Real Reason One Direction Broke Up

Whether you loved or hated Zayn, Liam, Harry, Louis, and Niall, these sad truths about 1D will definitely shock you...
Nightfam, please visit our humanitarian store! honesty.global/
For business enquiries please email [e-mail]
#ProjectNightfall #onedirection #harrystyles #zayn #liampayne #louistomlinson #niallhoran
FOLLOW US ON OUR SOCIALS:
Facebook
Project Nightfall - / projectnightfall
Project Nightfall Philantrophy - / projectnightfallphilan...
TikTok: / projectnightfall

[@abnormaltitanlol]

I really miss One Direction but I'm happy that they chose the path they find happiness in.

[@sharayugham8858]

Yea but I still wish they were there.

[@mukhtarmustapha3275]

@@sharayugham8858Ik it’s very hard for us to think but we had no choice but to respect their choice and move on because it will only get worse for them if they still stay there.

[@abnormaltitanlol]

@@sharayugham8858 Me too but it was best for them to leave only. Atleast their music is with us :)

[@zabbb_05]

They ain't coming back ever :/

[@zabbb_05]

Always wanted to be in a boyband like 1d lol

[@rinnzu]

Remember, your idols aren't always as glamorising as you expect them to be. The entertainment industry is a very dark and toxic place

[@phobictoeverything]

That's called sacrifice If you wanna achieve success you suffer first

[@assassin8636]

It's not an dark place stop making assumptions man yall keep forgetting pros and cons and this is the music industry not the entertainment industry

[@lemonademakers9873]

ik right? my friends woul worship celebs cuz they're hot and are nice in the interviews, i like that too, about my faves but then again, I wonder if they are just as nice, in their personal life as well

[@42cooly]

@@assassin8636the music industry is very toxic and evil. Just do some research and you’ll see my friend

[@sponish0]

Music is part of the entertainment industry.

[@fernanmontevista204]

Zayn has a lot of courage to quit.It's not easy to do that Especially when you're in the middle of the thing going.

[@fieryarctic8488]

your right man , zayn fr took a good decision

[@junepinedamercado1548]

Beside he his the most talented

[@1989elandy]

He’s still a loser who stopped being relevant 5 years ago

[@marielaita1]

It was actually the easiest decision. And Harry is the best of all of them

[@Film_Stadium]

Zayn made the path for all of them​@@marielaita1

[@lastskittle]

I'm happy you made this video to actually let people why they boys decided to go on their own ways.

[@arianalove.b]

SKITTLE CHAN OH MY GOSH

[@hdajq892ey7]

i-i-is it really you? 🥺👉👈

[@starshineyt]

skittel

[@amrit9480]

Hello

[@5iveshot170]

Happens to all boy bands as they grow up. The Beatles also broke up at a similar age.

[@savya4918]

To be honest, it is not completely one direction's fault. Its mainly the media and the OBSESSIVE fans who pressurized them into being perfect. Some fans (including me) were fine with whatever decision they made. The media really ruined them by putting tags on them and pushing them to create the 'perfect boy band'. They were fine as they were. The media and management really really took a toll on all 5 of them.. 😔☹

[@kookie_809]

Yes so true, people just want them to be prefect and they don't respect their privacy. Like stop. They're humans too. The same is with the K-Pop industry too, fans go way too far. People have done so many things that invade 1D's privacy. I heard that a girl literally went inside a toilet and licked a toilet seat her idol sat on. Girls dressed up as boys to go into a mens washroom for their idols. Camera's in rings given as gifts. Camera's in hotel rooms. People seriously need to learn to respect people's privacy... even mobbing them at the airport and invading their personal space. (btw the examples i gave are of other boy bands, i don't know 1D well enough yet tho the mobbing thing is common for every popular group)

[@tanushree_1d4life13]

@@kookie_809 I'm a directioner , and you're really right. Some fans once hacked the security cameras of an airport to just look at them

[@nowrinjahanmumu4086]

True ,even I feel guilty that when Zayn decided to leave the band I was angry on him and didn't try to understand his situation😢..but now I know it was the right decision and respect that

[@Sparkling_P]

While I can understand where ur coming from. I hope u know that a band entering the music industry especially ones as young and groundbreaking as one direction naturally invites a level of media attention and fan adoration. This attention, when properly managed can actually help push the bands success. When the band gets a lot of attention, it can actually boost their success just like what happened with One Direction.

[@savya4918]

@@Sparkling_P I do agree with you here since these 5 teenagers actually had fame in barely a year It does take time to adjust to fame but they didn't get any time so the pressure and the expectations of people killed the band...

[@Monkeyyy2091]

Being force to do something you don't like feels like torture and guilt

[@debrasnipes7431]

It’s called fulfilling your contract.

[@luvyatubers]

Fans need to understand that they are following characters planned by mgnt as this vid explains. Whitney Houston could not be herself by contract. Don't sign a contract if u don't want to act a script also. Be urself in a local music venue but don't expect to get rich either

[@abhayagarwal5097]

​@@debrasnipes7431fqk that contract and the type of mentality you guys have.

[@vialkitkat5349]

I miss them.. they'll always hold a important place in my heart. Big part of my teen years

[@darkness_sound1]

One Direction found their happiness but left us crying blood

[@NikitaNaidu001]

I was very sad to see the band break but thank you @ProjectNightfall for bringing the reality and problems the boys went through. I hope they're now living the life they dreamt of! ❤❤❤

[@Meera-p3r]

True

[@phobictoeverything]

That's why it's not easy to get fame and money even if you're the best singer

[@CodyMein111]

I miss One Direction but I'm happy that they are going to the path that they can have freedom to express themselves and to be heard!

[@EnergeticSpark63]

hey

[@anuragtumane5227]

One Direction was a popular boy band, but the artists are finally expressing their creative selves freely.

[@dainielleduran]

It's pretty sad that we don't know the full story of 1d, thank you project nightfall for covering this, we really need to know other group/bands story, I hope they are doing fine.

[@juhi3246]

It's soo sad to see that they were suffering like this . And I'm soo glad that they're finally able to make the music they always wanted . I'll always support their solo career and also would like the fans to stop shoving the same question as to when they'll come back again and again

[@GenevieveBarton-ee5ek]

I love both but they should move forward in the solo careers or whatever they choose to do. It's not my decision to make.Its up to them. Don't want to see them mistreated ❤❤❤❤❤

[@FruitManxSmolBean]

I love how he didn't just focus on one member in this video. Since Harry's intense fame most channels usually only focus on him when talking about 1D so its nice to see someone talk about all the boys equally.

[@Chiezah]

Zayn is way more famous tho ryt?

[@mercykachigunda9418]

😂😂😂😂 that's funny

[@fitzchivalryfarseer4835]

@fruitmanzsmolbean leave children alone

[@Chandni7962]

Still my favourite band🥺🥺💞

[@MohamadRaymie]

Exactly what is happening on K-pop industry.

[@JyotiBilwal-tw6cs]

FACTS

[@ShowerLove0]

Difference is that everyone knows about kpop industry toxicity but not one direction😢

[@deliacozo8542]

Yea, but why do kpop fans go in 1D video say about kpop or just simply say 1D werent overworked because kpop was?

[@rogue8903]

K-pop is far worse and more toxic😂.

[@fahmiariefathoni7636]

i love one directions song . i never knew this !! its so messed up! like , they were just teens! i am sad that there wont be 1D songs anymore but its for the better! good thing their ( individual ) songs are still catchy

[@KoyaHarmony17]

Me and my brother were a fan of One Direction, But watching this video, I couldn't say nothing but feel bad for them, It wasn't their fault, it's the fact that it was their management that pressured and they pushed them to be "perfect". But I'm happy that the boys went on to their solo careers, Create their own music, being heard and free, and follow their hearts in the one true direction. And I'm okay with it. Because I'm happy for them.

[@deliacozo8542]

Sorry, the fans didnt do shit, yea someties some push the line, but never pressure them, like Harry performing when he is sick is not our fault, he think he is gonna dissapoint the fans( he isnt tho), is manager and a little bit themselv never the directioners

[@Sanii21]

I was really sad and couldn't find out the reason for them to leave the band but after this video now I feel what happened was right and as long they're happy it's ok even there's no 1D again hope they're going to their own one direction of their life💗

[@pharmaiqeducation3425]

They are just in the right direction in my teenage memories. Maturity is when you see them being happy after departing from the band with a smile.....

[@atasikarati7997]

It has nothing to do with the boys, they were happy but it was always the management who pressured them..... But still they tried their best and they are still the best boy band ever and they wrote amazing songs ❤️

[@debrasnipes7431]

lololol 🙄🤦‍♀️

[@mariaeleonordaras8131]

as a directioner from the very start of their debut I was happy supporting them and I am proud for them. I’m happy for them😊

[@muneebafarrukh7034]

My elder cousins were directioners and we would listen to their music all the time. ID really was the best thing that ever happened in the history of pop music. But sadly, they were just teenagers who didn't know what to do in life yet. They were suffering under the controls of the management, had to be the fakes they were told to be. I'm happy that they went solo and can express themselves freely. I may not be a fan but if I ever met them, I want to give a big hug to each and everyone individually.

[@apaynedances]

i really miss one direction they need to have a reunion and i am pretty sure all of them have said they want a reunion!! i remember i never really new why one direction actually broke up but it was mostly bc of simon cowell 😭😭i miss them

[@dwayne5841]

Pretty sure the chance of one direction coming back would be so low. Even Simon said in his recent interview he doubt it that one direction would ever comeback. But I agree what you just said that 1D members want some reunion too, obviously Liam and Louis, but I think they’re also worried if ever the band will comeback because the traumas and threats that they receive on their management would eventually comeback also🥲

[@apaynedances]

@@dwayne5841 yea i know, but hopefully they do and simon has been like really rude about them, when he didn’t even put them together in the first place, but i still have hopes!!!!!

[@shayspoosay]

ngl the fans were hella toxic cuz they would just hate on whoever the band members decided to date and just make assumptions that were false, the members really suffered in the band 😢

[@assassin8636]

Not really to be honest more like the management

[@ahhwe-any7434]

I think I met them. It actually took me some time later to remembered it happened. I looked them up when I did. & When I found out they weren't these American dudes, I was like hmmm. Well isn't that interesting. Didn't even think about them till waaaay later after that. Like When my younger ex sent me a 1d song. & I laughed on the inside bc I was like wow. This dude really listens to 1d. Heard them at work another time. And I thought the song was so catchy it never left my head & drove me crazy till I could figure out who did it. Finally found out it was by 1d. Can u believe that ex dissing Zack Wylde acted like I'd take it personal if he just kept dissing him?... Him & some other random folks. If I had to sit and think about, I guess I understand what runs through his "holy" head. But from the top of my head it's dumbfound Pikachu face I got nuffin so I'll just laugh it off bc idek wtf. ure getting atOr me attempting the "complexity" is y u so weird for tho bruh. Him going on rants about sports & athletes somexs too. Like? Idgaf?! It just makes me wanna sleep. Also, I do remember that swift song style tho .. just barely. But I'm pretty sure the radio or the internet pieced it together for me bc I honestly had no clue. I just thought it sounded a little fitting at the time. & Yet I don't talk to that guy anymore either. Threw a ring in his face & ish

[@hrts4gyu]

im a directioner and im so thankful you're making this

[@guy608]

Were one of you guys one of the fans that pressured One Direction too much that they started going crazy with each other?

[@kag_17]

@@guy608 what type of a question is that?

[@guy608]

@@kag_17 You see, one reason I think One Direction suddenly started going against each other was because fans pressured them too much that they kept thinking about their fans more than their talent that impresses them. What I’m trying to say is, they might be overwhelmed by some of us fans.

[@deliacozo8542]

@@guy608 We wont want that. For us was normal because we didn't knew but for them it wasnt

[@celesteaylen3701]

samee

[@tanyathecow]

At least they are free from the torture and hope that they are living their best lives🥲

[@taytommohaz317]

Thank you for this night fam ....we still love this guys so much ...louies , Harries , lovers/horandogs , zquads, paynos ..we are them , just more names now...we can see in their music how free they feel now ...and aside all dark sides ...they kept their friendship so close to them ♥️.

[@Cerysjones56]

I really want one direction to have a reunion but if it is t on their own terms and regulations them I don’t want it I don’t want them to be fully controlled like they were back then they’re free of that now and are all on good terms I think which is good for now

[@RubixCubeSolving7]

Don’t be sad they separated, be happy they existed 😊 - a person on earth

[@corpsepixi]

the management they had was hella toxic plus they all have different music styles so they won't go back together 😢

[@HarryGzi]

7:28 he forgot dusk till dawn 😅

[@tanushree_1d4life13]

This is something we directioners have known for long. That's why we are accepting that they won't come back. Because their happiness and mental well being is what matters to us the most

[@jun2pogi466]

Project Night Fall needs more subscribers than 3M, Hes videos are inspiring

[@-THANHAN]

Already

[@arthagaming229]

That's why he has 3.06M subscribers❤

[@hizzhoguuujh]

i didnt realize he had already 3 mil

[@moseslenana65]

They have more than 3 million but I know what you mean

[@Noone_32lwt]

Never been a directioner, but as a fan of Louis, I'm just happy 1D is only a history. 1D is an important step of each boy that cant be skipped. But to be repeated? no. In 1D, they went through trial and errors, what is right and wrong, which choice can be repeated and not. I dont know for the other boys, but for Louis, I'm glad now he perfectly knows what he likes and what he wants to do. He can express his music in the way he loves to listen and to sing, despite being in the lesser popular genre (pop-rock/pop-punk), I can see he's truly enjoying every single bits of the process

[@jacobpakhuongte1466]

I really miss One Direction too but i am so happy that they finally chose to do what they really want to do in their life I hope they are happy now.

[@zaynzaddy9121]

One direction will always be in our heart i know it's hard to accept that they will never come back but it's fine because now they are more happy and healthy and we always support them...💗

[@vocaloid444]

it wasnt embarrasing at all.

[@princessberry98]

I used to be a huge fan of One Direction in my teen years. And honestly, seeing this side of them made me feel really upset for them, and I really am happy that they decided to find their own happiness after the era was over 💕

[@grace81919]

My childhood band..anyway, Agon you need to check out the rock/metal bands. Bands has pretty interesting back stories.

[@AstroWorldObjectCosmos]

This is what happens when you're too famous and successful It's just too much to handle and you become stressed

[@sunflowerstyles7582]

Babies suffered a lot. But yk, in all of these, they ahd eachother, and that's what kept them going.❤️💛🇮🇪💙💚

[@kingchavez420]

I'm so sad 😭😭😭 😭

[@__Liv_Slaysss]

Harry actually looks terrified. I went to see Harry in concert and he looked so much happier than when he was in the band ❤

[@NicNicLovesCats]

Hearing this makes me so sad they were treated like this when they were together as a boy band to make music. I can see why they left the boy band group and also quit making songs together. I wish them the best of luck on their solo career paths.

[@wilcisco1159]

I still hope someday they'll fix their conflicts and organize a reunion world tour that us 1D fans deserve

[@itzmeyumna]

Omg yes

[@javierofficialyt9867]

One d forever

[@HMMSHAUNAK]

Same

[@excripto1]

BTS enters the chat.

[@lost_blaze4725]

@@excripto1 yuck

[@excripto1]

@@lost_blaze4725Be careful BTS army will come after you.

[@Astro_78]

@@excripto1 Bangladesh Toilet Service? 😂

[@teohyangquing5467]

l always thought that One Direction was a couple of teens just making music and having fun, until i watched this video. l truly loved them l didn't know that they broke up it just saddens me l really thought they were all happy, Zayn, Liam, Niall, Harry, Louis l love your music is and will always be amazing

[@Maria-268-t3u]

I don't watch one d but I never knew this could be sad and annoying and happy somehow

[@amisharoy7285]

I am a directioner since 2013, and yeah it really felt sad to see the boys leaving the band one by one and I always wanted them to get back together but I didn't know that how they suffered as I was just a kid then but now I'm a 21yrs now I understand it n I still adore them as my idols but not like when I was a kid or teen I respect there solo careers and I listen the 1d trances as well as theirs solo many of my directioner friends claims that they left the Fandom coz they understood that 1d won't be back but they understand the fact and here I saw this video it is crystal clear here Thank you so much for this content ♡

[@jaydingunn]

I'm sad they're broken up but I'm also happy that the boys have found themselves. :)

[@kyouhate9453]

They have solo careers.

[@gullulikesboba]

glad to see that zayn seems to be much happier now. 1d

[@night2fransic]

Unfortunately this is one piece the dark side of the music industry we've never heard.

[@assassin8636]

Maybe we don't need to know about the dark side all the time

[@aryanipurnaningrahmawati5333]

I'm happtvthey have their own star and comfy place ❤

[@Fookingavocadoss]

It was their management who treated like shittt... traumatized those kids..made them overwork.mafia of industry simon...idk how these boys even survived.. I'm so happy for them that they're now atleast enjoying their life

[@christabel3626]

I know im two months late but as a directioner i think its safe to say we all knew what was truly going on behind the scenes eventhough we didnt know everything. We knew that they were overworked to the point of pure tiredness and exhaustion and that their management treated them horribally hence the reason why we were so strong and supported them thorought the entire journey. The fandom also saw problems and tried our hardest to fix what we could which hopefully helped.

[@nowrinjahanmumu4086]

In 2023 I still miss one direction...if going solo makes them happy then it's makes me happy as well,cz your happiness comes first for me..Hope you guys get all the happiness in the world❤❤

[@Hufflepuff17Coldplayer]

3:47 Zayn sounds like he's about to cry. What happened to them is great and terrible at the same time 😭

[@deliacozo8542]

I think we all knew but it still painful to see it. I mean they were treated horrible and Zayn leaving helped them

[@krishpeer2188]

Dramatic background sound in his video is making me tensed 😂😂

[@HarshitSharma-ci3rd]

Being a directioner,it always sinks my heart to think that this legendary Group don't exist now and listening to their music is just a different feeling. But we should also acknowledge the freedom they needed,they were artists,not slaves. They are or would be at their best sooner or later. And we ain't gonna stop loving them. One true Direction.♥️

[@YYCFilmer]

Can we all just take a sec to realize the moment the band split up, everyone seemed happier, but ontop of that; They all released a song that blew up just as much as I feel a 1D song would've today, due to their hype probably [by now] would've been dying a SLIGHT bit compared to their peak of 1D.

[@rohanbora3653]

Milions of girls? Also few boys, no hard feelings but the boys will forever remain a part of mine/our childhood.

[@kingchavez420]

I want to cry hearing Zayn

[@MrDirectioner.]

I mean come on,, Imagine being 5 complete strangers,, Being put in a band, for 5 straight years. And they did an tremendous job,, It will obviously bé fkin hectic for them all.. They needed a break so badly.. I respect them👏👏 And im proud to be a directioner

[@amymakesmusic]

this is not just a story about 1d, this is also a story about a lot of other famous bands/artists because this industry is a really difficult place to be in

[@nimetulaps]

i already know this all but dang i wasn't expecting a project nightfall one direction video

[@someonewholovesdog]

Thank you so much for making this video. After watching this video, I completely understand why they broke up. They were so unfree and totally controlled, and the tensions were so high towards the end. As much as I miss one direction, I will now refrain from begging them to reunite. They seem to be happy in their own career path and that's all really matters. I do hope they still talk to each other and remain friends tho (especially Louis and Harry).

[@angeliquephoebepalad3335]

If they're happy then directioners are happy, whatever decision they make.

[@JosMelodies]

Really Miss them a lot!😕

[@swarangi.m9450]

I really miss 1D but it's just really sad that the one who saved our life were struggling in their own thankfully they all doing good and seems happy in what they are doing

[@lukathelad2811]

When ever someone is in that direction their getting chills. and i'v been in that direction one time.

[@Vecna146]

ZAYN SUFFERED THE MOST JUST BECAUSE OF BEING ASIAN+ MUSLIM ! HE FACED RACISM AND EVERY BAD THINGS THAT ANYONE COULD IMAGINE ! HE'S SO UNDERRATED! BUT I'M DAMN SURE HIS NEW ALBUM(Z4) WILL BREAK THE RECORDS ! AS HE ANNOUNCED THAT NOW HE'S READY FOR TOURS AND I WISH HIS NEW LABEL COMPANY PROMOTE HIS ALBUM AS MUCH AS HE DESERVES! #ZQUAD #FOREVER

[@yourfriend7921]

Thats just how k pop groups are...

[@JyotiBilwal-tw6cs]

Facts

[@s12_20]

I miss them so bad but if they are happy i'm happy.

[@rod_at_adelaide5766]

Yeah all that and I'm sure they would never want to change their lives now that they all have millions of dollars thanks to Simon and their fans and can live any life they want to. It was only a few years of their lives, I bet people who have slogged through twenty or thirty years of their life working a job they hate won't find 1D's experience so bad

[@dchang11]

I remembered 1D's rise, and while the music was great, I wondered how long the stardom would last and when the group would burn out. Some fans cursed at me for saying this. Three album and tour cycles in four years. That's a lot for someone in their early twenties. When Zayn departed, fans were crying on social media, but I saw this as a sign of burnout for the group. The last album felt like completing a contractual obligation with Syco. If 1D broke up before that, Simon's company might've sued them.

[@ligiasoaresrodrigues9685]

My favorite band one Direction n my grand-daughters favorite too, thank you my favorite VODAFONE, for posting this beautiful video. Good memories. Love you always my FAVORITE VODAFONE.

[@vanshumeow]

I love and miss One Direction❤️‍🔥🥺...

[@SuperFlaGal]

How refreshing to finally hear someone speak out on this! These young men were slaves! They paid dearly for the fame. I wish them all the best.

[@emk120]

You did a really good job on this video and I have no doubt that everything that you’re saying is 100% right, but if not for One Direction, these boys would not have any career so for them to complain about it now is a little disingenuousHarry would still be working at a bakery, the other boys would be doing whatever the other boys would have done, and they would be basically unknown. And if that’s what they’re complaining about not being, then that’s completely legit, but they are famous. Harry has an amazing career as does most of the other boys. Harry is actually becoming an actor of all things. to enthusiastically embrace an opportunity, and then later, announce it, it’s just hypocritical.

[@ItseWilbert-y4b]

they deserve better

[@anastasia10017]

if Zayn didnt want it, why did he put himself in the X factor and audition for Simon Cowell in the first place ?

[@raihanavindi9364]

he auditioned to be a singer, a solo, not a part of a boyband.

[@ArmyTiny-nz8od]

My question?? Is Simon is also the reason why Jade from Little Mix leave the group??? Edits: because Little Mix are so close together and their is no other reason why Jade leave.

[@tinayang3845]

Great message, great video, thanks

[@RayMak]

So sad. I thought this only happens in Kpop

[@abhisheklama1393]

It’s been 8 years. Let it go, jeeez

[@bunnylover2221]

Yes they broke up, but I can guarantee you 1D ABSOLUTELY DOES NOT have a dark side.

[@itzlini1152]

I am happy that our 5 boys are doing what they like and whatever makes them happy ❤😊

[@Sanaxc]

For People Who Are Here Under 1hour 👇

[@leightoncatacutan3486]

Project nightfall is the obviously the best youtuber in my list :) keep uploading

[@CalebDumb]

1Direction be going into different directions

[@OscarGarman]

Liam has encouraged more improvement with other band members they're absolutely Beautiful and looking really Young having a speech of dark truth about Zayne leaving the band 😅

[@Exuqa]

Imagine if Ail Koca and Project nightfall collab

[@PyaePhyoHtet350]

SAME GOES FOR KOREAN BANDS TOO!!!! They're treated like a product

[@sarahalmaas665]

Very unpopular opinion..but as a directioner of course I was upset in the beginning but just a bit later I was soooo proud and happy and relieved that they disbanded..They're still brothers and that's all I want for them..to be happy and content in whatever their doing...I will support them in whatever decision they take and that's final! 💚💙🇮🇪💛❤

[@yea8393]

It makes me sad they all broke up especially when 1D is my childhood and I have been listening to their songs even till today. But I'm still happy that they are doing much better now. I hope they will meet each other one day again.

[@itshwhat]

i feel so bad for my boys. they were all too young to be dealing w all the pressure and hatred thrown towards 'em. however, things are better between them now. they seem to be happy doing what they're doing as solo artists

[@clovershop1712]

Project nightfall always succeeds to make my day. his stories r more interesting than any other channel

[@roozen5790]

That's what makes you beautiful!

[@Sleepy_sandy]

The popularity doesn’t matter it what they give us like if the give us a fact or something useful that matters in the heart