Ranking My 2021 Eyeshadow Palettes

[@Mrssandydoo]

I love how Mandy is so passionate about eyeshadows.

[@alisonhopper6724]

Please please do a tutorial for that eye look you're wearing with the avacado toast pallete. It's stunning x

[@dinabowling1234]

I second this 👌 🙏🙏 I'd love a tutorial! Maybe even a 7 looks one palette video with Avo Toast 😍

[@alisonhopper6724]

@@dinabowling1234 even better. I would love a 7 looks with this pallete 🤞

[@juliekruse4060]

I third this!

[@angelaburns4163]

Me too! I just ordered this please!!

[@suzannesinclair2165]

Another vote for a multi look video with the Avocado Toast palette - I just received that and the Blueberry Muffin palette this week x

[@stephaniefox9701]

Oh my goodness watching you do this gives me Christmas in July vibes! What a great idea doing this mid year! I think I might need to go online and do some shopping… Ho ho ho Merry Christmas mid year!

[@carolynclemens8606]

Loved the way Smitten in Switzerland looked, so popped into the ulta app to add to my cart, and it was 50% off!

[@agingophelia9812]

Been wanting to try that, but I settled on Blueberry Muffin & Avocado Toast instead.

[@pushpins926]

My daughter says that her favorite palette is Colourpop's Lemoncello palette. I can't decide, but I will say that the Wet n Wild Lucky Charm palette was the one that got me back into makeup this year. I had pretty much given up on makeup for years and years before I got that one!

[@ashleys7413]

I have tried so many eyeshadow palettes this year! I will say that I regret purchasing the ND Glam palette. I can get the same look if not better using my CP that’s taupe palette! You live you learn 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@taramisu9978]

Interesting, so many rave about that palette. It's nice to know I can create the same looks with a palette I already have. Thanks for sharing!

[@blurabbit848]

You look gorgeous today, love, love, love the eye look!! Thank for all you do chica!

[@Angeladtao]

I’d love to see you in blues. I have a feeling that it would looks stunning…

[@felicityrose11]

Im obsessed with the new Sydney Grace x Temptalia palettes! They inspire me so much to try new looks out of my comfort zone!

[@jessicalevy2415]

Me too!! I haven’t been able to put it down since I got it!

[@angelafishburn7654]

I love your Avocado Toast look. My favorite green palette is the Mandalorian palette. Green is my favorite pop of color for my coloring.

[@juliel8124]

Oh I missed you 💖

[@melissajones286]

I purchased the Alter Ego Canyon palette and can’t believe how much I love it. I always thought I was a cool toned girl, but there is something so special about those warm bronzy shades 😍

[@robserrn]

Love your videos. Every time I see you post I jump over to watch. LOVE all the rankings. Got to get some of the Wet and Wild pallets.

[@666k9s]

I'm saving this review! Good job. Even though I concentrate on cool pallets for my pink undertone, fair skin, there were several pallets here that appealed to me, plus a few I could probably wear in the fall. Thank you, thank you! ❤️

[@karennicholson4167]

I have purchased three ColourPop large palettes - Stone Cold Fox, Bare Necessities, and You're Golden. Between these three palettes, I have most of the colors that I need to create any look that I want and don't feel the need to purchase any others. My other favorite brand of eye shadows that no one talks about is the Iconic London palettes. I have Sunset to Sunrise, Day to Slay, and one other and these are beautiful quality shadows with great color payoff, a nice mix of mattes, shimmers, and glitters, and they last all day.

[@marywallbridge9749]

Hi Mandy great video thanks for sharing there are so gorgeous palettes, your eye look is absolutely gorgeous too I'm so wondering if you could do a tutorial showing how you got that eye look ? it's the most beautiful green are. Look blended so so well,thanks again for sharing all the best Mary in Australia 🌻

[@NataliaLavrovaBeauty]

I have been lucky enough to try so many good ones this year so far. I think the 3 stand outs for me have been Sydney Grace Tiny Marvels, Kaleidos Club Nebula and PAT McGRATH Divine Rose II. This was so fun to watch Mandy - thank you!

[@rebeccapinto9926]

Your earrings are stunning. Can you share where they are from. Great video.

[@LifeStirredUp]

Yes, please!

[@clarahullinger2210]

makeup + jewelry + outfit = PERFECT

[@brianamoss997]

This year I bought the Jackie Aina x abh palette on sale. My first abh palette. It's absolutely amazing!! Favorite formula ever now 😍 the shimmers are so incredible and gorgeous and everything blends so well!

[@kathybrou1340]

I love the Melrose pallete so much! The WnW palltes blew me away too. The textures or great and they stay on my lid!

[@maggie_maeve]

Eyeshadow ranking videos are my favorite videos! I’m excited to see your ranking.

[@NataliaLavrovaBeauty]

I bought so many of those Wet and Wild palettes thanks to you. I have only tried the 5 pan ones so far and have 3 of the larger ones that I still need to test out. So far I am really enjoying them!

[@TheMunchkinita2509]

I'd love to try Dominique Cosmetics eyeshadow, but I haven't been that thrilled with her color stories. The one that called to me the most is her first latte palette, but I have so many neutral palettes I just can't justify buying it.

[@sureiseeyou]

I just got that palette and absolutely love it!! The best part is using the cream under my eyes, dark for contour, and blush shades. Its such a great multiuse everyday palette. The 3 shimmers are incredibly stunning.

[@sfidler5101]

I haven’t tried her palettes either. But I just ordered the Celestial Storm palette. It’s on sale at Sephora right now.

[@TheMunchkinita2509]

@@sureiseeyou hmmm... I may have to revisit contemplating picking it up. It sounds fantastic! Thank you for your input!

[@TheMunchkinita2509]

@@sfidler5101 I hope you love it!

[@coltandkaylagunderson6672]

The blush in the Samantha March palette is so gorgeous, I can't not use it everyday 🥰 no other blush compares imo

[@cdiannethornton]

I enjoyed today’s video! I’m an OG (I guess 😂) but my daughters have me trying new things. I recently got Coloupop’s Stone Cold Fox. I would love to see you do several looks with it.

[@judymanning2374]

I just got Mercury Retrograde and I'm in love 😍!!!

[@sarahwalden178]

Oh man I don’t know how I’d even begin to choose a favorite palette-like you, I adore trying out new eyeshadow palettes! I was also shocked by how much I fell in love with Zendo (particularly that mint green) so that’s definitely up there! I also really fell for the CP Limoncello palette and shadow sticks. But I’d have to say that the BH Cosmetics 16-pan palettes, as a group, have probably been my favorites. (I want to say the BH Naughty palette is my favorite, but I realized I tried that in 2020. But it was late 2020 … 😜)

[@kristinandrews7471]

Earring Envy!! Love them 😍

[@darciann]

Loved this video and loved the length of this video too! 😂💖 My favorite palette I’ve been reaching for would have to be the CP Rawbeautykrist collab or my BareMinerals copper palette. I’ve also been getting a lot of use from my single shadows

[@melissakessler77]

The best palette I have tried this year was a recent purchase: in order to prevent myself from buying the new Patrick Ta palette, I got the LA Girl “The Nudist” palette. You would love it - great mixture of warm and cool neutrals, great formula, nice balance of matte and shimmer shadows, and I think it was $10. It’s sleek and compact, with a big mirror. Highly recommend!!!

[@DaraOber]

I love your comment about the Mothership palette. I bought it during the sale too and find myself cringing about even the sale price!! Lol!

[@kerrierohr9341]

I would like you to do a video of you ranking all your shell pinks and champagnes.

[@annaharryman4719]

I finally broke down and bought the Persona Identity 1 palette. And It does live up to all the good things I've heard about it.

[@lisapetitpas9476]

This is your eye look girlfriend! I love it!

[@reneesoli5345]

Me too.

[@makeupjunkie6790]

I bought the snail bb cream you love and used it today and I really like it.

[@cfsfibromom]

I love your videos so much! Your makeup is so beautiful today Mandy! It's crazy to me that when those Wet N Wild palettes first came out, the first reviews I saw of them said they were horrible! Since then I've seen more positive reviews like yours. Such polar opposite views of the same palettes!

[@sureiseeyou]

I just commented about that too. I wasn't going to get them because of that but when I saw them in the store for so cheap I picked up a couple. I seriously have no clue what those makeup artists were talking about. I loved them so much I went and bought the rest except for the pink 10 pan. I don't wear those colors.

[@blessdmommy]

I've been loving the Going Coconuts palette by Color Pop

[@amandas.2745]

Love the video.. You were ranking the palettes and other than Pat Mcgrath, Natasha Denona, Juvia's Place, and some of the BH cosmetics I think I have all those palettes. Plus a few others I've gotten instead of the ones you mentioned.. Helllo My Name is Amanda and I have a makeup addiction, My main vice is eyeshadows palettes... Go Commando has some of my favorite colors too not my 100%favorite palette, but great everyday palette. People can also get Wet nWild the palettes at Five Below the 5 pans 3$ and 10 pans 5$ and Dollar General pretty much same price, if they have them in their area. Or they can watch Ulta app for buy 1get 1 free or buy 2get 1free or buy 1 get 1 50% off.. They just had them on sale last week I think.

[@BreezyStreamy]

PM glitter formula is the end all and be all for all glitters, which was the shade that you loved in Midnight Sun.

[@S.Ja.]

I love Natashas glam ! You have a so nice eye look…

[@dreamscape405]

Out of all my newer palettes, I really enjoy that WNW Sundaze small palette, and Profusion Bare. The Bare palette doesn't look like it would be that interesting, but it's so pretty and satisfies my neutral cravings, which have been often lately.

[@agingophelia9812]

That taupe from JP reminds m e of Winky Lux's Cashmere Kitten, but the Kitten palettes have 9 shades. Love Berries & Cream so much, but more for the Blue, that amazing deep Taupe, and the cranberry/burgundies shades. What's the best I've tried this year, is tough-- I bought both of DC's Latte palettes and picked up her Lemonade palette on Glambot, and I love them all. DC has my favorite eyeshadow formula.

[@ashleywillard3033]

You should swatch the olive green in the Pat palette and then layer the gold on it. It's so beautiful!!! That palette is so beautiful for all year but I really love it for Fall.

[@sarahmorey8653]

Stone Cold Fox is the palette I can't stop using! I never get a result I will wipe off and it has shown me that I am, apparently, much more a cool-toned shadow lover than I realized!

[@AwakingOceanborn]

I have been resisting the siren call of The Chocolates and The Taupes but the idea of having two “baby” palettes with those colour stories appeals to me so much. If I ever give in, fingers crossed that the reddish matte brown in The Chocolates actually pulls brown enough to flatter me, sometimes I look fantastic in them (Nabla Side by Side, Melt Rust) sometimes they make me look corpse healthy (Both mattes in Nabla Analogue).

[@marbravo7001]

Huda Beauty Mercury retrograde, is old but I picked it up this year at the Sephora sale and I love it!!

[@suzannesinclair2165]

Completely agree. I just bought it this month too and it’s gorgeous!

[@katietetzloff9248]

I have really loved the KKW matte mauve palette!

[@megansimplystitch]

I love these long palette videos. I like to see other people's collections & how they rank them. I think of this as "me" time. Thanks, Mandy.

[@christiedennis1741]

It's all for " Science " 🤣love this video. Please please do a GRWM using the blueberry muffin pallette 🙏xx

[@lr8607]

I've been on the fence about the Avocado Toast palette but that look you have on today has sold me on it. Plus I see it's on sale on the BH website today.

[@julieligon9501]

Beautiful look...especially your eyes! Love your earrings!

[@angelaburns4163]

Finally got the BH palettes I didn’t get the Chicago or the Blueberry. Got the others and got some blush palettes to during their sale! So I’ll patiently wait to see that tutorial on that you have on right now!!

[@suzanneholman1203]

I find it difficult to replace the quality and creaminess of the Lorac Pro palette - those shimmers! I like the Morphe Truth or Bare palette for neutrals. The Sephora Eye Love palettes are nice, too.

[@meredithwebb2274]

I love these videos! So fun. I recently purchased blueberry muffin pallet and havent received yet but was happy yo hear the good things you said about it. Based on your wet n wild review(s) Im definitely considering buying. I’m all about spending barely any money and getting the minimum that I need. I wish that you could rank and review literally every eyeshadow in existence.

[@nancyjustme]

I’ve tried a bunch of these pallets, but I think my favorite is still my Zendo pallet. I wear it constantly and mix it with my Bronze pallet and other brands.💜💜💜

[@GazeldaS]

Great video once again. Love your eyeshadow look too.

[@paolafiora4170]

best you tube video about current eye shadows EVER. Thank you so much for all the hard work.

[@lorrainewhitlock5377]

You look so beautiful today and I enjoyed watching you brag all of these pallets. Oh my goodness was this a fun video!!

[@kristenjoy7159]

I love your eye look and your mascara looks amazing!!!

[@sureiseeyou]

Great video!! Love the wet n wild palettes!! I almost didn't get them because a few you tubers really dogged on them which surprised me because when I got a couple I was so impressed I bought all except the rose 10 pan. I really don't wear reds/pinks because they don't look great on me. I'm trying to think of my top palette. Thats hard because I'm in love with most of them. I'm gonna go with the Dominique Latte palette only because its so versatile that I also use it on my face and its just a great everyday palette. I know its not new but new to me. Same with the Too Faced Pineapple and Berry palettes. Love those too. I also really love those BH BFF, Avocado and Blueberry palettes. Just so many pretties really.

[@taramisu9978]

My favorite new palette this year is Sydney Grace Enduring Love, a close 2nd is CP The Child palette which was a very pleasant surprise. I also got CP That's Taupe (also very nice), Elf Bitesize quads Cream/Sugar (favorite) and Rosewater (nice). Lastly I got CP Wild Nothing which was an impulse buy, it's nice but probably my least favorite. I still like it though. Nice video and roundup of palettes.

[@melbygrace]

I’m not sure if anyone has told you, but the astral shade from Pat is the same in Divine Rose. So your AE dupe is accurate. It’s a crazy shade that is pretty much in-dupable. Even though I have been trying to!

[@myhauntingromance]

For what I've tried so far in 2021, I am in love with my CP Limoncello and really like the Nabla Secret palette. I really want to love the Club Nebula palette but I just look at it and have no idea where to begin

[@wendyvoye3110]

Ughh.. I have been eyeing the limoncello for a while but I have so many eyeshadow palettes already.

[@myhauntingromance]

@@wendyvoye3110 I totally get not buying it if you can dupe it with what you have. Its one of the ones that has become a hg because it has everything I need in one palette, if that makes sense

[@sfidler5101]

Excellent video! I ended up buying BH Cosmetics Blueberry Muffin and Avocado Toast . It’s on sale right now for 25% off!! Thankyou for sharing❤️

[@alexandreaturcot8921]

I love your ranking and eyeshadow palette collection videos. New subscriber, and I have a lot of the same palettes as you. I adore bh cosmetics; they started my passion/ addiction to eyeshadow palettes! 💞🧜🏼‍♀️🧚‍♀️

[@fuzaylova111]

the best of this year for me has been the quads from colourpop. i don't know if they changed the formula for them or what but they are just amazing.

[@ShesAnalytical]

I love those Wet and Wild ones!

[@nancycarnell119]

Love this Mandy. Waiting on the WW palettes to arrive in the UK and I'll definitely be snapping some up! X

[@laurahopkinson5138]

Loved this video! Eyeshadow palettes, my favourite! So many good ones!

[@adelekemp4235]

Please review the new ELF Electric Mood palette. Interesting color story 👍🏻

[@tessl4514]

Patrick Ta's new one is my favorite so far this year!!

[@sophiegamache]

Love ranking! Especialy eyeshadow palettes!!!

[@Andio1966]

Have you done a tutorial on this eye look? It’s my very fav! Feel in love with on the other video you filmed. Simply gorgeous!

[@cassandraqcassandraq5510]

Check out the silver in colorpop stone cold fox pallette.

[@cteacher4080]

Love your eye look and mascara! Do you have any suggestions for your eyeshadow colors if one doesn’t have the Avocado Toast palette?

[@allisonn9036]

Your eye look is beautiful! I was so excited to see what palette you used because I have that one and I’ve only ever used it once! You’re making me want to buy that blueberry muffin.. I’ve wanted it forever!

[@tiffanymcgowan9458]

I love the eye look on you. Beautiful! I need to know where you got your earrings??? Please, I love them.

[@kaarahulstrand]

Such a great video! I’m a big eyeshadow girl too!

[@zizzie4081]

I have been loving the Viseart palettes I have bought this year. Best formula. I always thought that I couldn't afford Viseart, but the Petit Pros are $30 (I got one for $15 on sale) and they have 8 shadows. Great little palettes, make me feel very Parisian!

[@jaycreswell7008]

The petit pros are $56.00 aud in Australia - equivalent to $42 usd. It'd ridiculous.

[@1liberaldem]

Favorite palette so far? That's a tough one! I do really love the Alter Ego Luster one. Great quality. ColourPop the Child ranks up there too.

[@lesnspired1]

I absolutely love the silver taupe type shade in the alter ego Blooms palette. I don’t have anything like it. I sure wish I could find it in a single somewhere!

[@taramisu9978]

Maybe check out Sydney Grace? They have pressed pigment eyeshadows, they might have a few that are similar. Just a thought.

[@lesnspired1]

@@taramisu9978 I might ask for her help to find one! Thanks!

[@taramisu9978]

@@lesnspired1 Yes, check out Tiara and Peace under the pressed pigment shadows in the brown section. They may be what you are looking for, just know they are bold and intense. Mandy likely has a swatch video with these too if that helps.

[@lesnspired1]

@@taramisu9978 Thanks! You are the sweetest

[@gingergirl8797]

Love your earrings. Your eye look is lovely.

[@lindacalandra2999]

What a terrific video! Loved it. Mandy, you look gorgeous and should be queen of KZbin! I love the new Wet n Wild palettes. Knowing how you love Sydney Grace, will you be getting any of the Temptalia palettes? Beautiful.

[@madelinesmith6306]

I look forward to your videos the most of all the KZbin I watch!❤ My favorite pallete I tried this year year is XX Revolution XXposed pallete!!!😍 It's a dupe I found from Jessica Braun for Charolette Tillbury pillow talk pallete.

[@sandylay4005]

Guess I’m going to get some wet and wild. Never tried them I love the ELF ones

[@JRed-go8wr]

Heart and soul is my fave right now. Never ever thought W&W could put out such a great product! Interestingly the very first one you showed caught my eye instantly. Chillin in Chicago. I love shear-ish muted but buildable shadows. Peachy Queen from Kokie is another one I have and love the colors but the formula is not so great. I’m a 50 yo red head who loves colors but knows I can’t get away with what I once did lol😂😂😂

[@olinayoung6287]

Your eye make up is so so stunning today 🌟🌼🌟🌼!!! Thank you!!

[@Sashas-mom]

Omg I’m so excited about this video! I needed something 😐 So thank you fellow makeup lover! I’m seriously going to go fix a snack and get cozy to completely enjoy this video! ❤️🤗

[@matildeosorio8257]

I just love your videos! Sooo much info to help me choose. Love your tutorials specially

[@angelaburns4163]

I went to check out BH and most of the pallets she talks about are on sale!! I just bought 3 of them!!

[@raquelarredondo1642]

Mandy you are so fun too watch!0

[@ceecee7879]

Nice ranking! If I were to get a Pat McGrath it would absolutely be Mothership VI Midnight Sun! Only think I’ve been reaching for new is my Sydney Grace Summer Daze ❤️

[@tamarasparks8065]

I tried only 3 for the first part of the year. Morphe 1971 a surprise hit. The blue duochrome is stunning. Makeup revolution Friends (with the fountain) bought for package. Much better than normal MR. Profusion Citrine. Not sure why I thought I needed it. May need to play with it more. Just bought Nomad Berlin (tried a couple times and is #1 of the year for me so far) Dupe for Huda MR-Bubble Nebula. (7$ to see if I will splurge for the real deal if I use this) On the way: UD Wild West and CP That's Taupe. To order in July: Menagerie Flight Club and Whale Song and still want more from them.

[@tammyherrera7262]

I just bought the Nabla Platinum and it’s Gorgeous! 😍 I loved how u used the word “Pizzazz” and was wondering if that was a word on a sticky note on ur window? 😉 Enjoyed this ranking video so much! 😊❤️💄

[@juliekruse4060]

Great video! Your oooooh aaaaah comment made me laugh! I bring out my Club Nebula for that reaction! 🤣

[@jill_the_organized_hoarder]

Love ur channel and am obsessed with eyeshadow palettes too!!

[@frankaufman8192]

I love the way you pick your eyeshadow colors. So beautiful. You are so talented. I would love to know how you pick out your eyeshadow colors. Do you pick by the color of your eyes or just what you like? ❤️Fran

[@itsCaseyWilson_Beauty]

You’re my eyeshadow palette soul sister! I love your collection...we have the same taste. I recently bought the Sigma Enchanted palette and I love it-it’s old but I put off buying it because I didn’t “need it”, but little did I know I actually did. 😉 I also love my Alter Ego Luster Charm palette.

[@mandimarie2379]

I’m obsessed with singles but fave palette this year is Tarte juicy!