Ranking the Pop Girls DEBUT Eras

[@AishahJenmi]

IM SICK I DIDN’T INCLUDE DANITY KANE….

[@BbbPp-qf5vq]

It’s crazy cause they sold so much that Bad Boy had to order more copies of the Cd

[@nicolettedidone8298]

queen where is chloe x halle 😢

[@circusbaby4014]

Where is Jessica and Ashlee Simpson? Also Hilary Duff and Lindsay Lohan?

[@itssskobeebiiiitch]

Yeeeees even diddy didnt think they was gon sell bc he just made money from the show so his “investment” in them was alr paid off from the show had to be

[@itssskobeebiiiitch]

@@BbbPp-qf5vqomg just commented this also Brittney spears in 2004 was supposed to do goodies by ciara also brandy the vocal bible was gonna sing rain by swv but her team passed

[@ababyrainbow_3099]

i love how we all start counting main pop girls since 1998 because of britney’s debut

[@AishahJenmi]

oh you get it

[@omarslayz]

it arguably should be started in 1982 when madonna and cyndi lauper first debuted but i understand that britney just changed the game for all

[@nightcrawler8864]

​@@omarslayzdon't forget about Tiffany too!!! She was a one-hit wonder but an iconic one at that. Max Martin and Britney's team original took the teen pop approach from Tiffany. If you look at Brit's earlier eras with her performing in American malls, that was homage to Tiffany. I know she's not that big in the grand scheme of pop, but I feel like she was this one small supernova to really turn the gears of pop back into teenage girls' and pop fans' favor. Her one hit wonder was "I think we're alone now" btw, BANGER

[@archivesunset4214]

not really because the main pop girls came out around the 70 like cher donna summer or 80s like madonna janet cyndi lauper and Paula Abdul sooo

[@hunterwilliams8923]

She was a true phenomenon that set a standard so high that not even she could live up to it. A true living legend.

[@rat-x7x]

Do this but with their magnum opum/most succesfull eras.

[@jaab.03]

Can u imagine? The Fame Monster, Teenage Dream, 1989, Loud, Renaissance, Thank u, next, Born to die....

[@angelic4mimi]

@@jaab.03u forgot blackout

[@twiiterthread3885]

@hyperpoppinno self titled is

[@D1ON101]

@hyperpoppinborn This Way did 1.1M first week

[@twiiterthread3885]

@hyperpoppin no

[@rochoa7408]

BLACKPINK and black P!nk sitting next to each other is so poetic.

[@EiscueBall]

SOUR was not for me either, I was in my 20s and wasn't even going through a break up but MAN that album was GOLD, it made me love pop again

[@ValerieAbena]

I was 27 lol. Loved it and still do

[@EiscueBall]

@@ValerieAbena Same here

[@sassygrilledcheese]

I was 12 when Gaga debuted and I distinctly remember watching american idol with my parents when all of a sudden this obscure artsy woman is singing a piano version of "Poker Face" which I only heard on the radio, some guy was playing the fiddle, homegirl was DANCING and the mic was ON. Truly watching Gaga singlehandedly outrage the christian church and suburban moms was an experience like none other. Because it took many many years for people to realize that she could even sing well! She was not recognized for her strides in pop music back then like she is today.

[@Kermitt_thee_frog23]

I need you to do a part 2 but with sophomore albums (since that tends to be a make or break era for many pop stars) or "flop" eras (since there's been a lot of albums that have aged well but just had poor rollouts/were ahead of their time).

[@grimvienne]

You saying "I love Black P!nk" and then placing her next to Blackpink was so funny to meeeeeee

[@ikaysiaprice326]

love seeing miss girl at the top of my feed!!

[@lexithevenin7823]

IM SO GLAD THAT SOMEONE IS GIVING EVOLUTION THE LOVE IT DESERVES

[@AishahJenmi]

No bc the way the ppl don’t know about Evolution and the Singular Act albums makes me FERAL..

[@Quinn_M97]

Beyoncé had one of the best debut albums of all time. Dangerously In Love is an RnB classic. Signs, Speechless, Be With You, and Yes are so underrated.

[@alsk20]

Yes, Zara Larrson's So Good was that girl that nobody I knew was listening to, but I loved that album!

[@CatNagTaylorsVersion]

I was rocking with and appreciating Gaga’s debut album at the age of 4…I can’t tell if that’s a good thing or a bad thing

[@kells5993]

Chappell is the only artist that’s nearly touching gaga’s debut antics TO ME

[@AishahJenmi]

I agree

[@archivesunset4214]

she seems like a flop tbh. she doesn't even have a to 10

[@kells5993]

@@archivesunset4214 numbers and charts have y’all in a chokehold she’s that girl. she can sing and perform better than most of the new girls

[@makayla03333]

@@archivesunset4214 Her album is top 10 on itunes and billboard but her singles aren’t top 10 yet but that shouldn’t matter because she just recently blew up and is rising higher everyday. stop being chart obsessed and give artists time to grow.

[@dreamsicle3225]

@@archivesunset4214Once upon a time there was an artist named Ariana Grande. She too released a debut album, like Chappell has. By the end of that album cycle, Arianas highest peaking song reached #9. Chappells highest song is currently at #16, and climbing as her album cycle is still active. Mind you, Ariana did not get her first #1 single until her 5th album. Ariana Grande, now on her 7th album, is one of the biggest pop stars in the world today. Because an artist doesn’t debut at the very top spot doesn’t make them a flop. Time tells. Chappell has plenty of said time on her side.

[@alishamertelus1340]

The fact that you highlighted Evolution. Thats literally my favourite Sabrina album aside from Emails i cant send. Nobody literally talks about like that.😭😭😭

[@nicolettedidone8298]

Emails was great in terms of the storytelling & songwriting but i need more r&b pop from sabrina Singular act i & ii were/are everything to me.

[@jacqulynmiller4489]

Okay but slay for putting Zara in top tier. Lush life still is played regularly, but I can’t not listen to never forget you bc I’m a big 2014-2018 edm girly as well!

[@nightcrawler8864]

12:19 I didn't get it at first but the way I GAGGED, you so sick for that wordplay but you ate. That album is FUNNN

[@ValerieAbena]

A bit generous with that ‘where would we be’ category

[@MultiOdom]

You’re not talking about eras you’re talking about singles. Eras should include performances, music videos, drama/lore. To put Christina next to Rina and Lorde is crazy

[@monstewr1]

Hers is a very gen z take, so i can kinda understand

[@drednd5837]

TRUE ROMANCE is how we got BRAT today

[@allthingspage1498]

putting Camila on “we swayed” is not fair because Havana is one of the biggest songs of all time and the album did really well and ALL EYES WERE in fact on her. Why we acting like Camila wasn’t HUGE globally?

[@CatNagTaylorsVersion]

Taylor making it on the list with a country album, that isn’t fearless is shocking (I’m a swiftiee but I’m so used to pop enjoyers use fearless or 1989 as her first eras, so it’s shocking to see outside the swiftie community)

[@maxwellbossong4706]

girl who is saying 1989 is her debut

[@CatNagTaylorsVersion]

@@maxwellbossong4706 her pop debut since she did country before

[@CatNagTaylorsVersion]

@@maxwellbossong4706 I know red exists but I see the pop girlies putting that in the country era more than pop era

[@eternalbliss330]

@@CatNagTaylorsVersiontaylor has always been pop. she was never FULLY country. she was country/pop. the only difference in 1989 is that she started going with the trends and went fully into pop, no country twang anymore.

[@RuuBjAh1]

Okay but if you're counting Can't Be Tamed as Miley's debut, not only are you missing the Meet Miley Cyrus "B-side" you mentioned you're also missing Breakout (with 7 Things and Fly on the Wall), which I can maybe get into that it's maybe a Radio Disney-only record (but so were Kiss & Tell and Don't Forget). But on top of that you're also missing The Time of Our Lives (with Party in the USA, The Climb and When I Look At You: The first two were the first hits for the second Disney girl generation to hit the mainstream hard). Like without Party in the USA and The Climb, Demi's Skyscraper and Give Your Heart a Break and Selena's Love You Like a Love Song wouldn't have even been considered to be allowed to go mainstream.

[@KingKissan]

‘Oops my bad made too big an impact’💀💀

[@melad3000]

As a Music of The Sun STAN! I will say we ALL know GGGB was her true artistic debut. where would she go Aishah🤭?

[@AishahJenmi]

I would like to think we ALL know the answer to that 😏

[@jaydenbrown8517]

one of the boys is thank you for your service to me!

[@valleyofthedawlz]

As Tatianna would say: "Choices."

[@mercurysims]

lorde ran so billie could run 🤒

[@about_to_leave_earth]

and why those two are comparable? The music is different to me

[@AdovianDones]

Pink, CTMH2 PLS. How You Like That was a cultural reset, Kill This Love was the eclipse. Spot on assessment💫

[@jacobp5348]

I feel like the fame and pink friday are gaga and nicki’s best albums… dont come for me💋

[@AdovianDones]

Paper Gangsta. Likee

[@jani4245]

Not the no comentry on the ciara debut

[@andrewchristenson5771]

Zara Larsson is truly underrated. I love the song ‘None of These Guys’ from Venus, her newest album

[@alexducosin]

Taste!!

[@FeeESC]

UR CHANNEL IS TRULY UNDERRATED

[@juxemz3388]

Zarra Larson is definitely talented but her personality is very bland, she has hits but the music doesn't have a distinct personality, just another white girl like bebe rexha. and the whole "stoop being like gaga, you're not gaga" bruh people be saying to her "stop being like Madonna"

[@alvinistrange]

Kiss is so underrated it’s pure bubblegum pop and I love every song except beautiful it’s not my fave track

[@Dereisendrache177]

Good Video! My favorites in this video were Bright lights(My favorite album of all time! Badlands Sour Dua lipa Taylor Swift Also is heaven and hell on here?

[@archivesunset4214]

as much as we hate jlo...that debut album is insanely good. too many bops

[@AishahJenmi]

The debut was good but JLo is when she shook up the industry to me !

[@princessofstars666]

Christini Perri meant the world to me as a child lol

[@melad3000]

ALSO WHERE IS MARIAH'S SELF TITLED AND JANET'S CONTROL!???😩

[@itsdekontee7950]

Tuning in early 🎉

[@nelsonasemota3534]

Omg!! We’re almost at 10k 😮‍💨 like this if you’re an OG subscriber 😎

[@xxsnoopxx483]

I would have put fearlesss for Taylor instead of debut, because that was her main entrance into the world

[@dajawnchriscross]

I went back to the don’t forget video and saw a comment I made from 15 YEARS AGO 😂

[@risizirevlon4338]

I saw 19 on top n just gave the video a like,legendary album

[@theebiggest]

I feel Cardi on being scared she won't fill IOP's shoes with a new album bc WHAT AM ALBUM 😭

[@alexacarter]

“IM SO GLAD SOMEONE MADE A FKIN VIDEO ABT THIS”

[@whatever5922]

Girl you HAVE to get into Under The Sheets by Ellie from her debut it shook me up…

[@AishahJenmi]

Ok lemme get into it

[@heekamalokilo7194]

@@AishahJenmi I personally think that song's one of the weakest from her debut album ("Lights" - I don't know why that EP was in the tiermaker). If you have time, I'd recommend just listening to the album. Ellie was in her own lane for a while as a pop girl before she became more mainstream.

[@ValerieAbena]

Depriving yourself of Charli xcx’s True Romance 🤷🏿‍♀️

[@about_to_leave_earth]

I love this video so muchh, also the fact that you appreciate little mix x

[@D1ON101]

Miley’s debut era is breakout which sold 371K units in its first week and features the top 10 hit “7 things”

[@paula3916]

HEAVYYY on butterflies!!

[@GerminaTosic]

I never heard a zendaya song in my life

[@agrace4688]

Miley had Breakout between Meet Miley and Can't Be Tamed! Seven Things and Fly On the Wall CANNOT be skipped over!

[@AishahJenmi]

You right! I just link it to Disney 😭

[@asli9812]

Breakout was thee album when I was in middle school

[@evanrachelhood]

As an old mean gay who just found your channel, this list is very correct

[@fdoneris]

The first five albums on the top tier just feel correct. Like, where else would you put them?

[@itssskobeebiiiitch]

Goodies was originally was gonna go to brittney but eithwr her or her team passed

[@king-my3ps]

Can’t be tamed is mileys THIRD album girl 😭

[@acrux739]

😭😭😭

[@archivesunset4214]

I think cause it was her first more authentic album that didn't have Hannah Montana brand and the Disney brand pushing her

[@laurenemily6580]

I’m glad I’m not the only person who doesn’t like bet you wanna lol

[@AishahJenmi]

I feel seen now

[@PrettyLittleXFactor]

I mean... One Of The Boys has I Kissed a Girl and Hot N Cold but ok

[@AishahJenmi]

They were huge hits for sure, but Teenage Dream was such a moment in time that One of The Boys just doesn’t compare TO ME

[@PrettyLittleXFactor]

@@AishahJenmi Totally valid

[@monstewr1]

Marina and the diamonds is missing! She would be maybe in where would we be 🤔

[@tianawilliams3160]

"these are MY rankings, not OUR rankings" !! great video, only wish Lizzo was on here.

[@badboideeja]

I hate to be this person but that wasn’t Sia’s debut album, it was her breakout album.

[@monstewr1]

EXCUSE ME, RIHANNA ON WE SWayed?!?! The disrespect 😭

[@star_radyo_arabesk]

lorde should have in #1 list with pure heroine

[@paccinocappaccino]

If this was made for the pop boys, the bottom would be heavy

[@AishahJenmi]

🫢

[@about_to_leave_earth]

poor Taylor's debut, not even herself sings it on the ERAS tour 😭

[@wig8055]

this is such a fun video!! is there a link to this tier maker anywhere?

[@AishahJenmi]

Here you go! tiermaker.com/create/pop-girl-debuts-16511588

[@angelblue52]

Fergie and Azalea Banks should've been on the top!

[@kiyaninoel]

keri hilson in thank you for your service?????? idkkk

[@about_to_leave_earth]

full of bops tho

[@BiancaMelrose]

what software did you use to make this chart???? amazing video!!

[@AishahJenmi]

Tiermaker!!

[@BiancaMelrose]

@@AishahJenmi thanks girl!!💗✨

[@VarjakVoid]

Jessie J being top tier is……..a choice lol

[@AishahJenmi]

Her debut did something to 9 year old me I fear

[@Orchidthatb]

Girl I thought you were tyla for a second

[@LayeredGamer]

Ok but not acknowledging True Romance is crazy

[@BbbPp-qf5vq]

I think it’s a lil too much bias here, mainly with the girls who are niche. Like Meghan Trainor definitely had a bigger debut than Azelia Banks or Rina but let me keep watching

[@BbbPp-qf5vq]

Zendaya?.. rlly?

[@BbbPp-qf5vq]

Chloe and Meghan’s debut are not the same

[@BbbPp-qf5vq]

Christina>BlackPink

[@BbbPp-qf5vq]

Both of them too Also I mean Aguilera

[@BbbPp-qf5vq]

On the 6 was a pretty good record

[@flvvrboy]

very much disagree that halsey is singles girl because if u wanna get into her i really recommend checking out her albums because her single doesn't do her justice especially her biggest hits.

[@worldofroseboihere9187]

Ooo what about ranking all the pop girls least favorable eras? Like who was just bad but ok and who down right fumbled it all ? 🤷‍♂️🥴😵‍💫😆😝

[@abrahammomani2107]

Why ru shading Selena gomes so much ?

[@taaiten2480]

popboys next!!!

[@Igiulian00]

No Hilary Duff? 😢

[@AishahJenmi]

I knew I forgot something 😭😭

[@Igiulian00]

@@AishahJenmiit’s cool though seems like gen z does not know of her lol 😆

[@beebeevids6851]

@@Igiulian00we know of her!

[@Igiulian00]

@@beebeevids6851 well when Doja tried to make everyone sing along to Come Clean nobody knew it 😂

[@iovannito]

Thanks for this comment, no queen Duff, now I don’t have to watch the whole video lol

[@NicksElixir]

The way that is not Sia's debut 🤭

[@keirmcnulty8606]

choices

[@MOONESTATE]

Kesha on top IKTR 😌❤️

[@jordanlandfair8664]

do you have a link to this

[@AishahJenmi]

tiermaker.com/create/pop-girl-debuts-16511588

[@jordanlandfair8664]

@@AishahJenmi thank you

[@marciooliveira5451]

❤

[@Lizard-y32jk]

Halsey in only we swayed… straight to jail

[@imjakedeason]

23:50 explain

[@AishahJenmi]

I feel like Fearless is when she started to get her flowers whereas self titled was just ok

[@hassanmansour9857]

​@@AishahJenmiexactly, only the singles and 1 album track are good imo.

[@elizabethgertzen3070]

How you gonna mention Joanna Levesque and not include her 😢

[@AishahJenmi]

I’m sorry friend 😔

[@briellaterrell7091]

Where is pinkkk fridayyyyy

[@AishahJenmi]

It’s at the top 😭😭

[@lukem5289kp]

one of the boys by katy perry is the best

[@isaacjterry7050]

NO MARIAH CAREYYY

[@acrux739]

lana del rey's unknown era above christina aguilera's grammy winning smash hit era....... gobsmacked. 5 straight HITS on that album

[@pawnblue]

unknown era? born to die is more successful than christina's debut at this point in time, not the mention the influence and impact it had on music and how it influenced almost every new female artist, it's just your ignorance.

[@archivesunset4214]

​​@pawnblue lana was pretty much unknown/1 hit wonder from a random remix and hated during that era from that very bad performance. christina debut basically got a bunch of number ones hits and got her the best new artist grammy award. it's clearly more iconic than born to die but both are good

[@pawnblue]

@@archivesunset4214 she wasn't known because of a remix lmao, she was hated but she still was more relevant than christina and in 2024 she is far more relevant and known, born to die did more things for music so it's more iconic

[@acrux739]

@@pawnblue christina's debut album is diamond eligible with 4 top 3 hits... 😭 genie in a bottle will be more remembered in 20 years than any lana song in history... 😭😭😭 16 year olds resonating with lana in 2024 does not make it more successful omg what. spotify is not even CLOSE to PURE SALES

[@pawnblue]

@@acrux739 lana has been relevant since 2012, you clearly weren't on tumblr 😭 christina stopped being that relevant in the 2010s, her debut might have done numbers back then but people don't really listen to her that much anymore

[@acrux739]

girl this is garbage. zendaya's replay is not better than 'like i'm gonna lose you' the bias is ANNOYING

[@GoodWin-j8k]

I’ve yet to see you create your own video…

[@lujay5624]

When was cardi b pop she can’t even hold a note

[@archivesunset4214]

neither could nicki but yet they're both there😭😭

[@acrux739]

YOU ARE SO WEIRD if you had my love and waiting for tonight are objectively AMAZING songs.

[@GoodWin-j8k]

lol calling someone weird for their own personal ranking is a different type of lame behavior

[@AdovianDones]

Jlo stole one of those songs & that's just for starters

[@acrux739]

@@AdovianDones what does that have to do with the smash hit era that *everybody* back then loved? if you had my love is so acclaimed

[@RonyChatter]

I'm sorry but you put Yours Truly, Kiss, Title (omg what a freaking flop🤣🤣🤣) and that Selena album above 1000 Forms Of Fear & Taylor's debut!!!???? We really need to talk about this one. Also, Rihanna's debut is 1000x better than these disney acts. So stop disrespecting her as well. 🤨And again, Can't Be Tamed was a DISASTROUS filler album with 0 substance, Evolution (omg again such a flop) should be really kept in 'there was a reason'. 😅

[@acrux739]

y'all stay overrating lana's relevance and impact. *nobody* knows her.

[@asli9812]

cry about it 😂

[@pawnblue]

lana is more relevant than christina who you cried about in another comment 😭 lana was literally the second most streamed female artist on spotify in 2023, christina wasn't close.

[@pawnblue]

@hyperpoppin in 2024 lana is more listened to than christina, calling her irrelevant and unknown when she's one of the most influential artists in music is just childish.

[@pawnblue]

@hyperpoppin It's hilarious how you're trying to defend Christina Aguilera by calling Lana a flop when the numbers exist 😭 mind you, one of Christina's albums does like 45k streams daily. Are you not embarrassed? She releases flop albums every year but they still do better than Christina?

[@pawnblue]

@hyperpoppin and born to die still had more impact 😭 it's not only about the numbers, if the music is forgettable then it will be forgotten