Ranking 'Wide Open' 2025 NFL QB Class w/ Dane Brugler

[@spoogtastic]

Nussmeier at 1 is insanity to me lol I think ward is #1 currently but wow, was not expecting nussmeier.

[@jameshollister8294]

Idc as long as cam ward slides to0 giants lol

[@nygblue24]

Cam Ward is #1, IMO. Nussmeier is a guy who you look to upgrade on every year.

[@blu0201]

patrick mahomes has rotted peoples brains when it comes to evaluating quarterbacks

[@jameshollister8294]

Nus hasn't played enough

[@frankl3518]

Lol, I doubt Nuss will be #1 much longer after that A&M performance

[@tylero2112]

For me it's gabriel

[@kevinmclane4054]

Loved Dane’s analysis on each QB and particularly Nussmeier. That’s refreshing and bold. People forget that Jayden Daniels was in a real battle with Nuss for the starting spot upon transferring to LSU. And Nussmeier has played really well against tough defenses - South Carolina, Ole Miss. It’s amazing he has only taken 2 sacks thus far

[@lucrative6477]

@@kevinmclane4054 your comment is being down voted like crazy because it is praising a qb not named sanders, lol. Pretty pathetic.

[@JamesSmith-jf5ge]

Mel Kyper has Nuss at #9. I'd probably rank him 4th.

[@jameshollister8294]

Dwayne hasking beat out Joe in Ohio why he transferred..so idk

[@itscebby8882]

​​@@lucrative6477Please, Shedeur is criticized more than any other qb prospect in this draft sometimes for the most ridiculous reasons that have almost nothing to do with football. Most people have Cam and Milroe higher on their boards than Shedeur so if anything people are more inclined to downvote people who criticize them than Shedeur.

[@lucrative6477]

@@itscebby8882 then you wake up from your fantasy land and enter reality.

[@teamramrod27]

It’s an atrocity that Dane doesn’t have a weekly podcast anymore. Have him on all the time!

[@theboystwo44]

If i had to tier them 1.cam 2.sanders 3.quinn, beck, nuss 4.allar, milroe I think nuss, milroe, and allar should come back and develop a bit more.

[@hansomr7511]

Please keep the content coming. Draft stuff saves my sanity

[@Jeffeleptic]

So this was 3 weeks ago and I think it’s aged poorly, Nuss has regressed a decent amount and Sanders has been better and better

[@nicholasbraxton1342]

I love Dane Brugler and his analysis but, to me the QB board is Cam Ward, Shedeur Sanders and, Garrett Nussmeier. I watched the All 22 against KState so I know what he is talking about when he references drifting. My rebuttal to that is I followed that tape up by watching the Arizona all 22 film. In that game it was a clear improvement in his drops. If Shedeur was drastically bad with this every game I would agree with Dane Brugler but, when you turn on the tape you see improvements in this area. The only argument you can have is the defenses he is playing. Shedeur's main weakness is him holding on to the ball too long but, we have seen QBs get better with this over time like Geno Smith who Shedeur has been compared to. In a timing offense I think Shedeur would really excel. Shedeur might not have an elite arm but, he has a good one. I have seen Shedeur make all the pre-requisite throws. I have seen him throw from hash to hash, I have seen him throw 50 yard passes, I have seen him fit the ball in tight windows etc. He makes all the throws necessary to play to at the next level. Shedeur in his playing career never really had an offensive guru. Nussmeier has Brian Kelly, Milroe has Deboer, Ward had GJ Kinne, Jack Dickert etc. The best offensive coordinator Shedeur has had is the one he has now which is Pat Shurmur. Shedeur has done a lot in a difficult situation. If you put Shedeur in a better situation I believe he would flourish. Shedeur to me is very similar to Geno Smith and, I believe he has Matt Ryan type arm strength. Shedeur has the intangibles to be a better pro than a college player.

[@jameshollister8294]

I'm not banking on a one year starter in nuss

[@tonypassaretti]

I like Allar more than all Ward, Sanders and Nussmeier, Ewers and Beck.

[@cmcgccjsl]

3 picks by Nussmeier in his first game against a good defense that could make him uncomfortable. I'm shocked! Shocked I say. None of these other guys could be remotely close to what Shedeur is if they had to deal with what he deals with on a regular basis, that being no running game and constant pass rush. 🤷

[@WilsonianGarveyite]

Beat me to it.

[@tyronedavis7656]

Bro listed someone who has played like 8-9 games, as the #1 QB in the class. Ahead of Sanders, Ward, Milroe, Allar, and Ewers. Even a subpar Beck deserves more respect than that. Then they wonder WHY it always ends up playing out like they don't know WTF they're talking about when it comes to the NFL draft. I don't know if it's a desire to LOOK like they see something that us mere mortals can't see, or what it is. Some other dude listed Miller Moss as a top 3 QB. After like 6-7 games? Do kindly STFU. 😑

[@SDRHaki]

Notice that all the analysts are doing this at the same time. Its every year I think they get together and try to elevate some of these average Qbs

[@TANKASAVAGE]

Right tell me about it I played Football my whole life. I know talent when I see it in I know what a good NFL Quarterback looks like and Cam And Sheddur is the only two Quarterbacks worth watching and Drafting in the Top 10. I hate people like this that never played the game but fell they can talk on the game straight clowns 🤡

[@noslen1988]

Interesting ranking to say the least…

[@Super.5th]

Why would I draft Jalen Milroe and the white boy over shaduer or cam it just doesn’t make sense

[@larrybedouin2921]

The white boy? 🤨

[@Super.5th]

@@larrybedouin2921 yea I don’t know his name

[@xrkuzd1569]

This dude is a joke of an expert. Imagine putting Milroe ahead of Shaduer. LMAO. WOW just WOW. Shadeur is the ONLY NFL QB in this draft. Will come back to this in 2 years.

[@Francisk25]

@@Super.5thCarson Beck

[@jameshollister8294]

They always inflate white QB if they can .. Remember Mitch,Pat, Watson

[@sportsking3631]

Jets fan here already looking at QB prospects

[@paulrobinette967]

The beast is great, I have to get it every year!

[@jonv1776]

Browns fan here... seriously depressed I even have to watch college QB draft analysis again... sigh.

[@smercxz]

Mann that’s why I’m here too bro 😭😭😭

[@jonv1776]

@@smercxz And apparently this draft class is Mid A.F. lol

[@smercxz]

@@jonv1776 just our luck to miss a great class by a year too😮‍💨 I’d only be interested in us taking Cam Ward or Garrett Nussmeier and maybe Jalen Milroe just so I can have some excitement for his running abilities 😭😭

[@ouroborosnagyok9306]

@@smercxz but a running QB doesnt fit Stefanski at all..

[@timedell2012]

Brugler is the best!!

[@tekkstar3055]

This video did not age well and it took less than a week to prove this "scout" wrong 😂. Nussmeier is a backup qb at best. Cam is QB1.

[@victorvaldes3700]

Bunch of clowns 🤡🤡🤡😂😂😂🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾

[@DK-BayBay]

Things being said about Ward were exactly the same thing they said about Mahomes and Allen and tbf other qbs that did bust. Its a risk reward. But fact remains if you dont have a qb, you cant win. Ward doesnt have that level of arm talent but its good, and he can throw with all the arm angles and off platform. However what he has that they never had was pre snap recognition and poise. The only qb to me with that besides him is Sanders, and both have the aura around them. Sanders aura is Cam Newton and Ward has that Mahomes/Brady type effect where game is on the line and you know he's going to make a play to win the game. You cant coach that.

[@RudeDawgRaider]

Yall full of it.... I've been last year draft class all qbs up to bo nix were top 15 everyone saying beginning jayden and Caleb were only 1st rounders.... say this crap every year... I'm telling you now.... if there's a demand of qbs like last year it will happen again. Not like last year qbs but you got Shedeur/Ward/Ewers/Milroe/Beck are 1st rounders candidates.

[@colbyhhh7444]

This list is absolutely horrible

[@DemWhoDatBaae]

Use of the word absolutely....now I know its a solid list

[@jamaalmorantjr2254]

This list is terrible

[@Landofhim]

This is honestly really bad, sorry.

[@jacksonklark6119]

Michael penix and Bo Nix didn't "sneak in there" they went in the first 12 picks penix went before McCarthy.

[@dtxbubba6717]

Yeah this guy is smoking if he thinks jalen milroe will be a good nfl qb

[@jameshollister8294]

Why won't he? I really don't watch him much

[@dtxbubba6717]

He will be very limited in the nfl he had one good half against Georgia and hasn't done nothing of significane since he will not beat you throwing the ball and will be easy to predict at the next level just like anthony Richardson, and also snt forget this is the same jalen milroe that got benched last year and this year might get benched again if he has another bad half​@jameshollister8294

[@michaelserkey6951]

Ironic. I have written in another forum that Nussmeier has the most potential to succeed in the NFL.

[@elevatedsports22]

Maybe it’s best that these guys aren’t going to go early to some garbage team that they have to pick up off of the floor. It’s better for PROBABLY all of these guys to at least sit a year and learn.

[@jameshollister8294]

I'm not banking on a one year starter in nuss .. Ome year starter is a mitch flag

[@jcl1964-m2l]

Given Dane's hesitancy, I wouldn't take any of these QBs in the first rd.

[@JamesSmith-jf5ge]

Unpopular opinion, I'm sure, but i wouldn't draft any of these qbs in the top 10. Id trade down and stash picks.

[@adrianbuck8772]

Why would anybody trade up? Also its still an long season and most of the guys have will have big time matchups to improve their Stock.

[@JamesSmith-jf5ge]

@@adrianbuck8772 It just seems like every year teams go QB crazy right before the draft.

[@SDRHaki]

Nissmeier is the new average Qb they try to move up every year

[@tylero2112]

Jaxon dart.

[@theredguy92]

Well this take on the qb class seemed crazy when i first watched it and 2 days later can confirm Nussmeir is not it.

[@nathanshlap]

Nussmeier 🤡🤡🤡

[@michaelavila9963]

Everyone thinks that the so-called "best" college QB RIGHT NOW is going to be the best PRO QB. Everyone wants it RIGHT NOW, but that's not how it works. Alot of these QBs are FINISHED PRODUCT. They are not going to get any better than they already are. Nussmier has potential to be a decent PRO QB, but it's not going to be right away. I want a QB that has room to grow and is willing to learn and be coached. Some of these guys think that they know it all and don't want anybody trying to coach them. (running QBs)

[@caleb8407]

Nussmeier 😂😂😂😂

[@ZWhiteSr]

Cam Ward is just another AR. Should be playing wide out couldn’t throw accurate through a open garage door

[@kaleb9203]

Dane trolling or he just hit the lotto

[@biggie6181]

This guy doesn't have a clue what he's talking about 😂

[@caleb8407]

This has got to be a troll list.

[@ElviraIancu-x6k]

Terrible list😂

[@jay32kool]

This is the dumbest list I’ve seen. Beck is not an nfl quarterback. Milroe and Nussmeier have two of the best rosters in the country and Sanders has clearly outplayed both of them. Tua has led the league in passing on C-/D+ arm strength. Using that as ur only argument to put him as the 4th quarterback in his class is laughable. Shedeur and Cam Ward are the 2 best in this class then there is a significant gap.

[@chasinspring]

I watched the Sanders kid for one game. Dude cant escape tackles for crap. Not impressed with anything other than the coattail he rides.

[@qjsmith5900]

Somebody trying to become famous because this list trash asf.Shedeur Sanders is the best QB in the draft.

[@lucrative6477]

I tried to tell everyone about shedeur. Lack of arm strength, very very very slow process speed, maybe the worst I’ve ever seen, even compared to fields. Can he improve and justify being a day 2 pick? Maybe. I don’t have much faith tho. He’s had elite coaching his whole life and just seems clueless out there.

[@luisgonzalez5076]

you don't know ball

[@nicholasbraxton1342]

One Shedeur arm strength is similar to Matt Ryan/ Joe Burrow. To me he is very similar to Geno Smith coming out of WVU. They both played in a wide open offense, both are natural throwers, both struggled with pocket presence in college so, I believe he can make improvements in that area. I disagree he processes fine, he is not as elite but, he is good. The issue is him tying his footwork in with his progressions. I also disagree about the elite coaching aspect. Nussmeier is with Brian Kelly, Milroe is with Deboer, Ward has been with GJ Kinne and, Jake Dickert. Shedeur has never had an offensive coordinator or QB coach of that caliber. Shedeur's best offensive coordinator is the one he has now which is Pat Shurmur. I believe in a timing offense Shedeur would excel. I watched the All 22 KState tape so I know what Dane Brugler is talking about but, I followed that up by watching the Arizona all 22 tape and, in that game his drops were very good

[@lucrative6477]

@@nicholasbraxton1342 that’s an insane comment lmao. No. Wtf are you smoking.

[@nicholasbraxton1342]

@@lucrative6477 How is it an insane comment? Shedeur doesn't have a noodle for arm. That's why Dane said Sheduer has a B level arm. An A level arm is like Pat Mahomes, Aaron Rodgers, Brett Farve etc. A noodle arm is like Kenny Pickett, etc. Shedeur doesn't have a weak arm, he doesn't have an elite one. I have seen Shedeur make throws consistently from hash to hash, I have consistently seen him be able to drop the ball between two defenders. Also I remember Geno Smith first seasons with the Jets. Geno struggled with blitz pickup and, recognition at WVU, so I guess you didn't watch him there. Three tell me who has been Shedeur's offensive coordinators and, how many QBs did they develop before Pat Shurmur, I'll wait. I watched Shedeur go through his reads, watched him throw people open. His main areas for concern is him holding the ball too long and, his pocket presence but, in a timing offense I believe he would flourish. I don't know if you just don't like him but, he has the intangibles to be good at the next level

[@lucrative6477]

@@nicholasbraxton1342 what are you on sir lmao. In what crazy world does geno or burrow have a weak arm? Have you never heard the story Travis kelce tells? That’s a hof tight end and ex qb who would like to disagree with your assessment. Geno and burrow both have strong but below elite arm talent. Shedeur isn’t sniffing either of their talent levels. Stop it. You are clearly just a bandwagon fan saying anything to cope lol.

[@cmcgccjsl]

Every QB in this discussion struggles against constant pressure and when they have zero running game, except one. Shedeur Sanders exists in that state constantly because he isn't playing on a loaded team with a great offensive line and elite RBs. If Sanders was so terrible against pressure he wouldn't have numbers at all because he's constantly under it. Also the back peddling is a result of two years of constant pressure with no running game. It's funny that folks can't see that. This is embarrassing and how guys like this just suck at picking QBs. Cam Ward is inaccurate, makes terrible decisions consistently and is doing so on a team that is measurably more talented than every team they've played. He's Quinton Ewers, destined to implode in the playoff against a defense that doesn't get dragged 5 yards by his running back. What Shedeur would be doing with his pocket presence/awareness, accuracy, and ability to process under pressure in the same situation as these other guys would be terrifying. 🤦

[@rocafellagibson502]

Facts brother i don't care what anybody say he's the number one qb i like cam too but put Shedeur on that miami team they would still be undefeated

[@nicholasbraxton1342]

I love Dane Brugler and his analysis but, to me the QB board is Cam Ward, Shedeur Sanders and, Garrett Nussmeier. I watched the All 22 against KState so I know what he is talking about. My rebuttal to that is I followed that tape up by watching the Arizona all 22 film. In that game it was a clear improvement in his drops. If Shedeur was drastically bad with this every game I would agree with Dane Brugler but, when you turn on the tape you see improvements in this area. The only argument you can have is the defenses he is playing. Shedeur's main weakness is him holding on to the ball too long but, we have seen QBs get better with this over time like Geno Smith who Shedeur has been compared to. In a timing offense I think Shedeur would really excel. Shedeur in his playing career never really had an offensive guru. Nussmeier has Brian Kelly, Milroe has Deboer, Ward had GJ Kinne, Jack Dickert etc. Shedeur has done a lot in a difficult situation. If you put Shedeur in a better situation I believe he would flourish. Shedeur to me is very similar to Geno Smith and, I believe he has Matt Ryan type arm strength

[@adrianbuck8772]

Sanders got sacked over 50 times last season. Thats not happening if your constantly taking the quick passes or dump offs. In college you can get away with it because its way easier to have an big play afterwards to keep the drive alive. In the NFL that tendency will get many drives killed. Also it will get him injured aswell.

[@bigsyke848]

Nuss the interception bust. Over hyped clear man.

[@chiefybaby]

Not good analysis at all