Checking in on One Direction

[@zuwildbruda]

check in again brother

[@pomegranate-f2r]

@@Hailurenow you can see what I can seee

[@yz4043]

Ngl this made me laugh 😂 (I'm fucked up)

[@er_cl]

oop

[@protonaccount2811]

Video definitely needs a follow up ASAP

[@ajayyxo]

damn.

[@emmylynnd1429]

This is the worst timing for this to show up on my KZbin recommended but I respect it

[@nvrlndJay]

Right

[@fraaci]

Same

[@Mr.LevelUp.]

Real

[@Lucia-k4n]

same

[@818cookies]

I mean, everyone was recently bashing Liam. So seeing he died is kinda crazy.

[@lissette05]

youtube is sick for recommending this rn.

[@Lucia-k4n]

real 😔

[@LolaLand]

KZbin's algorithms don't work like that, there's not a Wizard of Oz character deciding to recommend videos based on tragedies - the algorithm is simply triggered by people's interest. The algorithm saw a surge in searches and clicks on this video and as a result, it started recommending it more. No evil motivation, the algorithm follows the audience, not the other way around.

[@syonghosh-bhatt.7516]

Not the fault of AlexB though???

[@PincoPallino-zh8wm]

I love yt sense of humor! My kinda humor!

[@linanana2858]

probably every sentence you said about Liam was so on point. humen who radiate negative energy, struggle themselves. I wish the industry wouldn´t have done him so bad. he deserved better and he was better.

[@liste302]

Honestly I think Louis' has one of the most successful solo careers - not commercially, but his personal success is unbeaten. Louis never thought he'd be able to have a solo career, now he is on his second world tour (and unlike other artists, his world tour actually covers the world!) with sold out arenas, he has an insanely dedicated fanbase, has launched his own freaking festival the 3rd or 4th year in a row, released a documentary, launched a clothing line and has incredible merch. He also seems like he has found peace with himself. When I was a directioner, I have always liked Louis the most but he is even more hard working and striving then I have ever expected! as for liam, I think he struggles personally a lot and he is kinda missing the creative determination. The truth also is that even back in the 1d times he was the least popular member. But his career flopped more then I expected, ngl. Zayn had and still has so much freaking potential. He is ambitious and creative, but his disdain towards the music and live industry kinda slowed down his career. However, zayn has mentioned multiple times that he isn't looking for super stardom anyways, so I think similarly to Louis he is successful in his own way

[@ashleyiguess]

Zayn also has really bad anxiety which has stopped him from performing over the years, but he is back and is supposed to be going on tour soon

[@chesun4579]

@@ashleyiguess Zayn is still #2 behind Harry. Louis tours. Niall tours but yet their spotify and album sales does not come close to Zayn. His first album sold over nearly 2 million and Icarus over the years has sold nearly 600,000. That is better than Niall, Liam, and Louis. He has nearly 25m monthly spotify listeners which is more than, Louis, Niall and Liam put together. Being on the top of the charts in 2024 does not mean crap. Taylor was #1 with over 300,000 units sold in her week. The #2 person sold 31,000. #3 sold 27,000 units. Zayn sells because people listen to him and decide to buy and listen. Louis sells out but his sales are low, his music videos has less than 1 million views and his concert videos has less than 5,000 views.

[@ashleyiguess]

@@chesun4579 thanks for the info I guess but that has nothing to do with what I said

[@pennymikk]

@@chesun4579girl literally no one asked

[@FaithStrives]

Mentioning Zayn's success and not talking about*Dusk till Dawn* is a crime! that song slaps so hard it's a huge bop🔥🎉

[@sthefaniapascual924]

Who's here after just found out that Liam died 😢?

[@golden_28]

😞🤚

[@AllBlackAirpods]

Literally watched this the other day and came back

[@AITube2024]

me😔😔

[@adeebakhan799]

I watched this video just yesterday and I feel so bad now that i was agreeing whatever he said about liam😢

[@xfreja]

@@adeebakhan799just bc he’s dead doesn’t mean we all have to just ignore all the shit he’s done

[@lindasweis9733]

It still lives. There are so many fans including me.

[@Debbie-m7f]

Me too❤

[@xx1derqueeniexx]

Same

[@flour5135]

Well most of them live

[@lindasweis9733]

I did not get 575 notifications from the likes. Only like 3. Yt doesn't wanna make me suffer. Edit: nvm it went from 575 to 614 in one day. Nvm 864. Calm down people Edit: 889. Ummm. No words just um

[@BlueberrySummertime]

It will ALWAYS live on

[@sainz5581]

watching everyone fall in love with Louis is so pleasing to see

[@DirectionOne282]

For real I love him sm

[@sainz5581]

@@DirectionOne282 ussss

[@ele9875]

I have always wondered how could you not?! Lol like man could not be more likeable he is just a bright bubbly cutie who just writes his incredibly vulnerable songs and makes people safe and understood ❤ he has and will always be my favorite

[@sailorgoon805]

:i'm chewing

[@lorashukuryan4121]

I'm not in love with Louis, I love Harry 😅 Period.

[@Nowhatsgoingon11222]

I went to see Niall’s concert as well and the vibe was exactly what you described His confidence was on another level

[@2002narrie]

i saw niall at the end of june!!

[@khemwitha_k]

i went to niall’s concert earlier this year too!!!! the same vibe fr

[@Halfblood_Directioner]

I became a Directioner after hiatus, but I know a bunch of Directioners (online) that have been here since 2010

[@mrunmayeedabade8124]

girl sameee omg

[@sailorgoon805]

welcome to the cluuuuuub

[@Halfblood_Directioner]

@@sailorgoon805 Thank youuuu

[@jenni1089]

Sorry friend :(

[@Halfblood_Directioner]

@@jenni1089 Are you talking about what happened to Liam?

[@JohnnyNuelo]

Liam NEEDS to make a crooning album. Frank Sinatra, Paul Anka, Buble, could all be inspirations. His voice suits that genre so well and he could make such good music in that area EDIT: yes I know he can no longer do this and it’s saddening. Plz don’t remind me any more than i have to be 😭😭

[@gigglesmurf2004]

Yes. Liam and Louis were great writing partners in the band but Liam has really struggled since. I think the drawing and other art he’s done have been good for him. He just hasn’t found his place in the world and unfortunately his substance abuse issues that started in the band have been a real challenge since. ❤

[@bluemelody...]

I always thought this! He has a great jazz voice

[@kellydannar2027]

Yes! And his lower register is amazing. He do more with it.

[@pinkballoon8181]

I'm not sure that would be good for Liam, becoming a "crooner" He has the best voice (along with Zayn) and he is great at pop and RnB. If he did Buble' type stuff I think he'd be ridiculed even more. Louis was my favourite in the 1D days but Liam and Niall were close 2nd. I like Harry & Zayn, but just not my faves. Liam was the guy who had the most talent in the beginning, he started the songs on the live shows, he was dependable. I feel bad that he hasn't had more success.

[@A.Adam22]

@@pinkballoon8181Zayn is the best vocalist Liam is never be some vocalist as Zayn.

[@melissaparker915]

I have to admit, I was worried hitting play on this video because I am so protective of Louis. But your first couple words about Louis made my heart so happy. He never gets the credit he deserves, but recently more and more people have started to actually see and hear him and I could not be happier. The man is a shining light for so many of us.

[@veronicavillalobos3661]

That’s the having a 1d gf effect!!! We all love louis ❤

[@harleyquiinnnn]

lmaoo this man just wants views and subs from one direction fans

[@yeehawo7]

​@@harleyquiinnnn brother went to multiple 1d member events, i mean, MAYBE he did just for views, but that would be some dedication if so ☠️

[@xxshadowxx6698]

@@HarshKumar-rf7lushe is beauty and we are world class

[@heyitsmira17]

Honestly his voice was my favorite from 1D days. It has a very endearing tone to it that I found super charming. It was always a treat to find is (unfortunately few) lines in the songs. His Walls album is great.

[@butterfliesandpurplepinkskies]

I CANT BELIEVE HOW FAST I CLICKED WHEN I READ "1D" 🙃

[@haunted.1315]

SAME HERE

[@lindasweis9733]

same!

[@Soccer_fan4ever]

you just read my mind!!!!

[@Halfblood_Directioner]

I made it 💙💚28💚💙

[@1dfandomisalive]

Sameee

[@lastvalentinesx]

might want to check in again..rip liam💔

[@Nowhatsgoingon11222]

Liam’s problem is his awful team that ruined his career No organization, no promo, no guide And the fact that he said they forced him to take pictures naked with a model that sucks He would’ve succeeded if he had a better team and better production

[@Nowhatsgoingon11222]

Strip That Down was written by Ed Sheeran though as well

[@AnnoyedRocket-ep6dn]

Liam Payne strikes like an insecure person to me, mentally he is not doing good. I feel his bandmates becoming more successful than him definitely ate him from inside though he speaks positive of them. Especially since the band was created around him. His mental health definitely reflects his music, his solo music all together doesn't connect well on the personal level, his other bandmates found the genre that suits them but Liam didn't. His music is something that one would play in the club for fun but not the kind of music you would listen to relax and personal. Liam Payne is the one who still talks about the band reunion and stuff a lot, he is still stuck in the past and is unable to move on from his 1D days while Zayn, Harry, Louis and Niall have all move away and created their own identity. Zayn who does barely promotes his music is still very much successful. I think Liam Payne needs to focus on his mental health first and needs people that get honest with him.

[@Myllys2]

Liam is an adult

[@sofypi7493]

Girl no team can save a misogynist man like him, he is just trash get over it

[@thetannaree]

Liam’s problem is Liam…

[@Luke101]

Harry’s glo-up is so huge that I forget sometimes that he was even in One Direction, and I was VERY aware of them. His sound is so unique and each of his albums have been phenomenal. The dude is a born performer

[@sarahr4184]

I was never a 1D fan but I really like his music, especially Harry’s House. He’s reached a whole new audience now.

[@Rico401Prov]

Honestly he sounded good in 1D but none of his solo music is good to me. I promise if any other random singer released his music, it would not be popular. I think you’re more in love with his persona more than his music

[@RAralar]

Same here. I see current Harry as almost a different person as the youngest in 1D

[@SBTCP]

Niall said all of the unreleased one direction songs are unreleased for a reason.

[@kaleiah2800]

we were ROBBED of pick your poison and she got away and where we are and hideaway 😭

[@itspricila]

idc niall we need one direction from the vault

[@randompersontrying9700]

I'm still appaled they gave away "Just can't let her go" to someone random artist, like WHAT.

[@El1society]

@@randompersontrying9700and he’s singing it to his dog 😂

[@Imjustteacup]

The fanfic part was so real and I was literally crying the whole time 😭😭😭 *edit* Ok so seeing this after what happened it really breaks my heart, and hopefully Liam's doing better wherever he is, RIP Liam

[@KissyAdair]

The amount of 1D videos that were done recently us wild in light of recent events. RIP Liam.

[@anjahillenbrand4454]

I think louis has the most personal success. Harry may have the biggest fanbase, but a lot of them are following right now because it's cool. Louis however has a deeply devoted fanbase. He gets to make the music he wants and knows no matter what style he chooses, his fans will rally behind him. He also definitely has the best relationship with his fans, he's just so genuine.

[@Adriana-rf1lp]

Yes, Louis has always been the strongest one. And the management hated him for that. He was the problematic one. And he had such a hard time in life. Nobody wanted him in the industry after 1D. He was really rejected. It was all about Harry (he was also gonna be a movie star🤦🏻‍♀️). And you can't talk about 1D without the word Larry. For real. Huge part of 1D history. PS: Louis wrote saved by a stranger.

[@Adriana-rf1lp]

@@wsh0001 Niall either. It was just about Larry.

[@lorashukuryan4121]

@@Adriana-rf1lpBy saying Larry you mean Louis and Harry or Liam and Harry?

[@Adriana-rf1lp]

@@lorashukuryan4121 Louis and Harry. Big issue in 1D. Lirry is Liam and Harry

[@lorashukuryan4121]

@@Adriana-rf1lp Unpopular and maybe strange fact... I don't like Louis 😂🙈😳 I guess because he's not my type of man... don't beat me))

[@SpringSun-ll5bm]

15:00 Thank you fot being empathetic towards Liam. I always thought the same, we all can judge but only people who had the type of fame 1D had could understand. Now, he is gone and thought everyone hated him

[@Slynnmac]

Empathy where? Lol he said Liam had a glo-down and that his hit song wasn’t good, that it was grocery store music. Very unnecessary comments.

[@jagger5392]

exactly ^ describing his music as soulless, based only on one single?

[@k5935]

@@jagger5392 it's his biggest solo single and it has no lyrical creativity. it wasn't unnecessary to point out the big elephant in the room

[@michaeladkins6]

@@jagger5392 I have to agree with Alex and his record company.. Get Low, For You and Bedroom Floor.

[@taytayslayslayslay]

as a one direction fan who just saw niall in manchester, when we saw harry was in the crowd everyone went CRAZY so yah the one direction fandom is still around

[@majasobiech6913]

It is so sad Liam has not so much great music in his solo catalogue. He has such a great voice, when I listen back to their auditions I think he was the best singer then and now it does not show that much in his solo songs.

[@AnnoyedRocket-ep6dn]

Liam Payne solo music is missing heart and soul, his music is kinda very generic and doesn't connect well at personal level and it doesn't feel like the music have personal touch of Liam. I am not saying all music has to be gloomy but even his fun musics feels like KZbin music. Liam Payne's mentally has not move from 1D and its still yet to find a identity of his own. He needs time to heal, the plastic surgery, the drunk and controversial interviews just shows that needs time to take care of his mental health.

[@majasobiech6913]

@@AnnoyedRocket-ep6dn That's why I hope we will eventually feel better and find his own sound. :)

[@AnnoyedRocket-ep6dn]

@@majasobiech6913 I hope he does, he really needs keep his 1D days behind and start to focus on his music. Such a talented artist shouldn't go wasted he has so much potential.

[@gigglesmurf2004]

His voice is still beautiful. The shows he did during lockdown will always have a special place in my heart. He really did a lot for the fandom during that time. Niall did as well.

[@A.Adam22]

He was never best singer in the group that was Zayn then and it us still Zayn as soloist.

[@shelleynull6532]

I love Harry with my whole heart. I think the thing with him is that he is just so so genuine as a person and as a musician. So so many people can connect with his music

[@julestpwk]

you described him perfectly 👏💗

[@heyitsmira17]

He's the most creative out of the bunch, I feel. Unapologetically himself yet not interested in the whole superstar thing outside of performances. It's nice that he's so low-profile tbh bc when he comes back with an album, I can hear what he has to say more clearly

[@shelleynull6532]

@@heyitsmira17 well I never was a one direction fan because I was way older when that was happening lol I'm 53 now but I got into him at my girlfriends insistence that I give it a shot about two years ago maybe a little more and I adore him

[@merlinsbeard11]

I like his music, not a huge fan though

[@pradagirl777]

Rest in peace Liam Payne🕊️🥺 He will always be my favorite 1D member.💔

[@hrt4auro]

It’s crazy that he is gone

[@Lucia-k4n]

I know, I still can't believe it. 😔❤

[@itsbadvibes6504]

I think Liam's real song was "Weekend" where he talks about always being judged and never getting it right, people misunderstanding him, etc. as "fake" as he was, I don't think people ever really let him speak his mind for him to be authentic, whenever he was, even on Logan's podcast even though he explains himself people just took it the wrong way, he talked about this very thing in the Weekend song he said something along the lines of, "It came out wrong but I meant it right" RIP Liam

[@sohappyicoulddie123]

Teardrops is really good too. I feel like it’s meant for the fans and how he wanted them to love him again💔

[@itsbadvibes6504]

@@sohappyicoulddie123 yeh imma revisit that for sure

[@ChrisCampbellLA]

...obligatory "this got recommended to me after liam died and what do you mean I'm already living through the death of a one direction member" button?

[@deguzmanjacob2781]

Yes but it's still heartbreaking

[@LpsPunkWhore]

This Liam analysis was…. Pretty spot on … rip he really couldn’t find himself

[@kylabenedict7378]

I know we’re all seeing this after Liam’s death, but I think it’s really beautiful the way this guy talks about Liam in this video. Liam got a lot of hate after the podcast with Logan Paul but this guy was actually empathizing with him and saw the signs that Liam wasn’t doing well, unlike a lot of people

[@lisi2315]

The One Direction era and all the stuff they went through was actually so insane looking back. Also, the fandom experience was absolutely batshit crazy 🤣 It's honestly pretty incredible that they all more or less came out of it okay and with successful solo careers across the board. And it makes sense when you think about it that the members who didn't necessarily fit the boyband mould managed to find their niche on their own and are thriving. Meanwhile, the person who did fit the boyband stereotype seems to be struggling by himself and can't really carve out his solo identity. Great analysis Alex! Also, now I really want a video where you go through the 1D lore with your girlfriend 😄 I need to hear her thoughts and I want to know her favourite songs and albums!

[@madisonbusby1457]

This is why I always say that if the boys were ever to reunite I would be happy and supportive of their decision however they don't need it. Most of them have been able to find their individual sound and if they became a band again then I feel like it would hold them back slightly again unless they decided to continue their solo careers on the side but being in One Direction again would be an exhausting job and will be harder to work around everyones schedule. The person that I feel like does need it the most is Liam - he is lost without them. When he released his first album I was surprised because I knew Liam was an amazing song writer. Im pretty sure after Louis he or Niall probably had the next highest amount of writing credits on songs and I was disappointed to see that he released such mediocre music which just felt fake, ungenuine and somewhat artificial like he was trying to be someone else. I mean for literally his whole life he was trying to be someone he was not first the Bieber like hairstyle, then trying to look like harry, then going solo and making music that's also very similar to Justin Bieber - Which is what I think has contributed to his drinking problem because he does it to numb the pain that he doesn't feel like he's good enough to do it on his own. Even though I know if he put his heart to it he could really create some amazing music but instead rather than trying to learn from his mistakes he decides to talk poorly about his former band mates and talking about their personal relationships which are none of his business.

[@Plantlexia]

more or less :(

[@UcheOnuorah-iy7ls]

Just because you don't like Liam's Solo song doesn't mean others don't....his solo songs are my favourite after Niall's.....Rest in peace Liam 🕊️🤍 you deserve so much better than this world gave you 💔

[@kristalmatt6527]

Just how fast the night changes 💔

[@weezer_fan69]

no youtube ….not right now

[@심은비-k9c]

Ive always thought Liam would have been great at theatre/musicals

[@lala_again]

If one direction has no fans left, I am no longer alive 😇

[@markedrecoil4804]

I’m sending love and strength to your gf at this crazy time.. A lot of us lost our patience with Liam in his final days and he was on a bad path. But what he and the boys did to us millions of fans we will never EVER forget. Truly fairytale kind of moments i will always cherish forever in my adult life. RIP Liam

[@Ashley-ve2mt]

Was watching this when my friend texted me that Liam Payne just died. Literally wtf????

[@malejandragil]

same, I'm speechless

[@lindagreens9140]

I'm very protective about Liam Payne because personaly Liam's songs have saved and changed my life.The irony of you talking about Zayn being a dad Liam is an amazing dad too.Had a cover song for 50 shade freed with Rita Ora,had the greatest hit STD.I think you just don't like Payno for whatever reason.Liam has an amazing voice,co-wrote most of the 1D songs and was the Daddy direction yes correct.Liam is way too fine and rich to care if you judge him or not. LP1 for me has amazing songs with many collabos,have you heard of Teardrops a masterpiece song.Liam is kind and spends his time donating to charities too.He has achievements that no offence you can never achieve by sitting down and hating on him. Liam does not deserve a glow down ever,I adore and appreciate Liam and will forever be a Paynette. Love you Liam Payne❤❤ Rest with the Angels.

[@Mia-kq6ml]

niall is the absolute best

[@LauraLozada0327]

Well after watching this in tears for Liam. I have to say that people really need to watch his interview with a Diary of a CEO. That interview will change the perception you have of him. He was sober and doing so well you can see he was having a better time. That interview happened a year before the Logan Paul fiasco so Im not sure what had happened in between with his sobriety. I decided to remember him as the person I saw there. That was him being real about himself not as anything else. He will forever be my favourite 1D member no matter what. And I will miss him forever.

[@Jhanjar12]

The fandom still exists!!

[@keegansult2006]

I saw Niall last month! Wonderful performance.

[@mamapacto]

KZbin knows what it is doing. He just passed. Why this pop up? Also I’m still gonna watch it. 🥲 RIP Liam 🫶🏾🥺 1:15 GIVE THAT WOMAN A HUG.

[@Daniel-m1b1z]

I think the dramatization of Liam's life, even this video, is pretty strange and highlights exactly what’s wrong with society, including what Liam probably listened to but shouldn’t have. The guy was probably worth about 50 million dollars. To put that in perspective, most of us and our parents won’t make 50 million dollars in our entire lifetimes. He did it in five years. So, when exactly was Liam ever "down on his luck" career-wise? He was experimenting and likely taking advice from people with exceptional career records. That’s called being young and trying new things. That’s called actually being an entrepreneur. Not everything is going to be a hit right off the bat. I mean, have you made an album? Imagine making five of them with four other dudes. Now it's time to go make your own. The odds of it being perfect aren’t great, lol. That Logan Paul podcast was pretty innocent in terms of American media culture. He mentioned fighting with the guys he spent five years around in his 20s. Who wouldn’t? I’ve lived with my brother for five years, and it’s not that easy. I can’t imagine adding three other dudes to the mix, with our work and personal lives blending all day. Those guys were working 16-hour days, not just around each other, but also with security and crew. Hearing people say he had a “glow down” is ridiculous. Have some perspective. This guy not only made his family proud, but also provided for them and his friends. He probably employed 100 people at different times, maybe even thousands during the band days. Just think about how many people in his life were probably uplifted. Anyone who worked for him could use that experience to get future opportunities. His family and friends surely benefited as well. And let’s not forget his impact on fans. I’m sure his music literally saved lives, kept people sane, and helped them through depression. They say he donated massive amounts of money to help those in need and was constantly contributing his time and effort to charities. If we want to talk about the more superficial stuff: he has over 40 million social media followers, met the Queen, met anyone he ever wanted to, dated some of the most beautiful women, and traveled the world hundreds of times. From a deep perspective, this guy lived a life similar to Roman emperors and old presidents. This guy has lived 50 lifetimes in 31 years. So let’s chill with these videos that lack perspective and judge people who have achieved what most of us can only dream of. Personally, I could never sit here and judge a 31-year-old man who’s more successful than me, providing for his whole family and probably future generations. I just don’t have it in me. Change the content, dude. Good on you for making stuff and putting it out there. That’s so hard on its own, but be more positive, and the universe will probably reward you for it. Let me end with this. What people often forget is that success isn't just about continuous, unbroken acclaim. It’s about the deeper impacts on people’s lives.... providing for loved ones, having a career that uplifts others, and having personal experiences most can only imagine. Much love. RIP LIAM.

[@felinelover1191]

❤❤❤❤

[@lindagreens9140]

Thanks for reading my thoughts dear,people overlook all the good and success Liam has had for 31yrs and I get pissed LP1 album has amazing songs with amazing collabos people should stop this comparisons coz Liam was a very rich,famous and successful man.Forever a Paynette/Stan Love you Lima Bean❤❤❤ Rest with the Angels baby.

[@yomnaislam948]

zayn was also facing lots of racism he was always being portrayed as the bad boy

[@jessica3218]

Hmm

[@abelladored9830]

KZbin recommended me this video yesterday. And I wasn’t excepting to hear about Liam's passing away the next day

[@Ok_Loren]

I clicked so fast! Thank you for such a great video. I’m so glad you started with Louis & how well written both of his albums are. He’s known for his lyricism & his songs give you a sense of hope. Louis has really grown into his own & is finally making the music he wants to make. He has such a special relationship with his fans & he knows we are there to support him 💯. I’m so glad you were able to experience that at his concert. As for the One Direction fandom as a whole, I think the band & it’s fandom are unlike other boy bands as you said. Despite its hiatus, their fans are still very active & continue to grow in numbers. A lot of ppl, including me, found them during lockdown. Directioners welcomed us in like family, answering every question with kindness & providing all the background info you could ever imagine of the band’s history. They also support the members in their solo careers, which has contributed a lot to the characteristics of those individual fandoms. 💙🩵💙

[@GR4YS0NN]

i think we're all waiting, hoping and praying that Liam finally shows himself and what he's capable of in this new album he's making, as he said he is finally writing for himself and making the kind os music that feels right to him, it was so sad that he had to cancel his LATAM tour due to his medical complications but I'm hoping he'll be back stronger than ever.

[@Sissyphussy]

:( R.I.P

[@GR4YS0NN]

@@athrvv24 don't even get me started on this 😞😭

[@lindagreens9140]

Too bad dear our Payno left forever let's cherish him in our hearts.

[@PP-qq5zb]

Liam was undoubtedly integral to the formation and beginnings of 1D

[@shellieeyre8758]

well they all were.

[@carrie3952]

I think that it has been made clear over the past few days that the directioners are still going strong ❤ seeing everyone come together after this horrific event has made my heart so happy. Rest in peace Liam, you will be missed by all of us 💔🕊️

[@srikothur2845]

Liam was the quintessential boy band figure who had to sing leads. Arguably, he came in as the most consistent and strongest singer. The Brian Littrell or JC Chasez of the group. Ironically, both also were some of the earliest in their respective bands to get songwriting credits. And neither could not find solo stature.

[@kelsgm19]

so I watched this video a few days ago... and I was totally agreeing with everything being said about Liam, and now I find myself feeling so guilty. At the end of the day, it feels like Liam was misguided, and he sadly got into the trap that so many celebrities, especially those who see fame at a young age, lean into. this could have been different. it''s tragic to see how this all ended, but all I can think now is how we can prevent situations like this happening again. the music industry needs to change, but so does the fan-artist relationship and how we perceive celebrities.

[@diamel7647]

We should stop feeling guilty for what happened to liam, as you said, it was because of the music industry, and we can't do much about it. For years we asked and begged for a better treatment for one direction, but sadly, they only cared about the money. And time ago liam mentioned how his drinking problems started because of the poor management they had...

[@diamel7647]

Hola

[@Lilo_1108]

I saw Louis last Saturday. It was incredible🫶🏻😭

[@MrBassrazz]

I’m 20 years older than 1D’s fan base but truly love their music. Not really understanding the history of the group, the recent tragic event has lead me into a rabbit hole on social media to come to some degree of understanding what might produce such overwhelming emotions and pain. This overview of your opinions concerning each of the members has really helped me in my quest. If suicidal issues arise (and I have lost loved ones that deeply affect me…even decades later) in those close to me, I do my best to support them and keep in contact with them constantly. Thanks for your thoughts and insights into a very important, and deeply meaningful topic.😢

[@zahrakh.d1400]

Logan Paul is such a nasty person. always preying on people who are vulnerable and magnifies theirs lowest lows. Truly disgusting.

[@vanibajaj3245]

I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS FOR YEARS

[@maria1036]

i just got recommended this, what horrible timing 😭

[@arseniclawliet751]

same

[@Musiklife.9049]

Liam has come a long way, now he’s sober. Lad has a wicked sense of humour and a bloody incredible voice. I don’t believe he’s found himself yet. The other lads will always support him though. ❤

[@Musiklife.9049]

The funny thing with Harry is….I wonder if he’s happy. I think they’ve all struggled with finding partners…except Niall. Harry is where I think he always wanted to be, a famous entertainer, but is he enjoying it. The happiest I’ve seen him in pics was when he went to Niall’s concert with his Mum!

[@lorrainewaite1449]

​@@Musiklife.9049 Harry is happy with how is career is going . l would say it is the fact that he has had deal with all these larries & zarry rumours , and the way some fans treat his girlfriends really badly , the hate they receive, and getting photograph everywhere he goes. Harry has always been a private person, doesn't mean he isn't happy .

[@Musiklife.9049]

@@lorrainewaite1449 ok, there are many artists that make it work…just my opinion. Funnily enough, the Larry thing he seems to handle well. Louis, on the other hand, I think bothers him more. He has denied it numerous times.

[@Daphxxne]

@@Musiklife.9049 he never actually denied it.

[@Musiklife.9049]

@@Daphxxne are you talking about Harry or Louis? Louis has come out on numerous occasions and tried to dispel Larry rumours. The latest April 24…just google, there’s many to choose from.

[@watertantrums2000]

Y’all can say all you want about Liam and Lp1 it is a good album. Having almost all the music as radio hits is an artistic choice and somewhat representative of where he was at in life at the time and I could totally see it. It’s a shame it took so long to release and was barely promoted, his team messed it up for some reason. There was nothing wrong with him doing choreographed dancing, they never really danced in 1D so what was wrong with him dancing after the band? Y’all will bully famous people for the most unnecessary things forgetting the impact it can have on these very real people. There are artists making far worse albums but because they have mass followings and somehow winning awards yall will fake-like it just to fit-in. These are the kind of damaging videos that caused his label to drop him in his final days because his “1D audience wouldn’t like his new music.” Meanwhile, most of you making these videos are not even his target audience,just hater’s, hating for content. Liam and Louis poured themselves by writing so much of 1D’s music to make the band what it was only for them to get the short end of the stick since yall care more about looks, who’s doing magazine covers, tv shows and who’s making the gossip news frequently with a high profile date. Besides, the Logan Paul drama etc, in what world did Liam’s music have a glow down? You just simply did not even give the album a listen hence should not be speaking on him. It’s bare minimum to use your platform to spread positivity. If you don’t have anything nice to say, then don’t. You don’t have to make content at someone else’s expense.

[@mr.smart75]

RIP Liam 1993-2024

[@Leo-qw4gh]

Aw man I was just out of my One Direction phase and now you're bringing me right back in. I haven't listened to anyone but Harry in a long time but seeing as you said that some of the albums by the others are good… I'll give it a listen again. Pray I don't fall too deep into that phase again 🙏

[@jamiecastronova8282]

You should check out Zayn's new album Room Under The Stairs. The album has 15 tracks on it. Zayn wrote 12 out of the 15 songs. Zayn also cc-produced the album alongside Dave Cobb. There's also a Z-Side with 5 additional tracks. Zayn also wrote and produced those five tracks.

[@AverageMofo]

8:30 hahaha that is so true. the way you describe Niall's glow-up is PERFECT

[@TheWatcher2.0]

Yes! Was looking for someone who agreed.

[@Noterinxd0nnx]

check again buddy. rest in peace payno!! justice for LJP

[@valerianbowie1099]

Your fandom recruited this almost 40 year old mom about 3 years ago.. I LOVE Harry and obsess over everything as I play catch up learning everything about him and his career. Now you got me loving 1D songs from a decade ago! So.. thanks to each and every one of you! Best fan community ever! We all just want to see Harry happy ❤ Also thank you NPR tiny desk concert and the blue sweater. That was the moment I knew I was hooked forever and that he was truly something special.

[@RAralar]

Same!!! Became a fan of them individually long after the band ended.

[@autumnarends]

absolutely fantastic video. i loved how respectfully and gracefully you spoke about every member, including the,, less respected members. i got goosebumps multiple times & was v emotional. 10/10 video

[@brutanedda3107]

Zayn's probably my favorite. To be honest enough with yourself to leave the band in the peak of success, man, you need sooo much guts. He's a man with integrity, and I respect him even a bit more now that I know he's a huge Yu Gi Oh fan, like man the guy's truly amazing, never does something he doesn't want to do, and someone who chooses passion over industry will always be someone I will respect as an artist. The tragedy after Zayn leaving the band shouldn't be regarded as Zayn's responsibility, but as the band's marketing team condoning and actively inciting parasocial relationship dynamics between the fans and the band to get more money. Retrospectively he didn't do anaything wrong, at all, and today he's genuinely the only guy from the band I would like to hang out with.

[@sully0613]

He plays yugi oh ? My dream man fr

[@Sam.Hendy28]

Niall’s concert was genuinely the best night of my life

[@rileyrenee1172]

THE FANDOM IS ALIVE AND BETTER THAN EVER NOW THAT ZAYN IS BACK

[@thecritterc0ded]

The fandom still lives, I think we've proven that 🩵

[@larissafbraga]

Liam for me has always been such a complete artist but somehow he got lost on the way and followed a style of music that did not value him at its maximum potential. I still can't believe he's gone. Will be always in our hearts ❤️🥀

[@ayaelketabi2264]

the 1d fandom is still alive and growing, I'm a new directioner actually 😂

[@Ghost-1012]

Why was I recommend this on my fyp 😭💀💔 rip Liam:(

[@SebastianPerez-h3m]

It's like he knew what happened💔

[@butterfliesandpurplepinkskies]

can't believe liam passed in my country. still thinking about bear, god bless and protect him during this rough times. im like.... i dissociate, then remember and then i cry on loop. just can't believe it. my soul hurts. rip leeyum, you were and ARE so loved.

[@DeepScreenAnalysis]

The thing is, the most successful member of a band could be the one who outwardly seems to have it all but is privately unhappy. We can’t judge the amount of worldly accomplishments as the reason for a person’s wellbeing.

[@lorainevassallo9651]

I will listen anytime because I'm such a fan rip payno

[@alexandriasiler4387]

It’s odd that I’m seeing this video after learning Liam passed away.

[@gabbyg.b_youtube]

lol i feel like he was always a fan lowkey and just using the girlfriend story as an excuse because he seems to know all the lyrics to even the lesser known songs.

[@mg1romulus]

another video timed in a crazy fashion.

[@pakychachki]

is the youtube algorithm kidding me?

[@reaganfields]

crazy timing for this to be in my recommended

[@issybella66]

I’m surprised that the One Direction fandom is still around because a lot of people left the fandom after they broke up and forgot about the band like I did and I only member I heard about outside of the fandom is Harry

[@Debbie-m7f]

Niall .. Louie and Zayn are doing good!!! Liam not so much

[@Daphxxne]

One Direction has over 40 million monthly listeners on Spotify….the fandom is very much alive haha

[@danielamunozl]

I think Zayn is relevant without even trying. He lives off the grid, getting music out when he wants to, dedicated to his daughter and his chickens, yet he does whatever and people still talk about him. I think 4 of the members are successful, doing exactly what they want and how they want it. As for Liam i don’t think he has found a style. He has a good voice but it’s not memorable and it doesn’t have a personality. With the other 4 guys, their personality shines in their voice, Liam’s voice is too generic imo

[@silverkrieger]

Rest in peace, Liam

[@drdoom1786]

Imagine if Zayn actually tried...

[@carolineduff-riddell8109]

Prophetic and explains a lot.

[@sunflowermyeyes9758]

Also Harry did My Policeman and was so great in it ❤ his albums and live shows are amazing ❤ the best ❤

[@jamiecastronova8282]

Yes, Harry was amazing in 'My Policeman'. Zayn has an animated movie coming out in the US on October 11, 2024, '10 Lives'. He voicing two characters, Kurt and Cameron. Zayn is also the executive music producer overseeing the film's musical creative directions. Zayn also wrote four original tracks for the movie. He sings three out of the four songs. One being a duet with the actress Simone Ashely. I'm so proud of Zayn.

[@Ptenichka]

Really? It was worst I ever seen… he is good singer, but not an actor.

[@homejournalist]

Not a One Direction fan per se, but watched some videos after seeing Simon Cowell's podcast interview. Liam seemed to be the glue of the band while on X-Factor. Not sure they would have made it that far without him. He should consider musical theater. He's the only one who seems to have enough rhythm to sing AND dance.

[@AnnoyedRocket-ep6dn]

He started as the leader, was talented and still talented but as time went by Harry and Zayn surpassed him massively within the band once they all went solo. Zayn, Harry, Louis and Niall all surpassed him in terms of solo success. The rest of boys found their own creativity, own genre and move away form the big 1D shadow. Liam is still stuck in the middle unable to find his identity.

[@dreamchaser7603]

I genuinely think they will come back in a couple of years!! When 2010-s are back in trend the movement will be back!!

[@DingodileinCahoots]

It would be an almost impossible ticket to get. Can you imagine?

[@Debbie-m7f]

I don’t think they will unfortunately. Even though I hope they didn’t lie to us🤨

[@prunswithfoxes]

I don’t think Harry’ll turn back

[@DingodileinCahoots]

I agree, I don’t think Harry would do it. He always says, if there is a time when it would make sense. That time will unfortunately never come.

[@jamiecastronova8282]

​@@DingodileinCahoots Harry will not return, either will Zayn.

[@King_Jonghyun]

youtube recommending this to anyone today is FOUUUL 😭

[@keriiluv]

I truly love Louis so much, his concerts do really have the most amazing vibe and his fans are the best.

[@Dannalasapa]

So unrelated but girl you’re gorgeoussss

[@MirandaC-c2n]

Liam has always been my favourite from One Direction. R.I.P Liam..😔

[@gemmalow6515]

Saying every other member of the band member had a glow up than Liam... Its heartbreaking 💔

[@doa28xx]

we're not dead sir, not yet

[@Ash_tommo]

Louis’ music is definitely the best

[@stephanie-fh2jd]

personally i love liam's music, a lot of his first album was about partying and sex which i agree is not that deep or profound, but the actual melodies and stuff are genuinely so good, plus there are ones like "say it all" and "remember" and the bonus tracks (hurting me, before it ends, etc) that are more about feelings than sex or drinking. also if you look at his "first time" ep and his newest single "teardrops" they also are a lot better lyrically imo 😭i just feel like you should've focused on more than strip that down

[@butdaddyllovezee]

😢 this hits different after Liam’s passing.

[@veeva99]

As someone who started reading fan-fiction as a 13-year-old because of One Direction and 5SOS (and who still reads and now writes fan fiction as a 25-year-old), I can assure you that fanfics aren't just about celebrities and aren't just self-inserts. A lot of them are about movies, shows and books. Though yeah, there is still a lot of Real Person fanfics out there. Anyway, even all these years later, I still listen to 1D and the boys their solo stuff a lot. Louis was my favorite when they were still a boyband, but god has Niall grown on me more once he started releasing solo music. Out of all the members, it is his that I listen to the most.

[@itsmealyssaaa]

liam really was still figuring himself out.. he deserved the time to find it.. it took us years to hear from zayn, for him to heal and look back on his 1d days positively.. liam deserved the same grace