Raga Chords Season 2 - EP 6 - Nattai/Jog

[@samuelrobert2927]

Diatonically speaking Bb and Bdim shouldn't be the harmonic part of Nattai scale because note d is absent from the scale. Unless you're working with borrowed chords...

[@onlymusic400]

All Raagas chords give sir continue

[@kamleshdasmahant837]

Aapka channel itna underrated hi kya btau Mariana trench se bhi zyada under hai 😭

[@KarthikSekaran]

hahahaha..good one

[@mellowmonsoon278]

Hi thanks for this Cm wouldn’t work for Jog right ?

[@KarthikSekaran]

Yes it should. since both the Ga show up.

[@vishwanathSuvarna-qe5ue]

Super sir

[@qkbarbland4332]

So I have a question, at 3:46 when you're moving from a Csus4 to a C and then to a Cm , does that mean when we sing "ma ga ri sa" in nattai with the tanpura droning from Sa Pa Sa, we're actually "harmonizing" with the tanpura within these chords? It's an absurd thought but I was curious

[@KarthikSekaran]

Absolutely right. And it’s not absurd at all. The concept of harmony in Indian classical music doesn’t exist but the fact is that we do harmonize with the tanpura. In fact it is that very harmony that tells us whether we are singing the notes properly or not. Don’t you agree?

[@qkbarbland4332]

@@KarthikSekaran yesss!!! I completely agree!! I thought that means every note we sing within a Sa Pa Sa tanpura is harmonizing with either the sa or the pa, but now seeing your videos I think the shudha Ri purely functions as a gateway to resolution? or does it harmonize with the tanpura as well?

[@KarthikSekaran]

@@qkbarbland4332 it’s both. There are dissonant harmonies and then consonant harmonies. While dissonant one’s build the tension and give us a sense that “there is more to come” the consonant gives a feel of coming home. The shudh Ri wants to come to the Sa but with the tanpura it is still harmonizing.

[@qkbarbland4332]

@@KarthikSekaran ahhh I understand now, thanks so much for taking the time to respond!! I learnt a lot and this had been nagging my brain for so long I'm glad a professional well versed in western and carnatic theory could finally verify it 😄🙏

[@KarthikSekaran]

@@qkbarbland4332 Hey I am glad I am able to help..:)

[@Navajeevan273]

Thank you sir ❤🙏🙏

[@KarthikSekaran]

You’re welcome ☺️

[@ashokflash]

PLEASE TELL ME PERFECT WEBSITE FOR ALL RAGA NOTES, WITH JANYA TOO

[@KarthikSekaran]

Wikipedia is a good starting place

[@ashokflash]

@@KarthikSekaran ji please videos about key change modulations in carnatic ragas

[@pradeepedayam2208]

Please..speech..note

[@pianopianist392]

wow💙

[@KarthikSekaran]

Thank you 🙏

[@submadkicdar]

Chennai senthamizh.. Iyengaar veetu azhaghe

[@sreekumar990]

Malkauns pls... 🙏🏼

[@KarthikSekaran]

That's the first episode of season 3, which is releasing on 20th May. Please do watch.

[@pradeepedayam2208]

😢😢😢