RANKING EVERY SHADOWHUNTER BOOK✨

thank you to reinhardt asis for requesting i make this video!! it was super fun to make! :)
my goodreads: / katie
my instagram: / katieiisreading

[@zozotherat]

I feel like the main pinpoint of City of Ashes was literally just: Jace: I love you. Clary: I love you too. Jace: Let’s be together. Clary: Wait. Aren’t we siblings?

[@thegardenoftere]

the incest in city of ashes is very disturbing, at least in city of bones they don't know about it until the end

[@katieisreading]

i know, literally no words for that plot choice🤢

[@sheilajune9677]

🤢🤢

[@Jess-dv6py]

Loved this video! The shadow hunter books just mean so much to me and I love seeing other people love them so much!

[@katieisreading]

thank you!! i literally feel the exact same way!

[@shannonaardsma4782]

Skipped through that a lot cause I didn't want spoilers, but this is a cool video idea! Honestly thought you just decided to do it, lol, but really cool that it was requested!

[@jasmineardalan9862]

The Last Hours is now my favorite Shadowhunters series ngl. Very much agree with most of this ranking

[@herondale8]

I was about the sitting and waiting for your compliment about The Infernal Devices so here we go

[@katieisreading]

honestly i had gone too long without bringing it up, it had to be done😩

[@readwithzoe1412]

I think I’m the only one who is not a fan of any herondale boy 🥲😂😂 but my favorite books are definitely The Dark Artifices I just love the dynamic between Emma and Julian

[@katieisreading]

girl... that is a CRIME😩😭 (you opinion is valid, but it hurts me so), i do also love the dynamic between emma and julian though!!

[@theresa3152]

Me neither. I always love the Herondale's Parabatai.

[@CarliRas]

When I found out they were “siblings” I did the exact same thing! 😂I had to google where this was going otherwise I would have never picked up the other books😂

[@Jess-dv6py]

Also did you know that she has a middle grade series cowritten with Holly Black called the Magisterium series? I read it quite a few years ago so I don't really remember it much but I remember it being a fun time

[@katieisreading]

and i did!! i need to look into the series because i love both of the authors so much, i've heard its not spectacular but a really fun time which is exactly what i need sometimes, ty for reminding me!

[@Jess-dv6py]

@@katieisreading no problem! it’s definitely not a masterpiece but still fun 😂

[@daniellesanders9677]

can you do this for all the brandon Sanderson books you've read

[@angie-bd6vw]

thank you for the warning! because I haven't finished some of the shadowhunters books I'm gonna put this on my to watch list and see it when I caught up with the series, sorry!!! 😭😭😭 hopefully it's not far, because I want to read chain of thorns on its release date and I'm almost done with my qoaad read! Anyways I'll try to guess today's question 😅... If today's question is what's your favorite/least favorite of the shadowhunters books then my answer would be clockwork prince and least favorite... honestly every tmi book except the first fall into the last place looool ahahha

[@katieisreading]

no its okay!! haha, i wouldn't want you to spoil what happens in any of the books that would make me so sad omg! i, again, hope you're loving qooad, is the the only one you have left or are there more you have to get to? also a good favorite/least choice... tmi is not great...

[@angie-bd6vw]

@@katieisreading I am loving it! I have the red scrolls, the ghost of the shadow market (?) and first two in tlh 😶

[@joa2332]

i gasped out loud when you didn’t place clockwork princess in the top 5 but i see it now

[@katieisreading]

it pained me to do so... but it had to be done😩

[@Sophie-xu6cp]

If the infernal devices is not at the top I'm gonna cry 😂

[@sheilajune9677]

My 1st shadowhunter book i read was Chain of Gold, and that book made me fall in love with reading again, so i read the Chain ⛓️ of Iron and Chain of Thorns and then after I decided to read the 1st books (because I never read them) i discovered Cassandra Clares books back in November 2023. So, anywho, I really enjoyed those 3. And i really enjoyed reading City of Bones until the end, and then I tried reading the beginning of City of Ashes, and I HATED it. I can t even read it all. Like I felt there was so much potential in City of Bones and I really loved the book 📖 then once Valentine came into the picture and tried manipulating Jace into believing he was Clary's brother I just did not like that. 🤢🤢😪 sooo unsettling and disappointing because I really enjoyed reading most of the City of Bones.

[@Julie_ao]

❤️😻

[@deegoins6056]

we have a lot of the same ranking omg city of ashes is the WORST book i have ever read based on plot alone