Ranking All Cave Island Monsters! [Remastered] (My Singing Monsters)

[@GameyGaming]

Cave isn’t necessarily just a rock song. It has a spookier side to it, so a more old-fashioned instrument like Krillby is able to fit in with the theme

[@sampler2]

I'd say it's more orchestral and climatic than rock

[@3D_PUPPO]

It is a rock song, theres alot of things that match what a rock song is. Krillby just dont fit

[@GameyGaming]

@@3D_PUPPO Most MSM songs don’t fit any one specific genre of music, which is kind of the point of them. If you shove one into a category then you won’t see monsters like Krillby as fitting for the song, but they’re _supposed_ to be unique and versatile.

[@3D_PUPPO]

@@GameyGaming it still doesnt fit with how powerful the song is. Idc if its meant to be versatile, cuz thats like saying bugbo is a good monster and fits in light island.

[@MountainDewisthebest]

@@3D_PUPPO Well I think it fits light

[@TheRealRobloxNoobie13]

“A screaming booger” is crazy 💀💀😭😭 I feel bad for Yelmut.

[@PastNoobGamer90]

she does sound horrible when shes called a screaming booger smh

[@gargflow3336]

@@PastNoobGamer90a yummy gummy bear that sings

[@jurassicguineapig6697]

I thought he was a slug

[@That_1Pumpkin]

⁠@@jurassicguineapig6697Yelmut reminds me of jello with a helmet

[@PastNoobGamer90]

@@That_1Pumpkin screaming jello

[@Diimbou]

1:04 Oh yeah, my favorite fire monster, *mammott*

[@Boiky_Cheezooks]

Mammot is the best fire monster

[@ThingamajigThing]

Mammott carries amber island tbh

[@TheOrbGrindIsPrettyOrby]

I loved Cold Haven with the new monster, Mammot!

[@Dominus-ss8nq]

Can’t wait for cold oasis

[@hunterliam100]

Damn it you stole my comment

[@mrsgbrandi]

1:03 *screaming booger* ☠️

[@thestewartfam6333]

Quibble’s second track on cave island is 180 bpm in 3/4. His other 2 tracks are 120 bpm in swing.

[@hunterliam100]

Crazy 1: Gnarl 2: Glowl+Yelmit 3: Shellbeat+Riff 4:Bison boi 5: Everyone else.

[@Noggin-msm-u6p]

0:noggin msm

[@CringusMcDingus]

I’ll never understand the pongping hate. I mean, they didn’t need to add it, but they did, and it offers a catchy percussion rhythm too!

[@Its_A.Secret618]

It’s just not as good as any of the other monsters. No monster is bad on cave.

[@CringusMcDingus]

@@Its_A.Secret618 Amen to that. But idk why people usually put it last when ranking pongping sounds

[@thestewartfam6333]

Pongping is actually good on cave island IMO. He fits the vibe of cave island cuz his pongs and pings moving super fast sound like a double bass drum. Double bass drums are used in sludge metal music. Cave island is 40% sludge metal. So that’s why I like pongping on cave island.

[@Playerano8isntcool]

4:56 is there any chance I influenced this being higher? (I made an obscure comment you may have not read about it being audible)

[@U.S.E.R2-f7n]

W tier bro 😭🙏 Also does someone else remember when this got out 30 minutes ago? Those were the good times

[@mrsgbrandi]

IMO 0th place is prismatic riff (purple tier)

[@The_Jo_Bro]

Quibbles 2nd track is a slight delay in each note and change in dynamic for dramatic effect and to purposely sound wild and erratic since it fits the song.

[@FURIOUSNOOB1211]

You honestly have some of the best tier lists! also, is it weird that my favourite verse of this song is the start with riff quibble and shell beat

[@Chickenman241]

2:14 ahhhh, my favorite monster, cave island

[@FutureProGamer90]

Huh?

[@pizzaman2453]

@@FutureProGamer90 you didn’t include gnarls name in the top left

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@pizzaman2453 I didn’t make the video. That was void monster

[@pizzaman2453]

@@FutureProGamer90 ooooh

[@ZiHaoSaw]

​@@FutureProGamer90He doesnt exist in real life 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀

[@mrsgbrandi]

1:04 YOU FOUND A VIDEO WHERE THEY THOUGHT KAYNA WAS MAMMOTT

[@3D_PUPPO]

This ranking format reminds me of Inanimate insanity II, 19 contestants, A merge at 8, and the final 4 being the most known about that season and how long its been at the final 4.

[@Darealgoofytho]

1:Gnarls🟪(It sounds so heavenly. An amazing way to end off DOF.Doesen't carry though) 2:Shellbeat🟪(This guy is easily the best percussionist here) 3:Riff🟪(The 2 natural quads are amazing here! Best riff by far) 4:Bowgart🟨(Carries fwog's part) 5:Floogull🟨(Adds a lot of suspense) 6:Quibble🟨(Kickstarts the song) 7:Yelmut🟨(Great yelmut but I wish he was like glowl and had the second part to his tracks) 8:Glowl🟦(Her voice doesn't fit but unlike yelmut she has the second part to her track) 9:Fwog🟦(He is great at the beginning but then gets super annoying) 10:Thumpies🟦(These Thumpies are damm good Thumpies) 11:Krillby🟦(He adds a lot of suspense to fwogs verse) 12:Wynq🟩(This is a great wynq,only beaten by oasis) 13:Bisonrus🟩(Same as fwog but He doesn't even sound mysterious) 14:Flowah🟧(I didn't even remeber flowah was on here honestly) 15:Mimic🟧(Really ruins the final part but I like mimic so I'll let it slide) 16:Mammot🟧(I really aren't a fan of mammot here) 17:Kayna🟥(This voice does not fit AT ALL) 18:Barbb🟥(What the hell even is this.Can someone please get this guy some cough medicine please!) 19:Pongping⬛(This legitimately makes me extremely uncomfortable)

[@JustABulbasaur]

He’s not offbeat on bone island it’s syncopation 😭

[@U.S.E.R2-f7n]

Wth is syncopation

[@GameyGaming]

@@U.S.E.R2-f7na complex rhythm basically

[@GameyGaming]

Usually that would be the case, like with Sooza on Amber, but nah Gnarls almost definitely plays half a second later than when they’re supposed to

[@U.S.E.R2-f7n]

@@GameyGaming Oh ok, thx!

[@GameyGaming]

@@U.S.E.R2-f7n no problem, I might not be 100% right though so just look up the word if you wanna be sure

[@dunes1]

That was a fire video.

[@FutureProGamer90]

It literally just came out 😭

[@GingerBread1000]

@@FutureProGamer90 Man this video is so nostalgic I remember watching it many years ago...

[@Darealgoofytho]

Pongping makes me uncomfortable on this island knowing that it's sound is made from flicking your throat

[@GoldBox_MSM]

Strange question, but I am soon making a new island and I wonder if you will want to rank it (maybe on fanmade friday or some)

[@FutureProGamer90]

Sure

[@angelaakeson7827]

Ranking 3 random islands for no reason 1: fire haven 21st:tring, it’s hard to pick because i got a great island🟠 20th:barrb, no question 🟠 19th:glowl, she gets drowned out by everyone🟠 18th:reedling, it’s a hot take but reedling mostly sounds boring except for tribal island🟡 17th:shrubb, the bush proved himself here 🟡 16th:gobblygourd, she may be annoying but atleast she only plays once 🟡 15th:dandidoo, she’s alright🟡 14th:candelavra, just sounds so majestic 🟢 13th:rare wubbox, slightly worse than cybop🟢 12th:cybop, it adds alot to the ending 🟢 11th:wubbox, another great wubbox 🟢 10th:flowah, imo a better barrb🟢 9th:tweedle, i just like this one🔵 8th:dipsters, for me i never really hated on dipsters so they’re here🔵 7th:kayna, the first and best kayna is msm (not counting dof)🔵 6th:stogg, i never really liked stogg but he has been growing on me🔵 5th:buzzinga, again it sounds majestic🔵 4th:potbelly, Maybe a little suprising but a creative potbelly🔵 3rd:noggin, carries the first seven seconds when repatillo was not playing🔵 2nd:floogull, just carries🔵 1st:repatillo, the best hands down🟣 2: fire oasis 21st:wynq, it ruins kayna on this island🔴 20th:tweedle, ruins glowl🔴 19th:pango, a little boring🟠 18th:boskus, mid🟠 17th:phangler, already a good one!? Wow……🟢 16th:sneyser, it’s quiet but i can hear it somtimes🟢 15th:gobblygourd, hear me out! She is great with mimic🟢 14th:maw, it could have been anyone else but he’s good🟢 13th:wubbox, i guess the new wubbux is good 🟢 12th:kayna, gets ruined by wynq🟢 11th:toe jammer, i just like him🟢 10th:glowl, gets ruined by tweedle but still ok🟢 9th:cherubble, atleast you can hear her in oasis 🟢 8th:whaddle, i prefer whaddle instead of phangler🟢 7th:mimic, cacaw!🔵 6th:dipsters, they sure always sound great!🔵 5th:woolabee, overrated but still great🔵 4th:mammott, bum bum bumbum🔵 3rd:congle, carries the percussion 🔵 2nd: quibble, noice 🔵 1st:spurrit, huzzah!🟣 The next island is 3.seasonal shanty 15th:spurrit, it hurts seeing his downfall🟠 14th:whiz bang, never really been a fan🟠 13th:clavavera, same for her🟠 12th:viveine, same here too🟡 11th:blabbit, same for him🟡 10th:punkleton, i just wished that punkleton had his old voice on shanty🟡 9th:jam boree, he’s good ig🟢 8th:hoola, the first track is good but the second track is garbage🟢 7th:monculus, the others are better imo🟢 6th:boo’qwurm, noice percussion🟢 5th:carrilong, this is what i’m talking about!🔵 4th:yool,big improvement from cold island🔵 3rd:gobblygourd, the biggest boost up in msm history!🔵 2nd:schmoochle, duets really good with hoola🔵 1st:ffidyll, my 2nd favorite seasonal since my fav is spurrit(i’m not biased ffidyll sounds great!)🟣 I’ll make 3 more one day, can you guys suggest other islands?

[@Its_A.Secret618]

Dang bro how long did it take for you to type this

[@angelaakeson7827]

@@Its_A.Secret618 abt half an hour

[@angelaakeson7827]

@@Its_A.Secret618 can you give me 3 islands that i could possibly rank next time?

[@Its_A.Secret618]

@@angelaakeson7827 Idk, Wublin island, Magical Sanctum, and Space Island.

[@angelaakeson7827]

@@Its_A.Secret618 thank you! Then i might rank those islands next

[@PeckidnaPlayz]

After the okay rank was added I think everyone should be happy but sad like WYNQ in a good rank I guess? To okay

[@TheKoobik1]

boy oh boy 1 - Riff. I feel like without Riff the song completely changes and he sounds great. 2 - Yelmut. This is perfect for a song like this. 3 - Floogull. He does sound epic. 4 - Krillby. I like the sounds Krillby makes. And the final verse sounded amazing. Now Gnarls is there and kinda clutters it. 5 - Glowl. Cool voice,and does some sounds that Yelmut doesn't... Yeah,that's about it. 6 - Fwog. He does a good job of carrying vocals in the verses he's in. 7 - Mimic. He works nice with Fwog. 8 - PongPing. He's good >:[ 9 - Shellbeat. Plays throughout the entire song but wow,his sound is boring. 10 - Bisonorous. He sounds okay ig. 11 - Bowgart. Hey mister "You can hear me in like 2 verses" 12 - Mammott. How is a bass-like voice more hearable than Kayna? 13 - Kayna. She does suffer from not being hearable sometimes but she is quite nice. 14 - Quibble. Okay. Verse 2 does not sound good in the song in my opinion. 15 - Barrb. I find Barrb okay. That's about it. 16 - Flowah. He does make the cool ending tho. 17 - Gnarls. My least favourite Quint is in the game and he's... not good! Woooo! Granted,even the worst DoF Gnarls is better than the best MSM Gnarls(aka Bone Island Gnarls) but he's still not good. Also,why are you not on Party? 18 - Thumpies. Heeey Thumpies,are ya hearable? No? Well dang. They do sound cool. 19 - Wynq. PLEASE make him louder,I beg.

[@haroldwai6966]

Thank you for putting barbb in last place .I respect you for that

[@MonstrousUniverse]

Totally based list time‼️‼️‼️ 1. Literally every instrumentalist 2. The vocals outside of yelmuts verse 3. Every other vocal

[@CringusMcDingus]

I don't think bro should ever rank again (He didn't put Yelmut in 1th)

[@Oogiddyhittingtheoogriddy]

i remember watching this video 96 years ago

[@Awesomejjranger_again]

I got glowl on cave yesterday

[@plshalpmeh7941]

nice

[@liliana2003able]

1:52 there mess up is so cute 🥰

[@SunshinePIRRATA.]

3:26 It's so sad that you need to specify the difference between quiet and unaudible. Everyone always finds a reason to have a problem with your parameters XD

[@FutureProGamer90]

Yeah, someone on my ethereal workshop wave 6 video had said “Bro! You said that if something was quiet doesn’t mean it’s inaudible, but then you put Meebkin low because it’s quiet” and I had to tell him that quiet and inaudible are not the same

[@Memerath]

krillby plays during the bit that is explicitly Not metal. if it was during the other half i’d get it but that part is calm, it makes sense to have a recorder there

[@mrsgbrandi]

4:14 fpg in real life

[@Ghaztf0r3ver]

My rerank: 1st: Gnarls 2nd: Shellbeat 3rd: Wynq 4th: Floogull 5th: Quibble 6th: Thumpies 7th: Yelmut 8th: Mammott 9th: Riff 10th: Krillby 11th: Kayna 12th: Bowgart 13th: Fwog 14th: Glowl 15th: Bisonorous 16th: Mimic 17th: Flowah 18th: Barrb 19th: PongPing(the worst of the worst)

[@msma8437]

So a recorder doesn’t fit a rock song but a timpani does? Also that point is invalid because krillby doesn’t even play in the loud verse.

[@FutureProGamer90]

Yes, a timpani does fit. And your point is also invalid because what you are saying is the song switches from rock to another genre. How does that make sense

[@msma8437]

@@FutureProGamer90 how doesn’t it make sense? Those verses are clearly very different and the quieter verses really don’t sound like rock at all

[@EpicGamer_SansheeFreddy]

*Can you do a ranking of Composer Workshop, my recreation of Ethereal Workshop, and the ending? I prefer you use the remake, which was made before Wave 6, since the first version is pretty empty and bad.*

[@andistansbury4366]

"Mimic copies Fwog" gee I wonder why.

[@andistansbury4366]

Jokes aside, great video!

[@FutureProGamer90]

It’s not like the monster is called “Mimic” or anything 😒 lol thanks

[@mrsgbrandi]

3:26 just like cold island

[@DrBepis-jo7qt]

This need to be said even though I thought it was kind of obvious, Cave Island isn’t really a rock song. So saying that one or two monsters belong here doesn’t make much sense. And no, just because Riff and Shellbeat are on this island doesn’t mean it’s automatically a rock song.

[@ttvtla7469]

1:15 omg the new fire monster mammott omg I need it nowwwww

[@JackKendrick-lb2pg]

Ranking Cave Island monsters In Order: Goats: 1. Shellbeat 2. Yelmut 3. Glowl Better 4. Fwog 5. Bowgart 6. Riff 7. Quibble Good: 8. Krillby 9. Flogull 10. Mammott Okay: 11. Kayna 12. Bisonorus 13. Wynq 14. Barrb Bad: 15. Thumpies 16. Flowah

[@mrsgbrandi]

Bro put his favorite monster in 4th ☠️

[@mrsgbrandi]

5:23 spoilers for water island

[@WWEAndSubwaySurfersFan]

Are you gonna participate in the pyp contest?

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@WWEAndSubwaySurfersFan maybe

[@Larrythestickmin]

Imo pong ping should’ve been last

[@Pentrumbra]

Real 🔥

[@hunterliam100]

2:54 I'm in band and I'm pretty sure its some kind of musical technique but I can't remember it.

[@hunterliam100]

I don't THINK this is right but it could be cutting off the note in the middle of playing it. But I don't know how you could do that on piano, since I play trumpet.

[@OctopusMarkMSM]

FPG called my favorite monster "a screaming booger"... tbh, it does look like one.

[@rivinduweerasinghe8504]

Some of yall are gonna hate me for this pong ping is my fav monster on cave island- NOW WAIT WAIT WAIT QUIBBLE RIFF SHELLBEAT AND BOWGART STILL RANK HIGHER but its still my fav

[@HellmanakaUselessTeamakaDevad]

The fact that Yelmut is in second place should be a capital offence. I hate this damn monster!

[@rarewubcoolbox]

Imo 1-shellbeat 2-riff 3-floogull 4-bowgart 5-yelmut 6-glowl 7-krillby 8-gnarls 9-bisonorus 10-quibble 11-mammott 12-kayna 13-wynq 14-thumpies 15-pongping 16-fwog 17-mimic 18-barrb 19-flowah

[@JustA-RandomBoy]

Honestly I like Barrb on this island. It just sounds nice

[@DRouZY03]

0:43 FutureProGamer90 when same voice actor

[@FutureProGamer90]

I meant the melody is the exact same

[@DrBepis-jo7qt]

⁠Tfw copy paste hooga choogah 😔

[@TytheKing6158]

When’s fanmade Friday

[@FutureProGamer90]

Later

[@MsmKevinBR]

my cave island tier: 1: Gnarls 2: Yelmut 3: Glowl 4: Bowgart 5: Quibble 6: Riff 7: Fwog 8: Floogull 9: Bisonorus 10: Krillby 11: Kayna 12: Mammott 13: PongPing 14: Shellbeat 15: Flowah 16: Mimic 17: wynq 18: Thumpies 19: Barrb

[@zayzyverse7843]

This is completely unrelated but how is gnarls offbeat on bone island? It’s just syncopation where it’s not EXACTLY at the same time but is placed where it helps the harmony

[@UltraTheUltarge]

W real, shellbeat is a w on cave

[@Abelha-Carteiro]

Now I stopped to think that Pong Ping could go to Cloud Island, because he is on fairy island, and fairy island is the substitute for Cloud Island. For this same reason, Nharls Didn't go to Party Island as he's not on the light island In short: Big Blue Bubble could place him on Cloud Island so that in the future it would have made sense for him to have gone to the fairy island in the fire expencion

[@Sulithatrush]

Kayna: 😭 My brother: well i see epic kayna Kayna: HUH😦

[@Egg7751]

My fav in this island: Yelmut (AAAA) My second fav in this island: Glowl (yelmut but calm) My mid fav in this island: Bowgart ( uhh ) My least fav in this island: Barrb ( barrb is getting even worse )

[@colb27]

imo krillby suits cave. 1:they play in the fwog verse an d in fwogs verse, shellbeat is the only loud monster 2:im too lazy to think of any more reasons

[@colb27]

and they play in the verse that isnt rock

[@c4r3na-s]

Thumpies is inaudible in the full song (to me atleast) and mammot is catchier ngl. But its your opinion

[@TalonsandTailz]

*IS NOBODY GONNA TALK ABOUT THE VOLCANO GORL MAMMOT*

[@Alilteardrop]

0:21 true he more fits Party island than cave island

[@bruhlol1080]

I mean cave island shellbeat is the best out of all the other islands

[@AluYim-qu1bx]

All about the ranking Me focusing on the intro music

[@themasternoob943]

Can you rank "fright island" by interdimensional music? A youtuber created the designs and let people make sounds for them,and my favorite song from this monsters is the one by interdimensional music :)

[@Aguywhodoestuff]

i dare you to make an island that plays the intro music to your ranking videos

[@Reliquiocuarto]

Not a single complaint. Even yelmut got the treatment he deserved.

[@SomeMSMFan]

0:29 bro why did you mention the F word

[@OnePieceEditsChannel]

Bro I watch your ranking videos all the time

[@spiritblox1]

Krillby aint in the rock verses so like. I dont see your point

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@spiritblox1 the whole song is a rock song though. You can’t have two different genres in one song

[@Void49-l9k]

0:13 Now That You Mentioned It, It Kinda Sounds Like That…Huh

[@daniellelayton7023]

i honestly think that bisonaurus is a great monster on this island

[@MSMbuzzingafan]

1. Shellbeat👑 2. Glowl💛 3. Yelmut💛 4. Floogull💛 5. Riff💜 6. Gnarls💜 7. Bowgart💜 8. Krillby💙 9. Quibble💙 10. Mimic💙 11. Fwog💚 12. Bisonorus💚 13. Kayna💚 14. Mammott💚 15. Thumpies💚 16. Pongping🧡 17. Wynq🧡 18. Flowah❤️ 19. Barrb❤️

[@SunshinePIRRATA.]

0:29 I disagree, I think sometimes, instruments that aren't typical in X genre can bring a much needed freshness to the sound. Not everything has to follow all the standards to the T, Krillby sounds pretty good in the song, like if you brought an electric bass to a kids' music event, it wouldn't be normal, but wouldn't it be cool?

[@mrsgbrandi]

4:23 DOF Leaks: baby hoola

[@PeckidnaPlayz]

Krillby going to 8th place (I guess) to 17th place wow that’s sad I don’t get it why you placed it low

[@PeckidnaPlayz]

And you placed Barb lower than pong ping why?

[@SoxTheGirrafion]

Never let bro rank again

[@andrewdenison829]

0:36 MY opinion is that it's the worst wynq fire oasis is my favourite!

[@JKai2OFF]

Shellbeat kills everyone in this island oh my wubbox, change my mind

[@JackKendrick-lb2pg]

Will you add The Isle to Fanmade Friday?

[@FutureProGamer90]

No never

[@jrsgaming15]

Bro called kayna 'mammott'

[@nospamgaming6682]

how does an island that have such little percussion become the highest rated (if a bit over exagerated) island in dawn of fire

[@Nathaniel328]

0:35 and yet it still works

[@mrsgbrandi]

1:03 ah yes mammott slightly better than mammott

[@josephnicolakis6636]

Wow Mammott has an awesome kayna costume

[@AlpheusStapleton]

W ranking also i am that other person i will just be using this account for now

[@Boiky_Cheezooks]

I feel pongping should be on party, it fits pongping's unique instrument

[@Kye-kai]

ME TOO

[@PastNoobGamer90]

and it sucks so it should ruin the song more at the worst island in the game

[@GameyGaming]

@@PastNoobGamer90nah PongPing would actually help Party

[@GameyGaming]

Not to mention it hasn’t been updated in over 6 years which sucks

[@nikolajsrensen8616]

I think cave island is too loud.but i like the beatdrop. 7/10

[@Enderchomp0968]

I love this bowgart bro😭

[@jecobi]

KRILLBY IS YOUR MOST CONTROVERSIAL OPINION YET WHAT

[@MSMthealtfire1234]

In my head. I was thinking to do a what if. What if cloud island monsters where on cave island. And yeah I can kinda low my voice to sorta sound like flum ox. Phangler. Whaddle. And I think that’s all

[@itsjustanoob]

the vid called kayna mammot 💀

[@Teetertautertatertot]

Hi

[@FutureProGamer90]

Hi

[@mrsgbrandi]

IMO 1 riff🟣 2 shellbeat🟣 3 bowgart🟡 4 glowl🟡 5 yelmut🟡 6 floogull🟡 7 quibble🔵 8 fwog🔵 9 bisonorus🔵 10 krillby🔵 11 gnarls🟢 12 kayna🟢 13 mammott🟢 14 flowah🟠 15 wynq🟠 16 mimic🟠 17 thumpies🔴 18 barrb🔴 19 pongping🔴

[@BulboFan]

For next fanmade Friday please rank WIBG (wublin island but gay🤑🤑)

[@3D_PUPPO]

My ranking is drastically different from yours lol

[@Alilteardrop]

Yelmut, Mimic, and Fwog should be lower and Riff and Krillby should be higher

[@phoenixcoursey6711]

no way yelmut gets ranked #2

[@brasilparalelw]

kayna is mammott confirmed