Reviewing the YORKSHIRE PUDDING MEAL in YORK. My LOWEST SCORE so far!

[@Myteaplease]

We where going in there , when a woman said "do'nt go in there ,follow me " I do not know where she took us but the food was top 10/10 no stupid plastic or wooden tools , I'm just glad you went in and showed us what we missed . Thank you Arthur

[@GaryEats]

No problem Arthur you dogged a bullet there 👌

[@thekitowl]

What a great story.

[@shaniapearcey]

Good story bro

[@michaelmooney6671]

This is the type of story I like,honest and rewarding. Many thanks. They probably tell customers to take the used box etc. home with them too.

[@hannible1002]

I thought his name is Garry?

[@Oscarspaw1971]

Firstly using such poor cutlery such a let down,eating out a box in a restaurant is a non go. Basically looks like a microwave roast dinner. Does not look like you had a good experience Gary but at even £10-50 you can still get a decent carvery dinner anywhere in Britain. This is not one of them. Great review Gary👍

[@GaryEats]

Really kind of you to say. The cutlery was the worst part of it all!

[@Curryking32000]

Totally correct and my words exactly. No washing up for them, all ends up in landfill while at the same time maximising their profit margins. Cross between a macdonalds and a carvery except worse quality and quantity.

[@ChrisPatrick-q6k]

​@@Curryking32000It's disgusting really. 4/10 seems generous

[@kenirving5240]

Sadly, this is exactly the sort of place tourists would flock to so it’s no surprise the UK gets such a bad name for its food if this is what they get served up.

[@craigwignall8450]

Yes i agree 👍

[@paul_raftery]

Looked ok to me. I didn’t taste it obviously. Chester is the same for tourist places.

[@kenirving5240]

@@paul_raftery Yes, looked very nice but in a cardboard box with a wooden fork and plastic spoon? The spuds were inedible apparently and the beef was tough as old boots.

[@lukedrive2869]

I’ve seen this place on different programmes and always wanted to go there. But listening to Gary I don’t think I’d bother. Tourists must be very disappointed if they waste their money going there.

[@scotty6346]

If tourist's enjoy it then who can blame them? The hospitality sector in the UK is so hard hit ATM so it's no surprise to me that corners/Quality are cut to get a bit of profit!

[@VanDeVenDerVaart]

1980s school dinner in a box by the look of it! Another great honest review Gary. 👍 This has rapidly become my favourite channel.

[@GaryEats]

Really appreciate that, thank you!

[@pippin1ful]

A cardboard box that doesn't leak is a boon!

[@waynenunn8071]

Found your channel yesterday here in Australia …I’m going through each episode slowly so as not to run out as I’m thoroughly enjoying your presentation of each episode…I like how you try to find the good in the bad ,the glass is half full approach…friendly chap indeed…thanks for your videos

[@GaryEats]

That’s very kind and appreciated Wayne thank you for supporting the channel 🇦🇺🇦🇺

[@robertmclean5356]

Smart man! I binged them all in a day and am now kept hanging for new reviews. Hope Gary comes over to Australia one day.

[@aussiemouth747]

Lots of us Aussies watching and enjoying Gary's reviews!🦘

[@error_404-x6y]

Watch it with an empty stomach!!

[@johnmccormack4498]

Wow eating out of a box and using plastic utensils, even if it was the best roast dinner ever I wouldn't return....that's just cost cutting at the expense of the dining experience. You were generous Gary.

[@GaryEats]

The cutlery was a nightmare. Thanks for watching!

[@davidsworld5837]

if you are sitting in then you should have it on a plate with real knife and fork, even a place that looks like a dump give you this. bet it does not cost them more than £1.50 for what's in the box. its not worth even if it tasted right more than £6 tops

[@kevincox5232]

It looked like the meats in the window where to tempt you in and the meats dished up were from frozen catering trays

[@clives344]

I agree i would be unhappy eating out of a box. As for plastic knives and forks i am anti plastic.

[@viviennepastor3188]

Yuck.

[@kevwalton272]

frozen roasties, frozen stuffing, frozen yorkshire, gravy who knows? you were extremely kind.

[@GaryEats]

Not good Kev. The cutlery was a nightmare as well. Thanks for watching!

[@davidsworld5837]

i much bet its the large 50p YP from the shop it did not look home made. you could make a better dinner for 4 at home for under £10.

[@paul_raftery]

@@davidsworld5837roast beef dinner for 4 for under £10? Nonsense

[@davidsworld5837]

really you do not think at home you could make that dinner. well I can even if you can not

[@reevs2153]

​@paul_raftery 500g of beef sainsburies (6 quid), bag of potatoes can get for 1.25, 4 eggs for a massive yorky or a few smaller ones (say 1.25). 1.50 left for a couple carrots/veg of choice, use the juice from the beef to make a gravy and your sorted. Use a bit of flour and milk from pantry or add another 50p for that expense a guess

[@TheOriginalMegaKing]

Great video Gary I’m from Yorkshire and tried this place after seeing another KZbinr that went and gave it it a very very high score. I wasn’t impressed just like you. So credit for this realistic review sir.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you. Appreciate that, please let me know if you have any recommendations from Yorkshire!

[@TheOriginalMegaKing]

@@GaryEats if you’re near wakey get to the kingfisher for fish and chips, the red kite pub around the corner also do a great Sunday lunch both next to the motorway for a flying visit .

[@jacquelinebutters1201]

Could not use cutlery and that box yuk

[@mandymoo7406]

​@@TheOriginalMegaKingyes the king fisher at wakefield or the fishole in wetwang are both superb

[@deadzio]

Let me guess. Danny from RMT ??

[@awinbisa]

To be honest I think it’s rarely worth ordering a roast dinner in a restaurant. It’s such an easy meal to make at home , and you can get everything just as you want. It’s hard to mass cook roasts to a decent standard in a restaurant.

[@GaryEats]

Fair enough! Thanks for watching 😊

[@PaulHipToBeSquareAllen]

Easy yes, time consuming, Big Yes.

[@debeeriz]

l stayed at a motel in napier nz that had a small restaurant, run by the owners, an elderly couple, you had hardly any choices, i ordered the roast lamb and my wife ordered fish and chips. my mum cooked the best roast lamb ever until l ate here and even my wife said it was the best fish and chip meal she had ever had. l judge an eating place on how good they cook a roast, or a steak dianne, my 2 favourite meals. l am not into seafood and no one beats kfc for chicken if you get it freshly cooked

[@mypointofview1111]

I would agree with that statement. Home made roast dinners are unbeatable

[@chrislarge8704]

It is an easy meal to make at home, but it's time consuming - especially if you're single or just a couple. I have to disagree with you about mass cooking to a decent standard. It really isn't THAT hard, even for a moderately skilled chef. Look at Gary's review of Toby Carvery as an example.

[@David-Angela]

Hi Gary, My wife and I went to the same place 3 years ago, and sat where you were, and at the time it was very busy and we had a delicious pork and crackling and gravy sandwich, and Yes it was lovely! But I have to say watching you last night, we both said that the food did not look that great to start with , and the knife and fork, 'what the heck' ..how can they give you those plastic/wooden cutlery anyway trying to cut the meat..and also in a cardboard box! I actually said this is going to be a 4 or 4and a half, and to be fair, we both agreed with you. Its a shame, as its such a fantastic place in York, and where you ate probably had great reviews, so , it was really disappointing for you. You were really fair and honest Gary, and that's why you are receiving so many viewers now. Can't wait for your next review., and you saying 'As usual, lets give it a go'... Until next time... Thanks again for a great review. All the best David !!

[@GaryEats]

Hi David. I'm glad that you and your wife had an enjoyable experience, that's what matters. Glad you agreed with my score as well (the cutlery was an absolute nightmare) and I really appreciate your kind words. Have a smashing rest of your weekend.

[@MyMakingWavesProject]

I’ve had a few wraps there in the past few years and enjoyed those. First time I was out drinking while in York staying for a few days at an army base and remember going back in 10 mins after I demolished the first one to get a second. That was probably the drink enhancing the vibe 😂. The box thing does look a bit crap though.

[@BobDibb]

Who was bloke in background with giant plate

[@stephaniewhite9526]

This review Gary shows why you are going to become the biggest & best food reviewer on You Tube. You have been completely honest and correctly downgraded this pub, which quite frankly the plastic knives and forks, cardboard box and poor service before the taste test even began were ominous. So glad you will be showing poor reviews too as this honesty really helps the community when looking where to eat. I loved this review and whilst the food only got a 4.5, the review scored a solid 10 ! And congratulations on 5k subs. I will be congratulating you next on 10k subs so quickly. Thank you for this great channel.

[@GaryEats]

Wow Stephanie, that is very kind of you and I really appreciate that. I do think it's very important to be honest and I wouldn't recommend anywhere that I feel will not either give VFM or good food, this happens to be both. Have a wonderful weekend :)

[@anneperry9014]

I'm sorry but you can't tell the truth. Its apparently against the law now, although it's a deadly sin to lie. Anyway, great vid. Hope you find better food, which I'm sure you will!😊

[@Patricia-rc5gn]

Thank goodness the Yorkshire pudding came up tops! The cutlery would be a no no for me.Thanks for a great review Gary,

[@GaryEats]

Thank you!

[@DovidM]

They must do the paper box and plastic cutlery to save on labor.

[@ItzDylanM]

That Yorkshire is definitely a frozen one. Looks identical to them (alarming if that was one of the best parts) Great review Gary

[@GaryEats]

That was unfortunately the best part. The rest was sub-par!

[@nickycotton6137]

The potatoes even looked frozen!

[@johnoconnor7536]

5K Subscribers in 2 months. Great start. With the format and the length of the reviews the way they are I think you've got a bright future on KZbin.

[@GaryEats]

Thanks John. Means a lot - have a good weekend!

[@DavidMaud-j4u]

​@@GaryEatsbit late to this video but if it helps it was no surprise the beef was tough and bland because it wasn't topside or silverside the two traditional hind quarter premium roasting cuts...it was what we in the trade refer to by various names...pallis rib sometimes but is actually thick rib above the shoulder off the fore quarter...an extremely hard working muscle which is best pot roasted. The plate of gristle running right through it immediately gives the game away. It's been used as a cost cutter. And it's been sliced incorrectly adding to the toughness. Brilliant channel by the way.

[@Lloyd1885]

Those spuds didnt look remotely roasted, and the beef, it looked like the cow was suffering with anemia. All served up in a box with plastic cutlery, like something you'd get at a soup kitchen. You certainly took one for the team there Gary 👍🏼

[@GaryEats]

Thanks mate. Wasn't great at all!

[@chipnroll]

beef looked like it had been boiled.....

[@ikiddyounot]

Your forthright manner is so refreshing and the honest reviews are very much appreciated! Thank you for saving us viewers from lacklustre places such as this. Also, love how your viewership jumped tenfold in three months (proud to be part of it 😂) - it’s testament to how delightful you, your channel, and your cameraman 😆 are! Congrats, Gary!

[@GaryEats]

You are so welcome! That’s an extremely kind thing to say - thank you!

[@Bose_1010]

Food did look sub-par. "Everyday I’m Eating" also tested this place out recently and gave it a decent review but it was against a microwave roast from Morrison's 😂 Keep up the great work Gary & crew. 5K subs this weekend 🥳

[@GaryEats]

Rally appreciate that thank you. Food was very sub-par. I've just reached it, overjoyed!

[@phillipbrown2318]

​@GaryEats That food didn't look impressive at all they should had given real silverware not plastic forks or spoon.

[@Suve35967]

Yes I watched that. Same place, same meal. He was pitting it against Morrisons so I understand how he said it was good. Beef looked tough, roast potatoes were unedible..

[@billybatts294]

Gary you are as honest as they come dont be like other food reviewers tell it how it is and at least you look at youre comments not like some others who have a massive follwing and cant be arsed youre channel will get big good luck and keep the videos coming

[@GaryEats]

Hi Billy. That's very kind of you mate. Can only be honest as it's not really a food review if I'm not telling you all the truth. I will always do my best to reply to all of my comments as you've taken the time of your day to watch my videos and comment yourselves so I appreciate it. Have a good weekend mate.

[@Eric-the-Bold]

We were up in York in July, looking in the window. An old boy came up to us and identifed himeself as local, when he realised that we were English, he said dont bother, its for the Tourist. We took his advice. Bish bash bosh, stack em high etc. The pots were not roasted , boiled , then cold, then into a deep pan fryer, just saying. 4.5 . The wooded tools reflect the taste of the meal me thinks.

[@GaryEats]

Wish I'd have bumped into him as well. Agreed!

[@hacendado3840]

We've been really enjoying your reviews. We don't get to London much so good to see you getting out and about. I didn't think that meal looked very good and thought when I saw it that the beef was going to be chewy. Why? It was silverside, which has that signature seam of connective tissue through it, shown up perfectly by the camera. That cut is always tough, it's not a roasting cut. Keep up the good work, we love how you tell it like it is without any clickbait nonsense.

[@GaryEats]

Great to hear! I like doing plenty of places around the UK so that will be a common occurrence. The vein in the beef was extremely off-putting - really poor. Thank you - try to be as honest as possible!

[@fpwrankin]

Another good review - well filmed and good commentary. Beef should be served on a big hot plate and eaten with good cutlery. You asked for suggestions for when you go to Leeds and district. How about Afternoon Tea in the famous Bettys Tearooms in nearby Harrogate? You should enjoy that washed down with Yorkshire Gold Tea! Keep up the good work, Philip!

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Philip. There's a Betty's Tea Room in London so I might visit that one instead and go to some real local places in Leeds. Thanks!

[@fpwrankin]

It all started for Bettys in Harrogate over 100 years ago by a Swiss - there is a good history on their website. When I lived in Harrogate years ago people loved their teas in Bettys. I didn't know they had a place in London! I knew they were in York and Northallerton. All the best Philip.@@GaryEats

[@DrFrankLondon]

Been there, and we left extremely disappointed. It was absolutely not up to snuff. The Yorkshire pudding wasn't too bad, but had much better in Leeds. Another great and honest review, Gary.. When you took a bite of the roast potatoes, I knew it would be a disappointment. It's a tourist trap and not worth the money or your time! Great review as usual, mate! You're a crack and keep up the fabulous work! 😊😊😊😊😊

[@GaryEats]

You know it's bad when we both say it's not good. Thanks mate, have a wonderful weekend and I appreciate your kind words. Thanks for watching!

[@thecoldend_official]

Great video again Gary. You and other great you tubers out there are really keeping me entertained whilst I am laid up at home after an accident and knee surgery. Thankyou! Food wise this didn't look all that so definitely a fair review.

[@GaryEats]

Oh no. I'm really sorry to hear that, I hope you can recover fast mate - that sounds awful. My pleasure, please look after yourself.

[@stuartjomes7289]

Great stuff Gary ....How refreshing to hear a honest and personal review.🎉

[@GaryEats]

Thanks 👍

[@jamesking1952]

Well done Gary. A honest review. Clearly a tourist trap per se! Keep the reviews coming. Cheers!

[@GaryEats]

Thanks, will do James. Appreciate it mate!

[@barrierowlands3884]

Not a takeaway,plates are de rigeur & as for cutlery 🫣.Gary,you're the man‼️ Honest & Straight.Keep it up No 1.

[@GaryEats]

Thanks for that Barrie. I really appreciate it!

[@SimonStamenkovic]

I always appreciate a good honest review and after sitting here watching that i couldnt agree more with you. They seem to entice you in with a great looking building and display in the frontage. then churn out below average food. Maybe just an off day? who knows. Would be interesting to see if you ever returned in the future. Thanks again the the review.

[@GaryEats]

Definitely won't be returning, Simon. Always try to be honest, thank you very much.

[@ThecovertCustomer]

Definitely not an off day. I live in York and have taken visiting family there - nope. We residents wouldn’t go. It looks tasty in the window and it’s not. Tables have always felt slightly sticky. For that price I want it on a plate. I’d sooner get a delicious pasty from Thomas the Bakers.

[@Metallex]

As a 20 year resident of York, the locals stay away from the York Roast Co. We know it's a tourist trap and the food is crap. If you go a minute further down that street, Goodramgate, you find so many unique and delicious places to eat.

[@GaryEats]

I wish I knew that! I'll be back though.

[@grahamd3712]

It looks appealing from the outside, but when Gary was inside at the table, it looked like he was in a fast-food eatery. And the plastic and wooden cutlery - why??? One to avoid!!!

[@pippin1ful]

I once had a delicious roast mallard dinner in that district. I used to stay with my boys regularly in York. That meal you received I cannot comment on. KZbin bots will descend upon me.

[@HorseRacingLegends]

Cheap Crap.

[@HorseRacingLegends]

Should have demanded a proper knife and fork.

[@DannielleDelight]

Those " Giant Yorkshire puddings" are currently 2 for 80p in Heron foods. The roast potatoes are a common humble vegetable available for "ten a penny." The other accompaniments aren't worth mentioning. The roast beef was the most expensive element of the whole meal, and the portion you were given would not equate to even close to £2 in money. I'm sorry to break it to you, my friend, but you have been royally shafted, without the common courtesy of vaseline. I appreciate your reviews. You're good at what you do. Thank you for the upload 😀

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much. You win some, you lose some. That's part of the review!

[@aussiemouth747]

Thank you for your review of the review. 😂

[@johnboucher8226]

It’s good to watch these early videos again Greeno!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much, Fred

[@petemountford6931]

Very interesting. I first tried this place about 25 years ago. It was amazing. But, back then, all that was on offer were basically, hot carved meat rolls with sauces etc. We used to love it on our yearly trip to York. People used to queue down the road for it. But, as the years have gone by, the company has expanded, the range on offer has expanded, but the quality has gone way down as the prices have gone way up. Really sad in the last couple of years when we reached the conclusion it just wasn't worth bothering. The classic phrase of being a victim of their own early success is never more true than here. Glad you tried it Gary, as always, loving the reviews.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Pete.

[@bartonseagrave9605]

You should always check their star rating to see if it is correct. I have checked all the pizza shops in my local area, all 12 of them, they all claim 5 stars yet not one of them are registered proving they lie and the local council doesn't check.

[@GaryEats]

Indeed.

[@annecunnings7886]

Potatoes looked nasty,beef looked tough, dreadful cutlery and a cardboard box to eat from!! Unbelievable! You were generous with your score. Best wishes from Tasmania. And congratulations on 5k subscribers.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Anne. It really means a lot!

[@brickie59]

Excellent fair appraisal of what was a below average meal that showed you cannot present and serve this meal in a box with inadequate cutlery. I believe that a Roast meal should be served on a plate and not in a box.

[@uglenddalejones2]

Visually,it ticked the boxes And it just wasn’t what it said it was. Tough meat,dry potatoes and stuffing- that’s the essence. I would be very disappointed by this- after all they obviously spent good money on the outside to draw the customer in. Short staff ok- but it should not affect quality- The takeaway box and cutlery- no need inside sitting down.not in a place like this. I’ve a feeling the owner either doesn’t know or doesn’t care about all this *Thank you always for your astute review 🙌☺️👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻*

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much. Sorry for the late reply!

[@uglenddalejones2]

@@GaryEats not at all Gary ,it’s fine x

[@mattmorris6740]

FINALLY!! I see a lot of reviews of this place & you're the first to have my experience - crap & bland, I actually had the wrap version of this at the other shop down the road. What I will say, you did actually miss their one good item, you can have a tub of their crackling, which was basically warm pork scratchings on salty steroids. Keep up the great work Gary, you've become one of my favourites on KZbin!

[@GaryEats]

Wow Matt. First of all, I'm sorry that you also had a poor experience. I didn't actually see it on the menu otherwise I would have ordered it - sounds like I missed the only good thing. Secondly, thank you very much. That's very kind of you.

[@SassyCindy]

So sad. Just eating out of a box and using plastic utensils was a cruel start. Looks can be deceiving as from my end, it looked great. Inedible potatoes, who does that?? I’m glad the Yorkshire pudding was good. That’s why everyone needs you Gary, your taste test and honest review mean so much. Thank you!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you and it wasn't good this

[@Nevakonaza.]

Love the honest review, It didn't look great soon as i seen the potatoes i knew those would be one of the reasons for a low score, I do feel for the staff though they've probably been under staffed for a while and their employer wont recruit.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you. Try to always be as honest as I can!

[@richardd1329]

We were there just a few weeks back, over visiting from Canada. My son wanted to try the Yorkshire pudding wrap with roast pork. He asked if he could have some pork crackling with it and was told no. Asked why the guy serving him said he was instructed by management not to sell any. We protested that being lured into the shop with the display of pork c/w crackling and not being able to buy any didn't make any sense. Anyway they were firm so my son had his wrap without crackling. He said it tasted ok though.

[@GaryEats]

Sorry to hear you and your son has a poor experience there. I think they need to improve their standards across the board!

[@ekspatriat]

I wonder if it's pre-cooked elsewhere and just packaged. Then they would not have had crackling to give you. Either way is a rip-off.

[@awinbisa]

@@ekspatriat I suspect that’s exactly the story. Perhaps the ones in the window are plastic !?

[@jerfacekilla]

@@ekspatriat I would also bet my life that those 'roasts' on display at the front window weren't what they appear to be (i.e. FAKE)

[@johnmurphy1466]

I felt you were going to break the cutlery in half cutting into the meat there Gary! 😁 Yes I agree with the score, a shame really as the shop window display makes it look so inviting.

[@GaryEats]

Not good John. I'd say the cutlery was the worst part!

[@trevortreverson3049]

Love your reviews, you take your time and definitely know what you are talking about.

[@GaryEats]

That’s very much appreciated, Trevor

[@JanJury]

During my last visit to "Gods Own" staying in York I was craving a good Yorkshire Pud on a Sunday. After not getting into a couple of pubs, and finding the Hole in The Wall had sold out we wandered past this place....luckily they were shutting so I was saved this disappointment. As someone else said, it's a tourist trap which does nothing to enhance the world view of English food> Another great and honest review Gary...and another from Yorkshire ...we'll make you an honorary Tyke at this rate.

[@GaryEats]

Unfortunately, it’s a great concept, but it is badly executed and thank you very much

[@howlieMCFC]

Them roasters looked liked boiled spuds disaster class there Gary

[@GaryEats]

Massive disaster. Cheers Howlie.

[@lloydmorganmoore7810]

Great video, this popped up in my recommendations and it's good to see someone giving places an honest review on KZbin! I ordered the same thing as you when I went in the summer and it was mostly dry and tasteless. It tasted like it was cooked from frozen and left under heat lamps for a few hours. The place was swarming with flies too, and the service was all over the place. Definitely a tourist trap.

[@GaryEats]

Glad it was helpful to you, much appreciated for the kind words.

[@Buddybrindle]

That was like a McDonald’s for Sunday roast dinners! Eating out of a box with throw away cutlery! And those roast spuds - had they ever seen the inside of an oven? When I first saw them sitting in the gravy I thought they were dumplings like my mum put in stew 60 years ago!

[@GaryEats]

Didn’t taste good either.

[@clives344]

Even though it did not taste good i would prefer this than mcdonalds.

[@waynefoulkes2017]

i love youre videos gary so laid back allways make me hungry. i love york. i grew up in scarborough on the coast just down the road allways used too go there as a kid at weekends. i just gotta say one more thing you dont half look like jim dale out the carry ons hope you dont mind me saying lol keep up the good work youre videos are awesome.

[@GaryEats]

I'm sorry if today's video didn't make you hungry, hopefully the next one will! Haha no problem, I can see the resemblance kind of. Very kind of you Wayne, have a good weekend mate.

[@waynefoulkes2017]

@@GaryEats youre videos allways make me hungry my friend since my divorce 5 years ago i aint hardly eaten lol youre videos giving me the will too go get pub or cafe food. my confidence gone lol

[@craigwignall8450]

Hi Gary i passed this place last time I was in York and considered eating there but now i don't need to.great honest review again cheers Gary

[@GaryEats]

Hope I've saved you the trouble Craig. Thanks mate.

[@TheTreherne]

I’ve never seen a Sunday roast served in a card board takeaway box with plastic cutlery. I hope the owners of this establishment take on board your fair criticisms, Gary!. Keep up the good work! I look forward to your reviews👍

[@GaryEats]

Really appreciate that my friend. Thank you!

[@pippin1ful]

Effing insulting in my opinion.

[@davidcoleman5246]

Hi Gary, Take-away i can understand, but to sit-in and eat out of a cardboard box, very strange. What's with the knife and fork? Not good at all, the only good thing was that you only wasted a tenner. Look forward to the next, and hopefully much better quality.

[@GaryEats]

The cutlery was a nightmare. Thanks for watching!

[@66oggy]

We went there a number of years ago, and from the outside it looks fine. Alarm bells started ringing when our meals turned up in boxes. The meal was far from what I was expecting, and I would never go again. The worst was the actual Yorkie Puds. Ours were soggy and just tasted of eggs.... I love eggs, but if I want the taste of eggs I will eat an omelette, or for that matter, eggs. Like other tourists, we were conned.

[@GaryEats]

Indeed.

[@byteme9718]

It reminds me of a school dinner and quite honestly, I'd rather go hungry than eat this. You're a real soldier and need a medal for this.

[@GaryEats]

This is a great concept but badly executed

[@DarrenLampard]

Fair play gazzer another honest review mate hopefully next one will be better keep them coming mate enjoy watching them 👍🏻

[@GaryEats]

I really pleased you enjoy the videos and thank you for watching Darren

[@dannygeorge7909]

Beef overcooked,potatoes undercooked and plastic cutlery…. All in all my friend,that looked to be a disaster!! As you quite rightly said,it looked great from the outside… you should’ve stayed there!!

[@GaryEats]

The cutlery was a nightmare. Should have gone somewhere else, Danny! Thanks for watching.

[@andrewburton9643]

Looks good apart from the beef itself, and looks very hard to eat it while it's in that box and with plastic cutlery, ok for take away but wouldn't be happy with eating like that inside. Another good video though 👍👍👍

[@GaryEats]

The cutlery was a nightmare. Thank you!

[@brewsterkits]

Oh dear, dinner in a box and I hate the gravy pouring out into the box and the plastic cutlery☹️thank heavens the pud was good 4 ☹️

[@GaryEats]

The pud wasn't even particularly great, just better than the rest. The cutlery was a nightmare. Thanks for watching!

[@richardadesmond]

Thanks, Gary. I always appreciate your honesty.

[@GaryEats]

I appreciate that Richard

[@susandavis4821]

Evening Gary Please comment on the temperature of the meals as your beef dinner looked cold. I do not like cold dinners. Glad the Yorkie was nice, shame potatoes were dry. Too much gravy for my liking too but thats me! Like you said plastic cutlery bit difficult to use with a roast dinner. I haven't been to York so will give "The York Roast Co" a miss If I visit York in the future. Thank you again as your vlogs are so usueful and you give a brilliant run down, really enjoy your vlogs. Till the next one!

[@GaryEats]

Good evening. I will mention the in the future and thank you!

[@TelThePower]

Gary, I think it looked really bad mate, admittedly I am a slightly fussy eater, the beef I couldn't have eaten any of, the Yorkshire pudding looked like one of the frozen ones Iceland sells currently, the potatoes didn't seem to be cooked properly, possibly the heat or cooking oil?? The price was over priced, the cutlery was an absolute joke & as for eating out of a cardboard box?? Other than that, it was ok! 😂😂 My score is no more than 2 seriously! I still enjoyed watching the vlog Gary 👍 Cheers 🍻

[@GaryEats]

Appreciate it my friend, sometimes you get these frustrating places. Thanks for watching!

[@TelThePower]

@@GaryEats I'm going to watch the Chinatown and Blacklock reviews you done recently, & possibly a couple of others... I'll stick them on later 👍😊

[@GaryEats]

Excellent mate, thank you for watching. Blacklock was excellent!

[@fionacotter4287]

Roast dinner in a box, eating in??? As soon as you opened the lid I knew this was going to be a bad meal. Gravy spilling onto the box, plastic knife and bamboo fork, beef looked grey and the roasties had no colour! Fair enough to serve in a box with that cutlery if it was takeaway but not to eat in!!! Only saving grace was the Yorkshire pud. Fair score, Gary, but it would have been a three from me.

[@GaryEats]

The lack of plates and good cutlery was extremely disappointing. The food was really poor as well, a disaster overall Fiona. Thanks for watching!

[@stellabobbins5226]

And the room looked like a bland staff canteen .

[@thesufi]

If I ever need to justify the poor international reputation of British food I shall link to this video. Well done for managing to eat any of it Gary - you're a better man than I.

[@GaryEats]

Thanks mate. It was a struggle.

[@pippin1ful]

I lived in Yorkshire for three years and loved it. My sons were born and raised by my ex wife, in Yorkshire. I love North Yorkshire and frequently visited. That meal was a disaster, served in a cardboard carton with plastic cutlery. Nil points pour moi! My favourite lunchtime meal was at the Tan Hill Inn: the highest pub in the British Isles, on the Pennine Way. When Tracy owned it, you might get sheep and ducks wandering around in the bar, but the giant Yorkshire Pudding contained a coiled chipolata, mashed potato, swede, carrot, peas and onions, and lashings of gravy. Not haute cuisine but very nourishing, 1720ft plus, up, especially during winter. All washed down with Blacksheep Ewes Juice. If you didn't need to go any place else that day, you could book a room and just enjoy, with lunacy thrown in. Look it up. Scenes in Vera were shot there, as was Ted Moult's double glazing ads. One of my favorite places.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much as always for your wonderful comment, it is really appreciated

[@RickyBarnes-n7j]

Love your honest reviews keep up the good work mate 👍

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Ricky. Very kind mate.

[@cumbriabornbred3690]

I've been there. Glorified fast food, dressed up as something else to entice punters/tourists in. Ok if you have a hangover on a Sunday, but that's about it. Could be so much better, with a little effort Fair review Gary

[@GaryEats]

Thanks for sharing and thank you. Appreciate it!

[@PotatoPirate123]

Looking at this company, it seems the director started all this in 2015 with various hog related companies after working in radio. All the traditional look and feel seems to be a bit of smoke and mirrors to create a traditional vibe to get the tourists in. Maybe the guy had a wealth of experience in making this sort of food and it's his passion, but it could also just be a business venture. In terms of the food, based on the ambience you'd expect something hearty and homemade. I expect the potatoes just happen to look like they came from Aunt Bessy but it's unfortunate either way - roasties should be craggled and crispy and glassy and soft on the inside. The fact that they're needlessly contributing to the plastic waste in the world because they apparently don't want the hassle of washing any dishes just makes it all the worse. This is the sort of meal you'd expect to spend a tenner on at Glastonbury festival, not sat down in a restaurant.

[@GaryEats]

You would expect so much more from a company that prides itself on Yorkshire puddings in Yorkshire! Thanks for watching!

[@PotatoPirate123]

@@GaryEats I don't think the guy is from York. Also hard to say if they pride themselves on anything 🤣 the only thing we know about the company is that it was founded the same year the iPhone 6S came out, so isn't exactly oldy woldy

[@PastaSauce.]

It was more of a take out place and you are meant to roll the Yorkshire up and eat it like a wrap.

[@PotatoPirate123]

@@PastaSauce. I guess so, but if they offer an eat-in service then for that price they ought to offer a more comfortable dining experience in my opinion. The place just looks like it's worth a swerve to my eyes anyway

[@steviet3880]

looks hard to swallow not good when you need to chew so much looked like silverside the cut of meat cooked very poorly thumbs up honest review

[@GaryEats]

Thank you mate.

[@warbwarb]

Love your honesty. Please keep going. We need to keep calling these places out.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you, I will!

[@peterkops6431]

Love the quick turn at the “No Stupid People Allowed “ sign! 🤣😂

[@garyhardy5785]

Looked like frozen roast potatoes. Awful beef and probably gravy from a jar. Even yorkshires looked bought in rather than cooked on site.

[@spendover]

I live in York and it's frozen

[@GaryEats]

It was really poor Gary.

[@garyhardy5785]

Love your honesty. Really refreshing as i love food review channels. Keep up the good work.@@GaryEats

[@GaryEats]

Thanks mate. Only the best are called Gary haha. Have a good weekend :)

[@Mat-eq8mk]

A chef has been nowhere near that meal. Sad.

[@GaryEats]

Nowhere near.

[@KieronSmiffy]

Your voice definitely sounds like a TV Chef like a Gary Rhodes. Excellent review as always. :)

[@GaryEats]

Wow, thanks mate! Much appreciated Kieron.

[@paulcurd7617]

Glad this video came up as a recommendation thank you Gary! We are planning a trip to York in July and were thinking of trying this place. Think we will avoid as I know from watching your channel you are 100% honest! 👍

[@GaryEats]

Glad it was helpful! Thank you so much 👍🏼

[@Kwippy]

I went there July 2024, with my family of 6. Although technically we were tourists, I had lived in the UK for decades and my children had spent a few years at uni in the UK so we weren't clueless about British food. Even though it was a grey rainy day, the place was packed with queue stretching out to the street. We expected a long wait, but not at all the queue moved fast, so they seemed well staffed and well organised. Yes the knives and forks were stupid, but the food wasn't bad, we all enjoyed our meals. Another "tourist trap" place in York with long queues is Betty's. We tried that and you know what, we loved the desserts they were serving up.

[@GaryEats]

Hopefully, they have improved because of my visit. It wasn’t good.

[@thecolourblindartist9412]

The one thing Gary promises is honesty, and that's what you get, bless him. Yet another corker, mate. Mike.

[@GaryEats]

That’s really appreciated Mike 👌

[@justinthyme4154]

​@@GaryEats Gary, you're a gem, love the vids and the Honesty. These days I can't get around, legs want to go in different directions, you'd think at 73 years they would learnt who the boss is by now! I look forward to more cracking videos. Since I have been a fan the boss and I now go the the local Toby and Master and Carter. Enjoy your nosh, me and the boss. Mike.

[@jacquibradley1598]

Hi Gary and Cameraman, sad, thanks for letting us know, I would never go there as I think a Sunday roast should always be served on a plate. Greetings from Cyprus. 🤗🤗👍👍

[@GaryEats]

This is a fantastic concept, but poorly executed, unfortunately 🌹

[@flower-ss2jt]

Never having eaten a roast dinner out of a box with plastic cutlery I do not intend to start now, thanks for taking this one 'for the team'. Looking at the meat I would suggest each joint was all mechanically retrieved meat moulded into a shape that resembled a joint. If a place where you buy a meal does not serve the food on a plate, my guess would be the kitchen is a row of freezers and a row of microwaves - so not much need for a sink. I would have given it 1/10.

[@GaryEats]

It was really poor. No problem!

[@Car-f7h]

Yep for tourists sadly . Not great when we went . Well done on your honesty .

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Carmel. I try to be as honest as possible with these reviews. Thanks for watching!

[@leeirvine1784]

Gary, please never change, my word I loved your honesty, it looked dreadful, fat running through that sad looking beef…. You know what I am going to say about the pricing, not value for money at all!!! Looking forward to the next Vlog!

[@GaryEats]

Really appreciate that Lee. So far, you're not wrong whatsoever (not that I doubted you). I will be coming up north again soon so we shall see! See you then my friend!

[@oc2phish07]

My word, things don't change. On Thursday the 1st of August 2019, my partner and I ate in that same York Roast and it was possibly the worst meal we ever had. I left an honest review on TripAdvisor and also contacted the company direct. Everything about the place was bad, from the lack of atmosphere, the long wait for food, the awful seating area upstairs and the terrible presentation and taste of the food. We loved York and everywhere else we ate was outstanding but this place was appalling. Thanks Gary, for another of your fine, honest reviews.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much for watching and supporting the channel

[@marybullock7603]

Fortunately we were forewarned about this place and so gave it a wide berth. We had a wonderful meal in one of the many pubs in York.

[@GaryEats]

It’s definitely one to avoid Mary

[@louiseanderson1505]

You are growing on me Sir. What a let down the meal was. I did feel quite sorry for you since you were looking forward to trying that particular place out. I love your honesty and believe you marked it fairly, well maybe a tad generous but that's because you're such a nice gentleman. 😊

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Louise, I’m glad you’re liking the channel and appreciate your kind words.

[@HelenBrock-f8u]

Hi Gary enjoying your reviews your so honest. Keep doing the videos look forward to watching them👍👍

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Helen! 👍

[@andrewherold389]

I like the way he walked away when he saw that sign!

[@GaryEats]

I’m not sure what you mean, Andrew. Sorry.

[@bobs63]

We thought the same when we ate there, you can't beat Betty's when you're in York, its not cheap but you can certainly taste the quality

[@GaryEats]

Yep. Disappointing!

[@BsYtHandle]

What a pity you never tried Thompson's fish and chips on the A64 just outside York when you were in the area. Or the tiny Seamer Fisheries near Scarborough. Both are absolutely superb.

[@GaryEats]

Gutted Ash but I'll go back soon.

[@camptube7621]

Yep. Seamers are amazing.

[@melaniefrost6553]

Hi Gary I've newly subscribed to your channel which I'd just like to say I'm very impressed with ..I visit York quite a bit as only live less than 20 miles away ..Well I've tried both the 2 establishments of this said name a few time's on each occasion let down in the same context ..Fast food roast dinners that are lacking taste & not freshly prepared it's all about the money & not about good value ..I won't be fooled again !! I normally go to ASK Italian in York if I'm not in too much of a hurry .. It's in a lovely old building with great service & deliciously prepared food at a fare price ..Keep up the good work i will spead the word 🤗

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Melanie! Thank you so much :)

[@TrevM0nkey]

Not sure whether it was because the title told me it was going to be be bad; but when I saw all the food in the window and the place is empty; I wasn't expecting it to be great. The amount of meat and stuffing balls was more than you see at a Toby Carvery where you're expecting it to be busy. Sitting in and eating out of a takeaway cake box, didn't make me want to jump in the car and rush there either.

[@GaryEats]

The Toby Carvery is far superior to this and I don't eat there very often either. Thanks for watching!

[@carolinaheckard5059]

Great video sorry everything else wasn’t up to par but excellent review and video quality ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much, Carolina, unfortunately this is a good concept but badly executed ❤️❤️

[@gail2500]

My mum used to make the best Yorkshire pudding. She would pour the batter straight into the pan and give me the crunchy bits. My favourite meal has always been a roast beef dinner.🇦🇺😊

[@KKTR3]

Now you’re in my home territory. About 20 years ago it started out as just hot meat sandwich shop, and I think it was in the shop next door originally, and it was connected to some butchers. It might have even started out as a butchers and then moved over to the hot meat sandwiches. In its new location, it’s got worse every year in my opinion the more popular it’s got the more diverse. It’s got the worst. It’s got you should’ve just really gone for a hot meat sandwich. Wish I knew you’d come to York. I could’ve given you. Plenty of recommendations. Some of them that fly under the radar .

[@jimbojet8728]

You were very honest I thought. The ‘cooking’ is a bit suspect there I’d say. Who knows? What was brought in frozen and what was cooked fresh? That would be interesting to know. Plastic cutlery doesn’t do it for me either. A good and fair review Gary, thanks.

[@GaryEats]

All round Jim this is one to avoid it needs rethinking

[@barrywilton298]

We jumped in there for a quick the roast beef wrap, without the Potatoes. Have to say it was an enjoyable meal on the run. Looked at eating in but the crowds and services didn’t bode well as you suggest.

[@GaryEats]

That’s great to hear Barry

[@leebampkin6308]

Hi Gary I went there 3 years ago and had a beef sandwich, I was very disappointed, it was tasteless, that meal you had just look like sop, hell and earth was you suppose to eat that without proper cutlery and proper dinner plate. The mind boggles. Great review Gary, looking forward to your next review, all the best mate.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Lee this was so disappointing, a great concept but very poorly executed

[@kerrihowell7276]

I knew in your face as you went through the box 😢 Then the cutlery! Great review, love your honesty but truly feel bad when you get a bad meal 😔

[@GaryEats]

This is a fantastic concept, but badly executed, unfortunately

[@kerrihowell7276]

Yes I agree, but seeing the well done beef when you like medium rare or even medium and you can tell a stood around roastie a mile off lol. Thank you for your reply 🤗

[@DrewBlack-o4e]

Hi Gary. May I ask how you approach the various eateries re filming and reviewing them?. Do they ever refuse?. Regards and love the channel.

[@GaryEats]

We just arrive and film, only once and I was thankful as the buffet look terrible

[@artyfingers4488]

It looked like a ready meal I can buy from Asda for about £2.10 with everything inside a large Yorkshire Pudding. About half an hour in oven from frozen or 7 minutes in the microwave.

[@GaryEats]

Not good

[@Nickpaintbrush]

Thanks for another great honest review Gary, we will certainly give this place a miss. How hard is something as simple as this to get wrong, its almost like they are trying to upset people!

[@GaryEats]

My pleasure Nick. Glad you enjoyed it - I would give it a miss!

[@pablopablo3834]

I live in York and the fact people wanted you to review it is hilarious honestly. You rarely see anyone from York eating there which is a good indication of if its shit or not. York has expensive prices because of insane amounts of tourism so we wouldn't dream of paying that much for something that isn't good. There are a lot of good places in York to eat especially Cafes but you are better off getting a Sunday Roast in one of the pubs in the city centre or even outside the centre that place is genuinely sucks balls and most of it is frozen like the Yorkshires, Veg and Stuffing. York has so many options that I haven't tried everywhere and new places are constantly opening from former shops turned Cafe/Restaurant.

[@GaryEats]

Went a few lovely places in York. Win some, lose some.

[@stevedaly8048]

Well done on the 5000 subs mate

[@GaryEats]

Very kind of you Steve, thanks mate!

[@lindagrainger8765]

Hi Gary, i could see you were struggling with the meal where were the plate and cutlery (metal) the Yorkshire pudding did look nice but that doesn't make the meal , you gave it a go. Thank you.

[@GaryEats]

Unfortunately, this is a great concept but badly executed xx

[@terezap5756]

I’ve never have an yourkshire pudding meal but always wanted to eat one when in London, love you Gary from California 🇺🇸❤

[@GaryEats]

Love you too. Thank you!

[@CarlHosmer]

Damn Gary , all my pet hates in one video - a meal in a plastic box , plastic cuttlery that barely coordinates the food, faff disorganised staff service as you described, i mean it might of been a one off or a bad day for them but for £10.50 and you're still starving when you exit the premises damn you sure would vote with your feet and never go back. Btw the no stupid people sign, and you walking off had me in stitches. The best part of the video if the food is to go by 😂 cheers, mate 🍻

[@GaryEats]

Yes this wasn't good at all

[@RickyBarnes-n7j]

Mate your a Natural in front of camera could listen to you all day. Top man

[@GaryEats]

Thanks mate.