Ranking Every Mario RPG Game

[@kingboo4518]

Super Paper Mario is my favorite rpg as well as my favorite game ever, its number 1 for me.❤ The story is number one is most platformers itself

[@articunto]

Bobby’s death caught me so off guard, I loved that little guy 😢

[@Nathan-fo4ux]

Mario + Rabbids should have been higher on this list and is definitely better than Origami King. You must be really bad at strategy games if you thought that all of the characters played the same. They are all unique especially in sparks of hope.

[@Dubonus]

Nah

[@RoboMarioBros]

0:53 did u not watch this part? Plus he was generous enough to put it above Paper Jam and Color Splash. It has nothing when it comes to over world gameplay, it’s not that great.

[@bravetree]

Glad I found this comment… what was bro talking about.

[@johnnylew9455]

💯

[@dailthegoat799]

I think this list is perfect

[@Nintenguin]

This was honestly such a fun video to watch. I love all of the comical things thrown in, it reminds me of Schaffrillas.

[@cosmicspacething3474]

I personally thing BIS should go over TTYD. Is this my nostalgia talking? Yeah, but the same thing goes for most people and TTYD 🤷‍♂️

[@Loner098]

Let's not forget that crappy DS microphone BIS forced you to use, *especially* on the Fawful Express fight. That sucked for people who had asthma.

[@shifterlocker2361]

Bull ttyd actually is good unlike you who probably never played shite from it that’s why people don’t take modern fans seriously.

[@voltron77]

Ttyd is good, but Bis is just special.

[@megastarwarsrocks99]

🤮

[@bluesky5384]

Just watched this after playing some post game in the TTYD remake and on the heels of the announcement of a new Mario and Luigi! What a win for the Mario RPG fans!

[@manicedahokami5083]

I probably sound like literally any"You're so underrated" comment but I really like your style of humor. Side Note: I bought Paper Jam on release and was so dissapointed that we didn't visit the Paper World/had any "Non New Super Mario Bros" Stuff.

[@glauber8600]

very good video, you have potencial and you should do more videos like this if you can!

[@xffvfv1153]

Swap Partners in Time with Super Paper Mario and the list is spot on for me. (Except for the Mario + Rabbids games, I haven't played those)

[@vaantjes]

My ranking: (In my opinion there's nothing under C tier) C tier: 14 - Sticker Star (Isn't HORRIBLE like everyone says though) 13 - Paper Jam (Wasted potential) B tier: 12 - Dream Team (Good game but TUTORIAL) 11 - Kingdom Battle (Nice game) 10 - Sparks of Hope (Slightly better than Kingdom Battle) 9 - RPG (Pretty good) 8 - PM64 (Please don't kill me for this) A tier: 7 - Color Splash (One of my two most nostalgic Mario RPG's, but imo it holds up even ignoring nostalgia) 6 - Superstar Saga (I love this game) 5 - Origami King (Great game!) S tier: 4 - Partners in Time (My first Mario RPG, besides that underrated) 3 - Bowser's Inside Story (I. Love. This. Game) 2 - TTYD (This game is too good to be true, yet still not number 1...) 1 - Super (The story. The gameplay. The characters. Everything else. OH GOD! You love it or hate it, I'm definitely the former)

[@jefferyandbob3137]

Personally I'd rank SS and BIS above TTYD, yes TTYD is great but imo it's story is carried by the side plots, almost nothing happens in the main plot and imo (again for re-clarification) the villains (besides Doopliss and sorta Crump) are bland as hell. Whereas in SS the main plot is always moving, maybe more happens in TTYD, but the stuff in SS matters more to the main plot and makes the story feel more active: You team up with Bowser at first, Luigi is dragged along (remember this is the first ML game), the Beanish royalty are turned into monsters, Bowser gets amnesia, the main villain is killed halfway through and possesses Bowser, the Bros get elemental powers, etc etc. For BIS I won't say as much since most has been said but storywise, imo the endgame is just TTYD's main plot done better: the main villain has a personality and still part of the final boss alongside the ancient evil, both the main villain and ancient evil are fought first at half power before combining to form the final boss, dark hurricane is cooler than the sky getting a little darker, etc (Also I just like ML gameplay more than PM)

[@justaregulardude3195]

Color splash should have been a bit higher cause you can game over because a Toad yells at you about how his wife left him

[@thebucketgod9177]

Love Mario RPGs so much! I personally enjoy all of them except Sticker Star, but overall they all feel very unique from each other and are incredibly fun to replay every now and then. Definitely my go-to RPG games.

[@Waluigiisbest99]

4 things i hate about modern Paper Mario. 1: Over reliance on paper references even down to having literal office supplies as enemies. 2: Simplified and boring character designs. 3: Simplified or overly gimmicky battle mechanics no one asked for. 4: Uninteresting villains with maybe the exception of Origami King.

[@KaiJie-n8q]

I don't agree with your first point.

[@Bxrry125]

Bowsers inside story is definitely the best in the Mario and Luigi series. Public opinion agrees too. It’s so highly praised for a reason. It has the best story, charm, levels/level design, rpg elements, and don’t even get me started on the final boss music. I haven’t played ttyd but I won’t discredit or praise something I haven’t experienced

[@jbluyt8890]

The Mario + rabbid’s disrespect is crazy

[@SonicGamerLP]

I am disappointed, that you didn’t mention the way Mario & Luigi Dream Team forces you to use motion controls for every little shit!

[@CheesyCheeseCheesyCheese]

Origami king has the best Nintendo ost without a doubt

[@Heyhoopad]

Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword? Mario & Luigi: Bowser’s Inside Story? Mario Galaxy? Animal Crossing: New Leaf? The entire Wii Series?? No shade, but there are much better and more iconic Nintendo OSTs.

[@BrynQuintillus]

SPM?

[@JAL1403]

21:31 basically all mario rpg stories include it at some point , get some things to make a big thing to open a thing or make a thing to get to another thing. E.g. a good example, get the crystal stars to open the thousand year door to stop a demon, get the star spirits to resure peach, get the star cures to cure the blobs, or a bed example, get pieces of a bed to sleep on to get to a special bird to take you to bowser (or something like that). I don’t have a problem with fetch quests as long as they have purpose and are interesting.

[@PKMono]

Wanted to skip through this video to see your ranks and ended up watching for 45min straight. Good Stuff my man.

[@e2011ugdia]

17:00 he just wants revenge for his origiami people due to them being tortured and contorted by toads for fun and fun fact: when members of Lilys people die, they Turn into paper cranes AS Seen in the cutscene for the true ending

[@thenormalguy8244]

This is great, I think you should watch coney or carlito because you have very similar video structure to them. They are great at sarcasm and I think you’d enjoy them. I’d love to see how this channel grows and I think you’ll get far.

[@fernandothehorse]

Not enough people mention the Spin Dash. I’ve been playing the original Paper Mario to death via the randomizer, and mastering spinning across the map made it really hard to go back to TTYD with its lackluster movement options

[@zenchantrelle9779]

This is the exact same ranking as everyone elses so do worry about any backlash

[@JAL1403]

39:45 NOT ALL the mini games, what about the big carrot, I rest my case.

[@jumpmananimatic4166]

Great video! Sub earned!

[@KaiJie-n8q]

In the thumbnail, colour splash mario is hitting kersti with his hammer, I wonder if it's a coincidence？

[@tanook4751]

I love the Schaffrillas style ranking! Even if I think that Color Splash is overhated and I actually kinda like it, I love this video

[@NibirBaishnab]

super mario rpg is my favourite one also someone should make paper mario rpg

[@tulpenbambus]

In Japan Paper Mario is called Paper Mario RPG

[@NibirBaishnab]

@@tulpenbambusoh really?

[@poy110]

@@tulpenbambusthat's for TTYD

[@JorgeGarcia-fx1jc]

I loved Mario and rabbids kingdom battle so good but not everyone has the same opinion except for sticker star

[@e2011ugdia]

14:56 this rabbid is supposed to be rabbid Bowser because bowser is playable but doesent seem to have a rabbid version

[@gboogie3257]

Proof?

[@e2011ugdia]

@@gboogie3257 Well Bowser doesent have a rabbid Version and the oc kinda resembles Bowser down to her hotheaded personality kinda being Similar to bowser

[@gboogie3257]

@@e2011ugdia A: It’s not a OC B: not close to Bowser at all C: she’s not even hotheaded

[@e2011ugdia]

@@gboogie3257 i surrender, Germany IS yours!

[@IcedCube0310]

@@gboogie3257OC stands for original character, so yes Edge is an OC

[@goldenyoshistar1]

I see you didn't really add Sparks of Hope, Nor Puzzles and Dragons Super Mario Bros Edition. As well as the remakes of the 4 Mario RPG games. Though, of the 15 RPG games I've done (excluding Color Splash, TTYD Remake, Puzzles and Dragons (needing to be replayed) and Paper Jam (needing to be replayed) There is gonna be massive backlash if I even did a ranking video like this. let's just say... Paper Mario Community was not happy with the location of their fan favorite, and probably would dislike bomb me for my placement of this game.

[@bravetree]

I’d put the Mario Rabbids games above Origami King. Also the thing about the characters being clones of each other is completely off base.

[@thegreatkamekus4524]

I personally prefer kamek over kammy (pls don’t hurt me)

[@JAL1403]

20:40 Starlow will you shut up please 🙏, I know what I’m doing!! That star can be annoying, and so can dreambert. They turned her from being a very important character and guide in inside story to the Tutorial character in later games. it really is criminal of Nintendo.

[@BenAndJoshInc]

26:06 did that guy just say F#$% YOU

[@iLoveBread260]

Mario and Luigi Paper Jam is underrated, its a great game tbh, youre just too harsh on it.

[@Venoguy17]

I mostly agree with you except I would put Mario RPG at 1 and partners in time at 2 or 3. also i don't think really super paper Mario counts as its more just a really good new super Mario bros game with an good story.

[@JAL1403]

26:06 when did this happen?!?

[@BrynQuintillus]

When u get the pixel u can choose what they scream

[@alex-s6r7g]

Here’s my rank from worst to best Mario RPG series: 9. Paper Mario: Color Splash 8. Paper Mario: The Origami King 7. Mario& Luigi: Partners in Time 6. Super Paper Mario 5. Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga 4. Paper Mario 64 3. Super Mario RPG 2. Mario & Luigi: Bowser’s Inside Story 1. Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door

[@OmegaChase1002]

Why do you say "RPG game"? The G already stands for "game". You're saying "role-playing game game".

[@arkthegreenwolfx3627]

This has the same energy as "Chai means tea bro! You're saying tea tea!"

[@OmegaChase1002]

@@arkthegreenwolfx3627 BUT AM I WRONG THO

[@phil2160]

Sticker Star is overhated

[@xanander4693]

Opinion rejected. TTYD is overrated af

[@lorenzoantonio3630]

Same even though was lower so like paper jam

[@cedrikthibert7033]

Sticker Stars look absolutely horrible.

[@evanrosman9226]

I think you overrated Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story.

[@dr.wolfstar1765]

Impossible. It has so much character and fun moves to pull off. No way is it overrated

[@charismaentertainer1657]

@@dr.wolfstar1765that doesn’t make it not overrated

[@kingboo4518]

Cap

[@kieranstark7213]

I hate it when people say that about pre-2010s Mario RPGs in general with the “you only like the ones that came before Sticker Star because of nostalgia. The newer ones are objectively better in every way” card. Honestly, I’d spend quality time watching videos about Mario RPGs ranked/reviewed/played like this one any day rather than being forced to love the remakes and Super Paper Mario sequels (with the “You’re only saying the original trilogy is better because haven’t played the other games” defense… though I guess the Sticker Star sequels are marginally better in some aspects…) over the Mario & Luigi/Paper Mario games from the 2000s (though I do like Super Mario RPG for the Switch and the upcoming TTYD remake, that and I am aware that the Mario + Rabbids series are RPGs and ones from the 2010s-2020s that are comparable to the ones from the 2000s, mainly TTYD, so I’m really only applying to the Mario & Luigi games for the 3DS and maybe the M&L remakes would have been better if they put it on the Switch instead of a dying console, mainly BIS, and kept the same art style as the original or gave you the option to switch to it, Dream Team to the least extent for actually trying).

[@cosmicspacething3474]

I think he overrated ttyd