Red Flags Of Girl Groups BULLYING You May Not Notice

[@devon7179]

if they acted like this towards her ON CAMERA, imagine how much worse it was when the cameras were off

[@bluepink9816]

it remind me with naeun in extraordinary you scene, the way she potrayed differently on and off camera...

[@emogyu7759]

@@bluepink9816 IKR

[@snehathapa584]

@@bluepink9816 fr

[@meimarsella]

Ikr.. That must be awful

[@blinkherehylt2316]

@@bluepink9816 I didn’t see this. Is there any video for this?

[@rooowtwx]

The reason why a lot of red flags go "unnoticed" is mostly because many of the acts can be interpreted as "oh they are very close so they can be mean to each other".

[@giyaaa]

which is true. We can't jump into conclusions when half of us have never met them and everyone knows nothing about their idols besides how they act on camera. Of course, there are times we have to step in to get an explanation for something. It's just hard to be a fan and completely trust someone you don't really know. This is why I was and still am afraid to venture deeper into k-pop despite having quite a number of groups I stan, the possibilities of them being not who we think they are haunts me. 🙃

[@blueshoes5145]

Or like me they thought it's a coincidence (aka when they all held hands and hyunjoo got left out at the begining) or that were just tired or out of it (like when they look zoned out /disinterested). These compilations can only be made AFTER a scandal pops out because the truth is...most of us won't know unless it's that obvious on camera.

[@astxrism8236]

Yeah but even so, we shouldn’t jump to conclusions even if there are scandals because they may or may not be true..

[@kitsch590]

@@giyaaa Well, we can have a clue....from what people say about them. Like a lot of people say Keanu Reeves is a very kind person. He's nice to people even when he doesn't realize people are watching. Classmates say Jisoo was very kind in school.... and a lot of people say Jennie is very cute and sweet in person....as is Lisa and Rosie. I've never heard anything bad sad about Twice.

[@giyaaa]

@@kitsch590 I agree, but one thing to remember is people change, may it be for the good or bad. Also, there are idols who don't have people defending them. Maybe those idols were not as mature before creating more ruckus now that there's a lot of in-group bullying being exposed. The fact that we all have done some sus stuff before disadvantages the idols today. But clues like that definitely help. Thanks for sharing your insight!

[@yena.jigumina5500]

There might be more kpop idols who are being bullied that we might not know, it's heartbreaking...

[@doubleknotsonmyyeezys5498]

Yeahhh.. hi deobi i advise u not to support this channel bc the person bashes some idols and even bodyshames..

[@ninikikilashvili4926]

@@doubleknotsonmyyeezys5498omg really?

[@doubleknotsonmyyeezys5498]

@@ninikikilashvili4926 yeah in a vid i think outifs nancy "vs" bp

[@doubleknotsonmyyeezys5498]

@smoky joe right??

[@yena.jigumina5500]

@@doubleknotsonmyyeezys5498 oh okayy

[@jhm2732]

I think Rachel deleting APRIL from her insta right after the scandal tells a lot

[@peetscoffeelover]

@@hkimahmd was chaekyoung one of the bullies?

[@peetscoffeelover]

@@hkimahmd ah ok

[@ororla3651]

@@hkimahmd I thought chaewon was innocent? Wasn’t she the only one that wasn’t bullying hyunjoo?

[@hkimahmd]

@@ororla3651 nah she's also one of the bully

[@ororla3651]

@@hkimahmd oh I see, thank you for the info! I don’t stan them but I hope the new members will get to survive those bullies. Actually, I want them to disband or just find the truth to it:(

[@thesteakkimseokjinloves7676]

this is just what was somehow caught on camera. imagine what would’ve have happened off camera

[@punk5hits]

that bully is horrible like always...

[@reneew.7919]

my mind is going everywhere 😣😭

[@fromis.9]

You know nothing about the context and blame them

[@theoran7968]

Please watch "How Mina Assassinated AoA's Jimin Reputation" by Everglowup. She did A LOT of work investigating the actual evidence and it is NOT TRUE. Jimin deserves better but netizens don't care. Just like T-ara, the truth probably won't be addressed for many years, if ever at all.

[@ryuuisnothere]

@@fromis.9 ,,,did you watch the video like, at all??

[@misty9382]

Imagine getting bullied by someone you are supposed to stay with for so long. They are together like 24/7, 365 days(mostly). Getting bullied constantly for so long would be so exhausting both physically and mentally. I can just hope, all of them(bullied idols) are okay.

[@jinhub2175]

I can't imagine the pain they had to go through. I used to get bullied by my teacher in school for 1 year and so my mental & physical health got extremely bad. I couldn't take it for 1 year imagine these idols going through sh¡t for several years. Huge respect for them

[@nova-in9oh]

i cannot imagine what mina had to go through, i literally feel so bad. jimin is a monster to say the least.

[@Attackontitanlover123]

@@nova-in9oh idky people are saying mina is lying...like do u think mental health is a joke? Like srsly

[@cecaniacc]

The very people that's suppose to be their second family

[@kinawa2845]

At least built a healthy business relationship, you can't treat those that have to work with you for so long like that.

[@tochitaillustration9381]

For those who say this is not bullying: This is mental bullying! You don't need to punch someone in the face to be called a bully. Imagine you're working in a group and being boycotted by all the members for no good reasons. That even causes more trauma

[@은-h6p]

This is what happens to me at school- Not all bully is physical. D:

[@은-h6p]

Bullying*

[@swagwanhyung8413]

An example of this is being ignored in which Hyunjoo suffered from. Literally, these are her group mates that she’s supposed to be with forever. They are not just friends but also workmates! The others are being so unprofessional ugh! Imagine just being ignored almost everyday and not being listened to and being shut down! Ofc, she would stay silent all of these times. She became used to it😔

[@aanabs]

There's their so called fans justified those kids rude behaviours as to only acted all-natural and sassy, and to disciplined Hynjoo that they assumed to be slacking. They forgot that Hynjoo actually doesn't make silly mistakes on stage and even joined the UNIT program after departed from her group. Like, if I were Hynjoo I'll also feels uncomfortable around those kids let alone live with them in one dorm for years. Now ex-dsp staff even accused Hynjoo for plastic surgery?! WHAT A JOKE :)

[@dll7658]

Exactly.

[@주누스아시야]

That's why from gg's i stan mostly twice and mamamoo, they are like a family

[@ventibean]

Same. You can tell with the chemistry of those two groups that they genuinely get along with one another.

[@christivaninainggolan2220]

ikr

[@ShaneMorgan]

Same as Dreamcatcher. Very genuine

[@نور-ق1ف1ش]

Same

[@kpopenthusiast9755]

You have Itzy, IZONE, G idle and BP too.

[@thegreatunknown8574]

To be Honest, bullying in Korea is the issue, especially in schools...it's scary to think about all the bullies that actually got careers and influence later on...

[@CIAinTaiwanAndUkraine]

Like every show I watch in korea with schools always have bullying

[@MissRayneNerdiiChicK]

I think this is something that is not addressed because of the Korean hierarchical system(how people are addressed and basically assigned a role in society of how they can be treated) plays a huge role in why bullying is so rampant. The hierarchy and social class/status go hand in hand. I really hope this can be seriously addressed. I feel bad for the youth and all who are victims of bullying.

[@hkimahmd]

agree with this

[@aileen456]

@Chris R it's not normalized

[@SianaGearz]

School Bullying is an issue worldwide. However according to a Unesco report i think that i read a few years back, i don't have it at hand, it's actually comparatively rare in Korea, among the least prevalent in worldwide comparison, and forms that culminate in physical violence are exceptionally rare! Compare that to Lithuania or Ukraine where at least 40% of kids experience severe bullying in a given month and something like 10 or 20% i forget have physically injured their schoolmate on purpose in a given year. So there are a lot of countries with 40-70% bullying rate, USA+Canada are somewhere in the 25-33% region, Sweden closer to 15, Korea stands better than Sweden, at around 10%. You also can't accuse Korea of ignoring the issue, since a number of regulations, laws and measures have been launched over the 20 years to help mitigate bullying, perhaps the most extensive worldwide. Of course being less prevalent and better handled in international comparison doesn't make it a problem to be ignored, it's severe to those who experience it. i think i looked up all these things when flor_us (recently disbanded for economic reasons) released Masquerade, their first song, topic of which was bullying. I don't think it's wise to make up your image of a society from what it portrays in fiction.

[@Sheepy16able]

Weird to see Naeun getting bullied in my favourite KDrama but being a bully herself in reallife...

[@sudiptakar6955]

seriously i also never thought, guess what you can't see through the innocent faces they make

[@kay-tt8dn]

Exactly I was so disappointed from this video..

[@mamatakesarkar7444]

Same...in extraordinary you ( my fav drama ) she was bullied. Its really disappointing to see her as the bully

[@prettylife6086]

IKRRRRR

[@punk5hits]

ikr?

[@meh7497]

Just imagine how horrifying it was to live with not only one but four of your bullies 24/7 😭😭😭

[@kitsch590]

They were ganging up on her.

[@chiwilovely]

reading this just gave me shivers omg

[@jennydelaflor2087]

This.

[@ellenphilpotts-troy2098]

A living torture.

[@jtwinny4105]

and then not being able to tell anyone about it…

[@Persona_1398]

Fans should stop assuming groups are automatically close. Getting put in a girl group is the equiv of a teacher putting you in groups in class. Sometimes you get lucky and are with people you like and sometimes not. They have to live together, work together. If you don’t like someone you can’t avoid them. Doesn’t make it okay to bully them though…

[@EvalleDeMonaco]

I hope NewJeans is okay honestly 👀👀 like they are such young girls. Not saying they are bullying it's just it's a possibility because bullying is so common

[@Persona_1398]

@@EvalleDeMonaco with them I’m more worried about the sexualisation. Within a couple years I’m sure they’ll all be traumatised and in therapy. They’re really talented but being sexualised and exposed to such hostility at such a young age messes you up. I mean IVE Wonyoung is a child and she’s getting death threats. K-Pop is crazy

[@EvalleDeMonaco]

@@Persona_1398 IVE WONYOUNG IS GETTING DEATH THREATS? Starship better be protecting my girl or I'm gonna let them know how it feel to have a knife through their head 🤭

[@ariadnafriski_]

Agree

[@carat_light]

​@@Persona_1398 There is a reason so many older girl groups seem to be fond of/are looking after New Jeans; they don't want them to have the same fate :/

[@smolmin9660]

It's quite sad though because we would never know what is happening behind the scene

[@butter8552]

Sadly🥺

[@Nova-club]

*what is happening behind the scene

[@butter8552]

@@Nova-club as in the mistreatment these idols go through we will never about about it

[@oneitx1forever14]

Your username is too good

[@Nova-club]

@@butter8552 that’s sad 😢

[@thesteakkimseokjinloves7676]

april’s 4 members who were rude should literally be kicked out of the industry like jimin from aoa. bullying is no joke. it brings some serious issues for the victims edit: guys I am aware of the truth now. peace out please. back then jimin was seen as the wrong one which is why I made this comment.

[@froschesee4533]

But their f*cking agency really protect those 4 members, and claimed that Hyunjoo is lying about the bullying. Disgusting agency 😏

[@fmjjjjn7510]

What’s going on

[@breakpoint4268]

@@yujinism6870 Ok I see know I didn’t know she had been accused of bullying but it’s not about fairness she could’ve very well left and failed in the industry their group wasn’t always popular they’re just now getting more traction. Don’t hate on the group! I also would say we should wait until either somin comes forward I know bullying is common and we seemingly have the “full story” we weren’t there and don’t know all the details let’s hope the agency acts on these accusations instead of trying to shut them down.

[@minarii3554]

No wonder april still doesnt det their first win yet i hope they are disband

[@vixxexo6855]

That is too much for just bullying. They did not commit a crime. People like 6ix9ine still have a career.

[@adriannagreaves6356]

y’all need to give those other april members the energy y’all give to jimin

[@tadmira127dreamuvtadmir2]

They are so hypocritical , double standard

[@jam6486]

right, people are actually on defending them.

[@ongakira]

jimin a situation was diff bc they way she defended herself. she legit posted g0re to prove that she was innocent

[@kazuma1569]

Are they still in the industry?

[@CC-il5qr]

@@kazuma1569 yeah but they wer proven innocent

[@angelb173]

I´m from Brazil and there´s a korean youtuber that lives here,she´s really famous between kpop fans. She said in one of her videos where she collaborated with a male korean youtuber that lives here too that she admires how brazilian women are so used and not ashamed to compliment and help other womens, we are always hyping each other up. She said that in Korea it happens a lot between korean men but not between korean women.She said they are always so worried about looking beautiful and inside the Korean standards of beauty that when they see another woman looking more beautiful or receiving more attention, they get easily jealous and starts hating them without even getting to know them. That´s why most of them don´t compliment each other and end up in bullying, because they see each other as competition. And i think that´s why it happens a lot more in girl groups rather than boy groups.

[@daizielmuncal]

This thing also happend in philippines

[@hiddendoragon6867]

Wow seriously.. I didn't know that.. well can't blame anyone.. this beauty standard is cultural..

[@Katzerina]

Hey, I’m from Russia and I think we have same problem as you described.

[@jadenionova4430]

And still dsp & the bullies had the AUDACITY to accuse that Hyungjoo of lying and repeatedly calling her weak

[@lesley8256]

Hyunjoo**

[@aliez8280]

Logicaly if hyunjoo mental was so weak she would never go to "UNI.T " audition to be an idol ....!!

[@leeminhyung6733]

@@aliez8280 thats right👍

[@paulineroseesteban7026]

SN Aliez she said she went to psychiatrist and she took her shot because she has always wanted to be an idol so if that’s what makes her to be happy and forget the hell she went through so be it.

[@scarship8250]

@@aliez8280 um sorry but you are literally excusing bullying??

[@juleye6248]

Their bullying might not be like physically harsh but this kind of subtle bullying really messes up your mental health. It will make you lose self confidence. And in Hyunjoo's case, ALL of the members literally ignore and make fun of her. How lonely must it had been for her..

[@joielazu7867]

Hyunjoo admitted the bullying, and the worst part was, she said that she's been bullied also physically

[@danielloves7991]

I mean even the agency forced her to sing in a cute way and i dont just mean like Twice singing in high pitches, she was literally scolded if she sounded mature. She revealed it on The Unit when people where dragging her down bcs of her aegyo voice that she used even in mature performances. That girl literally forgot how to sing in a different voice that is not aegyo heavy. It is obvious she was heavily pressured the whole time there. And only bcs DSP knew she would be popular and the group needs her charm. Which also played part in the whole bullying thing I guess. She supposedly begged the agency to not debut her in this group. And yes since her brother posted her medical records about her trying to S-word herself it definitely messed her up big time.

[@juleye6248]

@@danielloves7991 wtf DSP... They really have a long history of mistreatment towards their artist

[@redefinedliving5974]

and people think being pretty makes you lucky

[@redefinedliving5974]

@Cupcake Bunni stop trying to be politically correct lol she's the visual for a reason. there are people who are objectively more beautiful, accept it. and looks like she's not even more beautiful externally, we can say internally as well

[@joo222e5]

april - disappointed jimin - mad and furious come on y’all keep the same energy

[@lovedmulti5790]

@@fromis.9 what are you so angry for?

[@fromis.9]

@@lovedmulti5790 destroying an innocent group with the best songs in entire gen 3 kpop

[@oxcherrx]

@@fromis.9 what's the point they having the best song/music but lack of attitude and bullying people?

[@fromis.9]

@@oxcherrx the only one lack of attitude and bullying people is you, 99% of the commenter here and especially Hyunjoo

[@thetreethatjoontalksto1150]

@@fromis.9 so your basically supporting bullies? Haha

[@yurika_edits]

AoA is example of why EVERYONE needs to stop judging a situation with a one sided story.

[@itsiraa]

it's happening again with Lesserafim, not even debuted -.-

[@ishhita.aggarwal]

@@itsiraa I don't think it's the same because their case is different.

[@kimjunkyu5331]

@@ishhita.aggarwal exactly

[@kimjunkyu5331]

Yeah but all situation are different

[@yurika_edits]

@@kimjunkyu5331 either way, both sides deserve to tell their story (not talking about the lesserafim, cuz idek them)

[@Alysaah]

Wow I’m kinda glad April really isn’t that popular. They literally go around bully any of the members and the rudest seems the be the youngest member

[@kitsch590]

Never heard of them until this scandal.

[@mulan7405]

@@kitsch590 Heard of them but never interested

[@kitsch590]

@@mulan7405 After hearing about the bullying, I don't really want to click to support them. I can't tolerate that level of harassment. It's one thing to get angry at someone. It's another to keep up sustained harassment.

[@WonHakWoon]

I never liked their music at all, glad I didn't and glad I still don't

[@CIAinTaiwanAndUkraine]

I only heard of them because of that song where one member literally didn't get a single line

[@rbiyav.3958]

I felt disappointed in April, especially from Naeun. I really liked her acting and thought she was really shy and kind. 💀💀

[@carljanenengasca3908]

I know right never really thought of this

[@anya21_10]

Same for me I saw her first in extraordinary you and when I came to know that she is an idol I was happy but I'm really disappointed with her

[@Aizannn]

Dude see her looks previously.. she clearly did something on her face after getting more money due to reduced members. Slitting her eyes to make it bigger is obvious

[@nayeemabegum7308]

Tbh i never even liked her as an actor I always thought something was off about her

[@lunalovegood6357]

Same I really like naeun and april songs...

[@mako5856]

i hate jimin from aoa but give april the EXACT same energy to aprils 4 members or even more cause constantly bullying a member is disgusting.

[@dararariiii2567]

Lmao if you said this on twitter April stans will literally eat you alive😭 some are even gaslighting Hyunjoo.

[@mako5856]

@@dararariiii2567 i know i would and there disgusting- they would probably say for me to kill myself smh.

[@cantputashrugasausernameso5105]

Don't forget Somin. Hyunjoo said SHE started the bullying towards her during their time as trainees and when they were a predebut group. Save some of that energy for her as well

[@mako5856]

@@cantputashrugasausernameso5105 agreed no one who was involved should not be praised but should get hate like they did to hyunjoo and rachel.

[@donniesalcedo6366]

Who is the four devil in april sorry im new😅

[@Memequeen89]

Jimin is literally the only person I’ve ever seen get cancelled in Kpop I’m honestly just shocked. I can see it happening in boy groups. I kinda think it happened in exo back when they had 12 members (think they all got closer after kris, luhan, and Tao left). I think the groups that have the most lasting success are groups that genuinely like each other. AOA always had a dynamic where the girls were just colleagues, not friends. That’s why they never grew as artists and why they fell apart when choa left.

[@taengooyaa7338]

I guess its the mistreatment from the management that made KrisTaoHan left. They are really close to each other. But then, yes, we do not know the whole story.

[@polysporin8332]

even though Jimin was the leader, at least with Choa (being the eldest) she could put an end to some of the bullying when she was present. With her leaving the group, there was no one left to protect Mina.

[@feithful]

@@polysporin8332 you don’t know that. don’t assume.

[@mr.a9696]

@@polysporin8332 lmao you're comment didn't age well kekekkeke Mina is a freaking psychopath. She doesn't need any protection

[@SilmeriaFantasy]

The heck… please don’t make such statements without clearly knowing nothing about them… and so do the people that liked your comment hhh

[@Catch-The-Ghost]

“Bullies gain strength from silence.” One thing I’ve definitely noticed boy groups saying is, “Oh yeah, we fought at lot at the begining/as trainees.” There may be something there about how boys are quicker to lash out about injustices and quickly resolve slights before they get too big. Where as girls may sometimes avoid confrontation and let bad behavior grow while bottling emotions until that becomes the norm. The longer that goes on, the harder it is to stand up to mistreatment later.

[@moonchild8403]

Girls from a very young age are constantly trained to act nice even if that meant to hide their real self... Thats why girls don't fight like boys do, resulting in hidden grudge and lot's of drama

[@PolliitoAle]

Idk why this reminds me to the Blackpink documentary, when Lisa and Rose said that they fought many times when they first met 🤔 maybe that's why they're closer?

[@Aditi-mb3qm]

@@moonchild8403 True 💯

[@alwaysunitg6470]

Agree . If your quiet, they make fun at you . Some reality of life

[@lillianpasta2486]

@@PolliitoAle yeah🤣😂,actually they still fight and tease a lot. I remember one time when jisoo and lisa were doing a vlive,Rosé actually ate some of lisa's rice and lisa immediately went and told rosé which bowl is hers. All the fans in the vlive could here them arguing over the rice and jisoo was laughing at this whole ordeal.

[@blackthreads1821]

Won’t even be surprised if it’s true that Hyunjoo was the said “lazy” When you been bullied 24/7 and live with your bullies it gets physically and emotionally effing exhausting tf do you expect?! she was so depleted she considered suicide

[@lunalouve1674]

True. I was bullied by all my teachers and a lot of school mates. I was body shamed and humiliated in public. Which is why I rarely attend school every week, always late at morning ceremonies, church mass, don't attend school festivals and stuff. I developed severe anxiety and depression to the point Nov 2019 was the last time I left the gate at my house. I lost interest and became lazy in school and going out. Though, 2020 I was home studied.

[@borneostreasurebox8339]

fr, i see some april fans defending naeun claiming that hyunjoo was just being dramatic & doesnt contribute much to the group... when ur being bullied for years how would u have the energy to perform smh

[@6rebelangel]

It's very common for people to be mistaken as "lazy" when they are actually depressed. People call unmotivated others "lazy" because they're too caught up in their own problems to properly look at said person and put 2-and-2 together to realize that they might actually have a problem and need help. The truth is: it's easier to accuse someone of laziness then it is to take the time to actually care about somebody other than yourself.

[@naegopayooo]

@@6rebelangel tru, people don't really get it sometimes. They will look and decide just based on what they see without thinking beyond.

[@saltNpepper952]

I can say that this is true. When you're being socially left out and you feel useless to the people around you it is possible to feel even more depressed and more likely to want to hide away instead

[@RotishaTamang]

In k-pop Bullying is the most disgusting and worst fact !!!

[@theMerryMonarch]

I feel like the sexual crimes like the forced prostitution of idols is worse

[@icebear4724]

@@theMerryMonarch What does that mean?

[@theMerryMonarch]

@@icebear4724 it means that idols are either perpetrators (doing) of sexual assault or victims of sexual assault by managers or fans. And several female idols have been forced into prostitution by their companies.

[@jadet9640]

That's not only in K-pop

[@yjl__04]

But that’s the reality. Face it. We never know the truth behind the idols. There are so many in the industry that are bullying, committing crimes, and such. We just don’t know who. We also never know if someone got accused for doing something disgusting.

[@jennaaaxoxo]

I feel so bad for the idols who got bullied by their own members.

[@snsdtwinkle]

The way Hyunjoo was my bias before she left April and then Rachel became my bias when she joined. My spidey senses were tingling before I even knew what the fuck was going on

[@nialapin]

Same... and Mina was my favorite member in AOA...

[@hkimahmd]

Same duhhh… Rachel and Chaekyung is my faves. while the others bullying Rachel and Chaekyung

[@mariannebec9871]

ME TOO AND MI AOA BIAS WAS MINA *good people are always loved*

[@xheom]

the bullies are mad and jealous because they're too admirable unlike them:'(

[@nikemaraje5]

You're so special 😍

[@carol-vt5ev]

can you please change this thumbnail??? those girls are from DIA and they’ve never had any bullying scandals so PLEASE take them off the thumbnail and put april instead

[@Allisonwunderlandd]

They definitely should because I clicked on this video to figure out happened between the DIA members (since I'd never heard of any animosity).

[@atecha]

same i stan dia and i clicked bc of them... the real enemy of dia and aid is mbk!!!

[@atecha]

@@Allisonwunderlandd there is a bit of animosity actually but i dont think it caused any bullying to happen??? afaik?? yebin and somyi talked about it on their the unit audition ://

[@Strawberymari]

@@atecha they said the felt bad for being chaeyeon and friends. I don't think there was bullying involved. The just wish they had a bit more recognition for more members than just Chaeyeon

[@Strawberymari]

@@atecha and I agree with this so much. Mbk needs to stop treating them so badly. I hurts :( the girls work so hard and try so hard to give us content and talk to us but mbk does nothing

[@chickennugget4052]

The worst thing about the aoa situation is that Jimin is the leader... a leader should be there for their members

[@mizterxc]

She is no longer the leader, in fact she is no longer even a member of AOA as of July 2020, there is only 3 AOA members left now: Hyejeong, Seolhyun and Chanmi

[@hummoon6920]

i actually curious about what happened to seolhyun, pretty sure she's got so much to tell but probably can't.. I've been watching all of their appearances on variety show etc since the beginning of their career, since then I've seeing some of them treating her like hyunjoo from april and only jimin stood there for her.. jimin probably wrong for bullying someone, but there's definitely untold story about seolhyun... she was so popular back then until the scandals hit her like a truck and it's looks like some of the members so happy about what happened to her, until one by one the members departed from the group.. it's looks like seolhyun finally be able to breathe, too bad it was so short... even tho disband is the only way for aoa, telling her side of story is not against any laws :(

[@davidwong6682]

@@hummoon6920 Seolhyun is still acting and she was in a cop-related TV series called Awaken recently. I guess that while she is still with FNC she wouldn't be able to tell her side of the story.

[@davidwong6682]

Ultimately poor leadership has led to the current situation of AOA.

[@hummoon6920]

@@davidwong6682 i always keep my eyes on her, she's like a big sis i want to protect ever since i saw what the ex-member did to her. glad she's still manage to keep her reputation even after all the bad things that happened to her. well, no matter how hard its for a public figure to speak up and how long the truth gonna reach people, at the end of the day.. it will come out :)

[@cherrymadden.]

How many of this “bullying scandals turning out being fake” need to happen so fans can learn to always listen to both side of the story before throwing hate! This vid should be taken down or at least have a pinned comment with updated info

[@axisboise]

Exactly!

[@NaomiiS]

FRRRRR

[@zah936]

true

[@plmdea]

I swear! So many people really believe that AOA, Mina, was a victim. I know this video was a year ago, but dispatch made it true a year ago, that Jimin was never a bully! Plus APRIL members I haven’t read anything yet, but I don’t know if many or all were bullying the former member.

[@sarahsomerhalder5482]

man.. being bullied by one person who lives with you is heavy enough.. but multiply that by four? someone said y'all need to give these girls the same energy you showed for jimin, and that's true

[@Maddie..123]

What did they do to jimin?

[@kitsch590]

Freezing someone out and ignoring them is psychologically damaging.

[@littlemisscypris]

@@Maddie..123 Jimin builled her former member Mina, and she was getting so much hate and attention but the 4 members didn't get any attention at all for bully their member Hyunjoo

[@Maddie..123]

@@littlemisscypris Oh ok thank you!

[@cintaranayanika]

Aged like milk

[@plantadelbosque]

tbh I doubt it's only girl groups. Korea has a big problem with bullying, and with all that militaristic thing going on, I won't be surprised there is as much bullying in boy groups as in girl groups. Just that we haven't heard a single one of them because it would look "unmanly" to speak up... I also kind of blame the system. I honestly cannot understand how idols work AND live together with the same people. For the majority of us, if something goes awry at your workplace, you can relax at home and forget everything. Yet here, you're constantly pushed to the limit. I'm kinda sad I always bring them up, but he's the only one I know who has been that open: Key from SHINee. He himself said that SHINee didn't have the best of relationships when they were living in a dorm, but once they separated, they became bffs. So yeah, I feel that might be a good step to improve the situation for idols in general

[@SianaGearz]

Korea has some of the the lowest prevalence of school bullying worldwide, less than Sweden! It's also the country with the most extensive measures by law against bullying, and the most opportunities for victim support. Bullying being tackled by the popular fictional media is also something that is done as a mitigation strategy, to make victims seek help and not feel alone - as a media company, you can get government grants for advancing social causes. Though it remains human nature, so all mitigating measures taken together aren't going to come close to preventing it entirely. And yet it's a fight worth fighting. But yes, it can potentially be more difficult to judge male groups whether they have some kind of bullying or exclusionary behaviours like seen here, because they have an overall much more reserved presentation. Close bodily gestures and touching are common to girl groups, so for example i suspected that Nayeon might be a bully, but at the end, i'm not worried since i have seen every member invite her to sit in their lap and vice versa, which shows that everyone is at deep comfort with her.

[@plantadelbosque]

@@SianaGearz I'm not familiar with those statistics tbh. But to know how trustworthy they are, you need to know the methodology. Once again, if bullying is *not* reported, then how can it be measured? I do admit my words come from anecdotes. Every Korean I've meet have had a bullying experience. I live in Japan, so it's not just one or two people, but of course it is not the full picture. Even less in comparison with other countries. But being completely honest? I don't think it is that relevant... I just wish abuse, in any way, shape or form could be diminished. No matter if they are the first or last in the rankings

[@eliza5473]

I honestly think bullying isn't that much heard or seen in boy groups because let's be honest here, girls get jealous over other girls easier than boys; this is all because of (mainly) beauty standards society puts on us women, emotions are seen to be more linked with women while for boys is strength or power, so emotions like jealousy are easier to be felt by female idols than male idols. I think for guys when they have issues going on they would fight or scream at each other and then talk it over, while girls won't say "sorry I'm just jealous you're prettier or you sing better or have more fans" or whatever, so the issue or feeling only grows bigger, because it isn't talked about nor resolved. I say this because I have way more male friends and overall I've interacted with males way more than with women and I've noticed it is easier for them to talk about everything and even comfort each other and I don't see them badmouthing each other behind their backs as I've seen with girls (this also depends on how close girls are with each other but I've seen it's really hard for women to open up to other women for fear to be disappointed or "back stabbed" so they mostly trust only one true friend), so to me it's easier for boy groups to resolve misunderstandings and not have bullying scandals (this depends obviously on how close they manage to get, but eventually they warm up to each other as seen with Monsta X's I.M. or SJ's Kyuhyun, who weren't really liked at first by their respective groups for the fact that they got into the groups last, when a friendship and bond had already been set, however the members of their groups warmed up to them and now they're loved and spoiled by them.

[@arnabchatterjee8611]

Agreed but I do think girl groups have more bullying because the matter of looking good, being the best, standing out are things that have been drilled into the heads of many female idols to the point where a lot of them are made to think that without looks they are nothing. Wanting to be the center of attention are things that are just generally more visible in female idol bullying cases . With guys the problem is harder to come by because they have fights openly that solve the problems before it grows.

[@andreinapereira552]

and suju too. They are very open about the way they treated Kyuhyun back then

[@sheenisweird]

the sad thing is that this really isn't anything new. i remember when people mentioned red flags about 4minute and miss a mistreating hyuna and suzy, especially after both groups disbanded. jessi even mentioned during a live once that actually a lot of girl group members don't like each other in real life and it really makes you think how many more victims are out there rn...

[@deerine]

please for the love of god stop spreading the lies that 4minute bullied hyuna. they all loved each other and were like a family. yes the disbandment did originally strain the friend ship but all the members have liked pictures supporting hyuna's comeback last year. Both Hyuna and Jiyoon were having comebacks and Jiyoon shared that she thinks Hyuna is a solo singer that has already succeeded and hence she has lots to learn from Hyuna. Upon hearing that Hyuna was also facing health issues right before the comeback, Jiyoon shared her well wishes, hoping that Hyuna will recover soon. None of the girls hated each other so please don't mention 4Minute in comment sections under these types of videos. They are not in contact any more but there is no animosity between any of them, they are simply not close anymore.

[@dilykairdos8547]

Why you think that Miss A bullied Suzy. She has very good relationship with Fey. Btw what it's mean "rn" ?

[@whiterose1831]

@@dilykairdos8547 rn = right now

[@dilykairdos8547]

@@whiterose1831 oh, thanks 😊

[@claudiapopa861]

Imagine how sad it is to work your back off as a trainee and then being put in a group where you're mistreated. The girls who got bullied deserve so much more respect.

[@Ryanaspen]

jihyo isn’t a bully or a hater all once knew that she always makes that face for fun idk how to explain but yeah

[@4foryouglencoco607]

Yea no worries xD we know Twice tease eachother and are blunt because theyre so close like sisters - no harm done

[@Ryanaspen]

@@4foryouglencoco607 yes exactly thank u!!

[@gotdibs3895]

Yeah honestly you know when people bully the ones they love/like against someone they dislike or feel jealous of right? Twice, itzy have bullying moments but heck the laughter and counter attacks were so natural and real like sisters unlike those above that are like hiding their annoyance all through out and faking their laughters, disgusting

[@meowtybae1610]

yeah we all once know how twice love and close each others

[@camilleniel6484]

yeah im not even a once but jihyo shouldn't be cancelled for that. i mean it's like a teasing face or behavior towards their member doing an aegyo. almost all gfrd members do that esp sinb to eunha whenever she does aegyo and apink members to bomi. i mean that's teasing behavior is natural and i understand you

[@ryuryu8796]

naeun is definition of angel face but actually have a satan personality

[@vandelope9737]

Fact✨

[@meh7497]

Nahhh she isn't even pretty

[@shenshouting]

@@meh7497 same. For me hyunjoo is more prettier

[@lalaloopsy5846]

@@vandelope9737 so?

[@vandelope9737]

@@lalaloopsy5846 LOL so her beauty is not natural duhhh

[@jnkiee]

The part where Mina was being criticized at an event broke my heart. Not even because Jimin was happy, but because she looked so sad it just makes me wanna give her a hug 😭

[@kitsch590]

That anti fan said some really vile things to her. I was really surprised when I read what he said.

[@RosarysLove]

They weren't even criticizing her. There's a difference between being rude and a criticizer. When you criticize you tell a person how to improve, but that person at the event was straight up degrading her like a idiot.

[@saenahunny.]

@@kitsch590 what did he say?

[@leuserafim]

This comment aged like milk

[@yesno6994]

@@leuserafim wait why?

[@onewhiteswan]

Proud to Stan Blackpink.... They always treat eachother like real sisters. All of them are pretty, talented, hardworking, down to earth, humble and kind. You'll never catch'em making eachother uncomfortable or trying to drag eachother down. They all give eachother time to shine.

[@windyp0d]

But the sad part is the solo stans trying to ruin their relationships.. I HATE (toxic) SOLO STANS!! like why do they have to hate on the other members because their idol didn't get the spotlight for 1 SEC. i really hope they overcome this and are not awkward around each other because of these stupid ass solo stans. "You can only be a blink if you love all of the members. it's okay to have biases but don't hate on the members. 4 - 1 = 0." is what i wanna tell them but they too dumb to understand. lol why did i just write a paragraph-

[@anonymousjanedoe]

Same!

[@anonymousjanedoe]

@@windyp0d Yeah and the shippers ruin it as well that's why blackpink and BTS barely interact because of ships and scandals. T- T why can't idols just be friends with each other..

[@windyp0d]

@@anonymousjanedoe ikrr :")

[@windyp0d]

@@anonymousjanedoe also the fanwars and hating. they never get a break T-T

[@honeybuns6771]

I think the reason why girl groups tend to have a lot of bullying involved is because women tend to be harshly criticized & barely praised compared to men. so the girls must’ve been through a lot as trainees & later let out their anger on the one they think is like a pushover or who’ll let it happen.

[@bxyz626]

I agree maybe the management played a part in probably comparing the girls to each other hyunjoo being the visual the other girl were most likely jealous. But that still doesn’t excuse it.

[@honeybuns6771]

Basma I totally agree that this doesn’t excuse their behavior towards one of the members, but I’ve always noticed people who are bullies are ones who can’t manage their anger. no ones born a monster or a rude person, it’s always taught.

[@stop4500]

Internalized misogyny breeds toxic competitiveness in women.

[@coquettecore1386]

@@stop4500 this is so true

[@aanabs]

Severe criticism and lack of apreciation seems to applied to both. But its no secret that women are being overly sexualized in kpop. But I think that doesn't seems to be applied in these cases tho. K-showbiz tend to focused on particular member like fotg and/or visual makes other members envious ("Why did she become the center of attention? I work harder than her. She's an attention seeker look at the way she talk, its too much, I am better than her,...blah blah") so their bullying is a fruit of their accumulated jealousy and frustation, something like that.

[@purpleglitz]

The intro with Irene was so out of pocket because the members have all come out and said how she's like a big sister/mother to them.

[@imnottheone3911]

Didn't she cuss out an assistant and make them cry...

[@purpleglitz]

@@imnottheone3911 What does a private matter that has already been sorted out have anything to do with her character as a member of rv? Also, them living together for 7+ years when other groups usually split far before then should be an indicator of how close they are.

[@nurulfarzana6898]

@@imnottheone3911 bruh. You trust a staff who just work ONCE for her. The staff definitely did something wrong that's why she's mad at her/(him). Plus, the other 60+ staffs keep saying how nice irene is towards them.

[@jeliyahbieber6854]

@@imnottheone3911 Actually the stylist did something really bad and then Irene scolded her later which made an misunderstanding between the two

[@yutisima]

@@nurulfarzana6898 please don't insult the worker, they shared their story but kindly and only wanted wanted apology which they got and they insisted people stop disliking Irene because she apologised to them already and people should move on. Irene was wrong for yelling at a worker, but it's not a sin nor something to ruin her life over

[@harrytimmy5070]

Am I the only one who sees her looking like Tzuyu for some reason?

[@sayeema7012]

Omg.. when I first saw her I also thought she's tzuyu

[@bellehoney6321]

yes and also Dahyun in that one picture 4:32

[@punk5hits]

hyunjoo face is hybrid of all beauty...

[@Toy_In_Tub]

I saw Dahyun and Jisoo, especially at 0:53 and now that you said it, I see Tzuyu as well 😂

[@arslnadar6578]

@@Toy_In_Tub lol I can see that now

[@RosyTa]

i can imagine that ggs may have more bullying incidents because of how easy it is to be pressured and stressed by the industry. it doesn’t help that if a girl becomes jealous of another girl than that feeling will likely never go away… i hope we as fans can support victims of bullying and hold people more accountable. and i hope in the future that companies will take bullying issues much more seriously and properly.

[@warrencaelum9536]

As soon as i saw Rachel getting 0 lines in April Story, i already felt something weird and sad. Anyone else felt that too?

[@hafizah0366]

Which song

[@warrencaelum9536]

@@hafizah0366 i already said it, it's April Story

[@CIAinTaiwanAndUkraine]

I fear she is their next target after Hyunjoo

[@bakamiku9428]

This makes me think of Everglow Onda.. I hope she is not going through the same shit.

[@inxiaomnia]

@@bakamiku9428 i never thought of Onda not until you said it. Damn I'm hoping shes not treated this way.

[@방탄앙제]

How is no one talking about one of the times where rachael was bullied was in one of the songs they sang,april's story. RACHAEL DID NOT SING A SINGLE WORD!

[@siputthesnail3785]

So that's why she doesn't have any lines in that song

[@방탄앙제]

That is what I think.

[@dragonair01]

that's not the members bullying. that's the company staff's decision. same for all the idols with no lines in other groups.

[@VolumePerfection]

Usually the producers and the company decide who sings what and who suits the song better. It could be that the team felt like her voice didn't suit the concept

[@방탄앙제]

@@VolumePerfection That is a good idea,but she should have at least been able to sing just one line. She was just completely left out

[@user-em7rx6gs4g]

It’s funny how naeun was being bullied in ‘extraordinary you’ but she was the one bullying in real life 💀

[@eunhastolemyheart6098]

April was jealous that Hyunjoo was prettier than them, imagine being that salty. Most Kpop girl group members are happy for their fellow members when they get praised. Because, you know, they're decent human beings?

[@realvibekilla4547]

I don't think u needed to include jihyo's and irene's clips here cause it may lead to non fans think that they are bullies too even tho it is not your intention(?) smh 🤦🏻‍♀️ Edit: Some of the replies in my comment says that you even put group pic of other kpop girl group in the thumbnail 🤦🏻‍♀️.

[@Purpelspy]

seriously. and they used a random group in the thumbnail :/

[@arimamira]

Fr

[@shenshouting]

Yeah. Irene's issue is different.

[@Orblinkluv]

Yeah I didn't like that either. It'll bring about misinformation

[@sb.mrrrbll_5730]

yes. jihyo and irene is way farther than these bullies.

[@Angel-ej4ui]

I still can't believe the April scandal I used to love them so much and I really loved Naeun she just seemed so nice and innocent to me but turns out she was faking being innocent I'm really disappointed and feel so bad for poor Hyunjoo and Rachel 🥺 I hope they both are doing better now🥺

[@wtzzz]

And chaekyung too .i hope Rachel and hyunjoo,chaekyung keep strong

[@Lalaland_130]

I heard that Rachel delete all photos of April member in her ig but im not sure if its true tho

[@megumegumi174]

I am also really disappointed cause Naeun was my bias in April

[@Jetty06]

Not only Naeun bullying their member

[@megumegumi174]

@@Jetty06 Yes and that’s really sad

[@seonghwatoothless1200]

The fact that Naeun acts as the one being bullied in kdramas

[@d4630]

damn, i feel so much for her!! I was treated in a similar way by "friends" whenever I was younger and it totally ruined my confidence and self-esteem. I truly hope that she is able to stay strong and that she has good support from friends and family - soo glad that she was able to leave

[@realnaryyl]

I'm just glad that my ult group (TWICE) has a good relationship with each other. At least, with the interactions ive seen on videos. ❤️

[@lushychan]

true bcs they shared the same hardships through a survival show and it makes them to hold onto each other more than any other group.

[@imahfathin2660]

yesssss

[@kateremullo5488]

YESSSS

[@nova-in9oh]

the april members who allegedly "bullied" hyunjoo are literally so disgusting. and the fact that people are over looking this topic makes it even worse. how did this get 1k likes 😩😩😩

[@bxyz626]

Facts and for some reason there are people that still support them and don’t believe it.

[@anilabullari7487]

I agree, its seriously so disgusting. Those girls should be kicked out of the industry honestly. Bullying is not a joke and can lead to as far as suic1de. Not cool

[@khiii7810]

@@anilabullari7487 Ikrrrr like I can’t imagine how she’s treated off camera if the members alr act like this on camera

[@nova-in9oh]

@@bxyz626 and the fact that DSP media literally has all the evidence in front of their eyes, but decides to ignore it and file a lawsuit against her

[@bxyz626]

@@nova-in9oh there insane but did you see now hyunjoo is filing a lawsuit against an employee at dsp media who accused her of lying

[@chichirockin13]

The feeling of being ostracized from your group mates you're basically with 24 hours especially during rookie days is extremely terrifying

[@aagbayani]

sitting here thinking about how badly ive wanted to knock my bullies out and seeing these girls who were stuck with their bullies 24/7 that havent lost their shit yet, mad respect for self control and i hope they get the help they need in order to get out of that situation

[@aagbayani]

@J J you are absolutely right

[@tofusuns896]

It really is more prone in girl groups mostly because we girls have this quiet competition within ourselves. We always (even unconsciously) try to compare ourselves to other girls, whether the dress you're wearing, your perfume, your shoes, your grade, voice, EVERYTHING!!! We're always insecure for unknown reasons... Edit: yall may misunderstand my comment, anyways THERE ARE A LOT OF REASONS OK i just didn't have time to list down every single one "unknown" means you can't just give one, there's a lot and even if I'm a woman idk every single reason so it's kind of unknown, anyways sorry if that offended anyone, i may have used the wrong term

[@percy-fiedbeauty8683]

That is true but it's not enough for most of us to resort to bullying others to feel better about ourselves. Plus I really doubt that Jeon Somin had really bullied Hyunjoo. She was probably a victim too and just decided to keep quiet about it so that when she departed it would be with very little ties to the rest of April. But that's my guess.

[@tofusuns896]

@@percy-fiedbeauty8683 we don't really know their stories and we don't know how koreans actually behave and think based on their own culture so 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

[@gabriela-id8jb]

Female rivality created by the society we live 😐

[@an-eh2wn]

We're not insecure "for unknown reasons," like the reason is that society lives off comparing women against each other, whether over appearance, personality, talent, etc., and we internalize that and start doing it ourselves. Even this whole designation of "visual" within groups is kind of ridiculous tbh, like all of the girls are already pretty, to go ahead and designate one or two members as "the pretty ones" is obviously going to make other people feel insecure. There are even girls who think it's fine to model their entire personalities around "hating all other girls" (pick-mes, for example). I think it's the consequence of years of society promoting female competition [for male validation] instead of female solidarity. I wouldn't say that means men never "bully" each other--look at standard locker room/prison hierarchical cultures. But yeah, men do tend to deal with their interpersonal problems in much more direct ways, while women have to resort to more backhanded channels like bullying.

[@skarbuskreska]

@@an-eh2wn Boys compete too with each other. But they can do it openly. But society has told girls/women for ages, that we have to act nice. So girls/woman found their own ways around that (the negative emotions were there after all) and you will find them gossiping and ridiculing (destroy others reputation), being extremely mean but in subtle ways (thus undermining others self-esteem) and all these things.

[@dreamdeukaes]

I really hate bullies and those who are should be extended to the fullest with extreme consequence's.

[@lunalins1114]

It is really hard to recognize bullying for mocking a friend or something and this is heartbreaking bc someone may being bullied and we would never know..

[@gstar81]

I think it happens more often in girl groups cause they get the most pressure and criticism from the public as well as constantly compared to other idols. Girls groups definitely have to deal with a lot more which creates more internal competition and stress

[@loki8450]

that one bully girl is from extraordinary you, right? her role is getting bullied but in real life she-

[@hyejoosego5338]

yes that's her, naeun

[@sehunseyebrows5067]

Yes the small clips of Extraordinary You that were uploaded have lots of comments of her being a bully

[@chuuuuu1375]

Yeah she’s a snake

[@leralorve12]

The irony

[@yaliaaaa.]

Yes! I saw the drama like two months ago and I noticed how she was really good at acting and going back at her bullies.

[@findingyuri5467]

April are just jeolous of Hyunjoo's visual

[@user-lesserafim0502]

I'm really so sad for Hyunjoo like seriously! All of those years with toxic people around you it hurts so much. The co-members should be the one that will help each other through the end. But damn those other members are a big disappointed and I don't see their careers seeing light again

[@kathreenallisa98]

Damn i didn't know that April is THAT problematic. I didn't even stan them tho nor listened to any of their songs so yeah. Kinda shock.

[@fruitpipiceglow8308]

Same here.

[@winter7945]

See the updates of April case first, day by day Hyunjoo is getting exposed and Knetz are siding on April again, even if you go on her IG and YT vlogs its flooded asking her to explain and give evidences

[@winter7945]

You didnt even know them but y'all judge them base on this cut and manipulated videos spreading, atleast now knetz are siding on them while Hyunjoo dropping followers and subscribers daily

[@2ndKidd]

Hold up. April’s company is messed up for siding with the bullies. I know everyone is a little more weary of these things after t-ara but if it’s this clear on camera and it’s a reoccurring thing with different people then it’s pretty damning imo I hope Rachel is okay

[@CIAinTaiwanAndUkraine]

It's because April (and especially Naeun) is their cash cow. I hope Hyunjoo wins so DSP can go bankrupt

[@eden_v3133]

I think boygroups probably have issues like this too. They're more open about their dislike though lmao. There are some groups where I feel the interactions are quite toxic.. or groups like Suju that are known for how much they hated Kyuhyun when he first joined and while Teen Top didn't gang up on one member they just simply disliked each other for a long time. There was one group called Pure Boys who even got some members charged with assault (and extortion) for beating one of their members frequently. It's best not to believe everything they act out on screen and remember that it's a competitive industry which pulls strong personalities.

[@SianaGearz]

I was thinking boy groups could in many cases be hiding it better since their presentation can be more reserved, you don't exactly expect them all to sit in each others' laps.

[@bunjibunjibungbunghe2813]

Im correct, whenever I watch them, the other members glare at hyunjoo like they are disgust or something! I really hate that girl group. First I really support them cause I like their music, but it really bothers me how they act around hyunjoo and rachel. So dissapointing!

[@brennathecatlover4360]

But to me it’s weird that every member or at least most of them didn’t like her for no reason

[@bunjibunjibungbunghe2813]

@@brennathecatlover4360 Hyunjoo is visual, whenever hyunjoo got praised they felt disgust. Rachel is a new member, it really shows they repeat again to rachel like what they did to hyunjoo. I can't see anything reason why all of them hate hyunjoo and mistreating rachel. They are just like that! 🥺

[@brennathecatlover4360]

@@bunjibunjibungbunghe2813 are u saying all of them do due to jealousy?

[@bunjibunjibungbunghe2813]

@@brennathecatlover4360 maybe? I always watch them cause I really love them way back, but every shows they participated, it really bothers me how they act towards hyunjoo. At first maybe it just my delulu, but it always happened. So, I can say that because of jealousy. Try to watch their videos, shows and etc, then focus on the members when hyunjoo start to talk or do somethin'

[@brennathecatlover4360]

@@bunjibunjibungbunghe2813 but why would all the members not like her

[@ikonthegreat6472]

now that I read what actually happened with Jimin and Mina, this whole video is inaccurate! If i’m a leader and one of the members on my team is not doing their best, constantly skip practice to hang with guys, and doesn’t progress? i’ll be mad too!

[@limario4220]

This topic makes me sad, imagine some of our faves were actually not who they are in camera.

[@chocochip7436]

I begin to know April when I started noticing Naeun from “extraordinary you”. I thought she is the visual until I found out the existence the former member like Hyunjoo. Naeun instantly became the visual after Hyunjoo left the group. Naeun was so pretty back then but not anymore when compared to Hyunjoo. I used to wonder why they aren’t not successful. It must have been because of their wickedness.

[@jeongyeon-san1350]

Personality is important to be an idol. As I love kpop for over 12years until now. I notice that the most idols with beautiful personalities are successful in Kpop industry.

[@astxrism8236]

Now you’re just being mean lmao, what does that have to do with bullying?

[@chocochip7436]

@@astxrism8236 I’m just talking about the fact. There’s nothing offending them. I’m disappointed since I like Nauen in Extraordinary you a lot.

[@jeniliminals8360]

Ik this is kinda off topic but Irene will never bully her members have you seen how she cares abt them In april and aoa vlogs you can see the bullying

[@chuuu4610]

Exactly! She cooked and ironed for Yeri when she went to school and there are countless videos of her helping to carry the members stuff. But there is a short Twice clip too and plenty of industry insiders have continued to say that the members are super nice.

[@shinichikudoz]

@@chuuu4610 stop copy pasta comment lol

[@shinichikudoz]

im like irene but the way she take seulgi mic there kinda...rude? like seulgi still talking tho

[@dlmytrx]

@@shinichikudoz i think most groups do that because they're afraid that they forgot what are they trying to say

[@shinichikudoz]

@@dlmytrx but come on...like why not wait until the person finish the talk

[@katherineramirez5163]

This video aged badly when it comes to the AOA scandal. This video is part of the bullying problem.

[@noonyakaleka2098]

Yea and Hyunjoo's lies exposed too.

[@mateopersaudez]

@@noonyakaleka2098 what happened

[@meem3236]

Literally everyone ignoring what happening in April just because they are pretty girls and they look “cute” so kpopis don’t really care if they are bully as long as they like how they look💀💀💀

[@constanzarojas1901]

This is why I get so uncomfortable with certain idols. I hate everytime they praise someone for being """"sassy"""" when they're just being disrespectful assh*les. There's so many idols out there who are blatantly rude to others _(not always members of their group)_ and get no consequences or show any repentance whatsoever. I can get doing pranks or saying things for the sake of comedy and reaction, but when a whole idol personality is them being rude to others, I start to wonder how they may behind closed doors.

[@seonghwatoothless1200]

Aoa's Jimin: I am the worst Naeun and Jinsol: No

[@yousraidir2289]

I think the reason why it's more common in girl groups than boy groups is that girls are taught to be meek and tend to bottle their emotions which makes the offender feel stronger and builds up more toxicity, whereas, we often hear about how members of boy groups tend to fight each other a lot pre-debut and that makes their relationships healthier, because they talk it out, let out their frustrations and resolve any issues they have, all because they're not forced to act as "appropriately" as the girls are.

[@LovelyKissess]

Where are girls taught that at? I'm just curious. I see quite the opposite. Men are told to keep their feelings to themselves because they're acting like a girl otherwise, whilst women are allowed to say how they feel and people respect them for speaking their mind

[@yousraidir2289]

@@LovelyKissess it's usually the traditional side of teachings as girls are regarded disfavorably if they acted strong or if they 'fight' between themselves, as if that somehow makes them delinquents. whereas boys fighting each other, either throwing punches or insults is considered to be more 'normal' because "they're men who have to defend their pride" idk if I explained it well sorry😭

[@LovelyKissess]

@@yousraidir2289 You explained it fine. I just never learned or saw it that way outside of tv. Do you live outside of America?

[@yousraidir2289]

@@LovelyKissessI guess it's more of a cultural effect as girls in Asian + African countries ,while it's not exactly all of them it's a great amount of them, are expected to follow the traditional gender norms. all in all I can say that it comes from deeply engrained misogyny. and to answer your question yes, I do live outside America.

[@LovelyKissess]

@@yousraidir2289 It does depend. I don't think it's as big in Asia though. The highschool girls there are always fighting or guessing and the kpop fans there are psycho, and they're teens. Africa is definitely huge on it though I kind of figured. Because here, it's so opposite. People of a certain status might teach their girls that, but the majority teach men to humble themselves when it comes to feelings and women are allowed to say whatever it is they need to say But I understand what you were saying now

[@doratonks07]

Mina from AoA is still suffering from all this bullying. People brush bullying off not realizing what damage this kind of behavior can cause, especially to someone who already has such low self esteem. Add the pressure of being a “perfect” idol and these girls are set up for disaster.

[@kitsch590]

From what I've read, what Jimin did to her was very cruel. Not just the normal bullying or being rude. And this was for 10 years. Not sure why the staff and her teammates didn't speak up.

[@chewymint5224]

days ago, mina posted a pic on her insta (the pic was deleted after) with her wrist being red and also the floors were splashed with bl00d. it was clear that the bullying took a toll on her mental health and it became much more worse

[@olyatelalim104]

@@chewymint5224 It has long been proven that she used a graphic editor for this photo, so she's lying... Also, I can't believe that she was bullied for ten years, like how did no one notice? Many videos have already been released confirming that Mina and Jimin had a warm and caring relationship (before the scandal, of course)

[@vixie109]

how do feel now about the situation? now that it all came out? mina was manipulative

[@doratonks07]

@@vixie109 who cares 🤷🏽‍♀️? I have a life. You should get one too

[@asiancommenter5974]

This is the day i start being sus of everything in kpop.

[@littlemisscypris]

Same here

[@SianaGearz]

Haha this is just the tip of the sus iceberg, just the tip, and only for a minute. There are a lot of unsavoury things in the kitchen. And yet things aren't overall... so bad? I mean Disney alone creates such a huge wake of destroyed lives behind itself. So many Disney child stars have had their future ruined and became mentally severely ill, so much so that growing up 'normal' is an exception for the Disney kids. I bet you never thought of it. A lot of industries worldwide are pretty ruthless. Imagine yourself getting a contract with a Euro/American recording company, you get a '360 contract' which on the surface of it gives you money, but is designed to bankrupt you and make you dependent on them, lose rights. You go on a TV competition show like X-Factor or The Voice? You sign away rights to any and all social media for 10 years, so they can use you to make content, but you can't use them as a springboard for your talent, not in a way which makes you independent of their system.

[@gassanzade]

Good morning

[@hanjaeseum1092]

the way how they look hyunjoo scream "insecurities"

[@TianXiaoMao]

Well this didn't age well, now that the truth about AOA has come out.

[@chuuqie9254]

just a little reminder: argument ≠ bullying // these people live together and are almost always together, so they will probably have arguments & fights sometimes

[@brennathecatlover4360]

Are u saying arguments are bullying?

[@jackiegalvez6576]

@@brennathecatlover4360 they’re saying that arguments don’t equal bullying

[@brennathecatlover4360]

@@jackiegalvez6576 ohhh ok thx! I agree

[@setsunahime2635]

While there might be arguments, but arguments that lead to one out of 6 to be publicly isolated and attempted suicide? Then, one member used the date of her being hospitalised was quoted as Hyunjoo being lazy and skipped work? Hmmm. I do hope Racheal isn't replaced to be in the next "arguments" position of the group though. Suicide attempt is 50/50 survival after all. Just because Hyunjoo survived, there is no guarantee the next "Hyunjoo" will survive.

[@Grace-pd5lu]

It’s all your choice but personally I’m removing all April songs from my playlists and no longer supporting dramas with them as the main lead. Those who have been bullied or have witnessed it will know how damaging and traumatic it is. And I can’t imagine being with your bullies 24/7 as well as your own company not standing by you. I think we should take this as seriously as we did with Jimin

[@bruffr7762]

Make one on male idols tooo...they go unnoticed 🙃

[@Ali-ni7uu]

hyper analyzing the actions of people we DO NOT KNOW is horribly irresponsible. i’m surprised videos like this are still up after the AOA bullying issue was revealed to be such a misunderstanding on the part of the public. i guess 1.2 million views is enough clout to forget how embarrassing this piece of bad journalism is, looking too deep into the relationship of teenage girls/young women that we don’t know

[@DaughterofMother1]

Exactly

[@confusedbread8936]

Finally, I was looking for this! April's scandal is such a slap in the face because it shows what is presented or what is "analysed" might also just be illusions or overthinking from fans

[@axisboise]

Exactly!

[@justahumanpassingthrough5544]

I would say it's more irresponsible to turn a blind eye to bullying. Even if it's just potential bullying, talking about it is extremely important -- yes, we don't know them personally; and yes, it's nearly impossible to know for sure in most cases. But the fact is, if something is going on and someone has the chance to help stop it, that's worth the alternative. Let's not pretend girls (and women) don't have a much harder time being truly close than guys do. If you're a female and haven't experienced this, then you're either very lucky, or haven't spent much time around other females.

[@zah936]

based comment

[@indiascarlett]

I've never been familiar with this group but Hyungjoo seems like such a sweet girl. It made me furious to see those clips where other members get together to mock or snear at her. I've had this done to me and it is awful. Don't send hate to anyone, but it's important this horrible behaviour is recognised.

[@doyoungworlddomination1322]

NOTE: please do not use analysis videos as evidence of if an idol has bullied someone or the group is bullying one of the members. it’s unreliable and is not strong proof. at the end we have to wait to hear the story from the idols themself, other than that idk april that well but i hope the member that was bullied gets closure and stays healthy 💓 edit: before you comment “stop defending those bullies” I am in NO WAY defending those girls for what they did. I’m simply saying video evidence is not 100% accurate, we don’t know what the other person feels, or what the context behind the video is, so PLEASE do not comment that i am making excuses for those bullies. thank you😀

[@tadmira127dreamuvtadmir2]

Hola Doyoung🧍🏾‍♀️

[@catacc.]

At the moment that we wait to hear her story, they may want to kill themselves already, and I'm not joking. We have to be capable of reading all the signs before something bad happens. If it's not true, well what a relief, but if it's actually true, and we didn't do nothing bc we wasn't paying attention, it can turn out really bad

[@doyoungworlddomination1322]

@@catacc. while that is a good point i still stand by what i said. we can’t assume someone is getting bullied from a video. bullying scandals are something really serious and can possibly ruin a group reputation or an idols career. we really don’t know what goes on with idols when off camera or we don’t know if that’s how idols joke around with each other. it’s also probably very triggering if us fans make an idol speak out before they’re ready. (if the bullying accusations are true) sadly the only thing we can do is wait for an idol to speak up and as fans we give them all the support and love we can.

[@felmargego2534]

@@catacc. there was literally a group that got their career ruined due to false bullying allegations, so we should be careful when it comes to vids like these and not instantly think of it as bullying...

[@ayanawest5934]

this video is more than enough visual context evidence that there was atleast subtle bullying happening. even here you can tell that the members didn’t try that hard to hide their distaste of hyunjoo that well. i see no issue with this video it’s just exposing the parts that many overlooked.

[@karoisart9266]

April may have great songs, but other groups could have pulled them off just as grest or even better. We dont have to support bullies just because of their music.

[@chocojicat]

Okay, I know I am going to be attacked, but jimin apologized multiple times and Mina just ignored the apologies and it seems like Jimin is now the victim...

[@lilyfiee]

True...

[@mctimmie8190]

Poor hyunjoo... She didn't deserve none of this, I hope it'll get better :(

[@briespen]

April has talents and visuals but they wasted it. Especially Na Eun. Dang! I rlly liked how she acted. I hope every members will get educated and change into a better person. Also, Jinsol is so disrespectful. Is that how she was taught? So disrespectful.

[@diagonally4364]

Hello! Can you remove Irene, Nayeon and Jihyo's vid on this? I think you might be just referring to them as 'samples' on the intro but people might get the wrong idea on this. You can cut out that parts and edit them. Thank you!

[@krisjnn9]

live with it. they’re obviously examples

[@ryannotreynolds900]

@@krisjnn9 Live with it. They're obviously not examples. Learn the difference between comfortable friendship and actual bullying.

[@joy0953]

@@krisjnn9 it's the ignorance for me

[@blinkonce6364]

@@krisjnn9 i could tell that you don't have any close friends. that's sad.

[@krisjnn9]

@@blinkonce6364 not really. why are you worrying abt a random person online.that’s sad.

[@kihyunsfavoritechicken5851]

When Naeun was an Ingkigayo MC along with Minhyuk and Jaehyun, i got to know her because of Minhyuk. And she always gave me a bad vibe like i don't know how to explain. But another proof my gut feelings were right

[@anu-rq1me]

Boys takes some things as a joke where as some things hurts dignity of a girl so I think girl groups are no prone but if a girl group sits nicely Like blackpink and twice .they can become family to each other which will never be apart❤️

[@anu-rq1me]

@@0_30mk yup..i m also a girl..but I feel like generating family like feeling is also hard after competiting for years and then being in group..i mean friendship is nice but somewhere they were opponents in a race

[@stillwatersrundeep001]

I think you're still very naive and inexperienced in this world. How old are you? Not trying to be mean, but want to let you know that it's unrealistic to expect that any family, even real ones, could "never" be apart. Any family is vulnerable to falling out and growing apart.

[@maine3319]

Lol if a person is constantly hurt physically and emotionally it won't be called as a joke (boy or girl group), a person who loves to bully other person won't be a willing one in making them close to the other person, you can't expect everyone to be like BP and Twice that is just a Naive thinking, some people are just selfish and full of envy, don't make this issue looklike just siblings having a shallow fight against eachother. Bullying is a serious matter.

[@anu-rq1me]

@@maine3319 i know ...but boys take some serious also as a joke which shouldn't be and also there are no conflicts as girls are more possessive

[@tadmira127dreamuvtadmir2]

We don’t know BP or Twice life’s

[@JM-xy3ne]

I don't want any Treasure members will gonna be part of any issue like this, I'm actually very worried about Yoshi and Doyoung but I'm not saying that Treasure members are very rude to them. I just hope they'll all get closer and closer soon and no one gonna felt awkward and out of place.

[@jennierubykim44]

Yess🥺

[@vanlalhlani]

I always have a trust in the bonding of each YG groups and they all have one of the most beautiful and realistic family relationship in K-Pop so I hope that too continues in TREASURE. I feel like they've gotten a lot closer and each of them have a secret bond like they're all close but some members don't really displayed their affection to certain members on camera. I see no awkwardness or negative feelings to their aura and I think that is why they are all so playful towards each other.

[@nanakurnia4689]

I believe in treasure's each member they already like family... doyoung and yoshi being different only because their sense of jokes, nothing else.... they also said that they would always support each other, you could see they always give reaction and compliment each other

[@reinventlove1866]

In big groups like that, having members that don't really get along is really inevitable sadly but true

[@JM-xy3ne]

@@reinventlove1866 yeah thank you, actually that was I was trying to say too. Btw, I appreciate the opinions you shared guys, y'all really love and trust our 12 gems😘

[@kheii3503]

Dude like being an idol is hard and things like this just makes it even harder. It's just sad and very infuriating for me that those that had to work a lot just as everyone else then decide to abandon their dreams in order to stop the constant pain.

[@zaynes5094]

And now we now know why nobody messes with APink’s Eunji as the APink leader. She might be strict at times, but she makes sure there’s nobody getting left out of shots and out of their own moments. Both in interviews and on stage.

[@_cheyrose_3236]

I feel like a lot of this group’s bullying comes from their entertainment’s not paying enough attention to how the group members get along before debut. And they don’t train together long enough to get so close like twice, bp, and other groups that trained 4+ years together.

[@casluvs]

It makes me sad because think of how many other idols are getting bullied in a group behind closed doors, its really upsetting :/

[@hades1907]

I can't believe somin could do somthing like that i loved her so much in kard 😭

[@shaniafrederik8377]

What happened?

[@hades1907]

@@shaniafrederik8377 she bullied one of her former member

[@sunnyunnie3225]

I don't think Somin had anything to do with this. At least I didn't hear her name mentioned anywhere. If anything, maybe she left so early because she couldn't stand the situation

[@harrytimmy5070]

@@sunnyunnie3225 that girl mentioned somin sweetie

[@hades1907]

@@sunnyunnie3225 but i still hope that ot won't be true.

[@xxmoonlightxx5742]

Who here after mina is now questioned as the villain?