Prof Romila Thapar on how History should be approached and the Aryans- Part 5

[@akashzz4347]

When connections truimph merit, Romila becomes a historian

[@ricin_mrt156]

Romila ji you are now history...

[@desigeekchishi]

It all dates back to The British who visited India, got shocked how developed the society and economy was and non existence of poor while there was abundance of poverty back home, so they distorted the actual History with the manifestation of the idea that Aryan Invasion happened , which is now proven to be false and no such archeological evidence exists that would support Aryan invasion and existence of so called aryan civilization. The history books need to be updated in school.

[@dharmashekhar1047]

Romila Thapar should have focussed exclusively on subverting the Muslim mind , Christian mind & leftist mind in India. That would have been her greatest contribution to modern India. She did the reverse. You can subvert an open mind but it would require herculean efforts to subvert a closed mind. This shows who has open mind in India.

[@chandrareddy4392]

Have you read any of the books she has authored

[@dharmashekhar1047]

@@chandrareddy4392 All

[@rajdeepghosh5942]

@@chandrareddy4392 Yes. And also understood her propaganda

[@chandrareddy4392]

@@rajdeepghosh5942 she is not making any propoganda.

[@nathuramgodse2334]

@@chandrareddy4392 she is

[@Mustang-yv9mo]

haha...teesta interviewing romila. this country has a sense of humor.

[@ChanakyanStudent7971]

Very nice Comrade Romila Thapar, +5000 social credit Laal Salam. ^here's your bias in case you forgot, thank me later

[@vermar88]

So Romila Thapar has Honorary doctorates from University of Chicago, University of Oxford, Institut National des Langues et Civilisations Orientales, Paris, University of Edinburgh, the University of Calcutta, University of Hyderabad, Brown University, University of Pretoria. She's an Inaugural holder, Kluge Chair in Countries and Cultures of the South, US Library of Congress; She's the Foreign Honorary Member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences and the Winner, John W Kluge Prize for the Study of Humanity, 2008. And just have a look at the people having a go at her in the cursed comments' section! Hilarious. Naach na jaane, aangan tedha.

[@anonymoussoul8619]

Dear, degrees don't give you character. And her farce has been proved by people who are more qualified in history (and probably degrees too!). Let's talk the facts, and not boast about the degrees.

[@sargonofakkad860]

Just imagine how An archaeologist that has degree from India in archaeology singlehandedly destroyed her on basis of archaeological evidence on the ayodhya issue.. Ever heard about KK muhammad? no? ooh acha talve chaatne ki adat h to romila irfan k hi chaate h abhi tk

[@rajdeepghosh5942]

Even Rahul Gandhi studied Italy and is highly educated. But still everyone calls him "PAPPU" and does not take him seriously. Degrees dosent make u genuine

[@binukj7970]

Being well connected made her capable of accompolishing all this. She is the only 'expert' in ancient indian history who does not know neither Sanskrit nor Pali.She is a propagandist, and her work as a propagandist paid off😂

[@VikPandey]

मनगढंत इतिहास लिखना तो वामपंथियों का विशेषाधिकार हैं।

[@jwngmagoyari7535]

Don't worry we bodo people gonna write you history same as you wrote our history

[@islandsunset]

What did she write?

[@spongebobsp100]

Ghazni never invaded )ndia or the number 77 is in dispute ?

[@mintusaren895]

Song of classical way ,the nature revealed. And the history. Moksha unknown, death might be known.

[@MukeshKumarprotagonist]

This is a great interview series. Learnt so much. Many thanks for uploading this for the benefit of all.

[@ShaileshYadav__]

Second bastard spoted, after "Butt-a" above

[@mayurdead9210]

A clown faced another clown and said everything is a lie to wear a gown.

[@jamesstevenson7725]

You took the words out of my mouth

[@whosright21]

👍

[@nonysing4575]

History is that Romila Thapar will be a history very soon.

[@chandrareddy4392]

You will also become history after sometime

[@tennisonchristopher861]

@@chandrareddy4392 may be earlier than that also. Who knows.

[@user-hx7pd3ys8f]

I love ramila mam

[@arunachalahs8580]

Scholarly explanations, jargons, accolades, awards and international recognitions are fine. But why lies were taught and truth was hidden about Sati system, Tipu sultan's atrocities etc ?

[@mohanamohan8726]

but why do u pretend that n. indian hist is indian hist ?

[@AnirvanRay]

Romila madam, you are history now, in case u didn't know.

[@gtj400]

Man... IT cell bots are everywhere.

[@MrAKshabji]

ईन्होने एक किताब लिखी है अभी 'gazing eastward' buddhist monks and revolutionaries in china

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Karl Marx wrote, "... Arab, Turk, Mongols, barbarian conquers being, who overrun India, soon became Hindoodized when they came into contact with a vastly superior civilization, by the eternal law of history" in "India's First War Of Independence, 1856-58"

[@Yfggghhhhhcdf]

Romila thapar as historian is pathetic ..She never mentioned evidence for her bold assertion in history

[@kps950]

I guess she must have provided the sources and research material in her books which you have read none.

[@sargonofakkad860]

@@kps950 No one is willing to wrap even their kachodis in the papers of the books she has written.

[@rakeshkatarey6067]

@@sargonofakkad860 You are such an ignorant person. You are not even qualified to comment.

[@sargonofakkad860]

@@rakeshkatarey6067 I hv done Mphil in history... you are ignorant because u still couldnt grasp the deep rooted propaganda in their history all these years.. Either ways u seem to be a congressi...

[@jashnchahal7544]

@@sargonofakkad860 shows who’s scared of facing his bias

[@Jannat-io3xe]

Romila the Sanskrit translator as well..

[@binukj7970]

She doesnt know Sanskrit at all😂

[@thetransporter1810]

Understanding is left to every individual, not imposing your ideas to people

[@karankhatri6291]

What happened to this hillele TV?

[@syedsaimashowkat5302]

Very solid personality. Much needed video. Ty👍🏻

[@shiwanibhosale476]

Chutiyaa

[@sargonofakkad860]

@@shiwanibhosale476 Naam dekh le behen uska.. usko romila hi psnd aegi😂

[@anthonymartino1901]

​@@sargonofakkad860 beta most of the marxist are hindus😂

[@goodchannel7416]

Aryan are Indian....no invasion

[@logicalsinner1269]

it is extremely a good series of interview. learned a lot .a great thanks to her

[@infinitewisdom6065]

Two Break-India villains coming together.

[@sudhakarreddy1453]

Commendable argument A rare type of women Wonderful understanding about history and past 🙏🙏

[@ssshammi]

veda came much later than the Bhudha? This lady is complete nonsense. there was an established culture and society. Bhuda himself mentioned several things which were part of hindu ritual. No buddhist text survived. there is documented edivende of hindu ruler ashkoa influenced by Bhudha. She is just trying to prove a non existent story. Bhuda before vedas and arayan before vedas is a joke.

[@alokbejai5250]

can you please tell us where exactly in the video does Prof. Thapar mention that Vedas came later than Buddha??

[@rakeshkatarey6067]

Fabulous series. Must watch for all Indians

[@techintern5566]

Yaa ful leftist movement to crack up india plz listen this evil women

[@cheranjeevijayam8163]

Both are narrative peddlers

[@letkarmadecide]

1:45 onwards, now I understand why RaGa has been saying all that nonsense things...Politics is in your pants, its in your shirts, its in everything.

[@mintusaren895]

Harappa to rg veda. Harappa yet to known but supposed the rg as supreme. Something like gatha mala.gatha mala resembling bengali as well as gatha of persian .mala aloof.i have inculcating the word nisad. One says its CHARIPASH,ANOTHHER SAYS BAYDHA. Question was ,what upanishad aloof the upo? Answer with duo.i an still third person.

[@Sanikumar-sb2cu]

You are absolutely right

[@Kevin-uc3ir]

2 antinationals on our soil

[@kaceobrwa7039]

she is 86, let see how many years she will survive

[@hellbird1381]

so u saying you dont understand and know past yourself..but want us to just believe u and must not listen anyone else ..sorry but with due respect mam u sound fool :)

[@chandrareddy4392]

She has never ask you to believe her blindly. As she herself mansions in the lecture, Hindi history that

[@hellbird1381]

@@chandrareddy4392 so wat..my comment is jus for this video.. in this interview she is fighting to make us believe she is right..and also saying she z not sure about history..we hv full right to question such stupidity :)

[@chandrareddy4392]

@@hellbird1381 as I have mention in my comment, she is not asking you to believe her blindly. believe on the bases of the evidence that are currently available. as a history student, I can say that history is beyond facts as knun of us could exactly comprihend it. but what is needed is to intrepretate things based on the available facts or the evidence.

[@hellbird1381]

@@chandrareddy4392 as i said in my comment..so wat..??..if she say she is not sure and also fight to prove she is right and others r wrong..i hv full right to question her stupidity..and if history is beyond the fact and also based on the available fact😬😬(its ur word😬)..than everyone here has their own available fact😎..n no one need any stupid expert like her :)

[@chandrareddy4392]

every one does not have facts or the evidence for this theory. for example, people who does not have any idea of history of this nation would say that aryans are native to Indians, but they don't show any archaeological or linguistic evidence to substanciate their view point. if you ask the evidence they would show the itihasas and puranas are the evidence. those containes nothing but supernatural stories. but it does not meen to say that the puranas or the itihasas have no value in turms of history. they will help us to understand the society at that time. no one can believe if some one says that some one has an aeroplaine before right brothers invention. so far, no archaeological excavations substanciated this.

[@akii0077]

She don't have any scientific proof....only chutiyapa

[@snigdhasamal7837]

Excellent lecture mam

[@bijaybasumatary5672]

These two writers thappar and hazarika how they can blame the whole community???How deeply and since how many years back they did research on this BODO community???If these kind of blaming incidents will occur oftenly and If Indian govt. not take any step it is bond that one they some indigenous group of North East India will prefer to go with China.Then it will be harm for Indian Integration and then responsible for this is only this kind of narrow minded writer not the other person.

[@chandrareddy4392]

Can you show me where has she blamed any of the communities that you have mentioned in this video

[@nikitakumari5535]

Abe, romila Shali mugal tere bhatar the kya... Sudhar jaa budhi

[@SwagokuLion]

indians are known to be disrespectful like u

[@sanjaygaikwad6130]

First learn to respect people with wisdom then only you can gain knowledge. Your tone tells that you have acquired only ego.

[@bijubaro1400]

Mem you don't know about history' of BORO people.

[@sunithaacharya4340]

Why is she refusing to give her CV. Is she afraid that everyone will know her history.

[@jyotivyas9286]

Please ladies. . Look . You all have misguided Bhartiya texts and books and Yuva a lot. Gone are The days. Now We Individual will Guide our Own Self. And We .. are done Enough Ishaara by A True Bhartiya Educationist Rishi Shri Rajiv Malhotra.

[@kattarhindu-qb2yt]

The neheru and gandhi chamcha

[@sapuo3359]

always ready to serve their masters across the seas.

[@manushbasu9138]

Her ages happened near about 80/90 Aldo she don't have Good knowledge about History of All Kinds community's of INDIA. Then how can become Writer? That means FAKE Writer. Example She wrote a book (stranger is no more) how can Blaming on a Community? This are called Spoiled heart writer. Love begets Love. So I, requesting to madam P. Thapar to write Like clean mirror. Sorry if will u get injured in heart (Excuse) me.

[@bijaybasumatary5672]

U r absolutely right sir.How a whole community can be a militant?

[@pviveknair]

Holy shit!!! Did she just say that!!! "History is not about the Truth about the past!!". She just lost my respect. History is the Truth about the past to the best of our current knowledge. When the knowledge improves, the History has to reflect that.

[@KushagraNamdev]

She is a distorian not historian

[@ansumamushahary8452]

nonsense

[@SuryaPrakash-tq8po]

Both are anti-nationals. Time waste.

[@roshansingh1623]

Don't fall in Romilla Thappar propoganda

[@logicalsinner1269]

it is extremely a good series of interview. learned a lot .a great thanks to her

[@Mustang-yv9mo]

+Sukanta Dutta great thanks to her? you think shes done a good enough job with our history text books?

[@daisykim23]

what do you mean?