[Q/A] India's Missing Kootayuddha (Covert Warfare) | Bharat Karnad | RAW | Kulbhushan Jadhav

[@dejikay2564]

Only way to get out of this "Lethargic" state is to never elect Non-State actors... like Congress Party and their wings. Let the Right Wing BJP take India back to what it was before the worlds decided to loot and pillage the spoils. Jai Hind!

[@DEEPANKARSARKARthegovt]

Why share such security infos

[@therushi1]

nothing to worry about it man

[@DEEPANKARSARKARthegovt]

@@therushi1 man I'm not worried , i was trying to point that ppl with such authoritative position must evaluate what they speak before they actually say it that to just to prove the correctness of his statement or theory

[@bhuvanc4992]

Bharat Karnad is misjudging Pakistan. Pakistan is the successor to the Mughal and Islamic sultanates. It looks at partition as unfinished business and will never rest content till it conquers Delhi. India's response has to be to weaken and isolate Pakistan, which Modi has done well so far.

[@AJAYSINGH-ns1vv]

Right

[@pbebington]

Compulsory military service for govt. officials--excellent!

[@sontuudaybhasker5187]

J5r90x9

[@MrSirAussie]

Awesome, Invigorating and thought provoking discussion. As one of the guest mentioned rightly ITS TIME WE NEED TO AND MUST GET OUT OF THE LETHARGIC PARALYTIC MIND SET. WE NEED TO ACT SMART........ENOUGH IS ENOUGH OF 50 YEARS OF INFILTRATION /VIOLATIONS AT THE LOC....TIME TO WAKE UP ....IT'S TIME TO ACT IS NOW. Thanks Bharat Karnad Jai Hind Bharat Mata Ki Jai

[@suneelreddyhadimani6058]

If I'm a prime minister of India. I would make him all in all Foreign secretory, foreign minister, NSA. Because his knowledge, skill and experience are fit for that.

[@skulchand2177]

Every other you tube speakers who come as a speaker who has no responsibility or diplomatic baggage will speak like this only Great paper planner without taking real dynamic facts into account

[@myarchitecturalview6632]

Edmund Burke had challenged Warren Hastings not Cornwallis sir

[@catlover9865]

I can say 4 sure that the amount of knowledge I received, by watching this video, I never had such an experience; I am really thankful to Bharat sir. I have seen him on rajya sabha tv on many occasions and knew that he is a real gem. Now I'm a fan of him for the lifetime. Bow b4 thou.

[@skg901]

Worship cows but dont get cowed down...

[@balajipadmanabhan2927]

Pakistan, a buffer state!!! Rubbish! Pakistan would have been a hindu nation. India knew how to protect itself for over 570 years. It would have learnt the hard way to learn to defend itself.

[@siddsy100]

Wow. The man's a strategic genius.

[@theybecameus]

Yogi ji future Prime minister 🔥🚩

[@raghavarvoltore6517]

Brilliant, wonderful, very insightful.

[@rambhakt4005]

Sir Pakistan is not a buffer state,it is,itself an Islamic State.So it doesn't matter if it exist or not.Rather it seems that Iran is a better buffer .

[@sebastianswett5860]

I agree with you.

[@Dee-bv4py]

I agree with you! Iran has been a buffer for over centuries. From Arabs, Mongols etc.

[@OnkarShrma]

But just imagine all the pakistani population can roam around India if we were united. And we are sharing boundries with USSR and Taliban in west. I can imagine the mess in our country. And we always have arab ocean between iran and india as a buffer.

[@rambhakt4005]

@@OnkarShrma Your concern regarding the issue is valid .But the point you missed out is that ,India has one of largest military ,navy and Air Force for the border defence.A network of intelligence agencies for providing the latest updates regarding the internal as well the external threats.Also a large number of Police personnel at the local level.

[@ameyasampada]

THE SWAYAM SEVAK : step aside your emotions and think logically...what srijan is saying its true

[@ravs4461]

Completely disagree with pax saving Bharat.. It sounds exactly like the weak shivering thought process of gutless spineless and lazy bum neru... What would have happened if pax was never created? .. Bharat would have been led by Sardar Patel... The Hindu population would've been empowered and given a fitting reply as required culturally or militarily... So Pax should remain a beggar state and suffer for the atrocities against humanity...

[@jagdishramanathan4620]

this prof is educated in US . he speaks a third party view .

[@NarendraKumar-jj4fu]

however, the kootaneeti, this gentleman talks is not anywhere in the Vedas. If tou are aware, let me know...

[@sahilsinghfrand]

BHARAT KARNAD SIR IS MY FAVOURITE STRATEGIST. LONG LIVE BHARAT KARNAD SIR

[@c.selvarajhunc.rajhun7021]

The implementation of foreign thoughts deatoryed nation

[@mandy28887]

I want to read Mr Bharat Karnads books but they are too expensive. I have read his book Staggering Forward

[@Sathia_Remix]

the speaker focussed on China, Pakistan, US and Vietnam in that order in tha main speech But one thing which has been missed is the utter failure when we lost our (at that time )Ex Prime Minister Sri Rajiv Gandhi to the debacle in Sri Lanka - what went wrong in the thinking in the SriLankan context will we be doing the same error again - by losing SriLanka like Pakistan to the chinese also in another talk by the MP Sri Subramaniam Swami he mentions that Chinese have utter disregard for the other country who is desperate to please another or for those who do not respect their own country he also further adds a more easier and shorter route of commerce could be through Kolkatta Port and via the nepal route - had India had offered this route of commerce the CPEC would have been discarded - does the speaker agree

[@harshnetrelations]

Why this session is so small. I can listen to it for days.

[@nothingwronginhinduism5923]

That's what I wanted to say.

[@Sumit-Sh]

Russia is also very cold T90 should be working fine in cold weather conditions.

[@RB-jv2si]

Wrong assessment supported wrongly takibg ancient India text

[@Col.J.N.W.SinghKhandala]

One thing that we Indians have to start developing is the age old yet forgotten skills of dexterity (read: crafting things with our bloody hands for a change) instead of software, software and software all the way. Because, when hunger and need strikes, those are hardware products that help you tide over the phase and not some stupid software. Our country has become the whole world's back office performing and accomplishing ridiculously low skilled back room jobs for a nickel or a dime. Our manufacturing abilities are in the pits and we are today incapable of crafting anything that is a fine product with our own hands. Instead, we pride ourselves in saying, "Oh! We use only 'imported' stuff." What must be considered shameful is a misplaced matter of pride for us idiots. China manufactures practically everything that the whole wide world uses. Albeit their quality of manufacturing might be suspect, it is still something instead of nothing. The Chinese don't sit pretty on their arse pushing keyboard buttons only. They are a toiling lot of people and hence command the economic might that they can afford to take for granted today and hold the world to ransom each time.

[@k.bhatta4257]

Absolutely correct! Cheap IT/Engg degrees only produce a large number of IT/factory Coolies. It is all part of the progression of Slavery which started because the Amerindians refused to be mind-colonised. Transatlantic slavery thrived for a while whch was the morphed into indentured labour and then to H1B Visa and willing slavery. The West is dependent on it. People in the west have almost lost the work ethic (together with desire and application to education, especially higher education, and particularly after the latest spread of mindless Globalization!

[@myarvind]

I hope the Indian govt really takes his advice

[@AJAYSINGH-ns1vv]

I don't agree that state was always oppressive.

[@vasudev2340]

If such a people exist in RAW then why fools pakistan sending terrorists into india to dismantle.kootayudh means this create a false impression about enemy to benefit that enemy.so he is saying securepakistan both financially & defence in our interest so india should help pakistan financially to secure itself so that they dismantle india more easily Poking china (raising tibet issue) is not a strategic move Regarding tanks in against china weight is the main concern because they cannot move mountains as easily as in plains for ex a car can fastly move & manouere in ghat roads rather than a bus so lighter tanks are best option Our bikes also dont start immediately in winter times so do the tanks of us amd chineese(because mostly of them are russian or with russian technology) International alliances are for mutual benefit(either financial or strategic)like pakistan and china etc

[@ganeshmavi611]

Pakistan will never be a buffer stage but a staging and lauchpad on india

[@user-bp5dm4tp6c]

Thode man is genius

[@sukiamirapu7325]

At 13:15, you have described a very powerful bribe. It would be of interest to know a list of recipients over the last ten years. Mitrokhin's revelation in his two volumes, does not come as any surprise. On the topic of compulsory service in any of the uniformed services, Singapore has a very workable and successful model. Their Government imposes a pathway of structuring their youth, so that they continue to be self-disciplined even when the structure is removed. The Government of UAE also took up this model to prevent their youth from being 'radicalised' by influences lurking around their political perimeter. Possibly a couple of States in India (e.g. the coastal states of Andhra and Odisha, going up towards Jharkhand) should try out this model within their own educational curriculum. Results of this investment would be clear to see when these empowered and impassioned youngsters grow into positions of influence and authority within the country.

[@NarendraKumar-jj4fu]

further, explicit issues of warfare come in book 6 (Bharadvaja) that cab a pleasure to read.

[@JoyousNightjar]

I am just 4 min in ur video but must say one thing. We don't have any problem as long as Pakistan doesn't creates problems

[@ritajha7302]

Slight correction it was Warren Hastings ,not Cornwallis.

[@marutirahul6078]

In start of this video who is asking... Is he the same guy who spoke on cannabis !!!

[@rahulpathare12345]

Yes 😊

[@nagavenipathak3219]

Very good

[@abhinavbhatnagar1566]

Sir we can use electronic heating coils solar powered to heat the fueltank of tank and after that one heating button coils heat up and pooofff tank will be rocking sir in minutes

[@heynobody007]

Do you think you'll be able to see sun out there Where temperature is in sub zero range

[@abhinavbhatnagar1566]

@@heynobody007 we have solar panels which work in deep space too used in space probes bro and don't remember the height we have more sunlight there with subzero temperature

[@bhavin105]

He has not answered a single question. Every answer is a heap of rhetorics. If I were him, I would at least give some speculative answers on why India doesn't do what others do. But this guy just rants and moans. I wouldn't trust him to be an expert.

[@adrrpa168]

We need to look after china pakistan can never do more harm than china.

[@10ssr]

He is expressing what he has received perception from USA. He has nothing special of his own which needs to be listen. We Indians like to listen negative feelings out of lacking something and he is fulfilling that.

[@TheGuruNetOn]

बंद मुट्ठी लाख की...

[@Adityaac1]

Too negative... Sir you are commenting on " what if's????" Too easy to speculate. Easy job creating worst case scenarios...🙏

[@sankalp3513]

Partition was a good thing for India to progress. We can be sad and angry at how it came about while still being relieved with the result. He is 100% right about Pakistan acting as a buffer state

[@TheGuruNetOn]

अगर हमारे पास धन ना हो तो ये सब खयाली पुलाव मात्र रह जाएंगे। या फिर हमारे पड़ोसी की तरह अपने आप को गिरवि रख के पंगे लेने पड़ेंगे। द्रव्य के अभाव में यह भी बहुत देर तक नहीं कर सकते। धन तो शक्ति का स्वरूप है। उसके विना ये सब काल्पनिक ही है।

[@k.bhatta4257]

Yes; that's why Atmanirbhar is so important; not more and more concreting the nation! Imagine what it would be if some modern Kalidasa were to write Meghadoota!

[@vimaldob]

India should focus on Socotra island of Yemen ...to be an unsinkable aircraft carrier to block gulf of Aden

[@zeroinfinity4082]

What Mr Bharat said 2yrs ago regarding strike core, is proved right.

[@navaprakashsingh5547]

Who is this spectacled "intellectual" who does not know his question and goes on rambling incoherently? Sir, please spare us with his intelligence.

[@peekaygaikwad4117]

This is an epitome of mediocrity. Utter Nonsense.

[@TheGuruNetOn]

विशेशज्ञ और नेता में यही अंतर है कि एक चतुरंग खेलकर अपने आप को सेनापति समझता है और दूसरा लोगों के साथ खेलकर अपने या दूसरों के काम निकलवाता है। इसीलिए नेता किसीभी स्तिथि में कुछ ना कुछ कर पाता है क्यों कि उसकी कुशलता लोगों से प्राप्त होती है जिसमें विशेषज्ञ भी होते हैं । परन्तु विशेषज्ञ अपने क्षेत्र से बाहर कुछ नहीं कर पाता।

[@hallojoy83]

If this guy was associated with RAW, i understand for such a long time a dwarf state like pakistan bleed iur country. People like this who mix T72 cold war operability with strike core reduction in weatern front assuming pakistan a saint buffer state then its better to leave him behind and not allowing crooks like that to share their opinion on Srijan. Lately Srijan is inviting more crooks like him from americal paycheck rooster. Its indeed shameful that these people served our so called proficient RA&W.

[@k.bhatta4257]

He probably was coached by the Atomic President?

[@sureshbabubabu5756]

Aap log hindi me bhi eska explanation karna chahiye

[@ranjithbcm]

Always agreeable theory, the trauma with or without Pakistan always there

[@prajkta123]

Is maria erith in audience?

[@TheBharat91]

Upload unedited videos

[@chauhanpruthvirajsinh3718]

Aapke sabhi video english me he. Kya aap inko hindi me nahi kar sakte ? Aap bat hindu or swadesh ki karte ho to ye english vali Gulami kyo ?

[@k.bhatta4257]

@Ram Krishna DashWell said! English is de-facto a world commercial language! Learn English as a 3rd/4th language, just like the Chinese, Japanese, Korean, French or Germans do. If you don't know English, how can you do poorvapaksha of any BI forces? Now even Westerners are learning Sanskrit - see American Sanskrit Institute!

[@sebastianswett5860]

Karnad is not coherent.

[@Aven-Sharma1991]

😂😂😂 Y’all wanna be so white so damn bad!

[@adarshpandey8023]

He wrote Indian Nuclear doctrine.

[@bhuvneshsharma1934]

India ko Apni economy Ka dhyan rekhna Chahiye,,,,,,,

[@debasismohanty7332]

Chahe gardan kat Jaye pehele economy...🤣🤣🤣 Kashmir me dhakke marke Hindu ko nikala... economy economy hote raho

[@NarendraKumar-jj4fu]

The speaker is full of horse-feathers. He accepts that he is reading some excerpts in translation. Himself does not have the knowledge and paints the Vedas as quite bloody a la the Psalms or the Koran. I do not where he derives his scholarship from. If these are the guiding lights of India, let the FORCE bless the country. He has skewed view of state rule/rulers, and quotes the half-baked Western thinking without understanding the Eastern ethos.

[@raghavarvoltore6517]

no he is right, your views are wrong. The vedas talk about wars especially the "battle of the 10 kings"

[@pratikkumar4471]

@@raghavarvoltore6517 leave it dude, few idiots like narendra kumar will never understand these things..

[@k.bhatta4257]

It was a feathered horse that took someone to heaven to be with his Ogre!