Ranking EVERY Mission In Red Dead Redemption 2 From Worst To Best (Main Story)

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Here's are my criteria for ranking each of the missions. 1. Gameplay - Because I'm playing a video game, the gameplay is most important. Missions where you aren't really doing anything but riding your horse, lose some points just because you as the player, aren't really doing anything. 2. Story - How does it fit into the story - If the mission could be cut out without affecting the story, or doesn't do much to advance the story forward, it will also lose some points. 3. Uniqueness - Does the mission have unique points - If a mission has things that aren't availble in the rest of the game, then it moves up. Here's me ranking the rest of the epilogue missions: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rpvYnJirg7Vnq7s

[@Dutchy4564]

I agree with everything here but why was the gator one so low. It's unique and scary since you don't actually see the monster that tanks about 39 express shots from a volcanic pistol

[@TheHunterX40]

Z

[@usmaniqbal1322]

Also add charachter development as 4th point

[@Uncle228]

I’m sorry but I just lost it when the skinned bear realizes it can’t die now and starts attacking Arthur

[@Cursed_sc0ut]

I know

[@FishNamedWall]

how’s the lumbago, Uncle? Getting any better yet?

[@TheWalkingDead-w3h]

Uncle Hows Your Lumbago?

[@dbcoopervidmaster]

yo i feel for you the lumbago must be doing numbers on you

[@bobsnow6242]

Uncle's lumbago was cured at the end of RDR1 courtesy of an experimental lead-based treatment.

[@CptDawner]

You didn’t like the hunting mission with Hosea? Barbarian.

[@RedDeadTierLists]

It has like 5 different intros into Rockstar features which definitely are not fun to sit through. I get that they wanted to introduce Stables, crafting, the camp feature, and legendary animals, but doing it all in one mission makes it extremely clunky.

[@foodafen7406]

​@@RedDeadTierListsBeing attacked by a skinned legendary bear probably lowers it for me too

[@corenasue]

@@foodafen7406 I saw that and that was funny It's like The Bear came back from The Dead and became a Zombie Bear.

[@moritz-4742]

Loved the mission too

[@im_the_trashman]

@@RedDeadTierListsalr that’s fair but it’s such a good almost father son relationship building with hosea and really

[@mickeyveach3612]

Imagine playing Honor Amongst Thieves where one of the most honest heart to heart conversations happen and arthur confesses to having a son and calling it "nothing special"

[@SHOOPY2021]

That's Archeology For Beginners, Honor Amongst Thieves is when you steal medicine for Captain Monroe

[@Groniallic]

archeology for beginners is so ass i fucking hated that mission

[@fortytwo4-2]

@@SHOOPY2021 what he said

[@fortytwo4-2]

@@Groniallic why?

[@Groniallic]

@@fortytwo4-2 trailing missions are so boring, normally when it's with a camp member its good but i just hated the whole rains fall eagle flies part of the story, theyre uninteresting bland plot devices used to convey dutch being bad.

[@SanAndreas24]

I dont understand why some of the most atmospheric missions (dear uncle tacitus, country pursuits) are so close to the bottom

[@RedBoko2017]

I think he was ranking the missions mostly based on gameplay, with atmosphere taking a smaller part

[@Boileryard]

@@RedBoko2017I mean it makes sense because it is a video game after all. Gameplay should always be the main thing you look at with graphics and story being more of just the icing on the cake.

[@SOBEKCrocodileGod]

I agree. Especially Country Pursuits with its terrifying atmosphere and how the game turns horror for a sec.

[@kindertak5396]

Because adhd is a serious problem

[@stinky.404]

Me too, I understand from a gameplay perspective they’re nothing crazy, but the impact for the story and characters hugely makes up for it (at least imo)

[@luksterr1997]

Dear uncle Tacitus was one of my favourites in the entire game 😭 Just riding your horse across half the map listening to a FANTASTIC score and turning cinematic mode on was one of the missions that really made me fall even more in love with this game

[@moister3727]

From a gameplay standpoint is somewhat boring

[@im_not_real7254]

I mostly don’t like it because I’m really bad at using the cinematic cam

[@Gabe-z9v]

I was trying to be honorable so I didn’t take the horse even tho it was yours so I walked back

[@Ninja_Gam-er.]

​@@Gabe-z9vReally!? 😂😂😂. So then did the song play or not? 😂😂😂

[@idioticmerc1512]

If I remember correctly it's not even your horse you just steal it once you get off the boat at Van Horn

[@The_Historic_Gamer]

Id much rather have a game waste a few missions to teach me mechanics instead of it just telling me all of it in the menu and having to memorize it

[@BlakeWR81]

People act like the first hour of GTA isn't exactly the same. The only reason people don't think about it is because you aren't constrained to a single region of the map for that hour.

[@bigDdavy]

Is everyone going to idnore the skinned bear coming back alive to maul him

[@MeaCulpa04]

No ish! I didn’t know that could happen.!

[@Postaldude2002]

That happend to me too in my game

[@epicmike43]

I thought the bear had unlimited HP and it couldn't get killed

[@yotte7959]

Or the gator at 20:02 tearing up the party 😭

[@fooperfarvey4812]

Riding back to shady belle after your return from guarma is probably one of my favorite moments from my first experience.

[@abdulwahab558]

Bro hates every mission in which you have to walk for 0.01 second

[@slipperydoorknob9950]

That’s valid, missions where all you do is walk around/ride around and do absolutely nothing important are terrible. The entire mission consists of holding the L stick forward

[@brendanlove9739]

@@slipperydoorknob9950 That’s because you’re not looking at it correctly. They’re not “missions”, they’re exposition and character development. You shouldn’t be bored by the gameplay but engaged in the conversation

[@slipperydoorknob9950]

@@brendanlove9739 It’s not character development though. I learned nothing about the black guy in Lagras while I was checking crayfish traps and nor did I care too. These missions are usually actually the complete opposite of character development. The only mission where all you do is walk and talk for most of it that I liked was the one where Arthur talks to rains fall while going up the mountain. That was actual character development. Nobody wants to hold X for an hour while Javier and bill yap about how they have money in blackwater. Some of the John missions are fine because the dialogue is interesting but other than that, those types of “missions” are just irrelevant to the game in general.

[@brendanlove9739]

@@slipperydoorknob9950 Maybe I misspoke about them being character moments but they are still important for the world too. When in missions do you slow down and actual appreciate the world. In the crayfish traps mission that’s all you really can do. If that bothers you then it’s not your game. The most important parts of the game are the quiet parts. If everything was just action, gunslinging and rootin’ tootin’, that would get old fast. There has to be variety. But to each their own. There’s the players that blaze through the story and kill everyone in sight because it’s “just a game” and then there’s people who love the world, characters, and setting so much that they relish every moment of it, no matter how quiet or slow it is. Talking about it, I take back what I said, it is still character development. Every time someone opens their mouth that dialogue was written for a purpose for that character. If they are saying something, the devs wrote that line for a reason. The game’s story is so in depth, so much so that people are still breaking it down and trying to figure out different themes and character motivations this many years later. This game would be more boring without fishing with Jack, or going to get Crayfish traps with the Lagras dude, or hunting with Hosea, or guarding a woman’s rights March. That’s what makes the game mean so much more. It’s not just go here and kill some guys and then rinse and repeat. It makes you connect with the characters. In the crayfish mission, that’s the same one where your trying to save a dude from a big ass alligator. Any other game I would’ve just gone through the motions to save the guy and be done with it, but in this I was in the moment, in the world, afraid that the guy would die. And then when you have that guy on your back, the gator starts chasing you to the boat as you slowly run away. There’s so much tension there and part of why it works is because it starts slow and makes you care about the Lagras fishermen. You just gotta try to enjoy those moments for their narrative and cinematic nature, rather than for gameplay. This game transcends being just a game because of how much you connect with the experience. Ok, I’m off my soapbox now

[@slipperydoorknob9950]

@@brendanlove9739 Rdr2 is one of my favourite games. I’ve done 3 playthroughs. I enjoy the game but there is a lot of missions that aren’t “fun” to play in MOST peoples opinions. Some people enjoy learning about complicated lore and shit but the majority of people would rather not. I wish I was that way but I’m definitely on the spectrum or sm shit

[@Somepepper]

15:17 you said it right there. Mary’s brother and the cult is symbolic of Arthur and the Van der Linde gang/cult. How Arthur was tricked into believing in Dutches ideas because he was weak and easily manipulated.

[@thirdhandlv4231]

I mean, the chelonians quite literally throw themselves off of a mountain and die, thats their whole goal, at least Dutch has a ''plan'' and the gang is a gang so they make money and try to survive.

[@samuelb18]

​@thirdhandlv4231 "the chelonians quite literally throw themselves of a mountain and die" "at least dutch had a plan" did you play rdr1? I hope not, cause if you didn't this might be the funniest comment on the entire Internet.

[@thirdhandlv4231]

@@samuelb18 Do you know what character progression/regression is?

[@samuelb18]

@@thirdhandlv4231 the point of dutch is that by rdr1, his character hasn't changed as much as it has been revealed to be what it was from the start. Dutch in rdr2 is as unhinged and irrational as rdr1 Dutch. In chapter 1 he robs a Cornwall train whilst already on the run because of the Blackwater massacre. He makes stupid, impulsive decisions repeatedly and instead of owning up to his mistakes he twists his own reality to convince himself the reason everything is going to shit is because the gang has "lost faith". By rdr1, his facade is completely gone, and all is left is the unhinged, insane man that was always there from the beginning. Him deciding to try and kill john in the middle of Blackwater for shits and giggles is a decision that is really no different to when he shoots Cornwall in annesburg (Im aware that Dutch had good motivation to kill Cornwall, but his death would realistically only lead to more attention from the authorities, especially considering the fact he did it in a crowded mining town in broad daylight). Dutch was always the same, and that's what makes him so fascinating.

[@alexhodder4918]

i recently replayed and only just noticed

[@antthomas7916]

Uncle is not stupid at all. He just acts stupid and lazy so he doesnt have to do any real work, which is actually pretty genius. If you listen to him around camp, you'll get to hear his wisdom and intelligence at play.

[@egoaeterno2347]

Well, Uncle said it himself, he's not lazy he's just doesn't like to work. 😂😂😂

[@M1N1molo]

@@egoaeterno2347he’s got lumbago come on

[@Jesus-vb1vc]

This man does not like any missions that are story/ lore focused.

[@Lilgooberr]

Ong he might as well play online

[@bawanki1179]

Pure fps games and their consequences on the gamer mind have been disastrous

[@bawanki1179]

Pure fps games and their consequences on the gamer mind have been disastrous

[@ZeroOdyssey]

Seriously, why even watch a video like this if the creator lacks nuance....

[@ActuallyLucasXD]

I’ve never liked the mission where you save Tilly from the Foreman gang, mostly because it does nothing for the story and is just filler

[@lemon4758]

Yeah it’s kinda just worldbuilding and learning more about Tilly. The consequences of the mission are cool though, since you can do an Anthony foreman bounty in epilogue if you didn’t kill him

[@TakodaRichard]

@@lemon4758😮😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅❤a

[@arthurmorgan8529]

Only thing what changes is if you kill foreman then John can't do his bounty mission later

[@weezerbeetle]

Agreed

[@rwils7925]

Jesus Loves You

[@ManyScaryMen]

He didn’t add the epilogue because we all know that the house building mission would be no. 1

[@jacksonslaymaker3901]

Based off his opinions of boring gameplay. This dude might put it dead last

[@crxstalgaming2052]

@@jacksonslaymaker3901 fr, he seems like he doesn’t even care about the story

[@eliawein4644]

Bro is gen Z attention span in person

[@LoCoAde87]

Lmao, said as much myself a few mins. iPad kid mentality this vid stinks of.

[@tonin5047]

Basically "If doesn't have a shotout, it's bad" lol

[@whoisterwoister8560]

I can understand for the missions like country pursuit or like, welcome to the new world cuz they're boring doing a run after your first, but the hunting mission with hosea was so good. Sadly not every mission can be number 1

[@Rce12808]

The part of blessed be the peacemakers where Arthur escapes the O’driscolls is actually inspired by Rambo

[@YourRedDeadPartner]

For the people who dont like dear uncle tacitus u can just go to lakay instead of going all the way to shady belle

[@imkool51391]

Calling Uncle one of the stupidest people on the game is a goddamn tragedy. He may be lazy but he is very far from stupid. Your ignorance revealed itself with this statement

[@v0x712]

He's not dumb at all, he shows he has Brains in epilogue, with him getting John a precut house and barn later on and so on.

[@lindseytaylor3793]

i totally agree. there are many things he does/says that show he has more wit than he gets credit for. granted, these instances are more often than not very easily missed, i've just spent an embarrassing amount of time in camp just observing everyone's behavior as if they're animals in a zoo lmao. seriously tho, uncle is definitely way more intelligent than he gets credit for. he's just lazy and apathetic, but certainly not stupid. he's smart(at least, in comparison to many other characters), but he's just too lazy to showcase it.

[@Locket.L]

Whether or not Uncle is stupid, he outlived almost everyone else in the gang.

[@terminallumbago6465]

I personally think Chapter 3 has 4 or 5 of the most fun missions in the game, including my personal favorite: Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern.

[@xtevity]

59:58 "miss grimshaw is shot by arthur" what that didnt happen

[@scottyshot]

7:44 that fall is so realistic

[@SOBEKCrocodileGod]

Country Pursuits gotta be in S tier for me because I love how it just turns into a horror game. The fact that you can’t see the gator makes it even scarier for me personally. Also holy shit 9:00 I didn’t know you could take Penelope to her cousin

[@moister3727]

Country Pursuits it's only good for the first time. Charm goes in the second playthrough when you realise the alligator isn't a threat at all. Could've worked if you were given more control of the situation, not being stuck in a swamp or hell or even be in the boat would've make it more scarier.

[@captainhowlerwilson508]

I would put The Course of True Love V at the A tier, because I had a lot more fun helping the lovers escape their families and have been kind of confused by the hate this section of the game was getting. It is also great as Arthur to help these two escape, especially after failing to do the same with Mary so many times before. It would probably be ranked at around 35 to 30 for me.

[@andrewlowden322]

I just find Beau so unlikable and IM genuinely surprised R* went with the long-hanging-fruit of the Romeo and Juliet theme. Im never excited about replaying their missions

[@captainhowlerwilson508]

@@andrewlowden322 Seriously? Him unlikable? Just what was unlikable about him? I struggle to see, especially when he is dealing with actual unlikable people in his family. I don’t care what kind of mission it is, as long as it is enjoyable. To each his own I guess.

[@andrewlowden322]

@@captainhowlerwilson508he is completely dismissive of Arthur; he doesn't stop his own agenda and listen/engage him. He has his own plans and Arthur is to be used. That plus the aforementioned contrived R+J story keeps me from wanting to play these missions again Cheers

[@captainhowlerwilson508]

@@andrewlowden322 Tell me, I don’t understand what he had to dismiss about Arthur. Arthur never asked for anything other than money in their first meeting. Beau offered to pay him for his services and that was why he decided to help in Chapter 3. By Chapter 6 though Arthur helped him and Penelope without asking anything in return. If you’re talking about Arthur’s tuberculosis, he wasn’t even coughing that much when on the train with them and besides, there was nothing they could have done for him except encourage him to do what is right.

[@nutsackreviews]

@@andrewlowden322 hello??????

[@captainhowlerwilson508]

I disagree about Archeology for Beginners. That mission was one of the most beautiful and deepest missions of the game and has some of the best stealth parts of the game if you chose to go that way. It also doesn't have any gunfights unless you decide to shoot the army.

[@RedDeadTierLists]

I literally put in A tier, Idk what you're disagreeing with.

[@jamaalsutton8241]

​@RedDeadTierLists i think its because he wants it in S tier

[@captainhowlerwilson508]

@@jamaalsutton8241 For me, it is close to that. Not quite there, but close.

[@suicidal_cookie868]

@@captainhowlerwilson508 what are you disagreeing about then bro?

[@captainhowlerwilson508]

@@suicidal_cookie868 I know. The only part I disagreed with was the placing and that was it.

[@wkirky]

This video just reminded me how i truly enjoyed every second of this game

[@joedwyer3297]

Yeah I liked all the f tier missions, the guarma walk was giving us time to realise what what just happened before with hosea, lenny, John being captured and the gang falling apart literally the only one I didnt like was the gator mission

[@SoapyIsThe1]

Tf happened at 1:20 bro came back to life💀

[@SuperKamekMac]

Fr what dah hell

[@grimblebimble6965]

19:33 Damn who invited the gator

[@spookieststories123]

Lmao I was waiting for this comment😂if this is a mod I need to get it

[@grimblebimble6965]

@@spookieststories123 Rampage trainer, it spawns anything or does anything, so he used it to spawn the legendary bull gator at the party

[@spookieststories123]

@@grimblebimble6965 aight thanks

[@GuessImaGuest]

I feel like most of the Guarma missions are so boring or just terrible because of the setting. The idea of being stranded on an island is great, but the execution could use improvement. There's a lot of things to look at, but it never actually feels worth it to explore, because you don't really find anything interesting. I loved the idea of being in a new setting, but once I realized just how little was actually going on there, I was happy to leave and go back to Van Horn/Shady Belle. In a way, R* managed to make you feel stranded and hoping for an escape by giving us little to do on Guarma, so I guess kudos for that.

[@sydneyallen8820]

Plus everytime you try to explore and wander the island even a little bit, you get captured and killed by Fussar’s men

[@Sektor-m4f]

They had to cut a lot so that they could finish the epilogue in six months.

[@Ravvox]

Only Hell Hath No Fury was cool and the scene where Arthur passes the gun to the captain was badass

[@oliverjennings9297]

I actually loved it I thought the music was amazing, the atmosphere was cool and it was something different to spice it up

[@koheletcalaforexclan6508]

That thumbnail infuriates me! I love Guarma Though I get it! 1. We don’t spend much time there 2. You can’t go back 3. You can’t really look around!

[@sankalpchoubey6629]

I can't believe the swamp mission is so low on this list. It was a great way to introduce bullgator. Also the creepy vibes of the place add thriller element to this mission. Pair it with Dutch acting like scared cat adds comedy. I would have put it in my top 15 just because it is one of the scariest mission in the game. Hunting mission with Hosea, I get it if you don't like this after many playthrough. But on the 1st playthrough, its great way to introduce game mechanics like stables, camping, crafting items and hunting. Also this is a great way to introduce us to legendary animals.

[@ethanringa7440]

My personal fav is blood feuds ancient and modern by far. The fact the entire core of the gang is united in destroying the braithwaites ultimately for good. The scene of the gang walking up the gravel road with the house in the background is probably the most badass scene in the whole gang. Blasting through the entire braithwate house and taking down one of the main antagonists of chapter three. This mission perfectly transitioned the game into the next chapter. Even the ending of the entire gang walking away as the manor burns to the ground behind them is probably the most badass ending to any mission.

[@joda6748]

Friends in low places is so underrated

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Yeah, I think you're actually right. Definitely should at least be in C, and could/should be closer to Spines of America, as both of those are really similar.

[@andrewlowden322]

TBH I was loving watching the legendary gator tear up the dinner party, super-fat Arthur walking Mary around and you blowing up Micah...def made those missions more fun.

[@귤귤-t5l]

no one has said it yet but I really like the tomfoolery you showcased in each mission lol, helps to spice up the video and show us some ridiculousness in the game's coding

[@calebryan3094]

The Bull Gator at the party got me 😂😂😂

[@Mystic-Midnight]

Eastward Bound will forever be like top 5 mission material just for the feeling of finally coming down from the Mountain that first playthrough. Now it's like oh okay big whoop but that first playthrough with the music it was something special.

[@PShrekky]

Who is without sin at 72 is a crime

[@petere.9138]

Guarma feels like they left it til last and then sort of wrapped it all up right at the deadline.

[@mr.reaperberr]

19:30 crocodile invited to the mayor party or i think this aliigator is a mayor too 😂😂😂

[@GabrielRamirez-ki7mw]

Wtf Country pursuits is literally a masterpiece, most intense and nerve wracking mission by far

[@JacobAery]

No, just no.

[@TheSloppyjoejr]

Some of the “boring” ones are really cool on your first play-through especially if you are being introduced to something

[@skor_refs]

Bear hunting with Hosea is actually one of my favourite missions. I also love the Shady Belle mission with Lenny. He's my favourite gang member together with Sean!

[@corenasue]

Dude The Mission when You run from The Gator is scary Your basically running from Jaws Jaws that swims in The Swampy Waters and has Legs and can run on Land and chase You down and eat You.

[@raffitorres1714]

That mission was awesome.

[@emilfrederiksen.1622]

A Fine night of debauchery is one of my favorite missions in the game, The fact that Arthur plays this sudo fake Oil Rich guy. And the fact that you get to play high stakes poker. Which should be an option to play besides this mission. The gun fight on the boat is also extremely fun. Should be an S tier mission to me.

[@Fluffysocks93]

Bro is nobody gonna talk about the flesh bear at the beginning? 1:11

[@LadyFinger_]

That skinned bear attack is nightmare fuel

[@User-ov2bg]

Bro, not every mission can be a super Duper fun mission. Some of them contribute to the story greatly and you get to know characters like the Charles hunting mission.

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Yeah, I took those into account. Still it not being a super duper fun mission moves it down the list it’s pretty simple the whole tier list is based on my enjoyment and how they impact the story. If the gameplay isn’t fun, then the mission goes down the list. I’m playing a video game not watching a movie.

[@User-ov2bg]

@@RedDeadTierLists maybe you should learn to watch movies a little bit listen to some dialogue find out some things about characters

[@RedDeadTierLists]

@@User-ov2bg Clearly I do let the dialogue play a big part in the mission as I literally pointed out how learning about Charles was important. But as Red Dead Redemption isn’t a movie, gameplay comes first.

[@Boileryard]

@@User-ov2bgThis isn't a movie though, it's a video game. Gameplay always comes first. Notice how Minecraft is the most popular game of all time despite having a non-existent story and everything being made of chunky blocks. Graphics and story isn't everything in a video game.

[@jackcalkins4232]

but this isn't minecraft. This is a game where story is highly valued but Minecraft isn't. It's not the same standard @@Boileryard

[@Im_in_your_walls629]

I literally walked to shady belle after guarma because i didn’t think there was a horse anywhere

[@mizraymoliveira8381]

me too lol

[@tazinboor3913]

“As I’ll be making another one of these, for Red Dead Redemption 1” Yes, after you rank the epilogue missions please, since you didn’t do those in this video and I thought that was a bit unexpected. I understand the struggle to rank every mission that’s not a part of the epilogue, but still, the epilogue is wildly important to the game’s story objectively in my view. And it’s not that long mission-wise.

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Yeah I’m gonna do a video for that and then a compilation of both videos into one longer one

[@RedDeadTierLists]

I think having two different videos for this really works better story wise tho since you can focus on Arthur’s story with this and john’s story in the other video

[@tazinboor3913]

@@RedDeadTierLists Well, alright.

[@tazinboor3913]

@@RedDeadTierLists Yeah I was kind of thinking that’s what was happening.

[@faaked.]

The bear one with hosea was insanely fun and nerve racking. The swamp missions were also really fun cause you were scared of the big alligator.

[@vitorlukits]

For this guy the missions has to have important stories and gameplay ecstasy , character development in all just 5 minutes to be good

[@limitlesscreations5782]

The gator misson was horror bro. Did you not point your camera backwards while carrying the bitten guy?

[@jonathandaykin3067]

For me," Blessed are the peace makers " is one of the few missions that you just want to get out of the way.

[@shizzdian]

my top 5: 1: An American Pastoral Scene 2: Banking, the Old American Art 3: The Spines of America 4: A Short Walk in a Pretty Town 5: An Honest Mistake

[@HighBluey]

What about blood feuds

[@Kevjohno]

Country pursuits has some funny lines in from Dutch. Like you can see why nighttime swamp wading haven't caught on .19.40s print coyote

[@ActuallyLucasXD]

56:12 Just fyi the mission is actually called: “Banking, The Old American Art”

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Yeah I wrote it down wrong I realized that after the video

[@Unholy_fryingpan]

Honourable mention: “American venom” from the epilogue: Music is fire 🔥 Gameplay is fun and (spoiler alert for the epilogue 🚨) FINALLY killing Micah feels so good and having Dutch finally changed sides is great

[@sarkarslg9911]

Guarma was pretty unique and stood out from the other chapters, In my opinion my rating for 'each' chapter would be -> C6>C5=>C4>C3>C2>C1, C5 may not have been the best one in terms of gameplay, but its story was extremely well executed and it was also unique in which we don't exactly explore but we only see the glimpse of war in other islands other than the endangerment of the Outlaws in the West, and this chapter also explores Dutch's character extremely well, and Guarma's starting and first chapter "Welcome to the New World," was bumpy at first, but then it got extremely well. With "A Fork on the Road,".

[@YouscaremeJeremy]

One of my all time favorites is country pursuits! The atmosphere of walking through the swamps is so cool and creepy! Especially when you play in first person view.

[@Plain-Ketchup]

That skinless bear attacking Arthur scared me

[@jackosharkpie3892]

It’s so funny watching you intentionally do most of the missions the wrong way in the background 😂

[@lordfury18]

some of my favorite missions are just where you do things with other gang memebers, i had a lot fun just hanging with some as we robbed folks my favorite mission was hunting with Charles, it felt personal!! like he was showing Arthur part of his culture!! i didn't feel even slightly bad for strangling that poacher

[@Jerryisntthecodgod]

Unpopular opinion but the mission where you save micah in strawberry is one of my favorite missions, I love micah despite him being a rat and the massive shootout is very fun in my opinion, It gives us more insight into micah being a psychopath and he gives you duel wielding which also bumps it up. A quiet time is in my top five aswell as the saint denis bank robbery. American venom is also in my top 5 if not top 3. And I know they are technically not missions but I love hunting down the legendary animals and making cool stuff from them

[@BrBird22]

I love "The Course of True Love 3" because I use the bit where you're supposed to be walking away from the cousins to practice my quickdraw.

[@TrinityMartin1]

You use "boring" as a descriptor way, way too much.

[@LoCoAde87]

For real

[@alexrabon3528]

50:19 i think it’s funny how the “replays” lessen the shock value of Johns fake death, like we didn’t play an entire game as just him

[@LettuceArt]

funny how half of the missions footage is weird bugs and glitches

[@mr.peruna7799]

Bro really pulled a dead rat out of Micah's back pocket😂😂

[@Wolfspaine7N6]

In 2 separate play throughs, the last course of true love mission got my horse killed trying to follow the train while I was on it. And it was my favorite horse and the only one in the game.

[@MrGuy42069]

I kinda liked the last part of Guarma, it was definitely pretty weak compared to most other missions, but really not bad

[@Y2JFanboy]

The skinned bear can attack arthur, wtf?

[@jonathandaykin3067]

Hosea is the soundness of mind that Dutch lost completely when Hosea died, i have a feeling that Micah made a deal with the Pinkertons to pave his way to power over Dutch.

[@swapsplat]

Here's a hint for you... People who aren't subscribed don't give a fuck about what percentage of viewers are.

[@dezyancey6336]

I'm started to get offended at the beginning of the video and then I realized I loved every single gle mission in this game. Greatest game ever made and GTA VI will have a very hard time touching it.

[@BurningPXG]

My top 3: 1. Guarma fort mission where you destroy the warship 2. Braithwaite mansion invasion by the gang 3. Hunt for Angelo Bronte in his mansion Also, can someone make this canon, please? 37:36.

[@chelseafuller6565]

Did anyone else notice that in chapter 1 when Mika said we’re not fall I don’t want no fuss and then when he said when you fall, they’ll be a party after John killed there was his wedding

[@tju960]

Welcome To The New World should be #1 because it was the closest we've ever seen Dutch and a bit of his gang not being in the wild west (just not on their terms)

[@NoFlu]

But the gameplay is utter trash...

[@tju960]

@NoFlu I can tell just by your profile picture that you're a man of culture and speak nothing but the truth. It's true the gameplay is utter trash, dare I say unnecessary. However, I believe that it shows us that even if Dutch and the gang went to a different country, they'd still have a form of law to deal with and life isn't as easy as growing oranges on Tahiti. Or maybe it is, idk if it's a native plant or if the climate is good for oranges to grow in.

[@javrami4883]

Why no inclusion of the epilogue missions? American Venom is perhaps the most badass mission of all time

[@zombiepsyco8578]

bro when you said subscribe at the end of the video the subscribe button lit up, thats fire

[@Generalmacka]

I noticed that you didn't have the special effect during A Fork in the road. That makes the mission so much better.

[@UndertaleFan-cx2mc]

I thought the idea was that you weren’t supposed to believe John was dead after Our Best Selves John gets arrested in the Chapter 4 finale, Dutch claims he had no choice John gets broken out in Visiting Hours, Dutch scolds John in a camp interaction and literally tells him he would leave him to rot in Sisika John also tells Arthur that Dutch was there, and he could’ve done something, but he didn’t, just as he does to Arthur at the end of My Last Boy I think it’s implied that after My Last Boy, the player should no longer trust Dutch anymore and therefore NOT believe his lie about not being able to save John in Our Best Selves

[@oogabooga612]

Bro are you crazy?!?! Country pursuits is a top 10 mission EASILY

[@AldraSandnaov]

Only good moment is tension between Arthur and alligator besides that the mission is an F tier

[@thejake1526]

Sadie getting revenge mission should be High A tier, A Gilded gage should be higher in the B tier.

[@trystanalava2398]

22:32 I was just listening and looked down after doing computer work and this caught me so off gaurd

[@BeauMillionFragrance]

It’s crazy because when I got to chapter 6 I was ready for the game to end. I loved the game, but man I was so ready for it to end… And then the epilogues happened lol

[@Tadicuslegion78]

I hate how when you try to get gold on certain missions, the time requirement is either ridiculously short or because you can't skip non-cut scene walking and talking sections they feel so long on replay

[@SebastianLien-mf4yg]

Is everyone going to ignore the fact that he said hoseas death was sadder than Arthur’s

[@Ninja_Gam-er.]

If you are saying that there shouldn't be so much of riding then tell me what are the two main things in RDR2? Those are fighting and exploring. Riding is one of the most important parts of the game. Surely sometimes it feels a bit boring but it is a open world game! (The best one till now) So what's the point if we don't ride anywhere far and just count on the game to bring a cut scene and skip the journey or skip it using a stagecoach or the train? I never use the fast travel option cause I like to explore the open world. There are random encounters and many more things in the exploration. If game would be just for fights, boom-bam and all, then the game wouldn't be as great as it today. Surely fights make a game so much epic, but the exploration, riding, random encounters, peaceful missions, etc. also play a major role in making a game more fun/epic and memorable. While everyone has their own tastes, perspectives and opinions but still I do hope that you understand.👍

[@TheWalkingDead-w3h]

The Skinny Bear Attacking You Looks *Cursed* Lmao

[@justjackorwhatever]

19:30 lol everyone just chillin while a crocodile mauls people

[@roryjamesvallely8167]

Bro in the gilded cage did anyone else realize there was an aligator mauling everyone

[@Boccan]

I rather like the "Aftermath of Genesis" mission because of the soundtrack that plays in the background, the conversation between Arthur and Charles, and just the kinda.......... Robert Redford "Jeremiah Johnson" vibes the mission gives to me, especially when the two are riding back to Colter....

[@pratiktandel5706]

37:39 that perfect character swap 😂😂😂

[@ArthurMorgan-bg1ni]

It would be better if you made it into a tier list so it’s easier to for us to know instead of having to memorize

[@skor_refs]

1. Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern 2. Red Dead Redemption 3. The Fine Joys Of Tobacco 4. A Quiet Time 5. My Last Boy 6. Preaching Forgiveness as He went 7. A Fine Night Of Debauchery 8. That’s Murfree Country 9. Banking, An American Art 10. American Venom is mine

[@cacbishop1462]

My favorite one was advertising because you are with hosea, and do a chase scene with unlimited ammo, plus you are fenton.

[@BloodeeJacob]

You can literally see the gator if you look behind you lol plus you can come back and hunt it later. And man you think a lot of the missions suck.

[@Joey-wb7vy]

Surprised I haven’t seen anyone mention the big ass alligator hunting everyone at Brontes party 😂😂

[@nomchrumth9501]

All mission with micah:F AMERICAN VENOM:SSS

[@thejake1526]

Honestly most of the missions Mid B tier, should atleast be Low A, Almost all the missions in this game have great replay ability and just overall pretty good gameplay. Cough Cough Sadie Alder killing the o Driscols mission.

[@emilfrederiksen.1622]

Some of Rockstars missions can get a bit boring especially since there is no choice in them its just go from a to b do this and complete the mission.