Ravnica Remastered Commander Deck Challenge! | Shuffle Up & Play #40 | Magic: The Gathering Gameplay

[@jacksonstein8866]

One of the things i consistently love about Shuffle Up and Play is that prof will bring together 4 giant nerds (him included) that are such DIFFERENT brands of nerdy and it brings so much to all of these episodes! Nerd unity bbs

[@TolarianCommunityCollege]

This is one of my favorite comments, because it really is what I am aiming for. :)

[@plushtheotter]

the diversity is really amazing to see. there's like, always one person who makes it their goal to be the most attractive person on the episode and they pretty much always succeed

[@Cyberium]

@@TolarianCommunityCollege Doctor and his companions. 😏

[@bryden5243]

​@@plushtheotterand somehow it's always prof

[@DefinitelyNotTroll69]

THAT'S A LAND DAMAGE

[@Stalzer2002]

Immediately killing Prof after he called a guild meeting was Joey's way of saying "This meeting could have been an e-mail."

[@shinykitsunelive]

the only gruul response to a guild summit

[@arridueldes9843]

@@shinykitsunelive Exactly my thought, it was the most in character response possible.

[@VBFilms]

Joey could have waited for Profs turn and see what he does and respond at instant speed and kill prof on the stack in response to anything sketchy. Would've been much safer option to do that instant speed. I see so much sorcery speed stuff being done on Shuffle Up & Play that can and should be done at instant speed.

[@TecnoSmurf]

@@VBFilms It's not competitive magic. It's content and fun. And that was funny. Thus good content.

[@VBFilms]

@@TecnoSmurf Well my opinion is that optimized plays are more fun and entertaining content even if the magic is as casual as can be. Casual tables doesn't mean playing suboptimally, but rather the casual stuff happens while deck building.

[@allielowry6191]

Prof and his 3 chaotic children is such a good dynamic

[@Guevon_Pajaro]

Just a buncha friends having a ball 😂❤❤

[@gemmafire8628]

This was my favorite episode I’ve watched so far!

[@brandoncreek5709]

It's literally the magic school bus

[@ericlee1113]

Production team is showing their fun side and I freaking love it.

[@arkb0t379]

Joey: "I'm playing a bit of a different deck than my usual Golgari fare!" Joey: Life from the Loam

[@lucas3463]

How could you say no to 3 Lightning Bolts for 2 Mana?

[@comlitbeta7532]

It's a good thing sensible people at wotc were able to explain to the higher-ups that the professor post critical content because he loves the game and will support it. It gave use great content

[@davidshiroky2932]

12:08 “Coke Dragon” is absolutely a Rakdos card

[@TheGrifcannon22]

I'm pretty sure more than one person had that as a nickname in college.

[@ElPayasoMalo]

Great, we get the fantasy knockoff Cocaine Dragon.

[@_underscore_9271]

@TheGrifcannon22 I went to school with someone who's legal name was "dragon coke" (long ã, but still)

[@tdip16]

OK, I'm SO grateful Joey sung 'This is the rhythm of the wild' like that cause I've done it for so long and needed someone to confirm I wasn't a complete nutcase, thinking it every time I saw the card.

[@Shydoshi17]

Fun fact: If you don't sing the Rhythm of the Wild as you cast it, it doesn't resolve.

[@PirateMaster45]

Now I need to sing it that way whenever I play that card!

[@mr.mammuthusafricanavus8299]

LOL Your not the only one :P

[@origaminosferatu3357]

Our pod have specific songs for a whole host of cards. Yes we've been playing too long.

[@xujpg]

me too!!!

[@CAPTAINCHAOS_]

As a Red player, seeing a game with all 4 guilds with red in them is very very satisfying.

[@LostLandsLife]

That Baja Blast joke was incredible

[@Amazonian]

shout out to Logan (SeraphSix) for drinking baja blast and posting pics of it for us to enjoy online

[@lethe8313]

As was the roo bee no roo bee no joke

[@starchaser6024]

25:15 Critiquing people’s decks for being “off Flavor” is now going to be my favourite way to troll the table 😇

[@huckthatdish]

Always remember to call a flavor judge when an opponent commits a flavor violation

[@sundalius]

following it with being a jace truther was the cherry on top

[@Crypt4l]

Isn't there a ancient friday night magic with a infinite discussion, that Ulamog doesn't belong into a vampires deck?

[@sarahbuck2506]

Petition to make Flavor Judge a legal card

[@troytaylor8225]

I don’t get it. All my cards taste like cardboard?

[@chefpaddie3771]

Two things, 1: Evan's outfit was slick and very Rakdos. 2: This was one of the most hilarious groups so far. Great episode.

[@MortonFMurphy]

Prof is not at all like my father despite his undeniable Dad energy, but he reminded me of my old man several times in this particular video. My Dad passed last year and frankly disliked MtG but came around eventually. I'm playing again for the first time in years and it makes me feel like a kid again. Love you dudes.

[@koenvandepoll927]

This has been one of my favorite episodes so far! Big compliments to the editor! All the little bits extra information and jokes were amazing. I cannot imagine how fun it must have been to think up all the fake usernames for the "comment section". Also props to all the players! And to Wizards for using this form of advertisement for the upcoming remastered set. Would not mind seeing that more often in the future.

[@Teedo_]

Ph4ntasmal.jpg really got me

[@pennsimmons]

This episode has a special energy

[@vipergtsrgt1]

Special is putting it lightly.

[@pBlackcoat]

Prof didn't know he was going to gay brunch

[@christopherfu2169]

@@pBlackcoat So it was rainbow energy.

[@Viperiish]

So, this group is gonna be a regular occurrence, right? Absolutely DED from laughing this whole episode!!! Would love to play at that table!

[@Amazonian]

Bloodlust, birdlust, and lots, and lots of soda pop.

[@JaySay]

Can't forget the masochism!

[@peterbrown7690]

I am loving the energy of this table. A mix of chaos and silliness My kinda people

[@rafaelvotu]

The chaos comes from the fact every single one of them is playing red.

[@joeberger5641]

This episode was so entertaining simply because I have never seen 3 guests get along so well

[@kylecooper7696]

The [Insert Soda] Dragon jokes, and the smattering of other soda jokes throughout the video hit every time. A fun table in general, and was laughing the whole way! Also just a fun and interesting game. Thanks for the video!

[@hugmonger]

I just got to say, Dark Pact's outfit is so damn good for Rakdos. Like the outfit, the laugh, and the mad chaotic energy of this episode... I dont know who actually survives this match, but the Rakdos Guild won this match up front.

[@Shydoshi17]

Massive style points for sure, their fit is fantastic! I do wish that Joey and Amy had dressed to match their guilds like Prof and Dark Pact.

[@hugmonger]

@@Shydoshi17 I mean t shirt and jeans fits Gruul imo

[@pascalsimioli6777]

No it does not, lol. Gruul is much more leather jacket, tank tops and ripped jeans at the very least

[@edwardking9359]

​@@pascalsimioli6777 Good luck enforcing a dress code on the gruul anarchs, lol

[@JohnSmith-en8xf]

“The 3 gayest human and prof play unhinged mtg”

[@ElDocBruh]

So I expected chaos gremlin energy from Amy, but I didn't expect it from every single guest!

[@starmanda88]

If Amy is invited I click every time. She is far and away my favorite MTG creator. Just boundless positivity and good vibes. Everyone was great during this episode though!

[@ShabbahCore]

I don't know but to me it seemed more like the opposite...: she wasn't fat and she was right there!

[@starmanda88]

@@ShabbahCorebad dum tish lmao you got me I was typing too fast for my own good!

[@ShabbahCore]

@@starmanda88 haha I get that a lot too. I saw it and it was just a dunny one! Funny*

[@7Stormwalker]

31:07 the timing on the 7-up was perfect

[@IanWeaver]

Dear god I love Dark Pact Cosplay. Not sure why but their reactions and humor are absolutely perfect and I love them so much.

[@HydeTheSturdy]

The red contact lenses really added to the "I WANNA DRAW" when Dark Pact played necropotence

[@hatchtheroostar6032]

Izzet player: calls for a guild meeting Gruul player: "NO. DIE." *throws a fistful of boulders* If that aint flavor, I dont know what is.

[@hodlsage8968]

I am 10 minutes in and had to pause the video at least 3 times to legit laugh out loud... I am not sure I can continue. The vibe is off the charts... It is like 4 people from different parts of town just found out they are now best friends !!!

[@KnicKnac]

The energy of this video was so wild. Gotta love it

[@Etruth14]

Can we just appreciate that Prof and DP wore outfits that match their color schemes for decks ❤ Very nice 😎

[@theswagonborn4164]

Absolutely love the energy this game and seeing everyone riding the same wave! Exactly what I needed after today!

[@santuli_91]

Joey's arms will never fail to hypnotize me...

[@arridueldes9843]

Ok between the Soda Dragon jokes, the sheer on flavor of some of the players antics, and the Gruulgari deck... this episode was amazing, such delightful chaotic, slightly thirsty energy

[@christianhatke477]

This group was so unexpectedly amazing. It was like Prof was an overwhelmed babysitter just trying to make it through the game with his sanity intact.

[@danielhenderson4795]

Realizing that these 4 personalities are all playing the Red guilds makes this much greater than I could have dreamed. Not even 10 minutes in! lol

[@drakegrandx5914]

At the "Insert transition here", an ad started... Nice to see KZbin lend out a hand once in a while!

[@Thaelkor]

Shoutout to the editors for having a great sense of humor.

[@mitchellbruderlin8621]

The energy at that table is insane!!!! I love all of you guys keep up the amazing work :)

[@hylian9098]

Thinking about getting back into MTG so I've recently started watching all these and loving every minute of them. This has been my favorite so far. This would be what i would show someone who was thinking about getting into MTG to have them play. Absolutely hilarious and so much fun to watch.

[@Agaures]

I'm less than 20 minutes in, and I love everyone in this episode. You all are an absolute Riot.

[@riverroth3688]

This is still, consistently my favorite actual play show for mtg on the youtubes. Your guests are always the best prof, and youre always consistently entertaining.

[@Punintentionally]

Angels are Bird Women was said with so much conviction and I love her. 😂😂

[@LOVES-A1911]

I just recently discovered this channel while considering getting back into Magic with the commander format after a four year break, it's a joy to see commander being played in such a fun and friendly way. Since I haven't bought any cards in the last four years I'll be doing a lot of RTFC, I hope that the opponents I face will understand.

[@treyx0]

I have never participated or played MTG at all, but I very much enjoy just seeing people have fun on this show!

[@briannasappho1545]

One of my favourite episodes of Shuffle Up & Play! A joy to watch

[@SeekerEddo]

There's so much chaos in one room and it's spectacular to behold

[@LordDrieg]

Props to the editor at 14:02. I laughed to tears! That was brilliant! 😂

[@watchdominion00]

The chemistry and the banter was top notch! Great ep!

[@TheKamikaze667]

One of my fav episodes! The energy, the vibe - everything works! Please do another episode with the same squad!

[@TheSaiyanSith]

Watching shuffle up and play has introduced me to so many MTG personalities i didnt know i needed in my life.

[@wordsonpaper3869]

Just in case you didn’t die to Joey’s lands he brought the guns 💪 for backup. Love the content prof, always have the best guests on with you.

[@SteakOSaurier]

14:21 that Joey SMIRK when Prof says it like "drawer" is such a throwback to earlier episodes of shuffle up and play and i'm all here for it!

[@pierre-loup]

Can we just take a second to appreciate Evan's glorious Rakdos make up? Love it!

[@dr00ness]

such a fun group of guests this week! and if you look really closely, you can see they're actually playing a game of magic: the gathering

[@TheBoss-vg2hw]

I can't wait to see this video! However, I wanted to suggest something for you guys to try ^^ with all the different versions of certain cards(Nilissa, Omnath, etc), what if you guys did a round of commander with only using different versions of one commander? For example, one person could have Omnath, Locus of all, another having Omnath, Locus of Creation, Omnath, Locus of Rag, Omnath Locus of Roil. Then everyone has to make a deck focused around those characters but they can't have any of those other commanders within their deck. This idea may have a few holes in it- but I wanted to suggest it still! Have a great evening and keep up the amazing work!

[@jackgebhardt2932]

The Omnath one sounds really funny.

[@eventuelleon748]

but do you have a 95 card deck or just a normal 99 with 5 Commanders? I like this idea

[@TheBoss-vg2hw]

I was thinking about how it can work, there’s a few ways you could do it. Each person could have each versions of those commanders then lower the amount of cards in their deck by how many commanders they have, I’d say they need at least 2-3 versions of that commander just so no one just puts a single version of the creature in. You can also do the same thing where each player still has 99 cards and that amount of commanders. You can also do it where each person has one version of that creature, like I said before, someone can have Omnath, Locus of Rage, another Locus of Roil, another Locus of Creation, another Locus of all. Then no one else in the game can add those creatures to their deck so everyone has their commanders a bit unique but also have slightly similar cards, relying on strategy and deck creation. Lastly, you could do a sortve commander bank. Where you put all of the versions of the commanders in the middle and everyone can use any cards that are in the within the color combination of the commander with the highest amount(example, Omnath, Locus of all would allow everyone to use all colors that he has) then everyone is in a sortve brawl to get the commander version they want, first person to pay for the commander keeps it till it dies then it goes back to the commander bank but costs 2 more to cost. Max amount of commanders that each person can have is 1-2, make it even so everyone can get one commander version. If anyone else has any questions then I can try to explain better if needed

[@TheBoss-vg2hw]

@@eventuelleon748I just sent something that has all the versions I came up with, hope it helps!

[@DarthHao]

One somewhat subtle shot of Amy at 18:15 untapping that land with murderous intent is hilarious and relatable!

[@Ox_ygen]

Hearing someone say bobobo bobo bo bo is their favorite anime Is somthing i have never heard, but im so happy

[@jumbotrash]

The chemistry with this group was great! Eve thing seemed really natural like my matches at home. Great episode Prof and team!

[@dubiousbrick4483]

Love this energy, had to revisit for another watch, this was such a fun episode xD

[@chubibi06]

Joey singing the "Rythme of the wild" may my day ! Gotta listen the song next

[@alexssain]

Joey is my favorite one! Hoping to see him more often

[@holyhandgrenade5]

This is one of my favorite groups so far! Everyone is chaotic in a slightly different direction and it all comes together nicely.

[@Neiros2]

Fun fact: The Hatfield-McCoy feud actually started because someone used a Grasp of Fate on someone else's Rhystic Study.

[@bonekill476]

Love the energy tossed around, amazing group!

[@hagashi1]

The editing on this is incredible, shoutouts to production for just having a nice time.

[@seapunkandroid]

I thought episodes with Arin were something else, but this crew has a truly special energy. Props to the editors for punching up the chaos! ...also I just realized that everyone dressed in both colors of their deck, except for Joey. It's okay, Joey, we still love you! *mimes holding a phone to his ear and mouths "call me"*

[@Awesomesausages]

Very surprised the one-Mana cycling lands are not included in the Borborygmos deck. They make Loaming lands a lot faster, since you'll be rolling in Lands in play anyways :) Gamble, a.k.a. Red Entomb, also quite strong as just a second copy of Loam. Loved seeing Tummyrumbles taking it home, doubly so after a wonderfully chaotic and fun episode. (big, big Assault Loam enjoyer so I had to check out the list for inspiration :P Sprouting Vines and Nissa's Pilgrimage are sweet)

[@MrBagelz]

IMO This is the best Shuffle up and Play episode that has been made. Hilarious, Everyone having fun, interesting gameplay, and wonderful guests and banter.

[@davidrosenberg9615]

This is an excellent table, I specifically love any content with Joey and Amy.

[@danpowell2018]

I. LOVE. THIS. POD !!! 10min in and it is already my favorite episode!

[@robbee8481]

I loved the dynamic between the group, great episode!

[@jakelarntz]

Also I can't say how much I adore the amount of laughing, and fun had at this table.

[@stelliocantos4639]

I know I say this on every episode I can recall, but I love all these people! Excellent guests as always with great energy and a great game. The jokes had me cackling. Love Ravnica a lot and very much looking forward to Ravnica Remastered. Thanks for playing.

[@kristopherwatts9466]

Prof has always been the cool cishet uncle that the queer kids always wanted to hang with. This video is the only evidence I need

[@nosrin1988]

That voice sends shivers down my spine. It's sooo good.

[@khazandcrit3066]

The land flinging animation was very satisfying to watch :D Great game, great fun!

[@mitdemall]

Man Rvnica was the the plain that introduced me to magic, hyped for the video :)

[@KBystedt10]

Best one yet. Rolling. Love this energy.

[@TidBitOf]

The table energy in this episode is great! I was laughing the entire time!

[@Guevon_Pajaro]

A true banger, one of the best SUAP eps of all time!

[@jaggedtoothgrin]

the energy in this pod is Immaculate

[@michaelsinnreich6626]

The energy and laughter at the table was more infectious than a golgari deck. Great to see people having such a good time. Psyched for rakdos er ravnica remastered.

[@MojAbidi]

This episode has a special energy and i loved every second

[@SomeOfTheJuice]

So to answer Amy's question: Dredge _started_ as an 8 on the storm scale. It then moved to 10 for quite a while, and is now 9 for some reason, as it should absolutely still be a 10.

[@joshualoiacono5488]

Fantastic guests, fantastic episode!

[@elmejordelagalaxia]

This has to be one of the funniest SU&P in a while! ❤❤❤

[@Shadow298]

One funniest episodes so far, such a joy to watch - as were all of the guests and how they kept feeding each other cheesy jokes & gags. Fantastic stuff.

[@dukelornek]

Love the interactions on this show you put together some amazing people!

[@MegaStevo1993]

this is the best episode ive seen so far

[@TecnoSmurf]

Waifu Birdie? :D Joey loving everyone doing dad jokes. I love the energy here. ^^

[@nunyabusiness-thankyou]

loved this ep!! everybody bounced off each other so well it was a joy to see!

[@TomAcrossAmerica]

Joey mentioned a format I've only dreamed of, chronological commander. I pictured the 4-5 diff mishras and 4-5 different urzas in the command zone in a stack, starting from their earliest depictions to their later forms, and they have a legendary rule applied of "only 1 of each legendary creature with a super name" so only 1 urza, 1 mishra on the field at a time. And as you cast them it reveals their next form which you can cast and it sacs the previous form. Get to see the brothers start as weak chumps until they hit their "ultimate form"

[@tatsuyakaiyo416]

Joey is giving me big "I've got a jar of dirt" vibes

[@RobThePrincess]

Amy is killing me, this episode. Love her! Haha

[@royceflores23]

Yeah, I see Amy in episodes and they end up being x2 watches for me. She is worth the extra time investment.

[@anrikurisuto4432]

I'm really looking forward to this one, 3 guests from some of my favorite episodes! My all time favorite is the one with Joey and Tomer (still disappointed that the soundeffects have not been updated for all episodes to Tomer noises), closely followed by the one with 'I'm not talking like a dinosaur, right?!' 'No, dad...' with DPC, Spice and Crim, as well as Amy and her stealing spree. I also liked the crabs episode, though. I rewatch those episodes almost weekly, sometimes even daily.

[@Devlerbat]

Proc: Okay, Guild meeting everyone Anarchist Gruul: Screw that! Eat Tree!

[@hackbug77]

This is one of the best episodes yet.

[@SirDanyTheWarrior]

Man, this episode was hella fun, I had a smile on my face the whole time... Thanks for always pumping great content like this!!!

[@anderslundtoft2315]

The best episode of this channel ever!! Love Mizz and his arrogance