Ranking The Top 10 Quarterbacks of All Time

[@FreeSociety1]

Fran Tarkenton was amazing. He held all the NFL passing records at the time that he had retired, and made it to 4 Super Bowls. And he was the original "Patrick Mahomes", as he would extend plays for 15-20-30 seconds at a time, and do figures-eights and reverse figure-eights in the backfield, while throwing the Football downfield with precision on the run. There was not a single pass that Tarkenton could not make, and he could also beat you with his feet. In terms of pure QB talent, Fran Tarkenton was at a level that redefined the range of the QB position. He is often overlooked, but deserves to be in the top 4 or 5 of ALL TIME.

[@nextmanupsports]

Frank is definitely underrated in the all time QB talks I’m a Georgia and Giants fan so I might be a little bias too

[@bryanjones4444]

Well done bring up Fran. I have created a formula that compares all the great quarterbacks since 1947. It is the most comprehensive analysis of a quarterbacks career ever created using 16 different statistical categories. It is based on finding out how far above the average quarterback in their own era that they were. When you run all the Hall of Famers and today's greats through the extensive process Fran is not only top 5, he is #1. The farthest above average of any quarterback since 1947 and it is not that close. Rounding out the top 5 are Manning, Brees, Unitas and Rodgers. And if you are thinking that the championships are not taken into consideration you would be wrong. Brady comes in at #7 and if not for the championships would fall to the mid teens.

[@DianeLake-sw3ym]

Tarkenton is very much under rated as a great qb. He was so dominate and seen in his time as what today we would call the GOAT. He really was a great qb and it's way past time for a re-assessment of this man's career and stop being overlooked. He needs to be remembered and given a little respect today. I like Mahomes being on the list. He is really what they call a baby Goat. Young and an up and comer but, already one of the great qbs.

[@bryanjones4444]

@@DianeLake-sw3ym Strangely he was not seen as a great quarterback by many when he was playing. He didn't get the respect that he earned because at that time it was looked down on when he extended plays with his feet. A quality that we value very highly today. It was not until he held all the passing records that he was talked about as being very good in most football circles. This feeling was emphasized when he was not elected to the Hall of Fame until his third year of eligibility. It was an absolute disgrace. That disrespect still follows him around today when you see top all time quarterback lists and Fran is ranked in the high teens or twenties. When in fact no quarterback, since 1947, has ever played as high above the average quarterback of their own era as Fran Tarkenton did.

[@philiprein8985]

Any QB list that doesnt contain Marino is worthless. Thumbs down.

[@phoenixghost1099]

Where's his ring?

[@limone2464]

L take. The list is perfect.

[@billycool6237]

chill buddy

[@phoenixghost1099]

@@billycool6237 ring?

[@billycool6237]

@@phoenixghost1099 i was telling the OG commentor to chill not you

[@curtisjones7489]

Steve Young, won the first two as a backup to Joe Montana. The Super Bowl victory in 1995 was the only one Young won as a starting quarterback. Troy Aikman actually won all three of his superbowls as the starter.

[@nathanalsbrooks1880]

No Marino and no Elway - this is a deeply flawed list. Young is a great player but way too high. Mahomes at 4 may be the future, but not the present. I strongly disagree with much of this ranking.

[@wiseandstrong3386]

I disagree with Mahomes resume and accolades alone he's top 5 as of right now.

[@roelcantu4035]

Frank Tarkenton , Roger Staubach , Dan Marino , John Elway , Jim Kelly , Bert Jones Bob Griese , Dan Fouts , Ken Anderson and many more great QBs , love football 🏈 watching their highlights leaves me in awe all so impressive

[@-PURPLE-HEAD]

Glad to see Young and Brees on the list. They both make strong arguments!

[@Wtfroflmao987]

putting brees at 9 is insanity after he owned almost every record

[@johnhardy7764]

But he only has 1 SB appearance and win

[@Wtfroflmao987]

@@johnhardy7764 takes more than a qb to win a superbowl. hell eli has 2 so by your logic hes better than dan marino, brett favre, and equal to payton. superbowls are a team statistic not a singular players. there are only 15 5000 yard passing seasons in history. drew has had 5 out of those 15. next 2 closest guys are brady and mahomes with both having only 2

[@AkhDawud]

Brees shouldn’t even be on the list honestly…

[@Wtfroflmao987]

@@AkhDawud thats biased as all hell man. you sound like a falcons fan truthfully. (before you get into your feels i said you "sound" like one. not that you are one

[@MrSpleenboy]

He was still the 3rd or 4th best QB in the league during his career though, 'cos he was playing at the same time as Brady, Manning, Favre and Rodgers

[@stephenwu1524]

No Elway or Marino is crazy imo, Elway never had great individual stats but that's primarily because he had the worst teams around him out of any all-time great quarterback ever. He was (justifiably) known for being clutch as hell and brought his Broncos to five Superbowls and won two despite the rest of the team being terrible for three of those Superbowl runs. Marino can be criticized for shrinking in the playoffs and having no rings, but his sheer production cannot be ignored. He had one of the greatest arms in history and his (regular season) numbers are still great by today's standards which you can't say about any other quarterback from that era, not even the illustrious Joe Montana. In my opinion, 1. Brady 2. Montana 3. Manning 4. Mahomes (if he wins while putting up good numbers in SB58, he's #2) 5. Rodgers 6. Brees 7. Young 8. Marino 9. Elway 10. Farve

[@Southern-t9t]

1) Tommy Brady 2) Joe Montana 3) Peyton Manning 4) Drew Brees 5) Dan Marino 6) John Elway 7) Aaron Rodgers 8) Brett Favre 9) Troy Aikman 10) Steve Young

[@Huntswick]

brady won with bad teams, good players get it done. stop making excuses for a bad qb

[@Southern-t9t]

@@Huntswick Brady had a bad team?

[@stephenwu1524]

@@Huntswick Brady always had a great team around him, in particular he’s been blessed with outstanding defenses throughout his entire career. Nobody on this list ever won shit without a great team. You’re also acting like I’m making excuses for why Elway never won a ring, when he literally won twice and got a Super Bowl mvp with a dominant performance in the last game of his career. Two rings is more than Rodgers, Brees, Young, Marino, AND Farve, and it’s tied with Mahomes (for now) and Manning. Manning was also dragged to a ring in his last year.

[@lightning10053]

@@Huntswick So you're just lying

[@sethadams2460]

Brees at 9 is absolutely wild.

[@Neckrollios18]

I think your list is very fair. I think some will say Marino or Elway should be at least ten, and I think those arguments could be made. But I respect you going with Graham.

[@landongray8687]

When will people realize wins are a team stat and it seems almost thats all people care about, the fact that a majority put montana over manning is baffling to me.

[@bryanjones4444]

Those people are out there. I am with you wins are team accomplishments. With that in mind I am curious who your top 10 wold be?

[@robertvirnig638]

I disagree. Winning games, especially in the post season is part of being a hall-of-fame quarterback through leadership and clutch play. I find it difficult to place any QB in the top 10 without a championship but in reality it is only tempting to do in one case and that is Marino. I would argue that all personal stats are team stats if you make the argument about wins. There are plenty of players at any position who had the talent but never put up huge numbers because of the team around them. Ironically some players like Marino may have put up huge stats because they were trying to carry their whole team on their shoulders. Dan would have never had so many passing yards if he had a good running back and defense.

[@bryanjones4444]

@@robertvirnig638 Very good points but I don't think you can have it both ways saying all stats are team stats and also saying that no one but Marino gets top 10 consideration without a ring. No player makes it to the Hall of Fame without their teammates coming through for them. Statistics are kept for a reason in all sports and generally are a good indication of the play of the individual. Especially over an extended period of time. Just to give you one example to consider, most pundits seem to think that Tom Brady is the GOAT and with the way you feel about championships it seems you may be among them. But you also bring up leadership and clutch play. Would it surprise you that Kirk Cousins average playoff game is better than Tom Brady's average playoff game even though he was sacked 3 times as often as Tom?. Tom's teams have enjoyed 7 championships and Cousin's teams have won only one playoff game. The answer lies in us realizing that a quarterback has only about 6-8% of the responsibility for winning and losing. That is more than twice any other player but still far less than most pundits would admit. There are 53 players and lots of coaches contributing but most pundits seem to think it is all about the quarterback, it is insulting to all the other players on the team.

[@landongray8687]

@@robertvirnig638 I get where you are coming from, I do believe it is the qbs responsibility to lead the team to win, but he shouldnt be credited for all of the teams success nor should they be accountable for all of the teams failures. A qb can only do so much, like look at the 2010 super bowl, colts saints, Manning was leading a game winning drive and he was supposed to get the ball out quickly to reggie wayne. Instead of turing quickly for the ball, Reggie Wayne runs a slow route and tracy porter picks it off. For some reason people blame peyton for that, and then the next drive peyton throws the ball over the center and his TE drops it, he manages to get in field goal territory, throws the ball again and another reciever dropped it. Theres nothing he could have done there to help his team.

[@stephenventura4075]

10. Elway 9. Young 8. Favre 7. Marino 6. Brees 5. Rodgers 4. Peyton 3. Mahomes 2. Montana 1. Brady

[@broderickcrawford8110]

In no particular order: - Tom Brady - Peyton Manning - Aaron Rodgers - Drew Brees - Joe Montana - Roger Staubach - Otto Graham - Johnny Unitas - Patrick Mahomes - Dan Marino Honorable Mention: - Brett Favre - John Elway - Steve Young - Fran Tarkenton - Ben Roethlisberger

[@KW_SPORTS_WWW]

Not having Marino is absolutely atrocious

[@phoenixghost1099]

Where's his ring?

[@goldwerewolf8651]

​@@phoenixghost1099 team stat

[@foosh553]

1 aaron rodgers 2. Peyton manning 3. tom brady 4 patrick mahomes 5 dan marino 6 drew brees 7 steve young 8 joe montana 9 john elway 10 brett favre

[@048et012]

No Dan Marino or John Elway? No quarterbacks from the 70's.

[@PaulSmith-xc7vt]

Where is Terry Bradshaw

[@luciomarchini6080]

And Bart starr

[@BigPackersGuy]

1. Brady 2. Manning 3. Montana 4. Mahomes 5. United 6. Rodgers 7. Marino 8. Brees 9. Favre 10. Elway

[@BigPackersGuy]

I don’t care what people say, I have done research and this is the list I have come up with. Mahomes can be put anywhere on this list I admit that 4 is probably too high but he will get there trust me

[@blacker5826]

Manning's playoff numbers don't justify him being over Montana. He almost always was a reason why his team lost. Averaging 19 points per game in the playoffs should not warrant you a #2 spot, especially with how gifted his offenses were and knowing they spent hardly anything on defense to make up that gap. He's #2 for regular season, but if you include playoffs, Montana should be at that #2 spot.

[@luciomarchini6080]

Manning at 2 Is horrible 3 or 4

[@BigPackersGuy]

@@blacker5826 5 mvps go a long way sir

[@BigPackersGuy]

@@luciomarchini6080 montana played in an easy nfc with by far the greatest wr of all time and didn’t put up the numbers and awards peyton did, also he did not play at his peak for as long

[@yomammasofat1000]

What Tom Brady did on the gridiron for 20 years was mythical. It just makes you wonder if Mahomes can keep his pace up…

[@Titanzilla-AKA-Titanus]

I don’t think mahomes will over take him in super bowls but I’d take mahomes any day if I was making a super team

[@tedfio1tedfio1]

Mahomes never played Tackle Football lmao... In 2018 Bodyslamming QBs was outlawed. He can't be on this list. ​@@Titanzilla-AKA-Titanus

[@blacker5826]

@@Titanzilla-AKA-Titanus Brady is THE quarterback for an all-time team. Mahomes is great, but he doesn't have the leadership, skill development of others, gifting, and being almost like a father figure to the team in a sports type of way. Brady did all of that,

[@campete8124]

​@blacker5826 for all time most positions are chosen by all pro selections. For qb that would be manning with 7 first team all pros. I know youll counter with bradys winning 7 rings. Thats a team accomplishment. 4 out of 5 times brady and Manning played the same team in the playoffs Manning had better stats and 3 of the 5 times Manning put up more points so no brady didn't play better than Manning against the same defenses when it mattered most.

[@blacker5826]

@@campete8124 Will you explain to me that, statistically speaking, Peyton had one of the highest-paying offenses in the NFL with Reggie Wayne, Marvin Harrison, and Edgerrin James, as well as almost his entire career, and could only muster up an average of 17 points per game in the playoffs? Tom Brady scored 29 points per game with having less than 40 games with a hall of fame receiver, and Gronk was unhealthy/out in about 60% of the games he could've been available. It took 2 historic defensive playoff runs for Peyton to win a super bowl. We've never brought up rings yet, rather just the context behind them. Too bad Brady wanted his team to spend more money on defense because he knew he could compete with Manning's numbers with almost nothing on offense compared to him, what a shame that a player doesn't want a participation award and would rather want to be first place. You're a participation award giver. Excuses is the language of losers.

[@yktvaha6538]

Steve young in the top 5 is wild lol..

[@BigPackersGuy]

I don’t understand why people put young so high. He is one of the biggest what ifs in nfl history. However he was only a starter for 8 years and was hurt one of those seasons… I don’t care who you are but you are not a top 10 quarterback if you only know played 7 seasons. Otto Graham played 10 seasons and made it to the championship every year and yet few people have him in their top 10… young is probably around 12 or 13

[@-PURPLE-HEAD]

@@BigPackersGuyMahomes only played 6 seasons and he’s 4th

[@fortitudetrainingsystems]

Dan Marino needs to be on this list. He didn't win a superbowl, but he was way aheas of his time and put up amazing numbers

[@JediJames21]

Very surprising. The OG goat of stats and the eye test!!!

[@MrSpleenboy]

@@JediJames21 and the most impressive 5000 passing yard season in history, which will never be bettered, considering the era he played in was so much tougher for QBs and WRs. Marino played through the era of Lester "the molester"...

[@Dan-qz8do]

Marino somewhere Montana #2 The fastest was Vick. There is no question about that. Most of the list i agree with.

[@robertogonzalez1494]

Elway, Aikman, Marino, Bradshaw, Staubach are also deserving. Honorable mention is Kurt Warner.

[@BigPackersGuy]

Aikman is the most overrated player ever

[@robertogonzalez1494]

@@BigPackersGuy whatevs

[@luciomarchini6080]

​@BigPackersGuy no

[@mattmccullough1093]

Brett Farr was Patrick m is hero growing up. He idolized him. That was his favorite player.

[@foosh553]

if he idolizes brett favre his wife should leave before it gets bad

[@mattmccullough1093]

@@foosh553 🤣

[@MrSpleenboy]

My thoughts. I'd have Marino in there at 9 or 10. He's the best QB to never win a Superbowl, by some margin, and he always kept the Dolphins at least relevant until his body broke down on him. And I'm a Pats fan from the early '80s 😃 Guy was like my nemesis... I'd also swap Montana and Manning. You want to win a Superbowl, you take Joe Cool over Manning any day of the week. Sure, Manning's stats are better, but they played in different eras, and it was *much* harder for QBs in the '80s compared to the naughties You could probably make arguments for Fran Tarkenton or Roger Staubach (although his career was quite short due to military service, he was a damn good QB)

[@denzellking-rn2kb]

In I agree with Mahomes and he came only go up or potentially stay the same, because he is still currently playing. In but right now with 3 Superbowl rings, and already passed Peyton Manning.

[@campete8124]

Manning the only one who went to the worse team in the league and did it as he's the only number 1 pick in the goat conversation

[@aledaandytaylor2613]

You have to put elway and Marino on the list.

[@edwardbright9434]

Look all th QBs of th world out all names and numbers but plz leave out #12 Tom Brady and his old Coach cheater these guys don't need to be anywhere in class of these guys

[@dougmiyamoto3109]

So I have Brady, Montana, Peyton and Elway on my Mt. Rushmore. But once Mahomes acends to it (which he will), who gets bumped? Elway or Manning?

[@campete8124]

Brady. Too much cheating and help. Second off would be montana. Loaded team with no salary cap or free agency. Manning is the only qb in the goat conversation who was actually a number 1 pick who went to the worse team in the league and he had to compete with the biggest cheaters the league has seen.

[@dougmiyamoto3109]

@@campete8124 Wow, didn't expect that.

[@williambarr3551]

Roger Staubach

[@hiatus161]

Was hoping this list wouldn't weigh rings too heavily, then the first comment I see before anything even plays is that Marino got snubbed...🤦🏽‍♂️ throw the whole list away.

[@lightning10053]

1. Aaron Rodgers 2. Peyton Manning 3. Joe Montana 4. Tom Brady 5. Dan Marino 6. Drew Brees 7. Brett Favre 8. Patrick Mahomes 9. Steve Young 10. John Elway Honroable Mention: Otto Graham (Patrick Mahomes place is debatable but too early to fairly say top 5)

[@ashtonmillis4951]

Bro is definitely a packers fan. Aaron Rodgers is great but he always came up short in the postseason. Losing to the 49ers in 2021 was the nail in the coffin for him ever being considered top 3 all time.

[@lightning10053]

​@@ashtonmillis4951 Nope. I'm a giants fan. The facts just speak for themselves. At a certain point you're just arguing with what factually happened. I watched the supposed GOAT get trashed by my team twice when it 'mattered most' so I've got no reason to cope like some of you to feel better. Aaron didn't choke or 'always come up short' nor did brady step up. His team choked while brady's regularly bailed him out. Stop listening to people like skip bayless. They factually lie to convince you of bs. Rodgers vs Brady per game playoff stats. (I'll even go based off 2008-2022 just so there's no era argument) 21 games vs 31 games. 100.1 vs 90.6 passer rating. 64.7 vs 62.4 completion %. 5.8 vs 4.7 TD % 1.7 vs 2.1 INT % 0 vs 2 pick sixes 3.46 vs 2.21 TD:INT ratio 7.6 vs 7.1 passing Y/A 11.8 vs 11.4 Y/C 3.8 vs 2.6 TDs per game. 443 vs 323 yards per game. See who wins in basically every playoff stat there is? Rodgers. In other words just say you didn't watch the games and only listened to skip bayless. Considering he's number 2 in MVPs. At minimum top 2 in talent. And staistically still the greatest QB of all time before adjusting for era when you look at both the playoffs and the regular season. It feels pretty safe to say he's at minimum top 3. I'm not even a packers fan it's just obvious when you just watch the games much less check the stats. The dude is at minimum top 3 if not the GOAT. Saying he shouldn't be considered up that high because of 1 bad playoff game is just delusion. Brady had multiple just as bad if not worse while rodgers has had so many great ones. Nail in the coffin? More like cherrypicking.

[@ashtonmillis4951]

@@lightning10053 well those are some nice stats, now let’s look at the most important one, winning. The excuses for Rodgers ended in 2021 like I already said. At the end of the day 1 ring isn’t enough to be the goat it’s really that simple

[@ashtonmillis4951]

@@lightning10053 I’m not sure I would call it trashed when they were both one score games if I remember correctly. And also I’m not sure why that somehow means Brady can’t be the goat.

[@lightning10053]

@@ashtonmillis4951 It's a team sport buddy. Claiming winning is the most important way to judge an individual is stupid. Terry bradshaw has 4 rings. Does that mean he belongs in the GOAT convo over Peyton? Eli has 2 rings. Does that mean he belongs in the GOAT convo over dan marino and brett favre? Otto Graham won 7 championships in 10 years. Where's his GOAT status at? Context matters. It's why bill russel ain't better than jordan, rocky marciano ain't better than muhammad ali, and robert horry ain't better than lebron. Context matters, whether it be a different era or a better team. So with all due respect you can take your winning argument and toss it cause it amounts of all of 2 cents in this discussion an that's me being generous. The fact your argument has to focus on a team accomplishment rather than how brady actually played speaks volumes. On any given year the best quarterback in the league will win league MVP. Yet before Mahomes last year no MVP had won it since 1999, and out of the 38 times a QB has won mvp, only 6 of those ended in a SB victory. Think back on the greatest QB seasons in NFL history. 1984 marino, 2007 brady, 2011 rodgers, 2013 Peyton, 2018 mahomes. What do they all have in common? No rings. At a certain point it just become obvious, the best QB rarely wins wht sb, so why does winning it the most make brady the best of all time? It doesn't. Brady ain't the GOAT. Like I said. Brady's had a ton of games just like rodgers did in 2021. So that stance doesn't even help you. We're talking about thee ultimate team sport here. Using team accomplishments to judge 1 player is just outright absurd. We're here to talk about how they played. Not how many championships their team won. It's just that simple.

[@SusanSloate]

Interesting list, but you never mention ANY of the teams these QB's played for, and I do think that's something we needed to know. I STILL have no idea who Otto Graham played for.

[@MrSpleenboy]

Edit: Full list 10. Otto Graham - Cleveland Browns 9. Drew Brees - New Orleans Saints (also San Diego Chargers earlier) 8. Brett Favre - Green Bay Packers (Minnesota Vikings, NY Jets) 7. Johnny Unitas - Baltimore Colts/Indianapolis Colts 6. Aaron Rodgers - Green Bay Packers (NY Jets) 5. Steve Young - San Francisco 49ers (Tampa Bay Buccaneers) 4. Patrick Mahomes - Kansas City Chiefs 3. Joe Montana - San Francisco 49ers (Kansas City Chiefs) 2. Peyton Manning - Indianapolis Colts (Denver Broncos) 1. Tom Brady - New England Patriots (Tampa Bay Buccaneers)

[@denzellking-rn2kb]

I think Joe Montana should ranked ahead of Peyton Manning. The guy has 4 Superbowl rings,and more clutch post season moments than Manning. I agree Brady is the goat. I agree with Brett Farve placement, and gun slinger and threw too many interceptions. I think Peyton is ranked too high,and he is in the lower top 5 ranged maybe like 4 or 5 but not 2 too high.

[@campete8124]

Only 1 who went to the worse team in the league as a first overall pick. When you watch the games Manning had no team help and receivers would drop crucial balls regularly with the colts.

[@candlestick1231]

​@@campete8124Montana was drafted to the worst team in the league, not as the 1st overall pick though, as the 82nd overall pick, and led the 49ers to their first 4 Super Bowls (all wins). The Chiefs receivers dropped their share of passes, probably why Montana didn't win a Super Bowl with the Chiefs.

[@campete8124]

@@candlestick1231 Montanas literally had another qb win with his old team in less than 10 years. Montanas team and coaching were stacked

[@robertwatson8408]

Bro how is Marino not on here

[@jp-ty1vd]

Bradshaw?

[@jeanninepetriel7114]

I guess getting 4 SB rings in an era that was anything but QB-friendly doesn't make you a top 10 QB. I have a massive problem with Brady being called the GOAT. Is he the best in the current era? Absolutely, but he wouldn't make it a season if he played in the 70s or 80s. In those eras, Bountygate was basically the defensive playbook. The defense's job was to take out the quarterback, and if he walked away at the end of the game, you weren't playing hard enough. The idea of roughing the passer being called on the defense because they looked cross-eyed at the QB would have been crazy in the '70s and '80s. Comparing QBs since the changes in the RTP rules with those before the change is like comparing apples and oranges.

[@lightning10053]

No

[@BigPackersGuy]

nope

[@luciomarchini6080]

Bart?????

[@adamstrange7884]

No Bart Starr?

[@Peakfreud]

Rankings ruin sports. They're never genuine, sincere or non bias. They're typically loaded with recency bias, because y.t users & viewers are predominantly a 18-35 age demographic And someone always sneaks someone on to be provocative...

[@steveporteroutdoorsohio4739]

Terrible list

[@crackerjack9320]

Montana is #1. Brady is the only argument. Definitely not Manning. Bradshaw should be top 10. Tough list to make.

[@candlestick1231]

I don't see many people discuss Bradshaw, he's 4-0 in Super Bowls and although his Super Bowl stats aren't as good as Montana they're still good.

[@mrmcllama0322]

Brees is at least top 5 and and Elway and Marino deserve to be be on this much more then Mahomes does especially Marino

[@lightning10053]

Overall facts. Although I have brees at 6.

[@BigPackersGuy]

I have Bree’s at 8

[@xiangyang99]

Steve Young was great but won only 1 Superbowl (1995) as a starter. Troy Aikman won three, but not on the list?

[@stephenwu1524]

Aikman was good and often downplayed by his haters, but he also wasn't even close to one of the greatest QBs ever. He was on loaded Cowboys teams that was akin to today's 49ers, except even better. Steve Young put up all time great level stats in the regular season and at least had one unbelievable playoff run with one of the best Super Bowl performances ever. Aikman's career isn't close to him individually, even if he did win more rings.

[@wolfwiles]

I have no idea where this guy got the Steve Young won three super bowls as a starter stat. Big error

[@stephenwu1524]

@@wolfwiles he did win three superbowls, but he was Montana’s backup for two

[@wolfwiles]

@@stephenwu1524 I meant to put “as a starter” in my comment. I’m aware that he was on the team when they won before. But no one is getting bonus points on a top QB list for winning rings as a backup lol

[@ThomasFaith-b5p]

Tom Brady 1 forever greatest pure passer and quarterback forever all time forevermore more no matter what love past perfect truths easily truth yes and he will always be 1 no matter what ❤🎉 truths.

[@Ghostrider-te7sn]

this is my top ten list and this is the right answer 1 tom brady 2 joe montana 3 terry bradshaw 4 troy aikman 5 patrick mahomes 6 peyton manning 7 john elway 8 Ben Roethlisberger 9 Eli Manning 10 Roger Staubach

[@timcoin4480]

I like your list👍

[@BruceDavidson-z1t]

Manning and Young in top 5? Really? Elway and Marino were better than both of them. Now Manning was truly 'Mr. October', just got a little tight when the games meant something. And Young played with all the Niner talent and went to .....1 super bowl? Elway carried 3 sub-par teams to the SB and then won 2 later with a decent supporting cast. Manning went to 2, defeating Rex Grossman the first time and then riding his defense to the next. Bad list.

[@timcoin4480]

What about john elway???

[@jimcurt99]

I know you only have 10 spots- but no Marino? no Elway? dump Brees and Mahommes....

[@All5Horizons]

Of the QBs in your thumbnail, Brady ranks third

[@jbeezy5]

No Elway? No Marino?

[@luciomarchini6080]

No Bart?

[@luciomarchini6080]

Bart starr no in top 10 😂😂😂 Nessuno nomina warner????????

[@anthonyglower2549]

No elway?

[@THG-nm9sy]

Dak Prescott? Kirk Cousins? They have proved to be some of the best qbs of all time. I could go on and on but i dont need to.

[@nextmanupsports]

Who would you replace on my list with those two

[@THG-nm9sy]

@@nextmanupsports Tom Brady and Joe Montana

[@crackerjack9320]

Dak and Kirk?! Not even top 100.

[@bryanjones4444]

I have created a formula that shows how far above the average quarterback of their own era all the greats were. 16 different categories are judged which makes it the most comprehensive study ever done. I am amazed that you bring up the name Kirk Cousins. Kirk is perhaps the most underrated quarterback of the last 40 years. Kudos to you. In my formula he does not make it to the top 10 since 1947 but he does make the top 20. I have not run Dak though the process yet. Kirk is ahead of Graham and Farve and Mahomes has not played long enough.

[@tedfio1tedfio1]

Farve won 3 MVPs in a row! He was better than Rodgers and Mahomes. Why. Everybody on the list except for Mahomes & and Rodgers to some extent played TACKLE FOOTBALL. In 2018, Bodyslmming QBs was outlawed, that was Mahomes first starting season.

[@ryanwills-37]

These kind of lists are the reqson Dave Stieb gets no love and isnt in COOPERSTOWN which ue deserves...if he was a yankee or Red Sox he'd already be there.

[@blakemiccichi2125]

kind of a shit list ngl

[@kennethmorrison7689]

What is this crap? Where is the GOAT: Warren Moon!! 4:36 4:37

[@SmackdownMadness]

Elway?

[@ah2552]

Brett Favre isn't top 10.

[@luciomarchini6080]

?????

[@jeremyroth6218]

L list

[@curtisjones7489]

My list of top fifteen Quarterbacks. 15. Jim Kelly 14. Bret Farve 13. John Elway 12. Drew Brees 11. Aaron Rogers 10. Steve Young 9. Matthew Stafford 8. Roger Staubach 7. Terry Bradshaw 6. Dan Marino 5. Troy Aikman 4. Peyton Manning 3. Patrick Mahomes 2. Joe Montana 1. Tom Brady

[@BillyChester-hb7cb]

Stafford over rodgers is blasphemous.

[@luciomarchini6080]

Stafford and Kelly over Bart starr ????and Warner?????

[@luciomarchini6080]

​@@BillyChester-hb7cband over Bart starr 😂😂😂😂😂

[@luciomarchini6080]

Unitas otto and Bart no?

[@ThomasFaith-b5p]

Tom Brady 1 forever greatest pure passer and quarterback forever all time forevermore more no matter what love past perfect truths easily truth yes and he will always be 1 no matter what ❤🎉 truths.