Ranking Project Sekai Vocals as someone who cant sing

hello! this is my first pjsk video ever so please enjoy
i got inspired by many creators such as jaey and hinomoriis just to name a few
here's the tiermaker i used to make the tier list at the end:
tiermaker.com/create/project-...

[@someone4585]

Tsukasa being number 20 killed me

[@lenny4244]

IM SORRY 😭😭😭

[@anonyme4659]

Thanks for spoiling me cause I would actually have been dead from the shock of this information

[@Tsummrm]

Womp womp

[@Higanbanaflowers]

Even though im a tsukasa fan, im not a big fan of his voice, its not bad, just not my taste especially compared to the rest of wxs, but then again i havent listened to tsukasa in a while so maybe my opinions will change

[@derrickchan3739]

I killed me as well 💀

[@t4woow353]

ena's voice its literally the most beautiful in the game, i get the feeling that she's "screaming" so i can get my attetion to her expecially in the envy baby cover

[@allyc.6978]

I think Ena has the highest-pitched vocals out of all the members of N25. She sounds pretty great!

[@beexox3442]

istg ena vocals are AMAZING

[@Kvnad3]

the way i SCREAMED when I saw Tsukasa at 20 (NO HATE TO YOU THO IT'S JUST HIS VOCALS ARE ONE OF MY FAVS)

[@DanielaSalamanca-te6cw]

For me, minori should be at #20 🎀

[@Harinrinlovesjellyjamm]

I also love his voice l9l

[@Pazweex]

I have never disagreed so much with a tier list in my life 💀

[@mop4yy]

Lmao it almost seems like the person who tiered the vocals are biased

[@0mega-pan206]

real

[@hamptercankill5985]

@mop4yy ​Well damn bro, people can't even have an opinion anymore? 🥲

[@J14078]

@@hamptercankill5985they never said that

[@bokunopico2226]

Facts

[@orange_nova4496]

My top 3 has gotta be Rui, Mafuyu, and Akito lol, I really love Akito’s voice for some reason and own every single cover of his ingame (I swear I’m not crazy)

[@depressedwaffle]

based

[@Phennysmusicstudio]

crAzy lol I love that song

[@orange_nova4496]

@@Phennysmusicstudio crAzy is such a good song bro

[@Dreamy29_76]

I'm still sad that the Tokyo funka and Meltdown versions won't be added to the game, like, why? it really sounds good there (especially Meltdown)

[@orange_nova4496]

@@Dreamy29_76 For realll they sound really good

[@keeweedot]

ive seen a lot of prosekai vocal rankings but the most popular opinions are having emu near the bottom, which i dont really understand. i just dont get how people think emus vocals are boring/annoying, she’s all you can hear or whatever. to me her vocals are what makes the wxs songs “wxs songs”. also, to me its honestly super hard to hit high notes especially in a higher pitched voice without using falsetto too much, and thats really unique. i really think emus va deserves more credit for being able to do that. if it was me id rank her somewhere in C at the very least, but just not in the very (second) bottom. overall nice video though! i really enjoyed watching this! (ur so based for putting akito at A

[@moon_dust4461]

UGHHHH ENA YES YES YES FINALLY SOMEBODY WHO AGREES OH MY GOODNESS PEOPLE SLEEP ON HER VOCALS TOO MUCH LIKE WHY??? DID U HEAR HER IN ENVY BABY BRO OML

[@lenny4244]

ENA AND MIZUKI HAD NO REASON TO GO THAT HARD ON ENVY BABY

[@moon_dust4461]

@@lenny4244 RIGHT

[@K00thryn]

ENA SHINONOME SUPREMACY

[@moon_dust4461]

@@K00thryn FUCK YEAH

[@Phennysmusicstudio]

AHHHH SHES AMAZING, but I have a question... everybody says her DSCF cover is amazing, I'm guessing you are an Ena fan, what do you think about the cover?

[@anemoiae]

i got hit with a metal pipe in the face so hard when i saw "can definitely sing (a rare concept for wxs)" 😭

[@Oyasumi061]

I found An voice incredible and it’s sad to see than I am one of her RARE voice fan 😭

[@q_zollie]

NOOO I LOVE LOVE LOVE AN'S VOICE TOO!!! She solos 😍😍

[@Oyasumi061]

@@q_zollie YES !!!

[@maea5158]

An’s voice is amazing I love it so much

[@its_luz904]

An is perfect!! I really like her voice!! I really think she need to be higher.... For my opinion she have a really good control on her voice and she need to place higher..... (Just my opinion)

[@foldy3129]

No it’s not just u it’s also me I really like her voice and I think she’s the best one

[@everythingz888]

I really agree on Haruka’s, her voice is beautiful but I feel like a lot of covers they get don’t show off how amazing her voice is. She doesn’t sound bad by any means but there are only a handful of moments where she stands out. I want more amazing Haruka vocal moments like If, Shoujo Rei, and Darling Dance (I don’t like the Darling Dance Cover but Haruka carried) Also as for Mizuki’s gender, they are heavily implied to be transfem. But using either she or they pronouns are ok…just no he/him

[@lenny4244]

Fr Haruka needs more love‼‼ Thanks for clarification on Mizuki, i was jsut really confused because people started saying that she's AFAB and transmasc because of the baby mizuki sprite on a recent event

[@cupcake8682]

I don’t get what’s with the pronouns thing I mean it might be HEAVILY IMPLIED but Mizuki never said her pronouns were she/them only I mean the fandom gets to call Rui a woman when you cant call Mizuki a man? Smh

[@BubblyGayThey]

@@cupcake8682 Mizuki is referred to with She/They pronouns in the global server. On the website (jp server) Mizuki’s gender is stated as ‘?’ So we may never know what their gender identity is. The reason we can’t call Mizuki a man is because it is disrespectful to the transgender community, if Mizuki happens to be Transfem.

[@cupcake8682]

@@BubblyGayThey yeah but “happens to be” doesn’t really prove anything and as I said, Mizuki never said her preferred pronouns or anything about her sex even though it’s heavily implied there is still a benefit of the doubt since Japan is mostly a conservative country and not really open to lgbt but crossdressing is VERY POPULAR. While nothing is still confirmed as canon about her identity, fans should be free to use whatever pronouns they want to use with her. And Mizuki is a primarily a female name And how is it even disrespectful for the trans community when you call mizuki a man when it’s not even about them it’s about mizuki. First off, She’s fictional and 2nd, why would someone feel oppressed by some internet user calling a bunch of pixels a man.

[@AmiaMizook361]

Haruka voice REALLY shows on Shoujo Rei

[@dima_yeon]

as someone who does sing, oh boy. i have a lot to talk about. first off, the title's somewhat misleading. when i read "ranking vocals", i thought the creator literally meant rating the voice itself without personal preferences - which is why i feel like the list is somewhat skewed and doesn't really share the clearest testament. i'm surprised honami wasn't lower on the list. while it isn't as prevalent now, honami always had this instability in her voice and her intonation isn't the best (you do need a bit of a criticizing ear haha). you can see what i mean by listening to honami's stella cover. i also think mafuyu should be lower. and i *mean* lower (pun not intended) - she shares similar issues with honami: she can most definitely sing soft notes. but hard notes is where shit goes completely haywire. to make the most literal comparison possible, it sounds like she's trying to take a shit after eating taco bell for the past seven days. her intonation's more noticeable by ear in comparison to honami's, but that's because it's when she belts that her vocals go all wrong. rui should *not* be this low. i personally consider akito to have the best male voice, but akito rly only won by a smidge simply because he is my bias. rui to me is that good. he has incredible control and is always completely on tune. it saddens me greatly that he doesn't have much spotlight in comparison to the other members outside of his focus songs. for saki, this'll be the time where i think the reasoning for her ranking is absolute bull. yes, she doesn't have many lines. but you cannot just rate her lower simply because you don't hear her much. this is really the only thing about the video that infuriated me. the an slander 😭 while all proseka ocs have great ranges, what separates an from the rest is her ability to control notes at lower ranges. for female singers, this is extremely difficult to do. many are predisposed to talking in their head voice and not their chest voice, hence they aren't able to quite understand how to control their chest voice. an does it perfectly. ena's voice is great, however she isn't the best. it isn't that she's bad at any particular category, there's simply others who do it *better* (i.e. Mizuki, Rui).

[@saint4331]

mizuki has a strong voice but Ena definitely deserved 1st her breath control vocals everything is really good especially her crescendos

[@its_luz904]

I 100% agree with this

[@krissu9864]

Interesting, what do you think of Ichika?

[@lemonadeboye]

i think the main reason tsukasa sings in a lower key in his NEO alt vocal is just not to strain his va's voice, as the original key is pretty high. so its ok when he sings the higher notes for a bit in the group cover but the full thing that high could damage his vocal chords. he slays it either way tho icl, and he's one of my least fave characters lol :))

[@Heyyoe_]

LEO NEED BEING HIGH ON THIS LISTS FINALLY THEY ARE SO UNDERRATED ESPECIALLY HONAMII

[@lunarmiau]

My top unbiased top 5 have to be: #1:Mizuki (Their voice is just so powerful and can switch so easily) #2:Shizuku (Romeo and Cinderella, Milk Crow on Sonechka speaks for itself) #3:Shiho (Her Peaky Peaky Cover? She seems more of the back up vocals though) #4:Nene (I absolutely adore her Kami no Mani Mani cover and I agree she can get to nasally) #5:Mafuyu (She can switch up between soft and strong so well, but whenever her voice is soft, it doesn’t stand out too well. Still, it sounds good)

[@Phennysmusicstudio]

Are you saying Shiho's Peaky Peaky cover is bad or good? Because from a long time Shiho fan (fave character), I have every single one of her covers and I can confidently say, Peaky Peaky is her worst cover. I'm sorry, I dont think any of the Peaky Peaky solo covers are that good, it will just never match to the awesomeness of the original! It may be different for the VS's, but overall I believe the original is best!

[@catrixnwn]

i saw rui on 15 i think bro gonna get cooked on replies

[@catrixnwn]

BRO DIDNT GET COOKED???

[@asheriiox]

@@catrixnwnTHATS SO CRAZY 😭😭

[@Kei-su4it]

Finally someone who rated them nicely! Even our opinions are different but I agreed on your perspective. Their vocals are incredible! Especially the fact that the VAs have to sing in characters 😭

[@Handuk.]

I still need someone who has hear kanade's high note in the full ver of reborn LIKE ITS SO ANGELIC, SHE CAN HIT NOTES THAT HIGH

[@RageDasher_7751]

Omfg. I would say An is NUMBER 1!!! I LOOOOVVVE HER CONTROL AND VOICE!! An ACTUAL singer, it's CRAZY! Edit, adding my reply: Okay, my point. I kinda agree that An's voice is weakest-ish in VBS, but I would like to imagine (thanks to her solo covers) that if she just sang alone, she would overthrow EVERYBODY! Being part of VBS and just the rap scene in general, imo really brought her down. From the VBS J-Rock/Acoustic and non-Electrnic tracks, she really kills it!! No offense to Hip-Hop, but I really don't think it's the right thing for An's voice. But for her story, it is magnificent.

[@lenny4244]

An was so hard for me to rank 😭after making this vid i do think i could have put her higher

[@RageDasher_7751]

@lenny4244 okay, point. I kinda agree that An's voice is weakest-ish in VBS, but I would like to imagine (thanks to her solo covers) that if she just sang alone, she would overthrow EVERYBODY! Being part of VBS and just the rap scene in general, imo really brought her down. From the VBS J-Rock/Acoustic and non-Electrnic tracks, she really kills it!! No offense to Hip-Hop, but I really don't think it's the right thing for An's voice. But for her story, it is magnificent.

[@AnOmoriFanatic]

I agree, i think she has super strong vocals, just not many powerful songs which is a shame@@RageDasher_7751

[@spookyghostthing]

I SO AGREE WITH SHIHO . im not obsessed i swear . . . just she has such amazing vocals omg . it just amkes me want to HASJAKJSND i want to buy all her covers tbh , theyre all amazing ( i think . . . i dont listen to covers often . . . )

[@AzuraNEKO14]

The fact that all member of n25 on top 10 is crazy

[@SakuraChuu]

Tsukasa being #20 made my heart hurt…😞Hirose Daisuke (Tsukasa’s VA) Actually sings like that on the regular, if you listen too his cover’s, He just adjusts his voice a lil to make it sound more like Tsukasa! Personally I love his voice…so as a Tsukasa fan, seeing him being the lowest on your tier list makes me cry- T_T (Also even though I’m not much of a fan of where you put some characters in this tier list, it was still a nice to see some good opinions on some.🙏)

[@olived9560]

This was made and edited so well! I loved the duration bar under each song, it was super helpful.

[@theaveragelogan7455]

Spoilers for vid guys teehee Shizuku and ena being top 2 is actually so real, btw ena is just like me fr!1!1

[@Pompomiswack]

FR I LOVE THEM BOTH SHIZKU IS MY #1 AND ENA IS #3 FOR ME FOR FAV CHARACTERS 😍😍😍

[@emmaforman4891]

an weakest of vbs is crazy 😂😭

[@TechneMakre]

frrrr shes my fave in personality, visuals, and vocals in the group

[@mint5090]

haruka NOT making top 5 is just hurtful PLEASE listen to her vocals in earths final confession one more time AND listen to her vocals in shoujo rei. her and ichika shouldve been top 3 with shizuku in my opinion and an shoudlve made top 10 at LEAST

[@AnOmoriFanatic]

An, Mizuki, Ichika, Mafuyu, and Shiho are my favs An and Akito have SUCHHHH powerful voices, they deserve to be higher/lh

[@AnOmoriFanatic]

I’d also like to argue that she’s one of the strongest in VBS, next to Akito, and Kohane has the weakest just because she has to maintain her soft voice more often An also doesn’t get many powerful songs to sing in which is unfortunate

[@AnOmoriFanatic]

VBS in general need more harmonic, impactful songs as a whole

[@shiraishifav]

an shouldve been sm higher ☹️

[@kumoric]

Although I love Emu’s vocals, I do find the singing high pitched all the time can get repetitive and even bad when it’s in deeper songs (especially Love Ka) Her voice (in my opinion) tends to stick out too much, which can be distracting sometimes BUT I do love her voice acting outside of songs, and also her voice definitely fits with more of the higher pitched exciting songs like Niccori Survey Team

[@anotherstrawberry-dn3nr]

Yeah, she's not as strong in game as I think her VA has the potential to let that be, again because the game devs want her to sing higher than the other guys. As an actual singer outside of the game, her VA's probably a better singer.

[@KatAstrophicPieces]

I’m so happy someone agrees with me on Shiho’s contribution to L/N!! Gawd I was expecting her to be in the lower sections since it seems like no one recognizes her 😭

[@Hamjam2223]

This is really well done! Even as a music major myself, I think you did a great job with the ranking!

[@starrshort6403]

I agree mostly and I like how you were nice and unbiased with the rankings !!! ❤ my favourites are Mizuki and Ena

[@YourLittleDovestar]

For me ill put shizuku at 3rd ena at 2 and mizuki for one Shizuku-for me when singing all together the mmj group her voice is not very standing but when its her covers its very soothing Ena-she almost has the same vocals as mizuki she has a strong voice that really stands out when group sings all together Mizuki-when she sings its very strong and high you could tell that when the group sings all together its very high with ena it almost feels that she was the only one singing with great control even when its a low note its still very strong

[@cottonyay]

i love the morning glory cover from honami its so calming and soothing it just wants to make me sleep 😴

[@_dolliepearl]

shiho carries every song she is in!! she is my number 1

[@yooootooobzz]

omg i agree with you kn a lot of these especially ena, shizuku, tsykasa, ichika and toya best opinion ive seen yet.

[@Luna_0521]

YEEEEEEEES FINALLY SOMEONE WHO PUT ICHIKA I TOP 5!!!!!!! I don't understand the people who thinks that Ichika sounds boring or too basic or something. Her singing skills are just so good and her voice is just beautiful! But I am not so sure with with your ranking of Mafuyu. I think it is really cool that her voice can change depends on the song, and most of all, she is REALLY REALLY GREAT ON PUTTING AN EMOTION TO THE SONG. Anyways, I would say your rankings was the most relatable one for me :) Nice video!!

[@pinkywiggler]

SHINONOME SIBS TOP 10🔥🔥

[@LemonJuice978]

This ranking is so close to my own ranking of their voices this was so cool to see!! No one gives Honami or Shizuku the credit they deserve so I loved this

[@someonewhoexists3972]

You are actually so real for this, I feel a lot of people overrate Tsukasas vocals due to him being one of their favourite characters instead of judging his vocals from actual singing skill (no hate to his VA of course he is still extremely talented)

[@lselm244]

9:06 Why did you put the worst Ichishiho cover as an example of why they're a good vocal pairing lmao, We're still underground is a much better example or even Tengaku 💀

[@monikaaaax3]

I definitely don't agree with this list for the most part , but I wanted to compliment your editing!!! It's really good and i especially liked the bar at the bottom that signaled the end of the segments My own top 5 would be (not in order) and favorite alt vocal Honami (tale of the deep-sea lily) Kanade (IDsmile) Ena (I nandesu) Rui (love Ka?) Ichika (idk, her voice is just nice in general)

[@swagcactus3497]

this is saur gooddd, i agree sm w ena and shizuku vocals hfhfvhv, but i would say kohanes parts in the meltdown archive shows she has potential to be top 5 but she is restricted by the voice directing of her character.

[@adamch.3003]

I'm so glad finally honami has a great place on someone voice's ranking but i really shocked you put An at #14 ngl xD, and totally agree how ena being 1# singer on pjsk voice's ranking if we about the technique same as ichika, they're top 1 and top 2 if we talk about singing skills, but everyone has their opinion and their fav tho. just like me if i made some ranking absolutely ichika has top 1 xD but as always i respect everyone opinion, is based on taste so it's fair, it's a great job you making this, i appreciated so much!

[@silverm00nlight22]

I have actually never disagreed with someone so much.

[@misspreacher28]

Shizuku at #2 is REAL AF IM ACTUALLY OBSESSED WITH HER VOICE ❤❤❤

[@sunnydotjpeg]

i cannot BELIEVE saki was that low, she has an incredibly ranged and strong voice and her cover of awaiting clear skies is arguably the best cover in the entire game

[@p1x13cr4k]

i was slightly confused by the way you ranked each character, like was it based on solo-performance or their performance within the group? i think if you said which way you ranked it, the ranking would make sense, like for example: i can understand why you would put tsukasa low based on SOLO performance, but his performance within the group is a lot better. or with minori, she was still low but it seemed you ranked her based more on solo performance, which was why she was above airi. js smth for though in case you decide to re-do this video, i did really enjoy it!! :)

[@beomkaslana]

(spoiler for the vid lol + my opinions that might be changed later) -As for Toya, maybe his voice is not the best in group for me but overall he's still good! Ito Kent is a great singer, really. But i still can't get used to his voice when he's in group, but when he's solo or with Akito, he's really great. But again, maybe i just think VBS are very lacking in terms of harmony bc their voices are quite clashing imo. Bad Dogs and Vivids are great, but as VBS... idk... (still one of the great units when it comes to stories though) -You made me realize how nice honami's voice is, would listen to her solos more -Ena #1 yes Yes YES!!! 🔥🔥🔥

[@Yumi-i]

In my opinion, the best voice in the game is nene, her voice is so cute and unique i love it! The second one is mizuki, she is my fave character too. And then An and Akito, I guess their voice together are so nice and i love their alt too (Odo alt is just so good!!) The fifth one is Shiho's, I loved her voice since Bang dream when promise was released and Lisa had a focus in a roselia song.

[@asheriiox]

I was so excited for this video until I saw tsukasa immediately 😭😭😭😭 (THIS VIDEO PHYSICALLY HURTS ME AS SOMEONE WHO LOVES ALL THEIR VOICES)

[@shogunRaiden228]

I love Mizuki's voice actor for the voice she gave to this character. it sounds both girlish and boyish, so you may argue about their gender a lot.))) the strength, the technique, the vocal range, the emotions.... all of these characteristics are about both Mizuki and Ena, and I really love them singing together. I recently played " I nandesu" in proseka AND YOU KNOW WHAT???? THE WAY MIZUKI SOUNDS THERE IS SO DEEP AND LOW, JUST NO WAY and Ena sounds much higher than Mizuki, so they create a great ta(o)ndem(o wonderz-) (sorry) and I really agree with the tier list, even if I dislike Minori and Akito singing a lot :") idk Minori sounds too sweet for me and I just don't like Akito lol. alsoooo I think that WxS is not about singing as well, their group is about amazing shows (oh wow thank you for opening our eyes, comment author) they put on the dance, special effects, the costumes that's definitely not about only singing, but creating a whole big show to amaze everyone and make them believe in wonders of the world so I'm not disappointed in Tsukaka being #20, his voice actor might not be a singer, but an ultimate actor as well lol tbh there's a lot to talk about every character and the way they sing, and even this as long as "that-one-long-haired-Tsukasa-skin" hair commentary isn't enough to describe all my feelings and thoughts so uh the moral of this tale is that everyone is good in their way so everyone has a song where they sound hella good p.s. sorry for my bad English

[@childofShizuKasa]

I do agree with some, I'd say my top 3 are def Shizuku, Mafuyu and Ena!

[@Ruirjdkd77]

YOU think like ME Personally, I like Mafuyu and Ena's vocals the most. I like Mafuyu because her voice is so emotional that she seems to cry all the time. When I listen to it, it gives me pain in my heart and goosebumps. However, Mafuyu's vocal is very specific to the group. People who like it will like it a lot. But people who don't like it won't like it at all (YEAH, I'm in a group that I really like :D) As for Ena, her vocal can be both high-pitched and low-pitched (although mostly higher-pitched). However, Ena's vocal is not specific to that group. Therefore it is easier to access. Personally, I like Mafuyu's vocal a bit more than Ena (because of the group I just mentioned), but overall the most mellow vocal is still Ena.

[@cutiesmileharuka]

HARUKA TOP 9 AND I ALSO CANT AGREE MORE AND HARUKAS UR FAV CHARCATER AMAZINGNDNRBSKGR

[@aimlessnights]

I highly agree with ur top 10 especially top 2 (shizuku😭❤ and ena appreciation) like omg, i was so shocked to see shizuku being in top 3 bc altho its not rare, normally when i see honami n kanade tgt or airi/haruka being low in other rankings, shizuku is often placed after them. I've seen ppl say so many things abt ena's vocals and especially shizuku's, like her voice being too soft (and yet they place honami and kanade higher than her) and has limited vocal range which I don't rly get but I'm also not one to judge either bc I too hv no singing background (but like i rly don't think she has limited range?? The high note in I am We are full version and milk crown A6??). Sorry for kinda ranting here but thank u so much for appreciating their vocals😭🥰❤

[@cybergalacticnova]

As someone who sings, I’d put Rui, Nene, Ena, Toya, Shiho, Kanade, and Saki on top. It’s not mentioned, but they sing with support. It’s diaphragmatic breathing, and more resonance is allowed into the voice, allowing more control and range. Also helps high notes better (bc u need to support high notes) and smooths out voice quality. I’m disappointed in Haruka, An, and Ichika. All do not sing with support. Haruka gets strained easily. Her character is being an idol for most of her life and she can barely do notes that can be EASILY sung with resonance, especially for her voice type. An sings with her chest/lungs. That accounts for lack of power. Singing from the diaphragm does give you more power, and since An has been singing a lot and VBS is based on vocal power, her voice could’ve been better to reflect it. Mentioned Toya at the top, yeah he perfectly represents VBS power; it helps that his vp was in Hypmic Mic. Ichika, same with Haruka. Girl, you’re the lead singer of Leo/Need and you sing worse than the rest of the members. I get that the VAs sing in character. If you can sing with support, you can totally sing in character.

[@bokunopico2226]

I'm so disappointed on how they used ruriko (ichika va) voice. She's such a good singer

[@krissu9864]

this comment makes me cackle, i don't know how i didn't notice this before - i'm sorry but "kanade and shiho good with high notes"??? kanade's va literally strains with them, she even once said she coughs much after voicing and shiho isn't good with singing high notes (stella, blue paint, from tokyo and meteor pulse show that) there's an obvious reason why she sang lower an octave lower than ichika during the chorus of lost one's weeping. also if ichika truly sings worse than her friends, then it'd would be the biggest screw-up from the management to have made ichika the main vocalist. if this was said on twitter i could just imagine the amount of qrts 💀💀💀

[@lilachues01]

ena has such a pretty girl voice ifykwim

[@bigchongus5140]

FIRST PJSK RANKING WITH HONAMI BEING HIGH?? SO REAL edit: ENA AT ONE IS SO REALLL... I SUGGEST YOU LISTEN TO "Sorega Anata No Shiawase To Shitemo" FULL VER IF YOU HAVEN'T YET

[@golfballveryepicfr]

Shiho fan here, I agree with everything you said about her. She does fall slightly behind in her LoW cover, but I think her voice fits perfectly in all her other alt vocals

[@pokalinka8097]

No way another Haruka fan?! I love her too!

[@eeveethefennecfox]

OMG?? SOMEONE WHO REALLY APPRECIATES ICHIKAS VOCALS😭😭 TYSM

[@Error-gz3pp]

Honestly a lot of your opinions match with mine. The only comments I would add are: Tsukasa: obviously he sings a bit different in his solo because of the pitch down (he probably had to record a whole other take for the cover), but honestly I don’t think there was anything wrong with it. On the contrary, I thought it was good that they pitched him down because that high note in the chorus would’ve been impossible in the original key lol Saki (and also kind of Tsukasa lol): the Tenma siblings tend to be much more unstable in terms of holding notes while singing, and that’s kind of their specialty. For some songs like Tera Tera and Nonsense Bungaku this works, but this also generally puts them on the lower end of vocalists for most people because they’re much more inconsistent An: does she have great control? I’ve always thought that An as a vocalist tends to struggle in faster paced songs (mostly I mean songs like Bring It On, but that’s basically the only song of that variety that she covers in-game) Nene: I feel like everyone knows this already, but Nene’s VA is a certified singer! She even sang the Konosuba OPs. Nene’s also a diva/songstress, so it makes sense that her singing voice would be so outstanding. Toya: can we talk about VBS Archives Dramaturgy together. that cover changed my life omg. Also Toya’s VA’s range is actually insane because if you’ve ever seen Hypmic you’d know Mafuyu: imo Mafuyu tends to use a lot of sobbing tone (idk I first looked it up in Chinese and that’s what it told me the English translation was) when her voice goes powerful and it gives her voice a lot of emotional weight but is also quite unhealthy. Also considering your placement of Kanade this doesn’t apply to you, but I personally greatly dislike sobbing tone and especially in the way that Mafuyu uses it. Ichika: FINALLY SOMEONE WHO UNDERSTANDS :D I love the darker mature tone in her voice compared to a lot of other characters tbh Shizuku: real because of that list of comments that runs off the screen, but also the light airiness in her voice that somehow doesn’t detract from her power??? she’s absolutely one of the most unique vocalists in the cast imo Ena: Minorin (Ena’s VA, not Minori the character lol) has released songs and covers of her own iirc, it makes sense that her technique would be top-notch. Belting is actually really dangerous for your throat and she executes it perfectly and in character how.

[@emuisthebest]

My top 5 definitely has to be: 1 - Ena 2 - Ichika 3 - Mafuyu 4 - An 5 - Toya

[@twstruggie]

this is just ena shinonome's world and we're all living in it

[@Oyasumi061]

But Ena have the best voice the game for me ( with shiho ) SO I’M REALLY HAPPY

[@sirlamp]

As a powerful voice fan, i am so happy to finally see the love for ichika, akito, and ena!! Some of my favorites in the game, great list!

[@Yuna_H490]

i'm so sad for emu tsukasa and an, i love an's voice :')

[@anotherstrawberry-dn3nr]

Finally, someone who's not dissing Honami! The amount of tier lists that put her in the last five for some reason do not appreciate that her voice is very much emotionally moving... besides most of your points do make sense and they were all chosen for the game for a reason... Pjsekai thought they were good singers for each of their characters, no? So really, most of the characters will be quite similar to each other in skill level

[@liveactionme6607]

I think that WxS has best vocals in game when it comes to singing together, i feel like im missing somthing if its just one of them singing, somehow despite being the only group not centered on singing, they sound the best together (VBS sounds the second best together thought) (Also placing mafuyu under all the other nightcord members is CRIMINAL her voice sound amazing)

[@m_catqueen646]

Dude the Shinonome siblings have the best voices in the game!! (In my opinion) Noooo you literally shot all my favorite characters at the bottom😢😭😭

[@jupiitersringzq]

REAL

[@MIZUKIAkiyamaFANNN]

OMG MIZUKI ♡♡ I LOVE THEM SM AND MY FAV IN THE ENTIRE GAME BECUZ OF THEIR VOCALS AND BACKSTORY ❤❤❤❤❤ MIZUKI SUPREMACY

[@x8shadowking8x]

Honamis cover of Kagerou Daze is absolutely my favorite in the entire game she sings it so well

[@TheSkyLightsUpWithYou]

For me, I would say Rui #1, Mafuyu #2, and Tsukasa #3. (Him being 20 killed me)

[@kakyoinnoriaki7288]

no honestly fr, i think rui has one of the best voices in game if not the best, his voice is soothing as hell too, i agree with mafuyu and kasa too

[@TheSkyLightsUpWithYou]

Ur so real for this @@kakyoinnoriaki7288

[@avvveryy]

I agree with all of your top 5’s fr

[@user-pz3qf1je9z]

I agree with how you rate the voices of mmj, l/n, and vbs But I really can't accept that why tszkasa is the last one 😭his voice is energetic, and I love his voice Also nene sings VERY WELL, especially in Hakoniwa no Coral I can't say so much about this (or I would talk about it using more than 1000 words😅) I would place rui, ichika and nene as top 3. I REALLY love their voice ❤ However, I hope there wouldn't be a last place😭It's so heartbreaking to compare with each other about how they sing p.s. I hope my English is understandable because I'm from hk😅

[@blndsunnndoll]

Honestly the realest tier list I’ve ever seen don’t know why these wxs fans r being haters 😭😭

[@Pancakesls]

I agree with this so much, KOHANE,NENE,AKITO,SHIZUKU,ENA,KANADE,AND TOYA HAVE ALL AMAZING VOICES❤

[@Dreamy29_76]

My heart can't help but insult you for putting Tsukasa last, but my brain agrees with you :( Unfortunately, no matter how much of a Tsukasa fan I am, I have to agree that her songs are almost always 60/40, 60% likely to not sound harmonious and 40% likely to sound good (not incredible, just good). Although I suppose that we cannot demand so much from him, Emu and Minori, since they are basically "embodying" their characters, Tsukasa is someone who keeps shouting and "exaggerating", it is impossible to ask that he not do so in his songs. do, because he would stop being "himself", just like Emu and Minori. Emu is the same case as with Tsukasa, both are very energetic, in the case of Minori it is because even her design could be said to be "simple/common", so her voice is not usually something to highlight beyond be soft (although she is overshadowed by Haruka and Shizuku, or Airi who has a slightly more squeaky voice) Still, I'm really surprised by Ena, I feel like she does it well, but she doesn't have something to highlight like the others, in my opinion the other members of niigo are better (Mafuyu and Mizuki can do really thunderous voices, Kanade with her soft voice sometimes it will make your hair stand on end, while Ena... ?)

[@roz5415]

Seeing Shizuku getting no 2 makes me teared up 🥹🥹

[@topiaz]

i think i got smacked in the head with airi's ranking /lh whie i mostly diagree with the opinions on this, still a good video!

[@shroominim9581]

AN????? 14TH WHAT

[@yurinate69420]

Don't mind those people who disagree with this ranking. They have some bias and got their feelings hurt when their favorites got to the bottom of the ranking.

[@starry.constellations_]

nightcord just has the best covers, period. (also wxs but nightcord ranks higher)

[@NiigoIsMyChildren]

I'm just happy that there's Ichika appreciation

[@gurryshark1361]

People early into the global server often hated on Ena, her voice, her character, everything! It is so nice to see her get appreciated like she deserves.

[@angelscurse_]

minori at 17 actually made me cry

[@HungryGumbo]

Seeing my girl An so low hurts my heart /hj nice video though

[@IzumiS3na]

Your lost one’s weeping take So true and real

[@Unichordfan]

tsukasa at number 20 made my day thank you

[@Pompomiswack]

YESSSS SHIZUKUUUUUUUUU AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH SHE IS BELOVED 🗣️🔥🥰

[@apfelkuchen9782]

I really like this ranking, just not that much of a shizuku fan but maybe I should play more mmj jump songs

[@strommieartz]

No hate on your placement, but have you heard tsukasa’s gunjo sanka cover? He hit the high note perfectly💀

[@slyar]

"Still not sure what gender Mizuki is" I think that's the point

[@TsukasaRui71684]

How did Rui get 14?!

[@shyseal347]

I have never ever agreed with someones vocal ranking list sm

[@Blubgrub]

Nightcord has got to have the best singers in my opinion

[@lemonlay17]

OMG YES ENA GETTING THE RECOGNITION SHE DESERVES KM SO HAPPY SHES NO. 1 AND SAME WITH MIZUKI (in my opinion my top 3 are: 3. akito, ena, and mizuki)

[@Kaisha99]

I’ve never been so enraged in my life

[@fullmetalfroge]

an and maybe mafuyu should be higher, same with tsukasa but not much, top 5 are incredibly valid but id have shiho, ena, mizuki in that order :))

[@fullmetalfroge]

ena's voice has such a great range, being sweet and youthful but also able to hit those angsty, more emotional moments. fits her character so well!!

[@worldsfuturestar]

Caca being at #20 is wrong His voice is majestic asf I love him so much Also Kanade should be #1 And rui should be in the top 10 THEYRE SLL SO GOOD EHAT Js my opinion 🥰

[@Katrinaa310]

Jeasus said he agrees with u

[@worldsfuturestar]

@@Katrinaa310 LMFAO

[@Leo_Lubz]

KANADE AT #1 IS SO REAL

[@worldsfuturestar]

@@Leo_Lubz YESYESYESYESYES