Classical & Jazz Musicians React: NMIXX 'O.O'

[@ReacttotheK]

YOO producer Charlotte Wilson weighed in on twitter and it turns out we were wrong- the song doesn't start at 133bpm and then slow down! It's actually super slow from the very BEGINNING and gradually speeds up till "check out"! The Hub will be making a video about it soon, i'll link it here when it's up 🙌 ‼ More NMIXX reaction content on our Patreon, including uncut versions of these reactions: www.patreon.com/reacttothek ‼ ➡ Reaction Release Schedule + list of all our Patreon-exclusive videos: docs.google.com/document/d/1uvf-u1EJVB-hmB3IU0P6M-obdMNu11fo_aUIf6dur70/edit?usp=sharing ➡ Songs that are currently being voted on or waiting to be voted on by our musician voting panel for C&JMR: kzbin.info/aero/PLFw_XZtkCVMMt3F3O3jvbeYlUyGo8v2nX ➡ Will not react to list for the CJ&MR series & why songs may not be reacted to: docs.google.com/document/d/1b5aQLWbYgUCm30Pj5-AalSjwMaq8gm5jOyrcbAlMu6c/edit?usp=sharing

[@rivanmahipe5168]

You guys should react to Red Velvet Feel My Rythm

[@teddyastronaut]

PLEASE CAN I REQUEST YOU TO REACT TO INDIAN SONGS? I HAVE BEEN WATCHING YOUR REACTION CHANNEL FROM A LONG TIME,AND I LOVE YOU, GUYS, SO PLEASE CAN YOU GUYS DO ME THE FAVOUR TO REACT TO INDIAN SONGS😊😊😊😊

[@erica8863]

@@rivanmahipe5168 Literally the outro card.

[@whoisthis1516]

i need g-idle reaction, in KZbin

[@teddyastronaut]

@UCQ_52p_bIMBipKtFMdjcXgQ what happened? Bro

[@MaluSilva-yx8nl]

I love how Red Velvet's "Feel My Rythm" was just released and it's already put next in the schedule, because the first time I heard the song my immediate thought was "I need to see ReacttotheK opinion on this one" 😆

[@Letsgo_NMIXX]

Exactly, I can't wait!

[@goodietwoshoes7238]

same!!!

[@sparkledazzlemoon]

Exactly !

[@K0ko53]

SM already contacted them to react to Feel My Rhythm before their comeback. That's why they reacted almost immediately

[@janixa8990]

Same

[@tinyteume]

I personally think the pause in the mv causes for more confusion because it creates the divide between the 2 parts of the song more evident. I didn't like the song when I initially heard it bc I watched the mv but when I listened to it on Spotify and the 2 sections were put side by side it wasn't as jarring to me

[@lepooploser]

Truth

[@ytprem306]

Same, personal i like the two parts individually but the song grows on me

[@suricatal]

i like both part as separate song not as a whole hhhh

[@hahengggggggg]

Yess, this the comment ive been looking for

[@choifays6043]

AGREED

[@pratamaputra000]

Honestly I can see why people don't really like this song. But It's also an enjoyable song for me. I'm already used to songs that changed genres suddenly. So it's fine to me. But I'm really worried cause some people calling people who enjoyed this song tasteless.

[@charred6683]

I grew up listening to music that change genres, beats, and experiment with different style in the same song. And now you think I'm gonna agree with you, but no, not at all. This song is tapping into the extremely short attention spam that the new generation have devolved into, just like what Next Level did, where people's brain forget the previous part when a new part starts, they focus on everything separately even if it's not supposed to be separated. This problem in the composition is caused by the actual and objective absence of a transition like it should have to connect everything together. People who dislike this song is not because they're not used to genre swapping, they dislike the song because they know it's lacking a lot to be considered a good composition. Those who like the song either don't care about well made music or are shills to the brands, they see a big name and just follow the crowd regardless of what it is.

[@NMIXXtopia_]

@@charred6683 "Those who like the song either don't care about well made music or are shills to the brands, they see a big name and just follow the crowd regardless of what it is" 1. 15:26 2. 15:40

[@MGalaxy23]

Agree, the hate towards this song is waaaaay too much. Sure it's not the best song ever but by any means it is not the worst, i would give it a solid 7, i like that they didn't do the typical debut, they took a risk.

[@witchyfairy_]

@@charred6683 AGREE

[@arusu1806]

Because it’s true.

[@crstn.909]

The guy drumming at 13:07 to the beat was so good and it felt so satisfying to hear.

[@virtual_angel_.x]

I am literally afraid to admit to people that I enjoyed the song so much from the first time listening to it because I would be called crazy 😭 (or be called a liar)

[@hederlisa]

You and me both. Chaotic goodness is what I called it.

[@paigea.316]

People are so annoying when it comes to people having a different taste of music then them. Like you’re allowed to love a song that they don’t like. Don’t be afraid to say you enjoyed the song. If someone comes at you you can come get me. I have no problem defending you. 😌

[@virtual_angel_.x]

@@paigea.316 eyy that's so sweet, thankies

[@hederlisa]

@@paigea.316 I mean. I had to endure Sticker slander too

[@baralsujal2004]

Same! I liked it on the first listen and it was on repeat for 4 days but whenever i tell people that I like it, they always say "oh you're just pretending to do it it's a bad song"😭 It's so damn annoying like let me enjoy the freakin song. I have a weird taste and i like savage, simon says, sticker so ofc i enjoy listening to O.O 😅

[@laurennn316]

5:13 I died laughing the attitude in “because some people like nails” is everything 😂😂😂😂

[@dikashafirahidayat1268]

THE MOMENT WE ALL HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR! Please help us understand why we feel the way we feel towards this song lmao

[@danielpeyrou]

because of the extreme tempo/harmonic contrast of the two (sub)songs is what most people don't like it.

[@whoisthis1516]

me watching nmixx debut first time: yeah, well..... me, now: *BAILA BAILA BAILAAAA*

[@eliasfv]

@@whoisthis1516 YO

[@universalsubliminals1174]

it's not as well done as an SM song, it isn't coherent at all so it just doesn't wrk

[@Friedensp4nzer]

You mean why I loved it after the 2nd listen?

[@bosgotnojams]

The song has been on loop for me in the past weeks and now I'm mindblown that the intro actually does start slow and speeds up. O.O

[@asdgfhjkl9017]

I kno u from TWICE! 🤩

[@jonan-pineda]

I didnt know the tempo of the different section had a connection and not just random tempos mixed. Great reaction from the musicians :D

[@CryptP]

Yeah, a lot of ppl complain about the "superhero" section supposedly coming out of nowhere but don't know it was technically teased at the start w the first 100bpm section

[@sidannial4161]

You’re watching the same video? Because the classical musician clearly stated how there was no connection between different tempos and ideas. Listen 9:30

[@CryptP]

@@sidannial4161 12:20 onwards they explain how the tempo changes work musically

[@emilzamudio1972]

@@sidannial4161 he was just talking about the ideas of each sections ☠️

[@CryptP]

@@sidannial4161 "Not a lot of connection between *some* of the ideas" is a totally different statement to "No connection between any different ideas" btw Hes saying that some of the ideas could be better fleshed out in how they complement other sections, he's not saying that there's no connection to anything else

[@iwouldrathernotuwu]

the editor needs a raise, all these lil jokes were fire!!!!

[@gaearin1662]

This song gets more addictive the more you listen to it. It's very weird. I got used to the switch ups the second time listening

[@unknownuserg2g]

I got used to it after listening to the final audio version...for some reason that silence in between the genre shifts was throwing me off...otherwise it was interesting...

[@Zerin666]

Saaame

[@ngasalaja2839]

I personally love every parts in this song i just don't like how they mix it

[@dhafaaa6823]

Literally every song

[@katrinnsch]

@@unknownuserg2g same!! For me the pause definitely throws me of

[@andersekoli]

Thanks, I really liked this reaction. After reading so many harsh words about this song I was looking forward to hear what you thought about! Always so knowledgable, always so insightful! Awesome!

[@renezhou07]

my first time reaction to o.o, this song was kinda messy because of sudden beat change but after listening so many times, i really like it. their vocals, choreos and stage presences make this song even better and now o.o is one of my fav debut song all of time.

[@asalshahrestani7377]

It's actually really good reminds me of nearly all K-pop songs, the change in noise, and the amazing dancing

[@ningningwonderpets4773]

I liked the song at first listen. I even thought all the parts fits perfectly in the song. It's great that they are exploring different genres nowadays. Kpop has evolved so much and it's making me proud!

[@willa9880]

Well ppl have diffrent tastes and Nmixx is just going on the same way like aespa both of them have a unique style that not everyone would like

[@taeyongscheeks]

@@willa9880 that is not just a thing für these groups it is in general. But yeah it is a riskier move

[@MorenoWanderley]

This was not trap. This is BRAZILIAN FUNK

[@glxoi]

melhor parte da música sim

[@MorenoWanderley]

@@glxoi COM CERTEZA

[@liammcmanus7502]

Hi :) when I said “trap” I was only referring to the hi-hat sound the producers used, not referencing the actual genre of music! I’m SUPER unfamiliar with Brazilian funk. Upon further listening the “baile funk” pattern that the producers employed here is a two bar pattern similar to son clave, as opposed to the one bar pattern you typically see in reggaeton music. However, the first bar of that “baile funk” pattern sounds very similar to reggaeton. That’s why I was confused after only hearing it once. Hope that clears some things up!

[@kaydenorusual]

the girl in white outfit is Jinni and yes, she definitely destroyed people's brains with that iconic first line

[@valentinuswinanda547]

YES

[@user-ey6lq9qe3n]

it was so shrill i hated it at first because it's so shocking now i'm addicted

[@04Ammy04]

I still really dislike the lyrics of the first 2 lines. Just reads like lazy writing. Idk just way too bizarre and awful to me. The rest of the song I like and I love the girls' talents.

[@mbae123]

@@04Ammy04 same. I cant get used to it

[@alvareo92]

@@user-ey6lq9qe3n it's so fucking weird along with the heavy keyboards. It reminds me of Die Antwoord whch I used to listen to back in the day so I loved it lol

[@a_k_406]

Agree with Sam about the trumpet, he put it into words what I feel. The Baila Baila part was a turn off for me, not a good loud. Middle section is great, I like that part a lot. Others are just okay. I don’t like some transitions, like before the last chorus and into it. Listening to it again now, I guess there’s more of it that I don’t like about this but it’s interesting, and also hear what reacttothek thinks and feel about it :)

[@brynmarie9655]

Yeah this is exactly how I feel. I don’t like the chorus in the first and last section, and I think the transitions could’ve been more tactful. I understand the connections between the sections and I also think they were going for shock value (and honestly I think JYP is trying to recreate the success of AESPA and Next Level a bit) in the way they moved, but I don’t think just the sheer fact that the sections are connected in some way makes the transitions effective. Mostly it’s just the transition back that I don’t like. The transition into the middle I like a lot more now that I’ve listened to the official track without that pause. But yeah it’s interesting to hear what they had to say as a musician myself, and while the song had grown on me, I still don’t love it.

[@yulana990]

Then theres me, who only likes the 1st and last section and wished they made a full song with that sound 😂 I still think they shouldve made 2 separate songs, cause a lot of fans have been saying they only liked the middle donut shop part and not the rest.

[@danicaalquisola3152]

I've been waiting for this. The reactors inputs put my brain into deep understanding about the sections of the song and how the chords connect with each other. I feel so smart hahahaha

[@leastselfawarepotassium]

This really helped me understand what people might find confusing about this song. I’ve been an 0.0 enjoyer from day one so I was struggling to understand what people were so confused about.

[@moonchild708]

me too! it was only the first line that threw me off and the long gap in the mv, the whole song is so cohesive and beautiful

[@saikojoji4079]

imo the first verse (haewon and bae's) was the most disappointing part of the song... felt like it could've been better constructed and mixed, it sounded a little off??? but everything else was great! i listen to a lot of "experimental" stuff and generally have a very welcoming approach on music, so the "confusing" and "terrible" comments didn't really make much sense to me

[@alvareo92]

The first time I listened to it I was like WHAT THE HELL IS THIS on like the beginning and every transition but in a very good way. I could totally understand how some people could be very put off but what I can't understand is people saying the song is "meh" or "girl crush stereotype" like it literally is a mix of girl crush and weird club music and Brazilian funk and colourful upbeat Kpop like how can you say it's just a failed generic attempt at a trendy sound?

[@saikojoji4079]

@@alvareo92 people are really firing off some crazy takes about this song, and while I understand this is more unorthodox than most, it really isn't that different from what's been going on in kpop right now. next level had a similar structure, o.o was just a little more experimental with the genres they chose to mix the mv did the song a disservice too, that gap really made it seem more disjointed and it's a shame because i actually enjoyed how they transitioned from one part to another. people make it seem like it came out of nowhere but i'd argue that the bridge on savage was even more out of left field 😭

[@asy11237]

@@saikojoji4079 true that

[@xiachrs7218]

i remember not liking this song, but the more i listen to it, the more it gets addictive

[@haehaehaechanie9851]

Omgg samee

[@SieMiezekatze]

Honestly I thought the song was a disaster at first, but the more you listened it the better and more addictive it gets 🤩

[@astronautsamuel_xxv2295]

I do not like this song, but I love listening to musicians react to interesting pieces of music. It makes me understand things better, and I'M LOVING THE EDITING

[@melatirahmiaziza7869]

It's ok if you don't like it. Bcoz there are other people like me who like this song, and this is not something that can be forced 😊 And nice to know that at least you could enjoy their reaction 😁

[@martinho7345]

I finished this video with a tear almost coming down my left eye, with how much I enjoyed these reactions/analyses! It feels so wholesome to have people who dedicate their lives to music, making you feel understood and not an alien for finding for loving this MV... Thank you!!!!

[@zarvhalter2224]

You're not alone

[@rakaaaaap5289]

Always love the editings: The memes, the funny pics, distorted face, the written and the illustrated theories, etc. I'm enjoying this channel so muchh 😍

[@JH-bb8in]

shOOOGG SHOOOOG

[@nikitaashok3818]

The owl editing cracked me up! 😂😂 Also I love that you're keeping in the impromptu Spanish lesson and spongebob singing, feels nice to see those natural/random conversations y'all have along with the music analysis and thoughts :) Looking forward to this video already

[@belleramos18]

when many kpop fans & typical 'kpop mv reactors' reacted to the song negatively but here's ReacttotheK liking the song plus giving us proper musical critiques. always one my fave reaction channels. thank you guys!

[@szdraa]

it always irritates me when kpop fans act like they know music chucking words left and right like "off beat" "not mixed well" "badly arranged" etc. while not knowing even the first thing about music (apparently not even how to count to 4 because according to them sticker is off beat when it is consistently the same) i get this song is confusing to most people and i understand why people don't like it, but people are criticising it without any musical knowledge and are saying shit that don't make sense 😭 like how is this badly mixed

[@davidmarclouiseencabo8072]

@@szdraa they be getting smart when throwing hates🤓 but when slapped with the truth they will ignore it🥴

[@technicaleclipse7456]

@@davidmarclouiseencabo8072 I don't you need musical expertise to know what sounds good to you and what doesn't. Though I do agree some can be pretentious.

[@yulana990]

@@szdraa You also gotta know that just cause some musicians in this video enjoyed it, it doesnt mean other musicians will think the same. Someone else also pointed out, just cause its intellectually interesting, doesnt mean it emotionally is. Just cause something follows a beat or is interesting to experts ears, as that is their job, doesnt mean the outcome is pleasing or good? Thats like someone making a salad where every ingredient is healthy and people saying its the most bland unsatisfying salad ever, but because 1 dietitian said "wow thats healthy" all the criticism is nullified cause others arent "experts"? When the criticism never even was about it being a healthy salad, but a TASTY salad. Same with this song, peple are pointing out that compared to other songs like these (all of SM) this one was done very oddly. Yes the transitions are there, beat there, and professional musicians ears might find it fascinating, but fascinating doesnt mean it sounds good or people cant say they dislike it. Cause the point of a song in the end is making a song people want to and enjoy listening to, not what song can please professional only ears. Most people have even said they loved the donut shop part and wished that was its own song, whilst other like me think the 1st and last part couldve been a great song OR if they shortened the donut shop part it wouldve blended in better. You even saw one of the musicians in the video be shocked that they kept going for so long with the donut shop mid section. Its not something people do in proper "weird mix" songs, because it makes people forget the other part even exists if it goes on for so long and makss it more jarring. I wouldve loved the song if they switched back to the 1st part after the swinging section in the donut shop, but they decided to add another section afterwards which makes it very long and then suddenly the end is just them saying the same words over and over again. You dont need to be a musician to know that wont be pleasing to most peoples ears, and just cause a song was technically made correctly doesnt mean it works. If someone gave me a bowl of tofu, spinach, almonds, quinoa and avocado and told me its healthy, I still wouldnt enjoy it when its clearly not seasoned properly even if its checks of the boxes and the rules for a good salad. Keep in mind I actually support NMIXX and still listen to the song (only for the start of the song tho) and love their bside Tank, but that doesnt mean people criticizing the song need to be musicians lmao

[@szdraa]

@@yulana990 i think i worded what i meant to say in a weird way. i never said people can't dislike it, i understand why they do, but they throw around words that make no sense to justify their hate towards the girls- i have seen some vile stuff being said that was just not necessary. that was my point. i personally enjoy noise music a lot and i always get excited for experimental releases, but i know that's not what a lot of people enjoy. the thing that irks me is people saying things that don't make sense. i could not care less about whether or not someone doesn't like a song, but these are the same people attacking those who do enjoy it while not even being able to count four beats twice over. this was the thing with sticker too and next level and i could go on. i know what you mean and i agree with you, perhaps i didn't articulate what i meant to say well enough. yes you don't need to be a musician to criticise it, but at the same time, if you're going to act like you know what you're talking about (like in terms of being off beat or transitions or syncopation and whatever else people like to comment on) then at least know what those actually mean, and also be aware that songs don't have to follow the same generic chord progression and bpm structure, because otherwise it sounds kinda weird. it's like if i was criticising someone's cooking while not knowing what half the words i'm throwing around mean and not actually knowing how to cook- acting like a know it all when i know absolutely nothing about cooking. i can say i dislike it yes. but if i decided to take apart the way someone prepared a dish, then i'd just look like a mug. i know it's not that deep, but when some people get bold with their opinions and think theirs is superior and everyone jumps on the bandwagon, and starts hating others for not agreeing, it gets very annoying.

[@Ahjusshi_Brown]

I’ll say this, I definitely don’t hate this song anymore 😂😂 it took me MANY listens but I really appreciate and love how they approached this song technically and my brain has made peace with its progression

[@Butterball2829]

dont force yourself to listen to a song lmao u can not like something

[@bronksalaji]

@@Butterball2829 some are not forcing they are just understanding.. stop the hate! Literally.. it's been a month.. Let people enjoy this song so it can CHART EVEN HIGHER 😍😍😍😌😌😌💅💅😜😜👀👀👀

[@cinnomix]

@Kadi was it the popcorn and zero coke part? bc if so, same 😂 but i did like the song from first listen, i just kept coming back to the first part of it and then grew to love the rest of the song even more

[@bethanydestajo1106]

agree it also took me several listens to actually like the song for what it is, but I'm still not happy with the transition from 1st chorus to 2nd verse

[@slaypa]

@@bronksalaji some people do forcing themself for liking the song, tbh i kinda forcing myself to listen the song because i love lily sm but i'm still not ended up liking the song so i just support the member rather listen for the song now but i do really like tank.

[@hannahulfat]

3:02 “its a nice drop” it really is , the reason i really like o.o is bc of the build up its so good

[@stbyl]

i love the instrumentals of this song. i mean SM raised me to enjoy this kind of songs. 😂 and oh boy! i'm excited for your reaction to "feel my rhythm". i know i love the song but something feels weird. it's so overwhelming.

[@lychee7391]

Sm makes experimental music yes, but not like this one.

[@ringdingding6561]

@@lychee7391 what do you think about glitch mode - NCT dream btw? I'm just curious

[@zbzbzb1]

yeah this song has sm vibes

[@choerim]

I'm so used to O.O getting hate that this reaction was a positive surprise, even though I knew the ReactToTheK reactors would appreciate it much more I was also ready for some harsh critiques so to see so many of them enjoy and praise it was an amazing experience

[@zheke_music]

*the reason why this is such a complex song because it doesn't follow the basic bpm arrangement, some parts are not on your typical song writing arrangement plus you add in a vibe change and genre change then obviously alot of people will talk, anyhow this is a very unique song and a very unique GG* 🔥

[@redredred407]

yessssiiirrrr

[@Kvneeeeee1]

Basically, it's a bad song.

[@hazelfayejuridico779]

But the technique and the way the song was written was not unique tho

[@imnayeon3164]

@@Kvneeeeee1 damn you really have a bad taste in music 🤣

[@monkeydluffy-nh2tp]

@@Kvneeeeee1 coming from nobody.

[@cloudsn]

As always, I appreciate the analysis. What a nice mix of thoughts. Personally, I do not care for this song at all, but I still like to hear what people who actually know music think about it. So yeah. You're doing great, keep going. :)

[@omegashots59]

Really enjoyed this reaction! When a song like this comes out one of the first things I wait for are your reactions to it because of how so much stuff is happening with the songs. It was really insightful and I was happy with the way things were explained and broken down. Personally, I really enjoyed the song when I first heard it and still can't get enough of it. Now hearing the analysis as well from you guys gives me a whole different level of appreciation now.

[@justlaila9834]

the song literally functions as a teaser for nmixx future comebacks and what they are capable of and i loved how all your reactions at the end of the song showed that (theres the literal lyrics 'its just a teaser' in the song) and it really makes me want to see what nmixx and their producers and company have planned for th efuture

[@lavenderkim07]

When I hear this song and watch the mv I am thinking about you guys "The reacttothek will like to react it" 🤣

[@pastelhotmess9299]

Riiight XD

[@preasia731]

SAME😅

[@nikitaashok3818]

Literal sameeee, my first thought was "I can't wait to see how all the reacttothek people will feel about this!" 😄

[@melatirahmiaziza7869]

And glad that they release the reaction not so long from when the song was released 😁

[@gp1925]

When I first heard the song I knew it was sorta funky But not bad. I just ignored all other reactors cause I didn’t think they could appreciate it. I’m used to enjoying Stray kids experimental stuff that got hated on by a lot of people and if reacttotheK can listen to that and be enthusiastic and respectful and give great musical insight then I knew they’d have a really insightful cool reaction to this song.

[@njcr57]

Wow thanks for breaking it down for us non musicians! I appreciate the editing that went into this - super helpful to understand the concepts esp when you were isolating the instruments and illustrating the tempo onscreen. Thanks to everyone who helped us understand why we were so confused. ❤ Haha

[@-EchoesIntoEternity-]

there is a lot of fusion going on in the song..... confusion

[@nzamiacid]

That’s why their name is NMIXX. It’s because they mix up their songs lol i don’t listen to them but i think they do it for all of their songs

[@susie6559]

as a retired musician, i love this song; it’s so addicting and their stellar performance makes it even more addicting. and i loved the way the mv complimented and emphasized the switch. it was like Narnia, going through a portal to a drastically different world. i get why people hate on it but i would say they missed the point of the song & mv. people are free to dislike the song; i just feel like people are being a little excessive and unfair w the way they’ve been expressing their hatred of the song.

[@melatirahmiaziza7869]

Yeah, it is the first time I see hate comment just bcoz they don't like the song. What they did wasn't state their opinion but humiliate the song, and maybe bcoz they are afraid that their favs will lose to them *lol :p

[@susie6559]

@@melatirahmiaziza7869 yeah people have literally been getting bullied online for enjoying the song. it’s a bit much.

[@Elsi-Music]

It’s really the lyrics for me. The English lyrics make literally no sense.

[@susie6559]

@@Elsi-Music i mean.. when do english lyrics ever make sense in kpop?

[@Elsi-Music]

@@susie6559 facts but this one is especially bad. Why do they say eye drop??!!

[@grassgrass1186]

I only heard bad stuff about this song I don't even give it a try, but after hearing it's not that weird. I guess the shock Sticker gave me make me used to something like this

[@sophie427]

K-pop is desensitizing us 😭😭😭

[@nurruddinaniqz.r.a597]

STICKER is more enjoyable.... NMIXX used SMP (SM genre) but they claimed they used new genre called mixpop 🤮

[@grassgrass1186]

@@nurruddinaniqz.r.a597 Yeah Sticker is more enjoyable, it just I got used to something weird after I heard Sticker. If I never heard Sticker before maybe this song will give me the shock Sticker gave.

[@emannn0912]

@@nurruddinaniqz.r.a597 lol who hurt you?

[@danidanialleee]

@@nurruddinaniqz.r.a597 ANIIQ FLOP 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤮🤮

[@shavow2500]

wow, their explanations of the beat changes and the other stuffs made even more like the song and now im even more stunned from those beat changes then before

[@melatirahmiaziza7869]

Same! It is a whole experience, right! 😁 Learning something new is really enjoyable 😁

[@jadalade]

it was a lot, its not my personal favorite but i can appreciate the style and the experimentalism of it. the group definitely has potential!!

[@hiame-dono]

I never felt so validated before 😂 a lot of people kept saying it was bad etc, but i really vibe with the song

[@yangfangfangon9jai788]

Thank you so much for making this video. I always hear people saying that the production was bad, but that's not true. In terms of music taste, it might not be everyone's favourite, but the composers did A LOT, musically, and it's quite complicated as well.

[@seif7933]

3:20 "Is this a coke ad?" Why yes sir, Nmixx pulled a Next Level whilst filming for a coke ad

[@Rerizz]

You know next level ain't the only one that did this type of thing with its song right? Istg yall are so annoying

[@slaypa]

@@Rerizz i don't really hear this kinda genre in kpop except for SM, can you give me a song like these type of genre beside SM?? i would appreciate it, Thank You.

[@seif7933]

@@slaypa SM Started it back in 1995 it's an experimental genre, yet JYP claims that it's a brand new thing called MIXX POP and they're the first ones to do it

[@seif7933]

@@slaypa For examples out of SM , check out Big Bang

[@erica8863]

The breakdown for the final genre switch was really informative. I originally thought the tempo/metric change happened with the scene change but the fact that it's delayed makes the moment both confusing and satisfying. Also, can't wait for Feel My Rhythm. As I listened to it, I was thinking "There's that modal mixture. ReacttotheK is gonna have a field day with this one."

[@professionalamateur741]

I love rewatching this video. It’s so fun to hear everyone talk about this song and why it’s interesting to the listener. Plus, “wait, is this a coke commercial” gets me every time lol!

[@SheepyxTails]

Listening to this song now after DICE makes me want this style back because, sure it was out there as a song, but you get used to it and it's unique. It made them stand out and I wish they kept that sound.

[@Katherine-dt9te]

I lost my shit when you have the transcription of how it change it back to baila baila baila in 13:08 - this whole reaction is so impressive

[@ildefonso5778]

Aside from great explanation from the team, another thing I appreciate is the editing. It makes it easier for us to understand what each person is talking about. Super thank you, Umu and the whole team~

[@mAsHuMaRoPanda]

FACT: I'm a musician ALSO FACT: There is nobody who can really fully comprehend NMIXX and their music, no not even musicians. But that is what makes NMIXX so unique! First, their sound and style MIXXPOP is meant to break musical standards and norms. Second, you will never know what they'll do next. Unlike other artists whose songs pretty much sound the same every comeback. This is why they made a statement with their debut song o.o . The song was a literal teaser, both conceptually and lyrically. A teaser of what NMIXX is capable of, and man are they more than capable. This group is not talented! They are skillfull... Because talent you may or may not be born with. But these girls are skillfull, due to the fact that they worked so hard not only just so they could debut, but they continue to improve. I believe that there is no limit to what NMIXX can and will do. They are true artists who stay true to their craft, regardless of what other people say and tell them to do. No compromise!

[@hwang_seungrae]

FINALLYYY! Loved this song at first listen so I'm excited to hear musicians' thoughts! 💖

[@thatmusadude777]

yess actual musician knowledge!! the producers of the song really thought things out and not just play around in the studio like what the haters assumed when this was released

[@MikoUlala]

Sorry, out of topic. Cant wait for you guys to Red Velvet's new song "Feel My Rhythm". Thankyou Umu ❤️ Edit : i comment this before i finish this video btw sorry 😅

[@YOUR_DREAM_GALLERY]

Yuppss

[@chrislee3601]

Fr i would love if she could get some art hustory majors too for thag

[@kimvious]

same cant wait too!!!

[@mariabelle]

up

[@rachaelh8026]

They will in April! Its on their schedule

[@cheerio4000]

im not into kpop at all but i am so obsessed with “O.O” rn like why does it sound so good,, I only found out abt cus I heard y’all hated it

[@miloneserey6677]

You never failed to impress me guys!!!! I am waiting for you to give us your insight about this song! Personally, I really really like the song when it first came out, I can of O.O too when I heard the different sections but I am loving it, maybe because I was watching you guys react to different songs and analyze the song production, beats, rhythm and everything that made me love this song because I definitely try to encode how it was made! I am not so much familiar about music production but all I know is that it was really unique and fun like playing a rubik's cube! Thank you guys for your reaction!

[@Gokai_]

After so many hate comments about this debut, I'm SO HAPPY that you guys reacted to this. Especially everyone who gave constructive criticism. You could clearly see that everyone enjoyed something about this, some even all but it's well explained for casuals like most of us who don't really understand why so much going on in this song.

[@JuliaGNava]

THANK YOU for understanding that in kpop, it's not only about music. This debut clearly was a taste of the group's identity, it showed fans what direction they intend to follow, their concept, and versatility. It was never SUPPOSED to be cohesive, it was supposed to be jarring, interesting, intriguing and make people look out for their next song to see what they have in store for us. Mission accomplished tbh, so props to all the JYP team for that!

[@crptpyr]

It's been 2 years but I've gotta say I still love that rug pull at the start of the song so much. That sudden meter change always takes me back to the first time I ever listened to this song, I was getting into the pulse of the intro and as soon as it changed I whipped my head back around to the front like "woah what just happened". Like it felt like a deliberate move to make sure you were paying attention.

[@liunenai]

not admitting that i loved the song at first listen in fear of being judged 💀

[@sullyoon8942]

Us😭

[@samruddhibande2656]

True😭

[@melatirahmiaziza7869]

It is so sad ToT And I think it's only happened in KPop. Maybe becoz of tough competition which made the fans gone crazy everytime a new group appear with so much potential, like them for example.

[@moamoaoz]

It’s not good

[@MaluSilva-yx8nl]

When I first heard this song, and I think a lot of people had a similar experience, it was just too much to digest, I finished watching the MV at first without remembering anything about the song because it was just too much going on haha. But after seeing this video, a lot of things made more sense, especially the very beginning of the song that always makes me feel weird and now I realize it's because of the lyrics being extremely offbeat. ABSOLUTELY LOVED THIS VIDEO 10000/10 I WAS COMPLETELY 🤯🤯🤯 WATCHING IT THANK YOU

[@nonjabulomangoro1871]

I always forget what this song sounds like until I hear it again. Which is frustrating because I vividly remember cool parts of the choreography. 😭🤣🤣

[@MaluSilva-yx8nl]

@@nonjabulomangoro1871 exactly!!! it took me some listens to remember any part at all, and it was the "baila baila" part that got stuck after a while 😂

[@melatirahmiaziza7869]

And our face after watch this video also become (O.O)

[@anxx5233]

Girl our take on this song is almost identical lol. It is just too much to digest. But for me this reaction video didn't really make the whole song make more sense, it just helped me to understand that there are lots of fancy technicalities in it and it's definitely not a sloppy production.

[@benkalem]

It's well-produced, visually stunning, and the girls do a great job. It's just kinda meh. It's one of those things, where this works as a performance, but as a piece of music, it's forgettable. It has so many good ingredients, but it comes out of the oven overbaked and a bit burnt. "Too many cooks in the Kitchen" kinda deal. It's intellectually interesting, but emotionally empty. The good thing is, they are great performers, well-trained talented entertainers, and I have no doubt, that with the right songs they can make a really big impact on the scene.

[@PlanA2013]

"It's intellectually interesting, but emotionally empty". Thank you for these words. It is just completely my thoughts.

[@sheryl_tan]

"intellectually interesting but emotionally empty" is so true for me. Just found it hard to connect with the song and I don't know when I am going to need or want to listen to it.

[@alvareo92]

I liked it because I enjoy some very weird experimental music and I also love Kpop so this was perfect for me. Maybe it doesn't communicate something coherent or poignant, but the craziness really resonates with me, it most definitely gives me an emotional reaction (not intellectual; I usually don't like art where you can tell it was primarily an intellectual exercise) that I keep coming back to. Just a matter of preference!

[@blanca3806]

Some of us are passionate about the “intellectually interesting” and it has emotional value in a different way than what other people like you are usually looking for. Like it was forgettable for you because you don’t value the things it brings but some of us like the ppl in the video do value them.

[@lunali7209]

ur bullshitting

[@sophie427]

the editing in the first half of this video was the highlight of my day

[@moomoomachines7193]

I find what Ravi said towards the end about it being a representation of virtuality very interesting, especially because the middle section's lyrics dissect a world of the new metaverse.

[@VNZ.00]

O.O is just the reaction everyone gets after listening to it once.

[@archraeimenu6767]

Oh my god I'm waiting for this since the song itself is kinda interesting for me in terms of its arrangement so I want to have an idea of what your reaction would be for this song!

[@aquarius489]

Whether I like a song or not, these videos always make me appreciate it so much more.

[@piaspiazza6851]

raffi's "it was a lot, I just went through a lot" :D I had the exact same first reaction after seeing and listening to this track

[@datspookywitch]

IM SO HAPPY YOU GUYS DID THIS SONG ❤️

[@imjayhime]

I honestly love this song. It’s so addictive and the more you listen to it, the better it gets. The MV and choreo are also really cool. It’s nice to hear good reviews of it. The song is getting so much unnecessary hate. I can’t wait to see what they do next

[@93faw]

5:46 "i just went through a lot" lol 😂

[@KayUncut]

had this song just been two separate songs I would’ve loved both of them but them together and the execution just wasn’t my most favorite thing in the world. extremely talented group though

[@itzshadin1012]

The funniest reaction so far lmao The editing I must say is just makes it Also I really love this song, i know ppl had different opinions on it but yeah, you know how you'd sometimes listen to the Instrument version of a certain songs nd it makes you feel like a whole new song?? This is one of them nd that's why I really enjoy it ++ as soon as RV feel my rythem dropped i thought to myself that's it's such a classical peace nd it well defiantly be fun WHEN you react to it cause i. Know for a fact you well, I mean you HAVE TO.. it just screams "react to me react to the K channel" lol

[@Rerizz]

I love this song, the choreo just makes it 100 times better. Loved the reactions. After so much hate for the song I feel safe in here lol

[@mixx._.]

i came back here because i had a class today where my teacher talked about hemiola, now I'll think about nmixx every time i hear about it✨

[@Esandeech2]

They will be like fx. Too ahead of its time, people call it weird. Then in a couple of years it will be called genius. As a SNSD fan who survived the IGAB era that was full of madness, O.O isn’t too overwhelming.

[@bella11110]

I wouldn't call it ahead of its time since this is something that had been done before by different groups, and just like IGAB, rn and in the future, there will be always people who'd call it genius or a disaster, it a taste thing I would say

[@Esandeech2]

@@bella11110 fragmented songs have been done. But not a song like O.O

[@bella11110]

@@Esandeech2 that's arguable

[@emilyflorie232]

my best friend is a music producer and learn classical piano. knows kpop briefly but nothing about nmixx. i introduced him to nmixx with o.o. and at the end he said "give me more of them. I WANT MORE"💀💀💀💀💀💀

[@daeundances]

the fact that i dont like the intro bc jinni isnt rapping on any beat but they like it about that is so fascinating. ig as a dancer im biased towards on beat where they can appreciate the music

[@SakuraStallion]

This song GREW on me after not listening to the MV version and switching to the one with no silence. Seeing the technical breakdown (Espically by Seth) made me appreciate this so much more as it genuinely is a bridge between musicians and people who genuinely have no idea WHY it works.

[@girigiriboy0124]

I knew you'd react to this song. I actually didn't like it at first so I was hoping you would react to this so I would understand what was happening in the song. Also waiting for subs!

[@ReacttotheK]

Subs will be up in a day or two :)

[@kesyorge94]

SM be like : No thats not how you do it

[@anjumlimbu914]

At first i really didn't like this song but after listening to it continues time iam in love with this song. This song is so unique also the vocals, visual of the girls are so good 😍

[@jialetang4492]

Cannt wait to check out your reaction to their new release of “Dice”!

[@mbae123]

They are vocally saved by Lily because her vocal tone isn't usually heard in kpop. It adds an interesting sound to their group vocals. The freshness of her voice is a very good welcome.

[@sam_sa09]

I have a voice of that tone too so I'm glad to see your comment, wish me luck on my auditions 🤗

[@mbae123]

@@sam_sa09 Goodluck girl. May you pass the evals!

[@sam_sa09]

@@mbae123 thank you so much, I just got to Seoul this month, but I'm super conscious about my age

[@mbae123]

@@sam_sa09 thats okay as long as you do your best. Just trust your instincts and watch out if its going to harm you or not.

[@sam_sa09]

@@mbae123 thank you sincerely for your kind words 💕 the fact that I've never had any training and that I'm the same age as lily makes me super nervous, and as much as I want to do my best, I'm trying to overcome self hatred and improve my mentality before I audition. Nothing scares me more than failure though, I tried so hard to get here, but it feels like my story has already ended before the first chapter was even written

[@xnctxo9876]

It’s SOOO good I’m so happy to finally see some positive reactions on it yeyyy ^^

[@alaisle7101]

why does it say nails cause somebody likes nails I BURST OUT LAUGHING TO THIS HAHAHAHSHS

[@JuanDMP]

The editing it's getting better and better, so funny XD

[@RudeMekanicals]

Thank you guys for giving O.O a fair shake. It is far from a perfect song but it is also not the worst debut ever that so many people claimed. A good subjective analysis is always appreciated.

[@rocacore]

Dude I was waiting for your reactions and yall did not disappoint!! The song gave me a big whiplash the first time i heard it, it was nice to hear yall thoughts on it!

[@DR-di1ow]

The part that I don't really like the most is the chorus 'balla balla" part, I don't like the composing and instrumental choices. I'm agree with Sam, that trumpet sounds is so disturbing, in the 'balla balla' chorus, I think it's either misplaced or the sound is just not harmonize well with the other instruments inthat part, also I'm sorry to say this but I hope THE HUB stop using that cheap trumpet sounds, they've used it a lot in their productions actually.

[@benedictusbimo]

THIS IS THE MOMENT IM WAITING FOR!! since the first time i listened to this song, i brb check ur channel ahahahaha

[@mbkbenz]

This is so educational. I f**king love it

[@chelseatibanye5914]

My first listen to this song was just a few minutes ago. It just popped up in my study playlist on Spotify and I just couldn't continue with my accounting. I needed to see your reaction😂. BTW, I love it.

[@jonk0830]

Really really waiting for their reaction on red velvets feel my rythm

[@ReacttotheK]

It takes us about 2-3 weeks to produce a classical musicians react video! FMR reaction in April is the fastest we can do 😭👍

[@nindi1105]

@@ReacttotheK ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@hightree9295]

@@ReacttotheK it's alright !!! I'll be waiting for it 🥰

[@2ndaccount913]

@@ReacttotheK i will wait for it, u guys should react to the song..

[@oncextwice6059]

Omg I'm so happy you guys reacted to o.o I've been waiting for all of your insights to this song because of how complex this song is! Thank you thank you thank you

[@exol1827]

HONESTLY I DON'T LINK THE FIRST VERSE BUT THEY HOOKED ME ON 2ND VERSE AND CHORUS AND I LIKE THEIR POWERFUL VOCALS TOO

[@mahdidrake7449]

this song just itches a spot in my brain i’ve become obsessed

[@7171C-l6n]

It's like the starting chapter in a music film to me + the feeling of something missing at the end = a nice intro to a group because you have a glimpse of how the group will be like and want more from the group. Just like you wanna know what will happen next at the beginning of a movie. For me, it is a good choice as a debut song but it would be better if it is the first song of a full-length album.

[@karinamarques2076]

YES YES I WAS WAITING FOR THIS REACTION!

[@bamboleoingwithrvdiscograp1471]

Don't lie. Everyone thought of Reacttothek after watching FMR.

[@JKReaxts]

Definitely a crazy song. I was ready for that Feel My Rhythm video on the end screen only to realize it hasn’t been uploaded yet 😭😭😭

[@nvis_9001]

Being SM stan myself, this song was kinda "normal" to me and i love it🤣 but i just hate it when jyp said "its a new genre" cause IT IS NOT and cringe

[@AnissaNoerSafitri]

yes exactly. I doesnt matter to me when they made a name of this genre MIXPOP but calling this genre is "new genre" when SM already do this kind of genre for their artist is teribble to me. Is like JYP is in denial that SM already use this "new genre" long time ago.

[@haidarirsyamal-farisy548]

@Tralala_Beez it's actually the mixing are smoother for those SM’s song you mentioned while in this song, I found the mixing and changes of genre are so abrupt and threw you off. Even Next Level has smoother transition going in to to slower tempo and back to faster tempo. And Next Level are the song that threw me off from three songs you mentioned.

[@manydaaa123]

Sm don't mix genres though.. Sm just changes beats yet still a single song However JYP just added 2 songs with different genres in 1 by mixing it

[@nvis_9001]

@@manydaaa123 dude dont me start. im busy enough right now🤣 go do some sm music history study urself

[@manydaaa123]

@@nvis_9001 sorry not interested

[@jshxaaa]

YOU DON'T KNOW HOW LONG I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO Thankss