Review: A comparison of lead holders

[@DeuceDangler]

I was gifted a Universe 98 - Italy along with a Staedtler 783 - Technico recently. Definitely greats addition to my sketch supplies.

[@b0xez189]

Thank you so much for this video , im completely new to this and this was the best video i found on the subject. You sir have earned my follow

[@laideae]

All the red lead holders and the yellow Adapto, were manufactured by Koh-I-Noor in Italy. If you disassemble them, you’ll find they all share the same mechanism. The yellow 5616 has the ability to take leads that go from 2 to 3.2 mm, hence the Adapto name. The red lead holder with the lead grade indicator might also be able to take different diameter leads.

[@ScottDSackett]

Thanks for the info, I didn’t know that.

[@d.st.michael4195]

Have any suggestions that won’t break the bank...PIGGY bank? Lol! Just curious if you have any thoughts

[@stephenmoore3035]

@@d.st.michael419514:01-14:50

[@Hfhskfbehjekslsmmndhhxhdhdjld]

I picked up a Vittorio Martini 1866 while in Italy about a week ago. It is lovely so far.

[@ScottDSackett]

Is it the Mat 4? it looks thick, but really classy.

[@TimKapow]

I own a Rotring 800 2mm, it is absolutely amazing. It has a click advance system like a regular mechanical pencil and not a clutch. I have had it for 10 years. It was discontinued a few years ago and has become even more rare than it was when I purchased it and even then it was sold in Japan for the Japanese market. Thank goodness for the internet!

[@ScottDSackett]

I have a rotring 800 .5 pencil that has been pretty temperamental.

[@Coco_NuT_Bruh_Z]

Holds up the second one completely broken…pauses in thought 3:45 “so eehhh I can’t recommend this.” Love it man ahaha. I too wouldn’t recommend a broken one either 🤣

[@themisterchristie]

The silver clicky Staedtler might be easily modified to operate like a normal clutch pencil. I have a cheap lead holder that is the clicky type and recently I took the tip off to look at it. When I put the tip back on it was suddenly operating like a normal clutch pencil. I looked down at the table where I had put the tip and there was a little rubber grommet sitting where the tip had been. It had fallen out of the tip. With the tip on I extended the lead, removed the tip, slipped the grommet over the lead and put the tip back on and the clicky operation returned.

[@ScottDSackett]

I’ll try that. Thanks!

[@cindydale2891]

Love the CaranD’Ache fixpencil 22. If you haven’t tried, it’s sweet!

[@TheDennyColt]

I like clips just because it tends to stop desk roll. Lost many a pencil to that.

[@ScottDSackett]

I have a metal lip on my drawing board that holds pencils. Since I keep my drawing desk at a pretty steep angle a clip doesn’t help. But pencils I keep in my backpack I like to have a clip on.

[@c0nstantin86]

$50 dollars is 100 more then on Alibaba for 5000 units P.s. you like "drop clutch" pencils over "incremental advance" pencils. Both are mechanical lead holder.

[@Ensign_Cthulhu]

7:18 Teledyne Post used to make slide rules (or rather, they contracted with Hemmi in Japan to make them and put the Post brand on them, but they are all clearly marked as Hemmi).

[@ThinkTankIllustration]

I started with a Berol 10 C 88, Love that thing!

[@ScottDSackett]

I'll have to look for it.

[@DreamQuillRose]

This was an excellent review for those of us completely new to clutch pencils/lead holders. I'm particularly interested in the lightweight Faber-Castell, because I have tendonitis, and quite small hands, so I think a lighter pencil would be more comfortable for me. I've read that it comes in 3.15mm, which interests me because I was wondering if a clutch pencil would work to hold the broken ends of expensive colored pencils, so I don't have to waste them. The leads range from 2.8mm to 4mm, with my 3.0mm (Prismacolor) and 3.3mm (Brutfuner) leads breaking rather frequently. Do you know if one of your lead holders could be used to hold waxy colored pencil leads? Have you ever tested the idea? I was thinking, if I leave a long piece of lead inside the pencil body, the colored pencil lead can't get pushed back inside while I'm coloring with it. What do you think?

[@ScottDSackett]

Thanks I’m glad you enjoyed it. Since recording this I’ve purchased several Faber-Castell leadholders to replace the one I misplaced. The lightweight makes it very comfortable to hold. It is a little small for my hands. You made me curious so I broke a few color pencil tips and tried it. It seemed to work pretty good. My main problem was getting the small bit in straight, but it worked. Also the lead is thicker and so it kinda stuck out. As someone pointed out, the Super Adapto is made to also hold thicker lead so you may look at those or the larger Faber Castell. Thanks for watching!

[@DreamQuillRose]

@@ScottDSackett Thank you so much! Which size did you try, the Faber-Castell 2mm or the 3.15mm? I'm having a hard time finding the 3.15mm in the U.S. Maybe I'll check out this Super Adapto :)

[@ScottDSackett]

Okay, I tested a few common leadholders. The Koh I Nor superadapto and the Technigraphic both work great. The Staedler Mars also works but not as well. The lead won’t allow the ‘teeth’ to retract. The smaller Faber Castell will NOT work. The teeth don’t open wide enough to grip the color pencils. I would suggest a Koh I Nor Technigraphic, it is a lighter weight than the Superadapto. Scott

[@DreamQuillRose]

@@ScottDSackett Thank you so much :)

[@AP7_TO.WANTED.]

What is the pacific arc one I cant find the colour and the style of it on anywhere you know any where

[@ScottDSackett]

I got it at Hobby Lobby a while back, I'm not sure if they still sell them.

[@greekveteran2715]

The sharpeners on lead holder's cups, doesn't have the super sharp razors that common sharpeners have. That's because one a razor doesn't fit in that tiny space, and two, because the less sharp edge will last longer because of the broader angle. That means, that if you sharpen the lead properly, you can still produce a fine sharp tip, like with any sharpener. It just takes longer and it is a different approach.

[@ScottDSackett]

The sharpener on the Steadler is best used in a pinch, but it is better than nothing. I typically keep a sharpener in my bag, but have been forced to use the one in the cap. I generally like drawing with a blunt pencil, but sometimes they get too blunt.

[@greekveteran2715]

@@ScottDSackett Yup, the cup sharpener is there to use it in a pinch when you're far from your main sharpener. It's more difficult to use, but with some experience, it can provide better/sharper tips. As for drawing I agree,however super sharp lead point,has it's place too, (for drawing fine details)!!

[@d.st.michael4195]

@@greekveteran2715 How far? Lol! Couple blocks. Mile or two, what? I’m just curious. Lol. I can’t be the only one, amirite? Maybe someone else wanna know too.

[@d.st.michael4195]

@@ScottDSackett Forced?! REALLY?! Under threat?! Who the hell needs a drawing THAT bad?! Where the hell do ya live?! Is art hard to come by where you live?! Jesus, I have so many questions! Insane! 🤣

[@ScottDSackett]

@@d.st.michael4195 The creative impulse forces someone to draw always.

[@LazyStory]

I just counted I have more than 100 Clutch pencils in 2.0 mm :D Lots you do not have: No Caren d'Ache (the first ever made), Rotring, BiC Criterium , Pyramid, Faber-Castell have made at least 5 diff. that I own. I prefer with out clip, so it does not annoy my hand.... and I also have a pencil case no need for clip, but also have room for eraser etc.

[@ScottDSackett]

Thanks for the heads up! I’m noting all these for future shopping.

[@adriantapia5407]

I have 2 steadtler mars techno bought in different places and the mechanism got squeaky in both of them is it normal?

[@ScottDSackett]

None of mine squeak.

[@d.st.michael4195]

Like, Brian Stelter of CNN fame, kind of squeaky orrrrr....?! You wanna talk about ‘not normal’ huh?! Lol! 🤣

[@ParallelUniversity]

I've had a couple dozen of the Turquoise 10 and 10C and the lead doesn't get stuck in any of them. I think yours is just defective

[@ScottDSackett]

Could be.

[@reginaldforthright805]

The knurl on the staedtler 780 is too short

[@greekveteran2715]

Cretacolor makes one,that looks exactly like the Red Kohinor 5611.They call it Tiotens.Does anybody know,if its all metal please or if its better than the Staedtler 780 (it costs more)

[@douglasbarbosa8450]

Hey! I'm between Staedtler mars and Pacific arc. Which one do u recommend?

[@kermitdoesminecraft7768]

I use the pacific arc and staedtler, the pacific arc kinda tires my hand out after a while so maybe get both because they’re both cheap

[@ScottDSackett]

I’ve never used a Pacific Arc, but Staedler Mars has made quality drafting tools forever. I have Staedler lead holders I’ve owned for 20+ years so that’s what I’d get.

[@douglasbarbosa8450]

@@ScottDSackett thx, I think I'll choose the staedtler one

[@FlyFoxPro]

Solid information thank you.

[@stephenmoore3035]

Nothing like watching an entire video that’s 85% out of focus. Enjoyed the info nonetheless.

[@ScottDSackett]

Sorry about that. Keeping the phone focused on something as thin as a pencil is challenging. I’ve added quite a few pencils to my collection, maybe it’s time for an update. If so, I’ll do some practice runs so the video is better. Thanks for watching and the feedback, I’m glad you liked it anyway.

[@MybeautifulandamazingPrincess]

Aren't Koh I Noor made in Czech republic?

[@ScottDSackett]

Yes, in fact they are some the same region my family is from.

[@d.st.michael4195]

@@ScottDSackett Do they know Koh, I or Noor?! Lol!

[@MybeautifulandamazingPrincess]

This pacific arc is a knock off of the Rotring

[@ScottDSackett]

That seems right.

[@d.st.michael4195]

YOU’RE a knock off! Lol

[@Lyttleton25]

It may seem like a knock off, but the one that you have, Scott, (the H-1309) is the best type they have; I got 4 of them (2 blacks, 2 silvers). I would not get the H-1305; the quality of that lead holder is a lot lower.