Praying behind Imams in Makkah and Madinah(Having a bad opinion)

[@IslamAnswers]

islamanswers.co.uk/question/is-praying-behind-people-of-bidah-makruh-tahreemi-or-tanzeehi/

[@IslamAnswers]

For further clarification: kzbin.info/www/bejne/iYTbgYlmYrSFgcUsi=aJWbHV_v7by6pNOm

[@MrARashid]

Brelvis should follow this advice. You may learn something.

[@shuaibabdulsalam5695]

Assalamu alaikum Please help me with this question becuase this is affecting my belief and iman i want to know is it mentioned in quran that allah is uncreated in surath ilkhlas allah said he is neither given birth nor he is born but a living being can exist without birth becuase adam as was created not born so my mind say allah only said he is not born in surath ikhlas but not uncreated please help me with this question

[@mz8452]

Allah said هو الأول. Meaning he is eternal without a beginning

[@hahdgdgherfhx]

Of course Allah is uncreated. He is The Creator

[@aljabartiyy58]

Allaah is eternal without a beginning. This means that he was not preceded by non existence.

[@AnasAli-dl5gp]

It is a well known fact that the Imams of Haramayn follow the likes of Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahhab. They can not become Imam, unless they adopt this Creed, and this rule is very well-known. You can not simply assume he's a Sunni, when it's a known fact that the Saudis don't employ Sunni Imams

[@navoxford8406]

It is a well known fact that Sunnis other than Barelvis pray behind those Imams. You are extremists.

[@mshafi4180]

'well-known' is not enough. Where is this stated for you to be this confident. Furthermore, an imam of the haram can outwardly show they follow him but in actual fact, they don't. There are multiple cases where the imam of the haram have sat with deobandi scholars

[@spawnnpwn4166]

Yes please, deobandis should stop hiding their beliefs from laymen... Or are they scared of losing followers?

[@navoxford8406]

This Barelvi keyboard warrior thinks he knows better than Sheikh Samir alNass. He said we should have the same Masjids as Salafis. And he is Sheikh Asrars teacher.

[@abdullahassaffah]

Thats not true saudi have long moved away from the creed of sh miaw they are now modernist and almost complete opposite of miaw

[@slimshady7625]

whats there to ask lmao we know they follow muhammad bin abdul wahab..

[@MuhammadA34777]

can you share where Asrar Rashid said that, and regarding whom?

[@slimshady7625]

@@MuhammadA34777 in one of recent qna live stream session you can check there are time stamps available

[@MuhammadA34777]

@@slimshady7625 can you try to find it please. I tried but can't find it

[@thepathofguidance5684]

He said one of the muezzin is sunni.

[@slimshady7625]

@@thepathofguidance5684 jazakallah edited it

[@AnasAli-dl5gp]

Check Fathul Qadeer. Salah behind Ahlul Bid'ah is Makruh Tahriman.

[@navoxford8406]

Barelvis are ahl bidda too.

[@IslamAnswers]

Fath Al Qadeer has been cited in the written answer. It is clear that Imam Ibn Humam does not consider it Tahreemi. Rather Tanzeehi. Since he said it is Jaiz. However, that is not the point. The point is about assuming to know peoples religious positions without asking them. islamanswers.co.uk/question/is-praying-behind-people-of-bidah-makruh-tahreemi-or-tanzeehi/

[@AnasAli-dl5gp]

@IslamAnswers There is nothing to assume. Stop fooling people It is known fact that the Imams of Haramayn can only be Imams if they adopt the Aqidah of Muhammad bin Abdul Wahhab. This is the standard for the government who appoints the Imams of Haramayn. Otherwise you are fooling yourselves that the Imams of Haramayn are Sunnis.

[@navoxford8406]

​@@AnasAli-dl5gpyou know better than Sheikh Samir alNass. Sheikh Asrars teacher.

[@hahdgdgherfhx]

Don’t you guys believe in good bida? You literally are ahlul bidah yourselves 😂

[@Ahlussunah786]

This is guy is soo corrupt, praying behind him is defo makru tahrimi

[@purityandaspiration]

KZbin comment section mufti giving fatawa left and right... Whats your proof? Do you have a concise proof based fatwa on this Shaykh to claim such things? Do you have an ijazah to talking about these things in this manner? Or do you want us to assume you're correct and authoritative just cause you used the word “defo“?

[@navoxford8406]

Barelvi are the most corrupt they defend insults against the Prophet peace be upon him. And always look to divide the Ummah.