Red Dead Redemption - Jack Marston kills Edgar Ross and avenges his Father

Jack Marston kills Edgar Ross and revenges his Father. The true ending of Red Dead Redemption 1.
All RED DEAD REDEMPTION 1-2 videos: • RED DEAD REDEMPTION 1-2
SUBSCRIBE TO THE CHANNEL: / extremegaminghd3d

[@klephenthurry3284]

Arthur Morgan: Revenge is a FOOLS game! John Marston: **Gets revenge for Arthur** Jack Marston: **Gets revenge for John** Arthur: 🤦‍♂️

[@saturnzdiplomat4794]

It’s canon that jack becomes a writer and is very successful so Arthur would actually be quite happy

[@willie9351]

Jack got Vengeance, as Micah deserved what he got

[@JRSRLN]

I mean, he was an angry teenager... all them hormones looking for vengeance.

[@thepredatorgamer8553]

@Travis Livengood in gta V , you can notice in a house a book and the author is J.Marston. So it is canon ( it’s an Easter egg)

[@toxpov3612]

@@thepredatorgamer8553 that would be a very interesting book.

[@bobross9370]

It's weird to think LA Noire is set 30 years after the ending of RDR1, Jack would only be around 45, kinda weird to think that he is still alive during that time.

[@michaelamail4407]

And how different times were!!

[@lMarco16]

@@michaelamail4407 Just imagine, Jack being part of the US in WWI and WW2. And watched Friday the 13th.

[@morgan0__o]

If he grows old enough, he can see how shitty humans became, but how technology developed

[@isiahmaliklevantezimmerman6570]

@@morgan0__o Humans were always shit

[@isiahmaliklevantezimmerman6570]

@Turok Hilsen I don't see the connection at all.

[@guccimalcs]

Jack is the last known survivor of the gang. To me, he’s the true victim of this story. He was born into a life he didn’t ask for, and he had to end the problems Dutch started. And then what is he left with after he kills Ross and looks at his revolver? Nothing. He’s left with nothing. Jack’s life is a true tragedy.

[@RRai2000]

Expect he wrote a book called Red Dead Redemption

[@volandblack666]

@@RRai2000 except it’s not canon

[@RRai2000]

@@volandblack666 Don't care

[@Xx_LowNSlow_xX1]

Tilly, Mary Beth, Jack, Charles, Sadie, Pearson, Trelawny, Swanson

[@Linkfan450]

I just hope the easter egg in GTAV is actually canon. Cause if it is that would mean he eventually found peace in his life and became a writer.

[@gamemaster613]

Imagine finding out your spouse is dead just after telling a stranger where they were.

[@thomasel9171]

Ultimate revenge

[@immrcontagious9096]

Haha boi

[@django8875]

Big F

[@king__T]

@@matteo-nf1kv Good Fucking Job

[@spartansolja2045]

@@matteo-nf1kv I'm weak I'm literally talkin to her rn I've already made up my mind I was killin her too lol I've beat the game b4 but decided to do another playthrough and killin edgar Ross was something I didn't know about b4 til I was watching a jack marston story on KZbin

[@Crow__007]

Jack wore his father’s hat to kill Ross, John wore Arthur’s hat to kill Micah. The cycle continues

[@mikotohimemiya4313]

Yeap

[@lewisjohnston7077]

The power of the hat.

[@shel8643]

Oh shit

[@javierescuella6737]

Edgar Ross: enjoy your fishing kid while you still can Jack Marston: enjoy your duck hunting old man while you still can

[@trax2703]

Javier what happened after I died?

[@javierescuella6737]

@@trax2703 Marston killed me Brother

[@trax2703]

Javier Escuella Oh great. You were one of my favorites, too.

[@Kira-pv4xq]

And you don’t got much time left to enjoy

[@kulelmao492]

Come here, you little greaser

[@mayoayo7107]

Fun fact: John and Abigail were buried in the exact same place they were talking in the rdr2 credits

[@denniscrimiel6977]

and where the strange man says "this is a nice spot"

[@GenGamesUniverse]

Same with Uncle. All three were buried in the same spot. Uncle was buried alongside John, then Abigail once she passed away was buried next to John and Uncle.

[@jethrotullz]

the place they married!!

[@junaoneil1202]

The last draw of the last American outlaw.

[@haki_hikari]

the last outlaw were saw in 1916 (they did the last stagecoach robbery of american history)

[@k9cobra728]

@@haki_hikari still the last draw of one of the last American outlaws

[@muskeman3422]

Not for me, I’m a low honor player

[@ddoubleg]

No 🤣

[@muskeman3422]

@@ddoubleg who r u to tell me how I play?🤦‍♂️

[@NephiTheSpaceWarrior]

4 year old Jack wanted to be a gunslinger, he becomes one. 4 year old Jack first met Ross while fishing with Arthur Morgan, meets him again while he’s duck hunting. I love R*’s writing when they go all-out with the narrative.

[@jakandratchet9930]

Yup. They even reunited at a lake, like how they first met. They first met at a lake, and they had their final confrontation at one.

[@RiceDaddy07]

I love how 5 year old Jack got revenge on him. He looks pretty old here though...like 21. Even though he's 5.

[@immrcontagious9096]

NephiTheSpaceWarrior yup

[@user-bq2ud8ij4h]

Jack is also wearing Arthur's jacket

[@joeymcm04]

@@user-bq2ud8ij4h Thank god, I thought I was the only one who noticed.

[@helmut8312]

Love how Edgar's wife just believes Jack (who literally looks like a mercenary) that he needs to deliver a letter.

[@orangutank626]

Well it was the ending of the wild west. People needed weapons to defend themselves in the crazy times. It wasnt a strange sight

[@LisaAnn777]

@@orangutank626 we still need weapons to defend ourselves, maniac outlaws haven't disappeared yet so untill they do I'm going continue packing.

[@alessandrajackson3768]

I have a funny feeling she didn’t like him very much 😅

[@karadanianoI]

@@alessandrajackson3768 i felt the same. She was avoiding eye contact, like knowing why jack was there and coming to terms with the idea of seeing her husband gone. Also the way she says her husband is a great man, makes clear that they didnt have a great relationship

[@Beezy5280]

@@orangutank626 well that’s the problem, the end of the Wild West should mean no one is carrying guns in the open anymore like normal

[@jesusolguin5896]

To think Abigail must've suffered for those years without John is painful to think about even more after RDR2

[@TypicalIndian1981]

Yeah

[@daytimeninja7888]

She died the same year as John Marston?

[@daytimeninja7888]

She died the same year as John Marston?

[@jesusolguin5896]

@@daytimeninja7888 no like 3 years later

[@suhsnow]

@@jesusolguin5896 yep, john passed away in 1911, Abigail died in 1914.

[@J99___]

Jack truly is the smartest of the gang and learned from John’s mistakes. He was the last of them and all his life has seen the chaos the cowboy life brings. He lost nearly everything to it just by being a relative, and he wasn’t going to make the same mistakes his predecessors did. Jack was patient as hell. He didn’t make a move until his mother was dead, he was a decently stable adult, and even waited for Ross to be a retired vet with no pull in government. He also left very little tracks, told nobody his name aside from Ross, and made little noise. Jack didn’t even let his temper move until it was about time to pull the trigger. Jack went in, did business, and walked out. He played the game of vengeance as smart as possible, with patience and strategy. I just hope it doesn’t bite him in the ass later, afterall “Vengeance is an idiot’s game.”

[@petermj1098]

I think John reflects Dutch’s legacy while Jack represents Dutch’s succession. Dutch was a highly educated criminal consumed by darkness, now Jack is a new highly educated criminal consumed by darkness. Ross killed Dutch’s legacy by killing John, but he didn’t kill Dutch’s succession which was Jack.

[@silversoulken]

@@petermj1098 🔥

[@stressoutspiderman]

​@@petermj1098wise word

[@user-vm7cj1qc6m]

Jack was smart probably because of them books. None of the gang did read

[@linuxtuxvolds5917]

@@user-vm7cj1qc6m a fair point. Arthur and John knew how to read and write, but smarts didn't interest them, they were more interested in gunslinging and robbing to survive. Jack was just a kid, had been through Hell as a kid growing up, and clearly didn't want to live that outlaw life after seeing what it did to everyone around them. Probably why he never become one himself and never joined a gang

[@Linkfan450]

You know Jack went about this in a really smart way. He didn't tell anyone his name, nor did he give them a fake alias. Only when he finally reached Ross did he say who he was. This is what likely lead to him actually managing to have revenge and get away with it. That's the mistake John made - he killed way too many on his path to Micah and left the perfect crumb trail essentially. Jack was a lot smarter than he let on which is impressive for the era.

[@Takaichi666-]

That’s actually interesting you said that about jack

[@speedking7224]

@@Takaichi666- I like jack a lot as a character. As I didn't do much of the side missions, challenges with john and went straight through the story. So when It came to getting 100 percent I had to do almost all of that with Jack and I bonded with him quite much. He needs a new game.

[@Czzor]

Not to mention during his time time as kid with arthur gang era hes already seen all the decay and mistakes theyve make and usually kids learn faster than most people think. And also jack reads, theres that bright side of him

[@reconscout2238]

Jack red a lot of books he was smart

[@Takaichi666-]

@@speedking7224 I hope he gets more in whatever installments that they do he’s definitely a cool character

[@milesupshur4179]

Getting to cheat ross out of 20-30 years of life after he’s only been retired a year is still a good victory. He was only 53

[@LosOjosTristes]

Life expectancy for American men in 1914 was 52, so not really. He would have keeled over soon enough.

[@juventinocasillas3023]

@@LosOjosTristesLife expectancy has mostly been skewed by high infant mortality. When you isolate that out, people are not living much longer compared to 100 years ago

[@CircusofPython]

@@LosOjosTristespeople always show they don’t understand what life expectancy actually means

[@kocek8273]

I like how jack ia carrying mementos of all the people he felt as family throughout his life he wears john's hat arthur's coat and dutch's bandana

[@glassuwassu6469]

Don't forget the Satchet

[@oj3774]

That isn't Dutch's bandana, its too light, and arthurs coat was black on the bit on the back of the neck

[@jakistyp7523]

@@oj3774 well maybe they changed it up in red dead 2

[@wednesdayaddams2550]

@@oj3774 Arthur's is like a bage or yellow

[@originaler31er67]

Jakiś typ there was no Arthur in RDR 1

[@CaioH.]

*6:39** The feeling I felt from RDR1 and RDR2 is like we were in a family. Seeing the gang slowly dying, going crazy, and Jack alone, was a sad feeling. He was a good kid who respected people, and he was smart. He got revenge but couldn't get his family back.*

[@christiancolarusso5835]

Yup everyone in the gang was dead but him if not maybe like 2 or 3 others

[@CaioH.]

@@christiancolarusso5835 Ikr.

[@LeWubWub]

Charles, Sadie, Mary-beth, Tilly, and maybe 2 or 3 others are still alive from the gang or at least not confirmed to be dead

[@hearttrash]

@@LeWubWubodds are they were probably dead from old age or smthn

[@LeWubWub]

@@hearttrash maybe not Charles, he’d be old but still alive like rains fall

[@nowaruku]

I just realized John's grave reads "Blessed are the peacemakers" which is the name of the mission where Arthur gets ambushed by the O'Drisscols, Micah even opens up the mission saying that line. Neat.

[@White_Wrath]

It's from the Bible. Jesus Christ says it during one of his lessons.

[@carjay7]

Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God. Matthew 5:9

[@stanleystove]

​@@carjay7 No one is a child of God. God is far too exalted to begget or be begotten.

[@VinEllis]

Another fun fact is the cattleman revolver is commonly called the “Colt Peacemaker”

[@LuLingqi101]

​​@@stanleystoveYou know nothing about God. Open a Bible.

[@felinusfeline5559]

That moment where Jack looks down at his gun and you know from his face that he realized what he'd just condemned himself to. The very thing John died to keep him from

[@aarondent6557]

I hear you but what John and Arthur was doing is different from what Jack just did. Jack is for the most part an innocent man who’s a rancher. Him killing Edgar Ross was bringing everything full circle. It’s not like he killed him for money. Jack did what had to be done. In cannon their isn’t any indication that he went to live a life of crime because John fought hard to make sure they had a legit way of living. Ross lied to John and killed him in cold blood even after pretty much being promised amnesty. If Jack doesn’t eventually become the one to kill Ross then their is no full redemption for John, Arthur and Dutch. If like Dutch said “their time is up” is true then that goes for filth like Edgar Ross as well. This was the only way for the cycle to stop. Ross was still working. His wife said “I’d wish they’d leave him alone” implying he’s still working from time to time. Jack did what he was born to do. Even if it was just one moment. That was HIS moment.

[@deathisSkele-ton]

@@aarondent6557 Facts.

[@micah7611]

5:33 "Your father killed himself with the life he lived." Such a cold line

[@-B-1]

the fact he sent john to get his former gang member instead of sending his pinkerton agency shows how good of an outlaw he knows john was

[@alexdinu589]

Jack: So did you ross

[@TheFunnyDictator]

​@@alexdinu589Wdym?

[@TheFunnyDictator]

​@@alexdinu589Reply, dude?

[@alexdinu589]

@@TheFunnyDictator ross lived a life of corruption and betrayl he should've known someone will come for him sooner or later

[@jonatanlarsen832]

Feelin good

[@jakandratchet9930]

Jack Marston Nicely done, Jack. Although I would’ve shot him anywhere that wasn’t the head

[@rewardunkind4541]

Jack Marston good job son me and your mom are proud of you

[@rewardunkind4541]

Carson Schultz I’m in heaven with Arthur and my wife

[@jonatanlarsen832]

@@rewardunkind4541 thanks pa

[@unexpected875]

@@rewardunkind4541 hey what about Uncle? ;(

[@JD-gh4tr]

He became the very thing his father didn’t want him to be, an outlaw.

[@leighbelk769]

TBH he probably killed him and never committed a crime again.

[@buddy4350]

@@leighbelk769 in canon terms that's most likely, because he didn't become an outlaw but actually a book writer

[@midniteryder_3-16]

@@leighbelk769& 2 b even more fair, ross was a backstabbing crook behind a federal badge…

[@criscabrera9098]

He killed his dad……he want or maybe needed to avenge him to finally be at peace I understand it’s a crime and that his dad was a criminal but still he did what he needed to do

[@lilyamaka]

nah its possible jack could’ve pursued his dream of writing books after this. there is an easter egg in gta v where you can find a book that says its written by jack marston. might just be a nod to red dead but it makes you think🤷🏻‍♀️

[@TRPDK]

Arthur sacrifice himself to gives John a better life. John hunts down Micah who was partly responsible for Arthur's death, eventually led Edgar Ross to him. John sacrifice himself to save jack, hopes he won't become an outlaw like him. Jack hunts down Edgar Ross the man who killed his farther. he is close to become an outlaw, the very life his father didn't want for him. "Revenge is a fool's game" .

[@Windowlicker545]

in GTA there is an easter egg if you look on a newspaper it turns out he became an author and he was very successful so john didn’t die for nothing

[@Vencidious]

Actually if you have low honor or go for money Micah kills Arthur

[@PolishGod1234]

Jack didn't became an outlaw. He Just wanted to get revenge on that asshole Ross-and after killing him, Jack became a Book writer.

[@RustyTheFoxxo]

Funny enough, if John didn't kill Micah, the Pinkertons wouldn't care about John. All they wanted is Dutch and the way to get to Dutch was Micah. What was the only person besides Micah that could kill Dutch? John. Tilly and Pearson are still in the country and they never cared about them because, like I said, all they wanted was Dutch, so if John didn't kill Micah, John would be safe with his family.

[@PolishGod1234]

@@RustyTheFoxxo not really, Pinkertons were already trying to Hunt down the gang members, Micah's death Just made it shorter for John to be with His family.

[@Windycityassassin3179]

6:40 Jack realizes what he has become

[@Freeman75901]

A giant square

[@constipatedparker5879]

Thus the meaning of the game title, a vicious circle.

[@v1ncebuthesjesus135]

“I’m sure your husband’s going to be just fine. Not like I’m gonna kill him or anything.”

[@ichigokurosaki9098]

Owen winky face

[@happygardevoir]

Owen-

[@hthomas98]

Anyone notice that Jack's outfit Is quite similar to Arthur's

[@samstocker6450]

Maybe it was intentional of Rockstar to make Arthur wear similar clothes.

[@noahherrera5214]

@@samstocker6450 the jackets a little different and it wouldn’t really make sense for John to have his clothes

[@lonecourierjoeyv2133]

Only the jacket looks close, but the jacket jack wears is more of a suit jacket than a leather one like arthur’s

[@UnclBerry]

Arthur's is similar to Jack's*

[@natetrivette7738]

There different but if they did do a remake of rdr1 he probably would have Arthurs jacket maybe idk

[@viniciusrodrigues8797]

Revenge Is a Fool's Game

[@uncleb6391]

Vinicius Rodrigues everyone is a fool for revenge even me

[@nyanveyan7341]

Uncle B Thought john beated you uncle...

[@sulkii9437]

Guess I'll be a fool then

[@Ch4os4ever]

Well, in GTA you find out he became an author after this and lived quite a well life, so it didnt turn out that bad

[@azazel166]

Not always. (If you notice a book in GTAV written by a J. Marston).

[@DoktrDub]

*looks at his revolver after killing Ross, he realised he is the final page in this multiple generation story, feels empty and is the lone survivor*

[@TheFunnyDictator]

Wdym? Reply!

[@DoktrDub]

@@TheFunnyDictator well that’s the impression I got when watching this.

[@KP-w4gu]

People don't forget. Nothing gets forgiven. -John Marston

[@THEPELADOMASTER]

Thanks for the huge fucking square in the middle of the screen when the title drops, arguably the best part of the scene

[@Taldorin]

Came down to say this fuck the uploader for that

[@itsshrimp91]

If you're on a phone, grab and hold a part of the screen and move it just a tiny bit and it will remove the title cards.

[@L.ysergicSD]

"Enjoy the fishing kid while you still can" * years later * Enjoy the fish

[@Carlito_Brigante93]

More like “Enjoy sleeping with the fishes” lol

[@ashfox7498]

So this is what becomes of that little 6 year old I took fishing.

[@DogGettingHaircut]

He was four

[@the-boone5161]

Jack didnt become an "outlaw" hes a good person who's just hardened to reality.

[@Kaminari_Akuma]

Jack lived over a hundred years and died from a heart attack in 1991. Even wrote a book called Red Dead, can be found in GTA V

[@imppro]

@@Kaminari_Akuma96 when he died, not 100

[@TheFunnyDictator]

​@@Kaminari_AkumaSource?

[@TheFunnyDictator]

​@@impproSource?

[@Kaminari_Akuma]

GTA V, in Franklin's new house, you can find the book@@TheFunnyDictator

[@redjack5034]

I honestly love jack and want rdr3 to be about him

[@josephscaduto9971]

Redjack Tbh, before I found out it was a prequel, I thought red dead 2 would be a sequel about him.

[@factualopinion6947]

My brother wants rdr3 to be about dutch

[@realkookiegames8762]

Factual Opinion a story on Dutch would be great as a DLC for rdr2

[@delta-bird-thing-donkeysir506]

That would be hard consider jack mostly lived on a farm and even after rdr1 he would be in a very civilized world with WW1 going on and like no outlaws left

[@TemplarsCreed]

Honestly, I stopped playing RDR the second I became Jack. You want RDR3 to be based on Jack? I REALLY REALLY REALLY hope this doesnt happen. I would not buy the next RD if Jack was the lead.

[@Waltuhwituh]

That day, Jack realised avenging his father didn't make him feel any better, it actually brought him back those bad memories of that day.

[@ArkhamCityIsGOATproveMeWrong]

"Enjoy your fishin' kid, while you still can" -Edgar Ross 1899 Be careful what you say

[@guythathatesbull462]

4:20 what a great shot. You can just feel the utter Hatred and Rage Jack is feeling in that moment.

[@CopiousDoinksLLC]

I love that Edgar Ross looks so run-down and haggard by the time Jack finds him. It's great because it really tells us two things: 1. Ross has gotten old but more importantly, he's lost his station in life. He no longer holds the authority and purpose that he once did and the society that he has ironically fought so diligently to protect and uphold his whole life has cast him off like a useless burden (which actually vindicates Dutch's beliefs that "society" is ultimately detrimental to the individual). 2. There's no honor or glory in what Jack is doing. This isn't something to be proud of - he's a young man hunting down a miserable old fart who is far past his prime and probably longing for death anyway (which vindicates Dutch's beliefs that revenge is a waste of time). ...Either way, Dutch was right.

[@covalentbond7933]

Dutch always went for revenge dafuq drugs you taking? He pursued Colm and that Italian douche for revenge

[@stressedbiryani5675]

Dutch, come with your real id

[@tuilleri]

Explain Dutch first point about society

[@xpendabull]

His wife says the Bureau keeps sending him letters, probably trying to get him back in the service. And the government agent we talk to before says he earned a chest full of medals and was honored and revered. It seems to me society didn’t turn their back on him, quite the opposite. I wonder if everything he had done weighed on Ross so much he decided to leave it all behind. Though like the outlaws he hunted, he too is stuck in the same vicious cycle of death and redemption.

[@neontaster8763]

Dutch is the Walter white of the RDR story, he was not right by any stretch

[@GaunteroDimmm]

That freeze frame at the end is one of the best endings I’ve seen to a video game. Felt like I just completed an epic western.

[@mistermoreto9562]

"Hello. My name is Jack Marston. You killed my father, prepare to die."

[@USMC49er]

0:55 Kind of wish that was Archer, Edgar's partner throughout RDR1. He was so honor bound that he refused to take part in the execution of John Marston because John paid his debts.

[@unclephil4573]

Im not afraid to admit... This game still looks fucking good!

[@johnhendrix28]

A masterpiece

[@TheFunnyDictator]

What do you mean? How so? Reply!

[@notsasuke22222]

jack: ive got a letter for edgar ross his wife/brother: ok give it to me jack:

[@howardmctroy3303]

I hope Ross enjoyed his fishing, while he still could.

[@blessedxxiii8908]

He was duck hunting

[@Black_Iron44]

@@blessedxxiii8908 close enough

[@farisfaizzal9825]

Both meet at the river tbh

[@TalibTaylor83]

If you mess with one Marston, you mess with another

[@juanzuniga2277]

I wonder if he still remembers his uncle Arthur

[@JD-gh4tr]

@Jy surrealist There wouldn’t be a RDR3 set after the events of the first game since it’s in 1914 and civilisation would’ve changed, so it wouldn’t really be a cowboy game. Unless of course if it was set before RDR2, then it wouldn’t be a bad idea.

[@keknov5555]

@@JD-gh4tr no I think red dead is done. Arthur died, John got his revenge, then he died, jack got his revenge. Plus by the time jack killed Ross ww1 was right around the corner

[@sirfishalot7569]

@@keknov5555 RDR3: John fights in ww1

[@k9cobra728]

@@sirfishalot7569 *Jack

[@k9cobra728]

@@keknov5555 I honestly would love playing as Jack fighting in ww1 in a 1917 world

[@abbuzers2145]

Red Dead Redemption 3 Jack Marston %100 Lyle Morgan %50 Story...

[@TheLastBabyMan]

And this time Rockstar learns from their mistakes and DON'T kill off the Protagonist.

[@ElSotanoDeLuisOficial]

Or maybe the formation of the Van Der Linde Gang

[@coolguymcfly4768]

@@TheLastBabyMan Actually, I think killing their protagonist is a great way to tell a story in the cases of Red Dead. I think in both cases, it was done beautifully. Perfect cinematic examples "crime doesn't pay".

[@landonricketts4309]

BenYokum Aslında it won’t be jack at all

[@6jackace]

I don't think they'll make another red dead redemption game, they may make another red dead game though, one set during the civil war would be awesome, like 40 years before red dead 2

[@MetalFox619]

"I'm sure your husband will be just fine..."

[@mitchellneuhoff9946]

How much you guys want to bet edgar’s superiors Found out that he went back on the deal they offered John and made him sit behind a desk for the rest of his career?

[@nave712]

That would be nice but I don’t believe. The government couldn’t give a rats about one of their underlings going back on a promise

[@xpendabull]

This quest solidified RDR as a masterpiece for me. I grew up watching westerns with my father and this whole game resonated with me because of it. I remember feeling so pumped to kill Ross and I audibly cheered when I won the duel. And that classic guitar when the title pops up. Chills every time. Outlaws to the end.

[@wickedishiccy7621]

Not even a one liner after ending him. I remember feeling just as empty as jack looked and probably felt as he looked at his father's gun with the same blank expression before walking away. That last hard rough guitar twang was like an explanation point on the whole story of red dead.

[@kevinfrancais27]

Edgar Ross really makes Milton look like an angel

[@flawlessxyeti4138]

Yes Milton was just doing his job Ross is just evil

[@josh.brunty]

Jack had 6 shots in him before he even hit the ground. John and Arthur taught him well.

[@divineshrek3307]

Playing red dead 2, it only makes this ending feel so much more. . .empty, Arthur and John watching Dutch's gang slowly fall apart, John being used to find and kill the survivors, only to be killed by the same people who used him, and Jack being left to avenge everyone he called family, knowing full well that it'd bring him no satisfaction or relief. All he did was condemn himself to a life his father never wanted for him.

[@KGWyzel]

Jack actually did this very intelligently. A few things to take note of: - Not once did Jack mention his name. - No one personally witnessed him kill Edgar. - He killed Edgar far from civilization, thus it will take time for anyone to find the body, if they even do. He will most likely get away with this revenge killing, as there will be very few leads to specifically tie him to the murder, and that is even assuming the authorities suspect murder, given that Edgar's body could easily float down stream or be picked off by critters, Jack would likely be long gone by the time anything of note comes up.

[@jonmcinnis1645]

I agree with what you said

[@andres20193]

And he kill him in a hunt zone, so they never can find any clue of who killed him

[@ppxoxo01]

plus he dont got a bunch of scars, scars were probs like the tatoos of the old west lol john marston was bound to be found

[@supafoxy]

@@andres20193 if anything, edgar's brother would probably be accused, as he was out with edger alone, hunting, and the last person seen with him

[@kinja9816]

Plus he waited for his mom to pass away before he made a move which was smart of jack

[@nicksalehi97]

Was i the only one that killed each member or Edgars family? No?....

[@anthonykeller1957]

I did

[@ratguy8812]

I wanted too the first time but they were so nice

[@supremeturtle1186]

They didn't do anything this is between Jack and Ross

[@volandblack666]

@@supremeturtle1186 still, revenge is a dish

[@PippyPopsSelfHarmMonica]

@@supremeturtle1186 But imagine their grief... i cant do that to them. Might as well send them all off together

[@rodneyevans3848]

I remember doing this mission. At the end with talking to his wife I put my bandana on and killed her. They took my family I took everything from him.

[@dans6046]

rodney evans really. I felt that was rather unjustified. That was like the one main thing John didn't want for Jack - and his wife didn't hurt anybody, neither did his brother. I simply killed the man and that was it, that was the revenge, killing innocent people means you're no better than him.

[@aspret315]

@@dans6046 Na this is the wild west should have hog tied her and threw her face down in a foot deep puddle with Edgar alive to watch.

[@jakandratchet9930]

Dan Sho My thoughts exactly. In fact, if you took it out on his whole family who had nothing to do with it, that could be argued to be even lower. Edgar Ross is the one who solely deserves punishment. Not his entire family.

[@WarmRepeat]

Ross took Abigail as a hostage, Ross should feel how it feels like to have your wife being taken away from you...

[@VincentK.McMahon]

I reckon Jack should’ve brought her down to the lake then shot Ross in the knees while he fucked her in all 3 holes then take the horse and stomp his brothers head in take a dump in Ross’ mouth and leave them there

[@indicahybrid974]

Just hit me now, "into The Sunset" 100g Achievement was for arthur

[@rus778]

Arthur wasn't thought of when this game came out so I'm not sure

[@mairidberz1450]

@@rus778 you dont know that. the game clearly already had backstory for the characters when it came out

[@rus778]

@@mairidberz1450 No it didn't, they wrote the backstory after the main story was created, why do you think they never went into full detail about shit like Micah and huge plot points, they wrote the story around John and his mysterious past and made up Arthur and the rest of the gang apart from Javier Bill and Dutch later

[@rundylaw6212]

It was sunrise when Arthur died though, also that's just a cowboy trope 'Riding off into the sunset'.

[@eustacethefarmer8989]

Jack: "Enjoy your fishing old man, while you still can"

[@krisskrosssss]

Red Dead Redemption 3 revolving around Jack fighting against Al Capone or maybe working in one of his branches would be sick.

[@romozaki1827]

Should be Jack fighting in World War 1, building the legend of an American gunslinger in the war to end all wars

[@magiccookies420]

I would rather it be about young Arthur, Dutch, Hosea and teenager John in the 1880s. It would be much more interesting than Jack in the 1920s. Because that would pretty much be a GTA game in the 20s. I like to think after this Jack went to fight in WW1 and became an author. I would love RDR3 maybe in five years time or so for the next Xbox generation and the PS6, as a total wild west cowboy game with age 20s Arthur Morgan. The problem is, it wouldn’t be a redemption game because they would all be young outlaws. You could call it “Red Dead Revolution” or something. I would really enjoy that as a final Red Dead game and have it be a trilogy. RDR3- Rise of the Van der Linde gang RDR2- Fall of the Van der Linde gang RDR1- End of the Van der Linde gang

[@itssonotover961]

It's amazing how you fanboys have the worst ideas possible for the next entry in the series

[@krisskrosssss]

@@itssonotover961 damn fuck me for trying to think about what Jack's future could be, which is left unknown for us to interpret as intended by the devs. You must be fun at parties.

[@ratguy8812]

@@romozaki1827 I don't think old jack would be to kind to the military after what happened to his pop

[@user-tk3mq7vs9u]

RIP . Arthur Morgan

[@anonzr5387]

I love the small detail that they first met down by a river. And they last see each other at a river

[@akeemtinsley3498]

I like when the Stranger says "This is a fine spot." Its the exact same spot John is eventually buried at the end of the game when Jack takes over.

[@cyberreact1091]

I loved how Jack was nice to the public making him think that he's a innocent cowboy until he meet Edgar 😂

[@ann2401]

I cant help but wonder..if jack lived long enough ,he would actually be alive in time of elvis presley,merlyn monroe and just in general techonolgy and all other things..and still he was living in era of cowboys and has memories of gang and how life used to be in cowboys era.Thats crazy

[@mikegallant811]

Yes that is true, he would have probably even been alive to see Neil and buzz walk on the moon, and probably a very Old Man by the time the shuttle program occurred, or at least started. His little ones would have been around to see two very unfortunate events strike our nations space program In 1986:Flight controllers looking very carefully at the situation here.... Obviously a major malfunction.... We have no downlink.... We have just received word from the flight Dynamics officer that the vehicle has exploded. In 2003: Columbia, Houston, com check... Columbia Houston UHF com check... GC, Lock the doors And of course Jack would have been alive when a certain space disaster struck in 1967,at Launch Complex 34: I've got a fire in the cockpit!.... We've got a bad fire.... Let's get out... We're burning up!!!

[@lonestarwolfentertainment7184]

There was an American Civil War Veteran who lived long enough to see the early days of the space race I think.

[@GavinTheFifer]

And that... is destiny fulfilled.

[@yorkiemute5296]

Looks like we found gavin

[@boliwijskisprzedawcakapucynek]

@@yorkiemute5296 Oh fuck, it's him I think.

[@postmanpat8166]

Nigel's been looking for you

[@GavinTheFifer]

@@postmanpat8166 damn, I’ve been found!

[@JRSRLN]

0:36 "oh great... mom's dead, too"

[@xxxslash616xxx]

Rockstar always made revenge feel really good and this is one of the best examples. Ross used John for his dirty work then betrayed and shot him like a coward. The first time I played this game this moment was so satisfying.

[@slidah1222]

"Enjoy your fishing kid, while you still can." - Ross Now he's the fish

[@samthompson7821]

the way he looks at the gun he realizes the cycle will always repeat

[@SirvivorYT]

“My name is Jack Marston. You killed my father. Prepare to die.”

[@masonm2140]

Princess bride reference

[@Elevator829]

RDR3 should be set in the 1920's with Jack working as a liquor bootlegger

[@SuperKitkat51]

I will Love Too Play As Jack And The Time Change Alot And you Will See alot of New stuff Like Cites And Slowing Turning in A New Era And He Can Do Alot Of Works For People And Alot Of Other Stuff And Becoming A Successful Writer

[@thegreatynot5049]

I think he'll end up meeting and working for the mafia. Imagine if RDR3 had tommy guns.

[@SugarSaltedFries]

Arthur told them not to get revenge. John killed micah so Ross found him. Jack silently and correctly killed Ross. But he was the only one left.

[@AustinGMRS]

Damn from getting captured by Braithwaites (if i spelled it right) and got feed a spaghetti to this is crazy

[@calus_bath_water]

I dont get why people hate jack tbh

[@maynorriveralopez9678]

Probably because of his voice.

[@briana_patrick]

@@maynorriveralopez9678 i like his voice. He is just a young boy. He doesnt need some overused gruff "badass" voice.

[@anti-ethniccleansing465]

His screeching, whiny voice! Worst voice actor casting ever! And I hated how he treated his horse too. Saying things like “WORK, YOU DAMN NAG!” Etc.

[@noriakipolpo8653]

​@@anti-ethniccleansing465 he's a teenager who lost his parents 3 years ago💀 no shit he's going to have a whiny voice and some disrepect

[@anti-ethniccleansing465]

@@noriakipolpo8653 No, he’s pixels. And this is a game. There are tons of teenagers in reality that are in tragic circumstances that don’t have such annoying screeching voices. Rockstar had plenty of options. It’s so bad that I literally refuse to play the game as him, and that sucks because it’s a product I paid good money for, and it would have been cool to finish my challenges, get more trophies, etc. Btw, newsflash: tons of gamers are animal lovers. We don’t want to hear our protagonist constantly yell meanly to our sweet horse as we ride around everywhere on them. RDR2 got it right. They don’t have either protagonist yell mean commands to their horse, and they are literal _MURDERERS!_ They do nothing but love on their horses (well not in _THAT_ way, but you know what I mean lol), as they are innocent animals. No matter how cruel the world can be, it’s disgusting to take one’s frustration/anger out on innocent animals. I went through some really fucked up shit as a teenager, but I never once thought of taking my frustration/anger out on one of my beloved pets or any other animals.

[@lwdrd]

After jack Marston said "I'm sure your husband will be just fine" that lady knew Edgar was gonna die

[@heyhocodyo1997]

Why can't you all accept that John is Jack's father not Dutch or Javier

[@Jonnny_Joestar]

What? Who says that crap?

[@heyhocodyo1997]

@@Jonnny_Joestar What? It's not my fault people are stupid

[@Jonnny_Joestar]

@@heyhocodyo1997 I was just wonder how this Idea came up. I could imagine Javier cause his beard but Dutch. Maybe they never played the Games

[@josephstalin2606]

@@Jonnny_Joestar It’s just dumb theorists that came up with that. Most of them played the 2nd game first and think that Dutch, Arthur, and the rest are more crucial to the story than they actually are

[@peacelovempathy1]

@@Jonnny_Joestar You’d be surprised how often people say that. Blows my mind. He looks just like John with a touch of Abigail.

[@Bizzy3663]

This is so weird like seeing how it all ended here. Red dead redemption 1 and 2 are masterpieces

[@opreacosmin5250]

The jacket he was of Arthur

[@nicksalehi97]

Nah this was a suit. Arthur had a jacket/Coat.

[@MA-qf5gq]

@@nicksalehi97 suit is top and bottom what you ment to say its a blazer. which its not its a jacket

[@richardwalsh3680]

I thought jack looked alot like John in fact i think that's why Ross asked do I know you to him because he sees john

[@KrugerLDN]

There's a reason they're called R*

[@funguy156]

Revenge is a luxury we can't afford

[@liljim3058]

Revenge is a luxury we can't afford ~Dutch van dir Lin 1899

[@alanmaclaren4366]

@@liljim3058 pretty sure it was aurther morgin that says it first in the game.

[@seaumuniverse8356]

watch to this while american venom is playing on a different tab

[@mitchellneuhoff9946]

To do the job he dressed like too many looked up to the most his father and his uncle Arthur Wearing his dad’s hat is uncle’s jacket

[@zlyexe1736]

It's crazy how only 7 Vander line gang member's survived Sadie Charles Tilly Josiah Swanson Karen and jack

[@Kraterlandschaft]

Karen survived? How so?

[@firesaint4569]

Mary Beth, and Pearson. It’s not known what happened to Karen

[@noriakipolpo8653]

Karen died by overdose of alcohol or she just loved a drunkard life

[@jluck1399]

Am I the only one that kept shooting his dead body after the credits rolled?

[@adianto1122]

Over here feller

[@Asphaltmonkey0]

It wasn't revenge. It was Redemption. Red Dead Redemption

[@Not-Natpex]

"You killed my father" the anticipation i had for the "no I am your father"

[@papytromblon]

The last living member of the gang

[@pacoramon9468]

5:38 Ross coud have killed Jack there if he wanted.

[@chase.mcf1]

i love how jack kills ross in a respectable duel, something ross could have never done to john

[@thedingo6577]

RDR3 with Jack as the last Cowboy in WW1 France, he would escape his sentence by volunteering to fight with the American Expeditionary Forces and ends up sacrificing himself for a small French town. IDK, just a thought I had after beating the second game...

[@silverback1953]

Jack ends up dying of age in the 90s

[@14TND88]

In doing this Jack not only avenged John but the whole gang

[@jagerbolt90]

I always preferred to kill Ross with the M1911. It's poetic justice in a way.

[@silentfanatic]

If you keep playing as Jack you can continue the hunting missions. I hadn't quite earned 100% just yet, so I found an animal I needed and skinned it. Then Jack said something like, "Just like you taught me, Pa." Such a throwaway line, and it absolutely broke me.

[@sodamncutestud2]

Great ending to an amazing game. I love rdr2 but I do wish it would have been a sequel to red dead and we got to play as Jack.

[@simplemusic3311]

Nah probably rdr 3 talking about young arthur being outlaw with dutch and hosea. Or maybe arthur dad.😅

[@jackattacktron1000]

One of the best revenge kills ever.

[@alexgorgeous2868]

And Still Ross is right - John killed himself with the life he lived.

[@elgiulo6649]

It's incredible to think that Jack could be an NPC from GTA SAN ANDREAS. He died in 1992

[@user-hx6gs9rq7u]

No he didn’t. Jack living until the 90s is fan fiction made up by whoever writes the Wikipedia page

[@Negius]

gotta love the tutorial popups on even the final duel of the game. modern game design

[@naveenvenkateshk]

I have completed rdr2 but never saw rdr1, After seeing rdr1 graphics which were good for it's time, rdr2 looks and feels so real