Problematic Hadith Predicting the Future | Part 18 | Dr. Shabir Ally

The #Quran speaks about the future, but the statements are worded in a general way, and of course, #Muslims believe the Quran is the word of God and cannot be wrong. On the other hand, hadiths predicting the future are dependent on the #Prophet peace be upon him getting revelation from #God and then people memorizing it exactly, which is complicated by the fact that futuristic concepts wouldn't be easy to grasp or imagine for people who had no consciousness of them. Dr. Shabir Ally discusses the problems with these hadiths, including that they run counter to the rest of hadiths.
If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by:
Visiting our website www.QuranSpeaks.com OR
Sending an etransfer to [e-mail] OR
Subscribing monthly at Patreon.com/QuranSpeaks
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: kzbin.info_...
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks

[@BruceWSims]

For the Life of me, I flat-out do not understand where folks get the guts to make the declarations that they do and then pull-out a Hadith to support their behaviors. I'm sure Shabir Ali probably gets not a little grief for calling a spade a spade but I really lose patience with these "scholars" who seem to purport to know Exactly what Allah (swt) means and intends and then invoke some man-originated Hadith. IMHO its is a blessing from the Creator that we have resources like LTQS that provide guidance rather than make declarations about we "should" and "should Not". May Allah grant you all Jannah. 😊

[@Halal_Dan]

The real scholars are people who know the Quran and Sunnah with the understanding of the favored generations. Shabir can't even remember that it was Dhul Qarnayn that built the wall at 4:20.

[@BruceWSims]

@Halal_Dan ...and yet, Allah has determined that this teacher has crossed both our paths at just this point in time and space. I need to pray on that.

[@Quran_Alone_Dawah]

​@@Halal_DanNo generation is favoured above the other.

[@Halal_Dan]

The Companions are equal to people of today?@@Quran_Alone_Dawah

[@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411]

@@BruceWSims Bruce please stop the self deluded hippie nonsense you keep spouting. Islam isn't learned from internal reflections, meditations or other woowoo. Islam's a completed religion that's applicable to the end of times. If you accept there's no God but Allah SWT and Muhammad pbuh is his messenger then you must submit to Allah"s commands and discard that ego of yours. Only prophets speak to Allah. Their purpose is to convey his message and show us the path to his pleasure. You keep acting as if Islam is a shapeless religion where every snowflake can have their own special interpretation of it. It's not about being unique it's about submission. You're not better than Muhammad pbuh or even his most humble companion. If you're sincere about being Muslim then humble yourself and start learning Islam. You won't find a better way to practice Islam than our predecessors. Your outlandish opinions show that you've yet to come to the path of Allah SWT.

[@Simarodra]

Some people scolded me when I said that I don't give much attention to the stories of Dajjal as those are not mentioned in Qur'an. They called me inkar sunnah. ... but I simply said to them that all those stories about the future has no benefit for my daily life as muslim. Thank you Dr. Shabir ...

[@Halal_Dan]

Every prophet sought refuge from the fitna of the Dajjal for themselves and their ummah, but I guess you know better than all of them?

[@hassanabdur-rahman1559]

​@@Halal_Danwhere in the Quran is the dajal mentioned?

[@AM-ub3nh]

@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 dajjal is not mentioned directly in the Quran, as far as I know.

[@Halal_Dan]

@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 The Prophet ﷺ mentioned the dajjal

[@furbycim]

dr shabir ally is just one of the best.

[@faizanahmed5816]

This is exactly what us m going through hadith are too mych some are really putting me in grave doubts and everyone simply casually believes no-one is supposed to have that problem

[@africandawahrevival]

Atleast a breath of fresh air from the Hadith absolutists, a balanced approach it is.

[@User-dn4vi]

Hadith absolutists? 😂first time hearing such a silly thing

[@cocoalfaridah5831]

@@User-dn4viyou don’t like it? Shaytan pee in your nose and ear?

[@africandawahrevival]

@@User-dn4vi well, I guess you still have a lot to learn then

[@User-dn4vi]

@@africandawahrevival Or maybe stop inventing ridiculous terms to call Muslims who are staunch believers of the Sunnah.

[@africandawahrevival]

@@User-dn4vi it is a category in the hadith literature, infact even in the tradition, early scholars grouped themselves, there were some who called themselves Ahlu hadith, and they called their opponents Ahlu Ray, just because it's in English doesn't make a good distinction wrong. For instance, read Khaarib Al Baghdadi principles of accepting hadith. There is a lot on this issue, for example, do we use Isnaad or Matn, an absolutist focuses more on Isnaad, while a relativist focuses more on the Matn. Isnaad - chain of narrators Matn - meaning of the narration

[@sobiakhan2153]

Thank you for doing this series. Thoroughly enjoyed all the videos!

[@risalaat2144]

What great scholar ❤

[@andrewischill]

Thank you both for your knowledge and the clarity you two always bring

[@idrisaleemdar]

JazakAllah learnt so much from this episode

[@lanre007]

Thank you Dr. Shabir for your honesty in this obvious

[@midnight_vw]

One of the worst sins you can commit is misattributing to the prophet what he did not say. And the term sahih is misleading. Sahih or correct is referring to the chain of narration, not necessarily the content of the Hadith. So if I find a sahih Hadith problematic, I'm not rejecting the word of the prophet, rather taking the stance that it has either been misattributed or manipulated.

[@TheTruth-hc7ww]

So why accept Hafs recitation; didn’t he misattribute what the prophet did not say? Wasn’t he called a Fabricator of Hadith?

[@idrisaleemdar]

MashAllah JazakAllah very good episode

[@Citizen052]

Thank you Dr Shabir for opening our eyes! May Allah bless you.

[@user-lc5ix6qm5h]

Finally a thinking Muslim questions Hadith: Hadith is not authority. Nor is it revelation. It is just a report of what the prophet might have said. No shape or form does it declare that the Hadith is valid

[@Fireboltdark]

Sir i think you should consilt sir javed ghamdi for this! Nonetheless a very informative and healthy approach to the matter!

[@sHuRuLuNi]

Don't "leave it at that"! Your videos are always WAY TOO SHORT! They should be much much longer. You cannot just skim over issues like this which need deep and thorough analysis.

[@sciencefollower]

Where is Yajooj Majooj wall ???

[@thamimahmed6108]

So what's the solution dr shabir sir...should we belive these problamtic hadees or ignore

[@abdulazmi1591]

Thank you very much Dr. Ally and Dr. Sayyia for outstanding analysis of the topic. Drs. Will it not be appropriate to call it Controversial hadith rather than Problematic hadith?

[@anonymous-dv1qr]

Exactly correct.

[@cocoalfaridah5831]

@@anonymous-dv1qrof he calle it controversial hadith then he is dismissing all Hadiths, but probablematic Hadith, he is not excluding all of thy they can be used when needed with affirmation statement..

[@anonymous-dv1qr]

@@cocoalfaridah5831 I mean those Ahadiths which two Drs. presented.

[@hassanabdur-rahman1559]

It should be called a fabricated hadith.

[@cocoalfaridah5831]

@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 for 1300 years they existed wny they didn’t do the cleaning long ago.. Why now? I wonder

[@alhajibukarbukar0]

❤❤

[@darkdoge9240]

I have a problem when people twist the translations of the Quran to satisfy the Hadiths. So many Hadith clearly contradict Quran. It was written at least 150 years later the passing Prophet PBUH. How can we rely our complete faith on the hope that these people had 'strong memory' and trustworthy rather than completing depending on the word of god?

[@TheTruth-hc7ww]

All you know about Muhammad comes from those same Hadith; so how do you know Muhammad as you know him existed at all? You said right these things were written long after.

[@Lordbear33]

Sam Gerrans explains this very well

[@naturegirl4803]

Very good initiative to take on the misunderstanding and narratives of Hadith which is explicitly ruining the imaan of Muslims and contracted Islam into a methodological religion. Good conduct of people matters more than anything in Islam..

[@Halal_Dan]

Good conduct towards God means you follow His commands and His Messenger. So follow the Sunnah.

[@cocoalfaridah5831]

@@Halal_Danno one wants to follow the sunnah anymore.. I don’t know why!? They say bukari Muslim came 280.. After the prophet

[@hassanabdur-rahman1559]

​@@Halal_Danwhere in the Quran does it says that believers must follow the sunnah of the prophet?

[@Halal_Dan]

@@cocoalfaridah5831 Bukhari only recorded hadith, and those hadith he recorded were passed down in the same way that the Quran was passed down, by the same people!

[@Halal_Dan]

@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 He who obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah ; but those who turn away - We have not sent you over them as a guardian. (4:80)

[@northstar_7]

Whoever remembers remembers, whoever forgot forget. Ppl are forgetful. Does this apply to the Koran?

[@naveedkhan8023]

Quran is in telegraphic form, it’s commentary is given in Hadith literature.

[@User-dn4vi]

Did this guy just say Solomon built the wall 😂

[@folaazeez8376]

That was a slip. He had mentioned DzhulQarnain just before that.

[@amitozazad1584]

Please condemn the futuristic Hadith Ghazwa e Hind (😧😰Invasion of India, Sunan an-Nasa'i 3175, Sunan an-Nasa'i 3173 ). I will quote Hadith 3173 here: Abu Hurairah said, "The Prophet promised us a battle expedition in India. If I live to see that, I will dedicate myself and my wealth to it. If I am killed, I will be among the best of martyrs, and if I return, I will be Abu Hurairah Al-Muharrar." Indian Muslims believing in such kinds of Hadiths will only increase insecurity among Hindus, potentially leading to repercussions such as violence and hatred. Continue making Islam progressive. Peace and love to all 🙏🙏🙏.

[@ahmadabdullahnazib1486]

Yes i almost gone crazy.We should take a balance approach with intellectually and historically

[@abdelrahmannur3174]

4:20 mins...u meant Thul-Qarnain... not Suleiman

[@Halal_Dan]

Look how much he doesn't know what he's talking about lol

[@cocoalfaridah5831]

@@Halal_Danall the people I found out say Bukari never meet prophet and he came 300.., and so later and was not arab,, he was old and he was blind too!

[@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411]

​@@cocoalfaridah5831Paul never met Jesus yet you still believe his teachings.

[@cocoalfaridah5831]

@@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 are you serious? Paul was working in gouvernement in the same time jesus was working in the masses, the same period but different sphere! Paul in your Quran ! Verse 36:13 what is your problem with Paul? Go find him in the Quran ask the most trusted scholars.. ⁠if Paul is the false then what he is doing inside you Quran ? Quran 36:13 Ask Ibn Kathir, Ibn Abbas, Al qurtubi, in their tafsir! Check it out I came tell us who is Paul ( bulus)

[@cocoalfaridah5831]

@@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 Muhammad never meet Jesus Paul meet Jesus and know he was in the masse! Quran 36:13 Ask Ibn Kathir alqutubi, ibn abass your scholars….

[@thisnthat6972]

The same way the Quran has been preserved and passed down from memory so have the hadith so you can’t follow one without the order because you will be going against what Allah swt ordered us to do in the Quran atiullah wa ati-ur-rasool. Prophet was ordered to explain the Quran to us so how can we follow him without hadith explain this Shabir ally.

[@savioshajahan4661]

Dajjal may travel in a special jet.

[@Saby217]

I think IF there is a dajjal, he or 'it' is already here and those demons aren't coming from the other side of a physical wall, but from another dimension.. they have been piercing the veil in various ways for some time now and rumour has it, cern has a big role to play in that. 8 wouldn't take any hadith on this topic too seriously. There is,a reason it is not in the Quran. We are not supposed to be future telling in any case, Astaghfurallah.

[@TheTruth-hc7ww]

The Quran gave alot of detail on whom is Lawful for Muhammad to Marry but all to find information about the Dajjal I have to look into Hadiths which can be problematic depending on which Muslim reads them🤷

[@Halal_Dan]

They are only problematic from a western-liberal view, which Shabir starts from for whatever reason

[@hassanabdur-rahman1559]

​@@Halal_Danthey are fabricated and contradict the Quran and logic

[@charlesmuhmanson3928]

Bad hadith, the gift that keeps on giving.

[@naveedkhan8023]

I am sorry your commentary is very confusing 🥵

[@sciencefollower]

DEAR SHABIR ALLY, VERY FIRST QUESTION IS WHAT IS THE PROOF THAT QURAN IS THE MESSAGE FROM ALLAH ... ???

[@Gandaogo]

Any revelation from Allah to the Prophet is in the Quran. Dr. Pls either stay with God or the so called Hadith books. There's no middle line

[@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411]

You're wrong. Not all revelation to prophet Muhammad pbuh is in the Qur'an. For example the Qur'an mentions the changing of the qiblah from Masjid Al-Aqsa to the Masjid Al-Haram. There's no verse instructing Muslims to face the first qiblah. So it's clear that the original instruction of facing the Aqsa Masjid was revealed to prophet Muhammad pbuh but not included in the Qur'an.

[@Gandaogo]

@@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 Quran 6:38 Allah left nothing out my brother.

[@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411]

@@Gandaogo Common Hadith rejector error. That verse isn't taking about the Qur'an. It's about Al-lawh Al-Mahfuuz in which EVERYTHING is recorded.

[@Gandaogo]

@@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 The Quran is the best Hadith as said by God. Allah said it's the only guidance,so pls let me follow what Allah said.

[@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411]

@@Gandaogo you are ignoring the Qur'an commands to obey the Messenger of Allah. You wish to follow your own desires and misrepresent the Qur'an to suit them. You either follow the Messenger of Allah or you're a kafir.

[@Black.Seed.]

What about the Hadiths warning about deviants like you, Shabir?

[@criticalthinker1123]

*He's not a hadith denier, he takes a balanced approach, which make sense for any one studies Hadith that, not all hadith including some deemed as authentic to be reliable 100%*

[@zak992]

He is not a deviant as you say, he is using his God given brain and intellect to question sayings that were written down some two hundred years after our prophet (pbuh ) allegedly uttered them. Think about it if hadith literature were meant to be so important then why did our prophet or his immediate companions not ensure their preservation and accuracy the way they did with the quran, why wait for imam bukhari and muslim to carry out this vital work some two hundred years later. Also dont confuse hadith with sunnah of our prophet pbuh they are different things go do your research brother

[@SuperJijja]

Why didnt Ibrahim(As) "use hus god given brain and intellect" to question god when he saw the dream to sacrifice his son? "we hear and we obey..."(2:285) There is a detailed science behind the preservation and accuracy of hadiths ie chains of narrations, pp lnarrating the hadith etc, categories of hadith etc .. The fact that you think Bukhari and muslims in his time started the works of hadiths 200yrs after the Prophet Muhammad (Pbuh) death shows how much basic knowledge you lack in regards to hadith. There's so many books written before Bukhari was even born ( ie tabi'un(r), tabi tabi'in(r), imam shafi , Ahmad ibn hanbal, imam malik, abdullah ibn Mubarak etc... ) practice what you preach and do your research and educate yourself stop relying on media and Yt for your knowledge.

[@SuperJijja]

​​@@criticalthinker1123don't know why someone studying hadith would even listen to shabir ally of all preachers when its not even his field of expertise. Your basically rejecting wisdom and guidance from the actions and sayings of the prophet Muhammad (Pbuh) by rejecting authentic hadith. Riiiiiiight that sounds like a good thing 🙄 Get help you really need it!!!

[@criticalthinker1123]

brother some hadiths are made weak and authentic in even in modern life day, and this only shows you that, while scholars come up with great methodology to evaluate hadiths, it wasn't perfect as such, if some hadith contradicts or talks about something unacceptable, not sure why i find that to be a problem. @@SuperJijja

[@JohnMoore-jz7be]

Israelites Hebrews they had a sacrificial system and every animal that they sacrificed had religious significance it was ritualistic , mephorical allegorical times and seasons religious order they played their rolls in Judaism there's no problems with their traditions festivities it's all religious beliefs history their traditions festivities plays into their teachings and ministrys their religion is complete mansions in paradise for all eternity biblical promises are for sure complete a new heaven and a new earth

[@semiot8305]

I am a bit confused. Isa bin Maryam is pure (like his mother, sister of Musa), was conceived with the direct intervention of Allah (that called him “his word”), he received the Injil, created a bird, performed countless miracles. Allah protected him from the Jews and raised him to Heaven. Above all, he is the Messiah, the Christ, that will return as king and judge, and will defeat the Antichrist. And yet he is just a messenger. On the other hand we don’t know much about Muhammad from the Quran, not even his name. His was born in a polytheist family. He was a sinner. He didn’t perform miracles and was killed by a Jewess. Now he is dead. What we know about him, was written after centuries, by people who had not known him and whose collections are not protected by Allah. And yet he is more important than Isa.

[@Halal_Dan]

Muhammad is mentioned by name in the Quran, so you're already wrong off the bat. And we know almost the entire life of Muhammad through authentic sources, but we know pretty much nothing about Jesus until his last year on earth. What sins did Muhammad commit? Name some. Muhammad died three years after that Jewish woman poisoned him, the other people who ate the poison died that night. Allah caused Muhammad to die exactly when he was supposed to: after the Quran was complete. Muhammad performed many miracles, and the Quran itself is a miracle and contains miracles. The Sunnah is revelation and is protected by Allah, as evidenced by the strong chains of narration.

[@semiot8305]

@@Halal_Dan “By God, I seek forgiveness from God and repent to Him more than seventy times a day.” (Narrated by Al-Bukhari). Abu Huraira reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “By the One in whose hand is my soul, if you did not sin, Allah would replace you with people who would sin, and they would seek forgiveness from Allah and He would forgive them.” Muhammad is a title. What miracles? Where do your "authentic" sources come from? Allah? Your "authentic" sources say Muhammad was poisoned: From Tabari Volume 8, page 124: The messenger of God said during the illness from which he died - the mother of Bishr had come in to visit him - "Umm Bishr, at this very moment I feel my aorta being severed because of the food I ate with your son at Khaybar." Finally, There is no Yeshua in the Quran. It's Isa bin Maryam. God did not allow the Holy Name of Jesus Christ to be desecrated in the Quran.

[@godisonegodhaswon5957]

@@semiot8305 1. Linguistically Allah Elahi Eloah Alaha are all linguistic cognates for the one God not "gods" ilah is generic God in Arabic Allah is The One God in Arabic eloh is generic God in Hebrew Elohim is plural so can be used for Gods Eloah or Eloheinu is The One God in Hebrew Hebrew prayers still use Eloheinu e.g. Baruch ata Adonai Eloheinu 2. Aramaic Hebrew Amharic and Arabic are all within the same family Semitic modernly or Afro-Asiatic 3. Factually Prophets such as Joshua Isaiah Elijah all praise YHWH ( btw YaHuWa in Arabic means "Oh He Is" or "Oh He Is the only one who ever was , is , and will ever be." HU and HUWA are referring to the Most High) 4. but what about all the -el prophets names in the Bible? Such as Ezekiel Daniel Ishmael these names praise Eloah or Alaha/Ilahi or Allah s.w.t. 5. Michael Gabriel also the Angels of heaven have -el names only 6. There are at least 72 names of God in Judaism and at least 99 in Islam many are identical Ar Rahman ArRachaman HaShem Hashim El Kodesh Al Quddus Ahad Echad Eloheinu Allah

[@TheTruth-hc7ww]

@@Halal_Dan So where can we find the story of the first revelation in the Quran; I can see Isa story Moses Story Adam story where is Muhammad’s first revelation recorded in the Quran?

[@mohammedafsar2320]

No, you are not confused. You came here to create a doubt. Please have courage to be straight forward instead of starting your sentence saying'I am bit confused' just to sound like how innocent you are. Having said that, Nabi(SAS) never in life disrespected ISA(AS), however he raised his status. This is enough to understand his greatness. You sound like Christian but I am bit confuse is that your religion's name.

[@user-gn1uz5wy6m]

😂

[@catnipenjoyer1]

Sahih al-Bukhari 5639 (momo turned into a garden sprinkler💧👈🏿👳🏿👉🏿💧)

[@thisnthat6972]

This man needs to be stopped ustad Asrar Rashid from United Kingdom Birmingham, please make a refuting video on this we need it please because this is leading the masses the opposite direction to what we know

[@PT-kk8dp]

You don't follow Islam you follow Sunnism i.e. based on alleged sayings from 3rd party sources. Wail all you want to Asrar makes no difference. If any of this dajjal stuff was important I'm sure God would have told us, as is seeing future events which as far as I'm aware only God can see and so hadiths contradict God again by giving you oodles of them.

[@skepticalzostrianos9875]

Bro is asking the guy that drank rat poison as a challenge to christians to refute Dr. Shabir lmaoo

[@JamesSmith-dy4bu]

Bro, you and your ustad Asrar Rashid are so intelligent 😂. You should donate your brain for scientific study so we can learn about genius like you 😂😂

[@thisnthat6972]

@@JamesSmith-dy4bu hey sorry if I rubbed you up the wrong way didn’t mean to

[@PT-kk8dp]

@@skepticalzostrianos9875 I forgot that! Thanks for reminding me. He also looks miserable as hell. If he's a walking talking example of the Muslim benchmark then something clearly isn't working. There was one "debate" he had against another sect fellow (I see it all as hate preaching from within and concerted efforts to destroy the rope of Ummah which brings us to the disgraceful state of affairs today re:poverty and ignorance in contrast to the golden age of real knowledge/sciences) and he sat there (as young man in his 30s or late 40s) holding a stick with both palms resting on top of the stick trying to look like Moses.

[@hamidkaramnia5927]

The whole problematic issues about Hadith is because ahl-Sunnah follow people who are not appointed by Allah. A leader to the ummah has to be infallible and must be appointed by Allah. We must get our Hadith from the right sources which are the Ahlu-Bayt and Allah has appointed them. If you need the proof, I can give it to you. The Hadith from Prophet says: Will you not be pleased that you are to me like Aaron to Moses except there will be no prophet after me. Sahih Muslim, Sahih Bukhari To see what’s the position of Aaron to Mose, we have to look in to the Old Testament. Be sure that the man you choose to be king is the one whom the Lord has chosen. Deuteronomy 17:15 You shall appoint Aaron and his sons to carry out the duties of priesthood; anyone else who tries to do so, shall be put to death. Numbers 3:9,10 You can also look at Numbers 3:38 Leviticus 15:1 Samuel 2:27 Leviticus 8: 1 to 5 Leviticus 10:11 Samuel

[@jj-yi1ne]

ahle hadith does that dummy. not ahlesunnah. stop bringing shia beliefs onto us.

[@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411]

If the Shi'a Imams were ordained by Allah SWT why's there no mention of them in the Qur'an?

[@Halal_Dan]

At 4:20 you prove you don't read the Quran.

[@emin62bek]

He just slipped. He is a human.

[@Halal_Dan]

From Surah Al-Kahf? He should have had that surah memorized a very long time ago at his age! The likes of Shabir are not people who you should take knowledge from. @@emin62bek

[@Dannydreadlord]

Yeah we will leave it at that, i guess this explains why people are leaving this BS in droves.

[@dodom.8741]

dont spread fitna and confustion in the mind of people, delete this video and fear Allah All u need in Islam is just to do the 5 pillers and not commit shirk and give charity and ask Allah for forgiveness