Reviewing & Ranking All the Miller Era Characters! (Thomas & Friends)

Todays Video I Gather EVERY Thomas Character that was introduced in the Miller Era and Rank Them from Best to Worst in my Opinion and I also review them. Let me know which character you like the Best and Worst.

[@PeePeeSam]

Well, I finally found Duncan... a lot less Scottish than I remember 🤔😂

[@cakehyrbid5315]

Oh hello Peter sam

[@PeePeeSam]

@@cakehyrbid5315 hi!

[@zmpjacksoncomics2077]

I thought the same

[@allisonkrueger8330]

Lol

[@kerryelliottdusablon4783]

@@PeePeeSam ❤❤❤❤ Peter Sam I’m running Peter Sam I’m running this

[@YouSoJames]

i thought this man was gonna say his fav miller era character was ol wheezy

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

I kinda expected Hiro to be the number one because he is a bit overrated.

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

But still cool

[@eduardoaguero1220]

@@DodotheWishFanboy Please elaborate.

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

Since Hiro is the most favorite Miller era character, who do you think is your most favorite Brenner era character (international or not) (What about Logan and Sam? They're both exclusive characters. Also, include Dustin, but he's only in the book.)(Exclue Big Mickey since he originally appered in Tugs and came to T&F faceless and suddenly gain a face.)? I "might" choose Ryan, Millie or Stephen as my most favorite Brenner era characters.

[@eduardoaguero1220]

@@CrystalClearWith8BE I say stephen and glynn were epic, and marion is comical.

[@amitysluzara2022]

Great ranking. Here's mine: 1) Paxton 2) Luke 3) Hiro 4) Victor 5) Sidney 6) Charlie 7) Dart 8) Bash and Dash 9) Den 10) Winston 11) Ferdinand 12) Stafford 13) Norman 14) Belle 15) Kevin 16) Flynn 17) Scruff 18) Merrick 19) Owen 20) Captain

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

Great!

[@thejohnsons2832]

Norman should get last

[@davinsmith7543]

The one thing I would change about Belle is make her a tender engine for fuel storage, but keep the side tanks for putting out fires. Also, it's kind of a stretch to call her an Arthur rip off, the BR 4MTs were based off of the Stannier 4P tanks, and Arthur is an Ivatt 2MT.

[@clown-cult96]

Honestly if someone didn’t like Hiro, that would be a red flag.

[@flickcentergaming680]

For real. Hiro is great.

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

Couldn’t agree more! 👍

[@jcjessica]

For me --- ⭐⭐⭐ : Luke🇮🇪🦌(he's such a sweetheart! And yes I also despise the scene where he runs away from Thomas. In fact I despise all of the narrow gauge engines in that single moment), Paxton☺️ & Sidney🥰(2 of my favourite diesel engines) 👍🏻👍🏻: Hiro🇯🇵🎑 & Victor🇨🇺🛠 💩💩💩 : Charlie, Bash, Dash & Ferdinand

[@steamzilla95]

Here’s how I portrayed Belle in my headcanon: 1. Instead of having water cannons on her tank, she carries a seperate water tanker which is longer the average tankers we have. 2. She has her bell with her because in case her whistle (which is more realistic)is broken and not working properly.

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

Interesting headcanon.

[@florjanbrudar692]

Wow I cannot believe someone hates a character purely because of the basis itself. Wow... You do realize that Belle and Arthur are clearly 2 different locos? Yes, they both have similar, but still different basis 25:52 Omg nobody working for the show came up with this at all, in real life the LBSCR D1s had water cannons to copy with bomb attacks during WW2 (according to Belle's article in the ttte wiki)

[@eateggs]

i do kinda like Den and Dart a bit more, its really cute that they have separation anxiety

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

What you mean is Den starts a speech and Dart tells him what he means.

[@eateggs]

@@CrystalClearWith8BE No no, in an episode from the Sharon Miller era, there was an episode about Thomas asking Den and Dart to fix Old Wheezy in The Misty Island. He takes them individually at first, they both said they'd feel better going together. So at the third time, Thomas takes them both.

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

Therefore, Den and Dart always help each other and they need each other to help Old Wheezy.

[@eateggs]

@@CrystalClearWith8BE Mhm.. I thought it meant they had separation anxiety.. Maybe if you watched the episode itself you'd understand.

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

Before I first replied your comment, I thought you're talking about Den and Dart's personalities and routines and especially their quotes.

[@nathancorcoran5347]

7:06 Technically he is not a brat honestly.

[@davidantoniocamposbarros7528]

I know this is a 2 month old vid,but idc. About the last character in this list: Belle isn't exactly a Arthur rip off,she's an modified BR standard class 4MT tank while Arthur is an LMS Ivatt 2MT class (although they have similar looks). Just wanted to clear that up

[@marybethricci9495]

I think the most positive side of Belle, is that if there is a railside fire, Belle can be there.

[@Mr_Gamer-Random]

Yes both of our favourite Miller characters are the same

[@SrMechaGojira93]

1. Luke 2. Victor 3. Paxton 4. Hiro 5. Den & Dart 6. Kevin (over-hated) 7. Sidney 8. Stafford 9. Scruff 10. Winston 11. Merrick and Owen 12. Bash, Dash and Ferdinand 13. Charlie 14. Belle and Flynn 15. Captain (he has *NO* backstory!) 16. Norman (he *never* got a starring role!)

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

Cool

[@Joey15811]

Captain really is why we needed Bulstrode to return. Gives him a character to bounce off and allow both characters to develop. And probably add a tug boat into the mix as well

[@rhyermine1004]

hiro sometimes sounds like he has broken english sometimes since he's originally japanese

[@RWSfan2024]

I agree with you on the characters, you also gave me an idea for a potential misty island rescue rewrite

[@dangerouslybean]

1: Hiro 🇯🇵 I love how kind he gentle he is, despite being a very big and strong engine. He always seems like he’d never even hurt a fly. 2: Luke 🇮🇪 Luke is just fricking adorable dude. And the fact that he became friends with a deer just makes it even better. 3: Victor 🇨🇺 I don’t know why, but when i was little i thought Victor was mean to Thomas kind of like Cranky, but now that i rewatch CGI episodes, he’s actually very nice. And the way he’s sometimes serious and sometimes nice is what makes him great.

[@wil4540]

My favorite ones are Victor and Hero. Also Ryan and James are also my favorites.

[@florjanbrudar692]

Hiro?

[@wil4540]

@@florjanbrudar692 yes my english is just kinda bad

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

Speaking of Norman, he's a brother of Dennis. In reality, there was only one diesel with the same basis as Dennis and Norman. Built in 1949 and sadly, caught to scrap in 1959. It lived for 10 years and I love the exterior design and even those wheels, side rods and counter weights. If you don't know what counter weights are, basically, they're behind the rear wheels and are connected to 4 connector side rods.

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

Interesting.

[@carolmckenna5567]

I learned that from the Thomas wiki

[@eljugasodemanzana8390]

2:45 Considering the fact that the ralways series, the model seasons, and the cgi seasons are different universes we could say that in the cgi series Hiro was actually the first engine on sodor

[@catinamavodones5620]

Bash Dash and Ferdinand are Laughing like Crazy

[@user-ur5lv9el4s]

If Nitrogen wanted to make Belle a fire fighting engine, why couldn't they just give her the same design as Asher from "Chuggington"?

[@Michipicoten]

OMG I WAS WANTING YOU TO HAVE LUKE AS 4TH BUT YOU ACTUALLY DID YEEEEEEE

[@charlesschofield4018]

The best characters of the Sharon Miller era in my opinion are Molly, Mighty-Mac, Jeremy, Freddie, Rocky, Madge, Stanley, Hiro, Victor, Kevin, Captain, Paxton, Den & Dart, Luke, Winston, Owen and Merrick. Because some of them were in Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure, King of the Railway and The Great Discovery which along with The Adventure Begins are the best Thomas and Friends movies whether they speak or not. Although Den & Dart were in the episode Away From the Sea which introduced Porter.

[@sdmedia1323]

Replace Belle with Mickey the Furness K2? “Really? I thought steam engines filled up with steam.” - Paxton

[@Mr_Gamer-Random]

That was legit the best line out of the entirety of BWBA

[@guilhermerossi807]

Great video! Keep up the good work. I Always wanted someone to review the miller era characters 🚂 I also lLove Stafford, he is one of my favorite Miller era along with Winston

[@emmawayland1]

My list 21: Flynn 20: Charlie 19: merick 18: Owen 17: den 16: dart 15: Norman 14: belle 13: Sidney 12: captain 11: Kevin 10: Stafford 9: scruff 8: dash 7: Luke 6: bash 5: winston 4: victor 3: hero 2: Ferdinand 1: Paxton

[@aessseomi]

My Ranking: Victor Hiro Sidney Luke Paxton Owen Merrick Winston Den and Dart Kevin Belle Norman Stafford Scruff Charlie Captain Bash and Dash Ferdinand Flynn

[@MariSuzuki19]

9:19 my ass could never remember anything 💀

[@nolancarey4500]

But Dennis manipulated Thomas into doing work for him on his day off, that's why I prefer Norman over Dennis.

[@PNate_KTrainVer.]

Ngl all these engines had potential except the logging locos

[@flickcentergaming680]

Totally agree with Hiro and Victor. I liked Victor as soon as I saw him.

[@marybethricci9495]

Everyone always says that Sidney is the most dumbest character because everytime someone tells him something, he always forgets it in like, 2 seconds!!!

[@asafjuarez1]

If Sidney’s a miller character then how tf did he survive the fire at the burning Dieselworks in Day of the Diesels, right when Diesel 10 was the one who started the fire and it was because of his claw pinchy

[@kadenrobinson7067]

I like fernanand if that's even how you say his name And I know I'm gonna get shot for this So let me explain the reason why I like him is because his basist it's literally a geared steam locomotive the climax But I do think he still had potential If only we changed his personality and his limits of speaking instead of saying that's right like I could just imagine him being a wise character like what duncan said

[@jamesthebluecat1263]

Don’t forget that smudger was also a meme.

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

Cool!

[@jamesthebluecat1263]

Imagine if after belle puts out a fire and when she tries to leave she doesn’t have enough water to cool her boiler down and she dies from a boiler explosion.

[@zoedaly214]

i like Charlie he is funny

[@MrTrackmaster]

Your voice is so deep

[@sophiebyers5496]

It is just or Kevin looks like SpongeBob?

[@Zombiehunter2_0]

1:04 wow, that's surprising. I mean he's the only good miller era character besides Paxton!

[@wenshulee]

Luke?

[@rokamayono2312]

@@wenshulee and victor

[@derekbackofen6]

My favorite is Luke absolutely love him

[@gabriellitewski7988]

But not in the cashcow franchise

[@Joey15811]

We really needed some more boat Characters and Bulstrode restorated for captain to actually develop more.not alot he can do otherwise.

[@IndominusRex315]

If you pause at the right time 23:26 Bash or Dash look weird

[@jimdunn8132]

For day of the diesels they should have just brought back the fire engines from season 5 I wonder what happened to them

[@laserene9012]

NEVER GONNA GIVE YOU UP

[@zoedaly214]

i like Bash and Dash they are like me

[@Bepe223]

Luke Victor & Hiro are definitely on my top 5

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

If you think of Hiro of having similarities to Murdoch, he have smoke deflectors like Murdoch, he have a wise personality but as for Murdoch, he likes peace and quiet the most. Hiro is also a strong engine like Murdoch.

[@huntersvideos905]

So Hiro is basically Black Murdoch... or if you will, Nurdoch, or Migga

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

No. Hiro is a JNR Class D51 and Murdoch is a BR Class 9F.

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

Since Murdoch is designed for freight, is Hiro mixed traffic or freight? He also kinda looks like a freight engine to me.

[@TomSonsTV]

nice list

[@westinbridges7321]

All opinions are respected

[@lightbendstudios832]

1:58 Hiro = fandom

[@lucasgabrielaraujoaraujo8943]

If there was some tingimento that Miller era was good! Was to create international caracters!

[@emmawayland1]

I love the logging locos they make me laugh especially Ferdinand that’s right it’s true bash and dash are still funny I even loved misty island rescue I think misty island rescue was 9/10 trust me

[@Mr_Gamer-Random]

"I'm bAsH." I'm DaSh." "That's right."

[@khorcalson6656]

I love Misty Island Rescue too. But I don’t like the overused rhyming dialogue.

[@emmawayland1]

Great I don’t mind the rhyming though

[@NitroIndigo]

Did you mean to give this a 4:3 aspect ratio?

[@savagegardenfan9680]

I would have Captain as my least favourite Nitrogen era Character simply because they didn't introduced him properly. and even though I dislike the Loggging Locos I kinda like their designs.

[@allisonkrueger8330]

17:04 hello fellow Minnesotan, also 22:09 it’s sounds like he says hairo not hero lol

[@henrythegreenengine195]

Nice video youngster

[@inoutdoor4211]

You missed Hank and Flora, both created and written by her, during her first head writer series (12). And for the record, Belle replaced Arthur surely for feminism, female character replaces a male character, it’s bullshit.

[@MSSCtheGoat]

He meant the seasons from 2009-2013

[@loresoong6626]

Freddie replaced Ivo Hugh for all of ~3 episodes and I don't see anyone complaining...

[@crazymarioshow5561]

Bash and dash are my favorite character don't ask why

[@florjanbrudar692]

Why are they?

[@crazymarioshow5561]

@@florjanbrudar692 they look awesome there designs are cool. Bash and dash personalities I like because they was in Island for 5 or 10 year forgot.

[@yrinnarhaizaribeirosantos6755]

I Like Luke Vctor Belle Flynn Hiro Paxton Bash Dash Ferdinand Captain Merrick owen Den and Dart i no like much Charlie

[@catinamavodones5620]

Gasp The Logging Locos

[@gabriellitewski7988]

I thought the animated series would be interesting but I was wrong

[@catinamavodones5620]

Did I Do anything wrong

[@asafjuarez1]

15:18

[@carolmckenna5567]

Hiro Victor Kevin Charlie Bash many youtube channels hated character Dash many youtube channels hated character Ferdinand many youtube channels hated character Captain arrived to sodor off screen Scuff Paxton Sidney Belle Dart Flynn Norman Den Stafford Winston Owen Merrick Luke

[@catinamavodones5620]

Oh you two

[@Gordonjamesheneryproductions]

Don't you dare mention forever and forget you ever

[@catinamavodones5620]

You are My Favorite engine Friends

[@bfine2832]

you forgot about porter

[@oldmemememe]

porter was introduced in season 17, nitrogen era was season 13-16

[@catinamavodones5620]

Gasp ahhhhhh

[@catinamavodones5620]

Oh Paxton you are kind engine and I am kind too

[@catinamavodones5620]

What?

[@catinamavodones5620]

Oh Hello Luke

[@mary.of.mares.1470]

And Sidney waz main character in sesaon 22 and that waz holarius

[@gabriellitewski7988]

I didn't know the CGI series was gonna be bad without proof!!!!!!

[@gabrielm1420]

I think Victor should have stayed yellow and Kevin be red

[@mary.of.mares.1470]

Don't you start 😡

[@DonaldoftheNWR]

?

[@ashleyjiscool]

Uncool