Reincarnation in Judaism

Where do we find reincarnation in the Bible? How many times might a person reincarnate? And how does reincarnation fit into the greater picture of the afterlife, the world of resurrection, and what happens to a soul after death? Also: does Judaism subscribe to the notion of an eternal hell?
Find out in this class as we dive into Biblical reincarnation and answer the big questions about the transmigration of souls and the afterlife.
For a written summary and more information, see here: www.mayimachro...
See also, ‘An Honest Look at Death and Afterlife’: www.mayimachro...
On the ‘Origins and Kabbalah of Kaddish’: www.mayimachro...

[@gpk7683]

Your teachings have given me hope. I do not understand why my eyes were opened to Judaism at age 84 but better now than later.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear :)

[@debrapaulino918]

Wow ❤

[@KateGladstone]

Well, 84 = 12 x 7, and those numbers carry a lot of symbolism in Judaism … in case that comforts you …

[@Lannaread225]

It’s never too late ♥️I am happy for you!

[@eesasaladin]

So none Jew can be Jew ??

[@4951wolcott]

Mr. Palvanov illuminates yet another subject of curiosity with the breadth of sources and penetrating insights that characterize his talks.

[@raf_abreu]

We are blessed to have a teacher like Efraim! Thank you again for all your wonderful lectures and all the efforts in teaching us the Emet of the Torah! Baruch HaShem!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@alchemistkingdickinson2256]

Imagine what hed teach if he knew Moshiach ; like Kaduri did?

[@dkbrain3434]

Agreed. Amen.

[@Everykneeshallbowandconfess]

You’re next generation is your children and grandchildren and people usually live to see them and some don’t have children at all, that theory of reincarnation doesn’t fit that How is 2-3, generations you live again if you still living??? Reincarnation if exist it’s on absolutely no need to know basic And that scriptures have different explanation much simpler and actually make sense, but I won’t say it here

[@Everykneeshallbowandconfess]

All this knowledge and no spirit no ability to understand, you need to go back to basics Understanding comes from God by his mercy, humble yourself and pray for understanding with real intentions to accept what he open up to you

[@gavrielgoldstein]

Rabbi I love how you strive to bring us back to the way judaism was meant to be understood. If only all Rabbis shared the same wisdom as you. You remind me that Judaism is not a religion like we are taught to believe nowadays but rather life itself and the way in which we should live.

[@dkbrain3434]

Profound! Exactly!

[@grantbishop1961]

It's all pagan annunaki ancestor worship. They stole the reincarnation ideology from the Annunaki who wrote the Indian philosophies / religions and the jews were known as the Kalani death cult, and yes they sacrifices women and children to Baal their Lord Annunaki.

[@grantbishop1961]

It's all Annunaki pagan worship. Jews worship alien god called Enlil - Yahweh - Satan - Yaldobaoth

[@Rohit-jc2sm]

Lol they are simply copying indian religion ideals

[@ShilohSapir]

Exactly. Judaism is not a religion.. Judaism is a profound way to live. Halachah and the extreme rituals created by the Rabbis after the destruction of the Temple are not the essence of Judaism as written in Tanakh or Kabbalah. Rav Efraim is teaching us the WAY of Judaism.... for the beauty of living the LIFE of a JEW. 🎉

[@shamini2811]

Wow! What a simple explanation about our life on earth!! I have been a catholic all my life and have been listening to Christian preachers since recently., but I have never heard such a good explanation about our life on earth and the purpose of our lives. I had so much of questions for which I never got answers from our religious leaders.,as a result I was confused., but today I received answers to most of the senseless questions I had haunting In my mind. Thank you so much for opening my eyes! God bless you!🙏

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear, may you be blessed as well!

[@dianagurman3649]

Jewish scholars dig into all aspects of Judaic teachings to bring us clarity and meaning.

[@commonsenselucy5697]

Thank you SO MUCH for this message. So comforting to me right now. My close companion of 4 years died very suddely yesterday from a massive stroke and brain bleed. He was taken from me "so suddenly." I believe I was put into his life to lead him to Torah. When we met, he didn't know anything about it, but he died KNOWING YHWH, and believing in the TORAH. I believe he "cleared some past sins" in this life, and has graduated. Perhaps he will reincarnate now at a "higher level." He had a VERY ROUGH LIFE in this incarnation. I PRAY HE DOES BETTER NEXT TIME AROUND. Baruch Hashem, and todah to you, Rabbi. Love your messages.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

So sorry for your loss... Baruch Dayan haEmet.

[@commonsenselucy5697]

@@EfraimPalvanov Thank you. I have been reciting the Kaddish Mourner's prayer this week. One question. If everyone gets reincarnated....even the goyim.....how does that line up with Amalek and Esauv being destroyed in "end times?" Would that be the equivalent to the 4 strikes and you're out? Just assuming then that even someone from those tribes could "convert" before the "final battle," and avoid that final judgment? I was just wondering how you could be reincarnated if you were part of those groups? Any light on this matter would be helpful. Again, this message has really blessed me; I listened to it twice, and really look forward to Part 2. Shalom.

[@shirleyannelindberg1692]

@@commonsenselucy5697 Isaiah 55:8 “For My thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways My ways.” It is a declaration of HaShem. 9 “For as the heavens are higher than earth, so are My ways higher than your ways, and My thoughts than your thoughts. 10 For as the rain and snow come down from heaven, and do not return there without having watered the earth, making it bring forth and sprout, giving seed to sow and bread to eat, 11 so My word will be that goes out from My mouth. It will not return to Me in vain, but will accomplish what I intend, and will succeed in what I sent it for.”

[@IAMTHEMANCALLEDO]

I've heard this topic before but never in such detail. Thank you so much.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Very welcome :)

[@i8dpie]

Yet another reason to be kind to animals. Compliments to whoever does the graphics and editing of these videos-excellent work, crisp, crystal clear, beautiful images.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you, it's a one-man team :)

[@isasalaam5055]

@@EfraimPalvanov No ordinary one man team...🙂

[@noahroad6577]

It’s amazing that I actually (over all these years) overlooked Job 33:29-30.. but there it is. Wow! Thank you ❤

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@ayrsine]

I know you’re just passing on all of the things that you have learned from your life and Judaism and the Arizal. However, the knowledge that you share with us transforms us actively while we’re listening to it brotha you’re an amazing Shofar for Hashem.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear, thank you!

[@debrapaulino918]

​@@EfraimPalvanovI passed the 30 Noahide laws onto a friend and am excited to pass this one tomorrow to same friend. I can hardly believe it. Great presentations. Simple and clear.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

@@debrapaulino918 Thank you!

[@Eliezer1018]

Baruch HaShem. Thanks for your outstanding teachings. May HaShem continue to bless all your handiwork. Beezrat HaShem.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Amen, thank you!

[@raychingcar7881]

The love of HaShem for His children is unmatched.

[@sikiescordova1826]

It has limits.

[@shirleyannelindberg1692]

@sikiescordova1826, Even Discipline is embraced with love 💕 He loves us like parents who love their children, while even disciplining them.

[@thatguy3468]

@@shirleyannelindberg1692 We are the ones that end up disciplining ourselves through free will. We are given choices, eventually the soul will correct through the learning process using free will.

[@VascoZaharra]

Masterful presentation Rabbi. Beautifully articulated every point. Thank you sir! Great work.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Appreciate the feedback, thank you!

[@nicolesawyer-jm6ir]

A rare and amazing teacher here. I do grateful for your work. I truly look forward to each session.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you so much!

[@alchemistkingdickinson2256]

@@EfraimPalvanov Moshiach who is his past incarnations? WANT TO KNOW? GO WATCH THE VIDEO LOOK ALL THE EVIDENCE! WHO DO YOU THINK WILL BE 1ST KZbinR WATCHMAN WATCHWOMEN RAPTURE BELIEVER KZbin VIDEO MAKER WHO WILL 1ST SEE THEIR ONLY HOPES HUMAN FACE? AMIR? BEGLEY? BLUE HEAVEN? MR BONES? WATCHMAN 88? BREAKER? GIRL?BOY? POPULAR? NOT SO POPULAR? REX BEAR? DIAMOND? DUTCHSINSE? ISLAM? MUSLEM? JEW? CHRISTIAN? ATHIEST? YOUNG? OLD? WHAT WILL THEY SEE MAKES THEM KNOW THIEF IN NIGHT IS PRESENT IN FLESH? KNOW ANYBODY SERIOUSILY SEEKING ONLY HOPES PRESENCE? EVERYBODY ALWAYS SAYING EVERYBODY WILL KNOW AND BELIEVE MOSHIACH? THAT IS MOST RIDICULOUS LIE ANYBODY COULD BE SAYING HERE! READ ISIAH 53 WHICH HAS TO BE FULFILLED AND IS AND HAS BEEN! MESSIAH HUMANS HAVE CRUCIFIED JOB STORY MAXMUS CHRIST OWN MOM CALLS CHRIST A LIAR ; CHRIST KIDS CALL MOSHIACH MENTALLY ILLED DEMON AND THEIR MOM A BEAUTIFUL ANGEL AND THEIR MOM HAS TRIED KILL THIER ONLY HOPE RIGHT IN FRONT THEIR EYES MANY MANY MANY TIMES!!! IF CHRIST MOM CANT RECOGNIZE GODS SON AND MOSHACHS KIDS CANT RECOGNIZE GODS ONLY BEGOTTEN SON ; THEN BY GOLLY ITS MAJOR DIFFICULT TASK TO RECOGNIZE MOSHIACH AT THE START! YES BE EASY ONCE BIBI SAYS HERE IS MESSIAH!!! MODERN PROPHETS PORTRAY MOSHIACH AS A UGLY STINKY BIG FOOTED BEAST MONSTER THAT ALL BLAME FOR ANY TROUBLES AND CANT STAND AND RUN FROM! THERE COULDNT BE A BETTER EXAMPLE OF HOW HUMANS TREAT MOSHIACH! MESSIAH IS IN JOBS COFFIN! NOT SEEN HIS KIDS SINCE MAY 13 2005! BIG EVIL ARMY HUNTING MOSHIACH!!! MOSHIACH BEEN HAVING TO LIVE IN A SWAMP TO STAY HIDDEN FROM THIS EVIL ARMY! GOING BE A RASING FROM THE DEAD SCENERIO MOSHIACH IS A DEAD SKULL NOBODY KNOWS ; NOBODY WANTS TO KNOW AND NOBODY SEEKS TO KNOW!!!! JUNG SAYS MOSHIACH IS A VERY ELUSIVE TINY FISH IN A GIANT OCEAN! Jung also says: The nuptuial union in the thalmus {bridal chamber} signifies the heiros gamos , and this in turn is the first step towards the incarnation, towards the birth of the savior who , since antiquity, was thought of as the filuis solis et lunae , the filius sapientia , and the equivalent of Christ. When therefore , a longing for the exaltation of the mother of God passes through the people , this tendency, if thought to its logical conclusion , means the desire for the birth of a saviour , a peace maker, a mediator pacem faciens inter inimicos. ALTHOUGH HE IS ALREADY BORN IN THE PLEROMA , HIS BIRTH IN TIME CAN ONLY BE ACCOMPLISHED WHEN IT IS PERCEIVED , RECOGNIZED , AND {DECLARED} BY THE PEOPLE. IF YOU KNOW SOMEBODY SINCERE AND SERIOUS ABOUT THEIR BRAIN CONSCIOUSNESS WANTING KNOW WHO KADURI MEET 11/4/2003 POINT THEM TO THIS COMMENT PLEASE! ALL ANY HUMAN HAS TO IS ESTABLISH COMMUNICATIONS WITH MOSHIACH AND CHERISH KNOWING MOSHIACH AND CHERISH KNOWING GOD AND CHERISH WHAT MOSHIACH WANTS YOU TO SEE AND KNOW UNTIL YOU HAVE NO DOUBT! CAN YA TAKE 15 HOURS OUT OF YOUR BUSY LIFE LISTEN TO MOSHIACH AND FOLLOW HIS COMMENTS AND VIDEOS HE IS WANTING YOU TO SEE? GO MY CHANNEL SUBSCRIBE WATCH MY LIVE VIDEO CLICK ON LIVE CLICK ON THAT VIDEO WATCH IT! THEN GO TO COMMENTS UNDER IT READ WORDS AND WATCH VIDEOS GIVEN IN COMMENTS AND LEAVE COMMENT; ASK A QUESTION! SEEK TRUTH AND REALITY USING YOUR FREE WILL TO KNOW MOSHIACH AND TO KNOW GOD AND TO BE BLESSED!!! YOU CAN DO IT!!! AND NOBODY IS GOING DO IT FOR YOU! Psalms 17:10 FOR HE DID NOT BREAK THRU THE HEAVENS AND DID NOT MAKE THE MYSTERY MANIFEST , BUT CAME DOWN TO EARTH SECRETLY ,LIKE RAIN UPON THE FLEECE Psalms 71:6 ; Judges 6,37 BECAUSE THE INCARNATION WAS SECRET AND UNKNOWN AND HIS COMING INTO THE WORLD ORDER WAS HIDDEN.

[@sajiissac1920]

I am very pleased with your teachings, and it distinguish the divinity of Bible. When you teach, the audience has the right and time to ask questions. The knowledge, scientific references, and righteous words impress me the most. The calmness and clarity make it more distinguishable. The ones who enjoy it the most are those who know the Torah by heart and seek to improve their knowledge. May God Almighty give you more talent and blessings.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Amen, thank you, and may you blessed be as well!

[@carolelouie]

Thanks for this series, Efraim Palvanov. I have learned a lot about this topic that I did not know before. Can I ask you to repeat the questions asked by the audience to help those of watching later to know those questions too?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Will try to keep that in mind, thanks for the feedback.

[@Red2mybones]

Fascinating! This answers so many questions i had in life! I'm so blessed to be on this level of learning vs what other ppl are using social media for being stuck in a sleep cycle of hate and unawareness of deeper meanings to life! Thank you HaShem for your lights of the world! This was amazing! 🥲🙏🏼✨

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear, thank you :)

[@mushtaqobaray7529]

Reincarnation of Judaism is somewhat similar to Brahmanical theology, you get reincarnated till you become perfect and Join with the creator as you are a spark of the creator himself.

[@John-ne4fq]

He said you only get 4 chances

[@debrapaulino918]

AI just today brought you in feed and im astonished at the timing of topics.

[@Ben-hs9dr]

How do we know how many times we have been reincarnated or do we even realize we have been reincarnated? Thank you for a very enlightening video.

[@vanessamoodie6068]

Baruch Hashem! Thank you. I'm a Noahide who always felt that I have a Jewish soul but who can't convert....always obstacles. So there's hopefor my soul and I. I've listened to many rabbi's explanations. Rabbi Efrain you seem to have wrapped them up into one neat, comprehensive parcel. Thank you.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thanks Vanessa!

[@samkarno8884]

Thank you Brother 👊🏻🥰 Coming from an Ashkar and Orthodox Family 🙏🏻❤️ And wow yeah Your words are Beautiful We are all the one true creator subjectively Experienceing itself to every single outcome which is eternal And LOVE We will Experience more together Are we not in Hell now Worrying All Together as a whole creation, all life. Does tomorrow exist the way the world is right now

[@jmichelleART]

You read my mind, ive been interested in the knowledge of Judaism lately, binging these videos a bit, and this was one of my questions.

[@grantbishop1961]

They never tell you the secret in order to retain your memories in the next life so you remain their lower caste goy slave. Even though they have the same amount of annunaki DNA as the next hybrid human on earth.

[@GilaDMD]

Excellent Reb Efi! So much clarity. Wow

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thanks!

[@isasalaam5055]

Thank you Efraim for video... It takes so long to get things right but once we do, then the REAL party begins....

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Absolutely :)

[@-kirsty-7879]

This was extremely interesting, thankyou! You have a new subscriber

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you!

[@shoshannafachima1306]

Thank you again for a truly thought inspiring lesson. Their is extensive research on past lives with vast documentation.the pioneering research was mainly carried out by prof.ian stephenson et al,and of course their are now more researchers doing fascinating work. יישר כוח וברוך תהיה🙏

[@omarlittle-hales8237]

SALaM, SHLAMa, SHLOMo, SHALoM, NAMASTe, PEACe. Though God Sent The Vedas, Avesta, Cannon, Book Of Enoch, Psalms, Torah, Gospel & Quran. No Where In The Vedas, Mentions The Word Hindu. No Where In The Avesta, Mentions The Word Zoroastrian. No Where In Canon, Mentions The Word Buddhist. No Where In The Torah, Mentions The Word Jews Or Judaism. No Where In The Gospel, Mentions The Word Christian. XXXxXXX

[@ReelJoyy]

How is reincarnation even logical if you can’t remember your past life? How can you improve yourself if you can’t remember what you did wrong in the past life

[@stevecruickshank8912]

You’re right I would like him to explain that

[@shirleyannelindberg1692]

With HaShem all things are possible 🙌🏻💪🏻

[@iansmith9474]

When is the next one? I can't wait to see how reincarnation is reconciled with the ressurrection.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

God willing, next week.

[@commonsenselucy5697]

@@EfraimPalvanov Yes, looking forward to Part 2 very much. Todah, Rabbi.

[@tangokaleidos1926]

we are given life until the Day of Judgement so that every man and woman has a true chance to accept the Savior. Then we are all raised up at the same time for judgement by Him.

[@carolelouie]

Wonderful video! Thank you for sharing.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@ludovictrouche7641]

Very interesting as usually :). What about the reincarnation of animals and plants?

[@my2cworth4U]

Could being born 'outside Jerusalem' mean 'as a gentile'? And as 1 day of God's time = 1,000 years our time, could the punishment time mean - for 1,000 years?

[@stevenxiaofenghuang]

Thank you Rabbi for explaining all this structurally and comprehensively. The light pushed away the darkness. Judaism is really the light for the world. Barukh Hashem.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure, thanks for the feedback.

[@TagMahirTzedek]

Rashi Commentary on Job 33:29-30 is "twice or thrice: He chastises him for his iniquities with his illness in order not to destroy him, but if he provokes Him further, he should be concerned with Gehinnom or death, as it is written, “Yea for four, I will not return them” (Amos 1:3)." - Also it goes against the Rishonim and Rambam's whole Philosophy.

[@yaakov9036]

No it doesn't contradict Rambam. Secondly, read Aben Ezra and Ramban on the Midrash Shivim Panim L'Toah. The School of R. Ishmael taught: "As a hammer shatters a rock" (Jeremiah 23:29) - Just as a hammer subdivides into many different sparks, so does the biblical verse extend into many different interpretations (Babylonian Talmud, Tractate Sanhedrin 34a).

[@TagMahirTzedek]

@@yaakov9036 You don't make sense. Rambam and the Rishonim never wrote FOR Gilgilum. In fact Rav Saadia Gaon wrote strongly against it. He had the literal Mesora

[@EverythingHumorous]

​@@TagMahirTzedek The Babylonian Geonim are our Mesorah for halakha, including the proper methodology to Biblical exegesis and interpretation of Midrash/Agadata. However, as Rambam himself wrote in Moreh Nevukhim, as far as he was aware, authentic Jewish mysticism was lost. A living esoteric mesorah was nowhere to be found besides Sefer Yesira (which Rav Sa'adya wrote a perush on but eventually admitted he didn't understand it), Sifre Hekhalot and shiur Qoma. Rambam rejected these sefarim but Ibn Ezra accepted and Rav Yehudah HaLevi did as well to my knowledge. At least Sefer Yesira. Chakhme Yisrael and Rome MIGHT have carried on an esoteric mesorah and transmitted to the German Rabbanim and eventually the Rabbanim of Provence and the Ra'avad's family, but it's difficult to say with full certainty.

[@yitzyfink]

Also Thanks So Much for the shiur!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@jefferystocker8214]

You’re incredible! Amazing lecture!!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you so much!

[@ijokoode9137]

Thanks for this is one of the greatest teachings I have ever had.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear, thank you.

[@SolariaEsoterica]

Thank you! This makes so much sense ❤

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@robertlucas3749]

At time 27:08. I have been saying for a long time”DOES NOT MAKE SENSE”. I live in America with western religion. Just recently received you on KZbin and you are my God send. Thanks.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear, thank you.

[@oracleig]

Firstly, I love your commentary and you bringing up topics that most do not bring up however JOB 33 29-30; YHVH refines us as bronze silver and gold... we are refined by fire or being tested so how would this verse state that we are reincarnation when we are merely spiritually being refined as we are tried in the flesh and the Ruach.

[@debrapaulino918]

Is there a connection then with the verse that promises Hashem will remember their children even to the 1000th generation?

[@rosslynjohnston3179]

I just have two questions. Yeshua said in Hebrews 9:27-28 And as it is appointed unto men once to die? Yeshua’s crucifixion for our sins and sicknesses negates having to come back?

[@JR-yx3po]

Hi Rabbi - You’re really brilliant. Thank you so much. Just curious - Is there a reason that you pronounce the word Judaism with three syllables instead of four?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thanks! That's how it should be pronounced - Judaism is the religion of Judah, not Judy :)

[@stevecruickshank8912]

How is reincarnation even logical if you can't remember your past life? How can you improve yourself if you can't remember what you did wrong in the past life/ please explain this question thanks

[@EfraimPalvanov]

This was addressed later in the series. Please watch all three videos.

[@stevecruickshank8912]

@ Thanks 🙏

[@lauriehowell4765]

Where is the accountability in the resurrection of the dead? Which life?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Will cover it in Part 2, stay tuned.

[@Tara98124]

@@EfraimPalvanovlooking forward to it because accountability would certainly be a question because how can someone so fractured know what they did or didn’t do?

[@MrZionomega]

My question is this, how did I begin my three or four times? If I began in a perfected soul state how did it get tarnished along the way? What would be the purpose of taking a clean soul and throwing it into this messy journey?

[@alecrim888]

Hi Rabbi! Warm greetings from Brazil 🙂 As a Buddhist, I know about reincarnation very well, as it's the only explanation for all beings' suffering. Although certain details may vary in Buddhism and Judaism, and even other reincarnationist belief systems, the purpose of reincarnation (if you can say that) is basically to right wrongs. Does motivation plays any role in this equation in Judaism? People may do bad things unknowingly or unintentionally and motivation in Buddhist is in the center of everything we do in body, speech and mind (you kind of said that something similar in the past videos, don't quite remember which).

[@benjohnson6128]

regarding 29:55 about a good god will not do these things, but Asiah says god creates the light and he creates good and evil. so he created all things. and again he says for the heavens are higher than the earth my thoughts are higher than yours

[@bookmouse2719]

Very interesting, thank you More Palvanov.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@sammymavorah9718]

Loved your class. Thank you ❤

[@Jasn_Chvz]

Great lecture. Definitely filled in a lot of rational questions about reincarnation and eternal punishment. Thank you.

[@deepwaters2334]

Don't you think that Job 33:29-30 is really referring to the 1st and 2nd resurrections that may be necessary for the final judgement ?

[@ellen-yy3oc]

One of the greatest blessings we can receive is to remember the former life especially if it is painful. Then you know clearly what you have to do.

[@Ben-hs9dr]

What if there are some, like myself, who have no recollection of a past life? Do they have any blessing or are they cursed?

[@ellen-yy3oc]

I think we only get recall if we need it. If no memory you have come in with a much cleaner slate than me.@@Ben-hs9dr

[@gaylenematherne1593]

Thank you so much for your wisdom and all the life long hard work you have put in to your soul and for helping all our souls fall in love with the Torah and Hashem. Your time and teaching of Hashem will bring so many to the truth of life . My love is with Torah . Shalom

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure, thank you for the kind words.

[@veronicaramirez4631]

So no one person can die for your sins? Truly amazing!!!

[@theinvisibleworld888]

I came not to break the law but to fulfill it. With that being said, there is no way "Jesus" died for "our sins"

[@SamsonZionist]

@@theinvisibleworld888 Well you are entitled to Your opinion but on the day of Judgment when You come face to face with King JESUS what will You say when He asks You why You denied Him?

[@theinvisibleworld888]

@SamsonZionist lol clown I'll ask him why he chose to hide himself and be silent , why he chose for us to come into a world with no memories and be led and given identities as a child out side of our will. Why he chose to play a game and force us to lean on our own understanding. Why he allowed the spell of religion on us , why he chose to come only as a man and who the hell is he to judge me. Lol clown 🤡

[@gyulaborzasi343]

​@@SamsonZionist what you reap you will sow, sorry to wake you up from your dream

[@SamsonZionist]

@@gyulaborzasi343 Amen, I pray I sow the Free Gift of Christ Jesus to all who will hear. Jesus alone saves. Shalom

[@Thenoobestgirl]

What happens if you come back as someone of another religion?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

This is certainly possible, and I hope to speak about it in Part 3.

[@30ps-y4m]

​@@EfraimPalvanovits more like our hinduism

[@EfraimPalvanov]

@@30ps-y4m Have you seen the class on 'Judaism vs. Hinduism'? kzbin.info/www/bejne/qIi1qH-XhLB0fJI

[@30ps-y4m]

@@EfraimPalvanov no will check it but some things are similar

[@rachelkennedy2161]

Brilliant teaching, Thank you Rabbi 🙏🙏🪷🇬🇧🇮🇱✡️

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@pizza4me298]

So it's a mission the soul has, but we don't know in life what the mission is or what we missed in a past life?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

I believe it is possible to figure out, or to have an inner sense of what one's mission in life is.

[@yhwhreigns]

He keeps back his soul from the pit, and his life from perishing by the sword. Job 33:18. Lo, all these things works G-d oftentimes (or, two or three times) with man, Job 33:29. It means G-d will save a man from death two or three times, not bring him back from death or the grave two or three times. I don't see that the Hebrew Bible is talking about reincarnation at all. It would be contrary to who G-d is and there is no example of it happening to anyone in the Tanach. Exodus 20: 6, uses generations, not reincarnations. This is Jewish mysticism (Kabbalah), not scripture. Thank you.

[@YouTube.R.]

What about Kaf Hakela? What about a person who brings others to sin. If after 11 months or 50 days, he is out of hell, but his actions in this world continue to cause people to sin even after decades, so does that mean he does not get punished for the fruit of his sins? Also if a regular rasha gets 11 months, what does somebody like Hitler or Mussulini or Bin Laden or Manis Friedman YM get? Do they both get the same 11 months? Please clarify, Professor Ephraim.. I'm not following your logic... if Hashem judges "middah keneged middah" your calculations are way off. I'm clearly nowhere near as educated as you are, and I admire your knowledge on all the topics you've discussed, and I'm fascinated by the breadth of your Torah knowledge, however I have a hard time following the reasoning you propose in this class, while also undermining notable Kiruv Rabbaim. Suggested reading of you haven't already would be Minhat Yehudah by Rabbi Yehuda Fetaya.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Please see all three parts of this series. I think your questions will be answered. Appreciate your kind words, thank you.

[@mikecitgo2939]

Thank You Rabbi for Your clear tesching. A question of interest. Would these rabbis who added on to this teaching of reincarnation,( for sbout 200 years) recieved the same inspiration as Moshe our teacher? Or did they recieved a lower form of inspiration? Thank You 😊

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure. It is a fundamental principle of Jewish belief that Moses was the greatest prophet of all time, and no one ever matched him in prophecy or divine inspiration. It is also generally held that the age of true prophecy ended shortly after the destruction of the First Temple. Since then, there is "divine inspiration" (Ruach haKodesh) but no genuine prophecy.

[@haemeth42]

when I first heard this topic from Rabbi Mizrachi i was so amazed. Todah Rabbi for explaining this topic

[@mitzijackson3598]

Thank-you so much for your teachings...very much appreciated. May Hashem bless you greatly.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Amen, thank you!

[@JustSayinOracleTarot]

Wow well this clears things up. Thank you

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Very welcome!

[@j.lsantos9106]

Impressive discussion

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thanks!

[@donnaburden.dip.d.analysis2148]

What a great blessed teaching. Thank you. Xx

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@shmuelprakash6849]

Shalom Rabbi.. Do..u plan to teach shaar hagilgulim text..in detail

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Will go in more detail in Part 2, with specific examples of reincarnation.

[@jennifferjude3156]

An Earthly year? Or a heavenly year? What’s the conversion, like , how long is a heavenly year compared to an earth year?

[@florenceAngel-dx1iq]

Doesn’t “we suffer for sins of great grandparents,” mean that the bad habits (sins) get passed down to our children and they pass to their children? Like I murder the spirit by criticizing, yelling, domineering ppl. My kid watches me do that (or is recipient) and s/he does that bc s/he learned that from me.

[@mickeyi.a.6465]

Hi, which family does a person belong to after many gilgulim?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Will address this in Part 2, stay tuned.

[@TheRoshav]

Thank you, this explains a lot!! If we are close to redemption and resurrection of the dead, anymore reincarnation?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure. I will go into this in more detail in Part 2.

[@SchrödingersBounty]

Job also says something like "...I exited naked from my mother's womb, and naked I will *return* there". In the case of Christian Bibles most translate it this way, but others change the meaning so as to remove the implications.

[@Josh-Leshem]

The reward for a Mitzva is so great that it can’t be paid in this physical world. So there will be a „payment“ in an eternal world or Gan Eden

[@RepairtheBreach5812]

Once again Rabbi, you have opened my eyes to see ❤

[@tommerphy1286]

@ two things if what you are saying is a secret ( that half of what you are saying is in Hebrew that I don't speak) two ) the denial of Jesus is the denial of his reincarnation. 3) does the realm of "I AM" accept dead flesh?

[@wickiezulu]

In some respects could reincarnation be thought of along similar lines to how a cell divides or how one candle lights many, essentially one is not strictly the same as before yet shares the same root. Also criticism of reincarnation within Judaism should be seen in the context of where critics mostly resided at the time, as reincarnation was largely associated with heterodox or ghulat sects. OTOH how does one reconcile reincarnation in Judaism with say the Ishbitzer's predeterministic perspective on free-will (where an individual can only at best control how they react to situations in life)?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Yes, the candle analogy is the one used by our Sages, and I plan to speak about it (and its Scriptural origins) in Part 2.

[@yitzyfink]

The Arizal writes that learning about קרבנות does Not help for the מעשה aspect, and that a person who needs to fulfill a sacrifice will reincarnate once the temple is rebuilt in order to physically bring a sacrifice.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Or you already fulfilled it in a past life when the Temple was still around!

[@seanvandiijk2889]

I read somewhere or heard that what sin causes is a disruption of the timelines since we are all connected and a sacrifice is required to restore the flow of time. Huge subject, maybe is not so great idea to dwell much into it.

[@JDogg9550]

Can you please make a video on Sefer Raziel HaMalakh?

[@yoshiperspectives4880]

Job 33:30 says "to bring his soul back from destruction to shine on him the light of the living." This speaks of the profit that is gained from the destruction of discipline, not bring a soul back that has died. Death is not mentioned here. "שחת" means destruction not grave.

[@deborahhicks4611]

Are the soul and spirit different?

[@donseesyourshaydim7529]

This is great, but goodness, every time you're mid sentence, about to drop more insights, the same dude inturrupts you. Like, compulsively. You have infinite patience. It's hard to tell when people really want to have dialogue sincerely or if they're envious that you're the one at the podium and not them.

[@Hbmd3E]

And the angel which I saw stand upon the sea and upon the earth lifted up his hand to heaven, And sware by him that liveth for ever and ever, who created heaven, and the things that therein are, and the earth, and the things that therein are, and the sea, and the things which are therein, *that there should be time no longer* : But in the days of the voice of the seventh angel, when he shall begin to sound, *the mystery of God should be finished* , as he hath declared to his servants the prophets. Rev. 10:5

[@user-pd7il3xz5j]

Reb Efraim, can the camera be positioned closer to you? I feel like I've been banished to the back of the room.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Sorry, I'm camera shy and really don't like to be in front of the camera. That's why there is very little footage of me in the videos at all and it's mostly slides and images! Maybe you can join in-person some day and sit in the front row :)

[@Bideosmedia]

At 10:10 you mentioned a book in alphabetical order of who has reincarnated from who and why. What is the name of that book? Thank you in advance

[@EfraimPalvanov]

'Sefer Gilgulei Neshamot' by Rabbi Menachem Azaria de Fano.

[@Bideosmedia]

@@EfraimPalvanov have you ever read Pistis Sophia?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

@@Bideosmedia Nope

[@Bideosmedia]

@@EfraimPalvanov I find your videos fascinating because what you teach correlates with my studies. I also recommend the Philokalia and the Nag Hammadi Library. What would you recommend?

[@Elysiel_cherub]

There was a wise man. He was dearly beloved. He was an intellectual and poetic individual. One day he met an Assyrian Prince who recently arrived to Jerusalem from Nineveh. The young man was sitting against the wall on a side street because a lover of his became physically abusive. The wise man saw that he needed help and magically healed his broken nose and ankle. The Assyrian couldn't understand why this man helped him when others he encountered treated him as a heretic. The wise man said, "I knew that I loved you the moment I laid my eyes upon you. I saw that you were in need of help. So I extended my hand out to you." The Assyrian questioned the man and accepted the hand that this man held out. The wise man invited the prince over for dinner but the prince refused to eat. The wise man saw that life was unkind and so he took it upon himself to do what needed to be done for his new friend and student. The wise man taught him the ways of being able to bring to balance the forces within themselves. He taught him the way to navigate the tree of life and at the same time, this wise man wanted to learn from the Assyrian, the mysteries of the Goddess. He was so intrigued by the man he met that he wondered why. They became more than just friends. He saw within the Assyrian an enchanting soul linked to the goddess. The wise man worshipped the ground the goddess walked upon. He began to covet the power of her and one day, he woke up and realized there was something deeply wrong with the world. He made it his mission to teach people what he realized. But the so-called sages didn't want him spreading the truth. IT is because the truth would set a person free. People haven't realized that they've been locked into cycles of reincarnation that has been causing them to get more and more lost in this matrix. The wise man approached the Assyrian and told him that he needed to see the truth, he said, "They will hate you because of me. Remember that you're loved. No matter how hard it gets. Follow the teachings I gave you." So the Assyrian indeed learned the truth about the old sages. This Assyrian man saw they were lying to the people and purposely holding them back from the truth. The Assyrian became an agent for King David. The redemption is here, but who will listen to the truth? When King Solomon heralds the arrival of King David, who will listen?

[@Josh-Leshem]

Here is another ineresting point I found concerning time differences: How Long is Punishment in Gehinom? Time There is Different. If a person goes to the first six levels of Gehinom for whatever sins they've committed, there is a punishment and it's a very serious punishment. But it end at some point It can be a month, it could be 5 thousand years, it could be five million years, but at some point it ends. Remember, time over there is not like time over here. So even if mashiach comes, it doesn't mean that the person, let's say mashiach comes next year, it doesn't mean that a person that goes to gehinom tomorrow is only going to be in gehinom for one year. It doesn't mean that. There's no time over there. Meaning, that moshiach could come next year, but that person went to Gehinom for 50,000 years. Why? Because there's no time there. Here it's a year. Over there could be fifty thousand years. One of the places we learn this in the torah is parashat shelach. What did Hakodesh Baruch Hu say to Am Yisrael? He says: you said something against the land and said lashon hara about the land after going there for forty days. For every one of your days I'm going to count a year. That's a forty year punishment. Forty days trip, one second actual sin, became a forty year punishment. No one from that generation entered Eretz Yisrael. Here we already see that Hakodesh Baruch Hu's time span and clock is very different than ours. A one second sin could be centuries of punishment. I think that’s something to think about also before claiming there is not more then max 12 months of cleaning. If this would be the case people could think ,H‘shem yishmor , „I can do which ever sin I want and get only max 12 month of purgatory. I think that also makes absolutely no sense

[@Dextermoon1]

Rabbi, to think about the opposite also, I wonder how eternal bliss and olam haba mathematically adds up for a creature of a finite life span? Would love to hear your answer

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Addressed this in Part 2: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aWiUn319abODjZI

[@Dextermoon1]

@@EfraimPalvanovthank you

[@ChuckEpstein]

How does this apply to people who commit suicide or are cremated?

[@BenjaminVela-uf3eu]

Info please

[@NathanJudahJoy]

Brother do we have higher self?

[@primoshe2]

also the gemora about onkolos asking bilam haman and yashka what their seemingly eternal punishment is and their advice as to whether he should join the jewish people... that gemora seems to indicate that punishments go on for hundreds even thousands of years ad hayom hazeh...

[@sarahyael8121]

I like Your Schiurim very much. They are very inspiring and I learn a lot. You do a great Job by putting so many information together. By this Shiur You did missed one important Information with all though respect. There is a famous Gemarah talking about Rabbah bar bar Chanah finding Korach and his group in the desert tausend years! after beeing buried alive screaming from Gehinom: >>Mosheh veTorato Emet

[@coachavi]

Hi Rabbi, Studying Shaarei Gilgulim it talks about n'r'n and how without rectifying the nefesh, the ruah can't come down...My question is: Since Hashem is beyond the measure of time, and is was and will be all at once, can a reincarnation/gilgul go back in time or is it always forward in time? Ex: a person dying in 2024 can his nefesh(or whatever part needs rectification) can that part of the soul be reincarnated in someone/something in the year 1800 for example? Thank you again! Coach Avi from Montreal

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Shalom Avi, this question came up in part 3 of this series here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/hp7dp6B8j72spJo and we spoke about it more fully in the recent class on time here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/e2GZoGCmjJKBn7M In short, I believe it is possible although, to be more accurate, "time" as we know it doesn't really exist and past, present, and future are happening simultaneously!

[@coachavi]

@@EfraimPalvanov beautiful, will definitely listen to part 3. Thank you again. If ever you're in Montreal, I would with many more, gladly come to your shiurim

[@RepairtheBreach5812]

Sorry, Rabbi, a quick bar. What is meant by the last part of Isa 58:10, Your gloom will be like the noontime? I have an ideal on it though

[@EfraimPalvanov]

I believe the simple understanding is that a person will be so blessed by God that even their gloomiest days will be as bright as the noon. What do you think?

[@RepairtheBreach5812]

@@EfraimPalvanov I was thinking that noontime is short-term and therefore our gloomy days be as well. Yours sounds better though.

[@dawncolayco9340]

Did lots of study as a serious Christian but these teachings i just soak them up. The old testament torah even the other things ten euchre. It is wonderful to learn how society is functioning with God how it all has a goal with learning doing working relationships. I sure hope I am done down here. It is so hard. Hopefully the messiah mosiah is coming. Tired of all this worldly stress.

[@caliphari]

Guys, which other authentic Torah channels are there on KZbin?

[@dkbrain3434]

Ohr Sameach, Jewish Learning Institute, Manis Friedman

[@Josh-Leshem]

The soul’s sentence in Gehinnom is usually limited to a 12-month period of purgation before it takes its place in Olam Ha-Ba (see: Mishnah Eduyot 2:10 and Shabbat 33b). This 12-month limit is reflected in the yearlong mourning cycle and the recitation of the Kaddish (the memorial prayer for the dead). Only the utterly wicked do not ascend to the Garden of Eden at the end of this year. Sources differ on what happens to these souls at the end of their initial time of purgation. Some say that the wicked are utterly destroyed and cease to exist, while others believe in eternal damnation (Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Law of Repentance, 3:5-6).

[@haemeth42]

what about the karet Rabbi,

[@TheMalka770]

Blessed thank you.very well rounded .pshat Remmes. Drash Sod.🔯I learn from you!💗

[@Dextermoon1]

If the soul can’t suffer than what happens in Gehenom for up to 12 months according to Arizal- its known to be tremendous pain to be cleansed in this way . Is Arizal saying one is cleansed without suffering ? Doesn’t seem to make sense ?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

See Part 2: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aWiUn319abODjZI