Reactions to Modernity: Revolutions, Reforms, and Repression | Syed Sardar Ali

[@HasnainUK2009]

A gem scholar of history. He has very lucidly presented broad developments around the world. I wish all this could have been compiled in a book preferably in English for a wider audience in the Muslim world

[@amandeep9930]

Syed Sardar Ali is one of the best historians. His lecture about the reality of colonial rule really opened my eyes. I used to believe that we are poor because of colonialism. Really impressive personality. It really shook me to the core. I've watches all of his lectures. Respect from India.

[@amandeep9930]

1:28:05 being from India, I would like to answer the question. Why did India progress inspite of the dominant ideology being Hindutva? Modi was not elected to the government on basis of Hindutva. He was elected due to the Gujrat Model and his pro-industrial stance. BJP has done tremendous work in making India better for business. BJP has also done excellent work in infrastructure development. The Hindutva narrative was not popular before BJP came into power. Also, many outsiders fail to understand the psyche of a common Hindu. Most young Hindus do not believe in the idea of a God very rigidly. They like to follow Hinduism as a culture (or a way of life). Some identity as Hindu in the sense of ethnicity and not in the sense of metaphysical beliefs. Most Hindus are sceptical about their belief system but they will get offended if someone from outside will criticize Hinduism. So there is a sense of togetherness in Hinduism without a centralised belief system.

[@sheryazdan8520]

Sardar Ali sb k 13 lecturers ki alag playlist bna kr share ki Jay. Yahan smjh ni a re ha pehly konsa lecture hua ha bd ma konsa. Great Work ❤

[@GP-wk2vh]

Dear sir Sardar Ali, a 🙏big thank you for the knowledge you have imparted and enlightening us on the past history. Request you to publish similar topic videos even after you complete your 13 lectures. I am from Hyderabad India. Thank you once again, you are too good in explaining precisely in such a short lecture about history. Hope you visit India 🙏

[@mubashirmurtaza2166]

Dr. Syed you have been great in all of your lectures. Thanks❤️

[@MrSufiSeeker]

I applaud Mr. Sardar Ali for his brilliant analysis of this situation. However, he confounded culture with civilization. There is only one civilization, the Western Civilization. Modernization is very vague term. Soviet Union called their system modern and scientific communism. Only when Soviet Union and China adopted the Western civilization, could they become successful. If the word, 'West" is left out, Muslim world will never catch up. Muslims need to be pro-West and that is the way they will change their mindset toward modernization. There is no other way. As a Bangladeshi, I will say that is the way Pakistanis can improve like they did during Westernized President Ayub Khan 's the 1960s era with British trained civil servants and other technocrats.

[@AJC1988]

Thanks 😇

[@shabbirahmeddar7765]

بہت ہی اعلی اور معلوماتی لیکچر ہے۔

[@mohsinafzaal7159]

Excellent lecture and discussion! Pakistan has a long way to go and that is only if we are serious about the future and start taking steps now! First do not interfere in the neighboring countries and establish peace with all of them! Focus internally and clean the country of these jihadi groups and make religion a personal matter! Reduce defense budget by at least by 20% and spend that money on quality and modern education, the education that can produce kids with critical thinking tolerance and respect for all and it will take at least 30 years if we start now! Time is running out for Pakistan do it now! Forget “Madinay ki Rayasaat” and look to the future modern tolerant peaceful Pakistan will justice for all…….😊

[@RWOOFKASHMIRI]

Can we arrange his lectures in a numerical pattern so we can follow the thought process.

[@majidbaig2913]

These are the thoughts

[@Ila_iri]

Stop saying Baresagiir Pak o Hind, there is no Pakistan before 1947. u must call Sub Continent as Indian Baresagiir. Indian civilization is more than 5000 year old and don't forget roots.

[@asad-kc8zf]

The name Hind was given to this region by the Persians. No one is doubting the 5000 years or so history but what was it called ?

[@cheetah2100]

@@asad-kc8zf Bharat Even in our texts which were written 5000 yrs ago This region is mentioned as Bharat

[@Ila_iri]

@@asad-kc8zf India arabs are not able to call as India name came from Indus river and our vedas also refer name Hind (land between himalyas and indi ocean) is called as Hind its Indian baresagiir, not Pak -o-Hind baresagir. because there is no Pakistan before 1947

[@praveenmalviya3604]

​@@Ila_iri we sometimes call pakistan as napakistan doesnt mean pakistan doesnt exist today.. It doesnt matter from where india name came. India used to be called as bharat jammudweep etc since thousands of years

[@angeshbhusan5520]

In India upper caste is not in power now . OBC and DALIT are now in power

[@truptib2174]

Most of the so called upperclass have migrated to USA, UK, EUROPE , Canada , Middle East etc.

[@hawkingdawking4572]

What a big fat lie.

[@TechWithNavodit]

Provide me the details to buy Pakistan economy 😂😂

[@Arubonal]

Lol 😂😂😂😂🤣,

[@vju7709]

Pakistani 40-50 sal purani ghadi use karte hain kya 😂😂wahi sui ruki hui hai