Classical & Jazz Musicians React: (G)I-DLE 'Put it Straight' vs 'Put it Straight (Nightmare Ver.)'

[@ReacttotheK]

➡️ CJ&MR Reaction Release Schedule + list of all our Patreon-exclusive videos: docs.google.com/document/d/1uvf-u1EJVB-hmB3IU0P6M-obdMNu11fo_aUIf6dur70/edit?usp=sharing ➡️ Songs that are currently being voted on or waiting to be voted on by our musician voting panel for C&JMR: kzbin.info/aero/PLFw_XZtkCVMMt3F3O3jvbeYlUyGo8v2nX ➡️ Will not react to list for the CJ&MR series & why songs may not be reacted to: docs.google.com/document/d/1b5aQLWbYgUCm30Pj5-AalSjwMaq8gm5jOyrcbAlMu6c/edit?usp=sharing 41 Since Community Contributions are down, if you’d like to add a translation, please email the subs as an .srt file to [e-mail]. Many thanks! Our team is currently working on Korean subtitles, they will be up soon :)

[@jeffersoncaingcoy8242]

Hi i hope you react to dreamcatcher's boca (k-zombie ver)

[@jomarpastor1391]

I hope you to react to twice lastest comeback "I Can't Stop Me"

[@jomarpastor1391]

I hope you also to react to blackpink lastest 1st album songs

[@JhonRS266]

album de twice es un estilo muy clasico les recomiendo "say something"(city pop) y "queen" tienen muy buenos saxofon al final les va gustar

[@danielluidalindin1985]

React to TWICE eyes wide open album hehe And also BLACKPINK The Album hehe

[@pyc912]

I just wanna say: The way they wiped off their lipsticks in the queendom performance still lingers in my brain.

[@mchurch1292]

best performance of the series!

[@kimjangseason455]

It's stuck in my brain ever since I saw it.

[@dasiamay2324]

soojin BODIED that part

[@deng1xia]

@@dasiamay2324 yesss

[@sweetmimosamommysaranghae3163]

Every time I think of put it straight it’s always ‘SOOJIN WIPING RED LIPSTICK OFF HER LIPS’

[@alice5753]

Too bad they didnt watch the performance.. I feel like the arranged version with the performance it's the full experience! But I think this way is better to focus on the song itself! Put it straight it's my favorite gidle song! Love your reactions ❤

[@ReacttotheK]

Reactions to MNET live performances get striked and taken down :(

[@cptkoby]

@@ReacttotheK :(

[@candyyy6690]

@@ReacttotheK too bad :(

[@CJKpoprox]

i feel like its a different feeling watching this version as compared to the performance version. this doesn't fully capture the "nightmare" feel that the performance tried to showcase, mainly because imo the different costumes were a little distracting :/

[@retrograderiding3486]

On the upside, I find the sound mixing to be much better in the dance practice version.

[@yangnuying167]

This song is honestly so unique. I mean, most g-idle songs are, they use very unconventional instruments and sounds but somehow always make it work.

[@spritzy9188]

Soyeon is a genius and GIDLE are incredible performers! While I still prefer the lonely, melancholy feel of the original, I do love how the Nightmare version stands on its own and gives a more unhinged feeling. Also I get why you decided not to react to the Queendom version (because of Mnet) but I hope the reactors watch the Queendom performance on their own because it's one of the best performances I've seen in a long time. The emotion and commitment GIDLE put into it was amazing!

[@reishiki_eito]

she is definitely amazing. i couldn't wait for her solo music after gidle in the future. for this song, i was introduced with the nightmare version first. so when i listened to the original, i could only hear the nightmare version. cant hear them apart xD

[@누리-i2u]

진짜 싫다괄해 처음 들었을 때 와 이건 진짜 소름돋는 천재성이라고 생각했음..... 진짜 소름.... 음악전공중인데 소연이가 음악적 센스가 너무 좋음 ㅠ 진짜 작곡하는데 불협이랑 분위기 고조시키는거 실력 보면 진짜 대단하다. 그걸 원하는 방향대로 진행해주는 멤버들도 대단하고... 진짜 심장을 쫠깃하게 해주는 노래들 앞으로도 많이 내주길!!! G Idle Fighting~

[@KR_ISTP]

음알못이라 마냥 듣기 좋아서 어디가 불협화음인지..ㅠ 혹시 집어주실 수 있나요? 너무 궁금한데 뭔지 감이 1도 안 와요. ㅠㅠ

[@_ouo4308]

@@KR_ISTP 13:49 이쯤에 반주음이 반음정도 내려가서 불협화음이 생겨요 아마 이거 말씀 하신거같아요!

[@KR_ISTP]

@@_ouo4308 알려주셔서 감사합니다. 알고 봐도 뭔지 모르겠네요. ㅋㅋㅋ

[@꾸루꾸룻]

@@KR_ISTP 18:45 여기부터 설명해주시는데 음이 변화는 과정 보시구 위에 구간보시면 조금 느껴지실수도 있으실거 같아요!

[@robertchou7949]

"That's so different, but it was the saaaaaame" 😂😂😂

[@shinyunastrophywife8896]

me trying to complete that venn diagram the teacher gave that made absolutely no sense

[@sososhi4177]

@@shinyunastrophywife8896 I got nothing to say, other than I really like ur name lmao 😭😭😂😂😂

[@scarlett9750]

@@shinyunastrophywife8896 lmaooo ur profile

[@sjonmac6012]

This reaction reminds us that Soyeon did a lot of stuff during the Queendom production: she finished Lion, rearranged Latata and (this song) Say No, plus planned all of (G)I-dle's performances including the set design, costume and choreography. I know she gets a bunch of help but a lot of i-dle's creative output does start with her, as was actually shown in Queendom. Too bad ReacttotheK couldn't react to the Queendom performance because that was the better version. And it was done live!

[@ranaammar6729]

Also a staff who worked on queendom said that cube told soyeon to make like 3 songs not only lion

[@Ravyyy1001]

@@ranaammar6729 but they didn't get to be the first :( and i realized that on the first perf there are a lot of neverlands but in the next it's like mnet reduced the seat or place for neverlands

[@ruthmaduka6631]

I don’t stan G-Idle, but I have a shit ton of respect for Soyeon.

[@sjonmac6012]

@@ruthmaduka6631 Girl is a workhorse and really talented. And she actually thrives on competition. If she gets to collaborate a third time with an SM artist, Lee Sooman should just adopt her already.

[@ruthmaduka6631]

@@sjonmac6012 I agree with you, she is soooo talented. And you’d think people will appreciate her more, but no they don’t

[@ele1370]

This might be one of my favorite reactions on this channel. You can tell how into and moved by the song they were. I love both versions, they each express a different form of heartbreak for me. The original seems more isolated, full of self-loathing, and like they’ve given up. The nightmare version feels obviously creepy but also possessive, like they’re in denial to the extent they’ll take drastic measures to ensure they’re always with their beloved.

[@blackfrost4414]

New reactor though, what's the skeleton guy's name? He cute.

[@sprotector3235]

It's jason.

[@blackfrost4414]

@@sprotector3235 wow, he have the same name as Jason, the guy with Juyoung.

[@jazzymartzz0825]

i was asking the same hahafahahah

[@MrLoipurz]

14:19 thank me later

[@scarlett9750]

Yall simp lmao

[@zdatze]

I found the nightmare version today and was mezmerized by it. But compared with the original song I'm even more fascinated how they rearranged it. Thank you for this experience! Keep up the awesome work, love your videos.

[@ENGRtube]

Watch the show Queendom! Soyeon completely rearranged and recomposed the song for their live performance and it shows a lot of behind the scenes stuff! You also get the Latata remix, Lion debut performance, 2NE1 Fire cover, Soyeon's record breaking rap, Minnie's duet with AOA main vocal and Soojin's insanely sexy dance solo performance!

[@hyagoalencar7677]

This rearrangement is amazing! Soyeon it's incredible talented and she and (G)I-DLE should have more appreciation!!!!!!!!! I'm glad the reactors really liked the 2 versions and all the differences.

[@dianan4921]

I agree I feel like they should get a lot more appreciation what they do is so amazing !

[@janasheenjumana]

15:45 "That's so Different....But it was the Sameeeeee" + the editing of the laughter. My favourite part of this video

[@luprsil]

The skeleton bopping to the music and at the end complaining that he wasn't included in the dance practice 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 This and the ENTIRE editing was amazing, CMR just get better I swear!!! Thank you ❣️❣️❣️

[@neysaaulia6130]

Umu wheezing and the skeleton omg 😂😂😂😂 The nightmare ver is definitely one of my favourite song from last year thank you for reacting!!

[@neysaaulia6130]

ALSO CAN'T WAIT FOR BOCAAAAAAAAAAA MY GIIIIIIIIRRRLLLLSSSS

[@newjunies]

maybe i'm biased because i've been in a similar situation as to what the song is about but ughhh this is one of their best songs, genuinely. i wish more people knew about it, it's stunning and you can feel so many emotions.

[@robobo9071]

Soyeon. Composer. Of. The. Year. ASAP

[@nora5848]

mama rigged

[@kylaholder3561]

Period

[@Angel-xg7vy]

@@nora5848 purr 🤕

[@김민수-t4b4b]

COTY lol

[@kimjangseason455]

PERIOD

[@lenatheworld]

yeah this is THAT song. I first heard the nightmare version first, on Queendom. That performance was a legendary one. Their emotion in their voices, their facial expressions. This song got me into them, and here i am now, a part of nevie since 2019.

[@dianan4921]

So cool to see an Orbits who’s a Nevie !

[@hemalimbu133]

An orbit appreciating gidle's talent and music it's very very rare to see

[@lenatheworld]

@@hemalimbu133 i mean who can resist the amount of talent they have? and i am a multi so :) it's really great to see a lot of artists express their everything into music, idle is one of them who succeeded on doing that. i hope they can continue what they're doing forever, expecting a lot from what's coming next!

[@ENGRtube]

Soyeon is a genius. Saying other wise makes you look stupid at this point, shes a once a generation talent and will go far from the confines of kpop. She's a God Tier rapper and one of the most talented upcoming producers in the industry. So much respect for her!

[@dtxhrvse1657]

"Soyeon is a genius. Saying other wise makes you look stupid at this point" sir/mam, there's thousands of languages in this world and u chose to speak facts 👑

[@dreamcatcherton]

I think with the nightmare version it feels like the heartbreak has driven them crazy while in the original it was more like sitting alone in a room with the lights off

[@cir3939]

항상 한국어 자막을 꼭 달아줘서 고마워요.. 한국어 자막을 기입하기 위해서 수고하는 분들 고맙습니다.

[@Dana-nk8fl]

퀸덤 무대 보여줬으면 더 좋았을걸... 볼거리는 팬영상이 더 많을지 몰라도 표정연기나 아티스트의 몰입도가 압권인디 ㅠㅠㅠ

[@NINAnYUNA]

퀸덤무대는 방송클립이라 더 허락받기 어려웠을거 같아요 ㅋㅋㅋ

[@Pookiewhore]

Mnet basically copyrights their stages sooooo the video could've been blocked

[@angmamatcookie]

아이들은 진짜 내가 자라면서 봐온 걸그룹 아이돌 중에 멤버 개개인이 음악성이 가장 뛰어남. 노래 다 기본 이상은 함. 오히려 타 그룹 메인보컬 급인 애들이 서브보컬로 있음. 랩도 소연이뿐만 아니라 우기도 잘함. 춤은 다 기본. 팀에서 지금 공식적으로 3명(소연, 우기, 민니)이 작곡을 해서 결과를 보여줬고 엄청 잘 뽑음 진심. 멤버들 피아노, 바이올린, 고쟁 같은 악기 다룰 줄도 암. 이 영상처럼 무대 위에서는 자기 컨셉에 맞게 몰입해서 연기를 함. 근데 연기를 개잘함... 그런데 이게 데뷔한지 3년이 안된 그룹의 실력이라는거... 외모와 춤으로 승부보는게 아니라 외모 춤은 기본으로 깔고 노래, 음악성으로 보여주는 실력파임. (블랙핑크, 마마무 같은 음악성이 뛰어난 몇몇 걸그룹도 존재함. 하지만 여기서 차이점은 아이들은 타이틀곡은 물론이고 95퍼센트의 앨범 수록곡까지 멤버들이 작곡한 노래들이란 사실. 그래서 아이들은 아이들만의 노래를 할 수 있고 아이들의 독특한 컨셉을 그들만이 소화할 수 있다는 점. 이 점에서 나는 아이들이 음악적으로 가장 뛰어나다고 생각함.) Of all the girl group idols I've seen growing up, (G)I-DLE's each member has the best musicality. They all can sing well beyond the basics. Rather, other group's main vocalist class members are sub-vocalists in (G)I-DLE. Not only Soyeon but Yuqi is good at rapping. I really surprised when I listened Yuqi's rap! Also they can dance. And three members(Soyeon, Yuqi, Minnie) of the team have officially written songs and showed us the results, and they're really good at it. They can play instruments like piano, violin, and Guzheng. They are immersed in his concept and acted on the stage like this video. And their acting is really nice. However, this is the talent of a group that debuted less than three years ago... Not by appearance and dance, but by music and their ability, they're talented idols. (There are also some girl groups with outstanding musicality, such as BLACKPINK and MAMAMOO. But the difference is that not only the title song but also 95 percent of the songs of (G)I-DLE in the album were composed by IDLE's members. So IDLE can sing their own songs and only they can sing their unique concepts. That's why I think (G)I-DLE is the best musically in this respect.)

[@isaidmoveout7654]

And they also focus on giving an outstanding performance and always sing live rather than focusing on dancing which is pretty great that's why I feel like Im watching a concert everytime they perform

[@hams_cu]

타팬인데 정말 인정합니다. 이렇게 멤버 개개인이 곡에 참여해서 기존 케이팝 노래들과 다른 시도들을 해볼 수 있는 그룹들이 더 성장할 수 있는 것 같아요.

[@user-ly8rm8ev8g]

사실 가수적으로 이야기하자면 그룹전체의 보컬을 세게 밀고 나가줄? 이끌어줄? 메인보컬이 다른 그룹에 비해 힘이 약하고 중심이없다는게 아쉬울뿐인데 리더인 소연이 대신해내는게 보여서 다른 멤버가 보컬적으로 연차쌓이는거랑 같이 열심히 실력 더 쌓아올렸으면..ㅜ

[@KR_ISTP]

@@user-ly8rm8ev8g 정말 그렇게 생각하세요? 상향 평준화라 타 멤버에 비해 보컬 스킬이 특출나게 돋보이지 않는거겠죠. 과거에 메인보컬 하나 나가자마자 모래성처럼 무너지는 그룹도 있었고요. 팀 곡이다 보니 곡 분위기에 맞게 힘빼기는 있을 수 있어도 절대 실력이 떨어지진 않아요. 따로 노래한 것 찾아 보시면 뭔 말인지 이해 하실듯.

[@KR_ISTP]

@@user-ly8rm8ev8g 메보 AOA 얘기 였습니다. 초아 가고 어케 됐죠? 심지어 티아라는 보컬이 없었.. 글구 님 예로 든 걸그룹에 에이핑크, 걸스데이는 인정 합니다. 그런데 애프터스쿨이랑 여자친구는 님이 강조할 정도로 중요한 보컬 멤버가 누군지 잘 모르겠어요.

[@ringelgollum]

When the harmony is scarier than the video, then it's probably this song (in K-pop).

[@nogamenolife1901]

Can anyone explain to me why G-idle is not nominated on any 2020 MAMA categories? Definitely one of the most talented groups, they're like Red Velvet for me, a group that's not afraid to do different kinds of genres (don't mention the groups that do different genres with their B side tracks, I'm talking about the title songs), they don't settle with the basic shits.

[@wifeysubbie7349]

They do not have bigger fandom. I mean MAMA is all about fandom. When you have the strongest fandom, you can easily win at award and thats how mnet gets their fucking money. Not by quality but by quantity. So just ignore. Many quality artist do not win at MAMA, doesn't mean they are not good.

[@ranaammar6729]

They got robbed at least for best performance 😭

[@gukmullie6706]

apparently there’s something going on between cube and mnet. because it doesn’t make sense since (g)i-dle had their most successful year so far. their latest single, dumdi dumdi, still charting on the korean charts and doing good. also they’ve won 4 music shows with oh my god and 6 music shows with dumdi dumdi.

[@wifeysubbie7349]

@@gukmullie6706 it makes me wonder, did queendom and kingdom has affect due to the cube and mnet relationship? I mean look at idle and pentagon, just make into top 3. I hate mnet.

[@gukmullie6706]

@@wifeysubbie7349 maybe, we don’t know for sure, but it kinda makes sense. i mean, idle was literally the only rookie group on the show and let’s be honest, they were the only ones that constantly gave us various spectacular performances. also the fact that they changed up the voting system during kingdom...as far as i remember, when idle participated to queendom no other cube group showed their support towards us, correct me if i’m wrong.

[@Superion74]

While I like Put It Straight a lot, after I watched their Nightmare version on Queendom, I prefer their new unhinged edition over the original. However, both songs are so different that you can see them as two separate songs. Btw, as good as the dance choreography is, their Queendom performance is still unrivaled, and it represents the song better imo.

[@coolandtrending]

The fact that none of the girls ever blink when they are square to the camera in the nightmare version is something your eyes pick up but your mind doesn't tell you is happening. The details (G)I-DLE puts into their videos is fascinating.

[@MaferPan]

It would have been such an experience to watch the performance but mnet sucks. But the way they described how the artists expressed their emotions, that’s also something I realized the first time I heard the song. Their voices bring you the emotions even if you haven’t felt a breakup. (G)I-DLE is truly unique. Soyeon is a genius. Also I Made is an underrated album, all the tracks are so unique and amazing like this, the girls know how to perform and are truly amazing artists

[@ciarannihill]

Thanks for this reaction!! This is one of my favorite songs Soyeon has ever worked on and seeing the reactors appreciate the subtle atmospheric moments made me so happy, haha!

[@jessica1480]

I totally agree with what Jason said at 10:05! Because thats what I always say when paople ask why I am listening to songs where I can't understand the language. You don't need to understand the language if you can understand the song just by listening to the music...

[@sayalizaware8060]

This reaction was so cool....once again I'm in awe with Soyeon's talent.... This girl can do anything

[@dianan4921]

For real I’m still not used to her talent after 2 years...

[@sayalizaware8060]

@@dianan4921 ikr....a very hardworking and talented queen

[@mayonnaiseket1497]

the skeleton reaction was by far the best one in this vid

[@asraffylago3312]

I'm just so happy that you seem to enjoy this amazing song from (G)i-dle.

[@정나은-f4p]

확실히 분석의퀄리티가 다르시네요ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ노래듣고난 내 멜랑꼴리한 기분을 음학적으로 해석해주심

[@jess3824]

i hope they all got to watch the queendom performances after to also enjoy it in another form!! also loved the reaction at 15:00 XD

[@LeachingJack]

The ballad version, to me, conveys the feelings of "why?" Why or how is this happening to me? In response to @9:01, it doesn't feel super sad to me either. It feels like the person in the story was in a state of denial or disbelieve that this event is happening to her and on the border of losing her mind. The nightmare version conveys the same disbelieve emotion except now the person in the story has lost her mind and gone psycho.

[@atothezartothemy5625]

*THAT WAS SO DIFFERENT!.... BUT IT WAS THE SAME..* 😱😱 me: well thats (G)I-DLE for you. They can make 100 version of the same song 😏😌

[@mizanorizam8184]

I actually lost count how many version latata have and I'm a nevie since debut 😂🤣

[@pangkouxiong1244]

Agree!!! XD

[@yasminty7404]

Loved everyone’s reactions! A correction on the song credits: the song was composed (and written) solely by Soyeon, and she worked with Houdini on the arrangement.

[@chenlesmom789]

That long pause on minnie's part really scared me before 😭

[@dianan4921]

Same it’s been a long time I haven’t watched it and I felt the same way I used to before

[@sepguwiki4776]

It's notable to mention that in the Nightmare version, they were wearing red wedding gowns ish dresses and there were props on the stage like broken bottles and other things behind a police tape. The rearrangement changed not only the instrumental and the atmosphere but also the meaning - while the original version was more mellow and sad, the nightmare version was angry and psychotic. It was heavily implied that in the end, they killed their "husband" for trying to leave them hence the police lines.

[@mwohaeyo]

This song is one of their greatest, the more you listen to it the more you feel what they created.

[@iswjyiswjy]

I love every single reaction!! ❤ Put It Straight is one of my favorite IDLE songs and the nightmare version + the Queendom stage made me fucking SHAKE last year, it's just THAT good. Soyeon is a genius.

[@ladylilac1533]

Original put it straight is my favourite (G)I-DLE bside song and when you explain details on it I just love it even more. For me it's pure emotion, I love it's vocal harmonies and less instruments. Thank you for video I enjoyed it a lot!

[@ice8918]

Imagine the different reactions they would've had if they watched the Quuendom Ver. of this song. Though that one has more choreographic elements to it, the percussions used as the dancers contorted their bodies was very nice and chilling.

[@eula-chan238]

i wanna tag Soyeon in this video so baddd so she'll make another arrangement of the song plus incorporating their comments. just thinking about the end product makes me excited 🤩

[@redoyjoarder6330]

This is making me appreciate this song so much more . Thank for the reaction and the musical interpretations. It was beautiful to see how the song and music actually affected the reactors, you can see that they felt it and related to it. Soyeon is just so gifted and amazing . I just hope they keep letting (G)I-DLE EXPERIMENTING LIKE THIS.

[@roomofmirros]

Idk why but I always crack up whenever Kevin walks towards the Piano while starting his statement with "SO BASICALLY..." 🤣🤣 (I appreciate his effort to Express his opinions clearly though ty Kevin !)

[@Yayafid]

thank you for making the video reaction for (G)I-DLE-Nightmare song, this is very interesting, fun and also educational. keep on enthusiasm to always create content like this I'm your loyal fan 👏💐🎶

[@mizanorizam8184]

Soyeon is an absolute talent

[@Catzy96]

Seoyeon is truly indeed a freaking genius... it's a pure fact!

[@kookoo7718]

퀸덤 무대 였다면 조금더 좋았겠다는 생각을 해보았다.... 물론 다 소름이었지만 무대가 이야기적으로 잘 풀어져있어서 더 재밌었을것 같다

[@omegashots59]

I hope somehow or someway even if its offscreen they were able to see the queendom ver. And we can know what they thought about it, since some talked about how the song was emotionally, and the emotional impact of the queendom ver was something else.

[@Lux_YYZ]

9:54 he nailed. Since the first time I heard this song it was an instant favorite because even without understanding what they were singing about I completely knew what they were singing about and it resonated SO hard.

[@yudisnatha]

Okay, both versions are dope as hell. It really amazed me that such beautiful, eerie sound in the first song could be rearranged even more eerie yet still retained the beautiful and sad emotions. Super, super cool. Btw, I had so much new perspective and admiration at some groups in Kpop after hearing their B side songs. They really does put their crown jewel and efforts in B side, some are even more experimental effect, themes or vibes (backward-kind effects in sync with the beats, longer delay in silence). Such a great experience and journey in music, I really like it a lot.

[@camilosandoval6691]

The dolphin at 15:55 when the girl laughed made me laugh SO HARD lmao And then the violins increasing size loool i died

[@noods2253]

THANK YOU. I FINALLY FOUND PEOPLE WHO APPRECIATE THIS BEAUTIFUL SONG

[@상추찬]

한글자막 금손분들이 달아주실 때까지 존버... 나도 무슨 말 하는지 알고 싶다....

[@gkdisvlzkcb]

존버2

[@ys-dx4lw]

생겼다!

[@dkgkgkgkgktgk2]

@@gkdisvlzkcb 생겨따

[@yanskidoodle]

This was so insightful! I don't know much about the technicalities of music but I love (G)I-DLE's music A LOT so it was really interesting to see music geniuses listen to their songs :3 Thank you!

[@nai5868]

15:50 that laugh killed me 😂

[@vanessaa.2130]

Same

[@mizanorizam8184]

I just noticed it was umu 😂🤣

[@Iv-zi5pe]

Soyeon is a genius, even if you don't know about music production jez, she saved my life.

[@EmilyMusic3v3]

Why did someone dislike this video already 😂

[@ELmayberry]

maybe they got scared

[@kimbappin]

idlephobic i say

[@krmiru_0240]

I think it's the youtube system..

[@meenoir]

@@krmiru_0240 what do you mean?

[@pancakewarrior]

This is such an underrated song, the pain and sorrow that the song gives is really portayed well. It makes me feel the pain from the song 😭

[@두부-s4b]

신기하다 나는 그냥 멋지다라고만 생각했는데 분석하는게 신기방기

[@peepawzhongli9217]

I LITERALLY LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH AND THE NIGHTMARE VERSION IS MY LIFE

[@angelalee7012]

Put it Straight (Nightmare ver.) is my absolute FAVOURITE G-Idle song.

[@MusicDoesChange]

gidle’s best song. im so glad musicians reacted to this thank you

[@multifandom1094]

soyeon's really is a genius. it wouldve been nice if they saw the queendom performance but i understand it could get taken down (fuck them for that) but gidle is really a unique girl group.

[@Moonsgoblin]

I think the chorus of this song is saying "it hurts' or something like that, and it's cool how they were able to catch that there was that pain in the music.

[@mikaylamerna62]

I gotta admit I didn’t watch ur vids for a long time but the editing though it’s so nice and fun!! I love how this channel has developed and seeing all the new reactors and also Kevin!! Love the reactions ~

[@rbear5085]

ah i wish you guys were able to react to the live performance (mnet sucks) i feel like the emotions captured in the live performance were even more raw and well real? but i loved this! one of my favorite groups

[@johnlee9192]

Well mark me down as scared and aroused, scaroused, if you will

[@jeonwi898]

I feel so good stanning gidle! Hearing their compliments made me emotional. My girls are getting recognition😭

[@cheese_ball_]

퀸덤 무대를 보여줘도 좋을거 같은데ㅠㅠ 아쉽고 기쁘고ㅠㅠ

[@bonepeonies]

So good!!! It’s so fun to have reactors be able to contrast two versions of a song (especially when there’s lots to say).

[@Adri-yc3tb]

I just jumpscared with Soyeon's rap here hahahaha omg, nightmare version is really a masterpiece

[@IGot7RevtinyArmyStayOnceBlink]

The nightmare version is everything! This song deserved more push it is so unique and hauntingly beautiful.

[@justshimatzu653]

Thank you for reacting to one of my fave G-Idle ballad!!! Put it straight just hit different no matter what version is 🥰

[@Camms96]

10:18 Cloud LMAO what Henry said sounded almost like another thing ehem 😂😂

[@ajdelapena7691]

Ah I've been waiting for this reaction

[@Ranimon25]

Lol the laugh editing is so crazy at 15:50 😂

[@yul_mi04]

I don't know who is subtitiling, but I want to say thank you for korean subtitle! 한글 자막 달아주셔서 감사해요!! 늘 재밌게 보고 있어요

[@nevy7097]

This is the best reaction video I've ever watched. Outstanding job guys ;)

[@ringelgollum]

I was really excited for their reaction. I was not let down.

[@blablashiba]

tooooo much unique songs describe different side of (g)i-dle!!! what they did is put emotions in their songs and u can flow with the melody 💙 i think that's why idle attract me :> really wanna recommend to you guys my fav bside tracks Luv u and For you 💖

[@Jin-zc5vk]

I wish you guys saw the Performance video on Queendom.. they really killed it, the performance and the stage was sheer perfection

[@mwohaeyo]

Seriously though, thank y’all for your work ❣️

[@jazz8482]

20:30 it's so crazy that Henry mentioned this technique cuz (G)I-DLE did this in their Oh My God mv!!

[@justinehercthehuman]

Was I the only one freaked out at 18:32 when someone behind the window walked by as Kevin said "hoping for the cycle (psycho) to kick in" paired with the scary sound effects? 🤣

[@OpinionatedMatt]

The little song that could

[@donthaveanamestill9221]

The skeleton tho lmfao

[@foreverrain7937]

Omg the intro popcorn speech is AMAZING haha

[@단울-l3z]

반응이랑 분석하는 것도 좋은데 해골땨문에 진짜 웃겨죽겠다 16:19

[@aqueelkadri8371]

If there is any reaction channel on youtube that deserves to be monetized, its reacttothek. Btw 18:45 it sounded like Kevin was playing the start of "You should see me in a Crown" by Billie Eilish

[@tanhowe6978]

Even though i'm a Buddy, I kind of understand why Yuju love (G)I-DLE! Their performance are amazing! The Joker is no joke! And the Nun too!

[@Sean-il7ko]

You guys need to react G-Idle's "I Burn" album (Hann in winter) is my personal fav😭

[@bo_rn2sleep]

나는 음악 하나도 모르지만 아 .. 그렇군 ..! 하면서 듣게되는게 재밌다 ㅠㅠ thx for k subtitles !!!!

[@meeu]

10:07 - i really like what he said there because that is how i approach most songs, regardless of whether it is in english or not. Many ask me how can you like a song you don't understand and i just raise my brow. You can feel it in the melody of the song and the how the artist treat it through their singing. That's how it is for me at least. Edit: i really love Put it Straight.

[@nikitanurazizah6410]

YYYEEESSS!!! I’VE BEEN WAITING THIS REACTION FOR DECADESSS 😭 THANK YOU SO MUCH UMU 🥺 ILY ❤️

[@xrmxssx2932]

15:55 When Umu start the bengek sound in her laugh

[@violent___serenity]

... reacttothek... you guys always introduce me to the best songs and analysis.

[@minominomino4526]

G-Idle is amazing. I remember the goosebumps when I first watch the horror version. Too bad you couldn't react to the Queendom one but I really love Henry's reaction here XD Thanks for the video, please stay healthy!