Reasons Why Sonic Adventure 1 is BETTER than Sonic Adventure 2

[@nerlam1]

SA1 is sooo good. The physics just feel so much crisper for sonic tails and knuckles. Sonic’s busted spin dash makes you really feel like sonic

[@Flare8295]

Agreed

[@TravisLee33]

@@Flare8295 100%

[@tailsprower8118]

Someone else who thinks 1 is better than 2. Yes

[@gameshock2916]

@pewdiebacon / delinquent Sonic Adventure 2 doesn't fucking suck. Sonic Adventure 2 is a really good game, it's just not as good as Sonic Adventure 1.

[@gameshock2916]

@I AM SPEED He's the only bad part of Sonic Adventure 1.

[@survive4life]

Game Shock What about Amy?

[@gameshock2916]

@@survive4life Her gameplay is alright. It's not as fast as I would like it to be, but it's still good platforming.

[@jjc4924]

I still think Adventure 2 is an decent game. Just an downgrade from Adventure 1 due to the butchered gameplay & lacklustering level designs.

[@59rlmccormack]

I think both games are awesome in their own right.... -JMM

[@livingdeadfitness1528]

Same here.

[@jjc4924]

I like Adventure 1 more. But Adventure 2 is fine as it is.

[@Anonymous.Throne]

Both games served their purpose equally & are EVEN honestly. yes, SA2 got rid of the exploration.. but SA1 never fully committed to full exploration. Nothing really important was lost since SA2 improved on a lot of things.

[@KingJames1089]

I agree 100%. I think SA1 offered a lot more than 2. I was also disappointed that SA2 didn't have adventure Fields

[@jaretco6423]

Same here.

[@Kelis98]

I think both are great

[@slwoo7432]

Also the level themes In sa1 are better since sa2 feels like they have mostly have 2 themes the desert theme and the factory theme which is tiring to look at

[@HyperS_LaunchedUpStudio]

Exactly, It feels more like an adventure with the adventure fields, and just makes the game more open.

[@sonarabit]

I am confused when people like the adventure fields a lot because I think it breaks the flow so much. And for the point of it feeling more like an adventure I am also confused about that because you don't really go anywhere and it's mostly a back and forth unlike sonic unleashed where you go on a massive globe trotting adventure. I know the Dreamcast probably could not handle that many areas but i am down right baffled that people see it as more massive than it actually is.

[@StockingRyza]

This vid sums up why I prefer SA1. However, one thing that SA2 has over SA1 is having a more streamlined story that doesn't conflict with other stories (if you prefer that) and it does have more refined game-play, but it sacrifices the open world aspect. I honestly prefer the self contained stories SA1 had unlike SA2, because it doesn't over complicate anything and that's what sonic needs to return to. Sonic's Spindash in SA1 is far better and versatile, treasure Hunting is less of a chore, Tails and Gamma are fun to play and unlike SA2 you aren't confined to the play-style the Game wants you to play. On the other hand, I can't really defend Big The Cat since his levels are bad. But I disagree with the whole Sa2 signalling the dark age. Blame Shadow The Hedgehog (The Game) or Sonic 06 for that.

[@themenacingsloth]

Both these games were dark, Shadow & '06 just made stuff darker

[@godfrey4461]

Big's levels honestly aren't that bad mechanic wise. They are bad because the game completely fails to explain how the fishing mechanic works. The second you get it you blitz his stages in like 2 mins

[@Flash-Light-Hope]

SA1 don't have a bad story it actully very good but SA2 might be have a Better story if JUST SA1 HAVE A BETTER Cutscanes the love more

[@itzderrio]

@@godfrey4461big is a garbage character , he absolutely ruins adventure 1 by just his presence alone .

[@AJ_hwd954]

Not saying Adventure 2 didn’t have hype but A1 had TONS of hype, being Sonics first 3D game,and a launch title for the Dreamcast

[@jaretco6423]

But Adventure 2 was more hype though.

[@jaysmith9933]

SA1 had way more hype for the reasons you stated. SA was seen as a symbol to usher in the return to glory for SEGA with the Dreamcast. SA2 came after SEGA had already announced its departure from home consoles so there was less hype for it back then. Maybe there was more hype for the SA2 ports to other consoles vs ports of SA1, but for the DC SA1 had more hype and sold a lot more.

[@jaretco6423]

Than how come alot of people I hear considered Adventure 2 to be the best 3D Sonic game or best Sonic game overall? If u ask me, Adventure 2 was way more hype.

[@HeartCloud]

I STILL think SA2 is better for me! This video did not change my opinion!

[@sonicplayer1142]

Same, sa2 is soo good

[@NightmareX42]

same also I got the 180 emblems a few days ago on SA2 wich I never did on SA1 because of the stupid missions and dumb levels

[@HeartCloud]

@@NightmareX42, Oh wow!!

[@venackon6969]

Me too, i honestly think sa2 was an improvment over 1 in many ways(yes, even treasure hunting and mech stages) but i still like sa1, it was my first 3d sonic game.

[@HeartCloud]

@@venackon6969, I do like the first but the second just blew me away way more!

[@mastervidxad5883]

At least the Adventure games are superior over current/modern games.

[@Isaac_E_M]

For me it depends. Like Colors and Heroes are my favourite of all time but at the same time the Adventure games are better than like Unleashed and possibly Generations. This is my opinion not facts lol.

[@Isaac_E_M]

@Daniel von Strangle I'm not sure what that's supposed to mean. Is it a joke?

[@crisp9929]

@@Isaac_E_M I think he's tryna say that the Mario avatar implies you're a big Nintendo fan, and so you like Colors (a Nintendo console exclusive) more than Generations (never came out on a Nintendo console other than a very different 3DS version)

[@Isaac_E_M]

@@crisp9929 Thank you for explaining. But it being a Nintendo exclusive has nothing to do with it. I have played both games equally and it's console has nothing to do with it. If Colors was on PC only and Generations was a Wii exclusive I'd still prefer colours.

[@trmispingus2018]

@@reddodeado301 What the fuck?

[@memesaregodly2738]

I agree with everything you said. I had a better experience with SA1 over SA2.

[@Clash_781]

Yeah as a kid I remember going ballistic on the final level in sa2

[@Clash_781]

@ELI BONHAM I know but I sucked as a kid and blamed the game but I was a kid and was too dumb to know what to do

[@jaretco6423]

Yeah. I'm on an same vote. Adventure 2 is still an solid game. But as sequel goes, it's inferior. And as it considered to be the best 3D Sonic game or best Sonic game overall, I failed to see it.

[@amogusxdlol7067]

I prefer sa2 because Amy and big were pure boring tails sonic and knuckles were mediocre and my favorite is gamma but I prefer sa2 because I can play different levels instead of playing the same one and the story goes by fast instead of going to mystic ruins 50+ times all in all I prefered sa1 butafter replaying sa1 and sa2 sonic adventure left a sour taste in my mouth.

[@amogusxdlol7067]

I feel like most sonic fans hate knuckles and rouge stages because they take more then five minutes rather than Tikal showing you where it’s at.

[@RosheenQuynh]

SA1's gameplay is by far better in terms of variety. I absolutely hate how the dark story is literally just a copy of the hero story. It's not near as bad as Heroes but it bothers me. All of the characters in SA1 were unique to them and that's awesome. Tails' gameplay mirrors Sonic's gameplay but only by a little. All other characters have different gameplay.

[@amyprobets9325]

I agree with you. I also prefer Adventure 1 to Adventure 2.

[@jjc4924]

Me too.

[@traviscunningham7062]

@@jjc4924 same with me.

[@Flare8295]

Same here

[@Flare8295]

​@@traviscunningham7062 Same also with me

[@joshstarr6400]

I don't see how a remake of SA2 wouldn't improve it though. Fixing the radar and mech controls are pretty substantial changes for the better imo.

[@jjc4924]

Yeah. I mean, I can understand remaking Adventure 1. But Adventure 2 definitely needs more improvements than Adventure 1.

[@themetalhorizon418]

Those improvements have already been made through mods for sa2

[@piggystudios6832]

Playing sonic adventure 1 while hearing this

[@SpeedMotionSamic]

I prefer SA2 over SA1. Sonic controls much better than he did in SA1, and the levels, while definitely more straightforward, are just more memorable and better to run through. I do agree that changing the radar for the treasure hunting wasn't a good idea, but I will wholeheartedly disagree that it ruins the gameplay. Knuckles control is "Yards" better than how he controlled in SA1, and his attacks are far more powerful and you can keep Knuckles moving when you attack instead of him slowing down after punching something. The levels, I feel, are also more enjoyable to explore. Yeah Mad Space is too big and the gravity gimmick hasn't aged well, but the rest are just fine. I know a lot of people say it takes too long to treasure hunt, but that's just you and your skills at the game. If you're skilled enough, you can beat the levels in like 2 min. As for the Mech Shooting levels, they're my least favorite part of the game. They're a little to stiff, and the jumping is too heavy, but the levels for the most part are designed around the gameplay style. Overall, I personally think SA2 is the better Adventure game.

[@jjc4924]

Even if Knuckles controls better in Adventure 2, it doesn't make up how horrendous the level designs are. Also, I found Adventure 1's stages way more fun & memorable than Adventure 2.

[@JeffTheBagel]

ok but like the speed stages have like no gameplay

[@oskarhasabeanie]

one of the main reasons that I like sa1 more than sa2 is because the stories are split up, it feels nice seeing what all the characters are up to. In sa2, this feeling is ruined because you constantly know every character's move

[@GamerGuyd7Aces]

Time to talk about how I really feel about the Sonic Adventure games, and why the first one is better. Please watch FULL video before commenting (If you're gonna talk about my thoughts... I already know you all will comment regardless lol) QOTD: Which Adventure game do you prefer and why?

[@59rlmccormack]

Both, because they're awesome and have good replay value..

[@edwardrobinson5470]

I prefer Sonic adventure 2 battle. My reasoning is I like all the content in the multiplayer it's really fun. Sure the radar is worse in 2 than one. I also like the gameplay nerfs. Also Chao garden being made to three. The mech stages in both I think good. I prefer Amy's gameplay in Sa2b,but I did like her gameplay in sadx anyway. She's faster in Sa2b multiplayer.

[@timemaster1016]

@GamerGuyd I agree that sonic adventure 1 is better than adventure 2.

[@tailsprower8118]

SA1 I feel more free when playing the levels in SA1 compared to SA2

[@luas2361]

Sa2 , treasure hunting . Treasure hunting. Fast thinking !

[@EA-bv8zk]

I like adventure 2 better but only because it had no hub and the speed levels world but I agree with you on tails and the treasure hunter stages being waay better in A1

[@selfishbeats]

The hub was great sa2 is so streamlined it is boring AF.

[@dreamcastdazia4753]

@@selfishbeats yeah

[@doireannlynch]

Really though Tails's and Eggman's levels are taking after Gamma from SA1, and I think they improved on those. Treasure hunting stages were also a big step up in SA2 imo but hey your opinion.

[@selfishbeats]

@ELI BONHAM no adventure, no replayability. just a bunch of levels cobbled together. I reiterate, boring AF.

[@selfishbeats]

@ELI BONHAM even sa2 stages were just okay, it was nothing more than a collection of levels. that's not that much that was interesting to me. that game sucks.

[@LucasMBoysOurRoy]

SA1 has better: -Level design -physics -story -soundtrack -knuckles and mech stages SA2 has better: -Chao garden I think we know the winner

[@ditto6533]

SA1 has a playable Big the Cat, so that immediately makes it a better game

[@codenation850]

But sa2 has chaos it wins

[@Jordan-sn4mw]

Lego Legacy sa1 had chaos

[@codenation850]

@@Jordan-sn4mw I meant chao

[@codenation850]

@@Jordan-sn4mw like chao garden.

[@Crazybark]

Glad to know I'm not the only one

[@damienvoltaire5626]

Tbh I like sa2 better because Better graphics Less glitches (Dreamcast version) Better control Better story Better soundtrack (more iconic songs such as live and learn, city escape, dr eggman theme) Multiplayer More action pack Better chao garden Tbh the treasure hunting stages were nefted but not as bad as everyone says

[@Crazybark]

@@damienvoltaire5626 dude, this is two years old. I could comment back but it's really not worth it

[@Crazybark]

@ELI BONHAM but why, out of all comments with the same premise, many much more recent than mine, would you comment here

[@Crazybark]

@ELI BONHAM not you specifically, you're just lurking, but the original commentor would have had to go so far down past many other versions of the same thing to reach here

[@Crazybark]

@ELI BONHAM I love both soundtracks

[@retrospades39]

SADX’s spin dash is the only reason I like it more, it makes me feel like I’M controlling Sonic; like I have to use my cognitive skills to find pathways with it, even though there was already a set way to do things. I never really came back to SA2B because once I finished it’s pretty epic story, I came back to play the speed stages for a few weeks after, and never came back afterwards. That’s really it in my book, gimme some freedom. P.S. Yes, I’m aware that SADX hadn’t entirely done that intentionally, but it just turned out that way, so that’s why I like it more.

[@gumi6751]

Actually theres plentt of pargs that leads me to believe its intentional. I'm lazy to explain right now (5am) but if you want to explain it just tell me and i'll do it later

[@retrospades39]

@@gumi6751 Surreeeyy- gimme dem reasoning plz-

[@gumi6751]

@@retrospades39 A lot of levels have specific places designed to skip sections (Twinkle park have a platform that allows you to skip an entire section) And some areas are filled with fixed cameras to said skips, and seeing how some sections are designed around spin dashing and jumping, it's easy to assume most of them are intentionally designed (Not all of them) Sonic 2 had a LOT of these, which shows that they tried to replicate that

[@TheRealDustinNunn]

Sonic Adventure 1 and 2 need to go through classic-style reboots. Same goes for the Dreamcast/Modern Sonic characters that appeared in SA1 and onward.

[@PJ-630]

I personally like SA2, i got used to the Mech and Treasure hunting stages and i actually quite enjoy them. But, you do have some good points on SA1.

[@WaterKirby1994]

Same, the reason for Treasure Hunting only using 1 Emerald at a time has to do with the Ranking & Hint System & because it makes the 2P Mode more fun. Treasure Hunting & Shooting Stages are quite enjoyable parts of the game that people hate just because they feel Adventure 1 did them better.

[@kristyosborne3416]

Ow the edge

[@jjc4924]

Johnny. I disagree on the Treasure Hunting stage being better in Adventure 2. If the radar system hadn't been butchered & the level designs weren't so massive to find those pieces at an time, it could've been as good as Adventure 1.

[@acousticslayer5883]

@@jjc4924 the radar system is the only thing that could be improved on. If the levels were smaller they would end in 20 seconds

[@jjc4924]

Aw man. Yeah. I'm also not an fan of the Mech Shooting gameplay.

[@NoelTFaulk]

Sa2 was meant to be better than SA1. And it is. But if you guys want to negate Amy and Big's stages so that you all can make an argument to prove that SA1 better than SA2 fine.

[@Gnidel]

If we were to compare just Sonic's/Shadow's stages, I would pick SA1. More speedrunning tactics with improvised paths, more fluid controls, no sommersault or switches killing pacing, no rails where switching them had more chance of glitching to death than working...

[@someguy3263]

@**Fancy Lighting** Why are they bad?

[@jjc4924]

I have no problem with Amy's gameplay & while I despise Big gameplay, even that's not hard to get through. Sorry. But I still prefer Adventure 1 over Adventure 2. Get over it!

[@SuperSonicWarrior93]

I love both Sonic Adventure games. But I respect your opinion.

[@طيوركالفضاء]

NO HIS OPINION SUCJ K JD DU CIC DIC

[@dsyyy9925]

Cool comment

[@jjc4924]

I like Adventure 1 more. But I can respect Adventure 2 for it's impact and still think it's an good game.

[@fausthanos08]

@@طيوركالفضاء LMAAAAAO

[@TheGOGOSFAN]

I used to like SA1 more than SA2, but I think SA2 becomes more fun to play once you learn the mechanics and how to play it. The mech shooting and treasure hunting levels improved in 90% of stuff in SA2 compared to SA1. For the speed levels for me it's a tie; in SA1 it's more focused on the open design and freedom in the controls while in SA2 the technique and spectacle is more important. SA1 is more quantity more than quality, too many gameplay styles and the only one reaching it's potential is Sonic's gameplay, while SA2 is more quality than quantity, there are just 3 gameplay styles but with more depth in their mechanics. In SA1 Sonic's gameplay aside the rest of the gameplays always felt just like test/trials to me, while in SA2 all gameplays feels fully realized.

[@jjc4924]

Yeah. I'm on the same vote. I always prefer Adventure 1 over Adventure 2 due to having better gameplay ( minus Big the Cat's ), better level designs, more fast paste, not being forced, not really have to worry about the ranking and it really feels like an classic Sonic game brought into 3D life. Now there are things that I'll give credit to Adventure 2 over Adventure 1. Liked being more polished, better animation and cutscenes, Chao Garden being memorable ( which I don't necessarily care about it ) and an multiplayer mode ( which is still the best multiplayer mode out of any Sonic game ). But as for an core game, I like Adventure 1 way more. Doesn't make Adventure 2 an bad game reminding you. It's still an decent game. But no way in hell is it the best Sonic game ever.

[@kero232]

I grew up with Adventre DX on my pc ages, but now I have a better pc and I finally played Adventure 2 just this month. And me, as a fan of Sonic, have a couple of things in my mind when playing SA2, which fit almost everything you said in the video When I was a kid and never really played Adventure 2, I always say "meh, that game lacks heart" (I was mostly referring to the music, since I haven't really played the game but I could easily go and listen to its music myself). Now, I still kinda the same. Yes, I finally manage to play A2 and appreciate it a little more But, at the end of day, the first Adventure is just better Gameplay-wise, I.. you know, Sonic and Shadow stages are the "only" good things abut Adventure 2, isn't that right?? welp, they're FEW. Only 5 for Sonic and 4 for Shadow. While they're fun, I am gonna say something here related to your "edgy/action-paced stages" point: they just rely too much in gimmicks. They aren't that open, they're just "woo im so cool im escaping the police xd!!" and stuff like that. They just feel like straight-forward levels, and damm, as I kid I loved Final Rush, cuz it was just so much riding the rails, but.... now I realize how automatic they are. And yes, as you said, rails brought that stuff: automatic But god they're FEW LEVELS. Said few levels feel automatic and there isn't a lot of nice exploration. yeah, camera changes and all that cool stuff, but it just stays there: posing cool. I hate how short Metal Harbor is. I hate how wacky Radical Highway is. I hate how confusing and short Rail Canyon is. I love White Jungle's ambient tho xd And man, their movement are pure awful. The way they jump is weird, they don't realy tunr into bals, they just do a werid air sumersault thing, which I always jokingly call it "slow motion jump", because hey, it's true, it's feels so fucking the way they jump that slow. Also, spindash reponse time is delayed, and that's awful too Treasure hunting... I actually love Adventure 2 stages, atleast compared to the Adventure 1. I love how big and huge the maps are, I love the music and overall I love the aesthetics (both Pumping Hill and Dry Lagoon are pure gorgeous). I love how there is a lot of stuff you can do there, and this is where I disagree with you. Radar sensors not cool? man, these are HUNTING levels, it's part of the challenge to work your ass to find the things you're supposed to find, and that's the fun part. Otherwise, they just feel easy, like "ok, you don't need to help that much. let me explore and find them myself god") In Adventure 1, the hunting levels just felt short to me. I loved Adventure 1 and everything, but I always wished they could be bigger. I do miss SA Knuckles's movement set tho, uppercut sucks and you can't do the lighting dash-whatever thing in A2, and that just sucks Mecha shooting... yeah, in Adventure 2, they are are shit. They just move too, TOO fucking slow it's not even fun, it's frustrating! There is not really anything good I can say about these levels I think... And now comes the major complaint (which you also mentioned): the edginess. And this is where I truly complain as the fan I am (well, classic fan). God, Sonic Adventure 2 was just the door that led to all the edgy dark anime-crap that future games follow. It wasn't the comfy mystical stories anymore, now everything was "cool" and pandered to stuff teens like. Honestly this ruined Sonic I am a person who prefers comfy stuff, and Sonic adventure 2 just isn't that. There is hype for Shadow and omg you're skateboarding through the city xddd uk police! and hype is just that: hype, a trend, a blind, fanboy reaction over something. This is what hype is, and obviously Adventure 2 was going to be "the best" since it had the very super cool Shadow, isn't that true? It's almost like DB vs DBZ lol Oh, I was forgetting to talk about Amy and Big. Well, I don't freaking care. I mean, I have no major complaints with these two. I believe that Amy, while slow, was very fun and interesting to play with, I also remember that, as I kid, I wished there were more Amy levels.... She was fine On the other hand, this is where I say a big "fuck you" to all the haters. Big's gameplay gave diversity, almost like a mini-game. I always thought that they were very cool. You can't complain about modern games being focused only in Sonic where you literally shit on Big. just fucking nope. you fucking deserve the Sonic-solo games we now have, face it. As I said, this is the part where I say "fuck you" I'm suprised you didn't talk about the open world the original adventure had lol My friend always tells me "it sucks SA2 doesn't have open levels. i haven't played it but I don't want to even bother". Something I missed while playing Adventure 2 where all those cool side quests the original one had (or was it Dx? Director Cut?? I don't know, but you know which ones I am talking about). Collecting al the emblems was so satisfactory, it wasn't just about playing the stages or chao garden, it was about exploring the hubs and doing those fun and curious little side quests, and that, people, is what I call a fun ride (pd: ok I don't remember exactly if the side quest gave you emblems. maybe I'm wrong there) Chao Garden in the sequel is just much better, not even a contest here, I think that's something we all can agree ..And yeah, Adventure 1 was about the good ol' comfy classic Sonic, on the other hand, Adventure 2 meant to pander the edgy desire of edgy teenagers, which, you know, this is about a character or franchise that was once a thing now evolving and turning into a different thing, for the sake of money xd You know there is, I don't know how to call it, a merchandise, corporative, selling choice That's how I see Adventure 2, and yeah, Adventure 2 was fine in its own and all that sutff, but I am not here to say that I like or dislike Adventure 2, that's irrelevant, I'm here to voice my thoughts in the 1 vs 2 debate pd: i don't mean to be harsh on Adventure 2, as I said, it's cool in its own way, but hey, I have to be firm

[@Archestereo]

I might be the umpteenth person to point out that you forgot the stuff I'm about to list, but just to be on the safe side: - Sonic's rolling mechanics were better in SA1 than the "somersault" in SA2; very much like the classics. - SA1 had those hub worlds, which made some things like entering the Chao Gardens less of a pain, included some extra content like the side stories you could follow by talking to the NPCs, and were generally just fun to explore and goof off in between levels. - Even if the cutscenes were repetitive, they weren't as repetitive as they were in SA2; usually they were somehow _biased_ towards the character you were currently playing as, and you kinda had to decide whose "version" of the scene was right as well as piece the bigger story together by playing all the characters.

[@NickRaeff]

As a kid, I almost lost my mind when I found Metal Sonic in Eggman’s lair in the woods in SA1

[@juliannajm3592]

I agree. While I didn't find Tails, Eggman, Rouge and Knuckles that terrible, it was still a massive downgrade from what Adventure 1 offered. Not to mention almost every story in SA1 is fun to replay while the only stages worth replaying are Sonic/Shadow in SA2. Great video!

[@kunlesanders]

I really miss watching and playing both "Sonic Adventure 1" and "Sonic Adventure 2."

[@jacobplute1655]

I like the freedom adventure 1 had over adventure 2

[@mexicansasuke5924]

One thing I hope they fix for an eventual SA1 remake, LOWER THE GOD DAMN MUSIC WHEN BOOTING UP THE GAME!

[@GamerGuyd7Aces]

MexicanSasuke lol yeah. Both Adventure games had that problem

[@SpeedyBlur2000]

Yeah sound mixing in general was a problem with both games, and somehow it got worse with Adventure 2.

[@louiepikmin3184]

It's so close between them. If adventure 2 had a hubworld and more open levels, I'd like it more. But it's about tied for me between the 2.

[@blaquelinktriforce4234]

I agree. In Sonic Adventure 1 the treasure hunting levels and shooting levels don’t overstay their welcome.

[@hadsbros]

I love both of these titles, but I agree, the 1st game is more fleshed out and has the feel of a world being brought to life. Adventure 2's final stages(Hero) are ridiculously brutal. Unless you know the game like the back of your hand, the rail physics are broken and trying to compete that final stage is so discouraging along with the 4 acts that precede it. Great vid and great explanation!

[@lunny3715]

There's always something about the original game prior to the sequel that has some things better when comparing the two. A sequel doesn't mean perfection!

[@motionproplus6346]

In movies it's usually the opposite. The second movie is 95% times is way worse than the first

[@genetax2371]

I think Heroes is better than both. It's the most underrated sonic game in my opinion.

[@Zak-bv4qm]

I love heros but the camera was a pain for me

[@genetax2371]

@xXMarklessMismanagementXx you don't even have to play the tutorial unless you pick team rose. Even then its like 4 minutes out of the whole game

[@jjc4924]

My biggest problem with Heroes is not only were the controls really bad, but the level designs better Grand Metropolis & Egg Fleet are obnoxious and most of the levels goes on for far too long. Not to mentioned playing all of the 4 Teams to unlock the final level of the game is an pain in the butt.

[@SuperSonicWarrior93]

Also, these 2 games are back when the series had a great voice cast. Especially Ryan Drummond who is STILL a way better Sonic, than Roger Craig Smith.

[@themenacingsloth]

Ryan is teen Sonic, I guess Jason would be a Sonic in his 20's, & Roger is......ugh..Grandpa Sonic......he sounds like an old man tryin' to relive his High School days now.

[@SuperSonicWarrior93]

Menace 2 'Murica THANK YOU! I've been saying that shit forever!

[@themenacingsloth]

@@SuperSonicWarrior93 Yeah, I've gotten used to everybody else.....but Roger STILL bugs the hell outta me. Also, I remember Jet's new voice being UNBEARABLE in Free Riders

[@collingravesandy7200]

So... technically Classic Sonic is like a preteen in Sonic CD? Although he has a few voice clips?

[@SuperSonicWarrior93]

Collin Gravesandy You could say that.

[@nan0smm647]

I personally like Adventure 1 better than 2, why? Becouse every gameplay style/Character/Story from adventure 1 is fun (Yeah maybe Big is an exception but his story is the shortest of them all), Adventure 2 was had Polished Sonic/Shadow physics but with a price of screwing the other game styles like Tails is now stuck in Gamma's Mech shooting gameplay (I loved Eggman's levels) or Knuckles/Rouge's radar got SCREWED by 60% and their worlds were too big + i liked how they had 7 different stories in 1 but now they stucked with just 3. The soundtrack in Adventure 2 is Amazing! And the story is perfect.

[@Robotponytron]

speaking of SA1, am I the only human in this universe that actually enjoys Big's gameplay?

[@kl5_racing251]

I agree with you. It may not be "typical styled Sonic gameplay", but that doesn't mean it's not enjoyable.

[@malcolmcowan2318]

No,NO YOU"RE NOT

[@malcolmcowan2318]

no

[@Whackywohopizzaman]

I like it but the ice level gave me trouble

[@Vi0lentThund3r]

I don't know how you enjoy that shit but, I won't judge

[@Isaac_E_M]

I definetly prefer SA. I love that there are 6 playable characters that are unique and the music and level design and when going back to play it I always enjoy SA over SA2. SA2 is still a good game but it's just not as fun to me.

[@jjc4924]

Agreed. I somewhat enjoyed Adventure 2. But it is overrated & I prefer Adventure 1 more.

[@theultimategamer95]

Favourited and agree with pretty much everything you said here. SA1 is my favourite game of all time honestly, and wouldn't have it any other way (not biased at all, pfft). You should totally do a comparison of PS2/Wii Unleashed to 360/PS3 Unleashed tho, just a thought.

[@jaybeematthewbacarro9001]

Ever since I revived my interest in Sonic, one of the first games I got was Sonic Adventure DX and I’m getting the hang of it and I love it so far. I definitely agree with most of your point but one thing we need for sure is a Chao Garden for mobile.

[@demetri2716]

Pros of Adventure 2 -No hub worlds -More extensive chao garden -All characters having unique stages custom-built for their gameplay styles instead of just throwing everyone into stages built for Sonic -Better emblem system, more missions and extra challenges to do after you beat the campaign -Rail grinding (you're tripping, the momentum-based physics are classic Sonic gameplay and Final Rush is my favorite in the whole game) -The treasure hunting is WAY improved, Knuckles/Rouge have better controls with the faster digging and drill maneuver, plus the stages again are built specifically for them, big and exploration-heavy. The only con is the radar system and while yeah it sucks that one part of it doesnt negate the rest. You can just download a mod that tracks all 3 pieces of its that bad for you -Multiplayer -The mech shooting stages don't reach their full potential in either game, but at least you're not just running through Sonic's stages again but with a gun -No Big the Cat Pros of Adventure -More fluid, faster Sonic control -Bigger, more open stages that allowed exploration -Lack of that stupid somersault thing that killed the momentum and delayed the spin dash -Tails actually being fully playable the way you want -More dynamic snowboarding course -Gamma's time limit, adding tension at least in theory since it's so generous anyway -Keeping the kart driving to one section of one stage and not a mandatory race that you have to do in 13 different ways to complete the game If you just want to plat Sonic levels Sa1 is better but if you want more of a full package from the game SA2 has a wider variety of things to offer

[@WaterKirby1994]

Agreed Completely it's unfortunate people seem to overlook this stuff. Although you forgot about the Lightdash in Adventure 1 you had to hold a spindash for it to work like Light Attack. Adventure 2 had it much more streamlined & faster to pull off.

[@jjc4924]

To be honest, Adventure 2 is overrated. Not an terrible game by all means. But it's an downgrade from Adventure 1 by 1/2.

[@ryantrusty8933]

sonic adventure 1 feels like the natural evolution of classic sonic going to 3d and I really like that

[@plushbro7797]

I want a remake of SA1 and SA2 so much....

[@jjc4924]

Me too. Especially Adventure 1. I love Adventure 1 so much. I like it more than Adventure 2. And Adventure 2 definitely needs the more improvement over the original.

[@epsilonalphaargo1948]

I've heard that the reason why Sonics' stages are far more linear in SA2 than SA1 is that one of Sonic Teams' key goals with SA2 was to get it to run consistently at 60fps. Achieving this on the Dreamcast meant that sacrifices had to be made.

[@epsilonalphaargo1948]

@Johannes Brahms You mean SA2?

[@MrGamer07100]

It’s funny you making a video about how much you realized SA1 is better over SA2 when you really break down what you find more enjoyable from each game! Because the reason people really love SA2 so much more is the character of Shadow, the level to level approach, Chao Garden, and Sonic/Shadow stages. I completely agree with you. Because SA1 even as a kid had me more floored then SA2 in most ways for the exact reasons explained in this video. Like you said, it’s the open level design, the gameplay mechanics that worked better for the characters then they did in SA2 for the most part. And a remake has the potential to make it vastly superior if they took all the great things that worked, and improved them! The biggest complaint excuse about SA1 is the hub words, and Big’s levels. I feel like SA1 is the Mario 64. I know people don’t look at SA1 as the defining resolution of Sonic, but that adds to your point about how SA1 felt like a classic Sonic era transported to 3D that’s what I always took from it! It wasn’t the first 3D Sonic game, but it was the 3D Sonic that kick off the potential for future 3D games in that vain. I love the sense of variety SA1 had too with the fulfillment of each character having there own journey, and personal scale. I love the continuity from the classic games brought to 3D. I enjoyed SA2 when it came out, but I had always had more fun with SA1 looking for all the reasons addressed in the video. SA2 had some improvements, but people looked SA2 like everything was fixed.

[@TheJadeFist]

@ 14:20 You do realize you can skip the credits by holding start and the ABXY? It'll reset the game but you're still credited for beating the story.

[@collingravesandy7200]

I know why SA1&2 are both great. Sonic's voice is awesome!

[@Flash-Light-Hope]

Yup ryan drummond is the Masterpeace Sonic voice actor

[@supernew10doh64]

I also prefer Adventure 1 to Adventure 2. Both games I don't think are anywhere near as bad as people make them out to be but one thing I have never liked but Adventure 2 does have a lot more stuff in it that I don't like then Adventure 1. I don't like crazy Gadget I don't like either of the space stages with Sonic or shadow and maybe I'm alone on this but the Final Bosses for both stories where you fight Sonic or shadow it's really fucking confusing for how you're supposed to kill them what I usually do is just kind of spam the spin dash were the homing attack and sometimes it works sometimes it doesn't. The second round bosses where you fight the other characters and they have there super moves from the multiplayer mode are also pretty bullshit at times especially when you are fighting Eggman or tails and they decide to have that giant fuck off laser that takes up so much room that is almost a guarantee that you're going to be hit by that thing and because of how much damage it does it's almost a One-Shot attack. I personally never had a problem with Amy or Big's gameplay in Sonic Adventure though I do understand why people don't like them. Also the soundtrack of Sonic Adventure 1 having a lot more variety to it hands down Beats adventure to Adventure 2 does have some pretty good songs like Pumpkin Hill City Escape live and learn and whatnot but Adventure 1 all the way especially with the adventure one version of it doesn't matter Sonic's theme. I vastly prefer that version over its Adventure 2 version

[@hankosanko]

i like sonic running style more in adventure, then in adventure 2

[@afork8265]

SA2 has better physics for Sonic than 1 and is the closest Sonic has ever been to working in 3D SA2 has a much better soundtrack SA2 has a better story SA2 has a better voice acting SA2 has only one bad stage which is Mad Space SA2 has better Knuckles physics SA2 has a much worse radar SA2 has more variety of levels I like the mech shooting in 2 more than the one in 1 combined with tails SA2 gave the birth of one of the most iconic and loved characters in the series- Shadow SA2 has a linear level design but that doesn't mean it's bad. Take a look at the other 3D Sonic games. Especially Colors, Generations and Forces. Sonic has always been linear. More open doesn't mean better. SA2 has a lot of exploration but more than 50% don't even notice it for some reason. It has multiple paths too. Most of us can say that we hate Big, Amy and Gamma's playstyles. SA2 has a better Chao garden. SA2 has a great ranking system that wants you to actually try your best to get an A rank and it awards people for their skill. SA2 has better boss and rival battles. SA2 has better cutscenes. I love both games but if i had to choose one it would be SA2. Edit: forgot to mention better abilities is 2.

[@afork8265]

Forgot to mention that I hate having characters being placed in the same locations.

[@jjc4924]

Talking about being an SA2 fanboy!

[@meatcanyonspongebob6988]

My opinion over some sonic games vs SA1 SA1 >>> SA2 SA1 >>>>>>>>> Sonic 2006 and sonic 4 part 1 SA1 >>>>> Sonic Forces SA1 >>>> SA1 Dx

[@Ron_Junkman]

I grew up playing both so I can't really say if I like one over the other as my opinion is in a rosy haze. After replaying them I feel they still hold up as good games. I also like the mech stages in SA2 so, take that for what you will.

[@connorplays6263]

Personally I love Sonic Adventure 2 more, sure the sound mixing may not be great and the radar isn't perfect but I still believe this is the better game I'm not saying Adventure one is worst thing a person I actually love both games a lot and I would even put Sonic Adventure on number two of my top 5 Sonic list why Sonic Adventure 2 is number one tied with Sonic Unleashed, also if you have trouble with finding a piece use the hint monitors, also I like the treasure hunting in Adventure 2 more because the levels are more refined the controls feel a lot better and you're ranked for your performance, also your complaint about sa-2 mech stages can apply to gamma because most of the time you're also running holding down the button releasing it to fire, and also gamma is on a time limit and about that beeping noise, yeah I haven't heard that 17000 times before, also Shadow is not edgy in this game it's possible to label him as that because he hates humans but he has an actual reason to hate them and by the end his thoughts on humans completely change and he wants to correct things even if it led to his own death, it makes Shadow a special character, but then his character was fucked up in Shadow the Hedgehog which tries to retcon sa-2 and I actually really love this story more than Adventure 1, is the game edgey?. Not compared to Shadow the Hedgehog. Does it have moments of tension yes but so did Sonic Adventure 1, while the Chao Garden was a lot of people's favorite part about Adventure 2 they didn't magically forget everything else about the game projared made the same mistake and didn't you call out projared in your mob mentality video? Also one more thing if you want to play the Dreamcast version of Sonic Adventure get the Dreamcast conversion with better sadx

[@sonicfanfirst]

Yes, I agree on almost everything you said! Sonic Adventure 2 is a lot better, there are sometimes in which I feel that Sonic adventure 1 is a bit boring, I disagree with almost everything Gamerguyd said!

[@TyDaWize]

Uh the camera in SA1 is trash (unless you mean the og dreamcast)

[@edwardrobinson5470]

Awesome video. Though I prefer adventure 2 battle over 1 because of the multiplayer and Chao garden. I respect your opinion still. Not that I hate adventure 1 though. I could never beat the big stages. Amy's story I like plus she's one of my favorite Sonic characters and I liked her gameplay in both games. Here's my other reasons.Stage select you can play any stage you want.

[@TyDaWize]

SA1: Open world= way to lose controls SA2: Linear= Tighter Speed Highway (Boost Pad spamming)

[@multimediaman5837]

I actually like the "beam" noise from the mechs 🔫🎯 *bleeeep*

[@morgboat744]

god, i could hear this comment haha

[@Sephictus]

I think you really hit the mark on why its better I always preferred 1 over 2

[@1upGaming1up]

Well I do like both Sonic Adventure 1 and Sonic Adventure 2 I like SA1 better. My best Friend favorite Video Game of all time is Sonic Adventure 2 and We got into a calm debate over why but We respected each other opinion. Going back to SA1 and SA2 I can see why now

[@skainphi]

Personally, sa2 is my favorite sonic game, sa1 is in my top 5 though.

[@dabboy6847]

the only thing I HATED in Sonic Adventure, is that I didn't know where to go most of the time in the world hub

[@palebluespeed6057]

Use Tikal's hints.

[@bennolan7040]

Please tell me you've discovered bettersadx and the dreamcast conversion mods since this video. I almost threw up when the video started

[@116merc]

I know its a small detail, but i liked the overworld from Adventure 1. I know there wasnt much to it, but it made things feel more like a world with a timeline and less like just a bunch of levels in a playlist

[@justdev8965]

Sonic 1 has the best soundtrack. I repeatedly found myself subconsciously pressing down on the d pad to make Sonic headbang to the electronic drums. Sonic Unleashed (day stages only) are pretty awesome and very under appreciated! I have no idea why people hate on forces and unleashed. Also, put a Mario Costume on Sonic Lost World and people would be like omg best Mario game ever, but because it's Sonic they say it sucks? lost world is pretty awesome.

[@SonicGamerLP]

I also like something about sonic adventure 1 that you haven’t mentioned: the Overworld you were able to explore and with all the details 😍. You had to find the stages but it was cool like that and also much story was going on there. Adventure 2 on the other side you finish a Level and then get send to the next sometimes with a story sequence in between

[@saricubra2867]

That's why i don't like Adventure 2 as much as 1, the pacing is kinda all over the place.

[@NYCKZ360]

I haven't even watched the video yet but boy is this gonna be fun to hear.

[@stevespud2707]

I respect your opinion and I see where you are coming from but I still prefer SA2 over SA1. I enjoy everything in SA2 over SA1 from the level design, gameplay styles, controls, physics, and story. I'm also not one of those people who really cares about "multiple pathways" to a goal. For me linear level design doesn't bother me as long as it's fun. Plus SA2 has far more replay value than SA1. Both are good games and they crack my top 10 Sonic games but SA2 is the better experience in my opinion.

[@jonahabenhaim1223]

SA2 did Ditch tail’s gameplay which sucks

[@Anonymous.Throne]

Jonah Abenhaim it most likely would’ve made the game more repetitive honestly.. unless they come up with some truly unique lvl design for him.

[@littleguystar]

@@jonahabenhaim1223 Tails did break SA1 a lot. Search up Windy Valley Tails Speedrun

[@harrymason5087]

I prefer non linear level design because it adds more replayability

[@traviscunningham7062]

@@harrymason5087 so I guess you prefer Mario 64, Sunshine and Odyssey over Galaxy 1&2, 3D Land and World.

[@tracyndiyob162]

wow didnt know you watched johnny's videos sweet. but yeah i am firmly in the view of this and johnny's viewpoints that the adventure games arent the magnum opus of sonic(especially story and voice acting wise they have different issues.) and they have alot of problems (2 moreso there are better games than it past and future.) and it kinda does unofficially have elements that were prevalent in the dark age(that suffer more from the problem of sega just falling apart after losing the console war and seeing what could stick, resulting in shadow the hegehog being made after a mistranslation in sonic heroes when you couldve just had eggman in the final cutscene tell shadow he was real before getting chased by the chaotix and just think of something better to do with shadow alongside 06 instead of christmas rushing it with sega repeating history with boom and basically giving up with forces.), but i would recommend them and still think there very good games(just because a game is better than another outside of a few things or overrated doesnt mean at all its horrible or should never be played, it means you give respect if they like it and be considerate with what they do like more and why they prefer another thing to it, which is something sonic fans ESPECIALLY ADVENTURE SERIES Fans need to cope with.) and i think sega should have a seperate team to work on the series styles.

[@hatty7637]

SA2 was a big part of my childhood, I use to play it a lot back then on the dreamcast, nowadays I have it for Pc same for SA1, I thought about it for awhile and after watching this video, I like SA1 more at least for Sonic Tails and Knuckles, the more I play SA2 the more I start to see why somethings in it are not that good, so to be honest I enjoyed playing SA1 more than SA2. I still love both games to this day, and I would love to see a remake for both games, at least for SA1.

[@jjc4924]

Agreed.

[@indiexcorex2]

Probably people are still going to attack this video anyways

[@SuperSonicWarrior93]

Indiexcorex2 Cause they don't know how to respect opinions. They fail to realize that it's not that deep.

[@MechaKnuckles]

I agree with the base subject, but a few things bugged me. 1. The Dreamcast version of Sonic Adventure looks WAY better than any other port. 2. Mania is not what I would consider the second best Sonic game. Both Adventure games would top that and Colors. But those are just my opinions.

[@Jordan-sn4mw]

I agree. In the GameCube port they look kinda like plastic. I mean mania was one of the best 2d games tho.

[@MechaKnuckles]

@@Jordan-sn4mw Yes. Also yes, but not the second best Sonic game.

[@ThePastAnalysis]

I can concede that Sonic's levels were better in SA1 over SA2, not by much, but still it's something. Besides that though, I do not think that SA1 tops SA2. SA2 improved just about everything for me. I'll prefer SA2's world map to SA1's hub world any day as most of the time that hub world was just needless padding with a bland aesthetic. I understand the general complaints with the mech stages, but i honestly prefer the slower pace which requires skill to mow down dozens of enemies. Gamma's stages were too easy and the high speeds didn't compliment his shooting in my opinion. I also liked the treasure hunting more as the levels were bigger, the controls were better, there was a ranking system, and the radar system allowed me to better focus in on one gem. I know the radar is often a point of criticism, but for me I accidentally would get distracted by a new beeping gem as I was looking for the first one. It made it annoying to play. Those are the main reasons I prefer SA2 to SA1. There's more reasons but they're pretty obvious.

[@jjc4924]

I disagree. Adventure 2 is an downgrade from Adventure 1. Adventure 1 has an simplistic story, better gameplay ( Minus Big ), better level designs thanks to it's open wide exploration while still being linear, better soundtrack, played any character through there own story instead of being in one group & I had alot of tolerable time with Adventure 1 than I have with Adventure 2. The only thing Adventure 2 does better than Adventure 1 is the Chao Garden; which I don't give an crap about it anyway, & an better Multiplayer mode. But as an whole core of the game, I think Adventure 1 is better than Adventure 2.

[@slainredd4339]

I disagree after just replaying both games. SA1 doesn’t flow as well as SA2. There’s too many repetitive bosses and cutscenes as well as having so much filler. Tails, Amy, and Big was such a chore to play through. I much prefer the story, Chao garden, stages, and music of SA2 not to mention how polished it feels compared to SA1. Back when I was a kid I used to have a blast playing the multiplayer modes.

[@kingofthe_humanz8285]

i think sonic controls SOOOOOO much better in SA1 because the spindash comes out as soon as i press the button. the somersault could have been mapped to another button because the akward pause before the spindash urks me. i think gamma and eggman's levels are great, but tails' mech levels suck. we all know the emerald searching in SA1 was better

[@akurio64]

I prefer Sonic Adventure 1 too. Physics were better, there was more content even tho it was unbalanced, the level design is way superior than SA2, and notice how in Sonic Adventure 2, chances are that you hate half of the levels because of how frustrating they are.

[@gabrielbarblay8120]

-people: omg, sonic levels need more exploration, exploration is so cool -Also people: ew, knuckles levels boring

[@drigo1160]

Sorry but i love all my sonic games they are masterpieces

[@ADjustinG2013]

finally some overdue love for SA1

[@somerandofromoregon]

It's more likely than you think.

[@frnameisstripes6840]

If I was to rank these games: Gameplay:both Story:SA2 Boss fights:SA1 Graphics:SA1

[@paulbell3682]

I don't understand why you think that SA1 looks better when SA2 has better models, better textures, runs at a hard-locked 60fps & has better overall aesthetics.

[@Ja.abbatta_V]

I like Sonic Heroes!

[@PaperMarioParty08]

SA1 is a thousand times better than SA2. I wanted to like SA2 but it's just garbage. The only aspects I can think of that are better than SA1 in this game are: 1. Story and cutscenes Oh... yeah this pretty much it... SA2 reeks. Admittedly, I haven't finished this game and I'm not even done with the Hero story but the mech shooting stages literally ruin the game for me. They're slow, boring, VERY repetitive, and EXTREMELY frustrating to get through. After playing SA1 and really liking it, I was excited to play SA2, one of the most beloved Sonic games of all time... This game is just disappointing on so many levels. Everything is a downgrade from SA1. Even the speed stages!

[@UncleJB]

Sonic Adventure 1 is a treat I recently played both games back to back and hot dam do I REALLY not like SA2. In 2, the gameplay for anyone whos not Sonic just straight up sucks. The levels are boring and forgetable. And the controls feel way too jank compared to the first game. Playing SA2 was such a chore and I straight up do not like that game.

[@IsaacBCh]

SA2

[@andreasmeelie1889]

OH MY GOSH You LITERALLY said EVERYTHING on why I LOVE Sonic Adventure DX WAY BETTER than Sonic Adventure 2: Battle! Now I LOVE Sonic Adventure 2: Battle for it is my second favorite Sonic game but Sonic Adventure DX is my main favorite Sonic game and to be honest I was nine when I first played Sonic Adventure 2: Battle and I back then I didn't really understand the Master Emerald stages so I only was able to play the first full level with Sonic and Eggman on Hero and Dark Story Mode so my friends, my younger brother, Ryan, whom loved rent the game and I only played the multiplayer mode. I loved the game but honestly felt like Ryan was more into it. Then I discovered Sonic Adventure DX as a New Release when I had just turned ten and talked Ryan into renting it to be a good big sister and get him into being a number one fan of the franchise thanks to me whether I so liked it or not. Back then I could care really less about anything that Ryan rented yet Sonic Adventure DX hooked me instantly so much that Ryan didn't even have to beg me to play with him for I WANTED to play it and even played it on my own. I was a casual fan of Sonic in the 90's but it was Sonic Adventure DX that began my lifelong obsession for Sonic. So yeah my plan backfired and I became Sonic's number one fan instead. Lol, Sonic is my favorite and is my hero! EEP! :) I got Sonic Adventure DX to own a month before getting Sonic Adventure 2: Battle and once I finally understood from my best friend, Ashley, and my friends at school what to do with the Master Emerald levels. I was able to progress through the game and began really loving it a whole lot more than I did so before and really began loving Shadow a lot more than I previously thought I would. Yet, I always loved Sonic Adventure DX more and could never understand why people loved Sonic Adventure 2: Battle more. I loved the hub worlds in Sonic Adventure DX and while I do admit The Chao Garden is much better in Sonic Adventure 2: Battle I always loved the locations a whole lot better in Sonic Adventure DX and the races. I even loved how opened the levels were in Sonic Adventure DX while the levels in Sonic Adventure 2: Battle while a blast to play I always found weren't as good as the original's. If anyone saw my top ten list of favorite Sonic stages a whole lot of Sonic Adventure DX stages would be there my main favorite being the Ice Cap! I LOVE snowboarding down that hill getting away from that avalanche as Sonic and Tails mainly Sonic! EEP! :) Lol, Not to mention, but, Sonic Adventure DX had me choose whatever character that I wanted to play as and had a whole lot more stages of me playing as my hero Sonic! What more could I ask for seriously?! :) I'm SUPER GLAD to see that other people agree with me over Sonic Adventure DX being far better than Sonic Adventure 2: Battle for my unpopular opinion is that I find it far better than its sequel and I'm SUPER GLAD to see that I'm not alone. :)

[@alexsartandgameschannel3883]

Why SA1 Is better... *Spin-Dash Spam Intensifies*

[@nowell6984]

Quick question is your whole channel about sonic I find your take interesting.

[@RobotnikUnit]

Honestly I can't agree. I can understand why you like SA1 better due to the classic feel and Tails but as an entire package SA2 just works better, cuz unless we're talking about Knuckles, the openess in SA1 was barely worth the trouble of making. Both games are monumental tho.

[@MrAppleSalad]

i completely agree

[@nancydaniels8572]

Both are the two best sonic games ever but sa2 is just better tbh.

[@jjc4924]

I disagree. SA1 is still better.

[@MeowyMakes]

I beat SA1 and I LOVED it. I'm only a few levels into SA2 and I already wanna throw my controller against the wall.

[@malcolmcowan2318]

same here

[@Back2TheOldDrawingBoard]

Amen! The Sonic levels are roughly on par with each other but the other characters are way better in Adventure 1 (besides Big) and they don’t overstay their welcome. Also I think the pacing is way better when you can stay with one play style for a whole story rather than switching all the time.

[@andersonsansonowski5644]

sa1 and sa2 are different from each other for example: the speed stages in sa1 are about being classic sonic in 3d but sa2 was about dominating and memorizing the stage for the A rank,the mech stages in sa1 are about shooting enemies to gain time while sa2 is about the memorisation of enemy placements and th risk -reward of combo for an A rank, and the treasure hunting in sa1 is about being just like sonic with a different obbjective,and while sa2 is about mastering the control to move fast and memorise the level design find the shards fast . Any extra comments are : shadow is not edgy in sa2 and i think tails and amy are fun.

[@ev3rst0rm-g1g]

Now I find both adventure games to be very flawed with their alternate play styles but ALL OF THEM ARE BETTER THAN THE WEREHOG

[@sonicplayer1142]

Facts

[@livingdeadfitness1528]

How is tails following Amy in Sonic Adventure? I played it recently on 360 version & don't know how to do that.

[@GamerGuyd7Aces]

That's not part of the original game. It's a mod

[@livingdeadfitness1528]

@@GamerGuyd7Aces I had a feeling lol

[@justinmartin8543]

I like sonic adventure because you can explore a lot more

[@premydaremy]

Did you really have to use purple border gameplay

[@GamerGuyd7Aces]

SADX my dude.. it's like that on the PS3