Beethoven - Rondo e capriccio op.129 - Rage over the lost penny

[@JSBach-tk9vr]

Whoo.. Thank God he didn't loose a dollar.

[@FutureAIDev2015]

J. S. Bach We might have had a fourth movement of Moonlight Sonata that was even crazier than No. 3!

[@seDj64]

he might have given you... a run for your money?

[@JSBach-pd4yg]

Wut?

[@wolfgangamadeusmozart2838]

Right.

[@ludwigvanbeethoven5483]

I lost 100 bucks once. I scrapped the piece though I didn’t want future pianists to quit

[@airplane564]

Imagine if Franz Liszt were to lose a penny

[@davidchernyy9026]

45 pages of rage

[@bradleyporter6091]

Beethoven wasn't actually the one who lost the penny, the story tells he saw a man chasing a lost penny down a hill and and thought it would make a good piece. But you're right about the second part lol!

[@mantictac]

Anton Schindler named this piece because of a fit Beethoven had over a penny that later turned out to be in his pocket.

[@mishatrubetskoy4084]

That's how Liebestraum came to be

[@Codmaster4488]

what if mozart lost a penny

[@sergei-prokofiev]

I lost a dollar once, I wrote all the Hungarian rhapsody's that day!

[@aicrim]

But you're rich. I thought you wouldn't care! LOL

[@laggyfilms4768]

Franz Liszt Ah! *Yes*

[@musicalguy9]

All 19 in a day I write 2-3 songs a day

[@davictor24]

Haha, I found Traum

[@daelcarl5204]

Bruh

[@jschmid26]

I guess Beethoven lost his cents of humor there :/

[@ilovemycatrussell9298]

Lol

[@NotMozart1685]

Underrated comment😂😂😂

[@antspiano1378]

I definitely don’t understand this non joke serious thing...

[@internetlunatic2.064]

Why must you-....

[@JoanKSX]

But the composition itself is humourous XD I can't stop smiling all the way I hear this piece for the first time XD I nearly laugh out loud XD

[@Murcielag0scuro]

*Checks wallet* Verdammt. Wo ist mein Groschen?! *Gets feather and ink* *Next Day* Waiter: Sir, you left this penny at the table yesterday. *Writes Ode to Joy*

[@capt.heinrich6945]

Feather and ink*

[@gissanchi7020]

*Random comment reply* Hotel: Trivago

[@capt.heinrich6945]

Ludwig van Beethoven Do this **With two asterisks on both ends of your word/phrase**

[@paula2683]

*verdammt - greetings from Germany! @Dannetic

[@ericdew2021]

Groschen, not "penny"

[@Jimmy-pg7ms]

this is SO INSPIRING WHY AM I WATCHING VIDEOS I SHPULD BE PRACTICING

[@TxRxAxP]

If you're serious about piano, look up hanon virtuoso pdf on google and practice through the whole thing for a year straight. Songs like this will seem easy to you and you can impress all the piano plebs who think anything that is fast is hard. Good luck.

[@harshvardhanpatel7256]

At least you're not watching minecraft tutorials

[@classicalmusiclover4029]

Trap Hanon is useless

[@TechWzBst]

@@classicalmusiclover4029 Why?

[@joemanley8749]

Normal person: drops penny down sewer, shrugs and moves on Beethoven: drops penny, gets mad and stomps on ground, nearly breaks foot, writes 12 page song

[@fangziqing1176]

Joe Manley actually it's 13 pages as i am learning it now...

[@xanthicatd3719]

Piece*

[@Midnight.Rain.747.]

Lol

[@neutronenstern.]

14 pages (in the print i've got)

[@yangerslu6008]

@@fangziqing1176 depends on the print ig and the copyright stuff

[@albanavarro1047]

i've never seen a child playing with such a heart, most of the time they are just machine like, congrats for this bless

[@chriswanjhang6258]

Yes, she really showed passion!

[@Deedo_67]

You don’t know what a musician feels on the inside when they play. I for one don’t make faces or bop around that much when I play, but the music still moves me. Not sure why a Musician has to move around to show passion, or if he/she doesn’t then they don’t care.

[@embux]

She must have lost a penny, so she knows how it feels

[@sir9151]

Like Arima Kousei

[@insearchofpeace2151]

@@embux 🤣🤣

[@PRmoustache88]

Has anybody written "Relief over a Spent Penny"? Because I can relate to that.

[@fluterific00]

Could you do it? :)

[@juniperwoodgreen4090]

Ha ha...

[@PRmoustache88]

Alison Hasselquist No, I am just putting out feelers for raw talent, who want to make a name for themselves. Please ask around.

[@juniperwoodgreen4090]

I'll do it...

[@PRmoustache88]

Juniper Green Thank you!!!

[@kanhaiya91]

It's sorry to see your video with only 37k views, whereas other crap stuff getting millions of views. You deserve much more recognition!! Commendable!

[@kanhaiya91]

*****.. Yes, well said :)

[@roseslink2000]

***** I agree, so very beautiful.

[@limitess9539]

Agreed! I play the piano and this isn't easy at all.

[@pakyukwokalex3683]

The views are ten times more than when you made this comment! Let's congratz Natalie! :)

[@OctaZR1434]

If Beethoven saw your performance, he would accept you as a student🎉🎉🎉

[@ArtVandelay99]

My God how much you must have practiced this to play it this fluently!! All respect for you and best wishes Natalie!

[@noahgisme]

I feel like she sits way too far from the piano, or I just sit really close.

[@soha7617]

I usually sit closer than her, but if I happen to be playing a fast piece, I tend to sit further back. That way, my arms are further forward and therefore easier to move :) That's what I do, but I think most people sit closer than her.

[@Musicrafter12]

+NoahGIsMe Whatever works for her, I don't really care what she does as long as she isn't hurting herself and it sounds good.

[@KenNickels]

+NoahGIsMe I like it that she wears sensible silver shoes.

[@PointyTailofSatan]

+NoahGIsMe Or she could do a Glenn Gould and sit close and practically on the floor. lol

[@jackdenihan5171]

She's just skinny

[@benrubin8624]

how is this even humanly possible? beautifully played

[@kel0326]

Even though the notes might be simple, it's not easy to execute the scalic passages and broken scales/arpeggios at such speed.

[@chriswanjhang6258]

Of course! If you work hard, you will get there! And I agree that this is beautifully played!

[@neutronenstern.]

@@kel0326 these notes aint simple

[@ma_monna1450]

Ikr like really lol

[@cfchh1905]

Extremely gifted girl - she will make her way to the Olymp of pianists, no doubt about that.

[@bedeo10]

ok lol. anyone can play this if they practice

[@cfchh1905]

Thats correct - if anyone means me, I´ll practice for a couple of years and then will see you again here on youtube.

[@EstebanygaboTFM]

+Bede Carrigan anyone can do anything if they practice, but that doesn't mean they're going to do it. Look at her age, stop being jealous because she's already better than you as child.

[@bedeo10]

The idea of giftedness is just s social construct and hence has no real basis for objective evaluation. Phhh stupid human

[@cfchh1905]

So every 11 year old boy or girl could play like this, when giftedness is only a construct and not real?

[@josemiguel95]

Congratulations for your performance. Your rendition is very mature, and demonstrates a very high level of talent and a strong background.

[@josemiguel95]

+Eyob Sisay (Edge) I said "background" meaning a solid technique and hard time of study. Maybe I picked the wrong word, keeping in mind that I am not a native english speaking person.

[@josemiguel95]

hahahahaha Thank you but I don't think so!!

[@jyuubako26]

もし、ベートーベンが貴方の演奏を観たらきっと喜ぶでしょう。素晴らしい。

[@HandattheHelm]

Only twelve years old, and already playing like a professional! I will be very sad if there aren't CDs of you in the future, you're magnificent!

[@jairow__1688]

She have cds now?

[@broadstreet21]

A certificate of deposit? Haha. Compact discs are so yesterday.

[@mayannaise77]

i'm learning this piece at 16, wtf im gonna kms

[@brothercuber3288]

​@@mayannaise77keep myself safe, you mean, right?

[@mayannaise77]

@@brothercuber3288 i was in rage over the lost penny indeed

[@opticalmixing23]

Beethoven needs to chill

[@iranianintelligenceagency9337]

Exactly this guy's raging too hard 😤

[@karimmechken3512]

wtf this is so fast and she's 11!!!! :O

[@karimmechken3512]

stellvia hoenheim ?

[@sethconway6465]

stellvia hoenheim um was that necessary?

[@fernandomarquez8890]

Ladies and gentlemen... we got him!

[@bakuto.1055]

@@fernandomarquez8890 tf

[@ieatbubblegumv6508]

Shes not asian

[@enricgarrigasanchez260]

she is playing with his eyes closed. Is feeling the music at 100%

[@albrechtvonretardenberg188]

Her

[@enricgarrigasanchez260]

@@albrechtvonretardenberg188 sorry i wrote that comment when i was 15 and english is not my first language. I've improved a bit since then, tho😌

[@TheArtofFugue]

@@enricgarrigasanchez260 i’m suprised you answered after 4 years. i’ve gone through like 4 youtube accounts since then 😂

[@quackson4905]

@@TheArtofFugue lol I’m 14 and i have the same account for 6 years

[@lucyscarlet515]

Stop saying anything about talented or shit, it's HARD WORK.

[@HarierSyauqi2503]

Lucy Scarlet why? Becus eventually hardworkers will be talented. U jealous u sont have the same the talent as she does?

[@lynx3791]

M.C. HARIER no, because calling someone talented implies that the talented individual got to their current level with less effort than others

[@HarierSyauqi2503]

idiot? this is a comment section. go back to school and learn some appropriate manners

[@Victor-ji1rz]

Does talent not exist ?

[@prestonjones3319]

Victor Paringaux natural talent exists, but without dedication and hard work which is demonstrated by natalie, you cannot get anywhere. You cannot be dependant on natural "talent". She may be gifted, but she didnt sit down and magically start playing this without practice. I'd bet she has put more effort into anything you've done, and she's eleven.

[@peteroh9319]

Technology is such a marvel. KZbin has brought so many talented musicians into my life that I otherwise never would have known. I grew up in the 70s with a black and white tv with 2 channels. When we changed the channel, we’d have to walk up to the tube tv and push the channel button.

[@sonjamuller2846]

Wunderschön, ich liebe es. Fantastisch gespielt! 🎼🎶👍🤗🥀💛🙋‍♀️

[@hyramesshiramess1035]

BRAVO! Very close to the level achieved by Sokolov and Kissin. Good control of dynamics and the shaping of phrases. I'd love to hear her perform the sonatas Opus 2,#3, Opus 7, Opus 22, or Opus 31, #1. The slow movements would provide the "acid test" needed ti determine the level of ARTISTRY n this highly gifted young player

[@bluetofu24]

my hand cried watching this cuz i can't do that

[@SunnyXD-ys7cg]

Me too

[@viktorijapetrova9127]

Omg especially my left hand, i get exhausted from Chopin waltz. This made my hands hurt just from watching.

[@joshuarosen6242]

Beautifully played. I started the video in the car and I just listened and didn't watch. Once I stopped and saw that it was a child and not a professional adult pianist I was even more impressed. Excellent work.

[@laytonrobinson-x]

I wish i could play this i can play funeral march atleast

[@haddayr]

FINALLY someone playing it at speed! Thank you.

[@philg4116]

What about Sokolov?

[@Gav729]

Guess what happens when he loses a 100 dollars lol

[@unstopology]

I played classical piano when I was a kid but this is amazing. Superb! Most people don't realize how much work this takes.

[@JohnWilliamGibson]

I've heard concert pianists play this... Poorly. For 11 years old she handles the piece like a profession. Not quite up to Jeno Jando's version (which to me us the gold standard for performing Opus129) but this young lady handles it well. Keep up your practicing and work. I hope to hear you on the major concert stages in the future.

[@cyrethkaiton1674]

+Michelle Kai ikr

[@JohnWilliamGibson]

+Michelle Kai I'm sorry, but what country are you from? I was merely expressing my opinion of her performance. She performed the piece remarkably well for one so young, though I did feel she was rushing it a bit. Natalie is a brilliant, up and coming, concert performer. I was only pointing out that she has a ways to go before she reaches the heights she obviously wishes to obtain. In the United States of America, we have the right to express our opinions, informed or not. I was only expressing my opinion. And who setup you up to be the censor of other people's opinions. Personally, I couldn't perform the piece as well as she did, I'm at best a rank amateur. But I can have opinions. Most music critiques are usually the the worst performers,which is why they are critics. Natalie was 11 at the time of this performance. Now that's she's a bit older, I'm sure her pacing is much better now. "Rage" was composed by a 25-26?year old Beethoven. He was 50 when he numbered it.

[@JohnWilliamGibson]

+Michelle Kai one last word, Natalie is brilliant with Chopin, whose work requires great finger work. I've listened to her later work, particularly her competition work. I was so impressed that i wrote to the recording studio Naxos that they should sigh her as soon as possible. So get off your high horse and read what I actually wrote. Young performers need criticisms in order to either grow or slink away in fear. She'll be up there yet. I expect great things from Natalie.

[@TelsMaviston]

What does it mean when I watch this and I keep picturing Tom and Jerry dancing on the keys?

[@FutureAIDev2015]

TelsMaviston You’re recalling the best of your childhood :)

[@fernandawestrup5849]

Look up the cat concerto ahaha

[@Sawdustinthemakeup]

It means you had a really good childhood

[@jackbohannan7149]

Or Buster Keaton running from the Keystone Cops.

[@delroyroberts9192]

Confusion. only Jerry danced on the keys in cat Concerto and Liszt never composed this piece.

[@srothbardt]

Very good indeed! Very clear with plenty of energy! Brava! We’ll be hearing from her soon!

[@RewaVowles]

Light and even touch. The phrasing is well shaped and leads the ear to satisfying cadences.

[@c0nqu3r3rlol]

holy shit

[@squirehaggard4749]

You beat me to it. Wow that's some playing!

[@joseantoniopulido5184]

No conocia esta pieza QUE MARAVILLA, de musica solo podia ser del MAESTRO Beethoven

[@pathorne2]

This is by far the best version of this song I have seen, great interpretation, very very well done, this is my favorite version.

[@TiroLocoKbŕn]

Ver este video es contemplar y escuchar la entrada al paraiso.

[@antonio.scalia]

+Santiago Arce Amo a a esa niña

[@rosaiselabarretomejia]

+Kelipop jaja por fin alguien habla español aquí. Yo igual amo a esa niña. Me encanta escuchar esta canción

[@liebesleid]

esta cancion.. que rayos.. solo me vienen a la mente 2 palabras : enojo y chistoso

[@ashamasha90]

I don't speak your language.. ._.

[@tebooXD]

AshaMashA ! Me too but I can understand you, they are skpeaking about the wonderful that are this piece (that are this piece its good or no?

[@СтасСавенков-з1х]

Умничка! Когда слушал очень смеялся! В нотах и музыке не разбираюсь, но настроение по поводу утерянного гроша великолепно передано! Спасибо за исполнение!

[@edgarallanpoestheblackcat6613]

Mr. Krabs's theme song

[@soundofpast]

0:40 - 0:51 one of the most beautiful passages I know of.

[@bruce8232]

Absolutely. My favorite part of the piece. The change from G to Bb is insanely powerful.

[@viktorijapetrova9127]

Yes the best part of this piece

[@Destroianus]

As a guitar player this sounds like just straight up shredding on a piano (the entire song but this part in particular would sound really cool on electric guitar)

[@soundofpast]

@@Destroianus At its roots, it is Hungarian gypsy music for the violin.

[@אסףשני-ר4ז]

I love how over the course of the piece, he slowly loses his sanity, and becomes more frightening and unstable. It's so awesome. I love this piece

[@fotisargyros]

This girl made me love piano!!!

[@brandonscherrer]

Amazing! Extremely even, fluent. This piece is often one that you controls the pianist, but here, it is evident, that you have a firm grasp on this one. Just exquisite, really! Brandon

[@sophiawang237]

It is actually rage over a lost penny, not rage over the lost penny😂

[@lisa-mariebausch9525]

This is unbeliveable 😱

[@maxwellspiano3580]

How old was she when she played this song?

[@kennywood6434]

Bravo! Exceptional performance. This is NOT an easy piece and you played it incredibly well. All the best to you!

[@pnsmexico]

i heard this for the first time on classical radio today in May 2022. never knew Lugwig VB composed it. Wow, I wonder if he ever found it.

[@MusikschuleClavina]

Every body tells how talented she is (she is making a very good job, sure, no doubt). But also don’t forget the excellent Teacher abviously behold her. Both of them diserve recognition.

[@brunocuriribeiro826]

A mão dela é muito rápida

[@federicopiazza4229]

Great dynamics and very sensible pedaling. Brava!!!!

[@abdamit]

And now compare that to the "masterpieces" of today's mainstream music... fucking kill me

[@StarReel]

Brilliant! Deserves more views.

[@BennoWitter]

Those last two chords where definitely saying “Oh, fuck that penny, I don't care!“.

[@TheFurryOat]

The Gould is strong in this one.

[@lordvivec9896]

I'm glad I'm not the only one who sees it.

[@alanchalloner2473]

What a wonderful thing is the human brain, well some of them! I am utterly enchanted not only by the ability to play this but to actually play it from memory. We have so many good things in this world that ought to be in our attention rather than the negative issues that plague our news and therefore our daily lives.

[@mraowjoyce17]

Great emotion in this piece, and perfect execution of the tempo. I really like how you bring out the left hand from :40-1:10 or so. Again, fantastic job!

[@ebutuoyebutouy]

0:40. 1:10

[@raidgens8839]

Imagine if Liszt lost a penny

[@romagman]

unbelievable ! This girl is Great !

[@johnleung3372]

Perfect performance, I wish I could reach 80% of the speed one day. A comment: the pattern started at 0:18, shall it appear twice as now it seems a few bars were not played? Or are there different versions of score? As it seems Kissin’s version also not played twice.

[@Jimmy-pg7ms]

this song is so fast, its basically one big trill

[@viktorijapetrova9127]

I can play this fast, but i can’t do that for almost 6 minutes like she did. She is amazing. After about 2 minutes my hands will start to hurt allot and i won’t have energy to continue, so I’m not even gonna try learning this piece.

[@BOCELLIRITTER]

Nice job! I think you did hard hard work for this.😃

[@erikdellblad7165]

Achievement is the result of effort and practice. It makes me happy that there are dedicated young people around the world learning this music and keeping it alive. I really wish I'd practiced more at that age...

[@bohong6082]

how old is her? I am actal not a parent okay now for my listing anyway

[@trumpnado]

"Where are my chips and tart, chips and tart, chips and tart?"

[@jillthomas148]

Haha that's hilarious!!

[@ma_monna1450]

?

[@Viktor-bc4gd]

Наташа, отлично сыграно ! ;)

[@barbaraender-jones7821]

This was one of my set pieces when I was 11, before my fingers started going to fast for my brain.

[@MarkHopewell]

Smashing.

[@bzeliotis]

Amazing. Well done!

[@enricozinanni2459]

Ė un piacere ascoltarti. Sei bravissima e precisa nell'esecuzione del brano. Brava, brava, brava!! 💯💯💯💯💯👏👏👏👏👏

[@johnmulholland8015]

I propose this as the international anthem for all matters thrifty and economic.

[@johnmulholland8015]

And for all essential contributors to our well being.

[@JanDeJong-m9i]

Nice her expression and beautiful playing

[@caspiano6277]

This is the only time I watched video that made me laugh and cry at the same time.

[@GlenGarcia1961]

This is my cat's new theme piece. He's two and a half years old and just as rambunctious and manic as this work.

[@mightyirishmen5271]

Glen Garcia umm ok

[@emilywilson-barry1308]

My mouth has been open the whole way through watching this! Just amazing.

[@TERRYBIGGENDEN]

Great stuff! You have energy and a real connection to this charming work! :-)

[@lydiaupsylon6293]

Bravaaa !! Herrlich zu hören und zu sehen, mit welcher Hingabe sie spielt .

[@gregkosinski2303]

sprech englisch.

[@lexsmith8689]

why should she??!! I see absolutely no reason not to use her native language!! I myself am czech just as Natalie is and I could just as well write here in my native language and there´s no way for you to stop me, so why bother tryin´to coerce others to do as you say??! and before you embarrass yourself even more, know, that certain questions need no answer but silent recognition to rectify your error..

[@gregkosinski2303]

so everyone can understand, dummy.

[@lexsmith8689]

silly man!!

[@muscledcowboy]

wie wahr!

[@BOCELLIRITTER]

Amazing! This is so fast it is awesome!

[@chriswanjhang6258]

This is the best version ever!

[@timespaice]

Extremely talented.

[@konahanaa]

I’m very surprised. You rock!

[@goktugblack]

Finally a young pianist who is not from Korea, Japan, China, Vietnam etc. (I dont use the word "Asian" because Asia includes Russia, India, Arabic countries and even Turkey where I am from).

[@themodestai9603]

There is a piano prodigy in India u might wanna check him out

[@nishantsaini579]

@@themodestai9603 who😃

[@viviondioline]

Do you have a problem with non-white piano players

[@philippemeunier8624]

Rapide, très rapide et delicieux, idéal au réveil!

[@ondatrachangchang9200]

Fantastique! IMHO and to my very personal taste, absolutely fantastic rendering. Personally I don't think that Beethoven had in mind to have played this work at the velocity that has been the usual standard since long time ago, which has converted it in a kind of tour de force for virtuosi, but in here Mlle. Schwamova not only gets through that challenge brilliantly, really brilliantly IMHO, but still even much more she, differently from some renowned pianists, keeps, or rescues, or makes present, the spirit of Beethoven's music; with other renderings one could say that it is an étude of Lizt, some renderings make it to sound like another Hungarian Rhapsody, in other cases it is played (too) much in a Mozartian way, but the rendering of Mademoiselle makes me to be hearing, from the beginning to end, Beethoven, Beethoven and nothing else than Beethoven at whichever velocity it is played.I am very thankful, very much so, for having had the chance to listen to this.

[@갱갱-s7s]

Очень круто

[@198001010101cat]

表情を見るに、自分の表現したい音色がすでにイメージとしてある。キーが重たいので、少し指が回らないところが。ちらほら。調律が完璧でないので、音が濁る。さすがに１１歳では弾き切れていない箇所も、でも凄いテクニック。ブラヴァー。

[@edithpiaf9747]

AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@lardyify]

And that was how angry Beethoven got!

[@DougDeBurrooo]

Beautiful, gifted, and hard-working?? We don't have enough young ladies like you in America 😭😭

[@agamaz5650]

well.. america

[@Sawdustinthemakeup]

Um well........we are America what do you expect.......

[@nicolasoloperto2819]

Emily bear..

[@yangjirat6084]

Thailand is less than USA

[@ironman133]

@@yangjirat6084 Nguyen ver damni shremaploja? Xebvi rjotgabol....

[@IvyKao_TPE]

Amazing fingers! It looks like the piano is part of you. Bravo!

[@jumpydashy]

Piano tiles 2 i came here

[@lawrencewei3583]

Rendell Sibal seriously!?

[@Avis_Rara_]

Симпли зе бест.. Мр. Кисин курит...

[@alcidesvilhena2366]

Bravíssimo, Natalie!

[@IMSColoradoSprings]

Kissin is at about the same tempo and maybe just slightly faster. I've taught this piece for several decades and the tempo is fine. It has a wonderful "rage" to it.

[@joshuabradshaw4302]

Amazing

[@juancarlosmaravillacampill3373]

A bueno gracias

[@mightyirishmen5271]

Simply beautiful.

[@Empedoclestintillo]

Soberbia interpretación. Felicitaciones!!! Un sola sugerencia: Beethoven no es Listz. Quizá habría que prestarle mas atención a los "crescendos" et "diminuendos", y romper el "tempo" para hacer la versión más personal. Sugiero prestarle atención a la versión de Wilhelm Kempff. De todos modos me parece una MARAVILLOSA PIANISTA!!!... Y la felicito!!!