gUYs lOoK iTS THe uNdERtaLe oSt gUY

[@StarkMaximum]

"I've included timestamps in the description, so if a part doesn't interest you, you can skip around." Oh, I won't be doing that, thank you.

[@Maravillante]

Oh yeah Misty classic catchphrase "Misty, Misty!"

[@wewhoareabouttodiesaluteyo9303]

DUMBLEDORE! Snape, snape...SEVERUS snape.

[@stephenrolle2671]

@@wewhoareabouttodiesaluteyo9303 Ron, Ron, Ron Weasley!

[@wewhoareabouttodiesaluteyo9303]

@@stephenrolle2671 Harry potter..harry potter...ooo....harry potter...harry potter...ahhh

[@carsonlove531]

Okay but what’s the video that was actually from??? It’s from like 10 years ago but I NEED to know!

[@LazurBeemz]

@@carsonlove531 look up Pokemon Trashanimation episode 1

[@TheNerdyGinger]

This was a really cool vid

[@Sir_Isaac_Newton_]

it's spelled "impostor," not "imposter"

[@TheNerdyGinger]

@@Sir_Isaac_Newton_ what are you talking about?

[@doigt6590]

@@TheNerdyGinger If I'd have to guess, it is either accidentally posted here and was meant for another comment OR it was a reply to post which has been deleted since.

[@anneshleah3626]

I'm impressed! As someone who does scientific programming and statistics professionally, I shudder at the thought of how much work it must have been to compose all that, run the simulations, evaluate the data and on top of it all animate it! I know, it's largely a matter of how familiar you are with a code (in this case, that of pokemon), but I can literally feel the frustration of all the failed attempts due to stupid mistakes it would have taken me. Great work!

[@lelandbatey]

The programming effort that went into this is absolutely incredible. Modding ASM based GB games is tough enough as it is, and to then script emulator behavior and save mods as well, AND THEN to run several hundred thousand simulations? THEN APPLY STATISTICS VISUALIZATIONS?! S S S T I E R

[@alexisauld7781]

The Elo system broke down slightly at the top- we do see that the Venusaur rival had the best ratio of the three- but at that point it's largely splitting hairs.

[@Horico12]

I'm not sure how I felt about the Elo score without knowing the 'order' which battles were fought. in some sense it doesn't matter what the Elo score is The trainer who fought their worst matches first would have the best score. But that could have been the difference between rival champ and oak fights

[@T_Lorentzen]

I feel like there is some match fixing going on here. Venusaur only lost twice, and at least one of those losses was vs. itself, which means it has at most one loss vs the top 3. The Charizard trainer fought two more matches than Venusaur, and Blastoise fought twenty more than it! Conspiracy theory: did they let Charizard continue until it was above Venusaur? And Blastoise until it was in between?

[@BillyBob-xx5jr]

@@T_Lorentzen I mean, most of the trainers have different numbers of total battles, it's likely he used some program or something to randomly decide the number of fights and who they fought, so some trainers had more fights than others.

[@TheBlueWizzrobe]

@@BillyBob-xx5jr Well he said in the video that he made every trainer fight against every other trainer, plus some more battles on top for good measure, so he definitely did not intend to skip any trainers at the very least. Yet Venusaur Green at 4th place had itself as its worst loss and 3rd place Green as its best victory. Because it only lost twice and one of those losses was itself, this means it somehow never fought either the Prof Oak at 1st or the Green at 2nd. Even besides the fact that a match against itself should definitely not count for scoring, something is definitely pretty screwy with how the matchmaking was done.

[@alexthorne1416]

The win loss ratios didn’t seem consistent between the trainers that confused me? Like at the top some of them clearly fought more games than others.

[@Munnmaista]

I would 100% watch this for every single generation

[@theramendutchman]

Oh heck yes sign me up! Maybe with something more linear than ELO the other times around, but either way sign me up!

[@KNPS-MAGIO]

This man joined youtube on 2006 and is still making relevant videos, what a legend

[@TuskyBaby]

piman: "the AI isn't limited by PP constraints" Me: same

[@Chocolatepain]

Wow the presentation of the cards was so nice to look at. I can't imagine the work involved in this. Kudos.

[@wuhoh5274]

"Professor oak is gonna win" was the first thing I said when I clicked on this video

[@reptilesceptile1035]

Proof?

[@tmcnairbledsoe]

I am a fellow data scientist and programmer. I just wanted to say that while watching this video I couldnt help but feel respect for the effort, setup, and visual presentation. So cool

[@OscarChevillard]

This is the most interesting video I've seen on KZbin so far, answering so many questions I was asking myself as a kid. Like : "How the fuck is Brock a gym leader, if every trainers we encounter on roads are better than him ?" Now I know he would lose to almost everyone in Kanto.

[@plumebrisee6206]

In the Lore ,Gym Leader have multiple team that they use depending on how many badge the Challenger have .

[@shinobix4925]

You already know you have to do this for Gen 2 now. The people need to know where Youngster and his Top % Rattata would end up

[@The_All-Seer]

s tier, obviously

[@Mernom]

How would it treat rematches, though?

[@kyurei4478]

@@Mernom As separeted trainers, like he did for this one.

[@Shog64]

The quality is way to high for this video to be only watched by around 1000 people. Hope it takes off.

[@rawbinYT]

Holy shit, I was surprised that at the time of me watching there's only 17k views on this vid.

[@MemeNess]

It is now!!

[@waterdrinker_]

@@rawbinYT I'm surprised there's only 45k views

[@TwinGrimm]

@@waterdrinker_ I'm surprised there is only 50.5k views

[@Entyipo]

@@TwinGrimm 60k now

[@amimm7776]

The music in the "how the ai works section" is a chiptune version of the mario 64 file select theme. Well played.

[@TheDukeCTL]

17:10 So Venusaur Champ Green only lost twice, without draws and his worst loss being.. himself? Looks like the real #1 trainer, ELO is somewhat random.

[@elvenchipmunk2369]

and with less total battles judging by the w/d/l Venusaur champion was robbed

[@joshualuigi220]

You're right. I'd like to see the list updated with W/L ratio rather than ELO

[@holdenfegan1613]

Charizard champ had 2 more losses and had a worse “worst defeat” with an A- loss. If this were a more manual ranking, like how college football ranks teams; Venasuar champ would be higher than the other rival champs

[@toxickandy9669]

@@holdenfegan1613 from what i can gather venusaur rival lost to charizard rival and oak with blastoise. Charizard rival lost to blastoise rival, oak with venusaur, oak with charizard and loralei. Rival with blastoise lost to all the oak battles, and the rival with venusaur. I dunno where that 5th battle came from, i can't find it because it's lowest loss is oak with venusaur, we can figure out it lost to oak with charizard. It didn't lose to the nonchampion rival fight since that trainers best win is against itself. And we know it won vs rival with charizard. Lost to rival with venusaur, and lost to oak vs blastoise. I'm guessing this other loss is a repeat battle against one of it's losses. The oak with blastoise lost to the rival with charizard and Lance. Oak with venusaur lost to rival with venusaur and oak with blastoise. So the top 5 should be 5th place rival with charizard since it lost to loralei which is way down on the ranking. Since i can only find 4 losses for the blastoise rival, it would take 4th. 3rd would be oak with blastoise since it lost to lance who's further down in the rankings. 2nd would be rival with venusaur since it's lowest loss would now be the 5th place rival with charizard. And first oak with venusaur since it's lowest loss is the now 3rd oak with blastoise. This ranking isn't including draws since we have no information on those and we don't know how many of those draws were rematched with a decisive winner. If we include draws. It goes 5th rival with charizard, 4th rival with blastoise, 3rd oak with venusaur, 2nd oak with blastoise, and 1st rival with venusaur. It would be nice if we could actually see the listings of all the battles and where the extra battles that some trainers have came from and who they drew against

[@sudiptodam3725]

Don't you realise that he played way too less amount of games, I think this was kinda sad for him

[@SoraDonaldGoofy99]

Dang. Maybe Oak retired from battling because everyone else was too easy?

[@wewhoareabouttodiesaluteyo9303]

No, all Oak wanted to do was "fiddle with his Pokedex" and he did not believe they were for fighting. Agatha talks about him before you battle her in the Elite Four.

[@aceclover758]

Agatha even said back in his young days, he was a great trainer

[@TheLastWizardOfTheCentury-u7o]

Go play a Rom Hack called Pokemon Rocket Edition, it is the best fanmade rom hack, and it goes into the story of Prof. Oak

[@ultimecia102]

This was so well explained and so well represented with visual data! You have a real talent dude.

[@lwouisYT]

Between the editing and visualization, and the actual coding and running the tournament, I can't imagine the amount of work! Really entertaining and cool! 🔥

[@boolean5162]

See you guys in a year when this vid has 5 million views

[@AmiiboDoctor]

Meet back up, December 16, 2021?

[@LOLquendoTV]

Aye, will jot it down on my calendar

[@ohhellwhereami2574]

😭

[@Orsonb]

This is legitimately one of the best produced videos I've ever seen. This should easily have 10 times the amount of views it has right now.

[@invisiblesymbol5188]

holy shit the editing on this video is insane

[@gnuwaves743]

"so son are you going to build rockets or work on AI for cyborgs?" no just....just pokemon stuff

[@jimmyhirr5773]

This is how TheZZAZZGlitch's videos make me feel.

[@GINeric_]

"When you're hot, you're hot!" Sweats in pokemon puzzle

[@fonzomatic2]

Yeah I immediately recognized that. Pokemon Puzzle League had some amazing voice clips "CL-L-L-L-LOYSTER"

[@thekiss2083]

Mewtwo PTSD...."I'm going to win"

[@Adriano991b]

I thought I was the only one who recognized the voice from the game, nice to see other people who played this game with its awesome voice clips!

[@Rabbit-the-One]

These digital graphics are amazing. I don't even expect visuals this awesome from double digits million channels. The Rolodex scroll of the character profiles was impressive. Well done AF.

[@thattimestampguy]

0:10 What would happen if we had all the trainers battle each other? 3:00 2 Emulators are kept in sync. 3:27 Save-State Swapping between Emulators. 4:04 EXP gains --> Disabled by hard coding memory values. 5:04 True-Round Robin, (every trainer involved battles every other trainer) 6:00 DRAW Rules if the battle goes 75 turns w/o either side taking damage or 1,000 turns long. 6:32 ELO Scores change based on who you beat/lose to. 7:40 Mathematical Tiering with a Kernel Density estimation. *Ranking all The Trainers of Pokemon Gen-1 Kanto Region* 8:50 10:00 Rocker #2 beat Swimmer #13. Electric beats Water. 10:30 Brock, Pewter City Gym Leader. 11:00 C+ Juggler #5 The Mr. Mime trainer. 11:58 B- Misty, Cerulean City Gym Leader. 12:10 Beauty #10 got a 1,000 Turn Draw to happen using poisonpowder vs absorb. 13:22 Lt. Surge, Vermillion City Gym Leader 14:06 Erika, Celadon City Gym Leader. 14:15 Lorelei, Elite 4 Ice Trainer. _she prioritized rest_ 16:10 The A+ Tier, The Top 13 Trainers. Sabrina, Saffron City Gym Leader 17:07 #4 The Venasaur Champion, #3 The Blastoise Champion, #2 The Charizard Champion 18:00 #1 The Professor Oak Hidden Secret Post-Game, Final Boss. 19:19 The ELO Scores Leveling Off in The Middle.

[@FSFSFS101]

This is seriously something superior to a college dissertation, holy hell

[@Sealed_Chamber]

And it only took him a single day to make! He is a genius of unparalleled abilities!

[@Eidenhoek]

I'ma save everyone 20 minutes: S-Tier: Youngster Joey Irrelevant-Tier: Everyone else.

[@amethyphoenix]

Joey was probably near the bottom. I know this is a joke comment, but still.

[@BioniclesaurKing4t2]

Youngster Joey's in Gold/Silver/Crystal, not Red/Blue.

[@amethyphoenix]

@@BioniclesaurKing4t2 So the OC screwed up anyway. Ok.

[@UDAMZ]

That ratatta is clearly op....

[@107thFruit]

That moment when you're playing Soul Silver randomizer and Joey comes at you with a Rayquaza.

[@edgarvega5859]

0:46 I can never escape pannenkoek2012 music whenever a youtuber explains something

[@JumpinJew]

Why is KZbin just NOW recommending this to me? This is amazing work. Definitely worth more than the 1.2K likes. props to you

[@pokemaster2641]

Would love to see other generations done! Also including legendary battles might be a good idea. Like the Mewtwo battle is rock hard so I’d be curious where it ranks.

[@Draeckon]

MandJTV sent me! This video is great and I love the editing in it. So slick and smooth.

[@swordfish3720]

So we’re just going to ignore how amazing this editing is?

[@Clear1]

I wonder if giving a flat level to all the trainers would yield some different results. it would seem more interesting to see the worst and best AI in the game if level is no object.

[@JKBrown-vv1yw]

I was thinking the same thing. It'd also be more interesting if they all had 6 pokemon, using duplicates to fill in missing slots, starting from the front. Rival 1 would have 6 lv50 squirtles. Mistie would have 3 alternating lv50 staryus and 3 lv50 starmies. Agatha would have her lv50 team plus an extra gengar. The later teams would still have an advantage, but it'd be so much more mitigated.

[@DutchDread]

Surely, attack selection is an indication of skill though, and who would decide which attacks they replace? And if they keep the same attacks, they'd stay disadvantaged.

[@JKBrown-vv1yw]

@@DutchDread Well yeah, that would be the key difference. What we're basically arguing for though is an AI, PvP version of these battles, where the only advantages come from typing, movesets, and skill. A guy with 2 voltorbs doesn't lose to a guy with 3 magikarp just because the former randomly chose self-destruct twice.

[@DutchDread]

@@JKBrown-vv1yw Why arbitrarily select "typing, moveset, and skill" as acceptable though? The question is do you want to see which is the best trainer, or which is the best AI? Because if it's the second, then any disparity in team composition makes your findings mostly worthless. If you really want to JUST test AI, you should combine every AI with every team in the game and see which does best with the most teams.

[@givecamichips]

But don't basically all of them have the exact same AI, just with differences in type matchups? It would just be a test of type coverage and RNG.

[@vaturi9254]

came over from mandjtv. thought i'd give the original a watch as well for the hard work put in. very nice work

[@SmashHighlights]

Really fascinating! And I love the presentation. It’s only a matter of time before manual editing is made redundant by programmatically rendering scenes...

[@logans.7932]

Alakazam is such a good Pokemon that Sabrina outranks half of the Elite Four

[@TheLastWizardOfTheCentury-u7o]

In Gen 1, Mewtwo and Alakazam are Gods

[@Lelouchxzero1]

The Strongest non impoartant character is Cool Trainer at number 14 using only 3 Pokemon. Executor, Cloyster, and Arcanine.

[@leirbag1595]

Huh, that's pretty interesting. That puts him well above many important trainers.

[@leerobbo92]

Dat coverage though. A grass/psychic, a water type with mad defence that has an ice move, and a fire type strong physical attacker that knows Take Down.

[@Lelouchxzero1]

I've been wondering what his other three would be if he wanted them. assuming he would choose pokemon with two evolutions. I would assume Electrode for speed and electric, almost guaranteed turn 1 tunderwave. Rhydon for ground/rock tank and good moveset without using the same type twice I could really only think of Golbat only for chip damage and confuse ray.

[@shawnsee6245]

Just wondering if bulbasaur family keeps pulling ahead of the other two starters in the lower tiers, because of enemy AI spamming poisonpowder/toxic futilely against bulba

[@leirbag1595]

Those would be advantageous matchups for the Charmender as well, but yeah. Not attacking at all is worse than landing non-effective hits.

[@laytonjr6601]

@@leirbag1595 Attacking charmander with super effective attacks against fire type: Ground.

[@javierbg1995]

Wow. The quality information density in this video is top notch. And the editing is so good! How can you have so few views, dude? Subscribed, really hoping this channel blows up! PS: I would love to see something similar for the 2nd gen games!

[@SuperKamehameha2]

Dude that “Misty! Misty!” Brought back memories of that video from like 15 years ago lol

[@CaptainMeleon]

incredible how prof. oak #2's worst defeat was against himself

[@MossyBD]

The production value for this is absurd, I’m very impressed

[@Hamhamsnoozer]

Kid's nowadays don't want math, they want tier lists! *explains complex math used to generate tier list* XD Fantastic vid, my dude. Hats off to you for doing all the work, we needed to know!

[@blippblob]

Ayyeee my boy Rival Fival getting up in that A- tier

[@357A]

“MISTY! MISTY!” That took me back

[@doratheexplora1555]

I was looking for someone who understood the reference. I actually was so surprised when i heard that

[@beforedawnYGO]

Fill me in.

[@ThirdGenGamer]

This is an amazing video! Not only with how you figured out which trainer was the best, but the editing was too notch. There is no way that this should have 500k views. It should have millions of views. Great work!

[@lisavauhti7675]

Alternative title: Youngster Joey exposed.

[@Vengir]

To be fair, he's a gen 2 trainer. So maybe next time.

[@ashmoleproductions5407]

FBI open up!

[@Stonewren]

"Misty, Misty!" I love the reference to Pokémon Spoof

[@UNICORNsoldier7]

Rewatching before I check out your new vid! Love this and can’t wait to see what’s next

[@jcKobeh]

Was killed on the spot by that Pokémon Parody audio of Misty saying her own name. Over an entire decade came crashing down on me in an instant.

[@GalaxySid]

This video is so well researched, explained and displayed - it rivals bachelor thesis I read... great work, that deserves so much more attention. Have a like and a sub! =)

[@timjimbob5839]

This is brilliant work. I have recently been getting into creators like yourself that really get in deep with their research and work that is the subject of their videos. Your explanation of the rules of not only the actual game and of course how you devised the tournament was just absolutely delightful. It amazes me that there are actual good youtubers who put real love and effort into their videos. I wish you great luck on your future endeavors.

[@sabbywins]

Fantastic video. If there ends up being a follow up, I'd love to see how each trainer fares in a level-adjusted tournament.

[@itsbmeGaming]

You got your wish!

[@FROZENbender]

okay dude, "Misty Misty", reminds me of that super old pokemon parody vid pret, elo world and tom7, references to the actual ai code, maaaaaaan you're good!

[@cellem6216]

This was surprisingly thorough and I just want you to know that I greatly appreciate the time you took to make this video.

[@NotTheWheel]

Actually, I know it's not intentional by design - but Lorelei is the first member of the Elite Four. It's up to those who wish to challenge the Elite four to defeat her. She is under no obligation to actually defeat her opponents. In Chess at least if you are the Titleholder and you draw against the challenger you retain the title. It is up to the Challengers to defeat her. So her rating is lower but the meta-strategy of drawing all her opponents works out nicely.

[@nihilist1680]

This video is insanely good. It should have millions of views!

[@renatatostada3318]

have you considered submitting this as a study to a real journal? it may seem trivial, but there looks like enough data and structure here to be an actual study. either way, this is geniuniely one of the coolest things I've seen from a pokemon related video. thanks so much for this.

[@chrishall5570]

I think that this is one of the most interesting things I've seen someone do with a pokemon game in a long time.

[@jj-sc1kq]

That was pretty cool. I almost want to see the lesser trainers specifically ran through the gym bosses / elite 4 in order. Just to see how many would actually gain badges.

[@Mackintac]

Absolutely goated video, came by because atrioc reacted and dropped a like and comment to help out :)

[@manfromnantucket9544]

Surprised there was no mention of Lance's Barrier spamming Dragonite

[@peytongibbs2171]

Considering it's his last pokemon, I assume most trainers never even saw it, and those who could had the potential to take it out.

[@TheCassiusTain]

Now I'd really like to see how each trainer would fare in a turnament environment, having each Pokemon set to level 50

[@ipsheet]

This is such an epic video. This should have millions of views. One of the best pokemon videos ever. Keep up the good work

[@JonnySpec]

16:23 Heh, Bruno beat Lance. That's what happens when the AI sees Agility as super effective against Fighting types. Edit: And Agatha beat Lance because the AI saw Agility as super effective against her Poison types.

[@Mernom]

That's probably the cause for 99% of the upset wins.