Answering Your Questions on the Meeting with Asrar Rashid & Hassan

[@truth-z7x]

Great video. Everyone who loves and defends the Prophet peace be upon him mist spread it

[@truth-z7x]

Thank you sh Nurudin this is such an important video. Clarifies everything. People have no excuse no. Stand with the Prophet peace be upon him

[@peacenow6618]

May Allah Accept your works, and make it a means of acceptance and Guidance for the Ummah!

[@TrueSunni]

Aqeedah Asrariyah (Barelvi Creed) 1, Awliyah have license to insult Allah most high and his Messenger ﷺ 2, Insulting the Prophet ﷺ is a Karamah 3, Revelation did not end with the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ

[@truth-z7x]

Asrar and the Barelvis want to praise insults against the Prophet peace be upon him so much they invented nee Aqidah They say Allah Tala speaks from the mouth of a Pir

[@navoxford8406]

Look at how many sheikhs and Mowlanas who claim to love the Prophet peace be upon him are silent on this insult. I guess they love themselves more. Hypocrites

[@truth-z7x]

This video has shut Asrar fans up completely. Normal they flood the comments. Hopefully they are reconsidering the stance they have taken it

[@asrarahmed177]

You are literally the one spamming comments with multiple accounts

[@navoxford8406]

​@@asrarahmed177yes I care about the Prophet peace be upon him so make lots or comments You cult members care about Asrar so make too many comments defending his insults against the Prophet peace be upon him

[@peacenow6618]

جزاک اللہ خیرا

[@navoxford8406]

Asrar believes it is fine to read out insults against the Prophet peace be upon him in a book and not condemn them.

[@peacenow6618]

actually what you have said re: Sh Asrar i noticed this years in certain streams which is why i stopped listening to him.

[@truth-z7x]

Brelvis and Qadyanis both believe in revelation after the Prophet peace be upon him.

[@mohsinhaq509]

What's the proof

[@TrueSunni]

Still waiting fir Asrars video defending the Prophet peace be upon him. Why is it taking so long

[@Umair1]

Shaykh Asrar hasn’t made any problematic statements himself, there is no need for him to make such a video.

[@truth-z7x]

Asrar make your Tauba video otherwise InshaAllah sh Nurudin will not stop.

[@TrueSunni]

Announcement: Asrar Rashid says it is fine to promote disgusting statements of Kufr without condemning them. Updated Brelvi Aqida!

[@truth-z7x]

They have arrived. It took them a while but Asrar fans come to the comments to spew their childish rubbish Students of sh Nurudin will speak about defending the Prophet peace be upon him And Asrar fans will speak about how prefect Asrar is.

[@truth-z7x]

What is wrong with Asrar fans why they siding with him against the Prophet peace be upon him

[@KASHMIRI_TERRORIST]

Brelvis Always bully people online when you call out something which is legitimately bad in their beliefs...they did the same to Shaykh Saeed Fodeh

[@amir324]

What did they do with Saeed fodeh

[@truthseeker205]

Why would anyone believe a Kashmiri terrorist?

[@truth-z7x]

​@@truthseeker205you brelvis follow an Indian extremist Ahmed Riza brelvi

[@Umair1]

@@amir324they didn’t need to do a thing, Shaykh Saeed Fodeh has said nothing but good words about imam ahmad raza khan and his literature on Aqidah.

[@KASHMIRI_TERRORIST]

@@Umair1 Shaykh Fodeh said "We know that they (ie:Brelvi) exaggerate their scholars {refering to Ahmed Rida Khan}"

[@TrueSunni]

Why is it only sh Nurudin speaking out against this kufr Is everyone else sleeping? Speak the Haqq you so called Scholars.

[@Mohammed-l6y6h]

@@TrueSunni shaykh asrar has been debating wahabis deos shias christians and thr far right and atheists in defence of the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him for decades,and has now called out the qadianis, what has nurudin been doing ? He lives is luton where the far right are constantly insulting, why has he not called them out ? ???? Sleeping ?

[@truth-z7x]

​@@Mohammed-l6y6hthat gives him the right to insult the Prophet peace be upon him? Brelvis are so misguided

[@TrueSunni]

As for Mobeen i guarantee he will not have a meeting on camera

[@MrRiz157]

Sheikh Mobeen is inmho a good guy with a soft demeanor.

[@TrueSunni]

​@@MrRiz157ask him to have a proper sit down with sh Nurudin on camera No way. He is on the wrong side of this

[@MrRiz157]

@TrueSunni Not everything revolves around the camera; this situation highlights a deeper issue. For many, it's about seeking clout rather than pursuing genuine scholarship.

[@navoxford8406]

​@@MrRiz157It is about clarifying the Kufr brelvis are spreading

[@Umair1]

@@MrRiz157 fully agree with this. There seems to be an obsession with the camera, these videos back to back seem more like bullying than anything shaykh asrar did

[@H_G2013]

Some have called him Asrar, the Runner, Rashid Now I know why He tries to make excuses and runs off always

[@TrueSunni]

Asrar has no choice he has to make the video now

[@H_G2013]

If you notice, Asrar always tries to manufacture a reason to not actually discuss the main point in hand. In the meeting, he tried doing this by saying Shaykh Nooruddeen has not read it in Farsi so is not able to discuss it. He done the same with Shaykh Uthmaan when he made Uthmaan not having read Munaazra Rasheediya as an excuse to shut down the meeting so the actual point of the meeting is not discussed

[@TrueSunni]

Whenever Asrar has lost an argument he uses tactics. Intelligent people can see it but the people around him cannot

[@TrueSunni]

You Gustakhs want to praise insults against the Prophet peace be upon him and we won't let you. That is why you are disappointed and upset You side with Asrar against the Prophet peace be upon him

[@TrueSunni]

Im telling you now that mobeen will never meet sh Nurudin on camera

[@navoxford8406]

True

[@TrueSunni]

Sh Nurudin is being too generous to mobeen he is the same as the others . He praises insults aginst the Prophet peace be upon him too

[@mohammadkhalid4236]

This guys a jahil he isn't shaykh ran away from basic questions lol

[@H_G2013]

Has anyone got a link to Hasan's channel

[@TrueSunni]

He is on Tiktok not KZbin

[@H_G2013]

​@@TrueSunnido you have link? Lol, a Tiktoki scholar 😂😂😂

[@H_G2013]

Everyone likes to point out, especially asrar, when it is convenient for them that Hasan is a child. But why then is Asrar allowing a child to make vidoes on such sensitive matters. Double standards O Asrar - please fix yourself up Asrar

[@TrueSunni]

Asrar plays games and his fans love it. They are not people of knowledge or guidance They are like sports fans . Hooligans and thugs

[@H_G2013]

I​@@TrueSunnii agree, it is like the Asrari Cult hahahah😂😂😅😅😅

[@navoxford8406]

They believe it is fine to quote Kufr without condemning it

[@Mohammed-l6y6h]

@@navoxford8406 they called it kufr....... what more do you want ?

[@H_G2013]

Asrar needs to fix up on his bully and thug tactics. He does not know how to have a civilised debate. He done the same with Uthmaan. He likes to divert, dodge and distract from the main at hand. Look what he did with Uthmaan - asrar started to go on a tangent about Munaazra Rasheediya haha.

[@TrueSunni]

Of course because he would have lost the debate

[@torjet5640]

Not The shaykh's fault the deobandiya's chose an uneducated and unskilled individual who didn't possess basic knowledge. The shaykh, however, respectfully asked the Ustadh present to step forward and discuss as his student was unable to comprehend the fundamentals of munazarah.

[@MrRiz157]

@@torjet5640 Come on, chaps, let’s steer clear of sectarianism. The disagreement with Nurodeen is based on his misunderstanding of the original statement, whether unintentionally or intentionally, not his affiliation with Deoband.

[@navoxford8406]

​@@torjet5640are you sick siding with Asrar against the Prophet peace be upon Asrar and Hasan praised an insult against the Prophet peace be upon him

[@navoxford8406]

​@@MrRiz157no misunderstanding by sheikh Nooruddeen he knows exactly what Asrar is doing and will not let him get away with insulting the Prophet peace be upon him

[@user-dj6ph7ho3c]

What is the meaning of chisti rasool?

[@truth-z7x]

Means Chisti is the messenger of Allah Tala. These vile brelvis and Sufis print and praise books containing it.

[@H_G2013]

Listen from 16:03

[@asrarahmed177]

A strawman

[@navoxford8406]

​@@asrarahmed177the entire brelvi sect os based on strawmen

[@samihussain9018]

The fact you have made a number of videos post discussion shows how you know you were intellectually destroyed by Shaykh Asrar and co.

[@truth-z7x]

You think it is intellectually superior to praise insults against the Prophet peace be upon him Are you Muslim or atheist. You have a shocking understanding of intellectual strength

[@traditionalmiddlepath3773]

^^ Asrar sheep alert .... The fact you think someone making " lots" of videos destroys someone shows what level of Intelligence you have . Lets see if Asrar will make the 1 min video defending the Prophet Salal la Hu alley wasalam.

[@navoxford8406]

Yeah what a great intellect he is. He uses it to praise insults against the Prophet peace be upon him Intellect of the shaitan

[@ZagiEscobar]

6:36 'None of them have made videos against me' So it's an ego thing?

[@manbetterunderstand]

He asked both sides to condemn the statements, no one from their side made a video refuting what he said. Hassan did.

[@torjet5640]

Hassan made a video to clarify the full statement that Noorudin failed to mention on his original video that Abu bayazid bastami even rejected this statement. Noorudin just comprehend it.

[@manbetterunderstand]

@@torjet5640 No, he called it a refutation. What was he refuting exactly? Yes, Noorudin didn't mention the next line which says God Most High was speaking through his mouth, which Hassan explained as a spiritual state. Do you believe this too? And the line he read out where Abu Yazid says kill me if I say this again was about another problematic statement he allegedly said, not this flag statement. Go read the Urdu rather than just regurgitating what you hear.

[@truth-z7x]

Now Asrar has to make a video. No more exuses. You have praised an insult against the Prophet peace.

[@Mohammed-l6y6h]

Please explain in detail where he insulted or defended an insult, explain it in detail then point it out on the video with a time point. You have posted everywhere, and i have continuously asked you, yet you have not replied once...is this just blind following of this shaykh? Or a personal hatred for the opposing shaykh ? Or are you just a clout chaser ?

[@truth-z7x]

​@@Mohammed-l6y6hhe explained it about 20 times in this video. Do you understand English?

[@DhilMurrad]

Do you know brothers . The comments about are not needed and not helpful and I know Ustadh nooruddeen would not appreciate it. It only stirs emotions and the point of this video is not to attack Ustadh Asrar or his students.

[@DhilMurrad]

Ultimately we are all brothers and should seek to learn and have adhab with each other. And on comments . People seem to lose all aspects of what we learn about adhab in our deen. Should not everyone’s intentions be that a mutual understanding occurs through good dialogue rather then fuel more hatred.

[@Mohammed-l6y6h]

@@truth-z7x you explain it.. seen as youre posting comments everywhere... and point it out ie the time in the video.... or cant you do that because you cant understand english ? Or youre just defending your shaykh blindly ?

[@MohammadQasim]

Asalamu alaykum can we talk about the donkey statement, what would be the best platform to discuss this

[@asrarahmed177]

You are all accountable before Allah. Think about this. If you accuse people of something they are not responsible for like this so called Shaykh has done, you will be held responsible and humiliated in the court of Allah. Now it's up to you to prove what you accuse.

[@TrueSunni]

Asrar is praising insults against the Prophet peace be upon him Sheikh Nooruddeen is defending the Prophet peace be upon him And you think sheikh Nooruddeen will be humiliated Are you Muslim?

[@MrRiz157]

I think you should debate salafi you did a far better job in debunking their ideology.

[@truth-z7x]

Nope he exposed the Kufr of Brelvis better

[@navoxford8406]

Even the Salafis don't say things like this against the Prophet peace be upon him The brelvis are enemies of the Prophet peace be upon him

[@thepathofguidance5684]

Thanks for answering my question Sh. It might be worth sitting with Ustadh Mubeen as you have suggested.

[@truth-z7x]

I'm telling you Mobeen will not meet sheikh Nurudin especially not on camera

[@thepathofguidance5684]

Sadly I think as Sh Nur alluded to, many don't want to be shunned by their base. It's amazing that Sh Asrar has a sensible conversation with Yasir Qadhi but not Sh Nur.

[@navoxford8406]

Mobeen will not meet sheikh Nurudin on camera

[@navahmed1590]

Thank you for answering my question at 42 minutes 50 seconds into the video. I was unable to continue watching the livestream and my follow up question would have been that you are claiming that Ahlus Sunnah dont call people kaafirs. This is false. The scholars of Ahlus Sunnah's books are filled with examples of people who believe in certain sayings or do certain actions or say certain statements, then they are kaafirs. A person who drinks alcohol, we call them alcoholics, a person who fornicates, we call them a fornicator, a person who commits kufr, we call them a kaafir.

[@TrueSunni]

You must be a fan of Ahmed Riza he loved to make Takfir too You lot are Sufi Khawarij

[@truth-z7x]

​@@TrueSunni100 % Ahmed Riza Barelvi was a disaster for the Ummah

[@navahmed1590]

@TrueSunni Jumping to conclusions with no evidence. Your level of intelligence is shining through....

[@truth-z7x]

​@@navahmed1590it is easy to recognise you takfeeri brelvis

[@navoxford8406]

Brelvis love making Takfir they are worse than Madkhalis

[@hermano6793]

This man is radically obsessed. You were debunked in the meeting and yet you continue to pedal the topic. Ridiculous from you shaykh

[@traditionalmiddlepath3773]

How was he debunked ?

[@truth-z7x]

He is obsessed with defending the Prophet peace be upon him like he said in this video

[@navoxford8406]

You lot are obsessed with insulting the Prophet peace be upon him He is obsessed with defending the Prophet peace be upon him The Muslims can pick the side they want to be with

[@hermano6793]

@@truth-z7x defending the Prophet ﷺ by accusing someone of defending a statement that they outright rejected and called Kufr already?

[@hermano6793]

@@navoxford8406 May Allah hold you to account for your slanders

[@omarascari7403]

With all due respect sheikh, these trivial matters have no place during a genocide on our people. May Allah grant you all better understanding of priorities and duties of your platforms of this time and the ilm that should be spread at this time. Its shameful to see this from people who are supposed to be intellectuals.

[@truth-z7x]

With no respect calling insults against the Prophet peace be upon him trivial is disgusting. Ask the people of Gaza if they agree with you. They love and Allah Tala and his Messenger. They are going through everything for Islam and you are attacking it

[@navoxford8406]

Look at this guy Muslims are dying for their deen and this one is saying that's why we shouldn't defend the deen. What logic!

[@ateeqaziz5110]

Clout chaser

[@truth-z7x]

Ghustakh Rasool

[@truth-z7x]

These brelvis have been shown as enemies of the Prophet peace be upon him Now they have turned to playground insults. Completely exposed

[@muhammadjameel4240]

Gustakh rasool ki aik hi saza...

[@MrRiz157]

I must say, this was truly disheartening and, sadly, an embarrassing display. Respect is earned through honesty and integrity, but taking quotes out of context undermines both. Such actions reflect poorly on one's character and are far removed from the path of wisdom.

[@manbetterunderstand]

Please quote what he originally said and then tell us what was the context that he removed?

[@TrueSunni]

Nothing is out of context you Gustakhs want to praise insults against the Prophet peace be upon him and we won't let you. That is why you are disappointed.

[@MrRiz157]

@@manbetterunderstand The matter was clarified by Sheikh Asrar and even that young brother, who demonstrated that the issue stemmed from being taken out of context. True understanding requires humility and patience, not haste or assumption.

[@manbetterunderstand]

@@MrRiz157 Brother just repeating what you heard doesn't make it true. You speak of honesty and integrity so once again, please tell us what he said that was taken out of context and then explain the context.

[@MrRiz157]

@@manbetterunderstand No, it doesn’t necessarily make it true, and I agree. However, I’ve been watching this scholar quite a bit and noticed that most of the points raised are more sensational than truly academic. This approach doesn't resonate well with most people, particularly those who value wisdom and knowledge.

[@shazaddad2892]

This is the great idea of sunni unity!

[@navoxford8406]

Nobody wants unity with Asrar he insults the Prophet peace be upon him

[@truth-z7x]

Unity with Asrar and his mob?! They are so arrogant they have started to insult the Prophet peace be upon him

[@MakhdoomAdil-ze7zv]

i am very disappointed in shaykh. Shaykh Asrar met him and he did not say any thing there and after the meeting he is making Videos Continously . Come on ,A person was in front of you and you were arrogant there and now making videos . سبحان اللہ

[@TrueSunni]

You obviously haven't watched this video. Everything has been explained. Asrar is Gustakh

[@navoxford8406]

You are disappointed that sh Nurudin defends the Prophet peace be upon him Are you Muslim?

[@MakeTawba.]

It's not permissible to speak about the statements of the Awliya of Allah without knowledge of their technical terms and knowledge of their Exalted States. We request no more discussion on the Great Abu Yazid RehmatUllah Alai. Sit with Those Who Know and go through His Statements.

[@traditionalmiddlepath3773]

So you are ok with Allah speaking through the mouth of someone if they are in a spiritual state ???!!!!!!!

[@truth-z7x]

Stop making excuses for kufr

[@TrueSunni]

You calling people who insult Allah Tala and his Messenger peace be upon him great. Are you Muslim

[@AbdulKhan-cg3hs]

​@@truth-z7xwhere is the kufr

[@MakeTawba.]

@@traditionalmiddlepath3773 No , we are against kufr. Please see the Hadith and the statements from Those in Fana are understood in this context. Again, please refrain and do no continue. On the authority of Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him), who said that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: Allah (mighty and sublime be He) said: Whosoever shows enmity to someone devoted to Me, I shall be at war with him. My servant draws not near to Me with anything more loved by Me than the religious duties I have enjoined upon him, and My servant continues to draw near to Me with supererogatory works so that I shall love him. When I love him I am his hearing with which he hears, his seeing with which he sees, his hand with which he strikes and his foot with which he walks. Were he to ask [something] of Me, I would surely give it to him, and were he to ask Me for refuge, I would surely grant him it. I do not hesitate about anything as much as I hesitate about [seizing] the soul of My faithful servant: he hates death and I hate hurting him. It was related by al-Bukhari.

[@kass254]

You try so hard to be like shayk asrar its embarrassing.

[@truth-z7x]

Who would want to be like a Gustakh of the Prophet peace be upon him Are you lot mad

[@TrueSunni]

Asrar praises insults aginst the Prophet peace be upon him No sensible person wants to be like him

[@AbdulKhan-cg3hs]

​@@TrueSunnihow and where

[@navoxford8406]

​@@AbdulKhan-cg3hsyou didn't watch the video. You don't even know why you are defending Asrar. You don't know you are siding with him against the Prophet peace be upon him

[@TrueSunni]

This is what we needed an open q and a clarify everything. Show you have nothing to hide. Sh Nurudin you are on the Haqq for this issue, don't stop talking about it.