Psychiatrist Rebukes Evaluation of Johnny Depp from Amber Heard's Witness Psychiatrist

A psychiatrist on Johnny Depp's team rebuked the evaluation of Depp from Amber Heard's expert psychiatrist. He stated that Heard's expert witness violated the Goldwater rule.
#JohnnyDepp #AmberHeard
Listen to Law&Crime's Sidebar Podcast on Apple & Spotify:
Apple: apple.co/3wMgRgB
Spotify: spoti.fi/3wITe7b
Written Coverage & Analysis of Johnny Depp & Amber Heard Trial:
lawandcrime.com/?s=Johnny+Depp
lawandcrime.com/?s=Amber+Heard
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter! bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletter
Watch Law&Crime Network NOW on KZbinTV!
tv.kzbin.info?...
OTHER WAYS TO WATCH LAW&CRIME NETWORK IN YOUR AREA:
lawandcrime.com/where-to-watch/
READ MORE GREAT ARTICLES FROM LAW&CRIME NETWORK HERE:
lawandcrime.com
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.com/podcasts/
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK KZbin CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Channel B: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel C: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel D / @lawandcrimebodycam

[@teresaalfano3879]

This psychiatrist has such a soft calming voice. I would tell him anything.

[@amethyst1826]

I would just happily sit and listen to him. Lol. He could speak alien, too, as I just like his calm voice!

[@Nicholas_Chen_]

That's a real psychiatrist's voice!

[@mothintofllame]

I would pay any amount of money for him to be my therapist 😭

[@dedekurniasig]

Hahahhaha different with Amber heard the psychit wetness isn't it 🤣😂😂😂

[@G-man45444]

Right ?!!!?!?

[@AJBesh]

Listening to this doctor feels like I just got free session…he is calm and well knowledgeable, someone you could actually trust & open up to and tell him anything

[@beatrizrubio3608]

💟

[@beatrizrubio3608]

I felt the same... so beautiful. Thank you for your comment.

[@Ersonified]

Same. He just have this vibe that makes you tell things.

[@unrelatablecontent629]

I could probably fall asleep to this man's voice tbh

[@B_Bodziak]

Something is wrong with Back to the Future Doc. I hope he's reported to the APA by someone in Virginia. There were several things he said he used that turned out to be completely false information (vomitus, earpiece, comparing JD in commercials and pirates vs testimony) in his evaluation, and when brought to his attention, he didn't seem to care. He definitely should not be an expert witness ever and it should be grounds for an appeal for any case he's testifed in. He does not need to be treating patients if he carries that same attitude into his practice.

[@anna1417]

I loved the way this psychiatrist explained. He knows that those who listen to him are not experts and he finds a way to make his knowledge understandable. The former psychiatrist... A cocky clown.

[@Benjy1]

The Feynman Technique on full display with this guy. Love it

[@gaming1zanagi-1999.]

And reeks of arrogance too that is.

[@davidmackenzie9701]

One advantage that he has is that he sees himself as a teacher, both as he imparts knowledge to his students and colleagues, and to those in his care as patients and families of patients. To do this job, it is important that you have these skills. This testimony is just an extension of these skills. He is much clearer in his testimony.

[@janekitenye399]

I still believe that crazy nutty crown was a patient not a Dr .😁

[@KatJ3st]

totally agree

[@beneustice9328]

Very calculated, and controlled. You can tell he isn't speaking on opinions, but grounded fact, and scientific procedures. What a complete night and day difference from Amber's "expert witness"

[@sharonalo6153]

Exactly! Night and day.

[@MightDie]

Truly!

[@kobakobakoba]

That perfectly describes johnnys entire team. Everything on johnnys team has had concrete evidence. And been nothing but facts. Not bs. Like rottenborn always saying "theres so much evidence" when theres none.

[@PronatorTendon]

It's like night an four days from now

[@JerryMetal]

Lawyer: Can you diagnose a person without speaking to him? This psychiatrist: No. Doc Brown psychiatrist: I'm sorry, sir, but that is not correct, although, under that rubric, you are saying, that all expert witness is being deemed immoral which is clearly not the case!

[@sadaf-ummminahhussain8094]

A professional that actually knows what he’s talking about and not regurgitating what AH’s team would want him to.

[@KingCrimson82]

"knowing what he taking about" in Hivemindtrollish = Serving you with Copium that Johnny is totally normal not on drugs, or if the only person who doesnt have a negative effeckt and never was angry or loud or impaired by substances. Do you people ever hear yourselves?

[@samiam9202]

@@KingCrimson82 what

[@highfiveguy]

@@KingCrimson82 what

[@samsteel4456]

@@KingCrimson82 Wut

[@spaghettienjoyer1304]

@@KingCrimson82 even if Johnny Dept is the one guilty, the entirety of Amber Heard’s argument is very poorly built and jumped to conclusions.I appreciate both that this man did his homework and the incomparable clarity and strength of a cohesive argument. Even if Mr. Dept was guilty, the professional whiteness called in by Heard’s team used an argument that would fall short under any scrutiny.

[@Nicholas_Chen_]

This psychiatrist is a REAL professional unlike yesterday's Dr Smeagol. Really satisfied with how he politely he tears down that crazy Doctor's entire reputation here, all class and no mercy LOL

[@Revan-N7]

Dr Smeagol 😂😂

[@babs420th9]

My vote goes to the woman with photos of her bruised face. Not to the dude who is staring menacingly at witnesses while wearing mafioso rings and a gangster suit. Sorry.

[@yhen2517]

Indeed❤️❤️❤️

[@yhen2517]

Nailed it.....💚💚💚

[@victoriawilliams2786]

@@babs420th9 I challenge you to look up photos of women who have actually been beaten in the face. Then take into account that Johnny always wears rings.

[@74Spyderman]

Whoever’s in charge of finding the expert witnesses for Depp deserves a humongous raise.

[@mikewheeler3994]

I agree

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

That’s what happens when you don’t source your witnesses from a trap house. 😂

[@levisview.5492]

@@LadyAstarionAncunin stop that 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣

[@sharzadangiki1950]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@ms.rachel9071]

@@LadyAstarionAncunin HAHAHAHA NOT the real house!

[@sylvain123]

This psychiatrist is obviously a caring empathic humane person who is in his career for the right reasons. Refreshing after yesterday's bizarre psychiatrist 🙏💖

[@Mysterywhiteboy78]

I think that was an escaped mental patient....

[@lea-anne9133]

He was crazy!!! He needed evaluating!!

[@eggshapedisraelioperative6317]

The difference between these two psychiatrists honestly makes me laugh. It really just makes me laugh. I cannot believe there’s such a dichotomy between them. One comes across as a complete lunatic strung out on coke, and the other is a mild mannered, soft spoken gentleman. Bizarre.

[@deeeaaa]

Similar like amber and johnny, right? 😁😁😁

[@tiffanymari1771]

yeah, right lol

[@jimmyclifff4849]

Probably is on coke. U see his face gestures. True coke head.

[@willspeed6804]

Wasn't the other called Dr Smeagol? Lord of Rings and "Precious" come to mind

[@MrScamexposed]

not coke, the other Dr was just very drunk }}}

[@Alexis-lh1ux]

I feel like he's just given everyone a post-traumatic treatment after Dr. Smeagol yesterday

[@eve6875]

We needed the therapy after that garbage.

[@cozzy9445]

Lol yes!

[@conq3097]

💯😀

[@JustSomeDude2161]

Lmao true.

[@delinawejdeby2043]

Nice one. Completely agree. Dr Smeagol was an absolute nutcase.. the only thing that got us through watching his 'expert opinions' were the facial reactions from Depp's legal team.

[@sethmachetedemeter]

Something I’ve taken note of is how Depp’s witnesses are noticeably well spoken and calm, while Heard’s witnesses are confrontational and aggressive and speak “to the jury” just as Heard did. Something about how well put together Depp’s choice of witnesses and experts tells me how professional he and his team are.

[@BoobooSnafu]

Ive noticed that too. Dont people tend to gather in like mindsets?😏

[@sharonellul7751]

I wonder if Team Heard couldn’t choose from the same quality of experts !

[@darkgamersupreme2348]

@@sharonellul7751 I assume quality experts wouldn't agree to evaluate a defendant they've never actually met in a televised hearing. Just makes them look bad.

[@FakingANerve]

@@sharonellul7751 I think you're onto something. Her team is likely scraping the bottom of the proverbial barrel because nobody with scruples will agree to work with what them.

[@roomeeartsy855]

those are the only 'expert' willing to say what she wants them to say... the real one will not take any risk towards their own career knowing they can't pinned anything on johnny and they should not falsely pinned him on something that he is not. that's ethic.

[@Berze08]

I love how everyone looked genuinely proud of the young lawyer that examined the witness and how happy she looked when she sat down. She did a great job and asked very intelligent and comprehensive questions that were met with equally intelligent and comprehensive answers. True professionals!

[@MrBCRC]

There will be plenty of high fives over that at the end of the day i am sure.

[@lilyluh]

That was cute. And likeable. I feel like AH lawyer only focused on not losing this case in court but totally forget that as it is televised they should also try to win the court of opinions. The perception differences between their experts and those selected by JD team is ridiculous at this point, on both personal and professional levels.

[@stevenlaczko8688]

I KNOW IT WAS SO CUUUUUTE

[@pinakijana9479]

JD's team looks like a loving family tbh! She looked like a proud kid being praised by her parents after a school performance.. so cute

[@CosmicAeon]

yeah at 7:40 you can see them being impressed by her confidence and Johnny saying "very good" in response to his team. Very cute.

[@MB_Ghostie]

And THAT, ladies & gentlemen, is a REAL Doctor and Psychiatrist!

[@ghost7524]

You are so right,. Psychiatrists are actual medical doctors, because they have medical training, so they can prescribe medicine. Psychologists are actual doctors too, just not medical doctors. They don't have medical training and can't prescribe medicine. Because psychologists have more training about the psychology of the mind than psychiatrists, That's why Dr. Shaw stressed that Amber Heard's expert was out of his pay grade when making his opinions.

[@serenajackowski5891]

"He did not have consent," says it all!

[@leo88775]

Dr Smeagol will go down as the absolute worst witness of this whole case, the sheer unprofessionalism and smugness on that deformed hobbit was unbearable.

[@mikewheeler3994]

Deformed hobbit!!! Lol

[@greatestoftheseislove738]

Hilarious 😂

[@clotildadaniels6453]

Is it me or JD’s Witness are literally collected and indeed professional both in speaking and facts of thought

[@katmicah9383]

I know. Thought the same too.

[@JordanDragonAs]

They are very calm and collected

[@marthasalter405]

A few of AH’s witnesses had impressive credentials (like Dr Hughes and Mr Schnell) but their testimony and/or presentation seemed so poor. We’ll see what the jury thinks.

[@glerasaurus7075]

But how did AH team gets their experts and witnesses though? I mean that twitter analyst is decent but other than that it seems they are too aggressive, in denial, biased.. are they already bribed to bias towards amber though?

[@Citizenh4ndy]

@@glerasaurus7075 Craigslist ofcourse

[@mykoniichistorychannel]

Not since Dr. Curry have we seen a proper expert on psychiatric matters. Now we have seen another one.

[@bobk2649]

I think we'll see Dr Curry again tomorrow... and Kate Moss

[@mykoniichistorychannel]

@@bobk2649 One can hope.

[@starrlove2060]

I bet kate can't wait to set this record straight.

[@JordanDragonAs]

@@mykoniichistorychannel no really she is on the list for rebuttal

[@mykoniichistorychannel]

@@JordanDragonAs I can't wait!

[@Nautinthislifetime]

This guy is calm, professional, eloquent and real. Yesterday?? Nutcase! Johnny's team is coming out swinging this week!

[@vanessabee6391]

Totally Agree.......

[@multifandomcraze]

Johnny’s team has been swinging since the beginning, unlike Amber’s team , they actually make sense and aren’t unnecessarily aggressive

[@squeeze1321]

Indeed! Wiped the floor with her witnesses

[@reesedanielsen432]

The defense has no time left

[@michaelcohen9363]

@@paulwaltersheherfeministvl521 You're clearly on the spectrum... get some help bud

[@deneicehunter2704]

Dr. Shaw was very impressive. He explained everything with such clarity. He used examples that were easy for everyone to understand, like the difference between causation and correlation. He was so polite and never condescending. If I were a juror and had to decide who I believed, it would be Dr. Shaw!

[@LonesomeCowgirl]

Exactly! Especially since he also sounded a bit nervous to be there, as opposed to the other one who seemed so full of himself !

[@ghost7524]

It shows how much Dr. Shaw knows his stuff , because causation and correlation is fundamental lower-level topics you learn about in Intro classes.

[@jltgp6703]

I love how Johnny turned around and acknowledged the good work of the blonde lawyer. His whole legal team is nothing short of phenomenal.

[@nicelizabeth8008]

I could listen to this guy all day, his voice is so soothing.

[@rachelkateve1397]

Thats why he is a psychologist. Someone who is there to listen to disturbed people and diagnose. He can talk and ask any type of people questions and they wouldnt fear to give him answers.

[@MrScamexposed]

can't beat a classy English accent over a ugly nasal American voice

[@-danR]

@@rachelkateve1397 He isn't a psychologist. He's a psychiatrist.

[@marianyx1161]

@@rachelkateve1397 psychologists and psychiatrists are different

[@-danR]

So could I, but L&C cut off the cross-examination.

[@catherinehubbard1167]

What a contrast to Spiegel! This man is a healer who wants to do the right thing to help patients.

[@yhen2517]

❤️❤️❤️

[@austinjoliet4412]

His voice, tone, and ability to speak to the common audience about high education topics is impressive. This may be the best court testimony I've ever seen.

[@Succubus_Loli]

The best part is, he doesn't have to be so LOUD.

[@meepengs]

Love how the witness trying to educate all of us how the forensic psychiatrist actually work, not like Dr. Spiegel who tried to intimidated people and kept making groundless diagnosis.

[@Succubus_Loli]

Notice how the other "doctor" speak the loudest too, even when compared to other witnesses because LOUDER SPEAK EQUALS I'M CORRECT.

[@mildredmadoda4224]

Dr spiegel swinging his chair like n excited child answering multiple choice questions!🤨

[@moving.quotes]

He was running round in circles throughout his testimony and was accusing the lawyer of running round in circles smh.

[@chumbawumba5486]

This is a true professional

[@mykoniichistorychannel]

I love his speaking voice. It's very calm and relaxing.

[@lola-sophiedanton5801]

Dr. Shaw was just amazing. Calm, clear, accurate testimony.

[@yhen2517]

Indeed

[@lola-sophiedanton5801]

@@yhen2517 i just loved the way he explained everything. True professional

[@ellex3987]

I love how you can tell he loves what he does for a living. He could go on and on explaining things. I wish I had him as my psychiatrist instead of the one I have now.

[@evangelineeriksson1358]

I wish he was my partner or father!

[@angelabarkley7181]

@@evangelineeriksson1358 I have wondered whether he's married just out of curiosity.

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

@@evangelineeriksson1358 Weird you'd have him as an either/or but okay. 😬

[@thebuttersqiud8912]

@@evangelineeriksson1358 Very Freudian of you

[@annedonnellan6876]

Respec worthy

[@xxassassinxification]

At first I was confused why Johnny's team was letting these clown experts testify. Now I realise it was to publicly embarrass them and expose their complete lack of expertise

[@donajoy50]

In America most psychiatrists just treat symptoms with medication. They do not diagnose professionally. They are lazy and money hungry. And Overstreet with meds. Children especially are not medicated according to weight..

[@Rmomar]

Amber side of witnesses will be devasted to know that she pledged their money rather pay...

[@gardeningisfun1139]

Bhai dr speigel saste nashe karke aa gya tha ab use kahan pata hai ki yeh pledge karegi uska pay 🤣😁🤣

[@amethyst1826]

@@gardeningisfun1139 Google translate appears to be broken.

[@thebestonearth17]

@@amethyst1826 Google translate translates only proper languages. This guy have mixed hindi with english like writing Chinese in English. So it won't translate.

[@harleyb7880]

@@amethyst1826 Yeah it's not working 😂

[@JustSomeDude2161]

🤣

[@Nicholas_Chen_]

Everyone on Depp's team are just class acts LOL compared to Amber's it's night and day!

[@yhen2517]

😂😂😂👏

[@jesusolguin5896]

Correction it's like comparing Depp's bed sheets and Heard's bed sheets

[@turdinabed5106]

Johnny’s Psychiatrist: Credible Professional Amber’s Psychiatrist: Batpoop Crazy

[@jhb1493]

I was very powerfully struck by the way this witness looked at the jury. He looked at them from time to time in a perfectly normal way. After the creepy robotics of Ms. Heard staring at them, normal behaviour really stands out.

[@campbell1446]

He did it the way Dr. Curry did. Answering the attorney, looking at the jury to clarify technical concepts.

[@sarahrose4126]

At least this man is rational ( and knows how to brush his hair ).

[@lifeinuganda1550]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@starrlove2060]

Best comment ever

[@greyngreyer5]

Yes. let's talk about looks again.

[@deedk]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣absolute truth! That was the first thing I noticed about him! What a sloppy looking and acting person.

[@rebeccacastro2525]

That fruit loop looks like the guy from the Back to the Future movie. 😂😂

[@johnnyjames9705]

Yes. This psychiatrist is very objective and grounded. He is easy to trust and understand because he just doesn't blur lines. The guy yesterday sounded like he was amber..he ascribed bad motive and intent o on Mr. Depp. Several times and it was glaring thar he thought Mr. Depp was like American psycho. Maniacal and wildeyes. Lol. It was so over the. Plus. His examples and definitions in general were lame and lacked substance.

[@disct1597]

Yes the guy yesterday got very defensive and arrogant, not usually a great trait of good psychiatrist.

[@lexxs8346]

Yeah the guy yesterday was a total a** 😂

[@quatro286]

The dude from yesterday looks like the type of psychiatrist who takes pills secretly. He sounds like someone who would need mental health assistance.

[@myname9337]

@@quatro286 Many psychiatrist off themselves. You can only imagine what they have heard and what they "take home" from what they hear.

[@narcissisticstatisticmonst4390]

Don't forget that drug lock jaw

[@JorgenPakieto]

I love how this guy explains the further processes that are required to properly evaluate someone. The previous psychologist felt like a guy who makes a diagnoses based on such little information it actually feels absurd that these people have status within the academic community…

[@mildredmadoda4224]

Yes and fir the jury to finally take their own decisions, is like lecturing them

[@connorcavanaugh4109]

He doesn't put on an attitude. He accuses of a peer of wrongdoing with clarity and robust arguments. He's respectful to the trial and his profession.

[@paulanoellez.muller537]

One thing I noticed: he looks at the jury when he explain things, like a professional should do. He knows the jury needs to fully understand the words, the steps, the paths of real psychiatric. Really well done. It's very clear now, I believe, for the jury.

[@truthwillprevail821]

Yes he's looking at the jury but not the way Amber did

[@dnt5volvo]

@@truthwillprevail821 Yes.. now that would be weird.. she overdoes the jury contact because she has been instructed to do so therefore is not genuine in her intent.. just trying to rally support.

[@JL-zn7me]

I’m still in shock over yesterday’s disturbing, appalling “Doctor “. How shall I put this, he made me extremely uncomfortable… like he frequents playgrounds and certain dark web sites. In no way am I joking, he should be investigated. I personally would not be alone with him. I hope his patients are safe.

[@cxdxvxr]

My thoughts exactly, I would not trust that man as far as I could throw him, let alone trust him with my mental health.

[@fashionista444]

He was unprofessional but we should learn from what happened to Johnny Depp where he was judged by his eccentric style and not follow down that path. We can say we don't believe in the Dr without implying he's a criminal because he looks weird

[@clarab6092]

Well, after I learned today that Amber gave money to witnesses she knew would be called to the stand, it's no surprise to me that condescending, sleazy people like Dr. Spiegel would testify on her behalf. He looks exactly like the type of person who would do alot of things as long as you pay him well.😝

[@Drip7914]

@@fashionista444 he looked like Trevor 😭

[@gamemediafan1714]

@@fashionista444 Or maybe we should learn from Johnny and not date people that are years younger then ourselves. Or maybe we should learn from Johnny in teaching men to be more careful about who they choose to date/marry.

[@jaywilldoit]

Give Johnny a million alpacas after this is all over. The man deserves it.

[@seriousoldman8997]

a Million and One Alpacas should be the movie title

[@jworth7203]

This man is lovely. He even knows when the objections will be over ruled. He is a true professional.

[@MuhammadAliGoat00]

The fact that this guy is smiling almost all the time and that his voice is so relaxing, not to mention his obvious level of intelligence and knowledge, makes me say that this is by far the best witness I've heared till now. Just WOW! 💯💯💯

[@blueXwren]

Dr Smeagol's testimony seriously triggered my anxiety yesterday. I don't usually get triggered from watching court/crime videos, either. One of my biggest fears is going to a professional for help and being hurt further or misdiagnosed instead of properly helped. This psychiatrist, however, seemed really soothing and reassuring. Trustworthy. Edit: Apologies. Got him confused with Gollum from LOTR. Couldn't unhear it.

[@jens2049]

@@Neuropschology.525 no lol

[@Sarablueunicorn]

All psychiatrists I came across were more like Dr. "'Seagul". They are not therapists and they just think they are some sort of "mind readers" mind scientists. The worst category of medical doctors.

[@FakingANerve]

No apologies necessary. Quite an apt comparison, and an easy mistake to mix them up.

[@fakeaccount704]

@@Neuropschology.525 the joke clearly went over your head. Every watch Lord of the Rings

[@nobodynowhere21]

I don't trust mental health professionals in general. Too many misdiagnoses, too many drugs I didn't need, too little care and attention to the actual human being. Also, psychiatrists seem to have a weird knack for picking up doctors with HUGE ego, and they WILL punish their patients for perceived disrespect -- one patient at mental hospital with me spoke up against his psychiatrist once, and he got sent upstairs to where "the REALLY crazy people go". I only saw him one more time after that, he looked like he hadn't slept in days. Mental health is a radioactive dumpster fire in the US, it cannot be said loudly or often enough.

[@dmz7696]

I would imagine Amber's Team would have a hard time trying to discredit the testimony of a Psychiatry professor from Stanford. Can't say the same for the freak show that we saw the day before.

[@BeegirlsHoneyHouse]

The crazy professor from Roger Rabbit with spiraling bulging eyes⁉️

[@eve6875]

@@BeegirlsHoneyHouse "My Precioussssssss"

[@BeegirlsHoneyHouse]

@@eve6875 hahahahahaha

[@gaming1zanagi-1999.]

That lunatic is already toasted since his unprofessionalism and arrogance are exposed to the public by now.

[@lilyluh]

@@gaming1zanagi-1999. I'm pretty sure he spent his day receiving calls canceling booked sessions. Not to get back at him for his testimony (well not only), but because he looked and sounded deranged and easily triggered.

[@RedRose4141]

Thank God a respectable professional who's honest and takes his career serious. 👏

[@jjktng]

ly Me OCD

[@jamillajohnson6108]

Her team was so proud of her, that was sweet to see! Johnny saying “good job, thank you” he appreciates the work this team is putting in to prove his case. They did an amazing job, every last one of them!

[@mightymouseandlittlemouse2332]

Another example of how professional and prepared JD's team is, and that they chose QUALIFIED professionals to testify. AH's team found the bottom of the barrel "professionals" who are all just an absolute mess!

[@antivenomadams6369]

Yep! Team Amber found people that could be paid to say whatever they wanted them to say

[@clarab6092]

Well, I guess they only found nutjobs because only nutjobs could be bought or believed Amber and would testify for free.

[@gaming1zanagi-1999.]

And a nut case too that one is

[@letabranch7459]

She hired cheap shrinks because her poor budget is low…..lol

[@85Kutcher]

Took this guy 35 min to just name all his qualifications and resume my god what a god tier expert.

[@alexsoto9285]

He spoke so well it felt like he should have been applauded after he finished his final statement

[@misscorvette02]

Dear Johnny Depp: Whatever the outcome of your suit against that despicable woman, and I pray it’s in your favor including her ridiculous counterclaim, I want you to know you have been vindicated in the minds, hearts and souls of your fans, the public and I hope within the acting profession. And I love you!

[@sarahrose4126]

7:41, Depps attorney , " Doctor , What is the difference between correlation and causation ? " I laughed so hard . I try to explain the difference between correlation and causation to people on Facebook on a daily basis ( usually to no avail ) . It is beautiful to hear an attorney try and point out that difference. I wasn't surprised when the world's worst attorney screamed out " Objection !" Nothing bothers an unethical attorney more than logic.

[@frumpusnumpus]

Yeah, that Amber's attorney objected so quickly it was clear he wanted to stop something from coming to light. Rotten indeed.

[@DiaryIsLocked]

My favorite example is shark attacks are correlated to ice cream sales and consumption. It was a real study. But basically its hot out so more people eating ice cream and at the beach to cool down. Since there's more people at the beach and trying to cool down, there are more people in the water which increases chances of shark attacks. Sharks are not attracted to people who are full of ice cream. But there is a correlation between ice cream sales and shark attacks. Real connection: Hot out. People cool down by ice cream and water. What lives in certain frequented bodies of water? Sharks. Plus its a fact and study based example and you can find videos and a whole bunch of info to back it up.

[@syd7801]

It's alarming how many people in the world lack critical thinking skills.

[@ziggypop8106]

Dr Shaw has Johnny Depp's attention, but in a positive way this time, unlike yesterday's bizarre floor show

[@veronicagalvin1770]

Yeah, it's almost like he is mesmerised by him.

[@sandythomas8847]

I noticed that too he seems to be paying attention to what this man has to say with respect

[@kevincorcoran7629]

Depp gonna make appt w this doctor

[@rossiikhan]

I was amazed at this guy's resume. Among other things, he is the fricking professor of psychiatry at Stanford University.

[@truthwillprevail821]

Yeah, his CV is impressive, JD's team brought in the top guy in the field

[@lp.shakur]

didn't Camille in her closing statement also say he literally worked for the Queen 😁 he really is the top guy it seems

[@oluomalocs4964]

I just love the way JD's team of lawyers are so supportive of each other as well as their client. As someone who has always viewed lawyers as cold, calculating, hard hearted individuals, this is extremely heartwarming to see.

[@Mashael199op]

He is professional and well mannered

[@adiaCimoune]

Pretty sure they chose this guy conscious of the stark contrast to spiegl. The defense should just give up with the objections. That testimony yesterday is beyond saving 😅

[@howardchambers9679]

Don't Americans consider an English accent more trustworthy? If so, great work by team Depp!

[@M1GYT]

@@howardchambers9679 I don’t think it’s necessarily that, more so the fact that he doesn’t act like he just did a line of coke, but it sure does help

[@eve6875]

With the time they have left, they will have no objections soon enough.

[@stephanie3087]

It sounds to me that this gentleman is professionally pointing out that AH’s psychiatrist testified with “information” that was out of his scope. Pretty sure his career is over. This man is very professional and informative

[@arshadd672]

I would pay to have a session with this guy. Seems so knowledgeable and supportive.

[@momennada2332]

and now ladies and gentlemen that's what a professional looks like

[@tamarakwara7258]

Justice ⚖ for JD, all the way from Pacific Islands 🇵🇬

[@julietteferrars3097]

That was beautiful to watch. He spoke with such truth. I am so glad they had him come as a second opinion and that he cleared up the lies of AH’s team.

[@de-brablair3751]

It's very refreshing to hear from someone who's knowledgeable and charming at the same time. JD even seems very interested in what he has to say. This witness helpful given us the knowledge needed. Yesterday Doctor was like watching a train wreck you wanted to look away but couldn't. Painfully horrific..

[@ovskii96]

I'm so glad they brought in a real professional instead of some crackpot.

[@84sillyme]

Real Psychiatrist, this one will not give you nightmares.

[@Smurfyis730]

Every time I close my eyes I still see that wet chicken. I do have to admit how hard I laughed at his "performance".

[@lezel4swarts]

🤣

[@franciscopartida2737]

OMG!!! This whole court case is like a children's movie where *the good people are really good and the bad people are really bad.* 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Literally from AH, to her lawyers, to all her witnesses, they are the most UNLIKEABLE people ever and the exact opposite can be said about JD and everyone he's brought along. Even the witnesses that didn't even help his case were very likeable.

[@rebeccaking7817]

Agreed! Depp’s witnesses have been all lovely, charming, charismatic and very knowledgeable. Amber’s have all have been, surly, combative and thoroughly unlikable. Kind of like her….

[@lisagaines9806]

What a great point!

[@childinchrist7335]

AH lawyers are just trying to do their job. They are terrible at it because it's hard to defend lies but I don't think they are unlikeable. Some of the witnesses were.

[@franciscopartida2737]

@@childinchrist7335 What?! They argue with the judge, they cut people off, they object impulsively, and are overall very rude. They are unlikable.

[@MagickCat861]

This is a great example of how every profession has its good and bad eggs. Always seek a second or third opinion if you do not gel with the professional and if their “diagnosis” doesn’t feel like it fits for you.

[@KingTairun]

This guy explains how should have been done, while the creepy doctor be like: "he eat candy therefore he is narcists"

[@chrismatthew5117]

Dr. Spiegel license should be revoke for being unethical and breaking the guidelines.

[@Smurfyis730]

I'm not for snatching people's jobs away, but that was absolutely horrid to listen to, Dr. Spiegel put on quite a show. When he mentioned he's never seen anyone fall asleep with vomit all over themselves, I rolled my eyes. That's what someone "told him" about the picture of JD falling asleep with ice cream. He had no business up there.

[@coquette7794]

Wow, this physchiatrist is awesome. Everyone in court was listening. No one is cutting him off. Even AH's lawyers shutted up! Amazing phychiatrist. Just.... wonderful.

[@Heaven-dy9lj]

It's the English accent! 😍

[@rosemariecastillo9256]

Highly respected! This Phsychiatrist speaks, talks in a very professional manner. On point what he is testifying. God bless you and JD and his team of lawyers🙏

[@ericapinheiro9891]

The difference between this doctor and Amber's crazy psycho doctor, is screaming lol.

[@KingCrimson82]

this is an esoteric and the other one a scientifical idealist.

[@natalijadizdar7824]

Love you Erica🤣👏👍

[@jaywilldoit]

Amber has turned this case from a defamation case into a defecation case.

[@BoobooSnafu]

😂😂😂

[@ryuj1n.sr208]

W comment

[@michaeljohndadd545]

149th like

[@tanushrideb4411]

🤣🤣🤣

[@bowlcutballfro]

This doctor is so eloquent. I could listen to him for hours.

[@lordmephisto6654]

10:52 The support and love Johnny and his team of Lawyers give each other is just so heartwarming!!

[@PronatorTendon]

This is absolutely devastating testimony. Seldom have I seen such a disparity between plaintiff and defense experts.

[@evilelf5967]

Guess thats the difference between being told what you can say and having the freedom to say what you want.

[@cynthiathiagomez7445]

A kind, understanding and knowledgeable psychiatrist. This type of professional is one that knows the rules and guidelines thoroughly of his profession. Even his pointing out all of Dr. Spegal’s beligerent statements from yesterday, it’s done in a respectable manner. The truth never needs to be screamed.

[@sairamughal8336]

'The truth never needs to be screamed.' Wow.

[@bandageoverheart]

I liked how JD and the team supported/congratulated the lawyer when she went back to the table. Wholesome 😊

[@priss88hdz]

That other psychiatrists looks like he would throw you away into a box full of spiders knowing that you are terrified of them.

[@juliaandjude3362]

Finally someone who knows what he's talking about. Bravo.

[@l0gray182]

No wonder he is teaching in Stanford

[@jordannazeer2191]

This guy is ace! His ability to break down and describe the methods needed to understand certain areas is so well articulated. Awesome guy to have overlooking the psychological side of the case.

[@carn9507]

Right? He's the anti-Spiegel.

[@capricris7672]

I respect this man, he knows his stuff and he's very thorough and is fully aware of the Standards of practice and guidelines.

[@istateyourname4710]

Ground control to Major Tom.

[@GeorgideMarne]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@ziggypop8106]

Massive Bowie fan here, I'll admit, he's also from the UK 😀

[@notonmywatch4291]

This psychiatrist is so professional, he should perform an evaluation of Amber Heards psychiatrist!

[@vanilittlestar6357]

I really love this psychiatrist, he's so professional & knowledgeable. He presents himself as a real professional psychiatrist unlike that other one who was more psychotic than psychiatrist LOL. This man makes you want to know more & learn something new. I really like him.🌻

[@metalinkin82]

What a difference! This Dr. is professional and ethical unlike why we watched yesterday.

[@That1guy247_]

Night and Day. Between the psychiatrists 😂

[@dkizzle1290]

This man is very well spoken. Cool, calm, and collected wow

[@TheScentinel]

The contrast between this guy and Spiegel🤣

[@ArmantoAlex13]

This is an example of what a ‘true’ psychiatrist is….he kicked the shut out of Smeagal’s testimony!! 😂😂🤣🤣😅

[@ladawn6426]

Dr Smiegal … you mean Lemony Snicket ?! That man did not fool me … I know a Lemony Snicket disguise when I see one!

[@phuongtruong100]

I feel like all AH’s witnesses and legal team will sue her after this case for destroying their careers.😂😂😂

[@jimmyclifff4849]

Dr Shaw. You the man!! True class act

[@KayosHybrid]

Anyone else notice that having a calm, professional, non-hostile and wise professional in the room has lead to Mr Depp’s body language relaxing and opening up? I don’t believe in the strict science of body language but he’s actually looking at this expert/witness with an engaged attention. I also feel far more reassured, personally.

[@dudettevlogs4257]

Ladies and gentlemen; this is a professional witness..!!

[@peytonamber3011]

Now this is a TRUE PROFESSIONAL

[@tonyrae86]

This man literally spoke to exactly why Dr. Grande always says he's just speculating before every video he releases. Professional ethics!

[@rivercanoli3600]

The difference between this gentleman and yesterday's raving lunatic is night and day.

[@ziggypop8106]

Dr Richard Shaw, almost said breaking of the Goldwater rule was punishable by death

[@Nicholas_Chen_]

Professionals have standards

[@ziggypop8106]

Yes I know, that's why I enjoyed this witness so much more than yesterday's comedy clown show

[@louisep4805]

Much better Psychiatrist very relaxing approach and speaking voice 👍👌 I admire his work in helping parents of disabled children too 🙏

[@telegnes4500]

Now, this is a doctor.

[@Yaya93288]

I bet this psychiatrist deemed Mr. Smeagol a REAL narcissist from yesterday’s horrible performance.