Red Dead Stories: Uncle & John Marston's Last Days (All Cutscenes)

John Marston returns home to his ranch where he meets Abigail, Jack, & Uncle. After having dinner, John & Uncle do some cattle & some rustling together. Then comes the final mission where the army comes to John's house. Outnumbered John, Uncle, & Jack are able to hold them off for a little while, but soon Uncle becomes fatally wounded. John, Jack, & Abigail head off towards the barn. John tells them to run away and he'll see them soon. As he walks out the front of the barn, he's greeted by close to 20 army soldiers & Edgar Ross. They show no mercy as they shoot him repeatedly. Some years later Jack Marston goes to hunt down Edgar and gets his revenge.

[@lorenzospitaleri]

That man was as old as rocks, yet he still fought to the end with terminal lumbago and all. Rest in peace Uncle, you shall always be remembered as the biggest Chad of the Wild West.

[@xxgamerxxyut1084]

@Roland Deschain haha same

[@xxgamerxxyut1084]

@Roland Deschain Co.Meath

[@mariguana7918]

@Roland Deschain I think it means a hot guy who gets with all the hoes.

[@anitadilldoe3440]

Lorenzo they didn’t call him “The One Shot Kid” for nothing. Uncle will always be remembered as one of the deadliest gunslingers in the west.

[@lscott4074]

@@xxgamerxxyut1084 I'm from Belfast lads

[@migoof]

“The day John Marston stopped shooting”

[@Jimmyneutron-ox7ry]

Jinxed

[@memoofjacoboarbenzjuanarev9724]

Kill him like the scene from Robocop.

[@siixeyes]

That shit hurt.

[@FrankTheRandomCommenter]

Fun fact: *it was the same day I died*

[@davidreynolds2390]

Spring Trap what kid

[@sterlingarcher74]

Everyone jumps to call John “illiterate” when he’s actually one of the few characters who knows how to read and write and he’s very well spoken compared to almost everyone else in the game.

[@averagedude6736]

Yeah you can see him write in rdr2 in arthur's journal so I don't know how he's illiterate

[@Uhhhh970]

@@averagedude6736 oh he can write just fine...drawing on the other hand...

[@kotarojujo2737]

@@Uhhhh970 cant herd, cant swim, cant draw

[@ethanthomas349]

He actually learned Dutch’s teachings quicker than Arthur, he just didn’t care enough to remember them

[@farhaxai9948]

he was taught by two of the most charismatic and well-spoken people in their time after all.

[@Astrogildooo]

Jack first encountered Ross by a riverside, and then years later, killed him by a riverside. Interesting little detail

[@FlySlyGuy]

The company knew this too. That’s why I’m that scene during RDR2 by the riverside Edgar Ross one and only line is “you better stick with fishing boy” .

[@ethanclark9248]

Ross pointing the gun while jack was fishing then jack pointing the gun while Ross was fishing

[@Odranoel_Iccugnem]

They could do Red Dead 3 playing with him

[@dwoh4345]

intresting thought but this time jack was the one putting him into defense in agression if you understand what i mean its some story telling tactic of ending the story as you started it. Very nice detail for sure

[@kokomine578]

@@ethanclark9248 He was duck hunting not fishing

[@colossaliscrazy5461]

If this game was like rdr2 he woulda slapped the horse to send it away and it would have kicked him across the barn.

[@seanisgone5413]

You're god

[@reecewouters1445]

1 Subscriber seems legit

[@RenegadeShepTheSpacer]

@One Meniacal Madman He was joking, you downer.

[@colossaliscrazy5461]

I love the chaos I’ve caused

[@KronoriumKid2210]

You made my day! :)

[@alexs5744]

When Dutch said "Our time has passed John", that should've been the hint that those government bastards were not going to let John go.

[@joshuahughes5761]

Alex the Hun Arthur did say johns dumb as rocks

[@Alphae21]

Tume?

[@coolkid350]

He was also saying that the wild west is done. John included.

[@griz312]

Alex the Hun John knew their time ended the moment he left the gang. It was just that Dutch finally accepted his days as an outlaw were over.

[@j.avance9031]

Dutch also said "when im gone they'll just find another monster. They have to. Because they have to justify their wages." which also hinted at the government turning on john.

[@Phurzt]

Uncle, sits around, drinks, makes excuses, but at the end of the day, when shit hit the fan, a switch turned. "Yeah boy, run" while standing unwavering at impending doom. Theres a story to uncle we will never know.

[@helljumper6969]

@21st Century Schizoid Man not confirmed.

[@gagetaylor192]

@@helljumper6969 Not confirmed, but rockstar throws every hint under the sun at you to imply it. In RDR2 they try to throw you off a little by not having his facial scars like he does in RDR1. But in the first game you can see his scars, and the beard would also cover most of the main scarring. There's several dialogue hints in both games that hint towards RDR. The "one shot kid" line is more than likely a reference to when red blow's the guy's arm off in one shot after those people kill his father. And as he reaches for the gun to do that with he burns his hand, his right hand. In both games Uncle wears a glove on his right hand. In RDR2 you can see what looks like scar textures on his right hand when he's not wearing the glove. There's a rag he also wears in his back pocket in RDR2 that looks pretty much identical to the rag red uses to wrap his hand after he burns it. RDR1 Uncle mentions having experience in ranching. Red having grown up on a ranch and that same ranch appearing in all 3 games. Also Uncle despite acting dumb and lazy most of the time is probably the smartest among the gang in RDR2. And after the events of RDR it would explain why he lies low under the name Uncle and falls in with Dutch's gang. And why at a moment's notice he can flip a switch like OP mentioned and hold his own against the army even in old age. Cause red literally fights the army and government and wins. So yeah it's not confirmed, but when you put 2 and 2 together like 15 times does it really need confirmed?

[@FedericoB1891]

I wonder if it was personal for him because of the gang

[@azuresky96]

@Kyle Castloo it's confirmed that RDR and RDR1&2 are separate universes by R* themselves. And more or less take place around the same time, so there is literally 0 chance of Uncle = Red being true. I don't understand how people don't get this.

[@PopeRecords]

@@azuresky96 RDR2 is a "prequel" to RDR, a prequel is events of an existing work that take place before it, meaning if its realised as a "prequel" than it's in the same universe.

[@johnychrist2559]

"In a mans last moments, he'll show you who he really is" Uncle was the last OG

[@punishedwhispers1218]

Red Dead 1s writing really was so much better, you didnt need to 60 hours to figure out who Uncle was, all we needed was three 10 second scenes to know their entire relationship, and all it took was those three words 'So it seems' to convey decades of history between the two

[@zairhussain5184]

Uncle’s lumbago’s really hardened in 1911.

[@ytn675]

@@seanisgone5413 ffs

[@unclebuns5286]

*hardened*

[@spotty4849]

No he just fell into a deep slumber

[@Scoffslaphead72]

@@spotty4849 deep thought*

[@spotty4849]

ScoffSlaphead72 nope

[@MistahJay7]

When I was younger I was upset that John just didn't escape with his family. But Now I finally get it It was the moment when he finally realised he had to let them go in order for them to live a life. His time was over

[@imjustheresoiwontgetfined3890]

If he escaped they would keep hunting him down and prolly kill his family

[@MistahJay7]

@@imjustheresoiwontgetfined3890 Yea he sacrificed himself in the end to protect his family

[@estellaruiz3125]

He sacrificed himself for his family ;/

[@JesusChrist-bq6lu]

Same goes for Arthur he knew he was dying and didn’t have much time left so he decided to go out helping John and his family Pursue a better life and warned John to not look back but John did and died because of it and jack repeats the cycle

[@RonIsElite]

Khal Drogo23 it would have been cool if u made choices in rdr 1and rdr 2 to change the ending where if you decide to make good choices then they live if bad then they will die

[@calebstevens7487]

Abigail’s reaction to seeing John is probably the most realistic thing in the whole franchise. Also after playing RDR2 you realize uncle was never a wanted man so he could’ve walked but still stayed.

[@josephstalin2606]

Uncle always finds a way out of work but when he saw the literal ARMY pulling up to kill John, he immediately grabbed his gun and stood his ground. Uncle probably hasn’t shot a gun since he was in the gang and yet shows no hesitation when defending John and his family

[@ultron-5600]

@@josephstalin2606 he was lazy and annoying to John but he wasn’t a coward. He had honor just like Arthur did.

[@mb-vf3kn]

@@josephstalin2606 we have a few missions with uncle shooting and when he defended the camp

[@joshedmonds5892]

@@josephstalin2606 uncle did know how to hold a gun I mean his red harlow after all plus in Rdr2 uncle played a huge role at the Stagecoach Cornwall robbery at chapter 3

[@josephstalin2606]

@@joshedmonds5892 He’s not Red Harlow at all and his only “role” in the stagecoach robbery was providing the info, originally he was gonna have just the rest of them go until Arthur forces Uncle to go along. It’s actually crazy how many people just parrot “uncle is red” like you realize there’s even more evidence proving they aren’t the same, not to mention it’s also been confirmed by rockstar that they are separate characters

[@buttersstotch601]

It saddens me that Jack ends up alone with everyone around him dying

[@terkz7945]

Unless he got a wife

[@RRRRRRRRR33]

He lived, wrote a book, got famous (perhaps, if the book is still a thing in 2010 something)

[@CupOfRunes]

@@terkz7945 well maybe he can find charles and sadie, theyre still alive, and it would make for a great game too. he might remember them since they came and helped john when they just got the farm, and im pretty sure jack was a teenager when that happened

[@PatchesDied]

@@CupOfRunes sadie helped john try to kill micah, So Sadie probably got killed by pinkertons

[@berryjuice8704]

@@PatchesDied pretty sure she moved to south america though, or at least she was considering it

[@ItakeiHyuga]

Uncle is more lovable in RDR2, the voice actor fits perfectly.

[@iiclyde_nodes174]

It's the lumbago

[@iiclyde_nodes174]

It's the lumbago

[@ReverendReverb]

The original one died during development of rdr2 (2016) Fun fact: When John, Charles, and of course, Uncle are celebrating the competition of the ranch and sing, this voice actor for Uncle sings with them; a somewhat melancholic last thank you for his dedication to the rdr project as a whole.

[@the125er6]

It's the luMb4g0

[@drumbeard]

@@ReverendReverb wrong. There were three voice actors for Uncle. Original one for rdr1 and two for rdr2. First actor for rdr2 died. But it's not the original one singing in rdr2.

[@darryldraven9093]

Every time Abigail Cooks I'm starting to miss mr Pearson

[@FoolsMasquerade]

@Master Farr or dead. It's been 4 years since rdr2s epilogue

[@CodyTheSec]

Shitposts Daily who knows!

[@bbseaman2812]

@@FoolsMasquerade it's now safer than 1899 so maybe he's alive

[@pakasteallas]

@@TONY-dq1pk who knows, maybe it was good?

[@dozer1431]

@@TONY-dq1pk That shit looks good tho idk what you mean

[@angus9165]

Uncles beard in Red dead redemption 2: whiter than snow Uncles beard in Red dead redemption: looks like he’s been throwing up on it since the day he was born

[@ryanmitchell7347]

It's a beer stain

[@gavinswearingen6492]

@@ryanmitchell7347 its from smoking

[@iaugh6342]

Probably both

[@rodrikofharlaw6848]

@@gavinswearingen6492 It's chew

[@TheRealGnomeChompski]

@@rodrikofharlaw6848 its clam chowder

[@ichangedmyusernamebecausei2551]

John’s death is more depressing than Arthur’s imo. John gets shot up like a stray dog by the people who took his family hostage and forced him to do their dirty work. Arthur, depending on what ending you got, dies peacefully on top of a mountain looking at the sunset maybe reflecting his life or thinking about the good times he had in those few minutes he had left

[@JuanRamos-re7rj]

when these happen i finished red dead redemption 2 include john marston when Micah Bell got shot how can i do that story

[@tracemasters620]

@@JuanRamos-re7rj play the first game stup

[@JuanRamos-re7rj]

@@tracemasters620 stup

[@tracemasters620]

@@JuanRamos-re7rj stup

[@JuanRamos-re7rj]

@@tracemasters620 is that story from red dead remdemtion 1

[@stubblygraph8211]

"Keep riding and don't look back" -Arthur

[@sp2618]

@@marcialdospuforini1197 sure boah the best character from rockstar games

[@juliet4093]

@@marcialdospuforini1197 so do you think you are cool by hating on RDR 2, because I hate to break it to you, but hating on a popular game isn't an interesting personality trait

[@johnnyjustadude1999]

StubblyGraph43 StubblyGraph43 and he looked back

[@QuenTeHein]

@@marcialdospuforini1197 Arthur better than John and fuck you

[@gaymert1246]

@@johnnyjustadude1999 But if he ran then he would do exactly as the van der linde gang did.

[@mills1198]

John :He ain't gonna be no frontier gun slinger Jack : hold my book

[@hanz2904]

Lol

[@union4814]

He actually goes on to be a writer sometime afterwards and makes a book I think it was called "red dead redemption" findable in gta v campaign

[@xxx_lordxbox_xxx4419]

Well abigail Say once that if he become gunslinger that at top of her grave well she was right

[@rinzler1801]

my headcanon is that jack fights in ww1 and then goes on to write about the Van der linde gang

[@kevray]

@@rinzler1801 He’s a little old to have fought in WW1. They usually drafted the younger men then worked up.

[@icantbiteice]

Rdr1: I wish I could play as John again I hate jack Rdr2: I hate John I wish I could play as Arthur Rdr3: man I don’t want to play as Arthur I wanna play as uncle again

[@PEBRIANS]

Rdr4:i don't want to play as uncle i wanna play as red harlow again.

[@anky9784]

@@PEBRIANS uncle is red Harlow look it up lol

[@PEBRIANS]

@@anky9784 where you know uncle ia red harlow?

[@julianajordan2660]

@@PEBRIANS it's just a theory, but there is a lot of proof that supports it

[@PEBRIANS]

@@julianajordan2660 Well,Fine.

[@woohoo1551]

What I like about the "Uncle is Red Harlow" theory is that it gives Uncle's life perfect symmetry. His story would have started with him defending his family's ranch. Ending with him defending his (adopted) family's ranch.

[@pugachevskobra5636]

I understand the urge to tie a nicensc bow around his story but he’s 1,000,000,000% not Red Harlow💀

[@ulric8445]

@@pugachevskobra5636 he’s got the red sash Harlow had from the beginning, not to mention he’s a good shot

[@connorandersen]

@@pugachevskobra5636Im sorry man but hes red harlow, and its in a different universe there’s nothing saying he cant be the red harlow of this universe, plus part of the theme of revolver was its exaggerated stories no one really knows how the one shot kids story played out, Uncles character is full of tales and exaggerations, maybe the tale of red harlow is actually uncles life story and its over exaggerated but the same crap still happened since the game can be seem as being told from uncles like at a campfire or something

[@MrHeadSet1]

Jack is the last living "active" member of the Van der linde gang

[@Vinman-fq7ff]

I mean there is Sadie, Charles, and most of the women in the gang are most likely still alive

[@SeanEazy]

@@Vinman-fq7ff I was just gonna say: Pearson, Tilly, Mary-Beth, Sadie, Charles, and maybe Karen

[@veritty6828]

Vinman1000 0 yeah but who needs them, I just want my boah John back

[@yourenotthatguypal3483]

I doubt the rest are still alive by the point Jack is a grown man, besides Mary Beth or Tilly

[@PillarCrown]

Mr.Brightside every time I look at him as 18 years old I can’t help but think how crazy it is that’s it’s the same person why was kidnapped all those years ago by Angelo bronte

[@teerboyd]

im sorry but the way John casually stands there screaming in uncle's face at 11:33 always cracks me up

[@leonrififi3543]

Jacks line is even better, he literally yells right in Johns ear

[@steverambo4692]

@@leonrififi3543 “oh my god they killed uncle”

[@davidduran761]

Gunfire can deafen you

[@jordanr2244]

@@steverambo4692 always reminds me of South Park when I hear that’, “OH MY GOD THEY KILLED KENNY”

[@porc1429]

That entire scene is so bad

[@aniisol]

13:50 When I played this as a kid I didn't understand much, and I thought I was just gonna be able to shoot everyone down, when john died my fragile heart was hurt for the very first time.

[@imdabanana1]

Bro I thought I fucked up and it was my fault he died I was depressed

[@randomperson-jt2pp]

guys uncle isn't dead the agents just hit uncles lucky ketchup packet

[@benisscrenis745]

this account has lumbago Brooklyn Nine Nine

[@InquisitorThomas]

Yeah, once the Army Left Uncle left a body double on the porch and then he spent the rest of his days in Tahiti, he was the only member of the gang to make it there.

[@neppy0021]

Made me choke on my spit

[@mike12pass]

His lucky ketchup packet! Of course!

[@gaming_theswag2634]

That lazy old man is just sleeping with some ketchup dont worry he'll wake up eventually

[@dannyecho2202]

Uncle didn't die. He's just thinking

[@Sir_Maximus_Hardwood]

Strange world we live in.

[@juice_stain3504]

Wonder if it paid well

[@fredmb123]

Now i think you are lieing, steeling and killing

[@doomer6521]

He's just using his brain, while you use what you got. Which is less of a brain.

[@ThatGuyKh1]

Danny Faumuina-Liu unfortunately it didn’t pay well this time

[@malamations3680]

Imagine if one of the gang members that were still alive came back to see how everyone was doing and found the graves of Uncle, Abigail, and John.

[@deus6383]

like sadie or charles? they would be devastated

[@PDFsArentPpl]

@@deus6383 charles would find jack i think. Or jack would find charles, for one of his books.

[@hossamhossam5197]

you got the gang girls except for Abigail and miss grimshaw, Pearson, Swanson, trelawney, Charles and sadie, alongside jack, they are the only members alive from the van der Linde gang, while the rest of the gang are all dead.

[@BWC-Chad]

@@hossamhossam5197 jack and Charles vs the early mafia would be insane

[@Courier2077]

They gonna mistaken Jack as John

[@abhinavamatya75]

8:56 "Thank you, son," said John Marston, with the pride of every dad who has ever made a terrible dad joke.

[@stonedennis3213]

Rdr3 play as Uncle in his glory days

[@AndresLopez-wn8lt]

Him or Hosea

[@dogeramsey9154]

Uncle: "They used to call me one shot kid!" Arthur: ...😒

[@loppitydick19]

Or Dutch it would be interesting seeing him before he became messed in the head or kinda like gta v where you can switch characters

[@stonedennis3213]

Loppity Dick I think playing as Dutch in his prime would be amazing, he was a good person in the begging he had a code, they could also include young author and John along with many others. They could make it even more Wild West oriented since it’s farther back too.

[@darrianx3676]

Stone Dennis that would literally be his entire life

[@cameronmccarthy4192]

Where’s Charles when you need him

[@danieldepaula6930]

Already dead, probably. :(

[@CuppedRamen]

In Canada probably

[@pent864]

Cameron McCarthy or Sadie

[@survivingnonutnovemberblue5720]

@@pent864 or Arthur:c

[@pent864]

surviving no nut November blue balls he’s dead soooo...

[@dantemorrison1997]

Did anyone notice Edgar Ross stole Uncle's outfit?!

[@epicdoge9473]

Ikr what a bitch

[@arthurmorgan2959]

Ross is a fucking asshole

[@Zayanfida]

Ross the stupid

[@terminator6552]

@@Zayanfida Ross the bitch

[@luigicavallo270]

I hope Lumbago is contagious

[@haiku5875]

This was the most traumatic game ending when I was little I cried for hours when they got john

[@sarahsamuel]

Don't worry your not alone

[@ripvanwinkls]

Same 💔

[@FlowerKnight2]

I just sat in disbelief... I was probably 14 or 15 and had never seen a character that I played as in a game get done so dirty before.. I ended up being more pissed than anything, I remember going to Blackwater as Jack and murdering everyone.

[@outlaw3964]

Legend says it that johns ghost still kicks uncle ghost

[@julesmcgrules3860]

Lol

[@ix3755]

G E T UP OWWWWW

[@metrolacketal7052]

And you ,Sean, still kicked by Hosea ?

[@FrankTheRandomCommenter]

I do because he's always sleeping in the bar of god

[@paigegrew5680]

Sean MacGuire “GET UP!!!”

[@stonedennis3213]

Even with terminal lumbago uncle still stood his ground and fought for john and his family, Arthur would of been proud.

[@jimmilton7513]

@@vengeance1450 ''strange world we live in, Arthur Morgan.''

[@fatassdogs8617]

You can still hear em kicking uncle in heaven

[@hafeeez87]

He knows his days are numbered, better die a hero than die a coward

[@KramYEET]

I like how the video is specifically about John and Uncle's deaths yet it still shows Jack's revenge on Ross because of just how sweet an ending it is.

[@josephstalin2606]

I mean Ross is directly responsible for John and Uncles fate so it’s only right to end the video with justice being served

[@chasescanlon6488]

“Just keep riding, don’t look back.” Sams message Arthur gave him.

[@HoneyBadger--sl6wi]

"Revenge is a fools game" arthur morgan

[@cumputerboys8880]

Sorry but i gotta satisfy myself

[@jeanmichel5882]

honeybadger4. john died ´cause he took his revenge from micah so pinkerton find him and killed him. so yes revenge is a fools game.

[@nicksavage1973]

And jack played it the best way you can ..we watched a innocent boy turn to a killer

[@thelordtachanka9823]

Dutch says that not Arthur

[@balabanasireti]

@Jesus Christ John killing Micah is what him a perfekt candidate for the Pinkertons though.

[@ArthurMorgan-qj7et]

RDR DLC Alternative ending for rdr1 John goes through the back door and went to guarma

[@JoseMora-wc5zz]

Would of drowned out of the boat, bastard cant swim lmao

[@Everik-ct6pg]

@Enjoy everything Or it’s fucking pointless the government would never stop going after him and his family, he had to die to free them.

[@estellaruiz3125]

Tahiti!

[@PrinceGummy]

@@Everik-ct6pg nah, they won't chase him if they leave the country.

[@noobclass171]

Tahiti dear boy, Mangoes

[@eyeyrownnn]

8:51 john pressed the antagonize button

[@alipotter6056]

9:18 Jack : "The day John Marston stopped shooting" Little did he know, that day would indeed be the day John Marston would stop shooting...

[@activebanans683]

Both John and Arthur died not passing the age of 40. Damn they sure are eager to meet each other again.

[@abdelrhmansherif8842]

Well John was 40 So maybe he is almost 40

[@benjamindiaz9396]

@@abdelrhmansherif8842 he was 38

[@gonzalo2465]

Yeah they both in hell for sure teaching satan how to shoot a gun

[@jacksonb.valentine8208]

Arthur was 36 and John was 38

[@imwrongyoureright.3890]

When was Arthur's age stated?

[@bigpuma444]

Uncles Lazy Eye meter must be empty

[@user-sx4qu4dz9z]

Because his Lazy Eye core is empty too, duh

[@bigpuma444]

@@anonymousanonymous5832 ..and a little Ring Dang Doo too!

[@Ellemen_LMN]

BIG PUMA Now what is that?

[@badussy]

His dead eye is full

[@Theevil6ify]

Either he had a Lazy Eye, or a lack of respect!

[@danieltrenkovski1629]

All of John and Uncles interactions in RDR1 and RDR2 some of the funniest dialogue i have ever heard. They come up with the most creative ways to insult one another.

[@alonnie1919]

Uncle was the oldest gang member and possibly the laziest. Yet he outlived everyone except John (who didn't last long after). He was always very clever and it is what had kept him alive for so long and doing the bare minimum. Yet he knew that the right thing was worth dying for and that is why the last thing he did was defend the Marston family and tell John to get them to safety. It is also why he ran away from Dutch - he knew Dutch was broken beyond repair. In RDR2, Uncle is portraited as nothing more than a lazy old man who sleeps around all day, tells lies and asks for money. He participates only in a few heists and they're not crucial to the main story in any way. But in encounters in the camp, with Dutch and Micah specifically, you can see how Uncle saw straight through them to the real men inside. Just another reason as to why he was probably one of the most intelligent gang members. His death proved he was also one of the most dignified and honourable.

[@B0BA-F3TT]

I always wanted to see or hear uncle say something when Hosea dies I feel like they would’ve been closer in the gang since they’re both old af

[@cheez3184]

Uncle probably would have had more screen time in rdr2 if his voice actor didn't die

[@crashedforeigncar]

Uncle isn't lazy He just hates working [wink]

[@Bacxaber]

Uncle is the morale booster. He may not be useful, but he's living proof that this lifestyle _can_ work out. Outlaws don't always die young. _That_ was his role in the gang, and I dare say it was an important one.

[@theoriginalstarwalker4357]

The reason Uncle never gets hunted is because he barely commits any crimes in the entirety of RDR2... And Ross didn't even know he existed because of that. Megamind moment

[@ateasewiththecheese2140]

"the day John marston stopped shooting" Holy fuck that foreshadowing

[@pradabears]

one of the best cases of foreshadowing i’ve ever seen

[@livewire2759]

Machines that turn men into angels... Little did they know, those machines were guns.

[@jacksonb.valentine8208]

Say what you want about uncle, for all his laziness he was the most loyal man around.

[@jamesjeffery277]

Douggie Redemption he was a scrounge

[@x15tian]

Him and Javier

[@Dagger_323]

@@x15tian Javier wasn't loyal. He turned his back on both John and Arthur and left them to die.

[@demiseyt2395]

Douggie Redemption Charles was loyal as well . My favorite brother in arms in RDR 2 .

[@x15tian]

Dagger 323 bruh he said time and time again how much Dutch is important to the gang. He was one of the most loyal to Dutch and that’s what I meant

[@DreKC]

Uncle and John are my favorite relationship in the series... through all of their interactions and passive aggressiveness... you know there’s love there

[@serdownofhousebad1127]

There's something so encapsulating about John's line to uncle as they stare at the soldiers, like they're both looking back at the days with the gang and how Dutch's mistakes caught up to almost everyone. Its really saddening to know the Marston's thought they worked their way out of that life and could live a better one as a family

[@zilentzap]

the other guy with Ross got respect for John he didn't go to kill him

[@greedgod5827]

Cuz he wasn't with Ross chasing down Dutch and the others all those years. I feel like to Ross it was a bit personal cuz Dutch and John and all them killed a shit load of the Pinkerton's and Milton. Ross seen everything they had done including John and he didn't want to let him go

[@rombus8202]

@@greedgod5827 yeah, Archer was pretty cool and kinda nice.

[@masteroutlaw100]

@@rombus8202 He's the good cop to Ross's bad cop

[@jacksonb.valentine8208]

Archer was a man doing his job, Ross was a man looking for glory. He deserved his bushwhacking.

[@NickBoss243]

cole lappan I never considered that and to be honest with that knowledge I would have done the same thing Ross did.

[@jeremiahgalvan9475]

Jack is wearing johns hat Jack is wearing arthurs jacket Thats what i call a huge Revenge story

[@JonF-iy1wp]

The jackets are different

[@franciscomora1449]

@@JonF-iy1wp the collar is khaki instead of black

[@SockPuppetzTV]

Jeremiah Galvan They’re obviously different jackets. Arthur’s is a buckskin hunting jacket and Jack wears a casual everyman’s coat. They’re not even the same color.

[@PyroSirBrad]

I feel like the outfit Arthur wore (pants, jacket, shirt, boots, neckerchief) is buried with him. I also think the hat and the letter's he gets throughout the game is either buried underneath the gazebo or right beside Arthur. Also Arthur hat is most likely buried with John though. Maybe now since the release of RDR2 the jacket that Jack wore is a callback to the jacket Arthur wore not because Rockstar had it planned from the very beginning but because it'd be cute seeing Jack take a note from Arthur's fashion. Arthur was head of the union and the guy who took Jack fishing. TL;DR the jacket isn't Arthur's but Jack is wearing it with Arthur in mind.

[@adnanpasha3919]

Jeremiah Galvan nice bro

[@The_ManInTheCape]

“Im sure your husband will be just fine” -Jack

[@MemeAlchemist]

I kinda love how Abigail was worried that John had taken so long going to take care of Dutch and the gang that she had a doubt in her head that maybe John fell back in with them and abandoned herself and Jack.. Cant exactly blame her for how John was as a father early on, looking for any excuse to not have to be a father and not be around.

[@warhawk9566]

I love how every criticism thrown at Uncle is valid but in the end he still fought to the death to protect the people he cared about

[@seanmacguire2128]

He was a hero deep inside

[@TemmieContingenC]

@@seanmacguire2128 still got a hole in your head Sean?

[@arthurmorgan3823]

The Red Dead games are on another level. They made such great characters. I miss Arthur, John, Lenny and even Uncle. Edit: Yes and Hosea

[@Berserk_96]

Its Tachanka Charles too

[@Ok-eg8dg]

@@Berserk_96 and micah

[@CHAZTEC]

@@Ok-eg8dg no... Bats

[@sanfordmann5344]

OP your right they have some magical way of getting their characters to be remembered for years to come.

[@spotty4849]

L E N N E H MY B O A H

[@shashankdwivedi5694]

At the end John did what Dutch could never do take the responsibility like man and sacrificed himself and let his loved ones escape

[@josephstalin2606]

Yep. Dutch allowed his entire gang to get slaughtered by the army and John and literally ran until he couldn’t anymore. And even then he still threw himself off a cliff so that the government wouldn’t have the satisfaction of killing him themselves (Even tho Ross shot his body and most likely fabricated the reports saying he shot him himself)

[@r3idmcread212]

Arthur’s death was sad yeah but this has to be the most badass, most memorable death of the entire Red dead series. It took an Army to kill John marston. Marston is still number 1

[@AnxietyBrainz00]

One of the endings it took a small army as well and tb to kill Arthur

[@r3idmcread212]

@@AnxietyBrainz00 Arthur was ready in battle. John got caught out unaware. And the key difference in their deaths is. Arthur was going to die anyway he had nothing to loose. But John could have left with his family where him and his family would have everything to lose.

[@smoothcheeky8910]

@@r3idmcread212 arhur is constantly hinted as being the best gunslinger in the gang. In the credits he's called the senior gun of the gang. Gameplay wise Arthur is far more capable. Both are legendary marksmen but Arthur is slightly better based on what we've been told

[@r3idmcread212]

@@smoothcheeky8910 Why you talking about the gang ? I’m talking about John as a lone wolf. The last fighter out of the van der linde gang. The creators at rockstar call John the most badass character and asked him to act that way

[@smoothcheeky8910]

@@r3idmcread212 John was in the gang. It's the only direct comparison we have between the 2. Arthur is consistently put above John as a gunslinger. Not to mention Arthur is capable of more gameplay wise. Everything points towards Arthur being a better shot. Rockstar have never said John is the most badass character as far as I'm aware. Can you provide a source for that claim?

[@BraidedYak]

Jack going for that Dutch look

[@ladyrest8455]

Braided Yak4384 his dad ...is

[@ladyrest8455]

Dutch

[@momsspaghetti7729]

@@ladyrest8455 or Javier or Bill or Arthur or John

[@crizsha7977]

Plot twist Javier and john are the parents

[@gaelcaballero6900]

@@crizsha7977 Why you say that? Jack is John's son isn't it?

[@theMrTJF]

"Guess all i got left is doubts, doubts and scars." -Jim Milton

[@obamaredacted2530]

*john marston*

[@craggywag5482]

*Rip van Winkle

[@ddddavyy8383]

"keep riding and don't look back". In this game we really do see John be such a wiser older man than we saw in RDR2, like he has literally learned so many lessons from Arthur

[@MrBenjarming]

That small animation John has just before stepping out the barn is one of my most favourite moments in all storytelling.

[@OtomostheCrazy]

Uncle, still with Terminal Lumbago: “I’ll take Y’all on!” Truly a legend among gunslingers.

[@youtube_untouched8401]

"the one shot kid"

[@thejokingsquire625]

@@youtube_untouched8401 id like to think that’s because he only ever fired one bullet his entire life XD

[@lewanbroski504]

@@thejokingsquire625 lmao that's funny but he did shoot alot of bullets here there's another theory that he's Red Harlow

[@ValiantSkyRider720]

Dutch: "When I'm gone, they'll just find another monster. They have to, because they have to justify their wages." And that monster turned out to be John.

[@johnspencer8268]

What are you talking about? Are you crazy? John marston was a good man he wants his wife and his son to be in a safe place what about bill williamson? He was a rat he betrayed john so did micah he doesn't appear in this rdr1 but he did appear in rdr2

[@zygard65]

Dutch was talking about Agent Ross and the rest, he was the monster they hunted, and after he died John was the next "monster".

[@mrplayfulshade1038]

"You always have a plan Dutch" "...This one is a good one"

[@blackpinkROSEJINIEJISOOLISA]

What? :/

[@deadgambler879]

@@johnspencer8268 that went right over your head...... Jeezz

[@GuyMaleMan]

1:40 seeing all the love between John, jack, Abigail and even Uncle through these cutscenes really pulls at the heart strings. Rockstar sure know how to write characters.

[@cadetheblade8138]

I love that John says keep running and don’t look back like Arthur said to him

[@uncleb6391]

I’ve been fighting the lumbago all them years and looks like the lumbago has won lumbago war now who is ready for lumbago war 2

[@highasthesun9342]

Uncle B what’s lumbago

[@Bekeon]

@@highasthesun9342 it's a slow and painful death my brother

[@carter_RU]

Uncle B You have old man you have you lived long you left too soon though

[@bingo9542]

Why dont you make yourself usefull and get up!!

[@elchinex4138]

gerbullo crolello shut up hurt ass

[@joseeduardovillanueva5150]

It’s okay Boah, he’s with Arthur now

[@tonydaza8504]

No he’s purgatory he never went to paradise like Arthur

[@theamericanboah5435]

@@tonydaza8504 Arthur and john are both in hell.

[@prod.tommylove3886]

I still get chills at the way the end plays out , especially with the knowledge of what he’s been through

[@freedragon3050]

11 years later and it still brings a year to my eye!

[@UGLYBOYwrld]

Is it me or does 19 year old jack look like Javier with a full mustache

[@gussmann6580]

Just you

[@gonzalo2465]

Synara Chan I mean Abigail was a prostitute so maybe the sperm did a fusion dance

[@UGLYBOYwrld]

Synara Chan 😂😂😂

[@jerrychicks2420]

Sad Cavs Fan Lol could be true it was scientifically proven that all the sperm from the dudes a girl has had sex with could lead to a baby with features from some of them.

[@sushiturtle1488]

Facts

[@Battingcox]

11:17 "that fella can shoot" after uncle gets shot in the chest. Pretty cold of you there John

[@masterassassingaming692]

John with his cynicism😂

[@uncle7215]

Lmfao

[@SewingMink160]

Didnt even sound like john. Sounded like his voice actor rob.

[@LuistheABF123]

"Well old man looks like things is about to get settled once and for all". Every time I say the trailer it gave me chills when John said it.

[@subscribeforn0reasonplz691]

"In my youth the used to call me the 1 shot kid" Uncle never lied

[@blackpinkROSEJINIEJISOOLISA]

Yeah cuz one shot killed him and his LumBaGo

[@unclebuns5286]

@@blackpinkROSEJINIEJISOOLISA nah his lumbago just got to him

[@tigrex6004]

15:54 "AND WHEN I DIE DONT BURY ME" *shows john buried*

[@brendanforester4601]

🎶'Neath the Western sky, on the lone prairie🎶

[@maxhoughtonmusic]

Yeah the full sentence is "don't bury me neath the western sky on the lone prairie"

[@ruger-biscuit7857]

"Oh bury me not, and his voice failed there... we buried him there on the lone praire"

[@franksalaz2590]

didnt notice that the shirt John its wearing its the one Abigail gave him in rdr2

[@johnbarrientosiii6586]

Well Red Dead Redemption II is a prequel so you probably thought it was just a normal rancher shirt and nothing else

[@lukasdoofus2592]

@@johnbarrientosiii6586 Exactly everyone praises them for this shit like they didn't get to look at rdr1 when making the second one. All they had to do was find little stuff in the first game and link it to the second one.

[@meech37]

@@lukasdoofus2592 Yeah that should get praise. They wrote, arguabebly, a better narrative using only small peices of context from the first game. It 110% deserves the praise it gets.

[@Caden-yr8ub]

Oh frick ur right

[@kaiashton2885]

10:37 badass scene uncle and John fight one last time

[@8mmkyle865]

After playing RDR2, I can empathize more with Abigail on why she thought John had left her to go back with Bill or Dutch. It always confused me as a kid why she'd think he would leave her and Jack.

[@Muzzly1234]

Poor uncle - - his ring dang doo core was clearly depleted, an issue only exacerbated by terminal lumbago.

[@MultiMasterfelix]

I had a bug in a cutscene in RDR2 where uncles bandana dissapeared and I saw Uncle with light stubble. A glorious sight.

[@avci6084]

Damn really??

[@sathlasdalaraynidridlendar6875]

Was it the chapter 3 stagecoach robbery mission? If so I saw that too on my sixth playthrough lol.

[@MultiMasterfelix]

@@sathlasdalaraynidridlendar6875 Sure was. Shaven uncle.

[@MultiMasterfelix]

@@avci6084 Yeah got a screenshot and all.

[@avci6084]

Unlimitedpower on ps4 or Xbox

[@pixoloanimation8895]

It pains me to see good educated kid like Jack go through so much pain and in the end he became a outlaw as well. A fate his parent or Arthur never wanted.

[@plexyglass429]

i dont think he continues being an outlaw, he just avenged his father, didnt kill anyone else, nor needed to. he most likely wrote a book about it all considering the journal arthur makes

[@Eaoden18]

I always appreciated the fact that after Uncle dies and Abigail sees his body, she stops, holds his hand and prays over him before she and Jack flee. We’re led to believe through both games that she despised the man for being a lazy drunk, but in the end, she loved him, and that he was family just as John and Jack are.

[@seantonnemacher6209]

"We're nearly out of money" How the hell is that possible after robbing Micah and Dutch??

[@legendhavoc175]

Invader Jet best . Fucking. Comment

[@CPNTT]

@@legendhavoc175 Probably. If you're 12.

[@youtube_untouched8401]

Pinkertons and the government potentially seized the cash as evidence or as relation to the black water massacre

[@mrplayfulshade1038]

Probably used it for the Ranch

[@danielyoung6778]

Real reason is because the money didn't exist yet in the story. In canon it might just be that repaying the debt and other expenses just drained it over four years and Charles/Sadie were given cuts as well. They still have enough money to buy from the MacFarlane ranch so maybe interpret that they're low on funds compared to the large amount they had.

[@WokeEarth]

Jack is awesome because he grew up in the gang as a child. Was around thieves and murderers but learned and enjoyed to read making him street and book smart. the way his character went to gather information on Ross was well spoken enough so not to raise suspicion and stayed polite and true to cowboy culture . He had to get revenge and closer like something out of the books he read as a child. My favorite playable character even if it’s just the epilogue of rd1

[@Dagger_323]

Totally agreed. I never understood the dislike of Jack by the majority of the fanbase. Jack in my opinion turned into the most badass gunslinger of all three playable characters across both RDR games and at a much younger age. In some ways I wish they had set RDR1 and 2 roughly 10 years earlier in the historical timeline than they did so we could get another game and play as a 20-something year old Jack Marston.

[@haroldgerken4835]

@@Dagger_323 I think it is because he was rude to his horce, but I don't know

[@danielyoung6778]

@@Dagger_323 basically just people being annoyed they can't play as John and frustration at him having an annoying line or two. Never really got it myself especially after 2 Jack is thematically a great character. Honestly the only added content I'd want in a remaster is a longer epilogue showing his turn from bookish boy to gunslinger.

[@Dagger_323]

@@danielyoung6778 I completely agree. A more detailed and in-depth look at how Jack conditioned himself into a deadly gunslinger would be a welcome addition.

[@danielyoung6778]

@@Dagger_323 I feel like seeing him grow more bitter with Abigail who's desperate to keep him straight would be an interesting dynamic. As she gets sick he takes on more responsibility and maybe there's a scene where people try to rob the ranch and young Jack kills the last one in the style that John does in 2 with the shotgun. That's the moment Abigail sees to much of John, Arthur and Dutch in him. Once she dies he gives rufus to the MacFarlanes and travels to Mexico where he meets up with Sadie and studies under her and Landon Rickets. Maybe bounty hunting and mercenary work for the mexican Revolution. Be cool to see him rob a train. I'd also like to see the morality system have some story consequence rather than just gameplay in the first game. Maybe how you play as John changes how Jack is in cutscenes and his honor at the end decides wheter he flees to Mexico with Sadie or north to Charles after killing Ross.

[@GlennDavey]

These videos are really well made, good work

[@rextamahou2577]

The scene where John says goodbye was the first time I ever cried in a video game

[@alec6583]

I like that you're still riding the mustang you caught with Bonnie. I rode that thing to the end of the earth.

[@NigerianCrusader]

YEP AND I RIDING MY MAGA HAT ALL THE WAY TO THE END OF THE EARTH

[@fps_shooter_0014]

Man imagine if Arthur MORGAN was there with sadie, Charles they would of succeeded

[@dawsyncanipe7947]

Cause they went elsewhere. Sadie went down to south america and Charles went to canada to start a family

[@H.K.5]

@@marcialdospuforini1197 I actually saw an NPC in RDR 1 which looked alot like Charles. Some big black dude with long hair.

[@mojiznaqvi8524]

Hamza Khaliq Yeaaaa there is a whole Indian character storyline in rdr1 soooo a Indian dude is not rare

[@Dagger_323]

Lol yeah right. They would have just increased the bounties on their heads more and more and caused John to have to pack up and run with his family all over again. Then all the work he'd gone to in order to build a home for Jack and Abigail would have been for nothing, and he would have to continue living a life by the gun. John knew the only way out for his family was by him sacrificing himself. Charles, Sadie, and Arthur being there would have only prolonged the inevitable and potentially Jack and Abigail could have been killed by the Army in a follow-up attack.

[@keithgreen9079]

@@dawsyncanipe7947 And my brother Arthur went to heaven

[@ManOhMan_1]

"This is a beautiful spot, see you around cowboy"

[@peacearbiter]

Arthur tells John “to not look back” years later John tells jack and Abigail to not look back

[@tundra111]

Red Dead Redemption is a masterpiece, I remember I shed a tear for this man right here 8 years ago.

[@matt.b5984]

"I'll give you a bad case of someone just shot me in the head" is till my favorite line from anything ever

[@bcgazero6472]

Jack marston secret dialogue for ross "Ill give you the lumbago that uncle had his entire life"

[@CaptnCrunch247]

This hits a lot harder now, after having played RDR2 and gaining a deeper understanding of John's and Abigail's past..

[@memebigboy5182]

And that was the day john marston stopped shooting...

[@SavoxYT]

"Oh mah gawd, they keeld 'im!" I expected Kyle from South Park to pop up and say "You bastards!" because of how Jack delivered that line.

[@Vomer0]

Meanwhile in rdr2....THEY GOT LENNY...YOU BASTARDS.... lenny is the long lost relative of kenny

[@NigerianCrusader]

AND TRUMP FROM REAL LIFE SPEAKING OF VOTE FOR HIM PLEASE

[@mr.bootleg424]

John rags on Abigail for being a bad cook, but I wouldn't turn down that T-bone and garlic bread.

[@division1handgun58]

The fact that edgar Ross's cabin is there in rdr2 is pretty cool i wonder if he lives there after the epilogue in 2 and John just never seen him until 1911

[@unclebenjamin9825]

“I thought you was dead... I wasn’t drinking” Goddamn I love Uncle

[@redryder7521]

I swear rdr3 better have a happy f***n' ending, you hear me Rockstar???!?!?

[@lilsavage3802]

Real talk

[@player70477]

Then Jack dies because thats what dead means

[@freakytaco697]

Well then it just wouldn't be a rdr game

[@freakytaco697]

@@vadersfist6495 Landon Ricketts died peacefully in his sleep tho it wouldn't make a good rdr but that's just my opinion

[@PALATA-Gaming]

RDR2 starts from a failed heist in Blackwater where some of their friends died. I doubt it will be happy.

[@beesonbandit6639]

I think jack came up with the idea of writing a book when he’s having that conversation with John

[@hugepickachupenis5961]

I love how Rufus is just chilling during the firefight

[@kincademay7359]

“Revenge is a fools game and it always comes with a noose” -Arthur