Real Electronic Engineers Respond to Mark Steele's claims about 5G

Mark Steele claims to be an expert in 5G, the current generation of mobile phone networks. In this episode, we review Mark Steele's claims about 5G and see if they hold up to scrutiny from three electronic engineers, Lee, Michael and Chris.

[@nebulan]

"A communications protocol that let's you watch cat videos"👌

[@chrisstreet6827]

I mean, I say it as it is right... :)

[@rylanasher4756]

A great video, Mr Wilson. Informative and entertaining as always. Great lineup of experts too.

[@peterq1978]

oh no, Mark had his PKE meter out... we are done chaps!!!

[@RaynardWilson0]

The psycokennetic activity is off the scale!

[@ptort]

I love that you guys take this so "seriously". Some of the best satire around!

[@RaynardWilson0]

Mark provides us with endless hours of entertainment.

[@jonwhall883]

Loving your work Mr Wilson. Thank you

[@RaynardWilson0]

Thank you for your kind words

[@thetryingscotsman4065]

Would this not be killing animals and insects if it was weaponized? Birds falling from the skies, 10s of thousands of insects lying everywhere, dead cats, cattle all over the place.

[@RaynardWilson0]

Have you seen the video when Andy Osborne blames the death of a bee on 5G

[@matteotomaso7204]

This one was great and informative. Thank your guests for us.

[@chrisstreet6827]

It was a pleasure taking part and glad you found it interesting.

[@diverdannavyvet9672]

I recently watched a Court case where a deadbeat squatter claimed she couldn't find a new place to live because she's 'allergic' to WiFi.🤣😝

[@RaynardWilson0]

Brilliant. Mark Steele should try that one.

[@vandammesque]

Hope it panned out like the Bette Call Saul episode!

[@martinbaxter4783]

🤣🤣🤣🤣💀

[@tzvikrasner6073]

I can't recall if that was Judge Simpson or Judge Middleton, but OldSquishyGardner and Law Talk With Mike both had that one.

[@scragar]

There's a lot of people that claim that, but of course none of them can tell if a wifi router is on or not if you disable the LED. Even more fun in one study from a few years ago they made the LEDs independent of the router, showed they could turn the router on/off from another room(actually just the LED), then asked them to describe their symptoms every 15 minutes while in the room where they turned the LED on/off every so often while they were all randomly assigned the wifi on/off for the entire time. Turns out not a aingle person they tested was consistent to the wifi state, they were at best reporting sysptoms when the LED was on and not when it was off, even though the wifi was consistently one state through their entire time.

[@ShotAndLeft]

Thank you, guys. I have learned a great deal from this. Cheers.

[@RaynardWilson0]

Every day a school day

[@KillerInc]

Ahhh yes Steele is using a image modified from a paper called "Mortality by neoplasia and cellular telephone base stations in the Belo Horizonte municipality, Minas Gerais state, Brazil" Fig 15. on page 15. from 2011. Which doesn't seem to factor in other effects of dense population or other environmental factors.

[@RaynardWilson0]

How did you figure that out?

[@KillerInc]

@@RaynardWilson0 I have no life and I googled the words on the graph... started trolling through anti-cell tower propaganda sites and landed on a PDF of that paper read through it found the graph. Notice someone did some checky edits... thought others and you might want to read it over to see if "Mr Steele" is dumber than he looks. I have a copy if you need it.

[@KillerInc]

​@@RaynardWilson0 I have no life and I googled the words on the graph... started trolling through anti-cell tower propaganda sites and landed on a PDF of that paper read through it found the graph. Notice someone did some checky edits... thought others might want read it over to see if "mr steele" is dumber than he looks.

[@fredygump5578]

Once I was doing environmental testing on a gas station....at night....and some guy was like, "Is that for the 5g?". Yes, it is if you want to think so.

[@RaynardWilson0]

It's all 5G... if you want it to be

[@mickeyfilmer5551]

Marks machine is called the "Juanercometer" it measures th Juanker of the operater *mexican pronunciatition works best* it measures the Juanker of the operator, and Mark is a massive Juan Ker

[@robbarton7972]

Chris raised a relevant point about RF exposure and the inverse square law that Mark prattles on about. It is not the tower you should be worried about it the phone you hold to your head. More towers and more antenna gain in the tower antennas allows your phone to use less RF power.

[@RaynardWilson0]

True dat!

[@brentwalker8596]

Are Mark Steele's glasses shielding him from dangerous radiation?

[@RaynardWilson0]

Yes, sunlight

[@TheZombieSaints]

Wow! I didn't know beam-forming was such an old tech!?🤯 I only thought it was a recent invention for wifi... Well I like to learn something new each day. Sweet, thanks guys.

[@RaynardWilson0]

Every day is a school day with Mind of Steele

[@chrisstreet6827]

TV antennas are beam forming in reverse as it were - Yagi-Uda is the proper name for them and they have been round a very long time.

[@cambridgemart2075]

​ The technology now is active beam forming / beam steering works, it uses a large number of phase controllable antennae and the phase shift is changed to steer the beam. They have been in use for satcoms and radar for over 40 years. Chris was mixing up this with high gain fixed direction antennae, AKA Yagi antennae

[@MichaelPiz]

I was making breakfast while watching but I'd lost my appetite by the time the food was ready so I tossed it all in the trash. Thanks, Mark, for making me waste food.

[@MichaelPiz]

P.S. The control group for those findings shown early in the video was Wales. Just Wales.

[@scragar]

I don't think Mark understands the figures he shows. He claims 0.25% of the population under 100m with die, but my work's HQ has one on the roof, and there's over 900 people working there full time. By his metric 2 people should be dead from tumours caused by exposure, and a lot more seriously ill. You'd think that'd be big news in the company, the last time someone was hospitalised(car accident) we had a get well soon card circulated and managers were told to allow people time off work if they wanted to visit them. It's so weird that no one has heard anything about these serious health issues before in a health software company. I guess it muat just be a big coverup, certainly couldn't just be the case that he's lying.

[@RaynardWilson0]

That's proof of a cover up, right?

[@MartinJames389]

Ah ... the Emley Moor mast! All the best places in England have at least a glimpse of it. Just England, mind. Scotland has many more such foci, starting with the Erskine Bridge.

[@RaynardWilson0]

I grew up in Helensborough, so that was always the best way to cross the Firth of Clyde.

[@arthurbrotleibe1528]

The magical distance Mark talks about for 4G, would require a near field power of about a Megawatt to have a far field power of 0.2W/m² at 30 miles away.

[@RaynardWilson0]

And that's why 5G is going to destroy our power grid. Imagine having to provide a medium sized nuclear power station for every phone mast?

[@arthurbrotleibe1528]

@@RaynardWilson0 I think if you lived within 200 meters, at that power density you could have a couple of copper plates on the end of a pole and power your appliances with the current lol

[@RaynardWilson0]

@@arthurbrotleibe1528 Oh, and hi! I've been hoping to make contact with you for some time. Would you like to guest on the next episode of Real Engineers React?

[@arthurbrotleibe1528]

@@RaynardWilson0 Hi Raynard, I DM'd you 🙂

[@RaynardWilson0]

Hey @arthurbrotleibe1528 - my email address and telegram deets are at the top of the channel page.

[@robertjackson8246]

HOW DARE these men suggest that companies should be using a high gain directed antenna!!!

[@RaynardWilson0]

I know, they fell for that trap

[@maxplanck4276]

Am I the only one slightly disappointed that expert Chris wasn't C C: Chris from New York, Westchester County?!

[@RaynardWilson0]

You are going to have to explain that joke to me sometime.

[@brentwalker8596]

Oh dear, please not CC. But it would have been insanely entertaining.

[@maxplanck4276]

@@RaynardWilson0 CC is a flat earth maniac, not "very expert" like Steele but comes unhinged quite often. [I very much appreciated your experts on this video]

[@maxplanck4276]

@brentwalker8596 🤣😂

[@RaynardWilson0]

@@maxplanck4276 I just watched Creaky's episode about him! Thanks

[@TheMeakster]

Ha, I remember trying to climb the Sutton Coldfield transmitter as a kid. Needless to say it killed me and I lost all my hair, dunno which is worse.

[@RaynardWilson0]

But you got better, right?

[@gaminggrandad5828]

Does Mark Steele also think Fixodent is cancer causing too because his dentures look like they're about to fall out haha

[@RaynardWilson0]

Alas, that might be the fault of my VFX.

[@hartmutholzgraefe]

The non-practitioning graduated electric engineer in me approves :)

[@ObserverDingue]

I love the little lights on Leigh's headphones! They look deadly 🤩 What model are they? Please do a vid on Mark's visit from the cops - they warned him about making threats online.

[@RaynardWilson0]

It's made!

[@BlueScreenOfDead]

So,,, the closer to a mast, the more screwed we are ? Than i must be a zombie !!!

[@katieheys3007]

Bwhahaha! I don't believe you at all! Stunning as always!

[@padders1068]

Thank you gentleman, for a very informative video. I've learnt a lot. 🙂😎🤓I'm a retired electrical design engineer, where my main skill set was in low voltage 12-24VDC design for vehicles (of various varieties), with a bit of Can-Bus networks thrown in. You have just obliterated the afore mentioned gentleman with true knowledge. I doubt that he could identify a hinged joint, from a certain orifice , any better than he could explain anything related to electrics, electronics or telecommunications! 🤣🤣🤣🙄🙄🙄🤦‍♀🤦‍♀🤦‍♀

[@RaynardWilson0]

Your confidence gives me strength.

[@padders1068]

@@RaynardWilson0 You're welcome! Keep up the good work, and a MASSIVE SHOUT out to all the the other contributors in this video! Much ❤ to you all

[@gregnietsky]

Stay sage folks if you afraid of technology convert your house into a Faraday cage we would prefer not to have you online

[@ianallan8005]

What’s going on with Very Very Marks face. His lips look as if they’ve been superimposed on his head. Reminds me of the way those AI videos of Trump look, but with Mark it would be Artificial Stupidity

[@RaynardWilson0]

All I can say is that he's a strange man.

[@brentwalker8596]

What regional accent is Steele using? It's quite odd.

[@ianallan8005]

@@brentwalker8596 he’s trying for posh Geordie. I hate posh Geordie. It’s all strangled and strained, and never sounds quite natural.

[@RaynardWilson0]

@@brentwalker8596 He's from the Northeast of England. That's a Newcastle upon Tyne accent. He's a Geordie.

[@cambridgemart2075]

So why hasn't Mark taken a spectrum analyser to these sites?

[@RaynardWilson0]

Mark claims that he has, but I'm sure he's lying

[@NutShellTheo]

In the world of the generally technologically ignorant, the equally ignorant man who acts like he knows more than everyone else is King!

[@Stealthmodeactivated-h8w]

MS is nothing more than a grifter,an idiot scaremongering but hey what would i know,hand on i got to fill out my icnirp paperwork for my antennas and station , 25W for foundation, 100W for intermediate and 1KW for the Advanced radio licence holders.

[@ObserverDingue]

The Steele twins (yes, there's two of them!) have been at this malarkey since 2016 when they failed to get an EU grant for their helmet business (the business failed). It's all about victimhood. 8 years of this b*llocks!

[@vallejomach6721]

The Mysterons vs Captain Scarlet The Mekon vs Dan Dare The Elekrons vs ?

[@RaynardWilson0]

Kraftwerk?

[@cambridgemart2075]

Was Mark measuring unicorn farts?

[@RaynardWilson0]

he was measuring his own power of imagination

[@mcleodclan]

May I add that just this now i’m holidaying in Wick Caithness and thanks to technology I’ve got a good 4G signal to enable me to communicate with the whole world 😊

[@martinbaxter4783]

MCToon asks how they got the baseline. IMO, they pulled on latex gloves and went… well, there are websites that describe it. Just make sure that the kids aren’t in the room. I live about 30 meters from a 5G tower, have for almost three years. I get checkups every six months. Cancer-free.

[@I-Am-Blue]

I live within 5 ft or less of a 5G enabled Wi-Fi router it both accepts an output's 5G I've been living next to this thing for the better part of the year or more now, and I've seen no ill effects in my health

[@SeidellNorbel]

What if I don't want to watch cat videos....

[@RaynardWilson0]

Otter videos

[@Lassisvulgaris]

@@RaynardWilson0 Ah, yes. Do unto otters......

[@cambridgemart2075]

So Mark also doesn't understand near field and far field effects.

[@RaynardWilson0]

Neither do I! What do you mean?

[@cambridgemart2075]

@@RaynardWilson0 It's a property of antennae with non-unity gain, the energy density in the near field has peaks and troughs, but in the far field, these are smoothed out giving uniform energy density. If you measure the field strength close to an antenna, you will get erroneous readings. The near field distance is dependent on antenna size and operating frequency.

[@diverdannavyvet9672]

Where did the chat go?

[@pjosephlthewonder5082]

That device, that looks much like the Sound Level Meter we use at work for determining is our work area is safe exposure for humans. The numbers are similar to the 'Sound level' not the dB level. Mostly an arbitrary number then a scientific number. I have, when I was working for a cell phone company measured the signal 'you can't measure' several times and as an interesting side note here If you open the Android to the ability for the SDK part of the OS there is a tool that will allow the user to see the RF signal data (RSSI and things like that) on the phone. Or at least at one time you could do this. Funny thing here the self professed 'unknown drip under pressure mark steele' (expert) has said Nothing correct at all in this little useless lie set he has produced. LOL Peace

[@RaynardWilson0]

Are you referring to Mark Steele's hand-held EMF meter?

[@MonochromaticLightsource]

Burram ah Weldah, annam very very expurt. Dorn beleeve anywun oo knaws wut theear talkin aboot. Why Aye mun.

[@RaynardWilson0]

Mark, is that you?

[@MonochromaticLightsource]

@@RaynardWilson0 Noooo! Haddaway beltas Areet Gadgie? Ahm paggered.

[@devastatZor]

Isn’t it a bit preposterous that there is not a medical or biological expert or “dabbler” on the panel?

[@RaynardWilson0]

The show is called "Real Engineers React", so the clue is in the name.

[@skysurferuk]

WTF was that interruption? Not funny, at all!🤬

[@RaynardWilson0]

Oh no! But let me share a secret with you: The show is edited so that's something that didn't really happen.