The Full Red Dead Redemption Timeline Explained

[@theYT_moderator]

Are we gonna skip over the fact that hosea looks 70 and Bronte looks 40 yet they're both born in the same year?

[@uhhnotluke4319]

i was surprised that uncle wasn’t older tbh

[@nikomindora]

are we gonna skip over the fact that Bronte is rich and has medicine and shit and is taken care of while Hosea has lung cancer, no money and lives in the swamp? ok

[@theYT_moderator]

@@uhhnotluke4319 Poor excuse, but ight 🤷🏿‍♂️

[@maximusandersson2389]

Wdym poor excuse ​@@theYT_moderator

[@theYT_moderator]

@@maximusandersson2389 Money and medicine aren't gonna make up the difference in 30-40 years' worth of difference in opinion. The kid who made that comment was probably like 7. The developers simply must've forgotten the age difference.

[@IamDonald5160]

micah joined the gang in either January of 1899 or December of 1898 because Arthur saves him from jail in June when he says “Ive heard so much bluster out of you mouth these last 6 months”

[@Cartoon_Cartoon187]

I was heated when he got that wrong

[@alfredfrost3660]

crazy content for a youtuber with less than 20k, love the energi you put into the video. keep up the great work

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Will be making a lot more stuff soon, but the format may change a bit.

[@katiedanner1]

​@@RedDeadTierListsgreat video I just subscribed

[@NOAHCOYLE1]

20:07 rdr2 is the greatest game of all time

[@levisheets6386]

Indeed it is 😂

[@Yourubeei]

My question is how hasn’t John heard of tumbleweed in rdr1 if some of the gang members are from there, surely not all the gang members we see trekking up the mountains are from black water, I find it hard to believe that every gang member met Dutch in black water and that the gang were never more western than blackwater

[@KC.45]

Which gang members are from Tumbleweed?

[@Yourubeei]

@@KC.45 I’m not sure exactly from tumbleweed but I mean surely some would be from armadillo, I can’t believe that many people met Dutch in one small city and formed a gang for that long

[@Schlonberg_Sachs]

⁠​⁠​⁠@@YourubeeiI’ve never heard any of the gang members being from armadillo/Tumbleweed🤔 Dutch is a well spokesman, he recruited people that had no one to turn to just like Javier being on the run also Arthur had lost his parents at a young age etc. He just had a way of keeping that group together and some of them even see him as a father figure.

[@Zyphings]

What are you talking about? The gang didn’t meet at Blackwater, they were picked up all over the country as the years progressed. And there’s many lines of dialogue that explicitly say that Blackwater is the furthest EAST they’ve been as a gang, so I’m not sure what you mean about them “not being more west than Blackwater.”

[@KC.45]

24:23 "In 1902, Landon Ricketts moved to Canada and settled in the town of Chuparosa, Mexico." What.

[@levisheets6386]

Makes sense to me I don’t see anything wrong😂 with

[@mohamedgaafar2584]

chill it's just a mistake

[@sushm_7767]

He moved to canada, then moved down to mexico and finally settled

[@KC.45]

​@@sushm_7767 Landon never went to Canada.

[@sushm_7767]

@@KC.45 Oh right i see (i just know YEEE HAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW about RDR1 years)

[@PyrosCat_YT]

You forgot to mention the deaths of Arthur's wife and kkid.

[@francescomcundari]

Great video but you forgot that John and Abigail had a daughter between rdr2 and rdr1 but she died before rdr1 started

[@officialconch]

No matter how many ways people explain Dutch’s actions in the final mission I still get pissed off

[@MRLIETUVIS]

YOU should be on this timeline as a legend youtuber

[@CameronMay-dp1fv]

L glazer

[@POWBxDX4DxZOMB]

Real

[@Yourrtyt]

​@@CameronMay-dp1fvyour not funny

[@POWBxDX4DxZOMB]

​@CameronMay-dp1fv haters going to hate

[@CameronMay-dp1fv]

@@POWBxDX4DxZOMB I'm not joking

[@zach1421]

Arthur was shooting at da opp at 14 crazy 🤠

[@TheYuty15]

make a tierlist about every camp side activity (like hunting, homestead robberies, and coach robberies with camp members)

[@bigfatpug_s1465]

Glad you’re back with a 35 min video

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Will be posting much more soon.

[@bigfatpug_s1465]

@@RedDeadTierLists😢

[@deathtoaster449]

24:18 it was actually Arthur’s dream to die facing the west watching the setting sun, he dies in the exact opposite way he wanted to

[@UplandCowboy]

The dpp lake theme tho 😂

[@Cartoon_Cartoon187]

can you believe Sadie and Jake got married 100years before 2pac was shot in Vegas ?😦

[@JOHNMARSTONmemes]

7:30 so does jack not count as a member of the gang?

[@featgorgon3985]

slight correction to the ending of II, I don’t think Dutch was there to team up with Micah, Dutch was likely there to shoot Micah himself as evident by when John prompts him “what are you doing here Dutch” and Dutch answers “same as you I suppose”, implying Dutch was going to kill Micah like John was, wether Dutch was merely there for some sort of revenge or closure, or he wanted to take over Micah’s gang, I don’t know, but everything in the scene seems to indicate Dutch was going to shoot Micah regardless of if John did it himself

[@joshstabo6931]

I think we need to know what happened to Sadie Adlers dad. Why is Sadie so tough? Your honor if it's good can have an ending where you end up being a good dad and raising Sadie right. Or you can have low honor, but still very much love your daughter and have a strong relationship with her. Your last moments as a low honor ending could be going out fighting for her and she had to witness you die. Both would explain why she was so tough and it would be set in a time frame closer to the civil war. You could even have a run in with Wyatt Earp. you could either help him or at the end Wyatt Earp guns you down. the options are wide open and the only option I see to stay withing the Dutch Vanderlin gang lore while having a completely separate cast of characters without the ending being predictable. Not to mention you could even put Doc Holiday in it. Gosh I can just imagine the hype of hearing "I'm your huckleberry" in a red dead game....bruh.... The epilogue could be a young Arthur when he was around 25. It could carry on the tradition of bringing back a loved character like they did with John. In RDR2 we have Arthur when he was in his 30's. So time frame wise it would make sense to have him at about 25 if were ending off with Sadie being close to 16 at the end of RDR3.

[@StuntXKnightMare]

20:10 that's my life in a nutshell

[@Realtrey31]

2:16 why is jack right there in the bottom right

[@Yes-Bean]

Aw-gues-teen Allende 💀 Vinchente de Santa 💀 Ricketts moves to Canada after a gunfight in eastern California and then suddenly settles down in the town of Chuparosa in Mexico💀 Nueva Parais💀

[@rickfruitygrimes]

Javier is also born in 1873

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Yeah, I didn't wanna cover every single birth tho, I just did the one I thought were the most important.

[@YYeezus]

You should definitely rank every single robbery, including the ones where you rob side businesses in free roam.

[@Lovenycdrill-h7y]

Bro i played the whole game and still confused

[@TheRealLifty]

"The legendary gunslinger uncle" lol

[@Minato_akaza]

That fcking bull in rdr2 prologue 😮‍💨

[@Justice4BurreRapes740]

Hey there Mister

[@hardcore13ful]

Arthur’s death hit hard man

[@KnifeSotelo]

Everyone forgot about Red Dead Revolver huh lol

[@skysquirrel587]

Strauss is younger than hosea? 😭

[@kristovmaminnn]

I thought Uncle is the oldest in the gang...

[@Arm2tr0ng]

I read in a newspaper in RDR1 long before rdr2 came out and it said something about the departure of the gang in 1906. All the characters in rdr1 speak on the past transgressions of John like they happened less than 10 years ago. And why did they take 5 years to capture John and his family. It’ll make since if he left in 1906 and got found in 1909-1010 and the events of the first game is of course 1911.

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Yeah there's a lot of changes tbh

[@Arm2tr0ng]

@@RedDeadTierListsYeah, not meaning to criticize you did a great job and I learned things I originally didn’t know. I just think R* reused lore and events that were left vague and missed place them in the timeline causing a lot of plot holes. Rdr changed a lot story wise and game wise throughout development. Sadie can be found in black water with Arthur and a lot of ambrino was removed. Not to mention the forgotten marston Daughter

[@KC.45]

Someone did not play these games thoroughly, I'm afraid.

[@Arm2tr0ng]

@@KC.45 wym? I know more about RDR1 than I know 2. I played it through so many times growing up. I learned new things that the 2nd game brought to the table.

[@b.u.l.1734]

That's not true. The newspaper only says that 1906 was the last time Dutch was seen publicly. The gang isn't mentioned at all. And Marston's daughter isn't ignored in RDR 2, there's a reference to her during the epilogue.

[@ChickenSandwich518]

The wild thing is mafia 1 is set only 19 years after this. I'm older than the difference between cowboys and the mafia.

[@roidrush155]

Am I the only one that noticed the background music is Pokemon? I was watching but couldn’t help thinking about Sinnoh and I put two and two together

[@Tren-i]

Bro upload a new video

[@aidenelliott6509]

No way Landon rickets is only 2 years older than Arthur 😂 he looks older than Hosea

[@JTJordanTakabadmofo]

Wait no red dead revolver

[@xXxCaptRebelxXx]

Arthur did not want to die facing East towards the rising Sun he wanted to die facing west towards the setting Sun

[@DevilAlpacca]

Subscribed!

[@Arthur_Marston875]

Uhm.. John was born in 1873

[@JacobBerg-mo3pb]

He said that

[@Arthur_Marston875]

Nah he didnt

[@Realtrey31]

He said that

[@DeeJaKinnZ420]

He said 1870​@@Realtrey31

[@daspsycho1609]

No way Landon rickets is not the oldest, he almost smells like dirt

[@Aziel-y7h]

i really like the red dead redemption iceberg explained, there is a red dead online iceberg going around and i was thinking if you could make a video of that

[@mcw-lg2dm]

20:10 they must have caught that train at the 9 3/4 platform

[@realbouncy]

are you Adichu??????????????????

[@DeeJaKinnZ420]

Also the o driscolls gouge kieran's eyes out

[@Slowk_Panda]

Hahaha the train just drove normal away 😂

[@jmfamily7841]

He's back

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Posting a ton more soon.

[@graydonnielson388]

when was armadillo founded?

[@badgers48]

“1880 Lenny Summers is born who is the youngest member of the gang”… Jack: “bruh”

[@bradylyons3281]

Jack wasn’t in the gang he was John’s son all of them were dead by then

[@RKvs21]

Pretty sure John Marston was born in 1873, not 70! Nice video :)

[@RedDeadTierLists]

You're right, I just messed it up in the video. It's right on my script but I must've included it with the last one.

[@larisa9035]

Great video, but I come here searching for money. Where are the 10:02 gold bars?

[@JOHNMARSTONmemes]

Fr

[@FedericoB1891]

I can't help but think that all those deaths in the Wapiti arc were all for nothing

[@maxbaker6220]

They were they only attacked the army constantly cuz Dutch used them like he did with his own gang Arthur even called him out on it saying that he’s just using them and Dutch as usual just denies it

[@miisterpika4485]

Was hoping for undead nightmare but I guess it’s non canon

[@KC.45]

You guess?

[@Makaveli1996RAP]

Ur voice keeps cracking

[@Reddeadking69]

Do u play rdr2 online on Playstation

[@RexCherries69]

This is what rdr3 should be about

[@AidenBallman]

Love the content so far. Please cover some obscure or new topics besides every RDR KZbinr who just does RDR3 predictions or talk about the same few mysterious.

[@RedDeadTierLists]

I'm likely gonna be switching the content away from these kinda videos soon, and making more stuff that I think is interesting. Still RDR/RDR2 stuff just likely not these types of videos.

[@bigfatpug_s1465]

@@RedDeadTierListsis the channel dead?

[@UltimateBrofist13]

Ur my fave rdr KZbinr lol ❤

[@Ryan_James2099]

Y don't we see Johnson in 1907 if he's Marshall in 1897

[@RedDeadTierLists]

He leaves because of cholera in 1907

[@Ryan_James2099]

​​@RedDeadTierLists thanks bro (btw love ur content.)

[@Jdmzero1]

Imagine we get rd3 avenging John as jack

[@Gtathatruth]

that was literally the end of rdr1 was him avenging John by killing the exact man who was responsible for his killing

[@Kacper_Akarii]

Damn i started watching you like 2 days ago and i must say the videos are super

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Yeah, will be trying to make a ton more videos but changing the format a bit.

[@enviousdisaster3280]

The mexican war was pretty much in red dead Revolver!

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Yeah, but Revolver technically is in a different canon like GTA HD vs GTA 3D Vs GTA 2D

[@POWBxDX4DxZOMB]

"La Mexican revolution"

[@KC.45]

​@@RedDeadTierListsProps to you for acknowledging such an overlooked, confirmed fact.

[@chrishelbling3879]

Superb!

[@geokeenremakes1199]

Can we get another characters tear list

[@RedDeadTierLists]

I will definitely try to do some this summer, but lots more of other stuff tbh, so many tier lists have kinda burned me out.

[@gragraboom.]

best video ever!

[@Michaelmccutchen]

This whould be a crazy twist

[@lfeeq8227]

Bro i needed your video keep posting

[@RedDeadTierLists]

Content will change a bit more in the coming weeks but will be posting a ton more during the summer.

[@adamnerd1236]

Love the Pokémon music