Rafe Heydel-Mankoo | This House Would Pay Reparations

[@johncatto5019]

These are supposed to be some of the most intelligent people in the country and yet they still refuse to listen to the truth. What hope is there for their future ?

[@Threemore650]

Quite disgusting behaviour. I was ashamed of them. Standards have plummeted.

[@goodlookinouthomie1757]

There is no real thought, only the awareness of what they must think - or appear to think.

[@bugzyhardrada3168]

These kids don't seem to have much hope for a decent future, all things considered. Their overwhelming desire to remain so woefully ignorant will most definitely lead them to a life of anger, resentment, misery and ultimately suffering, which they will blame on the rest of us. We indeed are in for a not-so-fun-ride in the not-so-distant-future.

[@mattwilliams369]

Cambridge students aren't there because they're intelligent. They're there because mummy donates to the Cambridge Union and daddy plays golf with the Dean (and got the Dean's son a job jn the City). The real intelligent youth are found in the upper performing universities outwith the elitist Oxbridge Bubble. St Andrews, Durham, Glasgow, Edinburgh, UCL.

[@saltymonke3682]

Wait it until 25, after that they will think rationally. Liz Truss is a prime example of swinging ideology and age

[@therageknight8546]

Very shocking to see the absolute disrespect displayed by these students who are meant to be the “future” of our country.

[@Omglolwut]

Your country is in trouble

[@WayneLynch69]

NEVER would I have imagined the green & white striped shirt girl was even college material. Shows how much test taking and parroting back misrepresents in admission.

[@cx3929]

The UK is doomed with disrespect & denial shown by the Cambridge students in the background. Cambridge is supposed to be one of the best universities in the world with the brightest minds. Unlike the US where they have the economy and with the USD as the reserve currency of the world, the UK is no longer part of the EU and will continue to decline in every aspect on the world stage.

[@timothyhallett3724]

As always with this speaker, opinions are underlined with well chosen, broad ranging facts, rather than weak and emotional arguments used in the counter argument. If people who are concerned about historic slavery were as concerned about modern slavery they could truly claim the virtue they crave and do so in a useful cause.

[@pablotheScot56]

If you think people who were never slaves should be given money by people who have never owned slaves, then may I suggest you pay them yourself since you feel so guilty.

[@mjgaming7603]

Your ancestors may not be alive but their money does and it passes on , First you acknowledge that you have hurt them , then heal the part that you have caused damage, then say we won't do it again that's how things work You won't do the first thing 🤣🙏

[@pablotheScot56]

@@mjgaming7603 my ancestors never owned slaves unlike yours. If you feel guilty about inheriting money from your forefathers then give it all up. My inheritance from my father was under £10,000 not the fortune you think I received. Again if you feel guilty then turn all your assets into cash and give it someone who has never been a slave. That is how it should work.

[@Facts-Over-Feelings]

THE WEALTH YOU ENJOY IN THE NATION TO THIS DAY IS FROM SLAVERY.. SO THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD PAY.. THE SAME WAY GERMANS PAY THE EUROPEAN JEWS.. ITS A DEBT OWED.. I NOTICE THEY PUT UP THIS INDIAN SELLOUT TO PUSH THE RACIST EUROPEAN TALKING POINT.. BLACK SOLD BLACKS BS.. THE ARAB CACAZOIDS STARTED THE CHATTEL SLAVE TRADE.. AND THERE IS NO SLAVE TRADE IF ARABS AND EUROPEANS DIDN'T PUSH THE DEMAND.. THE MARKET IS DRIVEN BY THE BUYER.. NOT SELLER..

[@Aiphiae]

I'm a high school teacher. Some of the rowdiest classes I've ever had were more respectful of guest speakers than these kids. I expected so much more from students fortunate enough to go to an institution such as Cambridge. Their lack of humility and openness to new (or competing) ideas is anathema to everything universities stand for. These kids should be utterly humiliated their infantile behaviour has been captured and permanently put on display for all to see.

[@markstott6689]

I have to agree. It was more reminiscent of my 6th Form common room 40 years ago than a supposedly August Cambridge Union.

[@problemswithmark]

Brilliant, I would have paid to hear him speak. Thanks for the upload.

[@retrodad6864]

And me. Brilliant speaker. 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧

[@chrisgodfrey6353]

Snickering and giggling at hard truths. Best brains of the country? Look to our future political leaders in the room so far removed from reality and the electorate. There's got to be a better way.

[@maggiemathars235]

The behaviour of the "students" sitting behind the speaker is utterly disgraceful. They have the manners of toddlers and are obviously determined not to listen to anyone who does not agree with them.

[@jenniferbate9682]

Badly brought up toddlers. My children would have been immediately taken outside and given a severe talking to.

[@michaelwhite8031]

All of the smug students will probably get good jobs while the poor working class who never gained from slavery will pay the reparations.

[@stub1256]

The audience..Ohh the horror ohh the outrage!! Wheres Nanny?

[@michaeljay4816]

Wow... The audience is as disrespectful as their attire is shabby. Have they no respect for one another? I don't think many of them were able to hear the speaker, having written him off before he began to speak, perhaps.

[@LOCATIONREDACTED]

If someone's talking, either leave or listen, particularly if you don't agree with them. They need to check their privilege as people seem keen on saying these days!

[@yamoto1833]

These students shows a very reactionary offensive and impolite attitude to engage in a debate.

[@guyellis19]

The behaviour of the people behind is appalling especially the girl in the green and white top - no interest or attention span - a future PM maybe

[@photoplanet]

Future comedian, perhaps (in the Cambridge 'Footlights' tradition)... Everything she said had Henry (or Tristran, Cuthbert or whoever next to her) entertained throughout...

[@m1tche11one]

Great RAF! 🫶🏻👍🏻

[@Threemore650]

Rafe. He’s wonnnnnnderful isn’t he.

[@peace-yv4qd]

The children sitting in back of the speaker snickering, chatting and texting are the future? God help the future.

[@mange2]

You will never change these young peoples minds because they view what you say as YOUR facts not THE facts. Its the way they contrive their own knowledge so think everyone else does. The Universities are complicit.

[@sheldonrichardson784]

Facts are stubborn things...... Rafe is correct.

[@Rickalicious]

So distracting when the audience keeps wanting to interrupt but then don't seem to even care to listen to the arguments of the speaker

[@Rallylabs]

If anyone can be bothered actually doing any research(certainly the children in attendance clearly can’t), all of these points actually hold up to scrutiny, unlike those of his opponents.

[@johnmccormick9992]

Are we now going to jail descendants for murder committed by an ancestor 300years ago? If these are our future l despair!

[@mjgaming7603]

Jail nope , First acknowledge that you have done harm , then heal the part which was damaged, then say we will not do it again You are not doing the first thing 😂🙏

[@sentientmlem727]

The difference between Cambridge and Oxford is most telling in the way the audience dresses. At Oxford, people dress for an important event. Here at Cambridge, students dress like they are going to a the movies.

[@apollocreed1000]

I don't think that's correct. All students dress casually. Oxford is much more aggressive to its right leaning speakers.

[@user-oi8ue3ns1g]

The group behind him have no manners. Isn't it common decency to listen when somebody has given their time to speak whether you agree or not with what's being said? Could it be they believe they know everything about this subject and have nothing to learn? They have shown their ignorance. Cambridge needs to teach independent critical thinking.

[@dreyfuss06]

Listening would mean cognitive dissonance. Listening would mean that the basis of their moral positions and the way they see themselves and the world is wrong. It’s easier to ignore and discredit an argument that to listen and admit all of that.

[@jeremyvlad5771]

What an utter embarrassment the students in this hall are

[@landsea7332]

6:00 Its no secret that China has operative students influencing Western Universities . Later in this debate this kid asks " Do you think we are still suffering from the consequences of slavery ? " Ask this kid how many millions died during China's Cultural Revolution and Great Leap Forward , and watch what his reaction is . .

[@jamesdufc1]

Why do they all look 12 years old

[@joannasimmonds3706]

Because that's the age of their emotional maturity

[@mariansheilamansilla6431]

Because you're old? Lol

[@icojb25]

I love this guy

[@Threemore650]

Just checking to see if you chaps have edited this marvellously articulate man. Hawklike, I am. How do you get angry about us buying your ancestor’s freedom. The names of who were paid of are accessible. Take it up with them!

[@deborahrobertson8606]

I am only a few minutes in and have decided to listen rather than watch. The behaviour of these ill bred toddlers around Mr Heydel-Mankoo is unendurable. What in God's name has happened to our august institutions?

[@sedwarg]

Those children sat behind the speaker are insufferable. I trust they have been banned from the Union for their disrespectful attitude and behaviour.

[@CarlAvoryMusic]

A room full of privilege that appears to be taking very little notice of just how privileged it is. I imagine the chances of finding someone that is actually connected to slavery is comparatively high in that room. Come on folks! You're the future. You'll be taking care of my kids. Please learn to absorb truth and not populism 🙏

[@vlyoz6088]

are these the students Cambridge University are representing? Disgraceful

[@vlyoz6088]

poor calibre of the Cambridge University audience

[@adamcotton2121]

I can hear the pimples popping from across the Atlantic...

[@Mike-tb9xq]

From Newton and Hawking to this lot...

[@thierrylx]

I very much hope, any of my 2 daughters ever aspire to go to any of these institutions...

[@ThatGuy-nt4jv]

Everyone who proposes reparations should be made to be the first in line with their wallets out, lead the way guys if this is so important

[@claudineijesus2230]

We applaud ourselves sir for the veracity of the facts in civil society and how the "youth" needs to come together and join forces for the future.

[@tombuddy100]

Debate Results: Prop: 302 | Absn: 67 | Opp: 93 I wonder haw many of these people (or kids) would vote pro Ottoman Empire pay reperations. Also, I wonder why Turkey does not even have such debates in their major university.

[@bjg3474]

Just brilliant.

[@aussiefarmer4955]

This just proves some educators are twisted enough to teach emotions to their students and not facts.

[@PD-uc5st]

The students sitting behind Rafe are rude arrogant and simply not able to accept facts. They are not open to reasonable debate. It is shocking to see this level of disrespect. I would understand their childish behaviour if they were 10-year-olds.

[@Rallylabs]

Why do they not have a minimum dress standard at these things? It is embarrassing to see people who resemble a teenager in a graphic tee smirking and sniggering in the background. It really shows a disappointing level of immaturity and laziness.

[@littlecatfeet9064]

I don’t think these best and brightest of minds know what a child of empire is or anything about tort law. Great speech though.

[@threecatsteve]

Glad you presents these facts that most ignore.

[@m1tche11one]

So true

[@jenniferbate9682]

I’m appalled at these young students rude attitude. No respect! Talking during the lecture and their continued interruptions are unbelievable and sad. This is our future! As an 80 year old, it leaves me completely distraught and incredulous.

[@philipdoran6596]

A very reasoned argument littered with facts. I have to add quite disturbing to see the infantile behaviour of some of the students . If you cannot attend a serious debate without smirking, chatting and interrupting the speaker, I suggest you shouldn’t be there in the first place. Well done Rafe.

[@assyriannahrin]

As someone Iraq he speaks the TRUTH

[@JimiGosu]

As I've come to expect from Rafe, his argument was factual, intelligent, and respectful. The behavior of these kids towards intelligence and truth is appalling. It's absurd that these kids aspire to ignorance and seem to revel in it so proudly. Not to mention their lack of respect and civility.

[@diannegough5830]

Hello Rafe, Cornwall also was raided and Cornishman enslaved by Barbary Pirates.

[@joannasimmonds3706]

Pearls before swine, unfortunately. Watching this" audience's" behaviour during this measured and informative speech makes me want to burn another ton of fossil fuel

[@advasity339]

Wait if these people can get into Cambridge maybe I do have a chance...

[@JenE3377]

The universities indoctrinate and don't educate. The experience of liberal education being like a man who lives in a town near a high mountain. He has grown up in the town and knows it like the back of his hand. But one day he climbs the mountain and comes to see not only the town in a new way-as a whole and from above-but also within the much broader context, catching sight of other towns and even other mountains. But it does not end there. After he returns to his town, his vision is forever changed. His view of the part is forever mediated by his integrated view of the whole. And his vision is marked by humility. For while he may now have an integrated and expansive vision, he also knows how limited his previous vision had been and how much more he still has to learn.

[@cx3929]

The UK is doomed with disrespect & denial shown by the Cambridge students in the background. Cambridge is supposed to be one of the best universities in the world with the brightest minds. Unlike the US where they have the economy and with the USD as the reserve currency of the world, the UK is no longer part of the EU and will continue to decline in every aspect on the world stage.

[@johnfowler7266]

Well said!!!

[@m1dn1ght5un]

Appalling behaviour from some of those in the audience. I hope they were sanctioned by the Union.

[@helenh8540]

just look at hongkong and mainland china, which one is better.

[@janeking5730]

Why as a mark of respect are cell phones not completely banned from these events. As for the ludicrous inane grinning idiot in the green and white top, I think she floundered into this debate by mistake. Future leaders, the thought is terrifying .

[@davehug5405]

The smug youngsters in the back honestly know nothing

[@hacgarimman9660]

Rafes speech/rebuttal isn't even opinion. It's fact. I find it incredibly naive to deny facts over opinion. How many are jeering, talking to each ither and playing on phones? They are a disgrace and I cannot even imagine what thier contributions to society will do. They should have given thier seats to someone who will do something positive with that information.

[@johnfowler7266]

Yes the slave owner got money!!!! Where is that money now??? The majority of British people never benefited from colonialism!!! It was a small minority!!’

[@davidwell686]

Rafe Heydel-Mankoo

[@MadelineMcneill]

I am from working class stock. The working classes never owned slaves, the wealthy and aristocracy owned slaves, let them pay reparation.

[@wychwoodfolkclub]

Don't think any of them are actually listening. That's the Xbox generation for you

[@makomadns4]

XBOX? Thats the TikTok generation, XBOX gen has already graduated, in the workforce and having kids.

[@litestuffllc7249]

If the Bahama's can't produce a list of harmed parties with evidence they are not compromised in their claim; then - was the slave status warranted? What if the original party put into bondage in Africa had murdered or raped or done some other crime for which they were put into bondage. Few if any slaves were brought with documentation as to why they were in bondage. Can we presume the bondage was not justified? What is fair compensation if I kill your husbund stealing money; and he was the breadwinner? Put me in prison? How does the aid or resplace your loss? Todays prisons are more like vacation homes, no work requirement.

[@tommyrotton9468]

who owes?

[@peterhobday]

Don't blame the students for being disrespectful. These students compete to show compassion 4 poor black people.. If even one of them agrees with Rafe, the speaker, they would be ostracized by the fellow students and find life at the university intolerable. Such is life...

[@lanehennefer5896]

and I guarantee they wouldn't step foot in a black area or help a black person walking on the street if their lives depended on it. The most liberal kids there are actually the most racist in the real world.

[@g.pmoore4293]

The audience all look about 12 years old !

[@wrongfullyaccused7139]

Well, since they act like they are twelve......

[@beatrizmurphy2724]

WHOS PAYING REPARATIONS TO THE NATIVES AMERICANS INDIANS???!!!!

[@litestuffllc7249]

You know this guy employed me for less that I should have gotten 20 years ago; shouldnt I be able to sue is family? He passed away; but they still are benefiting my my ilgotten work. All those people who had monopolies before they were made illegal - can't we go back and sue the Rockefellers; Monopoly was legal then but now we know it was bad. My X wifes family lost property to the Communists in China; shouldn't they be able to sue the Communists for that now? I am part Ecudorian; now that it is accepted the king of spain stole our gold and emeralds - shouldn't I get my share back now sure its been 400 years but I want my share back OK?

[@dawsonklinger]

What use is the truth when it falls upon deaf ears?

[@RezaRob3]

I am going to upvote this video because he said several extremely important things such as the burning of widows being banned by the British Empire. However, I would like to point out that the claim about India's population growing very fast during the Raj isn't a valid argument. The world population was doing the same thing. India's population growth compared to that of the world, just before the Raj, or during the Raj wasn't much different - if you compare the two time periods roughly around 1600-1750 compared to 1800-1950 (or the period of the Raj which was around 1850-1950), India, compared to the world, didn't change. UPDATE: I just realized that 80% of the world at this time was colonized by Europe - not just Britain. So, it might indeed be valid to say that Europe, in general, brought better health to the world. It might be interesting to compare this to the 20% that was not colonized.

[@RezaRob3]

UPDATE: I just realized that 80% of the world at this time was colonized by Europe - not just Britain. So, it might indeed be valid to say that Europe, in general, brought better health to the world. It might be interesting to compare this to the 20% that was not colonized.

[@daisyfish-fn4js]

The inability of these students to separate emotions from genuine debate and a search for truth is scary. They appear more bothered about appearing virtuous then listening to him to to seek truth. They appear to want absolute purity from historical figures and he's right only british figures for them to be considered as decent people. The appear to think of themselves as better then the people as came before them as opposed to being equally fallable and flawed. They don't seem to care about the truth what they seem to care about is fitting in with what the current narrative tells us is morally superior and its people like that I don't trust, but honestly it's their parents fault and their teachers fault.

[@KemetecusScholar]

Epigenetic harm caused by Slavery and Colonialism is real and cannot be disputed scientifically. It is beyond the legal statute of limitation as it does not affect just individual but is passed on genetically to a collective or Nation of People, and is the reason why reparations must be paid in full.

[@shivamvishal4497]

The only reason he doesn't allow any interventions by those students because he knows they would debunk all the factual misrepresentation (intellectual dishonesty) on which his arguments were based on. Shashi Tharoor, Vijay Prasad were right when they said, colonialism wasn't something of past from which everyone has moved on.. it's a permanent condition, it's in the mentality.. they would not acknowledge the horrors of it, but certainly pat thir backs saying how much benefits it did.

[@prescottsmith6561]

This host is totally lost. He knows nothing of this subject area at all.

[@shiva____]

The only reason he doesn't allow any interventions by those students because he knows they would debunk all the factual misrepresentation (intellectual dishonesty) on which his arguments were based on. Shashi Tharoor, Vijay Prasad were right when they said, colonialism wasn't something of past from which everyone has moved on.. it's a permanent condition, it's in the mentality.. they would not acknowledge the horrors of it, but certainly pat thir backs saying how much benefits it did.