rating Black Butler/Kuroshitsuji ships...

i apologize if theres any errors you notice in here, i have proofed and exported it about a million times; making the video delayed by an hour, and i haven't caught anything interrupting as of right now.
im very happy to finally make a narrated video again!
-
in this video you guys gave me a variety of Black Butler ships to rate and i rated the ones i had chosen! thank you for all of your suggestions! 💞
-
ships and their ratings: (explanations in video)
ciel x lizzy: 7/10
alois x ciel: 2/10
sebastian x grell: 3/10
grell x william: 1/10
ran mao x mey rin: 6/10
beast x joker: 5/10
ciel x mcmillan: 8/10
ciel x doll/freckles: 3/10
alois x lizzy: 1/10
sebastian x claude 0/10
beast x dagger: 7/10
-
music is by kevin macleod!
Basement Floor
-
i hope every one of you has an amazing weekend and that you enjoyed me rating your (MOSTLY) cursed and heinous ships 😨🤎☕️

[@casuilol]

I never thought about Ciel x McMillin but now I think that would be so cute!

[@ghostlyolive]

honestly it is rlly cute 😭💞

[@Sassy_Sylvio]

Mummified sushi roll lmao. Bro your reactions and randomness are so funny, I love it 😂

[@ghostlyolive]

THANK U LOL i dont see many ppl acknowledge it but i cant resist putting crack in every video.. 🌝

[@DrWho160]

Typically these sort of ratings are just whether or not the creator likes the ship rather than whether or not the ship itself would work out. Too often I see ships that could potentially be straight up abusive (Grell and William, for instance, I feel wouldn’t be the healthiest) being supported when they really shouldn’t be. All that to say this is a nice change.

[@ghostlyolive]

thank you so much ❤ i try to be logical and not get up in my feelings ☺

[@alexander_yoko]

You can ship what you want, but I'll have to defend Grelliam here. People say how this is abusive, but Grell is an extreme sado-masochist and she even said that in front of William. William is how she wants him to be. Both of them seem to have a problematic attitude towards violence, but this is rather their personal problem, not the ship in itself. Grell isn't a victim and even Yana and Editor K. said Grell allows William to behave like that. I made some videos about these two characters and they aren't angels, but I won't say their relationship is potentially toxic. Sorry for the long comment.

[@bellecarter6042]

YES OMG I'M GLAD I'M NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO FEELS THAT WAY ABOUT CIELOIS

[@bellecarter6042]

A PART TWO WOULD SLAY YOU'RE HILARIOUS

[@ghostlyolive]

@@bellecarter6042 THANK U BRO 🫶

[@bellecarter6042]

@@ghostlyolive YW MAN

[@shadowandlight237]

Ciel x real Ciel 💀💀💀💀💀 (I found that yesterday and my jaw fucking dropped)

[@ghostlyolive]

NO. PLEASE NO NO PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE 💀💀💀💀💀🤚🤚🤚🤚

[@lanahudson5388]

you're not acquainted with every fandom's no. 1 rule. If two characters exist, asume at least someone ships them.

[@Weird_Teenager-i7o]

I love how you described Baron Kelvin. and also………..WHY IS Alois x Elizabeth EVEN A THING Here is my reason on why THIS SHIP CANNOT BE A THING. in my opinion Elizabeth is way too pure for Alois way too kind for Alois and also she loves Ciel and I’m pretty sure Alois is Gay Enough said. 🙂

[@Mailed-Knight]

I thought Alois was just a massive troll.

[@Weird_Teenager-i7o]

@@Mailed-Knight in my opinion I think he was just a mental ill little Brat

[@mqillai]

3:48 definitely my reaction to the new season

[@lanahudson5388]

strange enough, I've heard very few people refer to Black Butler as "Kuroshitsuji" in western fandoms. Even in other languages it's translated as Black Butler.

[@shadowandlight237]

NOT THE MANGA REFERENCE AGAIN OF R U DIRIUS 😂😂😂

[@ghostlyolive]

LMFAO I HAD TO

[@Zekrel]

I recommended all of the first four but let me try to explain myself for suggesting Cielois. I promise that I did not decide to ship them. I still to this day do not ship them. The most of dream of is for them to be friends. That being said however… one day I randomly decided to search up Alois Trancy and accidentally stumbled upon a ton of fanfiction revolving around him and Ciel. At first I was like “oh I bet I know where this will go” and decided to one named I Love You, I Hate You… and that’s how I fell into that rabbit hole. I do agree with your reasoning and I respect your decision.

[@ghostlyolive]

OH IM SORRY I WASNT MEANING TO PUT YOU IN THAT LIGHT IF U THINK THAT 😭 I WAS JUST SHOWING WHO RECOMMENDED IT

[@Zekrel]

@@ghostlyolive no no no, it’s okay. I know you didn’t mean anything bad by it. I just wanted to give my reasons

[@Zekrel]

@@ghostlyolive also, I thought you did an excellent job listing your reasons why each ship works or does NOT work. Most shipping ranking videos I see are of people just ranking the ones they think are cute (even the more questionable ones 😐) so your analytical take on them was a nice change of pace. Well done 👏 👏 👏 P.S. - I would totally be down to watch a part 2 sometime in the future! 😍

[@ghostlyolive]

@@Zekrel THANK U COMMENTS LIKE THESE MEAN EVERYTHING TO ME 😩😩🫶🫶

[@Zekrel]

@@ghostlyolive No problem 😉

[@HelLen555.BittterRabbit]

I ship Grell x William but as a secondary pairing, o.o I don't see much potential in this pairing, but I know it's semi-canonical on Grell's part. Part 2 please!! (>o

[@ghostlyolive]

i understand why some people could ship it, but it doesnt seem like william feels the same way honestly 🤔

[@HelLen555.BittterRabbit]

I think the same (U_U) -Hel.

[@mikeywaythemikeywave211]

WARNING! EXTREMELY LONG ESSAY OF A COMMENT- but I watched this 6 minute video, so it’s only fair if you read my long comment /hj (you don’t have to lmao) Okay so now my counter to the things you said (for lighthearted, friendly, banter) Cielois: Yes they were introduced as enemies, but enemies to lovers exists (and I am a total slut for it- not in a creepy way, cuz they are CHILDREN FFS- just like the dynamic in general is amazing and I feel like saying I’m a slut for it is more amusing than just “oh yeah I like enemies to lovers 🤓” Plus I feel like if they sat down and talked for once instead of hating each other’s guts, I feel like they’d realize how much they have in common- their backstories are so similar and I feel like that ✨t r a u m a b o n d✨would be stronger than gravity itself. 💀 I kinda ship it- not full on UPS shipping, maybe FedEx. It might get there, it might not. (I hope that made sense 🤣) It’s definitely better than SOME SHIPS [coughs in Claude/Alois 💀] Sebagrell: … Look here- I’m way too obsessed with this ship. I know canonically there’s a very low chance it would work out, but- I just want my girl to be happy. 😭 I’m clinging to that one scene where they were on the boat and Grell leans her head on Sebastian’s shoulder and he does nothing about it. 🥲 I’m aware he literally tried to kill her when they met, but I feel like they’ve grown toward eachother. Just… let me have this okay? Grelliam: As much as I want to say Sebagrell is more canon, (I ship both but I’m partial to the other one 😅) that’s not true. Grell definitely loves William. Yana has even said that William is Grell’s one true love or something along those lines. Many people thing William doesn’t like her back, but my take? He definitely might- The Story of Will the Reaper definitely made me think about this ship. There’s so many little things that give off rivals to lovers- and while Will and Grell do fight, it isn’t as serious as when she fought Sebastian. They don’t seriously hurt each other. In fact, we rarely see Will hurt Grell. A couple of times he bonks her with his death scythe, but even people who love each other do stuff like that. He never really hurts her, but notice that pretty much every time someone almost kills her, he swoops in and is like “oh yeah sorry about that, (s)he’s one of ours- my bad-“ and drags her away. He saves her. And we’ve also seen that Will is very professional and values his personal space. Meanwhile Grell can be all over him and he just acts mildly annoyed. They act a bit like an old married couple. So yeah I ship this one too. 😅 As for Mey-Rin/Ran Mao: I have no counter. This ship is beautiful. However, I would like to add a point about why we should ship it; BRO THE MAKING OF KUROSHITSUJI II BASICALLY CONFIRMED IT- THAT OVA WAS BEAUTIFUL And finally for Sebastian/Claude: … I don’t ship this because Sebastian could do SO MUCH BETTER, but I think the ship deserves a little less hate. It’s not the worst thing ever- it could definitely be worse- so id give it like a 2/10 personally. 🤷‍♀️ (Feel free to leave counters to my counters lmao)

[@ghostlyolive]

im not saying you cant ship it, these are just my opinions on wether they would work out or not. 😅

[@mikeywaythemikeywave211]

@@ghostlyolive yeah I know lol. I’m just a fan of playful banter, and debate :]

[@Mailed-Knight]

Okay to be fair, I thought you were going to make this vid tiermaker style, not serious considerations. Otherwise I would have only suggested Ciel x McMillian and Ciel x Doll. I don't mind your longer videos personally. I'm surprised no one thought to ship Ciel with N. McMillian he seemed like the most obvious non-canon gay-ship choice.

[@ghostlyolive]

AW IM SO SORRY IT WASNT WHAT U EXPECTED 💔 i hope u still liked it 😅😅 also i agree, ciel x mcmillan is honestly underrated and i cant see who would object to it

[@optimist_introvertiert_nam7271]

I don't ship lizzy and ciel at all xD

[@lanahudson5388]

this is my rating: no

[@2og-melanie-K-12-edition2]

ME X UNDERTAKER!!!!

[@YourDadsLeftBallsack]

The obvious the best ships in black butler are Me x Hannah, Me x Grell and Me x Beast.

[@2og-melanie-K-12-edition2]

⚠️Ok I do not ship these⚠️but here! Hannah x Claude Undertaker x Sebastian ⚠️Ciel x grell⚠️ Ciel x mummy sushi roll😂 And then the OBVIOUS ships are Me x undertaker Me x Sebastian Me x Ciel aka smile Me x JOKER NGL HE IS SO H#T LIKE DANM! Me x doll ( pls DONT hate me) SO YEAH the ships up top are disgusting I hate them that’s why I showed them to you✨! For PART 2! YOU HAVE THE BEST CONTENT EVER!!!✨🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@ghostlyolive]

the last two prob wouldnt make it in BUT ILL ADD THE FIRST TWO TO A LIST, ALSO TY 😍😍💞💞