"Qualia Is Not Universally Distributed" | Adrian Johnston Against Panpsychism

[@MasoudJohnAzizi]

Very good discussion 👍, thank you for sharing.

[@RahulSam]

Cheers! Appreciate the kind words.

[@akbar-nr4kc]

Hi sam i have question what is zizek view on colin mcginn idea of new mysterianism from hegelain lens. Os zizek reject it or accept it ? Also why

[@RahulSam]

Not too sure, mate. You may have to Google it around.

[@Robert_McGarry_Poems]

.🔥.

[@akbar-nr4kc]

Hi sam i have question what is zizek view on colin mcginn mysterianism from hegelain philosphy of conyridictions lens . Is zizek accept or reject it ? Also why he reject or accept colin mcginn mysterianism from hegelain lens.

[@RahulSam]

I don't think he has commented on the matter, mate. Try looking around online, and if you do find something, please share it with me!

[@Footnotes2Plato]

Total caricature of panpsychism, I’d say? Even the Goffian substance version is more nuanced than he’s suggesting, to say nothing of the process-relational version.

[@RahulSam]

Fair criticism, Matthew. I think Prof Johnston was going off the cuff here. And I, too, am not well-read on Panpsychist literature in any way. I have your essay 'Physics Within the Limits of Feeling Alone' to read, which I hope to get to soon!

[@MasoudJohnAzizi]

Well, there seems to be a lot of misunderstanding about "panpsychism" and/or there is no consensus on how to define it (like "consciousness"). Even Dr. Bernardo Kastrup, in his interview with Prof. Dr. Brian Keating, referred to "panpsychism" as nothing but "hopelessness" that is not grounded in physical reality...

[@MasoudJohnAzizi]

I think Dr. Iain McGilchrist would classify the perspectives of Prof. Dr. Adrian Johnston as those which represent moreso the cognition of the brain's left-hemisphere relative to that of the right-hemisphere.

[@Robert_McGarry_Poems]

He who knows only his own side of the story knows little even of that. John S Mills. The self that knows only itself knows little even of that. Materialism and minds in a nutshell. But usefulness exists... so is it more?