The Canoe Of Death | Dark Waters Of Crime | Real Crime

[@missmaggie2620]

After being hospitalized twice with pneumonia & the other, double pneumonia, there is no way, I would be out in a canoe, lying down or even sitting up on a cold day. You value taking care of your respiratory after a bout with pneumonia, especially if you just recovered from having pneumonia. The detectives did a superb job of finding out the truth. The videotaping of the body, covering her head & hands before bringing up her body, just listening to what they did, they really treated her so well, to be able to nail the perpetrator. Fantastic job.

[@BlueIvysAssistant]

“We’ll never know if it was his intent to kill Jan Marshall” well seeing as how he hit her in the head, possibly tranquilized her, strangled her with his bare hands, and then tied her to a stone and threw her in the lake I would say it’s a pretty safe bet.

[@Frazzled_Chameleon]

Right? How was this second-degree murder? WTF, Canada.

[@crissaconway142]

@@Frazzled_Chameleon justice in Canada is more like over speeding fine ticket. 20 years for life. Only to be released after a few months.the rest is history.

[@crissaconway142]

@Wreck and Carey 👍😅🤣

[@john1606ful]

Breanna , you have hit the nail on the head , unlike Winston , whacking that poor lady on the head

[@johnmc3862]

They meant initially.

[@stephanielynn608]

Now THIS is how police investigations SHOULD be done!! Well done and BRAVO to all Innisfil officials and responders!!!

[@kimberleeswisher3414]

I am very impressed that these Police officers and detectives were so thorough unraveling this death. Especially Photographing the victim under water before moving the body. Making sure that the video was useable before moving the body.

[@Nipa10]

Agreed

[@davidc3839]

Unlike in America where the police simply select a suspect and then frame them.

[@Bailemos888]

When you decide to leave dont argue with the person and if the person gets aggresive just calm down and reassure the person and just make your exit when its safe. DOnt ever meet alone, always bring company.

[@BrigitteGoodman]

Most women don't think the guy they sleep with could be a killer. She most probably felt safe with him despite wanting to end the relationship. Sadly he didn't drown with her, the monster.

[@wandasimmons6067]

That's what I tell my daughter,she is with another crazy.i worry about her psycho boyfriend hurting her. I've seen him firsthand unfortunately, choking her saying he could kill her so easy. Yep and she's still with him

[@wandasimmons6067]

@Wreck and Carey we live in Alabama,she thinks he's all that. But I know different

[@brandyjean7015]

When you've decided to leave; just go! Don't worry about your belongings, your exit convo, finding your next place... just go, and live to work out the details another day.

[@mercyetgracerealtors7996]

@@wandasimmons6067 whao , that's serious and bad signs. I pray your daughter gets the will power to leave him, he's not worthy of her.✌️

[@Frazzled_Chameleon]

It's too bad that he got rescued. It would've been perfect poetic justice had he drowned while trying to get rid of his murdered wife's body.

[@Nipa10]

I know people want the bad people to die. I think death is too good for them. I believe they should be tortured the rest of their days.

[@annamarielewis7078]

Karma.

[@D-Elaine.dead-eye]

Indeed...

[@brandyrichard6001]

Agreed😮

[@markguang5540]

Hello everyone....i am so glad that there are so many of you using this method to fall asleep..bcuz i thought i was the only one...I zm in Los Angeles...

[@susanlumley5547]

I do! 😴😴😴😴😴

[@K8E666]

Me too…

[@kimberleeswisher3414]

Nothing good happens at 3;30.

[@mynx6969]

Literally here in Australia 1033pm Tuesday night. I'm Trying to fall asleep 😴

[@danchinoloves7804]

From UK better than some sleep 💤 stories 😴

[@warialdasue]

I knew he’d killed her right from when he said she was lying down shivering in the boat. Why wouldn’t he have taken her home? And wouldn’t the cold water preserve her body?

[@wickedlee664]

We all did genius. It’s the subject of the film. SMH.

[@Invictus13666]

What? Are you deficient?

[@Amoni.London]

He Murdered Someone & Hardly Got Any Time... America You Can Get Life For Drugs!

[@deborahkelly1948]

If I stole a bag of tayto from the local shop Id still be doin porridge!!!

[@Invictus13666]

Thank joe Biden for crazy drug sentences.

[@TawnyC_]

Malcolm was paroled in 2006, but his parole was revoked in 2018 because he had been living with his girlfriend (of 9 years) for the past 5 years (without informing his parole officer) and also drinking alcohol, which since he'd been "under the influence" when he'd killed Jan, was a no-no. But the article I read said the parole board might let him out again👌

[@kimberleeswisher3414]

He will do it again

[@BigfootForestVancouverIsland]

He died in jail in 2019. " An inmate from the Regional Treatment Centre at Millhaven Institution has died while in the custody of Correctional Service Canada (CSC). According to CSC, Winston Malcolm, 64, died on Wednesday, Jul. 17, 2019. At the time of his death, Malcolm had been serving a sentence for second degree murder since April of 1997." from the Kingstonist news.

[@smokeeymcpott7861]

@@BigfootForestVancouverIsland YES!!!!!!

[@EssexAggiegrad2011]

Canada has a too lenient justice system

[@tymom9313]

NEVER tell significant other that you plan to leave! Just get divorced

[@urmelausdemeis4743]

I am not satisfied with the sentence at all!!!!!!!!!!!! he planned this and should rot in hell..........

[@mariewalker4010]

I'm always surprised with the Canadian judicial system he went to jail for a few years and was released if you want to commit a crime go to Canada

[@toddzehr203]

Sentencing in Canada is far too lenient.

[@karensmith6557]

It's just so sad that she lost her life. But if you are going to leave a spouse or lover have somebody with you. There are so many people who are violent. Be careful. My thoughts to her family. Rest in peace Jan.

[@algimante2097]

He got parole after 10 years, but his parole was revoked for violating the rules and he is back in prison.

[@rowenadinglasan7998]

Unbelievable,,love the dedication of these men in uniform👋

[@rullmourn1142]

He was indeed paroled after10 years.... pathetically weak justice system.

[@aireothogaba8613]

Whenever you start watching a murder case from Canada, Britain and sometimes Australia, be prepared for such sentences. They’re very good at 🖕the victims families

[@xlia2114]

10 years is enough time. Chill. Pedos only get couple years !

[@JellyBabie1984]

@@xlia2114 As a family member of a murder victim no it isn't. They take a life and convict those of us left behind to a life sentence, why exactly should they get off easy. Also your argument is pathetic, should people like that get more time yes but it has nothing to do with how much time a guy like this gets and I say that as a sexual abuse survivor. One has nothing to do with the other all they both prove is the life of victims mean little to the system.

[@Moodboard39]

25 if he makes it lol

[@molliwilson5639]

What? Unbelievable!

[@luvsyb]

Winston....was anyone in the canoe with you?!? No. Well where's Jan?!?! She left me; I haven't seen her. 🤷🏼‍♀️ Hello?!? 🤦🏼‍♀️ I mean his dumb answer was better, but.....🤔 He should have just let her leave and moved on. Winston; you suck!!!! 🤨 R.I.P. Jan 😥

[@rubyholden2343]

Now that was a proper investigation. Well executed by divers, police officers and detectives 🎉

[@missychan63]

Seriously? The patio stone that he chose to use to weigh her body down was literally pulled out of his own yard and not even replaced? The ego on this guy is unbelievable! He really thought he was going to get by with this, without even really trying to hide it. That smells to me like he's got friends in high places he was hoping would cover his arse.

[@Moodboard39]

lol

[@molliwilson5639]

Winston is not the most polished stone on the path.. LOL

[@wickedlee664]

Sherlock eh? On the case .

[@Invictus13666]

Ignorant. He panicked...plus he had enough downers on board to put a elephant to sleep. He wasn’t planning. Cripes.

[@brandyrichard6001]

​@@molliwilson5639 He thought he was, for sure.

[@daysinn3801]

I can't believe he only got ten year's! She had no way to defend herself as she drown! I pray her family has peace no matter!

[@brandyrichard6001]

Disgusting right???😢😮

[@WVgrl59]

I live on a small lake in West Virginia with no ice floes. Do we go out on the lake in the winter time? NO we do not. Even after 7:00 p.m. on a summer day it becomes a little cool and you would be freezing in the winter. If you were alive, laying in the bottom of the canoe/boat, that would be like laying on a sheet of ice. I bet she was dead laying in the bottom of the canoe.

[@natalijaasbjornsen8827]

She was unconscious. Her cause of death was drowning, they found

[@Invictus13666]

So you never swim at night in the summer? She drowned. Didn’t you watch? Are you simple?

[@kimmyfreak200]

10 years...what the hell canada

[@patmcstuff671]

Good police work, nailed it

[@molliwilson5639]

Ah.. a grisly crime show… just in time for bedtime… my lullaby…

[@annamarielewis7078]

How did he think it would look if the backpack had not slipped off? With the paving stone from his yard in it⁉️Luckily they went back to look for more evidence, and found that paving tile. It’s hardly a stone🥴 He isn’t the sharpest knife in the holder.

[@annamarielewis7078]

That was soooo stupid! He couldn’t nip down to Home Depot and buy a paving stone? Nobbb

[@nonnyvundhla4715]

He could have saved himself by accepting divorce rather than to get himself to all this trouble.

[@savantianprince]

He was probably a narcissist. They said it was a common law relationship so thatrams no marriage certificate

[@alysononoahu8702]

Victim/perp went out on lake to "practice their skills"? For 4 hours, while she's laying in the canoe....freezing? Just like Scott and Lacey Peterson. Sad.

[@karenmcneill2602]

To be killed this way...I feel so very sorry for her. She just wanted to leave. Why would you want someone to stay if they don't want to? No kids involved. I'm guessing not legally married so not necessary to obtain a divorce? He tries to kill himself?? Really though? If he felt a scrap of guilt over what he'd thought he'd done, killed her after strangling her (which BTW takes 4mins to manually strangle someone so that they are dead), he'd have thrown himself in the lake! Gutless. I'm not saying he should have thrown himself in the lake but rather highlighting his weak guilt trip. Jail is the best place for him and from all that the Police discovered well deserved. If only when the murderer is jailed it is for as long as they draw breath. Jan isn't breathing any more thanks to this selfish 'person'.

[@deborahkelly1948]

Whos to say the 'overdose' was to be pulled put of the hat to avoid murder 1?? and show a lack of premeditation?? Hes a cold blooded killer who wasnt going to let 'his' woman leave him sadly its when the woman says shes leaving, that is the most dangerous time for her ,

[@BrigitteGoodman]

How stupid must one be to not replace the patio stone? He drowned her like an unwanted kitten. He should not walk after 10 years. He might do it again. They don't change.

[@deborahkelly1948]

The sad shape left from the patio stone, I laughed cause it was such an oddity to find in the lake and when they visit his home, voila!!!

[@birdyelke775]

Kudos to the investigators, prompt of courage and abilities to detect deception from the very start, they'd saved him. it's hard to digest that the one who' one 'd choose to share our life 's with, are the same person willing to killed. in today's world sadly, even elders, parents, sibling, partners, families and friends, we 'd to be very careful of our surrounding, eat your own food, do your own drinks, watch out. and if you'd intention to leave someone, don't publicized it, just walk away.

[@Nipa10]

Good advice. Trust no one.

[@brandyrichard6001]

​@@Nipa10 Absolutely No One!!!😮😢

[@MYStories-km9em]

Always always bring other company when meeting with someone especially if it’s with someone you had bad blood with. Bring as many people as you can.

[@Dx-zo8do]

At last a new doc been waiting

[@mollymuch2808]

She’s freezing and he takes her in a boat No woman would do that

[@nonnyena4267]

So he's just canoeing back & forth _for several HOURS _*_with an unconscious person laying in the bottom of it._* I *_hafta_* ask: What would his plan if she came to?

[@thesinglemale1]

i will never understand why anyone would kill someone just because they wanted to leave them. i myself would rather be free out in the world with the option of finding someone else instead of becoming bubba's new best friend

[@valsmith2156]

The guy said that they were going to practice their skills after she recovered pneumonia? How stupid

[@Catherinzsl]

I am in awe of the divers who were able to do all this work in winter. Searching for the missing woman, finding her, filming the body, recovering that and other evidence - all in that icy cold water. 🥶

[@SAMOANSTALLION1]

Great work to find the killer Very sad she was attacked

[@linvi_chemutai]

Yaaay..Today's lullaby 😌😂😂

[@jimenasanchez7026]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/paGscnV_jJp4kLM ..

[@smilin4God]

Wait…I’m not the only one that uses real crime and old detective radio shows to fall asleep? Niiiice…

[@imeanwhoknows3974]

OMG I always thought I was the only one 💀💀💀

[@smch6416]

Haha. So strange isn't it that we put this on to go to sleep 🤣

[@linvi_chemutai]

Strange how the brain works 😂😂😂

[@junemaclachlan2705]

Oooooooh just found this site... definitely subscribing 😁😁😁

[@elizabethmenegon8057]

He even accusing her of capsizing the canoe.. 🙄🤦

[@CrueMagnon]

One of the scuba cops looks a hell of a lot like Kevin Bacon

[@wickedlee664]

There water they are diving in looks cold. Around 6 degrees.

[@Alice-ui9oy]

He knew that no one had seen the wife with him in the canoe, so he could have told police he was out there on his own, and they may not have searched the water at all. Or if they did it would have been a lot later, and he would have had a better chance of the body having decomposed and not being able to determine that she was strangled.

[@annamarielewis7078]

Even though the press can be dreadfully annoying, the very often do provide vital information.

[@fiegenfiegen]

The woman lied in the bottom of the canoe because she was cold? I have never seen a person who is cold just lying anywhere: your natural instinct is to move, and the natural position would be sitting and moving as much as you can!

[@deborahkelly1948]

I know that you can be soooo cold that youre unable to move and just able to wrap up in something, its possible but in this case its highly inplausible

[@renee1961]

Thank You!

[@annamarielewis7078]

Oh well. This is Canada, so even if he killed her, he’ll only spend fifteen minutes in prison.🤯

[@absatwell8163]

Nobody had a pocket sized cell phone in 96! SBJ!

[@stacisewell7824]

Hi everyone. So glad you are herem

[@sophienben-achour5450]

I will never understand what goes through some people’s minds… Your relationship didn’t work out: so pick yourself up and move on! What kind of a scumbag monster, instead, decides to murder his wife and dump her in a lake? Also, even during winter, I feel like for a lake that big they should have a proper motorboat on hand instead of a rowboat 🤦🏻‍♂️. Regardless, great job to the detectives and forensic scientists who closed this case 👍🏽👏🏽

[@deborahkelly1948]

If they hadnt investigated as thoroughly as they did, he would be free though in another comment hes been released on two different occasions since??

[@TS-rd7oy]

A lot of them do this.

[@backoff333]

So she's still alive when he put her into the ice cold water??? Omg 😲 😱

[@elizabethmenegon8057]

He killed her twice and got away with ten years

[@theranjithjay]

1996- Ontario - Water gives life water brings death ! A Man walking by sees a man in difficulty in a lake clinging to an overturned boat.and called police. The man was identified as Vincent Malcolm and his wife, Jan Marshall was still missing and according to Vincent, the two had gone on a boating trip and the canoe had capsized. Police were not convinced of Vincent’s story and nobody had seen Jan in the canoe with Vincent nor had seen the canoe capsizing. After many searches in the lake divers found Joan’s body at the bottom of the lake. A large patio stone was found in the dead woman’s sleeping bag at the bottom of the lake. Investigators suspected Jan could have been killed at home and later put on the lake. Autopsy found bruising on Jan’s neck and shoulders.

[@williamsanderson7971]

@ Ron jith. What was the point of your comment. Like seriously. I mean people have ears. We can hear that in the start of the video. We don't need you to make this pointless comment. Get a life. Or buy a blow up doll. You CLEARLY need attention

[@filthhater5491]

He can get out after 10 years , there is something wrong with the judicial system!

[@williamshepley3923]

Dude probably had Benzo rage.

[@alysononoahu8702]

Laying on the freezing bottom of the canoe? He's is dripping water on her everytime he switching hands...

[@srsh12345]

BEFORE TELLING HIM ABOUT THE BREAKUP --- Women need to get everything out of the apartment/house that they care about. Then perform the break up in a public location.

[@lynnecook847]

The sentence that he received was a joke same sentences weak like Australia.

[@loriepaix6391]

Parole after 10 years

[@rudolphbondefangerer5513]

Strange to be out in a canoe in the winter? ok, I often use my canoes during the winter.

[@ev500sam]

The OPP sure has handsome guys!

[@lukeosullivan6771]

I use all docs to go sleep, space docs are good too

[@annamarielewis7078]

Now that is some fun looking diving. Just not the temperature. 🥶I’m in 80 degrees F, humid weather, and watching this is giving me chills.😨

[@williamsanderson7971]

@ Annamarie. Wow seriously. You are going to make jokes on this video about how the diving while looking for the body of a women is and i quote" some fun looking diving" Wow you seriously have no sense of human compassion. All you see is the and again i quote" fun diving" Dude you need to learn what compassion is before you post more insensitive comments on other murder videos. Next time think of the family before you post something stupid like you just did. Learn to show compassion to the loved ones and family members. It is not that hard

[@kirasmalley4937]

Omg this is wild.... I grew up in innisfill I was a young child when this happened.. so sad :(

[@lindsay5348]

When someone goes to prison for life what Happens to their homes and belongings??

[@lorenadonguines6238]

It's difficult to believe that men such as Winston Marshal resort to violence toward his common law wife! If he was brave a resolve to give his wife a break and so he can move forward in his life but instead prefer to be incarcerated!!👎🥵Shame?

[@deborahkelly1948]

If he thought hed loose money or the house? Dont know Canadian law regarding co habitation and the allocation of assets on occasion of separation?

[@betty-janececile5214]

Obviously murderers don't think they will be caught, or think of what will happen if THEYRE caught. STUPID!!!!

[@kevanhubbard9673]

4c is cold and you'd expire probably in about 30 minutes assuming that your head was above water.

[@laylasamata322]

iam in mombasa Kenya and i just cant sleep with this channel, so does that makes us crazies or weird?

[@christinesimpson6529]

I worked as a security guard on a gas pipeline in Queensland another guard had been a police diver for many years I'd always wanted to get a scuba diving licence I said I was a nurse but wish I had been a police diver he just looked at me very sad and sad No you don't I apologised and said I didn't mean to insult him and didn't think through the psychological side of the job he said one job was to find a toddler in a dam, I had also seen tragic case's but divers detectives pathologist's etc get a front row seat and do such amazing work I find ridiculous centencing a major insult to them and the family it would make me feel is that all the system thinks my precious loved one is worth

[@davidc3839]

This is how to conduct an investigation into a suspicious death. In America, the police select a suspect and then bully people they know with threats of prison if they don't help frame the person.

[@jkshanahan007]

His statement is one of the most ridiculous things I've heard on these crime shows.

[@amirmurray9916]

Smh to think he only got 25 eligible for parole aftet 10 just proves how soft the Canadian justice system is..wat a fukin joke

[@Moodboard39]

Brutal. Kill cuz she leaving you lol weak minds

[@kathyjones3320]

All that fantastic work the police and scuba divers done and all he gets is 10 years absolutely disgusting justice system.

[@mohammedtalib3421]

To recover the body in huge water precisely is plausible in first place but to turn the attempt of killer husband to notify the drowning case into criminal case was very veryy difficult and incestigators with power of scientific knowledge and forensic gathered substatial strong evidence to make guilty of second degree murder and convicting the killer husband 25 yrs prison is welcome verdict...to family and all

[@aaroncross2366]

Winston is a worm.

[@Urconnect]

Just in time for my evening joint

[@danielelliott4458]

What strain of weed you smoking

[@Emiliapocalypse]

Bong rips for me 🔥🌬💨 Have a good evening

[@Urconnect]

@@Emiliapocalypse likewise

[@TheRight-handedStranger]

“The investigation team is satisfy with the sentence” but if he behaves well for 10 years he will be released… would you be satisfied about that too? After all you think he didn’t attend to kill her, just never let her have the opportunity to leave him and possibly be happy without him. He never meant to kill her just beat her and strangled and then let her slowly drawn, yes 10 years is perfect for no good husband who is afraid to be dumped, NOT let him stay in jail for the entire 25 years what he deserves.

[@lindamarsh6711]

No, I’d not be satisfied. Canada’s judicial system for murder is very pathetic, usually 7 years minimum and 15 to 25 if you misbehave. Off earlier with good behaviour. Imagine getting off with 1st degree murder and getting out in 10 years. He didn’t even have the decency to finish her off before throwing her in the lake. Maybe on purpose but that we’ll never know! Mind you he’s a drinker, he may brag eventually. 😡🤮

[@leegalen8383]

Agreed!

[@Invictus13666]

He didn’t beat her. He didn’t realize she was drowning. Good grief. Get a grip.

[@franceshaypenny8481]

Ten years, for taking a life.

[@mariartyd6029]

These titles are getting wilder with every video 😂

[@kol2han]

I googled and nothing found about the case. Any information pls.

[@legitbeans9078]

They didn’t seriously call this episode “the canoe of death” did they? 😂😂😂 That’s the most unthreatening title ever

[@ktcooki276]

Speak for yourself!!!😆 terrified me!!😆

[@williamsanderson7971]

@ Legit. Maybe they called it the canoe of death because it was. Like hello. I don't see why you think anything about this is funny. A women lost her life. Parents lost a daughter. And her family lost a sister, a cousin, a niece, and a granddaughter. And her friends lost their friend. But hey so glad that you were able to find something to laugh about. Let's hope that you never lose a family member to murder. I mean if you do. Then you will know that there is nothing funny about it

[@williamsanderson7971]

@ Legit. Seriously show just a small bit of compassion to the family and her friends at least. Like wow

[@wickedlee664]

10 years eh? Society is falling apart.

[@MsTeaRex]

It's just my opinion but I think she was almost dead when he put her in the canoe

[@jrain9085]

Then you just ignore the warter in her lungs?

[@MsTeaRex]

@@jrain9085 no she was almost dead

[@TahtahmesDiary]

@@jrain9085 That’s what they mean, she was still breathing, but barely and so she drowned.

[@kingcockroach.]

Wow. Always check the bodys actually body guys

[@amaliyadipita7749]

After talking 30 tablets of diazepam he would have slept like a log rather than preceding the rest of the crime

[@cambobby2011]

16:03 vs 19:09 Why this guy has some kind of pimple on his face's right side first and later on his face's left side?

[@simonemueller7693]

Sometimes the water can be your friend Amy episode served her because it was so cold

[@simonemueller7693]

David Politis and myself say the same thing why does everybody leave their shoes somewhere

[@molliwilson5639]

It is a strange fact - about the shoes being removed..

[@simonemueller7693]

I mentioned the two other boys and the one in Portugal there’s another one nobody no getting in court

[@DEATH-THE-GOAT]

So they water boarded the divers... 🤔

[@synthiaofulster8388]

"...sometimes domestic situations get out of hand" (blink blink)

[@edithaalcock6164]

Maybe our brain donot record lies thats why we forget what we have lied…

[@cplmpcocptcl6306]

I’m disappointed that tool was pulled from the river.. Really hope the inmates are passing him around.

[@sharyldutter9694]

Sad, this is one time we're I wish the waters would've won. In dying the same way she did would have been justice. He almost did. I'll never understand fate. But am a big believer of karma.

[@riiernest4562]

Bedtime stories 💨

[@katherinecollins4685]

Interesting

[@terrysommers7239]

the makers of this vid are very good at going into great detail on useless details to stretch out a show that could have lasted 15 minutes. YAWN