Pressure Gas Coleman vs Oil Lamp vs Aladdin Oil Lamp

Pressure Gas Coleman vs. Oil Lamp vs. Aladdin Oil Lamp
Names:
Coleman Dual Fuel Lantern (Buy Here: amzn.to/2gJ0B9e)
Standard Oil Lamp ( Buy Here: amzn.to/2gVxn4Q)
Aladdin Genie III Incandescent Oil Lamp
A discussion and comparison between three different types of Oil Lamps.
Hopefully after watching this video you will be more knowledgeable about which type of lamp/lantern to purchase with your hard earned dollars.
Keep in mind cost, efficiency, fuel availability, repairs, maintenance, heat output, and a host of other things when you purchase your next light source. Whether you are preparing beforehand or living off the grid this video will help you.
Please check out some of these other Aladdin Oil Lamp Videos
1.) Pressure Gas Coleman vs Oil Lamp vs Aladdin Oil Lamp: www.youtube.co....
2.) Aladdin Oil Lamp : Flat wick vs Aladdin: www.youtube.co....
3.) Aladdin Oil Lamp: Video Overview:
www.youtube.co....
4.) Aladdin Oil Lamp : Putting together your top assembly: www.youtube.co....
5.) Aladdin Oil Lamp : How to change your wick: www.youtube.co....
6.) Aladdin Oil Lamp : Running your lamp effectively: www.youtube.co....
7.) Aladdin Oil Lamp : Charring your wick for optimum performance: www.youtube.co....
8.) Aladdin Oil Lamp : Heat Output Demonstration and Safety Video: www.youtube.co....
9.) Aladdin Oil Lamp : Installing a New Mantle: www.youtube.co....
10.) Aladdin Oil Lamp : Mantle Burn:
www.youtube.co....
11.) Aladdin Oil Lamp : Slow Motion Mantle Burn: www.youtube.co....
Thanks for watching and please do not forget to Comment, Rate, and Subscribe
Donate & Support Channel : www.paypal.me/...
Weston

[@kylej741]

I never knew the Aladdin lamps existed until I cleaned out my grandma’s attic. Bought new wick and chimney for it (company still exists found on internet). Fantastic lamp and good source of heat when power goes out in the winter!

[@soniadee2674]

Great video. Finally someone on KZbin that truly knows about lanterns. I’ve used lanterns for years and have recently seen some video by people who really don’t know what they are talking about. Well done and informative video.

[@jbetz78]

Man you really gave a ton of information in this video, great job sharing your knowledge.

[@freeheeler09]

My wife just inherited and restored two Alladin lamps. They are great. Nice video

[@robaldridge6505]

we used to cut our oil lamp wicks (the middle one in your vid) in a V shape so that it had 2 points, gives more light, we also used to cook on top of coleman lanterns, made a cook top out of a coffee CAN (the old metal ones) they fit right on top, you punch holes around the outside edge with a can opener and put a coffee pot or a pressed steel frypan on top, and you can cook....

[@WestonSummers]

+Rob Aldridge Awesome! And they actually make some lanterns made specifically to cook on. Great survival items for sure.

[@richardanderson6874]

Precise, concise, and to the point. Many thanks!

[@samTollefson]

I had an Aladdin lamp in my cabin in the WV mountains in the 70's. A wonderful lamp, but very delicate. We learned the best use was to hang it in a permanent place and move it as little as possible, then we would get over a year out of a mantel - I never used one up, they always broke first. I highly recamend them as a bed side lamp.

[@WestonSummers]

+sam Tollefson That is probably a very smart move! I try and keep mine stationary also. They are awesome machines for sure.

[@samTollefson]

+WestonSummers Thank You Weston. I bought my lamp new in about 1972, aluminum (I couldn't afford the brass model at the time, I now wish I could have) I then ordered the aluminum hanger kit with smoke diffuser and made a heavy wire shade frame and covered it with burlap from a feed sack. It hangs in my house now, although I haven't used it since the last hurricane here in Florida. I took a photo of it but don't know how or if you can post it on KZbin. If your interested, send me an email and I will send it to you. [e-mail] Thanks, Sam

[@WestonSummers]

+sam Tollefson [e-mail]. :)

[@SpectrumSurvivalist]

I'm going to get one of those Aladdin Genie III Oil Lamps from Lehmans for $165.99, this video convinced me. In fact at least one or more for each room big enough to need one. About survival and not letting people know where you are, that lessor regular wick oil lamp is best for that. Tonight high winds took the power off for over an hour, I fired mine up to max brightness with a freshly cleaned globe and it was setting on top of my closed laptop on the ĉoffee table in my living room, top of lamp about 3 feet off the floor. As there was no street lights or anything burning outside, just dark clouds and wind, I went outside for awhile. While I was standing in the road, about 25 feet from the living room window, I looked and I could detect zero light from the road. In fact, the only way I could see any light was within a few feet from my window, and it was the faintest yellowish glow. Just enough light in the room to be able to move around, but not enough anyone passing by from the road would ever pick up on unless they were running NVG's. So this is just something to think about, and by the way, my walls in this room are dark, 2 shades of blue, I imagine brightly painted walls would be a bit more detectable, but that can be fixed with curtains are by turning the lamp down some, but I'm not using curtains, this allows me to be able to look out. For inside I would go with a regular oil lamp and an Aladdin in each room, but only use the latter if the shtf sparingly. This is just something for you people reading this to think about, sometimes less is better. You could put that little oil lamp in the opposite corner from the fron't door, and hide in the dark corner with a gun, when they walk in without a light you would see them, they wouldn't see you, just the gunshot, too late. I can sit on my couch and see both my fron't door, and my kitchen door at the same time with just moving my eyes, a small oil lamp near each door would cover me. I don't have a back door, just fron't and side. Play around with it, might save your life one day.

[@easein]

Thanks for the tutorial. I've been itching to get an Aladdin for a year or so. You're the only one that's answered a couple of my questions. Thanks

[@harbourwoodlandvisitor2445]

i think this video for information on these lamps is the best i had seen so far.

[@fredford7642]

VERY informative video! Thank you! I learned a lot about oil lamps in these short 16 minutes.

[@perkinsofmonterey]

Thanks for this video. Very well put together. I've been keeping an Aladdin in storage for the last couple decades or more. Never got around to messing with it so seeing you fire one up next to the Coleman was very interesting. I knew it was supposed to be bright but seeing the three put it in perspective. Seems two mantles vs one might give an advantage? Notsure. Probably not really an issue. Anyway, you've inspired us to get out the Aladdin and do our homework. Love this stuff. Thanks again!

[@user-by7hj4dj9s]

my reaction to seeing the Coleman and the Aladdin is the Coleman don't spread light up only out to the sides

[@tcphll]

One of the big things I don't think you covered is the CO output. They all put out a bit of CO, but the Coleman puts out a very significant amount compared to the other two, which is enough to kill you. I'd never run a Coleman indoors, especially the dual fuel kind.

[@crabtrap]

Dude, i hope you're in sales somewhere!

[@kimmer6]

Nice review. Thank you kindly. I live in an earthquake zone and my heart would break to find an Aladdin in pieces on the floor. I made snap hooks to retain my Deitz lanterns on their rods hanging from the rafters in my open beam ceiling. I worry less but the one converted to LED's is probably the safest! Also have a Coleman 200A single mantle pressure KEROSENE lantern. Nice and bright. I will have light when nobody else does.

[@user-by7hj4dj9s]

in our cabin we have an Aladdin hanging form the ceiling. not sure if the chimney would fall off in an earthquake. they are pretty secure

[@kimmer6]

@@user-by7hj4dj9s I found a brand new Aladdin lamp with a spring mounted arm that is bolted to the wall. Its all aluminum and was intended to be used in passenger trains. It was a very lucky find. Now I wish I had a cabin!

[@SpiritHowler]

Great video. Thanks for all the information and the reviews. You did a really good job. It was enjoyable to watch.

[@dandelk664]

Great video there are a handful of Aladdin lamps at a local antique store I’ve been looking at

[@hauckjohn]

Living in the Texas Hill Country, this subject matters. We have the same exact lanterns and I had the same question. Thanks for posting this. I am burning Jet A (JP5) in the lanterns, since the airport is closer than the city.

[@kateinmontana]

I feel you are a very good teacher, and a lot of good information. thankyou

[@StumpGreenwoodSC]

The Aladdin is a good looking lamp !

[@lindamorgan2678]

You are a gem and yes I agree you have a pretty face. Ha Ha You have very organized thought pattern and speech. One of the better presentations I have ever seen ...and not just lamps. Thanks so much I learned alot looking to purchase an Alladin and have used the other two quite a bit. I like your accent North Carolina ? Thanks so much. all the best from Canada.. Subbed and hit the alarm

[@mmoss8576]

Duel fuel update I found that you can run klean heat or alcohol just fine, running klean heat allows for using all 3 types of lamps/lanterns with one source of fuel.

[@Captain_Char]

I have a Dietz 76, and found it puts out a solid bright light, and in pitch darkness I found it throws a good deal of light

[@LoftechUK]

Amazing video. Shame you stopped here. Would like to see more

[@tecatenacido4192]

I was hoping I could use Olive Oil in a lamp like the one on the left cause I heard Olive Oil is safer. I have one. I guess I have to use Mason Jars for Olive Oil Lamps. Thanks so much for this video. Excellent video. New Subscriber.

[@lampcollector6242]

I think you will find me quite interesting as well.

[@Begining2013]

Outstanding review and info. I learned so much from this. Thank you!

[@dinukajayawardena5473]

5:38 We call it the "Hurricane Lamp" runs on kerosene. Good explanation man !

[@altrock86]

My grandpa had an Aladdin lamp and several oil lamps and my mom had several oil lamps I was surprised how bright the Aladdin lamp was it’s like a light bulb. But it needed quite a bit of maintenance from what I remember.

[@RidgeRunneR937]

GREAT video, first of all, and thanks for putting it together. I own an Aladdin Genie, some normal wick oil lamps, and a Coleman, albeit propane lantern, and I'd say you're spot on everything. I've begun to look at things from a "preppers" standpoint and happened to come across your video and wanted to see someone else's take on some things I was considering as far as lighting, fuel, wicks, etc... I thought it to be well put together and a great comparison as to the available fuels vs light output vs various wick designs. Thanks again.

[@mayansurvivor]

Very informative video,

[@WestonSummers]

Thanks man. Nice comments mean alot. Cheers - Weston

[@spockmcoyissmart961]

Nice vid, very useful. 1st time seeing an Aladdin in use.

[@oldgoat8861]

A very good educational video with alot of information. Well done !!!

[@mikafoxx2717]

An interesting experiment would be to try mounting am Aladdin mantle on a standard flat Wick lantern, and see if it works, might be a neat video.

[@carmenmartinez2882]

Single Coleman lanterns are not nearly as bright as 2 mantel ones. I have the Coleman 800 dual Fuel and love the amount of light while camping, I get a bit nervous while camping in bear country, I’ve had some close encounters. Thanks for a fantastic video.

[@MrHelidude]

Thank you, thank you very much for this video. Does the Coleman give out a lot of petrol fumes/smell when burning indoors please? Might you think I should invest in an Aladdin lamp or a Coleman dual fuel lamp for use in the house if and when the power happens to go out please? Thank you kindlyand many happy greetings. Nara (from Launceston, Tasmania)

[@ryanmcdermott657]

Excellent video, very helpful, thanks.

[@Partisanpackrat]

I liked your vid and I have used all three. However, as of lately, I use only the Rayo lamps, they are just as bright as the Aladin and as durable as the oil lamp. You can burn about anything liquid in them, I have used diesel, kerosene,lamp oil and I have even heard of people burning jet fuel. Of course all the center blast lamps are hot and that huge round wick goes through fuel lickety split but if you need light I think they are the only way.

[@Diwana71]

Nice comparison. Aladdin is the thing.

[@richs9543]

Good job on the comparisons! One thing missing... Smell? How would you compare the odors? Thanks, ....Rich

[@lampcollector6242]

It mostly depends on what fuel you are using.

[@FloryJohann]

I got the B and the 23 model. On the walmart '' lamp oil'' there is no smell whatsoever. Also on K1 there is no smell. Now, right after changing the wick on the 23 model I pick up a little smell. Looks like I have to run it a few hours to get rid of the smell. If you turn the flame to high, then you will get kerosene odors.The coleman smells more like car exhaust to me.

[@Subgunman]

I've been using an all aluminum Genie 3 style lamp for over 40 years. I have used regular kerosene in my lamp with no issues. After moving to the EU I have been using paraffin oil with zero issues. This comes recommend by Pelam in Germany who has parts for the Aladin line of lamps as well as Petromax and regular oil lamps. I have had the best results with paraffin oil with very little odor in a closed home and the only type of kerosene available here in Greece has a green dye added and is made by Kerosun and sold as fuel for their heaters. Aladin does not recommend their fuel for the Aladin lamps. My next mod to the Aladin is to order a plain glass Aladin shade an harp to help cut the glare of the lamp.

[@cofeebeing]

Thanks . Great straight forward information.

[@Walkercolt1]

An Aladdin's Magic Lamp gives more light (lumens) than a Coleman Powerhouse Lantern (I own both) and uses FAR less fuel per hour (even considering kerosene has almost double the energy per gallon as naptha or Coleman fuel) and is FAR SAFER as it isn't pressurized. I own an Aladdin Lincoln Drape Green (antique) and a Wall pivot brass font Aladdin (modern) for emergencies. They are rated at 2200 lumens or equal to a 200 watt incandescent light bulb, but my $600 photographic light meter shows they both output nearly 3000 lumens when adjusted properly. The Coleman Powerhouse Lantern outputs less than 2000 lumens with a Coleman reflector on it.

[@totallyfrozen]

The only thing I was hoping you would cover that you didn’t was lighting each of them. Since they each have a different lighting process and accessing the wick/mantel can be more or less cumbersome for a new user.

[@anniekook2787]

Thank you for all your wonderful demos!!!!!!!!

[@LittleMakeupChannel]

thanks for an outstanding quick pace review of these 👍🏻

[@Asertix357]

I keep seeing those Blizzard lanterns with green paint and brass trim on videos, but I don't see them for sale anywhere.

[@EdWatts]

Try Lehman's: www[dot]lehmans[dot]com

[@Ces1um]

lee valley sells them too

[@Keithers_]

Thanks for the demos!

[@jimmydodgen588]

Lantern make a good heat source you have a good video

[@pcer9973]

2020 thank you, very much sir.

[@haileylynn15151]

I used paraffin oil in my Aladdin 23. It seemed to work fine. Is that okay to continue using regular oil lamp oil in the Aladdin?

[@SuperJhon360]

how do you put out the aladdin if you cant get above it because of the heat?

[@jdj5952]

It's worth noting the Coleman will burn E85 just fine. I have tried it personally. I'd just recommend flushing it with white gas before storage to prevent moisture and rust issues.

[@harrymills2770]

You need to pump up the pressure lantern more often than once every couple hours. It's kind of a pain, but you get good light from it when it's pressurized. 4th alternative is a propane lantern. It's also loud like the white-gas pressure lantern, but it runs full-on until you turn it off or it runs out of gas. When I camped for weeks on end, I ran a hose from a 20-lb propane tank, and I could forget about it for 2 or 3 weeks, and that's staying up late playing camp chess.

[@tallcedars2310]

Our coleman lantern will burn all night outside without pumping up pressure. The light gets lower, but still provides plenty of light until morning when we shut it off.

[@Jchathe]

Thank you for such an informative video 🙏💖

[@explorermike19]

Really excellent and informative and well done video. thanks.

[@AuGold808]

honestly, phenomenal video

[@xshanghu]

Great video!!!! - - - Very informative !!!!!! - - - Key Man

[@Sb129]

Lol was this filmed on a camcorder? This is pretty cool though, an incandescent mantle that isn't propane is exceedingly interesting.

[@brianmccann666]

As you're talking about noise, i can hear that coleman hissing away the whole time. Good if you need noise to sleep. Some people want noise like running a fan, etc... The Hurricane Oil Lamp is the BEST choice hands down. Cheap. Multiple fuels, quite... And very portable.

[@nunyabizness199]

Brian Mccann You don't want to run an Aladdin dry while you sleep or run one while you sleep. When Aladdins run out of fuel the wick smolders down and will be ruined. Also, then "can" flare if theres a malfunction and burn your house down. Never run one unattended.

[@gtb81.]

I have an aladin lamp and I have walked through the house with it burning, nothing happened to it Also I have an antique regular oil lamp and it lights up my entire room to be able to comfortably read almost anywhere

[@thomasf.5768]

Great video. Super info & presentation

[@tundraheights7518]

I liked that. good video.

[@mosmanque]

Informative! Well done.

[@cyndifleck9750]

Excellent video. Thanks for the information!

[@callmeBe]

Weston, you really have an outstanding video here! Thanks for being so thorough. I live in rural Mexico, and the only fuel I could easily find around here would be for the oil lamp. My question is this: I need a lamp for heat, not light. I have a room that is 15'x15'. And the temperatures at night get around 50 degrees or so. If I was burning two of oil lamps (hurricane lanterns are easy to find here) would I be able to heat the room up by 10 degrees in an hour or two? What do you think?? And thanks for your kind response, Weston!

[@danielbingham3124]

One typical wick kerosene lantern puts out 1400 btu, 4 or 5 lanterns will raise the temperature about 15°

[@classic287]

Excellent video. Very entertaining...

[@mo-reesespieces9066]

Just wondering, on the Colman dual fuel, are you able to run a cooking oil out of them or do you need the fumes from the required fuel to make them run? Have you or anyone tried to see if they could get the Colman to run off of some type of cooking oil? Nice video, thanks for sharing and taking the time. Peace, Reese

[@oaney]

I doubt a cooking oil would work, it is much too viscous. Possibly a much lighter oil like 3 in 1, but even that is very doubtful. These Colemans usually use something called White Gas which is mostly Naptha. Dual Fuel Colemans can use gasoline also, but neither white gas or gasoline is very oil-like. I cant say anything for certain because I wont risk damage to my Dual Fuel to test oils, haha

[@carmenmartinez2882]

Mo -Reese's Pieces you’d be ruining the generator. In fact you want to use unleaded gas only in emergencies or if you don’t mind cleaning the generator often. Best to use white gas, crown is way cheaper than Coleman fuel .

[@chevy6969200]

Very good video to show the differences. A little bit of light. Decent light with 5,00 BTU and a lot of light and more heat, Be aware of the dangers of using them indoors. Is there a replacement for the Aladdin mantel without replacing the entire assembly?

[@EdWatts]

www[dot]lehmans[dot]com

[@lampcollector6242]

Yes there is. You can buy them on the internet for 10 to 15 dollars a piece.

[@coreymason7662]

Thanks for the info, great video. 🌝

[@tadapdavis]

Are all three safe to use indoors?

[@wholeNwon]

The burning of any hydrocarbon fuel produces CO (carbon monoxide) among other combustion products. There is no such thing as a non-toxic dose. Obviously, high doses are deadly; but, even low doses can produce measurable harm. The literature with pressure lamps like Coleman products states that they are not to be used indoors (at least it did the last time I read it). I don't know what Aladdin's literature states and wonder whether it would ever say that their products ARE safe to use indoors.

[@MonkPetite]

Of my coleman starts to die out its time to go to bed in most cases.. the fun of the Genie and the coleman it does heat up the room a bit ..

[@amra.haleem5175]

Hello. Where to buy olive oil lamps online? Thanks.

[@pratoarancione7646]

I love you, Weston.

[@bethbeckett9219]

How often do you replace the mantle in the Colman lantern

[@jamessandifer6119]

Cherping flames noise...lol Good review.

[@MADuranDude777]

Good information. Thank you

[@vincentrobinette1507]

The Aladdin seems to be the best compromise between fuel cost, noise, and usable light output.

[@philipvernejules9926]

....... Probably only our local lexicon but one of em was called a hurricane lantern , I always thought that was the pressure lantern cos of the roar , but others reckon it's the fourth one you held up that's called a hurricane lantern . Always amuses me how in western movies that all the strong light in the room is attributed to the kerosene wick lanterns. Sure , the Aladdin has a chimney flue to create air feed draught for a hotter flame. The mantles need a temperature just a little higher than what a non flue wick can provide and the alladin does the job. ..In the hippy era there was a little lightweight metal foil attachment that fitted around the wick to spread the flame and increase light output . The mantle as invented by Swedish chemist in 1860s was the first exploitation of the lanthanides or rare earth metals. Along with the reliable utility gas distribution those mantle lights persisted till the 1940s as household lighting in some regions . A sturdier type of mantle was used .

[@66lwmorgan]

I have to stop you at 13:27, did you mean to say pretty piece of paper, lol. Just kidding, that was a very good demonstration between the lamps.

[@jaquepaulo]

Just purchased my first Aladdin lamp. Completely ruined the mantle and did some damage to the wick. Got a new mantle and got a new wick but the flame is not symmetrical. In some spots there is almost no flame and in others quite a large flame. Lamp runs but at low power and I get dark spots on the mantle if I turn it up much at all. I’m running kerosene. Your help would be appreciated. Thanks

[@danodbdb]

Tons of great info. Thanks!

[@ChintanPandya01]

Great review! Thanks man.

[@terryshrives8322]

awesome comparison! Thank you Sir!

[@bmcgraw3840]

Leaded gas can be used in regular Coleman lamps, have both types, but generator will carbon up the expansion tube and it can be cleaned out with a 22 caliber brass rifle bore brush, no need to discard them. I do have regular Coleman fuel. Yellow kerosene (drives bugs out of the house) works well in Aladdin lamps and stoves if used every night for hours at a time, 9 days after an ice storm here but I have #1 kerosene as well. I have a Rayo kerosene lamp, no mantel but its system allows unusually brighter light than wick lamps. STA-BIL brand fuel additive for kerosene will prevent bacteria from growing if kerosene is kept for many years. I bought a Coleman kerosene pump-up lantern when on sale, prefer kerosene inside for safety, gasoline is best used outside for fire safety and to avoid carbon monoxide gas in closed spaces such as tight winter tents. I have two grain alcohol stoves, no moving parts, easier and sturdier than the homemade ones on You Tube, produces carbon monoxide as well. I keep a large number of LED flashlights as well as lamps. I question using non-ethanol gas, harder to find, as useful in Coleman's and what is the problem there?

[@TF856]

Don't forget that some hardware stores sell generic white gas which is cheaper than Coleman brand white gas and there's also some other type of fuel that you can use in them that is also sold in some hardware stores, I don't remember the name, but it's not unleaded gasoline.

[@lunger2006]

Naphtha is what you are referring to, as what you can find at hardware stores.

[@frugalprepper]

Great Video. Thanks

[@FloryJohann]

I got 2 of those regular oil lamps and 1 tank last about 10 hours, The Walmart el cheapo storm lantern for about $7 last about 13 hours on one tank. I got the Aladdin B and 23 model and I love them both. If you do not want smell, then the Aladdin is the one to use. You forgot to mention fume smell while operating.

[@cymond]

How much spacer is needed above an Aladdin lamp to prevent damage to a ceiling? I'm considering putting one in my mantle, or perhaps on a shelf.

[@DogStar84]

24 inches clearance above chimney. They sell a chimney lid for it too if you have concerns. It puts a LOT of heat out the chimney top

[@oaney]

Thanks for the video!

[@dungbanhai9827]

Có bán không anh

[@jaguarangel2000]

Excellent video! Very informative. Thank you so much. :0)

[@poseypapusdiazfamily4630]

Metal Aladdin's?

[@kennethmccann6402]

Thank you!

[@themadscientest]

an oil lamp is a different beast and it usually is not using any draft like a kerosene lamp. for oil lamps a few different variations on the designs exist but most keep the fuel and burning end of the wick within an inch of each other at the most, some let the flame directly touch the oil.

[@JerryWick]

Can you use a light sweet crude oil in any of these lamps in a pinch? Lots of oil wells where I live

[@EdWatts]

No. Even "light" crude oil is many times "thicker" than any of these lanterns can manage. Kerosene (up to and including "liquid paraffin"), naphtha, and "white" gasoline are the fuels which work. Diesel fuel will also work, but it will make your living space smell like a truck stop. If what you intend to use is less than transparent or has much color, it will be unsuitable for use in these devices.

[@tylerhall6455]

If your talking shft, then if your really motivated you can distill crude to a diesel. Don't think any of us will be doing that, but its not that far out a idea. In africa they have clandestine fuel making operations that are very sketchy distilling crude into diesel over fire pits and using 55 gallon steel drums lol. But still, I dont have any idea if diesel would be refined enought to be usable in either the alladin or colman lantern. Wick one would work fine I imagine.

[@rickytoddbotelho9555]

Excellent review.

[@sebster3gmail]

Thank you.

[@gwEmbassy]

Great video

[@eron1979]

Should have included fuel cost but good video

[@bobg1685]

Nicely done.

[@VernonWallace]

Well done. Thank you