Producer Reacts to Red Velvet "Bad Boy"

In this episode the Producer checks out the repackaged title track "Bad Boy" from Red Velvet!
You can support us by purchasing some of our merch here: teespring.com/stores/formofth...
Help support Form of Therapy by subscribing to us on Patreon! / formoftherapy
Subscribe to Form of Therapy for more future Reaction videos & let us know in the comments down below what else you'd like to see!
#REDVELVET #RED_VELVET #레드벨벳 #BADBOY #THEPERFECTREDVELVET #PERFECTVELVET #PEEKABOO
Follow us & stay up to date
Facebook: / formoftherapy
Twitter: / formoftherapy
Instagram: / formoftherapy
Follow the cast
@formoftherapy

[@formoftherapy]

Hey everyone we want to go to KCON LA this year so PLEASE fill out this survey and SUGGEST US: Form of Therapy for a panel! If you're going you'll have a chance to meet us, and even if you aren't we'd appreciate the support! bit.ly/KCON18PANELS

[@rapmonster1648]

Form of Therapy Who produces, who writes the music for Red Velvet?

[@ashriboydalexa8750]

hi, you said in 0:10 that you will do Perfect Velvet Listening Party but i couldn't find that post. can you post it? thanks

[@autumneagle]

This song SCREAMS Aaliyah to me.

[@kpopscenario1406]

Hiii

[@emid9875]

"I can't believe I went from knowing nothing about red velvet and- oh my GOD JOY HOLY CRAP" same 😂

[@caratswiftie]

moosoobee :3 me too lol

[@Jt46629]

I had the same reactions 😝😝

[@aorieedx2096]

moosoobee :3 me too haha JOY MY SPIRIT ANIMAL

[@ilyuser]

MOOD

[@bluequeen8022]

moosoobee :3 I laugh my ass off

[@---xo3em]

“what is a bias in red velvet” true

[@VeroSim]

Josh Dun yeah, like Whats the point lmao 😂😂

[@patjuice8677]

Yep gave up that bias thing in red velvet

[@patjuice8677]

Francis Sone yep i failed at first it was joy then yeri and then this drop now i cant pick

[@asheallise7367]

for me it was yeri, joy, wendy and now I'm a comitted Irene stan, bitch I have a poster and everything

[@Mogajaee]

I legit haven't been able to decide on a bias since they debuted. Every comeback I have a new bias :')

[@juncity]

"Joy, what happened to you this comeback?" - me and every other Joy stan.

[@yeahitotallyagree.2062]

vminist it’s kind of expected tbh, if you follow her on all of the variety show she’s like the biggest HyunA fan and she literally state that she’s in charge of the sexy concept for Red Velvet. Even with Sungjae she was asking to dance Troublemaker with him, and asking him to take her to the club 😂😂😂

[@emk4147]

She got even more hot that’s what happened😂

[@juncity]

Yeah, I totally agree. I love that she's finally able to show her sexy femme fatale side because honestly I couldn't really the cute concepts on her, and gosh how I miss Sungjoy 😂

[@aorieedx2096]

vminist Yess af she got more sexy omg

[@danichivess]

LOUDERRRRRR

[@diphyi]

SEULGI POPPED ALL THE WAY OFF, A BOP!!!

[@s.o.m3241]

seulgi with the red pants is literally my entire aesthetic

[@mobblemaggotgutter]

Joy just ended everyone... She has evolved so much from Happiness era to Bad Boy era. You can vividly see her growth, her improvement. You're right, at first no one really noticed Joy that much but now so many people are joining the fandom bc of her... I'm so so proud of her. Love her the most

[@bethereorbesquare3416]

Mobble Maggotgutter idk why since day 1 i noticed Joy bcs of her green hair😂😂😂 n her sweet smile in happiness thoo

[@yejimin1863]

I remember how she was hated because she looked healthier than the other members back then. That really made me feel bad as a joy stan. But hey look! Those people who hated her for that? They're now addicted with her.

[@mobblemaggotgutter]

Tippachan Hwang ikr!! But she looked so pretty and fluffy and soft when she was healthier 💚

[@ThatsManar]

Can we point out how confident she became, I can't forget how she was very insecure about her voice and her singing, and I think that affected her behaviors, now that she became more open and confident she shined, her aura is mesmerising, and I'm glad I believed in her since the beginning. Look at her now singing OSTs for dramas, joining masked singer and passing the first round, I'm proud of her improvement:)

[@wowjuswow]

yeah what made me notice red velvet (even though i already knew about them) was joy in that rainbow dress when they were performing Peekaboo. LIKE HOW. how can someone be so gorgeous?!?

[@arcnemo]

I love their Velvet side so much. It truly amazes me how well they can showcase both their 'Red' and 'Velvet' sides, it just shows how well they've matured in the industry yet still be able to stick to their roots and not diverge too much. Side note, looking forward to your reaction for LOONA's newest member, GoWon. Would be nice if you listened to her duet with Chuu featuring Kim Lip as well (See Saw).

[@nataliaseixas2994]

Yōkai Bushido Yes i’m obsessed with one & only!!

[@arcnemo]

I know right, LOONA are simply unique in this industry. The way BBC plays around with music genres and are highly experimental shows how they're going to hit everyone in the face when they fully debut as a twelve-member group.

[@nataliaseixas2994]

Yōkai Bushido yess (again ahaha), the world isn’t prepared for their debut! also it was very cool how they putted a 3d version of the song on the mv

[@kingkrystal6123]

Yesss!!! Love loona stans !! Can't wait for the 12 members to debut . *LOONA WILL BE SNATCHING WIGS* ♡♡

[@kingkrystal6123]

Yōkai Bushido I think BBC did good because it promotes each member individual before all 12 as a group . Each memeber brings in many new stans so I think they are doing well .. im a wjsn stan and looking at bbc with loona I just kind of wished starship did the same with wjsn . I also hope loona will be recognized for their talent and won't be underrated when they debut

[@gwen6937]

Dude Joy had always stood out to me since their debut, like straight away i decided yep shes my bias

[@MegaYujing]

SAME

[@dasbrot7200]

same.

[@nurfarhana8585]

Mee too! She's my first girl crush everr

[@spress15]

I know, anybody who's just now noticing Joy hasn't been paying attention... in the right direction. 💜 She shines in variety shows.

[@smartlikewoah]

THANK YOU! lol Since day 1 she's stood out for me too. A lot of people have been sleeping on her and her visuals. Like some people are really just NOW noticing how beautiful she is 😣

[@aziraphaleluvr]

"I don't like projecting my own agenda onto things, but like this feels inherently very gay-OH MY GOD" MY FAVOURITE PART HAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[@matoolhaq]

You didn’t notice the footsteps effect in chorus? It’s quite jarring at first but it grew on me lol

[@syazwa61]

Muh Iqomatul Haq u should hear the instrumental of bad boy. There's a mam cheering, police siren, heel soumds ant etc

[@jellybaebi]

same, i was hoping it would only be in the music video but it's on the track as well... i guess it grew on me too though

[@losangyolmo19]

haha i love this song but that footsteps effect still hasnt grown on me

[@sharifahnursaadahsyedalwi3171]

Omg at first I thought that my parent's coming to my room. I glanced to my doorstep several times like wattttt.

[@gmarpaung170]

Muh Iqomatul Haq yup, i think i read somewhere, rv girls describe the song about a chic girl chasing a bad boy, and there will be a shoes sound and police sirens on background

[@sushisoon1420]

"thiS feEls inherently vErY gAy" joy & irene scene comes up right after *IS SHOOK*

[@lauraashleythomson3067]

Be careful this song grows on you...the chorus is permanently stuck in my head now...not that I'm complaining haha

[@jychoi5026]

the book seulgi reads is a motif in the whole MV, and the book actually reads "ceci n’est pas de la lèvre" (eng: this isn’t lip). its inspired by René Magritte’s "The Treachery Of Images". so while the lips are represented on the book, but aren’t really lips since it’s only an image of it. i think this gives this an overarching sort of idea that what you see is not what it actually is in this music video.

[@kalebsok2947]

최주영 I love it when SM does this that

[@BeanSprouts02]

Omg then what were they trying to show? I want to understand so bad

[@volterz619]

@@BeanSprouts02 vagina

[@BeanSprouts02]

hili pili 😒

[@volterz619]

@@BeanSprouts02 ahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

[@Ilovecatsgurl]

knew it was gay the first 10 seconds in the video. makes the title 'bad boy' even better lmao I haven't heard a well balanced sexy r&b track in a long time. Red velvet delivered and i'm happy!!!

[@kalebsok2947]

Snow Han isn’t it suppose to be ironic or something like that?

[@maeganvillar7612]

Listen to their b-track cause i did just recently and i instantly downloaded most of their songs 👌🏼

[@anne92mary]

“JOY NOW A DROP DEAD GORGEOUS” i love you for that 😘

[@sukiyumki]

2:14 "Joy oh my god what happened to you in this comeback" sAME

[@jellybaebi]

"this feels inherently very gay" cue the iconic joyrene scene me: manically laughing in my room at 12am something cool in the mv is @ 3:30 when the girls are turning in the choreo and then it changes to a solo shot of yeri turning towards the camera honestly though, dunno if you've seen my comment from your 'diving deeper into red velvet' but i recently checked out red velvet's spotify about page and it blatantly states that they're influenced by en vogue, destiny's child and gwen stefani. I feel this really explains a lot about their music, especially put into perspective with other kpop gg

[@munchingcookies]

"What is a bias in red velvet?"- an intellectual. I love when their Velvet side comes in and absolutely wrecks everyone like yasss look at that versatily from these absolute QUEENS!

[@sonjasun9420]

"Film Noir" exactly!!! It definitely has that vibe, the gun the suitcase and the strong shadow contrast... You are the first KZbinr I saw who pointed out this😄😄

[@ihsantriapramanda1973]

Exactly. I felt this atmosphere when seeing the MV but forgot the word. Film Noir, that's it!

[@lightefilit]

Right after their MV when I first watched it, I went to look for some Noir movies LOL I was slightly disappointed no reactors except him noticed the theme of this MV :(

[@mellojiapsa]

I agree but that air purifier thing at the back caught my eye

[@abbyvachirawit2508]

"What is a bias in Red Velvet" BIHHH !!! THAT IS THE TRUTH !!! IZZ A FACT

[@VaneesBabySteps]

Your reaction to the presence of JOY was so real LOL

[@louisabelle6514]

“Like, what is a bias in Red Velvet?“ - Legit every REVELUV.

[@theodelacruz2799]

From without knowing bout Red Velvet to becoming an official Joy bias, welcome to the Reveluvs PD haha

[@ellieishappy4418]

i got so excited when i got the notification !! i’ve been waiting for you to react to this !!

[@egglumi]

i lOVE HOW U GOT INTO THEM, IM RLLY HAPPY TT

[@schelm9757]

i’m very curious to see what sm will do about their next comeback! i hope they keep the boss ladies vibe.. it’s suits them extremely well

[@LOOKATMYEPICNESS]

ryndomm next comeback will most likely be a red concept comeback for summer

[@thehantus9774]

vA Soapy i wish its is sexy red instead of cute red.

[@nyzae655]

Well the next comeback is literally a “power up”

[@sapphic.flower]

“This was inherently very gay- Oh my god!”

[@dariasolomon8576]

I AM SO HAPPY U DID THIS

[@totally5694]

"this was inherently very gay......" -> 2:48 "oh my gOD!!!" ME! xD

[@KilBlackmagic]

2:52 The timing lol. "This feels inherently gay." * Cuts to Joy and Irene about to kiss*

[@markkostecki4558]

1:37 That camera zoom on Irene is awesome

[@larissaferreira5852]

Joy was GORGEOUS ON THIS COMEBACK HOLLY GOD!! O.O I prefer Peek a Boo actually but I think that they shown that they are mature now..specially Joy. Plexus put out the highlight from the newest SVT album..I wonder what you think about it.. ♡♡ I love your videos

[@sam_sa09]

This wardrobe is really iconic!

[@ashleyhunte]

YES I love your RV reactions

[@jannamarie4681]

yesssss bad boy

[@spress15]

Red Velvet used to be the rookie little sisters within SM groups. They've blossomed. 🌸

[@saltytsukki4232]

RED VELVET MY ONLY QUEENS 👑

[@velvetsquid6114]

Thank you for reacting to this!

[@exo_velvettt]

“I thought joy is the least stood out to me but joy stood out the most “ this me

[@Alexa-cr1vy]

Loved your review ! That’s for all the comments on the cinematography and wardrobe. Def the first things I noticed

[@SappyTedjajuwana]

red velvet evolution is awesome...

[@ninanano]

I'm so happy that they're finally able to be commercially successful with RnB songs because ever since The Velvet and Automatic "flopped" (at least compared to how successful their SM peers are) we haven't really got anything more on the Velvet side because usually their best RnB tracks end up being hidden gems in their albums that the general public doesn't hear (like you didn't until that AMAZING LAST VIDEO OF YOURS, AGAIN, THANK YOU SO MUCH). Until Perfect Velvet, their Red side (the pop side, meaning Velvet is the Hip Hop, RnB, trap side - their name gives them the dual concept) was way more successful so SM obviously paid attention to that the most while giving us a Velvet track here and there. I know the girls and the fans are SUPER HAPPY with this, the aesthetic and fashion compliments them the best, there's the type of dancing that Seulgi likes, Yeri likes RnB, etc. And non-stans FINALLY get to see how damn sexy Joy is. They look SO comfortable they just fit the genre and concept so well and it makes me so happy that they're being successful with it meaning we're only gonna get more of it. And I can't wait to the Perfect Velvet listening party, please make sure you listen to the repackage version! 💓💓💓 thank you so much for giving my girls this attention, your opinion is ALWAYS wanted! 🌹

[@OtheringHeights]

so glad you reacted to this so soon 😍 i feel you so hard on an inability to have a bias here..they all sound, move, and look so effing GOOD!!!

[@esmehoskins4557]

You explained and analyzed this really well I enjoyed listening to you go in depth with this music and video

[@RosiliusC]

YESSS I WAS WAITING FOR THIS!!!!!!!

[@isabellacarrillo3062]

Ever since the mv came out I was waiting for you to react to it, your reactions are so well thought out and actually something I can really listen to and enjoy. All of your videos make my day, week, month. Thank you producer !!

[@starrydaisy]

OMG YAY, I WAS ABT TO SLEEP BUT ITS OKAY

[@cassidyanncherelus3240]

I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS

[@impostoderendadabolsa]

loved your videos!

[@reveluvredvelvet3309]

Loved your reaction that's so true its hard to find a biast in redvelvet they all have strong individual charm mysteriously dark and dangerously beautiful at the same time❤ in love with redvelvet

[@enctinyluv]

love ur explanation on this :)

[@KimKim-bb5hm]

I WAS WAITING FOR THIS REACTION

[@siqishi1662]

Been refreshing my notification page to wait for your reaction video. Tbh I look forward to your review the most on KZbin. Speaking for Bad Boy, I really love the sin city + pulp fiction + kill bill look of it. And the 90s r&b + a little bit of trap is just so refreshing! Seulgi stood out to me the most in the video tho. For me, She pulls off the chic, grownup style of RV the most. And I just can’t even with the bang! Too perfect

[@gabrielamejia688]

First time watching one of your videos, and I absolutely adore your commentary, very concise with your thoughts plus your voice is delightful. Congrats!!! 🤗

[@sonnybflover]

I stan this man! I like his reactions

[@formoftherapy]

Aw shucks

[@dystephiary]

Your RV reactions vids are just too funny haha you're inner fanboy naturally comes out! haha

[@moonjaypark]

That dark aura you were talkin about, I think the right word is alluring bc they are, the song is, and the music video as well

[@dariasolomon8576]

also i like this way more than peekaboo and i really appreciate the fact that they have some form of lgbt representation

[@dariasolomon8576]

DarkbloomTV if you argue that is appropriate then alright

[@dariasolomon8576]

MG Alvarez true, i agree, better said

[@Lualvarez]

yeah, at least it doesn't feel salacious. It's tastefully done.

[@AoiKyuuketsuki]

sis they literally spend the whole song singing about how much they want a bad boy it's more like fanservice pandering to a male fantasy

[@kalebsok2947]

jeremy I thought that was irony lol

[@tigersmiling3915]

Your reaction is amazing! I started to like them more when I got to listen to their actual album..the songs were very good.

[@greek2550]

i love how chill this video is! keep it up man

[@greek2550]

also how you really listen to the music and pay attention to the video details/cinematography. its rare to find a reactor that appreciates that :)

[@umyeahok2097]

You're by far one of my favorite kpop video reactors. You actually comment decent things instead of just saying "oh wooow or yaaaas" You be goin in depthhh. I appreciate ya dude 🙇‍♀️🖤

[@formoftherapy]

I appreciate you too

[@anandaf.8293]

I've been waiting for this! I wanted to hear your thoughts :)

[@Kata_Rin]

Came back to this reaction because I fell in love with the song all over again. This is my favorite release of theirs to date still.

[@sinfall5280]

Yessss! He stans them now! I love Red Velvet

[@amelieborel8270]

This boi is so whipped for joy I love it

[@mlk0-0]

YES THE STYLING AND THE SET YES HOW DOES ONE BREATHE DURING THIS VIDEO. I APPRECIATE THIS ANALYSIS.

[@giovannislasagna]

Nice reaction man!

[@Lualvarez]

I love this music video so much, it's my favorite too!

[@aditidurgapal]

review totally resonated with me. I too had a hard time getting into red velvet till Peek-a-boo despite listening to all their old songs

[@nurulannisaafitri6512]

Yeah, red velvet SLAYED in this music video. I agree they are soo gorgeous. Everything was on point. I'm so in love!!! 💓💯

[@PamelaRubel]

I live for their 90's r&b influenced tracks! I am glad the b side is out of the basement! Automatic and Be Natural also have this style 💗 I am absolutely in love with them

[@anqzvii]

his reaction to joy!! I relate too much

[@sarahjane1011]

indeed. what is a bias in red velvet? you cant choose but love them all

[@cassandra4258]

0:12 perfect red velvet album listening party pleasee!!!! we've been waiting for quite a while

[@judy1519]

that look you gave to the camera after that scene!!! i choked on my drink lmao

[@stickbush3257]

Things in the BadBoy MV that should be talked about more: Yeri’s bun Irene’s pigtails *Seulgi’s pants (they should be the main topic of every conversation)* Irene’s wardrobe 3:44 The hand winding move

[@Pyearrrow]

this video was so goooddddd

[@13carat65]

they look so good!!!

[@JusticeGamingChannel]

...and the song is really good too :P I appreciate your view on the sets, cinematography, etc... but the song is also very very good, and catchy, this starts of 2018 very good, I want to hear the rest of the album, ty for the reaction and review

[@jhundeldador1079]

Who's here after PD's reaction of Psycho?! 😂

[@stanleymaximillian8403]

Meeee. Forgot that he actually said Peek A Boo is still better than Bad Boy here Hahahhaaaaaa

[@disneuf4678]

YOU ALWAYS SAY THINGS AT THE RIGHT TIMING AND ITS AMAZING 😂😂

[@seque8219]

I love your videos by the way! I just wanna ask what that smoke thing behind you is? Also I totally agree with their wardrobe because it's the first thing that I noticed they look AMAZING.

[@purpleyams4ever]

Loved your analysis! Anyone else think this MV felt like a Wong Kar Wai movie? (esp that scene with Seulgi with the money gun). I have this theory...(because I have watched this MV too much) that Yeri is writing the book that Wendy is reading (hence Yeri with the typewriter scenes), and the book that Wendy is reading is a book about badass lesbian assassins.

[@baddad9141]

*PREAAAAAAAACH!!!!!!!!* I been sayin so loud...1) RV is about the b-sides, 2) videography leveled up 100% with Bad Boy, 3) lighting finally makes sense...(instead of the bleeding red wash in Rookie, and the cold blue wash in Peekaboo, and the blank white wash in Red Flavor), and 4) the R&B is blended so nice with their modern take on the 90's. You validate me bro.

[@TheDrumsofDharma]

Your analysis was on point! The video was stunning in every way. "Cinematic" is very appropriate. The clothing and styling is impeccable to say the least--every member looked gorgeous. You were also correct about sensing a maturity. When I was writing about the MV, I said "There's something about a woman with a cash cannon." Red Velvet put out the boss vibe with this release. Great video!

[@bobansak2583]

Luv the "fog effect" from the humidifier!

[@teanykim6106]

I have been waiting for this so you can explain the MV story

[@formoftherapy]

There was a story? I was distracted

[@teanykim6106]

Form of Therapy I didn't know there was a story till i read a comment saying Seulgi is the one who wants to take revenge so i thought you may notice something

[@nurfarhana8585]

Everything you said is on point really.

[@ashineengflame]

PD I am here for you and your reactions!! 😏

[@ffeya]

i’m in love with their velvet side

[@cielodebrum7842]

yay i was waiting for this, this is one of my favorite rv comebacks, i may like it even more than peekaboo. I'm glad you liked this. Also, did you thought irene was wendy at 3:46?? because irene is at the center

[@mincraftsderpina]

you really need to do a the perfect red velvet listening party!! I'd like to think you would love it.

[@mikanlin]

"What is a bias in Red Velvet?" EXACTLY.

[@Mia-nj5dc]

I'm totally here for the girl group 90s R&B vibe! it's way better than the cutesy vibe 😩 I was never able to hop on that train, that's why I like guy groups more ....( Can you tell I'm a YG Stan? lol)

[@syazwa61]

Mia if arent yg's music is more into hiphop, edm and pop? Well i dont know tht much but if u really follow rv they alr done much rnb song in their album. Try listen to this repackaged album, u can hear a lot of rnb and 90's vibe in there

[@rv2616]

Try to listen to their album you will like it for sure :)

[@stevenstevenson6667]

Mia if you like rnb listen to automatic by them too

[@Mia-nj5dc]

steven stevenson666 I'm obsessed with automatic. I stumbled upon it and was like bless their souls for the song lol

[@Mia-nj5dc]

_ trouble yeah YG is everything that you say but they occasionally do R&B and when they do it, they do it so well. I mean every Big Bang R&B song is amazing, well at least in my opinion lol

[@fanzo24]

nice reaction!

[@reveluv_blink_once_army_in5731]

RED VELVET QUEENS👑❤

[@senpailisa5047]

Wendy with PURPLE HAIR IS I DONT HAVE ANY WORDS

[@joytroye2971]

My favourite girl group. 😍😭 Get that love.

[@larakyu2200]

JOYYYYY