Revisiting The Single Sloppiest Play In MLB History

[@swagmuffin9000]

it's interesting to see plays where an entire team collectively turns their brain off for a minute, and chaos immediately ensues

[@Sarcasmiccc]

Still not as bad as that cubs/pirates baserunning error from a few years ago. It was like they didn't even know the rules

[@JT29501]

Yeah for me that is definitely the worst play I've ever seen.. and one of the funniest.. Baez calling the runner at home safe when he was still at risk of being forced out at 1st (and so the run not even scoring) was absolutely hilarious

[@rocritz]

In the same game, they challenged a cubs played getting hit. Cub played gets called back to the plate, cranks a home run.

[@JT29501]

@@rocritz Pahahahaha I don't even remember that but thats classic

[@greenhat7618]

Hope he does a video on the play, cuz I’ve never saw it

[@tommyfu9271]

@@JT29501 yea that was the most hilarious part in a total debacle of a play.

[@xuimod]

Definitely sloppy but it was a low leverage/stress situation. Regular season game where the Dodgers were up by 7 runs in the 6th inning. After the play they were still up by 5 runs.

[@Notkimbosliced]

Tommy John in 1988 committing 3 errors on one play all on his own to let 2 runs score might just be worse

[@jaad9848]

This is worse because the awfulness took teamwork.

[@garyoakham9723]

To be fair he just had Tommy John surgery

[@Ericktj29]

Most people don’t even know who Tommy John is nowadays, (aside of the surgery) so they think these 2024 Yankees are the worse

[@robloxvids2233]

I died watching Kershaw dive lol. This was such a little league play. Like 1st or 2nd grade.

[@AlbireoMahado]

That hanley throw was 50 centesque. kershaw was appropriately backing up the play. no one anticipated the throw to be 20 ft off coming from shallow center field

[@jmg999]

Just what you always want, one of the best pitchers in the game having to dive for a ball, then jump out of the way of being spiked for covering the plate.

[@jackgoodman2498]

When they throw the ball away for the third time, vin scully says "Are you you kidding?" Like, if you could make vin scully say are you kidding after all the baseball he'd seen, that means you did something extraordinary

[@baseballkid3542]

I'm a Dodger fan and this is kinda funny

[@petergriffin8767]

It’s actually hilarious

[@Kimblesss]

Vin Scully's reaction to this entire debacle is truly a moment in broadcaster history, lmao.

[@SuperCatacata]

Also encapsulates how Hanley Ramirez ruined Kershaw's perfect game around that same year with sloppy defense.

[@BrooklynBum]

Vin Scully’s call of this play is hilarious

[@samiam619]

I love Vin. Where would I find his call?

[@GhostShark357]

Definitely the white Sox be doing this next season!! 😂

[@jimgray3346]

At the end of the play, Kershaw looked like someone had just informed him he had been traded to the White Sox

[@alejandrorojas2253]

😅

[@jimlahey3919]

I’m a Pittsburgher, and I’m fairly sure that the pirates make plays this sloppy in every series

[@RobertJ-vo4bk]

Will Craig certainly tops that list. 😂

[@tommyfu9271]

lmao@ hanleys throw. that's incredible. Tommy John once made 3 errors on one play by himself.

[@thorazine8402]

The Dodgers still won the game 9-4. That’s why that play isn’t as notorious as the Yankee collapse in the 2024 World Series, which actually cost them the World Series.

[@LN004]

That laziness cost Gerrit Cole the $36 Million extension. That's approx $600,000 per feet from the mound to 1st base if he hustled.

[@tommyfu9271]

no it didn't.

[@leoan8830]

Ah yes of course one of the most important games of the season for the yanks is choked yet again….

[@garyoakham9723]

I’m surprised the white Sox didn’t do it

[@LoneWanderer-172]

I’m a Dodger fan and this is hilarious, especially Kershaw’s dive

[@MrTycobb25]

There's a play at Coors Field where the Brewers embarrassed the Rockies by scoring three runs in what looked like a bad movie script.

[@___dh__dh__]

My old coach always used to say, "You throw the ball, and you catch the ball." That's all baseball is, if you can't do that, you're not good.

[@TheoHuxtible]

Puig tryna b cute throw from the SS to Home was just blasphemy ⚾️

[@TonyCrenshawsLatte]

Vin Scully worked this game, and the dismay in his voice was palpable. When Kershaw jumped out of the way to not get spiked, Vin called it the only smart thing the Dodgers did in that play. That play was so iconically bad, when FOX made a baseball TV show titled "Pitch" a couple of years later, they reenacted that exact comedy of errors in one episode.

[@Praetoriusify]

Man, I love seeing Hanley "line up" that throw to the plate and then chuck it like 20 feet wide, lol. Wow, what a clownfest. Still doesn't compare to the Yankee's 5th inning meltdown. Or to Javy Baez's play against the Pirates between home and first, lol.

[@BuddyLongplays]

So basically this is what every defensive play would look like if I was playing baseball 😂⚾️

[@williamkerfoot8039]

The real reason the Dodgers made it to the World Series and won it was because Clayton Chokershaw #overrated wasn't part of the postseason rotation.

[@TygerByte]

At least this didn’t happen in the World Series.

[@PhdflopperTommy]

playing mlb the show 23 with button accuracy be like

[@andrewharris4268]

Doesn’t even approach Tommy John’s three errors.

[@Russ-gy7tx]

The Yankees said hold their Beer!

[@Syrin23]

All the Yankees have to do is pay Cole another $40 million a year, and he'll cover first base

[@generalmoonstone]

Rangers/Blue Jays Game 5 Inning 7 is the worst defensive inning ever.

[@Parlimant_Strifey]

and those were almost all all-stars in that single play.

[@danieldravot341]

It boggles the mind, not baffles the mind.

[@RobertJ-vo4bk]

Sorry, nothing will ever be sloppier than Will Craig. Ever.

[@Zagirus]

Imagine going back a decade, all to dig up an obscure regular season game where the Dodgers had an 6-run lead in the 6th inning. Why? Just to exclaim, "L-look, the Dodgers make little league blunders too! It's not just the Yankees." Never mind the minor detail that those Yankee little league errors happened in the World Series, with a 5-run lead in the 5th inning, resulting in an epic choke. But sure, let's focus on that mid-season Dodgers game from 10 years ago. C’mon, you’re gotta try harder.

[@nothingcankilldagrimace]

Vin Scully’s “holy mackerel, that’s embarrassing,” is still hilarious.

[@starsportscardshobbiesandm7222]

How about the Ronald Bellisario and Ellis miscommunication triple error

[@someguyik]

Time traveler here: the 2025 Yankees will repeat as champions of baseball buffoonery.

[@bill929]

As a Jays fan: The Blue Jays.

[@9Ballr]

I think three Padres scored from the dugout on this play.

[@Un_k_noWN]

yet they can't score for theirs season's last 24 innings.

[@theCinemaHaus]

Remember when people said Puig was the next Clemente? Yeah, not so much.

[@joebarr725]

Puig is the perfect example of a guy with a filet mignon body and a minute steak brain.

[@Ravenholm337]

There's been worse.

[@michaeldavid6284]

No, the sloppiest play in MLB history occurred on August 17, 1946 in a game between the Detroit Tigers and the Cleveland Indians. With the score tied in the bottom of the eighth inning, Luther Fuchs of the Tigers tried to score from second base on a base hit by Tiny Freemantle. There was a play at the plate, and as Fuchs began to slide, he suffered an attack of explosive diarrhea, fouling himself, Cleveland catcher Big Joe Bombacelli, and home plate. THAT was the single sloppiest play in MLB history. You can look it up.

[@joebarr725]

I looked it up. None of the "players" you mentioned are on either team's 1946 roster. On the date you mentioned, those teams did not play each other.

[@michaeldavid6284]

@@joebarr725 Gotcha, Skippy. Time to permanently retire your pipe.

[@bcabrera971]

Hanley and Yasiel had terrible baseball IQ.

[@knarf714sc4]

How about the 2004 Yankees!

[@May-ve6sr]

The White Slops

[@iAintSayDat]

I saw in a blooper video where Rajai Davis hit a ball back to the pitcher vs the Red Sox and ended up scoring, didn't cost the Sox 2 runs though.

[@kurumauzamaki2731]

Or his better known blooper of being crushed by umpire Joe west

[@dansullivan1246]

Puig was a doof...

[@pointreyes4272]

Comedy of errors but it doesn't even come close to the yanks game 5.

[@dt81819]

Definitely the California/Anaheim/Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim will experience innings like those in 2025.

[@joebarr725]

And most likely for many years beyond.

[@jorgejohnson451]

Team most likely to pull this off in 2025: The White Sox. They’re young and motivated.

[@lordkreigs1978]

Who in 2025? The Oakland/Sacramento/Las Vegas A's

[@Pepe-recha]

We love LA ! 💙

[@Mike-mc3sh]

Lol why do you have Puig on the thumbnail?

[@joebarr725]

Because he's funny.

[@rogerkinard7446]

Uhhhhh, it definitely won’t be Dave Roberts’ DODGERS; that’s a certainty - unless they re-sign Yasiel Puig. 🙄 🤣😂🤣 We LOVE L.A.❤️💕 and we LOVE the 💙DODGERS.💙 Let’s go DODGERS 2025 !!! ⚾️⚾️⚾️ ROGER, The LOS ANGELES DODGER

[@owenfawcett5036]

Lets be honest the white sox beat this next year.

[@rickrandomites]

Next year? Still the Yankees lol

[@antoniodelatorre3121]

Worst play in MLB history… and they lost the World Series because of it… oh, they didn’t… that was the Yankees terrible plays in one half of an inning. Somebody is looking to hate on the Dodgers.

[@davidhorwood-r1c]

Did you review every play since the 1870s. IF not you cannot say of all time!

[@jrviade85]

in 2025? well the teams that make it to the post season!! duh!!

[@chrischen0709]

go back to longer videos pls

[@statusblvck6801]

Bro is on a toxicity binge, take a walk and maybe mix things up a bit.

[@Oraanu]

On the 69th pitch as well!

[@Anthony-dy5cq]

Damn, this foo hates the dodgers that he needs to dig in deep into the archives to find irrelevant game footage to even up the score with the Yankees.

[@icandreamstream]

Ah yes, let’s reference a regular season game from 10 years ago. 😂

[@jimgray3346]

I know right? Baseball has been around for 150 years; let's only ever talk about the past two years. Nothing interesting could possibly have happened before that

[@Anthony-dy5cq]

Someone is a Yankee fan.

[@benclemens5311]

I was at this Dodgers Padres game, the only thing that made it not so bad was that the Dodgers were up by a lot.

[@congressatorial]

first

[@Golden-tales1-h5s]

first other then a bot pin?

[@warlordop713]

I’ve seen worse way worse bro this must’ve been the first World Series you’ve ever seen if you think this is the sloppiest in history or the worst showing in history or whatever the lamestream media is saying right now about the Yankees. 😂

[@blakedralle9031]

Somebody didn’t watch the video

[@ED-wj5tp]

Nope , the yanks was the all time best fail

[@rauljimenez1015]

In 2025. Who cares what was the worst play in 2024. Judge missing a routine fly ball to start the melt down that is now all the Dodgers receiving World Series rings. lol