Radio Signal of Unknown Origin Discovered in a Nearby Galaxy NGC 2082

Good telescope that I've used to learn the basics: amzn.to/35r1jAk
Get a Wonderful Person shirt: teespring.com/stores/whatdamath
Alternatively, PayPal donations can be sent here: paypal.me/whatdamath
Hello and welcome! My name is Anton and in this video, we will talk about a discovery of an unusual radio signal from another galaxy
Links:
arxiv.org/abs/2205.11144
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_2082
Support this channel on Patreon to help me make this a full time job:
/ whatdamath
Bitcoin/Ethereum to spare? Donate them here to help this channel grow!
bc1qnkl3nk0zt7w0xzrgur9pnkcduj7a3xxllcn7d4
or ETH: 0x60f088B10b03115405d313f964BeA93eF0Bd3DbF
Space Engine is available for free here: spaceengine.org
Enjoy and please subscribe.
Twitter: / whatdamath
Facebook: / whatdamath
Twitch: / whatdamath
The hardware used to record these videos:
New Camera: amzn.to/34DUUlv
CPU: amzn.to/2LZFQCJ
Video Card: amzn.to/2M1W26C
Motherboard: amzn.to/2JYGiQQ
RAM: amzn.to/2Mwy2t4
PSU: amzn.to/2LZcrIH
Case: amzn.to/2MwJZz4
Microphone: amzn.to/2t5jTv0
Mixer: amzn.to/2JOL0oF
Recording and Editing: amzn.to/2LX6uvU
Some of the above are affiliate links, meaning I would get a (very small) percentage of the price paid.
Thank you to all Patreon supporters of this channel
Special thanks also goes to all the wonderful supporters of the channel through KZbin Memberships
Images/Videos:
Sam Moorfield CSIRO CC BY-SA 4.0 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Odd_rad...
Balzan et al., 2022.
ESA/Hubble and NASA CC BY 3.0 www.spacetelescope.org/images/...
CSIRO CC BY 3.0 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austral...
NASA, ESA and J. Olmsted (STScI)
NASA www.nasa.gov/images/content/7...
Licenses used:
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
creativecommons.org/licenses/...

[@Phantaxxx]

This is my paper! I was hoping you’d cover it, and thank you so much for doing so - I love your channel.

[@idealsAREisomorphic]

Bro where aliens

[@Atxurra]

NEEEEEEEERD!

[@D4RKWolf2240]

Link?

[@jimmison]

Congrats, your research definitely looks interesting

[@adamm2716]

@@idealsAREisomorphic yes

[@jimleane7578]

"It's not aliens" statement never gets old. I always chuckle. One day it will be "umm, this IS aliens". Can't wait for my chuckle to be stifled.

[@jiggyv6139]

It’s not.

[@SamtheIrishexan]

One day we will find out pulsars are just alien beacons from an extinct civilization. I am convinced aliens don't exist because the great filter, anyone who gets to AI, and creates self aware AI, is doomed.

[@SamtheIrishexan]

@@jiggyv6139 you say that with great scientific authority based on....

[@odszczepciesie5128]

They'll be laughing much more for new planet for colonisation, after some deratization of human mankind

[@odszczepciesie5128]

@@SamtheIrishexan And IA is taking the rules

[@nowymail]

Radio signals are good for short distance communication. Voyagers are already too far away for talking to them effectively. And they are still under the influence of our solar system. Trying to talk to someone in another galaxy is like sending a regular letter to a nearby Fire Station to inform them your house is on fire and asking them what to do. By the time the message comes back, it's waaaay too late. If we want to talk to another galaxy, we need to invent something faster than light.

[@nobodyknows3180]

And any civilizations in the universe that have figured THAT out probably wouldn't even bother with radio signals - either sending or monitoring - unless they had passed through their own radio astronomy phase themselves and were still 'keeping an ear out' for radio signals from less advanced civilizations.

[@Eidolon1andOnly]

@@nobodyknows3180 Or they could use radio signals more for navigation, like beacons, essentially making artificial "quasars".

[@Roshan_420]

Communicate with gravitational waves

[@nobodyknows3180]

@@Roshan_420 that's pretty advanced considering it takes black holes colliding to generate detectable waves. Too low frequency however to contain much information. Look at 5G technology - fast data transmission, at frequencies of up to 52.6GHz

[@filonin2]

@@Roshan_420 Gravitational waves are no faster than radio waves and cost much more to generate.

[@Hopeless_and_Forlorn]

I believe it takes millions of years for radio signals from other galaxies to reach us. Best case, it may be interesting to know that intelligent life once existed elsewhere, but we could never communicate with them.

[@Dead_Empire]

Yeah, theres no reason to think that these signals couldnt get warped over long distances, reaching us with our radio "codes". We would have to translate their signals and vise versa. Causing them to be unuseable. By the tume those signals reach us they have probly flowen to us

[@joearnold6881]

60 million years from this galaxy, specifically. There are small galaxies within the hundreds or even tens of thousands of light years distance, though, orbiting the the Milky Way (the Megellanic Clouds being the most famous) But still, unless we get some Warp Drives or something, we won’t be asking them to come over for Netflix and chill

[@nobodyknows3180]

Kind of spooky, that if we were to receive an intelligent radio signal from a source, say 1 billion light years away, we would be hearing what they were saying 1 billion years ago. The day we receive that signal, they may no longer even exist, maybe their star went supernova a million years after sending that message.

[@ferd1775]

@@joearnold6881 I was hoping for Hulu and SnuSnu

[@TEFLONDONTRUMP2024]

Radio travels at speed of light

[@burtgallagher6499]

We need a super-cut of Anton announcing "It's not aliens". Thanks for making science digestible even for toothless minds such as mine!

[@maggs131]

Toothless mind? 🤔

[@burtgallagher6499]

@@maggs131 doesn't digest well, being without teeth.

[@maggs131]

@@burtgallagher6499 😲ooooh ok makes sense. I gotta remember that one

[@burtgallagher6499]

@@maggs131 ^___^

[@gmgunner]

Gum it.

[@MaryAnnNytowl]

It's never aliens... but if it ever IS aliens, I trust Anton to be the one to say so! Thanks, Anton, for all you do! LOL, cute little nerd kid story: I used to think (a long, long time ago when I was like 8 years old) that NGC __xxx___ meant "Near Galactic Cluster! After all, galaxies were super cool, so they needed cool names to go with them, right? Alas, I soon learned it was just a catalog name... New General Catalog. I think of that every time I hear about NGC __anything__!

[@Lou.B]

More than ANY other source, Anton provides a sense of the complexity of space at it's leading edge of study - even for Newtonian thinkers like me. THANK YOU, Anton, for your great mind and superlative teaching skills! A True Gem!

[@ctrudeau55]

Brother I just found out about your pain, and i hope you are doing the best you can nothing in this world is worse than a parent losing their child, the Save The Children is an amazing outcome from such a horrible circumstance.. I really believe that you are a wonderful person inside and out and your videos your intellect is amazing and wonderful.. stay hopeful my brother. Here in Tennessee I'm praying for you...

[@AboveEmAllProduction]

Stop fucking talking about it

[@ColinTimmins]

@GreenTea💚 I agree. We all care about him so it is best not to bring it up as I’m sure he knows we support him.

[@Av987]

@GreenTea💚 saying he has “moved on” from losing a child sounds even more rude to me. And we also wouldn’t know how he would feel if nobody ever brought it up. For all we know, these kind of comments give him that little extra support that he needs right now

[@clintforeman6019]

Yuhhhhh I love when new Anton videos come out

[@MaryAnnNytowl]

Every single day at 5 pm, too, like clockwork! 🙂

[@therealjamespickering]

@@MaryAnnNytowl You're lucky. I have to wait for midnight, but it is well worth it.

[@Chlrintruc]

It’s crazy how radio waves can be NATURALLY produced by certain things in the universe. Just beautiful.

[@mrmadmaxalot]

Yep, it is basically just really low energy light, which is cool in itself. :)

[@filonin2]

Radio waves are just a color of light you can't see. All radiation is produced naturally somewhere in the universe. Almost all of it is natural. Natural X-rays, microwaves, IR, UV, Gamma, everything.

[@shukrantpatil]

we are natural as well bud , you mean to say through non human means? haha

[@someguy233]

Personally, I think it’s a lot more crazy that a natural frequency of light (like radio waves) can be used to transmit information that has nothing to do with light (say, sound). edited in sound, in case others get confused as to what I was getting at.

[@blinded6502]

@@someguy233 wdym "has nothing to do with light"?

[@biggill7176]

It is such a delight to see your passion for the subject matter. Thank you for the amazing content as always!

[@taconator1213]

Ey! Hopefully we get more signals without explanations, we need more challenges towards our understanding :D Maybe one day we’ll have a similar situation as to what happened with Hubble confirming other galaxies, pushing our understandings past intergalactic heights in a tangible way

[@RepentJC]

Jesus Christ is calling everyone from everywhere to repent of their wicked ways. Therefore, if you confess with your mouth and believe in your heart that God rose Jesus from the dead you will be saved. And for now on, love, obey and seek Jesus with all your heart, soul, and mind. (For Jesus said, “If you love me, you will keep my commandments.)

[@simonmultiverse6349]

"Intergalactic Heights" -- that sounds like a GREAT name for a new housing complex, maybe a large block of flats.

[@simonmultiverse6349]

@@RepentJC Which is better - the wickedness or the repentance? I suspect that there is a relationship, so that if you want a lot of repentance from me, I'm going to have to arrange a huge festival of sin, so that the repentance will be correspondingly greater. Would that be good?

[@simonmultiverse6349]

Is a Taconator a super-intelligent robot from the future which makes tacos and destroys anything which interferes with its taco mission?

[@planexshifter]

@@RepentJC REALLY? That insanity on a science channel? Please, grow up.

[@drewjohn6847]

I just thought it would be nice for you to know, (hopefully you read this) My 10yr old son absolutely loves watching your channel, he actually wants to be an astrophysicist, and has a few channels he watches all the time, you are 1 of them, so thank you, its people like you that keep my boy interested in space , and for me, that is incredible, instead of playing or watching shit, mind numbing things that are all to popular these days, he watches very interesting channels like this, Thank you Anton...I really do mean that...

[@katiekane5247]

Keep his mind active & if no one said it today, Happy Father's Day! Thanks for being a good dad, they're hard to find.

[@JulesStoop]

@8:02 A probability of 1.2% is pretty high. There a probably at least a several thousand galaxies in the sphere of space constrained by the distance to NGC 2082. If I understand statistics correctly, this could mean we can actually be pretty sure to find one or a few of these objects.

[@Dman6779]

@@bobbymartin5220 quantum nuts

[@michaellee6489]

It's always exciting to hear about new things being discovered! Sometimes the wonder and mystery is more fun than actually knowing. Thanks again, Wonderful Anton!

[@CosmicShieldMaiden]

One must be satisfied with the questions

[@davidescobar5366]

It's distracting yet calming to learn about the mysteries of space. Just like it was when us as humans learned about the mysteries of our own world thousands of years ago to basically the present

[@GatchamanG4]

Hey Anton, thank you for the informative videos. I hope you & your family are doing better. I keep you all in my prayers every night.

[@GroundbreakGames]

@WhatsAppme +①②①⑥③⑤②③④①⑧ reported for spam

[@infinitemonkey917]

Nice sentiment but you should check out the results of a 2009 randomized control study on intercessory prayer: "This study showed that remote intercessory prayer did not improve outcomes after coronary artery bypass graft surgery. In fact, the knowledge of being prayed for was associated with a slightly but significantly higher rate of postsurgical complications." So it might be best to not inform the intended recipient of your prayers that you pray for them.

[@lookupverazhou8599]

@@infinitemonkey917 You keep someone in your prayers to keep them in your thoughts. You keep them in your thoughts because they matter to you, because they represent some goodness in the world that is important for you to celebrate lest goodness should be extinguished from the world altogether. Having someone in your thoughts helps to remove that barrier we all have between one another as strangers. In a time of need are you more likely to help someone whom represents positivity for you, or someone whom you despise, or are even indifferent towards? It is not merely for the other person for whom you pray, but also for yourself to ensure you are always trying your best to act and be Godly.

[@infinitemonkey917]

@@lookupverazhou8599 You were doing so well until the last sentence. It's nice to keep people in your thoughts, and express that to them, but I see no reason to invoke imaginary sky wizards.

[@willo7734]

The amount of interesting and digestible information that you can pack into a 12 minute video blows my mind. The fact that you do it every day is amazing. You’re an amazing teacher, thank you!

[@metasamsara]

Every time some science topic comes up and I want context, the first thing I do is check your channel, and it never disappoints. Thank you so much for your great work!

[@shawnferguson5681]

Learning how to identify the weird phenomenon is going to help us identify the actual intelligent signals when/if we start finding them someday. Speculation is a way to start, but let’s not rush to judgement. Thanks for your balanced and rational coverage of this kind of sensational topic. Mainstream media, if they pay any attention at all, they leap to all sorts of premature conclusions. I like how Anton is willing to say when we don’t understand something YET.

[@RepentJC]

Jesus Christ is calling everyone from everywhere to repent of their wicked ways. Therefore, if you confess with your mouth and believe in your heart that God rose Jesus from the dead you will be saved. And for now on, love, obey and seek Jesus with all your heart, soul, and mind. (For Jesus said, “If you love me, you will keep my commandments.)

[@Technodude255]

Interesting! When we actually do find intelligent signals we'll learn how to make our own to be understood by our galactic neighbors. :)

[@jemborg]

@@Technodude255 oh yeah? There's not only The Tyranny of Distance there is The Tyranny Of Time. Can you imagine hearing the signals of an alien civilisation 20,000 light years away? Can you imagine one day they just... stop?

[@jemborg]

@@RepentJC... or not.

[@Technodude255]

@@jemborg i can't amagine what we'd hear or see or any senses beyond our own bodies. What i can say for sure is that day by day we'll keep improving our transmission range and communication abilities.

[@hughjanus6041]

So happy to see your KZbin family growing Anton.

[@NatureJoePureCanadian]

This is my favourite channel!!! Thank for all the great education and keeping us updated on the latest discoveries from the observational universe!

[@DeadDave666]

A million subs. That's great bro. You deserve it. Your videos are very informative and interesting to watch. You explain things in layman's terms so even a guy like me can understand. Thanks for ur hard work and dedication to the universe. Be safe. Much respect from Detroit. 🔥😈🔥

[@MichaelOfRohan]

Consistently interesting, easy to listen to, and already gathered the relevant papers for my later curiosity. This channel is one giant class act.

[@MichaelOfRohan]

@James Henry Smith Not everyone loves Anton, so if it is here today, it isn't him. "He will be loved by all the world, and take his seat to proclaim himself god on earth," or something like that. Anyway, it hasn't happened yet and judging by how much we hate each other, it may not need to... I guess the answer to your question is no, but your comment is important because it shows we can still question each other as a species, and that is required for us to evolve. So thank you for pointing out that anton is just like us, and nothing more.

[@briantaylor1578]

What do our radio signals look like? For example if the voyager probe turned around and looked at us what would it “see”

[@jacksonjohnson9674]

2:42 That is my favorite explanation of where something in deep space is located. "Eh, turn this direction and it's somewhere in the direction you are currently looking." lol love it. Anton is my favorite astronomy youtuber, so I'm not poking fun.

[@jimcurtis9052]

Wonderful as always anton. Thank you. 😊

[@nugboy420]

I love how in depth and multi sided you get with your videos. Love. It.

[@Jurassic_Fart]

Pls don’t say “it’s most likely natural phenomena or measurement error.” Just let me believe.

[@JessiV111]

Right !? Haha

[@rootedorganically4911]

It’s either a fart or a rave

[@JessiV111]

@@rootedorganically4911 😂

[@curtisdecoste9345]

No click bait or ambiguity with Anton. Always straight up “It’s not aliens.” 😆

[@jeffstock7819]

I mean it COULD be. They admit they don't know and I heard nothing that would rule it out...

[@kingjames1308]

Im never worried about aliens… until that day Anton is like… “this is aliens” then i know its the real deal

[@BBoldGaming]

Technically we are the aliens

[@HarlanHarvey76]

When enough data comes in, soon we will be saying that we are surrounded by intelligent life and it's been out there this whole time.

[@terryhemingway6983]

From the wizard of ID. The wizard at his telescope tells Flo, his wife,"I've just discovered Intelligent life." Flo asks, "Why aren't they communicating with us?" The wizard replies, "You weren't listening ..."

[@Novak2611]

Before the 90s, everybody had a radio telescope at home able to detect the big bang. Now very few people have them, probably only in some developing countries 😉.

[@timsullivan4566]

Despite (or because of) your speedy speech, I could - and occasionally do - listen to you for hours . Thanks for your not inconsiderable efforts in delivering so much excellent content. Quantity AND quality - how can you beat that?

[@timsullivan4566]

@James Henry SmithWell yeah, but why do you ask?

[@cmdrvex]

Anton, you are a calm and rational face in a mad world! Thank you!

[@R-bobo]

Anton being so laid back, even if it was alien his demeanour and body language would stay the same.

[@Dyslexic-Artist-Theory-on-Time]

Great images and info!!!

[@sevensohigh2083]

Hello wonderful Anton... We really appreciate you my brother thank you!

[@hybridtechowns]

Thank you for continuing your work

[@acemanNL]

Come on Anton, we want ALIENS! 👽

[@chrisfuller1268]

Agreed, we expect intelligent radio transmissions to have tight frequency accuracy, unless they are very early in their development of radio (e.g. spark gap transmitters)

[@user-ii9vn6vo6k]

If we ever find aliens or they contact us, I just want Anton to get on every news network and say "um, it IS aliens..."

[@paradox7358]

"Something unknown is doing we don't know what." Arthur Eddington

[@jobinFOG]

amazing video as always

[@johnkoch2]

Anton - I really love your channel and fact-based reporting on things like this without all the sensationalism. First, I am very sorry to read the side-panel note about losing a child - that is a horrible experience that no parent should ever have to go through. Knowing several people who have lost children, I know there is nothing I can say to bring peace, but I send my heartfelt condolences to you and your family. Second - I am curious what the pink triangle represents on the "heat map" of the radio signals. Thanks again for all you do.

[@grfd-xs8me]

When you got to the part about the possibility of the object responsible for the radio signals being behind the galaxy that was what came to my mind. There is a chance that it’s close enough to the galaxy to have the dust in the galaxy amplify the signal.

[@view1st]

Maybe this will kick-start a new space race the way the launch of Sputnik, the first artificial satellite, did: which nation can discover aliens first.

[@TheAaronDrew]

Thank you, wonderful Anton

[@easyadmin3429]

You look GOOD ! Love your Videos! Keep it ON! Cheers!

[@michaelmcgarrity6987]

Little Green Men is my favorite part of the day. TY Anton.

[@nugboy420]

Hello wonderful Anton.

[@ArchaicHumansWorldwide]

I worked on the big Electron Cyclotron Maser at USC (designed the premodulating cavity) and masers can be formed in the oddest ways in the cosmos.

[@MrJitendra007]

Love you Anton for your information 👌❤️❤️

[@BRIANJAMESGIBB]

Loving the point about given how many 'telescopes' we now have existing explanations are now being overwhelmed by data gathered... OMG - astronomy is now a REAL science :)

[@dianastevenson131]

Information overload comes to astronomy.

[@tuxuhds6955]

Check it in six months to see if the phenomenon is parallaxing compared to the said galaxy position. That should give a range estimation, assuming that radio source remains steady.

[@CanabisRevolution]

Thank you Anton

[@jasonhardison7103]

Belated congratulations on 1million subs.

[@robinchwan]

if you wish for people to get interested into space and the unknown you got to spice it up a lot in a way they can't dismiss and they can't really prove if it's true or not. people need to get excited, tourist attractions where we terraform a planet and make beautiful vistas and breathtaking waterfalls etc etc. caves that glow in the dark because of crystals etc. you also need to bait them where they get to own a piece of land they help to make liveable. space ships we can easily fly like cars nowadays where all you need is a simple license

[@ThomasKelly669]

Fascinating 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🕊

[@AlwaysSunnyInBooTube]

The first thing I wait to hear when I watch a video like this from Anton: "It's very likely not eliens"

[@hl8333]

great video

[@mbukukanyau]

The Asgard opened a hyper space window to take a planet with them to another galaxy

[@Msnicole223]

Every time Anton says it’s not aliens, I die a little inside. Lol 😂 Hey you wonderful ppl, first before you think anything unprecedented in the search for alien life has emerged, let me crush your hopes and dreams. 😜

[@dkeffectdetector8920]

aliens watches you right now, it's the igigi [the greys, the borgs, the abomination], they are led by half annunaki and half igigi [bastard] called marduk [yehova, baal, moloch, zeus, horus], marduk is a psycho path he got evicted from the Council horus wants us all to become borgs as well you are living inside an aquarium, you live in a matrix

[@onlinemodus]

Whats so funny about it

[@MrAnderson4509]

As always fantastic I wish I had lots and lots of cash to just sponsor you out right maybe one day I'll have a job that feeds me and my friends and takes care of my utilities but I'll ask my skill sets which are amazing and my knowledge in this country are repaired by offers of jobs of labor that as little money as they could possibly pay legally. Hence why years in days grill closer to an end for building models to test the parameters of this universe, to experiment and prove or disprove what I know exists through science in observation

[@darkomadjanovic7538]

Elektrika, bro, elektrika. Živiš majstore u srednjem vijeku. Pomalo tužno ali na sreću smiješno! 😀

[@iiseedeadpeople]

I have a good feeling about the “source is behind the galaxy” theory. that was my immediate thought when looking at the map, and it is the simplest answer.

[@Roguescienceguy]

"It's not elliens" 🤣 each time he says it with his accent, it makes me giggle. It's quintessential Anton

[@jairo8746]

Any intelligent signal traveling from so far would be pretty much unintelligible by the time it reaches earth.

[@SeniorMoostacho]

Hello Wonderful Anton. Loving your following up on this and yet still saying, it cant be from aliens. Tell me please, is it a planet pulsing? Is it a moon, exploding? I love it all... your very animated. 8D

[@ghostcat5303]

If we've got a lot of unexplained phenomena and a lot of theories that aren't explaining them well, then surely that points to new physics. Super exciting.

[@progressor4ward85]

Is there a way to detect artificially entangled particsls used for communication, if we can maybe we should in tandem search for those types of signals as well.

[@joestrat2723]

Considering the near infinity of the universe, and the exotic elements, energies, bodies, and near infinite combinations thereof, I think anomalous radio detection is a nothingburger. Of course there's going to be a lot of weird electromagnetic noise. Unless it's saying in clear English "Shut up, they'll hear you," I'm not much interested.

[@colors6692]

I get the feeling that Anton, the Eastern European, does not believe in Aliens!

[@beta_cygni1950]

No, I don't get that sense. He does correctly need to see evidence before he attributes anything to aliens though. And the fact is these types of things have ALWAYS been proved to NOT be aliens before.

[@dawnagamble1549]

That is very awesome!!

[@russellsmejkal304]

Do they ever run these signals through things like old satellite antennas and hook them up to a TV of send them there an am/fm frequency. To see what happens. Do you think they have tried things like that at all. I’m jest wondering because what if there is something out there trying to contact us but we are jest using the wrong thing to understand it

[@cjtymczak4687]

Hello wonderful Anton

[@christisking1576]

Humans: "Here we are.. Hello!" Aliens: "Shhhhh! They'll hear you!"

[@stopthat1546]

Love you Anton

[@kyleness12]

I’ve watched your videos for years. I’ve had a few drinks tonight and you talk to fast for me now. Wanna sober up to learn damn you

[@ast0nv8]

Question? If an alien species was looking at our radio signals wouldn’t ours also be unpredictable?

[@brosephbroman7564]

Yeah, they assume it would be predictable coming from aliens. We haven't discovered other life to be an example, but they want to assume.

[@gooberclown]

The content would be unpredictable, based as it is on enculturation. However, our current and recently past light emissions would be recognizable as a form of artificial technological data.

[@ast0nv8]

@@gooberclownWe’ll be far well into our extinction by the time anyone answered back.

[@vermasean]

Anyone else think they missed a part of the video when the video doesn’t start w/ “Hello Wonderful Person”? 🙃🙋‍♀️🙋‍♂️

[@strixfiremind]

Yeah, even backed it up to hear it lol

[@dieseldes1301]

I’m gutted I don’t feel so wonderful anymore!

[@_________________404]

He said it at about 0:40

[@karoshi2]

@@_________________404 Not to nitpick: 0:37

[@dieseldes1301]

@@_________________404 phew that’s a relief !

[@Shideous]

Yay, White hole not eliminated as of now. I can dream a while longer. 😁 Thank you for the videos. Allways amazing new stuff.

[@LordDustinDeWynd]

It's not surprising that no one has seriously looked at that galaxy - there's SO MANY OTHER wonders to behold!

[@flashahhasavedeveryoneofus2824]

Super interesting

[@ImTheDaveman]

One thing for certain is., that one day, perhaps in the far distant future, astronomers in a different galaxy will pick up mysterious signals from a place they will learn eventually, called Earth. I mean - it's not like we have been quiet or hiding our small world. We make all kinds of sounds. I'm just curious what they would think of our music (especially rock and roll) and our TV broadcasts. Assuming these signals have not degraded so bad they are indecipherable. And I wonder if Earth will still be here when that happens. In my own personal opinion - any signals that would survive that kind of distance would be unrecoverable and be interpreted as nothing more than noise. Maybe some of these signals we get are from intelligent life somewhere, just far too weak to understand as anything but space noise.

[@halverde6373]

So that radio signal is 60 million years old. If it were alien, 60 million years of their evolution has taken place. They would be gods to us now.

[@uhohhotdog]

Or long gone

[@rauljimenez8132]

Or Extinct.

[@view1st]

Dead or alive, if it is aliens then it would still be absolutely amazing.

[@scottowens1535]

Hey Anton, What do you think our signature looks like from their? perspective. Are we obvious to someone looking? And how does our presence reflect in the background.

[@Booyabocka]

It seems this always gets ignored, but if gravity affects light, then gravity can affect radio signals. With this in mind, a perfectly symmetrical and syncopated signal can be distorted by various gravity sources during its lightyears of travel towards us, and finally arrives as a chaotic mess of random noise.

[@Microxz141]

I always love anton awkward but beautiful smile in the end :>

[@DataJuggler]

0:42 Even though he is wrong in my case, it is still nice to hear it.

[@manowartank8784]

Every mainstream news media: ALIENS? Anton with calm voice: No.

[@qwadratix]

'Oh, God aliens again! Everything is aliens with you. That time we used a whole bog-roll in one day. You thought that was aliens!' Dave Lister. Red Dwarf.

[@MaxBrix]

1% means you should see one in every hundred galaxies.

[@falcychead8198]

Do we know for certain that it actually is in NGC 2082, and not within our galaxy lying along our line of sight?

[@pauls5745]

i like that there are enough stellar objects to study that there is more than enough for every astronomer to have each their own galaxy to study haha

[@LuisHerrera-mq9uk]

hello wonderful dork

[@waynegoddard4065]

Would you be surprised if you were watching a television programme and one of the experts they spoke to about space was young Anton?

[@mraggressivestoic8442]

My guess is that it's a entire piezoelectric planet with a metal asteroid impact acting as a broadcast antenna

[@mountain_man_mike]

Hello wonderful radio signal

[@anastephens2214]

👍 myself also I love when you put out New videos

[@ro4eva]

Anton, you're such a wholesome guy.

[@brucevennell810]

So what galaxy is this,radeon signals travel the speed of light so if this place is how fare away? So is the galaxy still there?