Ranking Every NFL Starting Quarterback From WORST TO BEST 2024

[@TheBottomLineView]

Gronk Spike the LIKE & Comment Your Opinion on my LIST! Join TheBottomLineView Discord Community for FREE to chat about NFL Daily! discord.gg/jeXCfCV

[@arkang3l80]

Now this was a good decent video and a fair break down

[@TheBottomLineView]

Thanks man

[@Issaiahenrique]

Can’t wait for these vids again!

[@TheBottomLineView]

🤟🏻

[@_Killswitchhh]

Love that you spoke highly of Lamar Jackson but also kept it honest about the playoffs! GO RAVENS💜🖤

[@TheBottomLineView]

@@_Killswitchhh thanks!

[@Hazy_Fforest]

The in video chat fucking sucks man, they're so mean. Good vid, I loved the way you explained your points. Keep up the good work, and don't listen to the hate.

[@TheBottomLineView]

@@Hazy_Fforest yeah its annoying ill turn it off for the next one

[@Hazy_Fforest]

@@TheBottomLineView for what it's worth, I'm not concerned with them being annoying to me. I just wanna make sure you know that they're dicks and your content is fine 🙂

[@brandonmitchell6351]

I love Josh Allen. Even as a chargers fan, I gotta get his jersey

[@tjab1715]

Your assessment is unbelievably accurate!!! Love your show! Keep up the incredible work you’re doing!

[@TheBottomLineView]

@@tjab1715 thank you appreciate the love!!

[@BurntPenguin8371]

My personal list: 1. Mahomes 2. Allen 3. Burrow 4. Lamar 5. Herbert 6. Stroud 7. Love 8. Dak 9. Stafford 10. Goff

[@timm5970]

If based off accomplishment, switch lamar and allen. If based off actually skill then herbert is 2

[@BurntPenguin8371]

Allen has better numbers than Lamar, FAR better post season numbers than Lamar, and even though Lamar had the MVPs, statistically Allen’s best seasons have been better than Lamar’s they just happened when Rodgers and Mahomes had historic seasons as well. Herbert is not a better player than Burrow or Allen, even in a vacuum. Lamar is debatable.

[@nickfred1829]

that is a solid 9/10 list

[@timm5970]

@BurntPenguin8371 Herbert is better then both Allen and Burrow. He's a better passer then mahomes as well. Mahomes is a better scrambler/better at keeping the play alive

[@BurntPenguin8371]

@timm5970 Heavily disagree, if you want to argue per passing, I could see him at #2 behind Burrow. If we’re talking overall at QB, I don’t see how you can argue that he’s better than Allen.

[@283-73]

My top 10 is 1. Patrick mahomes 2. Josh Allen 3. Lamar Jackson 4. Joe burrow 5. Justin Herbert 6. CJ stroud 7. Dak Prescott 8. Matt Stafford 9. Jalen hurts 10. Brock purdy

[@nickbrown1843]

Having CJ Stroud at 6 and Jordan Love nowhere in the top 10 would be really interesting to hear you justify

[@283-73]

@@nickbrown1843 shit I forgot abt him, swap him out with stafford

[@newerax1009]

Very solid list. Much better than some of the others I've seen for sure. My list is: 1) Patrick 2) Burrow 3) Allen 4) Lamar 5) Stafford 6) Stroud 7) Purdy 8) Herbert 9) Dak 10) Love (Just on the outside: Kirk, Rodgers, Hurts)

[@TheBottomLineView]

Purdy over herbert is just crazy to me but i like your list

[@newerax1009]

@@TheBottomLineView I had a feeling you would catch that 😂 I'm not against putting Herbert higher, I just really love how smart Purdy is and how his anticipatory throws are absolutely ELITE. Plus he's a gamer ( like you said in the video ), and has won way more. But put Herbert in the right system with enough pieces around him then he will be in MVP discussion, no question.

[@David-uh8bx]

I agree that Josh Allen is that most physically talented QB ever. Justin Herbert is better than either Joe Burrow or Lamar Jackson.

[@icertifiedjosh6488]

My top 10 1)Mahomes 2)Josh Allen 3) Lamar Jackson 4)Justin Herbert 5)Joe Burrow 6)CJ Stroud 7) Matthew Stafford 8) Trevor Lawrence 9) Dak Prescott 10) Jalen Hurts

[@TheBottomLineView]

Don’t have many disagreements there. I think Lawrence needs to be more consistent to be ranked that high

[@sebastianperez4666]

My personal top 5 is pretty similar. 1. Patrick Mahomes 2. Josh Allen 3. Lamar Jackson 4. Joe Burrow 5. Justin Herbert 6. Jalen Hurts 7. CJ Stroud 8. Aaron Rodgers 9. Dak Prescott 10. Brock Purdy Just misses; Kirk Cousins, Trevor Lawrence, Jared Goff, (not high on Matthew Stafford).

[@TheBottomLineView]

@@sebastianperez4666 why are u not high on sb champ matt stafford?

[@newerax1009]

I think you guys overestimate how good Lawrence is. No way does he deserve to be in the top 10

[@icertifiedjosh6488]

@@newerax1009 he’s gonna be better this season, he has all the physical tools and is very strong in the pocket

[@ryangillispie5094]

Bo Nix is gonna be much higher on this list next year. Also his accuracy is elite.

[@diamondrg3556]

What I learned, not only does the AFC have the current best quarterbacks, but also have the most promising future best QBs.

[@karmvirsingh1845]

Here are my top 10 Quarterbacks 1. Mahomes 2. Allen 3. Lamar 4. Stroud 5. Herbert 6. Purdy 7. Love 8. Burrow 9. Hurts 10. Rodgers

[@BurntPenguin8371]

Purdy over Burrow is blasphemous lol

[@NathanDean79]

My favorite teams starting QB should be number 2. Joseph Lee Burrow.

[@BurntPenguin8371]

Number 2, for the amount of times Burrow has played through a full 17 game season (JK I love Burrow, I just think Allen is slightly better)

[@JohnDoe-kh6mt]

When burrow starts completing seasons healthy then get at me.

[@devantejones10]

Swap Baker with Trevor lawrence

[@TheBeggies95]

Yep

[@timdejoseph1595]

This list is questionable at best. You have a lot of qbs who have never even won a playoff game let alone never played a single down in the NFL over ones who have.

[@TheBottomLineView]

what did i get wrong? (i also choose to project how good players are instead of taking the easy way out on things)

[@timdejoseph1595]

@@TheBottomLineView there are a few you have too high. I get the projection aspect, but having Tua where he is with that arsenal at his disposal makes him inadequate on almost any other team. You expect will Levis to be better than Daniel Jones with Malik Nabers joining the team? I get the expectations of Caleb Williams. Anthony Richardson played well before he got injured, but he hasn’t really proven much yet. Id have to go back and look at the list again to see what else. Oh, and Cleveland is where QB’s go to die. I’ll be shocked if Watson has a turnaround.

[@scottblakely4419]

Allen is a beast! Mahomes a magician! Trade coaches and the hardware would be in Buffalo!

[@gamerthe192nd3]

Before the post season began I bet heavily on KC to win it all because when you have one S ranked QB and there is no one else who is even a real A+, the team with the only elite QB is always going to have a massive advantage. If Mahomes stays healthy he is going to have a lot of rings because there is no one in his way. Brady's record of SB wins is especialy impresive because he played durring the golden age of QBs and still won 7 rings.

[@JohnDoe-kh6mt]

Imagine saying allen isn't an a+ qb and then expecting people to take you seriously

[@NicolasGill04]

I think you are underrating Carr. 25/8 TD-INT ratio and winning record in his first year with Saints, I think he only improves in his second year with the team. I also think you are underrating Bryce Young. I get he had a bad first season, but with the upgrades around him I think he's gonna be the most improved passer in football this year. And if we are ranking rookies in the upper 20s, I think it's fair to put a forward projection on his ranking.

[@NicolasGill04]

I also think other NFC QBs like Purdy, Goff, Hurts have shown to do as much if not more than Dak with a similar cast around them and that should move them above Dak. Although Dak did have a very strong regular season last year.

[@NicolasGill04]

Carr also completed 68% of his passes and almost threw for 4000 yards and he prolly would have been in the playoffs if it wasn't for his 3rd qtr injury in Green Bay when they were winning 17-0 then went on to lose the game without him.

[@shrabonichatterjee7979]

I like this list! Well researched and fair assessment for each QB. Appreciate it. Hopeful for the Bills 😊

[@TheBottomLineView]

thanks 🤟🏻

[@Justincase994]

I was waiting for you to say Deshaun Watson the whole time 😂

[@spencerk45]

bo nix will be better than most people think

[@jerryhollon6153]

He’s going to put up better numbers than Drake Maye.

[@TheBottomLineView]

🤔

[@101less]

How about reading the D and altering the play? Goff's been amazing at that and doesn't get credit for his growth and his brains.

[@Jdvdsnn]

Idk man, I really don’t see how anyone can have Stroud above Herbert when Herberts rookie season was literally better and people have already forgotten that, then he goes for 5k yards and 41 total tds in year 2, and still puts up 4.7k yards and 25+ tds with fractured ribs the whole season in year 3. Even in 2023 he was playing great before the hand injury. Herbert is without a doubt a top 5 QB and id argue he’s top 3. He’s 27-15 when his defense gives up 28 or less points, and 16-0 when it’s 20 or less points, has 11 game winning drives since 2020 which leads his class and is 3rd in the entire league, and his team has lost 7 games when he leads them to a go ahead drive so he has to just sit there and watch his historically bad defense and coach give games away. His playoff performance wasn’t the best but it was definitely solid enough to win the game. I’d bet my life that with Harbaugh as his coach he’s going to show everyone how great he really is because as of right now people just don’t want to acknowledge it because he isn’t “clutch” or a “winner” which is just not true.

[@TheBottomLineView]

Cj was better as a rookie than herbert imo. Just played a more mature style and carried the team to a lot of wins . Took care of the ball and threw it down field . Herbert had impressive stats but not a lot of wins . Cj to me is a smoother athlete and has already shown a rare ability to not flinch under pressure. Thats the difference for me

[@TheBottomLineView]

Great qbs win. At a certain point herbert has to win some

[@Jdvdsnn]

@@TheBottomLineViewit is just an opinion thing because to me Hebert is 5 and Stroud is 6 so they are very close, but I’d say Hebert has the same element to his game where he doesn’t flinch under pressure, but you’re right he needs to win more games. My argument is just that it’s not his fault they are losing games

[@TheBottomLineView]

@@Jdvdsnn i dont disagree . He isnt the main reason but you also need to elevate everyone . I feel like stroud is more creative and has a stronger leadership skill. Small margins but thats what i see from the 2. I like both a lot . I think herbert is kinda like stafford where he needs a strong personality at hc to steer him

[@Jdvdsnn]

⁠@@TheBottomLineViewHe is very similar to Stafford where he didn’t win early in his career but the potential was always there, Now that they have Harbaugh things should change, I hope. I think this is Herbert’s most important season yet so only time will tell.

[@A_Name_]

I'm not ready to crown levis the guy let alone great. I think your ranking is about right. That said, in Sharps recent qb Accuracy stat drop he has levis top 10 for fewest incompletions due to accuracy. How much of that was him being accurate and how much was everyone but dhop sucking idk. Also I would say his release is more than "better than given credit for" I didn't want anything to do with hom.coming out but his release looks like a glitch. He gets like 2. 3rds of the eay locked and the ball just goes.

[@philibusters23]

Guys I would rank a bit higher: Daniel Jones, Jayden Daniels (but I am a Commanders homer), Tua Tagovailoa, Aaron Rodgers, Trevor Lawrence Guys I would rank a bit lower: Brock Purdy, Jordan Love, Jalen Hurts, Jared Goff, Anthony Richardson, Drake Maye, CJ Stroud Nothing that I hated in this video. For all the guys mentioned, I am moving 2or 3 spots for them most part.

[@philibusters]

I enjoyed the stat list for each one too.

[@AM-ug9ck]

Jared Goff is probably the best play action qb in the league

[@gamerthe192nd3]

This video shows how sad the state of NFL QB play is. The NFL was so much better 8 to 10 years ago.

[@JohnDoe-kh6mt]

You mean when there was like 4 total franchise QB?? What a braindead take

[@Navigator001]

Menshew is not the starter for the Raiders. Not even close. AP has said over and over again the Aidan is his guy. Doesn't turn the ball over? are you kidding? Fumbling while being sacked is his specialty. You may still rank Aidan as low as Menshew because he hasn't really proved himself yet. He will surprise people in my opinion. But of course the Aidan haters will say that it is only because he has great talent around him.

[@kashanteche]

Michael Vick gained an average of 7.0 yards per rush in his career. What's touching that? #pleaseeducateme

[@TheBottomLineView]

@@kashanteche ??

[@isaiahmcconnell]

The thing that makes Mahomes the best imo is that he’s the one qb in the league that has no holes in his game AT ALL Allen’s decision making can be poor burrow is hurt all the time and isn’t nearly as gifted as Mahomes Lamar pocket passing is improved but obviously not as good as Mahomes Mahomes does everything Good and most things great

[@TheBottomLineView]

Fair take

[@akaniners]

There isn't 8 QBs better than Purdy

[@erikpuka2627]

On tape Mahomes has never been the best QB in the NFL. The insane Scheme and cast of the Chiefs might have made him look as such 2018 - 5th 2019 - 4th 2020 - 5th 2021 - 15th 2022 - 2nd 2023 - 9th His only legit claim is 2022. He was neck and neck with Herbert. Barely worse. Like 1%. Got to learn how to "isolate the QB". Alex Smith led the league in passer raring in 2017

[@shortestwidereceiver]

Bruh next time leave off your chat, I about had an aneurysm seeing everyone spam next on a list video that was specifically made to break down EACH QB. Y'all some goofy asses

[@TheBottomLineView]

I will next time that’s on me

[@shawnclapper6581]

Its not a Brock Purdy system stop with the BS ALREADY SYSTEM LOL KIDDING ME? EVERY TEAM HAS WEAPONS

[@gamerthe192nd3]

Drake Maye does have fantastic traits he just sucks at playing football. He is below par at every esential skill that QBs need (acuracy, timing, getting through reads, understanding oposing defenses, exct.) NC did not suck despite having Maye at QB. At times they sucked because they had Maye at QB. No firstround quarterback has ever had such bad film as Maye. I hope that our coaches can wave a wand over him and make a viable QB out of him but ranking him 24 now when hopefully he will not even play this year, costs you all credibility.

[@benjaminhawkin5564]

I’ll take dak or hurts over Herbert

[@TheBottomLineView]

Why

[@havanascp9602]

Why? Hurts only had one good year.

[@someperson8151]

​@@havanascp9602Hurts made the playoffs all three years as a starter. Herbert has one playoff in 4 years.

[@BurntPenguin8371]

@someperson8151 Hurts has arguably the best receiving duo in the league, a top 10 TE, and the best O line in the league. He has the best surrounding situation in the league aside from maybe Purdy. Herbert has had absolutely abysmal coaching, a bad o line, and not bad receivers, but definitely not close to AJ Brown and Devonta Smith. Making the playoffs being your measure of a QB’s worth is just ignorant.

[@HOUSTON_TEXANS713]

🤘🏽LFG TEXANS C7️⃣J HIM STROUD

[@TheBottomLineView]

@@HOUSTON_TEXANS713 HIM in HOUSTON

[@godiswatching9501]

Deshaun Watson was the 11th ranked QB last year until he got hurt, 25th? Really? 🤣

[@TheBottomLineView]

11th ranked in what exactly lmao he was not good

[@godiswatching9501]

@@TheBottomLineView In fantasy scoring? Lol, he didn’t have the greatest numbers overall, but he ranked 11th in the NFL up until his injury, he was ahead of guys like Russell Wilson, Trevor Lawrence (who has somehow gotten better?), and probably would have finished with a better season than them if he stayed healthy 🙃 The last full game he played he had his best game since joining the Browns, which was a win IN Baltimore, where he led them to a comeback win after being down 14 in the 4th, keep sleeping on Watson 🤣

[@godiswatching9501]

Not Russell Wilson, I meant Zach Wilson lol

[@FPFOdylanrice]

Bryce Young will finish top 16 Mitch

[@TheBottomLineView]

Lmao

[@jeromeperry5472]

U was doing good with your NFL rankings QB's until u was ranking the top 10 QB's

[@TheBottomLineView]

@@jeromeperry5472 why

[@jeromeperry5472]

@TheBottomLineView LA Charges QB shouldn't be in the top 10 & Jordan Love should be in front of Dak in the top 10 QB's & Josh Allen shouldn't be number #2 QB Jalen Hurts should be in the top 10.

[@TheBeggies95]

@@jeromeperry5472Jalen Hurts should be around the 16th mark

[@jeromeperry5472]

​@@TheBeggies95 I don't think so why u say that? I think he will win a superbowl 1day.

[@timm5970]

LOL bo nix is the best in the draft easily.

[@TheBottomLineView]

According to who? Ahah

[@buffpatrick7735]

Don’t understand how ppl have cj stroud over Jordan love , Aaron rodgers took all the receivers with him to the jets and yet Jordan love had more tds then stroud and was one rookie mistake away from beating the 49ers meanwhile cj got smacked by the ravens . Just don’t understand

[@TheBottomLineView]

Stroud made the texans a relevant franchise? Stroud is smarter. And much More accurate.

[@buffpatrick7735]

@@TheBottomLineViewevery one thought Aaron left the packers to die but love revived them

[@TheBottomLineView]

@@buffpatrick7735 i didn’t i had them winning 9 games and making offs lol but that was my belief in love. I think you’re underrating how good stroud really is

[@buffpatrick7735]

@@TheBottomLineViewmaybe I am ,I guess all we can do is wait for the season to start and see

[@someperson8151]

​@@buffpatrick7735CJ performed as a rookie. Love had two years of benchwarming duties before he played. Think Love would have played well as a 2nd pick for Washington? Washington had the 2nd pick in 2020.

[@shaqyboirealer]

1st off I love your channel bro , great content every time 💯 but Bro u got Hurts too low! I don’t think you factored in 1. Durability is the best ability ! 2. Winning! Or 3. Clutch Factor… His entire life , He barely ever misses games due to injuries, he’s always been a winner and he’s always been clutch! So how is it possible Love after just 1 good half of a season is better ?Love threw more game losing interceptions last season than probably Hurts have his entire life 😂 .. Dak a choke artist, Hurts already lead his team to a Super Bowl appearance , dak can’t even come close & he won’t ever play in a Super Bowl. Now Purdy over Hurts is just insane! 😵‍💫🤯Im not even gonna go there 😂😂😂 … Lamar and Allen are my other 2 favorite qbs I love but idk if I’m takin them over Hurts in a playoff game. Definitely not takin Lamar in a playoff game over Hurts! Stafford and Burrow just always injured. Herbert idk how good he is in big clutch playoff games yet but choking a 27 point lead is definitely crazy ..

[@TheBottomLineView]

I think one thing that people never talk about with hurts (they talk about this with purdy, tua, dak whoever else) is how much help he has. His game as a passer has too many limitations. He doesnt have arm angles, great pocket movement, or even above average throw on the move ability. He is a pure athlete (one of the best) with a strong arm but is limited in a lot of areas i look for . I like the guy a lot but i think his end of 23 was concerning

[@TheBottomLineView]

Also thank you for the support

[@BurntPenguin8371]

Lost braincells reading that, relearn to type please. Hurts has a top 2-3 receiver duo, the best o line, and a top 10 TE, and still up worse numbers than Love with a middle of the road O line and a committee of rookie and 2nd year receivers. Hurts also put up 9 points and got blown out in the wildcard after starting the season 10-1. Hurts is not clutch, and his stats aren’t good.

[@shaqyboirealer]

@@BurntPenguin8371 I stay in Wisconsin, I seen Love choke and throw interceptions at the end of 3 or 4 games last season. Buccaneers always gives Hurts trouble but Don’t forget AJ Brown missed that game playoff game too , probably still would’ve lost but still

[@shaqyboirealer]

@@BurntPenguin8371 and bro this is not school I don’t have to spell you instead of u , are U slow or somethin? 😂

[@benguensche]

drake maye aint even startin though. Or is he?

[@TheBottomLineView]

He might. Just the chance that he might hes more interesting to discuss

[@DevinMcelwain]

Your wrong about Bryce young

[@TheBottomLineView]

Y

[@davidbratsko5791]

It's hard to take your list seriously when you didn't research enough to know Aiden O'Connell is the Raiders QB1. You may like Minschew, but Antonio Pierce said O'Connell is the starter. Who makes the decision, you or Pierce? Bad job dude

[@TheBottomLineView]

@@davidbratsko5791 minshew is expected to start but it is a competition. I dont think the raiders pay minshew the way they did if its not a legit competition You claiming that o’connell is the clear cut starter and then ripping me for it is wild considering thats not even true. Its a competition

[@davidbratsko5791]

@TheBottomLineView The fact that you are arguing a fact, not an opinion, shows your lag of research. Antonio Pierce has said multiple times that O'Connell is the starter. He earned it with what he did last season. He said it is an open competition, so Minschew could win it, but its O'Connell to lose. The reasons are the following. He was projected to be a 1st round pick after his junior year but he decided to stay at Purdue to take them to the big ten championship game. They got there but lost because most of their good players graduated. That ultimately hurt his draft spot. Add in the fact that he did so well at the end of the season that he was a big reason Pierce got the full time job. Because he did so well, combined with no viable option in the draft for a qb, they are going to see if O'Connell is the qb of the future. If he is great, if not they will use next off-season to address the qb. Another thing is 12.5 million average salary a season is not starter money, it's high end backup money. When starting qbs are getting over 50 million a year, 12.5 is not starter money. Something else I left out. Pierce wants to win with defense and ball control. O'Connell showed the last 5 games specially he can protect the ball and win. Minschew takes too many chances and fumbles a lot. Minschew is simply an insurance policy in case O'Connell doesn't play well. You can check out anything factual I wrote. Most of the info comes from news conferences and Hondo Carpenter. I'll conclude by saying put your money where your mouth is. I'll bet you $100 O'Connell starts week 1.

[@davidbratsko5791]

@TheBottomLineView P.S. Watch Hondo Carpenter's podcast from 3 days ago. It will explain to you why O'Connell is going to be the starter over Minschew. He has inside info on the topic, and frankly, you dont. If you want to have a future in football commentating, you need to research better. Frankly, you're making a fool of yourself in front of your viewers by giving wrong factual info. Your opinions are just that, opinions. They may be uninformed but not wrong. Your facts are what I'm saying are wrong. I have the facts on my side, you don't. Just watch the video. Inform yourself, then your opinion on the qb situation will be based on facts, not speculation. I would guess since you did it with the Raiders, you're probably bsing your viewers who root for other teams, too. Ive rooted for the Raiders since 1970 and have studied football my whole life. My advice for you is research your facts and don't let your heart influence your opinions. Raaaaiiiiddddeeeerrrrssss

[@StevieS1]

@@davidbratsko5791 My friend is a original raider fan and i can say Aidan O'Connell isn't him from what i saw and being a eagles fan i know Minshew is better and can rack wins so we'll see.

[@davidbratsko5791]

Davonte Adam's did multiple interviews yesterday and clearly stated in them that O'Connell is his choice. Listen to the interviews. 2 of the 3 I saw he either didn't mention Minshew or said his name in passing. In the 3rd, he only commented about the Minshew media day photos. He spoke much more about O'Connell. Raiders fans, please get your info from legit news sources, not these youtubers who have no connections to any players, coaches or gms. Get your info from press conferences with players, gms and coaches. That way you know the facts to form your opinion from.

[@pixel1897]

H7M

[@NicolasGill04]

My Rankings for this season 1. Mahomes 2. Burrow 3. Allen 4. Stroud 5. Lamar 6. Herbert 7. Stafford 8. Hurts 9. Love 10. Purdy 11. Goff 12. Carr 13. Lawrence 14. Dak 15. Cousins 16. Rodgers 17. Caleb 18. Tua 19. Young 20. Murray 21. Richardson 22. Russ 23. Geno 24. Baker 25. Maye 26. Nix 27. Jones 28. Levis 29. Watson 30. O'Connell 31. Daniels 32. McCarthy

[@JohnDoe-kh6mt]

When burrow can finish a season healthy and makes the playoffs 5 years in a row.... he can be above allen

[@joemannix6155]

Watson led a comeback against lamar in baltimore with a broken shoulder. Hes in the top 10

[@gonzoprodz2024]

1 mahomes 2 lamar 3 allen 4 burrow 5 stroud 6 herbert 7 dak 8 hurts 9 love 10 stafford

[@kameronduckett]

How is Allen Better than Jackson and Cousins better than Wilsons and Maye better than Young like how

[@Theodoredarling]

I also think Maye will be better than Caleb. He’s my QB1 in the class

[@TheBottomLineView]

You Maye be on to something

[@BurntPenguin8371]

I don’t think it’s impossible that he is a better player in a vacuum, but I would be shocked if he were better this season given his much worse surrounding cast

[@Theodoredarling]

@@BurntPenguin8371 Maye won’t be better this season. I don’t think Maye is even locked in to the top 3 production wise this season for rookie QBs. In fact if I were to bet on it I’d bet that Bo Nix has a more productive rookie season than Maye this year and Nix was my QB6 in this class

[@BurntPenguin8371]

@Theodoredarling In terms of rookie situations this season, (excluding Penix because he’s incredibly unlikely to start) it goes Caleb, JJ, Nix, Daniels (I go back and forth with Nix vs Daniels, but I think the better line and the more established coaching staff that plays to his strengths gives Nix a higher floor), Maye. JJ and Maye I don’t even think are guaranteed to start at all this season, the other 3 will definitely.

[@Theodoredarling]

@@BurntPenguin8371 I hope Maye sits this season and they’re bad enough to get Luther Burden

[@UchennaJohn-np6kz]

Joe burrows Josh Allen’s daddy

[@BurntPenguin8371]

a full 17 game season is Joe Burrow’s daddy. So is scoring 0 points on your last 4 drives of the superbowl and choking away a ring.

[@JohnDoe-kh6mt]

Lmao. 1 game doesn't decide anything. Allens stats blow burrows clean out of the water. Allen has the FAR better career and playoff stats and is the current NFL ironman.... Burrow averages 7 missed games a season for his career. That's 🗑.