Ranking EVERY Mario Game From Worst to Best (Including Super Mario Bros. Wonder)

[@AntarcticaMade]

Bro, New Super Mario Bros 2 is not a better game than Super Mario Sunshine.

[@coltonk.3086]

Agreed

[@LUCAS.THE.GAMER.MASTER]

And to him it seem like super Mario dumbshine

[@traviscunningham7062]

It’s also better than 64.

[@Durtle.]

Mario sunshine is the worst 3d mario game

[@GusHeap-x9m]

It is cry about it

[@AlexxxMYLSince2013]

It seriously sucks that Super Mario 3d all stars didn't have 64 Ds and Galaxy 2 in it.

[@arshkhanlm3086]

and 3d land

[@darkdragonmedeus705]

It lacked the duel screens to do 64 DS; would have been able to on the Wii U though. But it sucks balls Galaxy 2 wasn't on it yeah.

[@AlexxxMYLSince2013]

@@darkdragonmedeus705 All Ds emulators allow you to play with only one screen, im sure that Nintendo could have figured something out to make it work.

[@zacharyk.2766]

I agree about Galaxy 2, but how would they put all the features on the switch for SM64 DS?!

[@AlexxxMYLSince2013]

@@zacharyk.2766 the switch has wireless conection for the multiplayer and it has a touch screen for the minigamed

[@jeremydixon1675]

I would consider Super Mario Galaxy the best Mario game ever! There is a lot to explore, and a lot to fight for.

[@mikeytim1402]

Ranking every sonic game from worst to best

[@dripp_dropp]

mania & 3k >

[@timmyv0069]

🎉🎉🎉🎉❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@mikeybennett1904]

I would actually argue New Super Mario Bros. DS is the best of that series. The levels felt so tightly designed with all the secrets and that Star Coin battle mode is probably still my favorite multiplayer in the series to this day. Side note: Really solid video, love the sense of humor here a lot.

[@GusHeap-x9m]

Yea I agree maybe cuz I got more nostalgia for it but I just it to be enjoyable

[@traviscunningham7062]

My only problem with DS is that it lacks a secret world compared to later games.

[@clairehislop5873]

New super mario bros ds was quite literally my childhood

[@corn1zgud4u42]

I agree, but I feel like Mario controls so weirdly in that game

[@nintony2994]

The level design in Wii was designed in a way to be more open for multiplayer. But if you're playing alone, then the level feels barren and empty. DS has tighter levels because it was designed for a single player experience. and I love it too :)

[@extrememediamaster1432]

Fox McCloud Relationships: Healthy to Toxic

[@IrinaSilveira]

Super Mario World is my favourite Mario game!

[@ebreggie8783]

Odyssey is amazing, but the Galaxy games will always be a step above for me.

[@traviscunningham7062]

Agreed.

[@coltonk.3086]

Agreed!

[@honcho4581]

Cap

[@cartoonfan9million468]

Ideas for videos for 1upBinge to potentially do in the future in no particular order. 1. Super Mario Bros. Wonder powerups, least to most useful 2. Super Mario Bros. Wonder Characters good to evil. 3. Sonic Mania Plus, Origins plus and Superstars characters good to evil 4. Sonic Mania Plus, Origins plus and Superstars characters weak to powerful.

[@RufusLeeKing]

Odyssey definitely deserves this praise! It feels so immersive and snappy, but light at the same time. Everything a Mario game should be and more!

[@batmanbud2]

My list: 1. Galaxy 2. 3D World + Bowsers Fury 3. Wonder 4. NSMBDS 5. Odyssey 6. World 7. Galaxy 2 8. NSMB2 9. Land 2 10. NSMBUDX 11-13. 64, Sunshine, and 3D Land (tie) 14. SMB3 15. NSMBW 16. SMB2 17. Land 18. SMB 19. Run 20. The Lost Levels

[@benjaminparker671]

Can you do every Mortal Kombat game ranked from worst to best

[@CarsonGriffin-h7t]

Mario plus Rabbids characters good to evil

[@TristanCrabtree-um8gv]

Yes

[@zkosmith1662]

we do need that after 2 games tho

[@geomania8533]

We all agree Rabbid Mario gets the gold medal for most awesome.

[@samyb4566]

@@geomania8533 Well, he is awesome, we are ranking them based on morality. He is good, but he's not this good. I mean he suggested to burn a forest in Palette Prime to reach a darkmess tentacle.

[@CarsonGriffin-h7t]

@@samyb4566 if they were to rank bowser jr on that list do you think he would be in the bad and evil section because he was responsible for the rabbid enemies

[@Itsnoahscott]

Mario has the longest win streak in video game history.

[@Joseph_Drew_III]

Indie Horror Boom villains: least to most evil Bad: John Munkford (98xx) Evil: William Afton Diabolical: The Prototype (Poppy Playtime)

[@duckygamer01]

Idea: Mario Characters Nice to Most Forgiving

[@williamsummerson1204]

Super Mario world, Super Mario 64 and Super Mario Bros 3 will always be my favorites.

[@raggeragnar]

Agree 100%.

[@williamsummerson1204]

Thx.

[@JavenarchX]

Truely magical...

[@otaviourso]

Agree

[@cookieguy9885]

nostalgia merchant

[@MrGoat-cd8lt]

Awesome video! Loved all of the reasoning you guys gave for your opinions, and the editing was phenomenal! One thing I’d recommend for next time is putting the number each game is ranked at on the screen when you show which game is next up. That would be really helpful as us viewers would be able to keep track of where we’re currently at in the ranking! Other than that, this was great! Can’t wait to see more videos from you guys!

[@duganred]

Top 5 1. Odyssey 2. Galaxy 3. Sunshine 4. 64 5. 3D World

[@Frostedfire6568]

Understandable, but sunshine would be at 5 and 64 at 3 and 3d world at 4

[@VelasiTheSussyImpostor]

I̺ l̺o̺v̺e̺ w̺o̺n̺d̺e̺r̺ t̺h̺e̺ m̺o̺s̺t̺

[@duganred]

@@VelasiTheSussyImpostor I enjoy it also

[@albertovargas1764]

Inaccurate!

[@duganred]

@@albertovargas1764 It’s subjective

[@supermariof0521]

29:56 I'm pretty sure he meant to show Sticker Star and Origami King in that part but got the wrong games by mistake.

[@garveyneal1672]

Can you do Ranking Every Donkey Kong Game from worst to best?

[@ErenKaraman-li6uf]

Galaxy, 2D world and sunshine are ahead of their time.

[@Frostedfire6568]

Can't we all appreciate how these guys went from top 10s and 5s or scary cartoon secrets videos too having many different channels with increasing quality

[@kindlestix8079]

For some reason I really love the aesthetic of bowsers fury

[@Aples_YT]

bro got the whole multiverse

[@jjminor]

Super Mario Odyssey?? That made your number 1?? I did enjoy it the first time through, but then my son wanted to go searching for the moons and, bam, it went from a good game to a bore fest. Such a cool premise that did almost nothing with its ideas. I started a second play through and noticed it even more. The T-Rex part is cool. All 30 seconds of it. And that was it. I got through the second play through quickly because there was nothing overly enjoyable to do. Mario World is much more enjoyable overall.

[@GAMEL4ND_]

My personal list: 1. Super Mario Odyssey 2. Super Mario Bros Wonder 3. Super Mario 3D World 4. Super Mario Maker 2 5. Super Mario Galaxy 6. Super Mario Galaxy 2 7. Super Mario 64 8. Super Mario Maker 9. Bowser’s Fury 10. Super Mario World 11. Super Mario Bros 3 12. Super Mario Bros 13. Super Mario Sunshine 14. Super Mario 64 DS 15. Super Mario 3D Land 16. New Super Mario Bros Wii 17. Super Mario Run 18. New Super Mario Bros 19. Super Mario Bros 2 20. Super Mario Land 2 6 Golden Coins 21. New Super Mario Bros 2 22. New Super Mario Bros U 23. Super Mario Land 24. Super Mario Bros The Lost Levels

[@lilelbee423]

Lovely video! I understand not putting Yoshi's Island in this list, but if Mario Maker is here you might as well include it. I personally find Super Mario World and Yoshi's Island to be my top two favorite 2D Marios!

[@coltonk.3086]

Personally I'd say it's not a Mario game. It's a completely different style of platformer, and it only had the "Mario World 2" title to sell more. Same for Wario land. Not only that, but every time thereafter when they use that style it's a Yoshi game.

[@hhuntsman]

I’m not even that big of a fan of sunshine but it should definitely be higher than nsmb2

[@AlexMoore-y4o]

Sunshine under NSMB2 is wild!!!!!!!!!

[@talesfromtheclassroom]

Super Mario 2 should be way way higher on the list.

[@isamelzorrilla5639]

Hi 1upBinge I love this and I hope you have a good day and you are awesome

[@OmnicidalClown1992]

I'm still hoping for another Good to Evil list involving the Danganronpa franchise, but I would also like to see a Good to Evil list involving the Insomniac Spider-Man Games. Which would include the original Spider-Man game, the Miles Morales game, and the recently released Spider-Man 2 game. And of course, when I said I want to see a Good to Evil list involving the Insomniac Spider-Man games, I am talking about a BIG list where all three games are on the same list. Not separating Spider-Man, Miles Morales and Spider-Man 2 in three parts.

[@Hood-lord]

Wich Crash bandicoot character would win Squid Game

[@danielmoncrief4997]

Odyssey is amazing, but to me Galaxy is way better. I really think that 64 ds should've been higher than the original. With all the cool extra levels, bosses, characters, and minigames that have been added.

[@coltonk.3086]

YES

[@LUCAS.THE.GAMER.MASTER]

64 sukes

[@MeWhenYourMom69]

​@@LUCAS.THE.GAMER.MASTER bro I bet you never even played it, you look like you're 5, you probably like skibidi toilet

[@coltonk.3086]

​@@LUCAS.THE.GAMER.MASTER Not NEARLY as bad as other games on this list. Lost Levels and the new series in particular. (New series weren't "bad" games, just horribly bland and soulless.)

[@traviscunningham7062]

The New games were just good imo. I couldn’t find any other word to describe them.

[@kschshchshl]

the galaxy games will always be my no.1s

[@extrememediamaster1432]

Super Mario Galaxy: Good to Evil

[@JackAttack345]

If Rosalina isn’t the most good, I will get mad

[@Hithere-uz6wd]

Tip for game footage: Use early game footage as to not spoil the rest for those who havent beaten the game yet!

[@kyleirwin3216]

Could you do these good to evil please Sword art online games Batman Arkham series Injustice 1 and 2 Life is Strange Spider Man, spider man miles morales and Spider Man 2

[@Sly88Frye]

1:06 Okay I'm confused as to what you are trying to say there. Yes the lost levels is a hard game, but battletoads is way harder. That turbo tunnel is impossible unless you've actually played the game a whole lot and well I actually grew up with the SNES and N64. I also played a lot of Genesis and PS1 growing up so yeah I grew up with the consoles that came out after. I got familiar with the lost levels thanks to Super Mario All-Stars, but I didn't play very much NES growing up so it wasn't until way later I finally played baltoads and oh my gosh that turbo tunnel is absolutely brutal

[@landermortier2245]

They should add sum of best so you want to speedru' levels to get your total as low as possible

[@Obi-wankenobi35Clonewars]

I think new super mario bros wii u should be higher and especially super mario 3d world, i really love these games, i also love new super mario bros, new super mario bros wii, super mario 64 DS, super mario maker, super mario bros wonder, super mario 64, super mario galaxy, super mario galaxy 2 and super mario odyssey. I personally think many or at least some of these games should be much higher than others like super mario 3d world or super mario bros wonder, but it is ofc a personal opinion either. Some like 2d some like 3d, it all plays a big role in their lists. It was overall a amazing video and still with the differents of your and mine opinion i think you have a very good taste of playful and wonderful mario games.

[@ognurd9858]

My personal ranking from worst to best goes: Mario the lost levels, super Mario run, super Mario land, super Mario bros(original), super Mario bros Two(US), new super Mario bros two, new Super Mario bros U, super Mario land 2, super Mario sunshine, super Mario galaxy 2, Mario 64, new super Mario bros Wii, New super Mario bros, super Mario 3d land, super Mario Wonder, Mario odyssey, super Mario world, bowsers fury, super Mario bros 3, super Mario Galaxy, and in fist place, Super Mario 3d world. I didn’t include the maker games but if I did they would be on the very top. 1st and second.

[@alexisruiz5144]

Wait bowser fury that high? Its good but uts not even à full game

[@AyeYoYoYooo]

Super Mario Galaxy 3 for Switch & Switch 2 is gonna be completely insane.

[@Iucian]

my favorites are NSMB DS, 3D Land, and 64 DS (i was born in 03)

[@Engaged.tourist]

I was born in 03 but my fav is Mario galaxy 1 not the second i hate the second as it has no personality and it always pissed me off that the planet looks more like Luigi than Mario cause it's green but no one in the game acknowledges it

[@jlbwho7913]

Super mario 64 DS above 3D world 💀. I've tried so many times but I can never get used to 64 DS. Probably my least favourite mario game. With the original on the N64 being my favourite

[@sekarramanathaniss-student4843]

Top 5 (my opinion): 5: Super Mario 64 4: Super Mario bros wonder 3: Super Mario Galaxy 2: Super Mario Galaxy 2 1: Super Mario Odyssey

[@Enan63.]

It's hard for me to choose since all of Super Mario mainline 2D Platformer/3D Platformer video games are masterpieces! Favorites for me would be:

[@elliotloucks5249]

F-Zero characters good to evil Good: Captain Falcon Gray: Mr. Zero Evil: Deathborn

[@mysteriousgamer8941]

For me? It's like this (no spinoffs, mario kart, mario party, mario sports. Just core games here) 👇. 34. Mario bros 33. Donkey kong 32. Super mario run 31. Super mario sunshine 30. Super mario bros 2 (jap) 29. Super mario bros 2 (usa) 28. Paper mario stickery 27. New super mario bros 2 26. Paper mario color splash 25. New super mario bros 1 24. Mario & luigi: dream team 23. Super mario land 1 22. Mario & luigi: paper jam 21. Mario & luigi: partners in time 20. Super mario 3d land 19. New super mario bros u deluxe switch 18. Super paper mario 17. Paper mario and the origami king 16. Mario & luigi: super star saga 15. Super mario land 2 14. Mario & luigi: bowser's inside story 13. Super mario bros 1 12. New super mario bros wii 11. Super mario maker 1 & 2 10. Super mario 3d world + bowser's fury 9. Super mario 64 8. Super Mario RPG Legend of the seven stars (the remake will replace the original here most likely once it's out) 7. Paper mario 1 6. Paper mario 2: the thousand yr door 5. Super mario bros wonder 4. Super mario odyssey 3. Super mario galaxy 1 & 2 (tie, although i personally prefer the 2nd one) 2. Super mario bros 3 1. Super mario world

[@barbararenna3969]

W list

[@talende]

I don’t know about odyssey. On one hand, it kinda begs me to come back and casually play around with its smooth and responsive controls and diverse worlds to explore. On the other hand, it feels a bit hollow in the sense that it’s all about moons and moons are littered throughout the worlds. Many of them present boring or tedious challenges - or no challenge at all. So Odyssey holds no permanent spot in my personal ranking - it shifts between being top of the line and bottom of the barrel, depending on my mood.

[@jeremybottoms7619]

I cab understand that it's the best mario have ever controlled the world is beautiful and the capture gimmick is so fun but to many moons and most of them your don't have to do much to find

[@wcraig4]

Yep. It feels great but what good is it? The game is way too easy!

[@fiachramcveigh1974]

Super Mario sunshine is so underrated

[@ZRP_Guy]

All who skipped the Super Mario Bros. Wonder segment to avoid spoilers ↓

[@clairehislop5873]

New super mario bros ds, mario kart ds, mario power tennis, mario golf toadstool tour, mario party 8 & super mario 64 ds are my favourite

[@TheBua0042]

3d world and new super mario bros u should’ve been higher

[@The-EJ-Factor]

This begs the question. How many Mario games are there really? I don’t see you including the game and watch games.

[@puffdaddy6488]

17:27 One of the most laughable takes I have ever heard 😂

[@WarioEnthusiast]

I don't even liked mario 64 and I agree that that take was dogshit

[@riahlexington]

Liked just because you said NSMBWii is the best new game

[@ogkfabrication4180]

Imagine being addcited to peens, must feel pretty weird

[@batmanbud2]

It's not

[@traviscunningham7062]

DS:

[@peders9153]

Mario Galaxy 2 is about as close to perfect as a game can be imo.

[@coltonk.3086]

Celeste has entered the chat

[@callinater6133]

@@coltonk.3086 never played Celeste but galaxy 2 is definitely close to perfection as far as 3d games go

[@traviscunningham7062]

Twilight Princess has entered the chat.

[@callinater6133]

@@traviscunningham7062 TP has quite a few flaws imo

[@Salmonell.a]

@@coltonk.3086 im soo bad at celeste iit frustrates me too much

[@TheOmniverse1]

Super Mario Bros. Wonder Characters - Good to Evil

[@1upBinge]

in the works!

[@TheOmniverse1]

@@1upBinge I also look forward to Super Mario Heroes - Good to Most Heroic (especially with all the Mario stuff happening this year like the additional characters in Mario Kart 8 Deluxe since Booster Course Pass Wave 4, Super Mario Bros. Wonder, and more). And as a little treat to celebrate the implementation of characters like Pauline, Funky Kong, & more in Mario Kart 8 Deluxe (as well as a "Belated" celebration of the Mario Kart Series' 30th / currently 31st Anniversary), how about...? Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Characters (including DLC) - Worst to Best Or... Mario Kart Series Characters (Including Arcades & DLCs) - Worst to Best

[@kenworth2012]

my ALL TIME FAVORITE 2d mario game will ALWAYS be, Super Mario World

[@tiagofernandes8389]

SMBW is at the same level as SMB3 and SMWorld. SMG2 is the best 3D Mario by far. SMSunshine today is better than 64. At the time Super Mario 64 was the most impactful and amazing game of all time.

[@diabolicamires]

Super Mario World is the best game. It is the newest and most evolved if them all. You can put all mario games together and wonder still is superior. Name on other game that is using background manipulation, reality change, creativity evolving and level control. Yeah Sunshine can't do that. 64 aswell. Galaxy can't do anything besides being 3d. Wow. Lame. Wonder is truly the best one.

[@callinater6133]

@@diabolicamires I’d say galaxy 2 is the best overall. The level design in that game has yet to be matched by any game I’ve ever played, period. Wonder’s definitely the best 2d game tho

[@diabolicamires]

@@callinater6133 Fair

[@JackAttack345]

My favorite is Super Mario Galaxy

[@michibuchmayer6224]

so glad somebody finally gives SM64DS the recognition it deserves

[@willsgaming1481]

5:48 hell nah how is sunshine ranked so low

[@SleepingintheTrenches]

Super Mario world 2 Toshiba island is criminally underrated it’s more fun than super Mario world

[@theredblur9598]

Idea: Shantae Characters: Good to Evil

[@TheIntrovertedPikachu]

Honsetly, I have enjoyed every Mario game i've played, exept for the lost levels, I agree with the placement

[@manoftheusajones5147]

Sky landers Characters: Good to Evil.

[@Avarege-physics-and-mario-fan]

Super Mario bros isint that good, but i understand the ranking

[@g_money76]

Putting Sunshine so low is a crime!

[@nathannurse-cp6mi]

super mario bros does NOT deserve to be so high when you put so many better games with so much more content lower than it

[@Joel-wr8dr]

I like your ranking of Mario games and you are good and wonderful and I enjoy this video and in my opinion the super Mario bros wonder and super Mario Odyssey are one of the best Mario game in my opinion but like I said I like your ranking of Mario games and you are good and wonderful

[@pinkprincess6136]

I love Super Mario Sunshine It's my favorite. I enjoyed playing it when I played Super Mario 3d all stars.

[@phantomsplice488]

Yeap, sunshine still my favorite as well. I think its such a unique and fun setting. Would kill for a sequel

[@stormshadowproductions1660]

The Batman Arkham series good to evil

[@Dunno683]

OUTRAGEOUS take with NDMBU. It's definitely better than Wii

[@syedharis3603]

Super Mario Bros. Wonder is the best Mario Game

[@VelasiTheSussyImpostor]

Y̺E̺A̺H̺

[@josephkaza704]

My favorite Mario games was on the 3rds cause there so care free on the dialogue and lots of other stuff

[@xrocketboix7464]

Yeah, this is gonna be one of these lists thats gonna be controversial.

[@nickn271]

It's sad Sunshine is so low on the list. I'd rank it far above most of these except for 64, World, 3, Odyssey and maybe a couple more.

[@LilJeezyLoC]

What type of demon plays SMB 3 on widescreen

[@jaredlanglitz5651]

At least Super Mario Sunshine introduced Bowser Jr. I personally prefer the Wii version of New Super Mario Bros. I think Bowser’s Fury was based off of Godzilla vs Kong. There sure are different main line Mario games here (Mario Kart, Super Mario Bros, Super Mario 3D, New Super Mario Bros, Super Mario, Mario Maker, Paper Mario, etc). The Goomba king is known as Goomboss. I think Super Mario Bros. 2 was based off of the Super Mario Bros Super Show, similar to shows SMB3, and Super Mario World. The added music with Elephant Mario is similar to the added music when riding on Yoshi. My first ever main line Mario games were Mario Kart with Wii, and Super Mario with Galaxy. Some Super Mario Galaxy themes help me go to sleep. When do you think Mario and Peach will ever get married, and how did characters like Giuseppe and Pauline find the warp pipe to the Mushroom Kingdom? Maybe Nintendo could bring back Stanley so he could be Mario’s protégé.

[@Obi-wankenobi35Clonewars]

Where are the paper mario games? Btw amazing video!

[@1upBinge]

we may do a Mario RPG ranking soon!

[@timmarks976]

I am mad. He put 64 above new supe u browsers fury sunshine wonder both maker games and 3d world I know my opinion is VERY VERY controversial but that is just wrong. 64 is easily the worst 3d game and is only barely better than the two Mario 2s

[@Calvertron]

Super Mario World for the SNES is the greatest game ever made.

[@toondreamer4438]

I can't believe you think that Super Mario Odyssey is better than Bowser's fury.

[@lathanscivicque2795]

Please do more evil to most evils please

[@thevman5501]

23:12 I’m sorry I can’t agree, the single player might be fun but the multiplayer is just frustrating and not in a good way.

[@traviscunningham7062]

Basically the opposite of NSMBW: Mutiplayer is fun but single player is boring.

[@michaelrenna5752]

Only 2 player is good I hate 3 and 4 player

[@DivineCuts11]

I just dont understand the people in the comments. Odyssey solidifies its place as the number 1 best mario game. People are saying its overrated, which i find a joke. They say that the game gets boring and exhausting to play with all the power moons. In all honesty, these power moons is what makes the game ao good. From strategic to hard moons, it all comes down to the skills that the player has learned while playing. Each kingdom has its own beautiful graphics. Luncheon kingdom is a pure example, as it literally brings food and uniqueness to a whole different level. The bosses, although extremely easy, are very creative, also applying to galaxy. People say the moons are frustrating, but the frustration only makes you feel better about the game. Do u really expect everything to go ur way and to be easy?! There is some challenge in this game and it only makes it better. "Exhausting" is a complete excuse, as a person could just take their time. Whats the point of playing any game if you dont even take ur time experiencing and getting the most joy out of a game. Ur just ruining ur game experience. Odyssey is just an incredible game with everything going for it. Although it might not be the game for others, its certainly not overrated or trash, it just doesnt fit ur playstyle. Stop trying to insult a game when knowing really nothing about enjoying a game; ur just ruining ur game experience lol.

[@Tucj-zh1dy]

Can you not handle the fact people have opinions?

[@randomdude8790]

When do we get to Tahiti? I was promised Tahiti like 2 years ago at this point

[@1upBinge]

Don't worry. I have a plan. We just need more money, Arthur.

[@randomdude8790]

@@1upBinge I have faith in you, Dutch

[@MMAengineer]

where is the tier list?

[@c88rrado]

Super Mario Land 2 better than Sunshine?

[@Tucj-zh1dy]

Yep.

[@graycat9577]

Он угорает что ли?

[@Dylan-me7dw]

Super Mario bros should be lower It has not aged the best and just can’t hold up against newer titles Other than that great list

[@coltonk.3086]

Slightly disagree. There's a reason it's so prominent in the speedrunning community. It's still fun to run through to this day!!

[@traviscunningham7062]

I think it’s better than 64.

[@Kilo-the-Teapot]

spoilers for the video go here

[@Kilo-the-Teapot]

honestly i think mario galaxy (1) i superior in every way compared to odyssey

[@WickedBinge]

spoiler: mushrooms make Mario big

[@Kilo-the-Teapot]

@@WickedBinge omg

[@DemonKingNemo]

I must be the only one that thinks Odyssey is okay at best

[@coltonk.3086]

Overall this is a pretty great list, but I have some issues with it. While Odyssey is still really great, I feel like it's one of the most overrated Mario games in recent memory. It had a lot of fun aspects like costumes and its various kingdoms that were fun to explore, but the campaign was too short, and after that you have no motivation to collect the remaining almost 1000 moons. Which, by the way, groundpounding the 100th glowing spot on the ground, guiding the 60th skittish sheep, and waiting for the 20th seed to bloom is not fun. It's bloated. And the "reward" for grabbing all 999 moons, 120 of which REQUIRE coin farming for the shops, is absolutely pathetic. Again, a really great time, but it's not the best. As it stands, it's probably either #4 or #5. I'll get to my choice for the #1 slot in a moment. Second, putting BOTH 64 and World above Wonder is nostalgia bias. 64 was impactful, but it's clunky and literally half of the levels were just thrown together, admitted by Nintendo. I groan when I have to go to Dire Dire Docks, Tick Tock Clock, and Rainbow Ride. It was a worthy first 3D game, but some parts of Sunshine were better, and putting that one lower than NSMB2 was not a great move. Not sure where to put Sunshine, it was a decent ranking, but better than NSMB2. As for 64, it's probably #8. Regarding World, it's still an incredible game to this day that has aged like a fine wine, but Wonder improved upon the formula with even better Power ups, more world variety, and the incredibly fun and versatile badge system. And that's without mentioning the Wonder flowers. World stays within the range of #4 or #5, roughly tied with Odyssey, but it's comparing apples to oranges. Wonder, however, is #2. It's the best 2D Mario game by a long shot. As for #3, the bronze goes to Galaxy 2. It has incredible gameplay, but it's lacking in every other aspect. No backstory, a lackluster hubworld, a really generic world map, among other things. And finally, #1 goes to Super Mario Galaxy. I rank it above it's sequel because while 2 might have overall better gameplay, the original does much better at perfecting the balance of gameplay, world-- uh, I mean, universe building, being emotional, and pulling your heartstrings. It has cinematics and epic scope that belong in a movie theater, and there is a distinct feeling in those opening moments that sells you on the grand scale of the adventure at hand, but it also shows you the loneliness of space. Galaxy is without question Mario's greatest adventure. Thank you for reading this far, and I wish any Soupy Marlo enjoyers a very pleasant evening.

[@nicknick493]

100% agree with the Odyssey stuff, found myself being excited for that and botw when they came out. Took me like 2 MONTHS to beat botw and then like 2 days to beat odyssey lmao. A lot of the moons werent even that creative either, I'd say about half were just bought from shops or in some random corner. I think odyssey was a good game but tbh there are much better mario titles than it.

[@coltonk.3086]

​@@nicknick493 Glad I'm not the only one!!

[@traviscunningham7062]

Same, I found it overwhelming as well. BOTW and TOTK are better.

[@luismvg11]

Now I realized why I love Galaxy I also felt emotional is some way. There's something so magical when I played that game for the first time.

[@coltonk.3086]

​@@luismvg11 Can relate.

[@kindlestix8079]

Tbh sunshine is one of my favourites

[@THE_CLOWN691]

Glad odyssey is the best game

[@WarioEnthusiast]

I'm fine with your list, I'm not even targeting you specifically with this comment: What the fuck is it with people glossing over Mario 2 USA??

[@Skippernomnomnom]

I don't know what you were playing, but that's not how the original Super Mario Land looks