Rebuilt or Scrapped (A Henry the Green Engine topic) (Two Henrys Theory) (Re-edited)

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

Discord for those who are interested: discord.gg/UwUsSpRrc6

[@An_Sudrian_LBSCR_Mogul]

Your Henry's theory really inspired me in your previous video, on how his reconstruction could have occurred. Damn bro, my sister's birthday is today.

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

Oh happy birthday to her then

[@jordaneriksson5417]

Happy Birthday to your sister

[@wyattm6782]

I Think Your Reasons Are Valid. I put the wall theme wile He Was Getting Rebuild. TheTramBand (I think that's the name) Extended It 6 Years Ago. I Don't Think Henry Wasn't Scrapped.

[@MCstudio1274]

My headcanon is that when Henry was rebuilt, instead of being completely rebuilt as as a Black Five, he simply had the parts of a black five (namely the Boiler, Firebox, and Tender) integrated into his Gresley inspired design. He basically looks like that one photoshop done by the Unlucky Tug’s Thomas Debunked short on Henry’s Rebuild.

[@yoniazrad5752]

As a matter fact, I don’t even believe there were two Henry’s all because of the personality and memories that Henry has after his rebuild makes me think there is only one Henry I like to let you know the black 5s has their metal wheel a bit away from the back driving wheels and closer to the front driving wheels which that makes me think even if Henry was 4-6-2 they could probably just modify the driving chassis even removing the back trolling wheels not to mention Henry was meant to be expensive what if Topham had got the idea for the Workmans in crew selling some of Henry’s parts that weren’t supposed to stay before rebuilding him

[@RobtheD41Loco]

I can imagine Henry 1. Who I see as a C1 or a C4 getting replaced by Henry 2 Also, I like that Gordon's a Raven A2

[@Saby-yl7yx]

I believe that Henry was given a rebuild because Sir Topham Hatt the first send away to crew on the LMS he given a new shape new boiler and a firebox a new cab and new Falerd tender

[@mightymolly8783]

Like a part of me stayed behind save Henry’s face and switch to black 5😂

[@tiagosimoes1994]

that a lot to take in, but, they propably remove henry from his old shape and put in to a black 5

[@railfandepotproductions]

3:53 *construction process

[@Allosaurus-Productions]

I know this is kind of crazy like a part of me left behind they saved Henry’s face and slapped on a black five

[@RavenandCandleDude]

My take on Henry is an LBSCR H2 and later rebuilt into a Black 5 The only LNER Atlantic i see Henry as is an LNER C5

[@An_Sudrian_LBSCR_Mogul]

From LB&SCR to LMS, fascinating

[@megariderfire1994]

Ah yes, the "Three Strikes Formula" for Awdry. XD - One. (William Middleton) - Two! (A.R Payne) - THREE! (Reginald Payne) YOU'RE OUT! (Awdry's "Alright! That's it!" moment that lead to him initially wanted to write Henry out of the series...only to eventually rework into into a character he can utilize and actually became a character that really grew on him over time.)

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

the three strikes of the Reverend Wilbert Awdry

[@tiagosimoes1994]

since his old body was badly dameged and beyond repair

[@ReviCat]

I don't know what to say about this but I can highly confirmed yes he was rebuilt he got an overhaul of a new tank and boiler + a tender water budge rebuilt because if he was dead his new counterpart would be built in 1940 when the second world War had its first birthday, but then Henry was built in 1919 so Henry is actually 105 years old, so yeah I'm not preparing a giant three paragraphs this video since this theory is actually very dumb not to be rude, it was just an overhaul and he was wiped out when he was being taken to the works and rebuilt an overhaul. As the TTTE wiki says "Before his rebuild, Henry is a freelance design, combining aspects of the Black Five shape and his original shape in The Railway Series, as budgetary constraints prevented the crew from constructing two separate models for him. Changes made to Henry's model for his old shape include a tapered firebox, inside steam pipes and the topfeed being removed. Additionally, Henry originally lost his splashers following his rebuild, however these were later added back in the second series. Contrary to how his old shape was portrayed in The Railway Series, Henry does not have a sloped running board and is depicted as having always been a 4-6-0, while in the books he was originally a 4-6-2." and yes Henry is a former LNER owned engine that was an A1 and another LNER class hybrid but then got rebuilt into a Black Five.

[@SodorExpressProductions]

Well this is a strangely better then the other one

[@timothythetankenginesfunen1075]

Narrow Gauge came up with a way for the Henrys theory to work while making sure the same Henry's story wasn't ruined. Here's a link to find out how he did it: docs.google.com/document/d/18x7cfBtictygFQ0qLKwGmMNZJLq8qZPS2WdTTB8tSjA/edit

[@thecaledonianthegreat]

actually the builders put henrys boiler on to the stanier 5

[@thecaledonianthegreat]

so now he wasnt scrapped

[@jasonallen6918]

I hate the idea of their being two Henrys because it undermines his character arc and would defeat the purpose of his own story.

[@gfuelmonster5415]

Well I don’t think I believe this theory of the two Henry’s theory my only believe that he was rebuilt into a stained black 5 like remove the parts of gner pacific and liner a1 pacific like giving him new parts form the stainer black 5 like removing the steaming problems like a mixed into two firebox’s I believe they remove it to replace a larger firebox form the stainer black 5s

[@SparklingJam]

Where did u get the old shape Henry model for blue train with friends

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

@@SparklingJam this was before it shut down, then reopened. otherwise back then there was a mission where you had to find two pieces of a plan for old shape Henry. One behind the S7 knapford shed and another behind the stationmasters house at tidmouth. Sadly that mission is not longer in BTWF.

[@SparklingJam]

@@ScorchZaneTrains well what about the others? Like the other engines or RWS accurate characters

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

@@SparklingJam can’t say, they were all removed when BTWF started to update more and more

[@SparklingJam]

@@ScorchZaneTrains damn Still good videos

[@olivergould3878]

Is it true James is a Class 28 with a Fowler tender? I only ask because i am from Huddersfield were they served and we eventually scrapped one of them also one 15 miles down the rails at Mirfield was scrapped aswell sadly. They were designed by George Hughes in 1910 they also had poor build quality's tho non survive

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

according to the IOS Book and offical canon yes here’s the link to it: drive.google.com/file/d/1Z1R1eWWX2-iwRTVxmuyYj5ebrgzE9KCs/view

[@An_Sudrian_LBSCR_Mogul]

@@ScorchZaneTrains I wonder how some characters in the books get Fowler Tenders before they are even built.

[@olivergould3878]

@@ScorchZaneTrains thank you just read it thank you so much

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

@@An_Sudrian_LBSCR_Mogul sometimes I wonder that as well, which is why I often disregard the Fowler tender idea

[@SMG48796]

Request: the ideal Alled greedy

[@An_Sudrian_LBSCR_Mogul]

He is just a fan interpretation, he is not canon

[@SMG48796]

@@An_Sudrian_LBSCR_Mogul okay how about ideal Emily

[@olivergould3878]

Sorry to be a pain just wondering would Henry undergoing a rebuild be painful?

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

I don’t think so since he would miles not be awake

[@olivergould3878]

@@ScorchZaneTrains So would he have something like green water like Victor Tanzig would add before undergoing the rebuild?

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

@@olivergould3878 Awdry never elaborated, as for the green water that’s solely Victor Tanzig’s solution. Though it likely something similar was implied

[@olivergould3878]

@@ScorchZaneTrains Thanks

[@chavopatyfanstudios2005]

Why do people potray his old shape as a 4-6-2

[@An_Sudrian_LBSCR_Mogul]

The fact that the A1 1915 Draft has a 4-6-2 wheel configuration, but in the books we see that Henry is 4-6-0, is confusing

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

is probably due to the fact since he’s a stolen Grelsey design built in 1919 it makes sense for people to think he’s from the 1915 draft, since it was never out into use.

[@xavierjuno4572]

​@@An_Sudrian_LBSCR_Mogulhonestly for as good as an artist as Dalby was, he really just did not care for detail for some reason, even when Awdry provided him reference material to work with

[@xavierjuno4572]

@@ScorchZaneTrains honestly that is a reasonable assumption to make

[@dylanlyles9453]

I find the whole theory of Henry being scrapped and replaced is stupid!

[@dylanlyles9453]

@@ScorchZaneTrains I wasn't talking about Percy or the W&S engines.

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

Oh whoops wrong comment sorry about that.

[@dylanlyles9453]

@@ScorchZaneTrains That's alright.